Skip to main content
Loading video...

Imperial Settlers Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 24:37

welcome to John kids games today I'll be reviewing imperial settlers this is an ancient building card game with asymmetric civilizations tableau building and just a little bit of burning each other's bill hangs down first I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review there are two different types of cards in imperial settlers we have faction cards and common cards each player is going to pick one of the four civilizations to be their faction we have Romans barbarians Egyptians and Japanese and they'll be the only one who gets to draw from that deck however everybody is gonna be drawing from this very large common card deck after each player has chosen which civilization they're gonna be they're gonna grab this tableau tile that is associated with that civilization and put it right down in front of them for instance for the Romans out put it right here and now each player is gonna draw two cards from the top of the common deck and two cards from the top of their specific faction deck to create their starting hand we're now ready to start the game there are four different phases to each turn and the first one is the lookout phase for that phase the start player is going to reveal cards from the common deck equal to the number of players plus one so for instance if this was a two-player game I would reveal three cards now the starting player gets to pick one of these three cards and put them into their hand so they might take this building here for instance now the second player chooses a card between the remaining two they might take this one into their hand and this final card is going to be discarded now we do this one more time we reveal the three cards for our two-player game but now we do a reverse player order for picking the cards so the last player is to choose

which one of these cards they want first they might take this one and then these starting player gets to choose again they might take this one and this is discarded every player now has six cards in their hand the starting four they drew and then the two they picked Phase two of each turn involves production as you see at the top of our tableau board we have a variety of resources that we're going to make just for being the Romans here so this is going to be two people one sword a shield a stick in Iraq all of which we get now immediately it's important to note that each of these starting races has differing amounts of base resources that they're going to get for production now we're at the third phase of each turn which is the action phase at this point most of them meat of the game is going to happen each player going clockwise from the starting player is gonna take a single action and they're gonna keep going until every single player has taken every action they want to do so let's take a look at what the action options are the first thing we can spend an action on is to build a building from our hand of cards if we look at the top left corner of each card we have paid to build and some resources so I can spend one wood and one Rock in order to build this town so I take the rock in the wood I would spend those to go away and I would take this card and play it down now there are two different zones in each of our civilization areas we have the common area which is denoted by the green side of our tableau board and then for the Romans we have a gray area here although that color changes for the different civilizations so we see that this is a common card it's got the blue back so we're gonna put it over here and we can see the green grass kind of matches which is nice we also see

that this is a production building and we know that because a it says production here but we also have a little road that goes across and then down but not up and that kind of matches up nicely with this road that's in line with the production up here so we always put production buildings in this top level the moment we build a production building we actually immediately produce from it so we see this town produces two people so this is here and I immediately get to take two people from the resource pool and add them in and I get to use them on this term in on subsequent turns I will be creating two people each time we do the production phase I'm sure you've noticed that we have a feature line and then we also have an action line in our card tableau those are the two other types of cards that can be played down so if you were to build this feature you would put it in line with the feature row and then likewise if you were to build this action that would go into the action row of your tableau area this is good because it keeps the various card types organized we know that when we produce we only have to look at this top row here and get all the resources on those features are kind of triggered conditions so when one thing happens you get another thing alright it's a bonus to doing certain actions so they're ongoing effects and then actions are cards that can be activated for actions on your turn so that'll be the second action type that we can do on our turn we can activate an action building if we look at the building here we see it says action spend one person and one coin to get two victory points so in this case we would need to take a person from our resource pool and a coin well let's just say I had one you put them onto the card right there and then you get the victory points in this case

we would take our victory point marker and we would go up twice to show that we just got those two victory points the reason we pay for actions by putting resources on them is because you're not allowed to use an action card more than once in a turn unless the card specifically says so so we have the resources on there that's going to remind us that we've already done this cistern and we can't do it again the third action type is raising and that's where we use these raise tokens here if we look at the cards in our hands some of them say raise to gain in the top right and some of them don't the ones that don't are going to be your faction cards but all of the common cards have this up here you can spend one raised token to the bank in order to get resources equal to the raise the game portion of the card unfortunately that means you get rid of this card here but you'll get to would because of that those get added into our resource pool we don't have the race token anymore but we have more wood to build more stuff however raising a card from your hand to get resources is only one of the two ways that you can raise the other is you can attack opponents now let's pretend for the moment that these Romans are not us that they're an opponent we're sitting over there or something like that and we want to destroy one of their common buildings we see that it says race to gain in the top right corner but this time it's going to take two of our race tokens in order to destroy one of these buildings as opposed to the one token to get it from our hand when we raise an opponent's building we are going to get the resources in the top right so in this case would be a gold and a wood but as a consolation prize the opponent is going to flip that card face over and they're also gonna grab one wood from the bank and put it into their resource pool so this is one of the main ways that you can get into opponents tableaus and really mess with

their engine but at the same time they get a little bit out of it let's talk quickly about this card that's face-up now we see on the back we have a little house icon and you might have noticed that the faction cards we have in our hands are often gonna have a little house icon in the pay to build this means that in order to build our faction cards they have an extra cost of spending another building so if I was to build this building for instance it is a action building so I put it down here on the gray side because it's rhomin but it's gonna cost a rock and a house so let's just say I had a rock here we spend that and then you can also spend one of the facedown raised buildings to account for the house requirement for building this building if you don't have any raised buildings you can still build this faction building but you're gonna have to discard another building as that payment so you might take this card and get rid of it you can even discard another faction building if you wanted to but that's gonna be pretty expensive getting back to raising you might have noticed that the faction cards have no raising icon in the top right that means that you're not allowed to raise opponents faction cards although if you're playing the Japanese that's not exactly correct most of their buildings can be raised for victory points but that's one of the asymmetrical bonuses of being the Japanese player the next action type we can do on our turn involves these faction cards that we have in our hand if we look at the bottom it says make a deal to produce a resource when you make a deal you simply pay one food and it's always a food and then you take this card here you flip it upside down and you slide it into the top here where it says deals at this point you immediately produce that good

because this is in the production area so that would generate me a food back and then every time we have a production phase on future turns we're also going to get resources for every one of the deals that we have made the final action option that you've available to on your turn is this one right down here now these are all the same on everybody's tableau and they say spend two people to gain a would a rack of food or a card this may be played at multiple times so simply put you can just spend two people as a wild resource essentially in order to grab other stuff the only thing you can't grab from this is gold coins when you get a card through this two people exchange you can simply draw the top faction card from your deck or the top common card from the main deck the last thing to note is this little shield icon now this is a resource that we grabbed from our first production because it's on our little tableau here however unlike the rest of them in the game you only ever have one shield so you don't produce more each turn on your turn you can put this down on any of the common cards that you have available to you and this increases the raised cost for that card by one so if an opponent wanted to raise this card here it's gonna cost them three raised tokens instead of the usual two because the shield's on there the action phase is going to continue until every player has done every action that they want to do on their turn they might be out of cards or out of resources but once everybody has passed we move on fourth phase of each turn is cleanup and this is pretty simple if we see the middle of our tablet board it says you may store any number of swords now this is the Roman only bonus so the Romans would keep all the swords they want but

they're gonna lose every other resource all excess resources that they were not able to spend on that turn each of the other factions saves all of the different resources the Japanese save all the food the barbarians save all their people and the Egyptians save all of their gold coins once every player has discarded all the resources that they're not allowed to save we pass the starting player token to the left and begin the next turn on the score track we can indicate this by going for the first turn to the second turn location if you notice there are five different turn spots this means that the game is going to be five overall turns along once we have done five full turns we evaluate to see who has the most victory points we've already accrued victory points on the track throughout the game by raising cards or activating buildings that give us victory points at the end of the game we also get victory points for our buildings all of our common buildings are going to give us one victory point we see this little star in the side and all of our faction buildings are going to give us two victory points we see two stars over there once you add all that together you see who has the most victory points that player is the winner if there's a time then the most resources breaks it if there's still a time most cards and hands breaks it and if there is still a tie then they get to share the victory for my review of imperial settlers I'm gonna explain my thoughts on each item of this list starting at the top and working my way down so let's start with the positives and the first of these is the tactical hand puzzle that this game presents each player with you have so many different things you can do with the cards in your hand you have somewhat mundane buildings but they usually give you resources you have very interesting specific action buildings and you can make very cool

combos where this building does this building and because I did this I get to do that but you have to find your way through your hand to make that happen looking at the resources you have available in front of you and maybe deciding which cards you might raise to get those resources to build other cards you might turn certain cards into deals there's so many different ways to evaluate your hand you really need to think about which cards are gonna turn into buildings and how am I gonna get to the end of each one of the five turns having the least amount of wasted resources because it really is an efficiency puzzle too everything to the best you can because you're gonna lose almost all of your resources at the end of each turn and I always enjoy that kind of mechanic in games I think this game does a very good job of having that awesome puzzle that you need to kind of figure your way through and the other positive involves those four civilizations that the players get to choose from at the beginning of each game and play as now they are asymmetric they play somewhat differently from each other specifically the kind of synergies that they have in each of these different civilizations varies quite wildly and honestly all of them feel kind of overpowered in their own right so as you're playing each race you can tend to feel like you have somewhat of an unfair advantage but it kind of feels like everybody else has a similar feelings of that that's not gonna happen every single game but they could do some really cool stuff you know for instance the Egyptians get to save gold and they make tons of gold and gold as a wild resource so it feels like they can just do whatever they want because they've all this resource and they're not really restricted in any of those ways versus the Romans that have amazing building synergy they build buildings to

that give them bonuses when they build other buildings and it seems like once they get to the mid game they can't do anything without giving victory points because of the synergies that they'd built up the Japanese are just really powerful but their buildings can be destroyed the barbarians have people like crazy and they can just spend them as resources and they could raise all over the place so they all have their own thing going for them and all of those are fun it seems like they're bounced relatively well I've seen each of the civilizations when I've seen games where the Egyptians look like they're amazing they have all this gold they're just steamrolling like crazy but then the Romans just clean them out because they had a more efficient victory point generating engine even though they weren't doing the flashy cool thing they played a little better and a little bit more focus and they were able to win even though this other thing looked amazing so I really like how all the asymmetric civilizations fit together in the game I think it's definitely one of the big strong points for it neutral point number one has to do with downtime due to analysis paralysis now I mentioned already that I really like the puzzle that the hand gives you of you kind of value which cards you want to play and how you're gonna do that how you're gonna use all these resources efficiently what I don't love is when I've kind of figured out what my plan is and an opponent takes five or six seven more minutes to figure out there's because maybe they have this huge hand they've this massive mound of resources and they feel like they got to use them efficiently because the game penalized is you so hard for saving resources or you don't get to save almost any of them you really want to use all of them and you want to use those cards in your hand the correct way and you can kind of spiral down into

this analysis paralysis black hole and it's not fun for the other people at the table you know it might take them all those minutes to even take their first action because it can have very real ramifications and then it comes back around to them and they might take another several minutes because maybe they drew a card and that might have changed their plan and I don't love that part of it now this definitely hits people who are susceptible to announce his paralysis quite hard if you are not then it's not as big of a deal that's why this isn't really a negative it's definitely player dependent but the game enables that analysis process a little more than I necessarily like neutral number two has to do with card draw and how overly important it seems to be to the game in order to play well the first time you play the game you're not really gonna think about it too much you're gonna play it and that's okay but the second and third time you're gonna really realize all those times we had resources you couldn't spend because you used all the cards in your hand you need to get more cards in your hand you have that deck of the faction deck that has 30 cards in it and that has all those awesome potentially overpowered tools in it that works so well together so you've got to start spending to people to draw that card and spend two more people to draw that card did you draw a card that lets you draw more cards you better play that and the drama more cards and you get this huge hand of cards and you have the two mounted resources and it leads directly into neutral point number one that I didn't mentioned it feeds into that analysis paralysis situation and I wish there was less ways to draw cards in the game so that you could have it more centered around how you're specifically playing the cards you necessarily have and the cards you have facedown in front of you more so than the cards that you have not quite gotten

yet and that that constant drive to get more cards in your hand to spend everything well neutral number three has to do with the balance between faction cards and common cards when they're out there on your tableau what I found is that people tend to get rid of their comment cards very quickly in order to convert them over into faction cards because you know faction cards are where they're awesome stuff is and it makes tons of sense you really want to get into those great roman cards but mechanically it means that people tend to have almost no common cards out in front of them they just burn them oftentimes after not even really using them in order to get those good fashioned cards going and you look at a table of people playing and it feels kind of a little bit bland seeing this humungous sea of faction cards and almost none of the generic ones I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that those fashioned cards are with two victory points each and the common cards are only worth one I kind of wish that maybe the faction cards were just worth one victory point or some of them were too but not all of them were because that would make you really think about if you want to get rid of that card to upgrade the action or the ability that's necessarily on that action whereas usually it seems like a no-brainer like yeah get rid of that card place this down it's worth more points than that one was and it's gonna have better things going on it so I wish there was a little more incentive to balance both sides of your player tableau instead of having it all shifted over to one side but it doesn't necessarily hurt the game overall it's just kind of a nitpick and now for the one negative and simply put I think this game has too many actions

in it now not action types but overall action opportunities that are presented to you in the game on that first turn you might do like four or five actions and that feels good you know you're building a building you're getting a couple resources that was good the second turn you might take seven or eight actions and that feels really good okay great the third turn you're taking 14 actions and that fourth turn you're taking like 23 actions and it just can explode and this is if you are playing well I mean obviously if you're not playing very well you are gonna be taking far less actions and other players and that is also a problem so if you are that person who's playing well and you have like 20 actions available to you on this turn where you're building this action getting that card and doing this and raising that to do this and taking this and trading this in that just makes your mind explode with that analysis process that I talked about already the flip side is if you're not doing very well or maybe you got really unlucky I don't think luck is that big of a deal but if you have found yourself in a situation where you spend two all the four cards you have in your hand and you look across the table and that person has amount of resources still and they've got like eight ten cards still in their hand you realize it might be 15 minutes before you get another action because they're just gonna keep doing actions and they're gonna keep thinking cuz I'm like wait oh if I do this and if I do it and said wait no if I do that instead and it just it really slows down and now you don't even have a handle cards in front of you to strategize about what you're gonna be doing on the next turn you are just waiting you may as well just leave the room and then come back in once that person says they're done I wish there was some way to rein in the crazy amount of actions that this game generates near the mid to late game I think that two things really feed into that one is the fact that when you build

those production buildings you immediately produce out of it oftentimes you get exactly what you spent or even better you might spend one wood and get to wood back out of it which just perpetuates this engine that can just explode and on top of that or the other thing is there is no penalty for somebody taking way more actions than anybody else now I'm not trying to fix the game I'm not gonna like house rule it and say oh well you can only take one more action after somebody passes because that really is gonna stifle another person the game was not designed around that but I wish it had been designed around the idea where once somebody passes other people kind of have a clock where they need to really consider how much more they can actually get done they are not going to get to do every single option that they have presented in front of them because that just makes the game take too long overall and it makes the down time be a problem and now let's talk about replayability the game comes with four different factions that are completely different you know their faction decks have no similar cards between them but at the same time you are playing the same game no matter what faction you are and you are still kind of focusing on some of those things I talked about in the neutral section on like getting card drive so really trying to fill your hand up and you're trying to convert those common buildings into faction buildings as soon as you can pretty much no matter what faction you are however you are going to find yourself really gunning down different synergies and different focuses for the game depending on which faction you're gonna play so there's definitely some differentiation there I think that as you play specific factions you're gonna get significantly better at

them which is kind of cool you might find yourself three or four plays in and you'll probably go from being like oh that's a new car didn't really know how that worked to I really need this card in that card and I'm gonna build this amazing thing so you switch over from shiny to like really well honed machine and I think that a person who's played this game like 10 or 12 times will probably destroy someone who's only played the game two or three times there's definitely a skill area for this game for each of the different players so if it's a game that you find yourself enjoying for a couple plays then I can see yourself getting a ton of replayability out of it however if you've played it a couple times and it's like it's enjoyable then you might find yourself only playing it you know eight or so times you know each faction maybe twice so I think that's a good thing to keep in mind and now let's talk about player count the game plays one to four players and I've done all of those except before now the one I can't really speak to it too much I enjoyed myself playing that solitaire game but I don't play solitaire games very often enough to really have an opinion as to how it stacks up it was okay but I really want to talk about the multiplayer aspect I think that two-player is the best option for this game for probably obvious reasons based on the things I've said before downtime and analysis paralysis are much smaller when you only have one opponent if you take an action than they take an action then you take an action back and forth you're gonna have much less time where you're waiting for your opponents to do stuff I have played three player games and they worked it's kind of cool having multiple civilizations going if somebody's doing

really well you could try to have two people kind of attack them and slow them down but the downtime really started to get in the way there I mean the three player games took over two hours for my play group and I felt like I did not want it to go that long I could see myself playing a three player game again but I'm gonna hopefully play with specific people who know the game already and maybe aren't necessarily prone to analysis paralysis I have not played the four player game and that is by choice I mean I've seen how slow the game can be with that three player game I don't think I want to try a four player game I'm worried it'll go well over three hours and definitely overstay its welcome now if you're playing with people who are very anti analysis paralysis you could totally get a four player game in in probably two hours if people are really going for it maybe even a little bit less but they're not gonna be playing at the level that the game is beckoning you to play you know it's saying you know be efficient do amazing stuff with that hand and it really pulls you in to those really long play sessions fortunately as I said two player plays very well there's only so much punching back and forth you can do to a there's quite a bit of an multiplayer solitaire since you can only raise the target of the opponent's buildings and oftentimes you want to spend those race tokens to get cards out of your hand to get better resources it can be slightly more efficient so I really like the two-player game and I don't necessarily recommend it for too much more than that in conclusion I came into imperial settlers with incredibly high expectations I was very very excited because I loved the inherent ideas of it of asymmetric civilizations I love that hand the cards are figuring out you

spend cards to play cards and which cards are more important I love that stuff but my excitement was very much tempered by how kind of too deep the game ended up being for me you know too long too many actions too much synergy and too much focus on being hyper efficient you know it really smacks you down by you losing all those resources and it really wants you to use all those resources and feel awesome because you have this amazing efficiency engine and I don't necessarily want it to be a 2 plus hour game almost every time I play it you know in a two-player setting I've seen it go a little bit over an hour maybe an hour and a half and that's ok in certain settings but I found it pretty hard to get to the table honestly especially after the first few times when I played it with some of the people in my game group in general people have enjoyed it in fact only one person has liked actively disliked it but it's hard to get it on the table with the play time that it takes and also the amount of brain space it takes I love that puzzle but it's a little bit too big of a puzzle usually you really find yourself investing in a lot of mental energy it's not a light game at all that cover with all the cute awesome artwork I really like the artwork really kind of makes you feel like this is gonna be a 60 to 90 minute game and not this quite deep skill driven also a little bit of luck driven game and it just didn't end up being exactly what I wanted at the end I definitely recommend this game for people who would like that challenge who like that deep awesome gameplay and specifically people who like two-player

games I think that some people will enjoy the 4 player game but it really shines with that two-player game I feel like you should give this game a shot but definitely understand the kind of time commitment and brain commitment that you are setting yourself up for I hope you've enjoyed this review if you'd like to see more like it please consider subscribing to my youtube channel thanks for watching

Progress saved