Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 234: Paul and Liz on the Evolution of Foxes & Lions

Transcript 1:02:21

It's ad break time. I'm proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. I'm personally very excited because CLGS has a springtime crowdfunding project on the way. They'll be publishing a revised edition of Jason Morning Stars the Blue Way, which you can hear about in episode 224 of this podcast. But for now, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire. And this week on the pod, I am super happy to have Paul Wright back on for us to talk about our co-design, Foxes and Lions, which is now on the P500 at GMT. I can hardly believe it. All right. How you doing today, Paul?

Good. Good. very happy it's uh officially public now and we can talk about it in all kinds of ways.

Yeah. I mean, we've been obviously working on this for years. So, you were last on my podcast to talk about Foxes and Lions on December 9th, 2024.

Seems like a lifetime ago.

Oh my god.

Given given the design curve,

the games had several lifetimes as well from between then and now. Oh, and for people who have not been tracking what Fox's Lions actually is, um, well, Paul, you want to take it away?

Sure. So, the title comes from something Makaveli says in the prince that you have to know when to play the fox and when to play the lion. And honestly, you'll need to be both at one point or another or either at one point or another. Uh, being the fox mean being crafty, cunning, and clever. And being the lion means knowing when to be wrathful and to use your force. So the difference between force and cunning and frankly you need both. Uh so that's where the title comes from. The setting is Renaissance Italy during the Italian wars 1494 to 1527. Those were the bookends we imagined. 1494 is when King Charles VII of France made his way down into Italy to pursue his what he saw as his historic claims on Naples. Uh and that really ushered in a period of enormous uh chaos and conflict. And 1527 is the year of the sack of Rome when the imperial troops of Charles V descended on Rome. Uh Pope Clement IIIth ended up hiding in the castle San Angelo and Rome was torn apart. A really sad and disastrous moment in European history.

So we are covering that era in the game. But unlike most games that treat the era, we don't put the focus on the great powers like France, Spain, Holy Roman Empire, and Ottomans. They're in the game as non-player factors and you can lose collectively to them. Uh but the focus in our game for player agency is on the five powers that Mchaveli talked about, Italian powers. So you have the Republic of Florence, you have the Maritime Republic of Venice, you have the Duchi of Milan, you have the Kingdom of Naples, and then of course one of these things is not like the others. One of these things is not the same. Uh you have the papacy. So those are the big five that you're playing in the game. And it is a game about politics, economics, as well as conquest, and it has plenty of Mchavelian backstabbing and skull duggery, but also a lot of Mchaveli's more serious ideas about the nature of politics. But just to kind of catch people up, uh, Foxes and Lions used to be something we're conceiving as a possible coin game with possible alliances, which I still think is cool, but we showed it at Circle DC in spring 2025, and we had some really, really great play test feedback that made us realize that we were maybe trying to uh fit a square peg into a round hole, as it were, uh, and that the game might be better in the here I stand system. Um, so Paul, any thoughts on that?

Sure. Um, I mean, it's a long story that I'll try to keep short, but I've always been a fan, uh, not only of Coin, but also of the Here I Stand series, Virgin Queen, Dantto, etc. Uh when I originally envisioned the game, even before you and I met, um I had been talking to Vulco, Vulco Run, who had come to my university to talk to my students about game design and game-based learning and the idea for perhaps trying a coin in Renaissance, Italy came to me and Vulkco was incredibly supportive of that. But uh as you know uh it was a really long process to get anywhere near prototyping it and thanks to you coming on board it changed everything and we ended up prototyping a coin I guess we'll call co-esque or coinish uh version of the game and you know we we tested it and and it was fun it was cool but uh it wasn't going to work long run

and as soon as Jason Carr suggested that we try to move it to the here I Dan model. Um, that was preaching to the choir, at least for me, uh, because I'd always loved the series anyway. So, uh, with Vulko's encouragement, you know, we ported the whole design over to that series. And thanks in part to, uh, a retreat, a game design retreat at Beaver Island, Michigan, very idyllic setting, uh, sponsored by Central Michigan University, Center for Simulations and Games. uh I was able to put a lot of work into retooling the whole thing and with your help obviously we managed to uh create a prototype that we ended up showing uh in San Diego last November which was really the first outing uh for this iteration of the game and it just uh even with all its uh quirks and and and challenges it ended up being totally the right fit for the material and

we're really delighted at the shift.

Yeah, I think it's been really good, especially because the changes we've made since San Diego to show it again at Circle DC. Um, really make me feel like we're headed in the right direction. Although, what's been really funny for me is in this process is that, uh, you know, I feel like you say yes to what's best for the game, no matter what consequences that might have for you. Uh, and so you were a Here I Stand series fan already. I had not played it uh, at the time that we were like, well, okay, let's talk theoretically about how this could look. Uh, and so I've had to totally crash course myself and like change a lot of my

caught up. You've played it a lot

now.

But, um, you know, you you do what you have to do to make it work, right? Um, and so now I'm like very comfortable with the series and, um, can get in there and be a little monster with anybody. Uh, but but um, it uh, it took some time. And so it's been a really interesting process for me too because it's like been a study and design year for me uh in ways that I was not anticipating um when we when we first showed this project in early 2025. Um but you know many happy games of here I stand in Virgin Queen later. Um and of course now Foxes Lions I'm feeling feeling good.

Absolutely. Um, so you know, I don't want to don't I don't want to dwell on the past. So if you want to listen to what we were thinking about back when it was a coin system, you can listen to the old episode. I still think there's like interesting design stuff in there for a future project. But we had to figure out how we wanted to fit our work into a here I stand style game. Um, so you know, we're also trying to keep the complexity under control. So let's talk about what we scooped out of here at standard virgin queen and like what we've grafted on.

Yeah. So uh there are a lot of ways to approach that uh question. So this may take a while but uh it really starts with uh Mchaveli. So originally uh way back when even before we met I always wanted uh Mchaveli to be the touchstone for the game. um both from a game point of view because I I I have fond memories of the old Avalon Hill Mchaveli and I wanted to bring that kind of uh backstabby environment into uh the series we're now part of. But much more importantly, uh, having studied and and written about Mchaveli's works over many years, uh, I wanted to capture the Mchaveli, not only of the prince, which is sort of the go-to default, uh, but also the Mchaveli of the Discourses on Libby, where he writes about republics, the Mchaveli of the Florentine histories, where he takes a deep dive into the tortured story of his own city, the Mchavelli uh, of the Mandraala, a very famous sex comedy that's absolutely hilarious but also deeply political. And we ended up now with three cards in the game that reflect these different mchavelis, if you will. Uh so we wanted a a game that honored him in all his complexity and three-dimensionality.

Yeah.

We also wanted a game that would uh

test his hypothesis. So one thing I would stress, you know, I have his mug here today for my coffee. You'll notice that is our cover, at least for now, of of the game itself on P500. Uh, but we never wanted this to just be a simplistic a geography of him or uncritical, you know, uh, agreement to all his ideas and interpretations of Italian history or classical history. He really wanted a game that would test his hypothesis. So, the simplest example there is he hates mercenaries. He complains about them being the commercialization of defense and thinks that they will never be reliable or trustworthy. And yet even he would have admitted everyone was using them and they were an essential part of the fabric of Renaissance warfare. So with that reality in mind, we have mercenaries, we have mercenary captains, we have all the things you would expect from this period, but we're also testing his hypotheses about whether you should rely uh on those mercenaries or go a different route uh altogether. So that's just one area in which you know we started to think about what could be different in this series. Uh so we have a variety of unit types. You know, we have feudal levies, your more traditional regulars if that's what you want to call them. We have citizen militia, and we also have the mercenaries, of course, uh which you have to pay. So that was one area that we uh had to figure out how would the current series uh accommodate that. Yes,

there are mercenaries in the other games in the series, but really really wanted them to be uh a very different thing altogether in our game. One thing, uh, there's a pool of mercenaries that you're drawing from, and once they're gone, they're gone, and you're going to have to wait for many of them to die in battle to draw on them again.

Um, the other thing we added, of course, was uh, politics and economics. So, government systems and trade,

which we think we now have at a very manageable, userfriendly kind of level. It was not that way in the past. We've been doing a lot of trimming and cutting and simplifying of things that yeah, they were cool initially, but they were going to be too much overhead and be a waste of your CP if you want to put it that way in series terms. Uh, and now I think we have a much more streamlined integration of politics and trade into the existing system that we think players will pretty quickly grock.

Yeah. Um, one thing that I mean, you know, we've kind of touched on this, but you know, when you say a Mchavelli game, people's eyes immediately light up and like, "Oh, so we're gonna get the backstab." And like, I mean, yeah, it's a Mchavelli game. But what's really excited me is that what we're encouraging players to do is kind of play with these systems and do the best that they can for themselves. And then inevitably, because it's Italy and it's a tight space and there's a lot of external pressure, which we're going to be talking about, um you're just eventually going to have to do things to suit yourself that don't suit other people. Um and it's it's simply inevitable. And so the game is set up for you to think about like, okay, you know, what kinds of political systems are present in my domain? Am I able to get the kind of units that I want? If I'm not currently right now, well, what can I do to fix that? Um, and you know, I'm really enjoying that sort of play with politics and also with like the hard money economy. So, one thing that has been kept through all versions of this game is the floren economy where you are, you know, trading to get money, cash money, and then using it to pay mercenaries, but also to pay for other things. So, if you're trying to, you know, do some lawgiving or do some piracy or do, you know, there's like ways to spend your money to get an extra

die here and there to help push the odds just a little bit more into your favor. And I really like that on top of the sort of political CP that you're using for your normal actions.

Yeah, I think that's an important point about the game. Uh we introduce trade and the floren economy uh not just for the mercenaries although that will be the first thing you think of using your florins for but you also use them to bid on mercenary captains. You use them to do a very long list of things that we've actually tabulated uh the money to be valuable for. And so it really functions as I would call it a parallel economy to the CP economy of the game. And the way we envision uh the CP economy, which is very consistent with the series, is that's your macrolevel social and political capital. That's you pulling strings at the highest levels to get things done. Many of the things you're already familiar with perhaps in the series, but the Floren economy is that cold hard cash uh for cold hard mercenaries and captains, but also for other nefarious purposes, including espionage and things like that. So we wanted that parallel economy to kind of be the dark underbelly of the CP economy and in some ways to get at the rise of a kind of nent capitalism which is incredibly important to the Renaissance period. So I felt like when we were designing this and getting deeper we couldn't really have foxes and lions without that dark underbelly. Um on the government side I think one thing you'll notice we have six different types of governments. Uh if you go to P500, you can see them all listed. We're going to have inside GMT articles about all of them. But one thing that will strike you

for the most part uh for most of the player powers is that you'll have a diversity of governments in your dominion even at the start. And that wasn't all your decision or your doing. It simply is the case that each city state on the map uh may have its own political leanings. We do have a central government that reflects the government of your capital, but uh for the most part you could have a more or less homogeneous arrangement of uh governments and you won't have uh the ability to just snap a finger and make any city you a government you want. That's not how it works. You have to do what's called lawgiving as Liz mentioned. Uh and lawgiving really goes back to Mchaveli's admiration especially in the discourses on Libby for lawgivers above all else. I mean he could have his um admiration for princes and even a bit for people like Jes. He could have his admiration for republics in general and great leaders. But at the end of the day it was lawgivers that really inspired him. people who laid the foundations uh the ordiny the orders as he would say in Italian uh of a given political system. So we wanted to introduce that into the game as well to honor that side of Mchaveli.

Uh so the political landscape of your dominion is not going to be an easy thing to manage. If you're Naples, one of our big five, right, you have a pretty homogeneous feudal kingdom. So Naples doesn't quite have as much chaos going on, but if you look at all the other powers, um, particularly Florence, Venice, and the papacy, they're going to have a hodgepodge of governments within their dominions, and that comes with a lot of administrative challenges, as you'll see when you play.

Oh, yeah. Um, you know, I love an administrative challenge. Um, the other thing I'm really really happy about that's kind of been more emergent in our current iterations of the game, you know, I mean, this is under development. You know, it's it's things are in a fun state of flux right now and we're about to open up to wider testing, which I'm really excited about. But one thing we've been working on that really makes me happy is we've also been working to make espionage uh more meaningful. And I think like an actual way around um you know sometimes in previous iterations of Here I Stand I've always or that system I've felt like you know in Virgin Queen um especially because Espionage in that game that sometimes you can't use it quite the way that you want to and like you have to have that declaration of war to really mess with someone. So if you know you've got a player who's pulling ahead and you made the mistake of being a coward and like not declaring war and you can't get to the point where you can declare war, they're just going to run away with it.

And so one thing I really like about what we've been doing with Foxes is that there are more ways to declare war, which we can talk about momentarily. But I'm also really happy with the way that espionage is working right now

because me too.

It's much more compelling and there are real ways to screw with people, including people that you are allied with. um using your espionage actions.

Yeah, I I will just name a few of those actions. Uh before listing those few, I will stress that we decided early on to let espionage be possible from turn one. And we know that in Virgin Queen, espionage was delayed a few turns. You couldn't use it early on. And there were design reasons for that that made sense. But we felt like you could not have foxes and lions. You could not have a proper Mchavey Valley game in Renaissance Italy without the dark side, you know, of espionage being available from the get-go. So, you will be able to do any number of espionage actions from the first impulse. Uh some of the new ones we've added include uh fermenting rebellion, which may sound familiar to virgin queen players, right? The Protestants can ferment Protestant rebellions in that game. This works a little bit differently and it's open to anyone. So anybody can ferment rebellion anywhere at least try. Uh we also have the ability to suborn uh conductary captains. So if you have a mercenary captain, somebody can try and bribe him away from you and possibly steal away any mercenaries that are with him if the result is successful enough. We felt that had to be part of the story as well. There was a balancing act there because um some historians debate how often uh mercenary captains were really as treacherous as Mchaveli portrays them. So it was a balancing act between making it possible something that could and probably would happen in a game without having it be something so easy

that it's happening constantly, right? We don't want that either. Uh and lastly, we introduced alongside the other actions you may be familiar with uh sabotage fortifications. So now you can attempt to take away the fortified status of a space. Uh past games you could build fortifications, but now you can actually undo them. And this thematically could represent any number of things. It doesn't have to be literally sabotaging the walls, although it could be it could be traders uh inside the city. It could be uh subverting defenses in any number of ways you could imagine thematically. But effectively in the game, you're no longer fortified space. And yes, that means you could have a key that is no longer fortified, which means now that key could be taken away from you in a much uh nastier way than you're used to.

It might not require the usual siege and assault. So, I agree with Liz. Uh we're really enjoying in the testing right now all the different uses of espionage and we see people doing it a lot more than you would have seen, for example, in Virgin Queen.

Yeah. Um, one thing that's made me happy about as we're getting the TTS together, I've been playing some more with Joe Doohurst, uh, our developer, and I have just been getting a lot of laughs out of how dramatic we are. Like, good lord. Like, could we be more drama queeny? I feel like it's very perfect topic, but um, you know, like you'll come in and it'll be like, "No, I was trying to take down Venice, but she stole my mercenary captain and then she set the Holy Roman Empire on me." Which we could talk about. Um but um you know it's like a really

I I've just been enjoying like the the emergent narrative of playing uh because there's a lot of range to do things that are mean but that are also kind of funny and also that you know it's like but I'm not at war with you. I didn't do anything but you can still really really mess with people

even your ally, right? You thanks to your ally.

Yeah. And so I I really really love that because to me that represents I've definitely sat through a turn of something like here I stand or whatever and been like oh well this person's not at war with me and I'm pretty sure that I'm safe so I could just do what I want. Um and I like that little prickle of fear that that something could go wrong uh even within the turn.

That's a key thing Liz you're mentioning the declaration of war process. Uh it does follow most of the series standard procedures. You can play it that way, but no alliance is completely safe and no uh at peace status between two powers is completely safe. We have event cards that would give you the opportunity to declare war on the fly. Yes, the series has had some of those before. We have more of them. Uh and we also allow through espionage that you may if you roll really well um get an opportunity to declare war. So, for example, if you do gain intelligence, uh, familiar espionage action from Virgin Queen, if you're very successful, you can forego all the other advantages of doing that, uh, and instead declare war on your target, uh, basically engineering a Kazpelli, however flimsy it is, uh, but you now have it, and you can go to war with that power. Uh, conversely, if you're defending against things like sabotage fortifications or assassination or faux rebellion, and the defender rolls really, really well, uh, the defender now has a cause of spell and can declare war on you because you were messing with them and you were trying to be cute and get away with it and now all of a sudden they have a pretext to go to war with you.

Um, as you can see, I've been having a good time. Um the other thing that I have been enjoying though is that there are more card opportunities to go to war um mid turn as well. So depending on what somebody's holding in their hand um some of our event cards will also allow you to break an alliance or start something and you don't know for sure what everyone else has. So Paul, you want to report further on where we're at with that right now?

Sure. I mean, we we're trying, I think, from a design point of view to create the paranoia and distrust that was certainly part of Renaissance Italy, particularly during the era of the Italian Wars, only a part of which we cover in this uh first game. Maybe there will be follow-ups, who knows? Uh, at any rate, the uh paranoia is a reflection of the actual situation. It's also a reflection of the fact, and we've, I think, talked about this in the original video way back when, but it's even more relevant now. Every player power, you're talking about Papacy, Naples, Milan, Venice, and Florence. Uh, all of them would in any other game in this series be a minor power at best. At best. And so, the feeling of being the big dog on the block that you get in Here I Stand, Virgin Queen, even Tantoont. Uh, I love that. I love playing those games, but it would not work for this game because we wanted to capture the Italian experience of the Italian wars. What did it feel like to be one of these so-called minor powers that was trying to win against rivals, but at the same time avoid collective defeat, which is part of the game as well, to the so-called great powers of Europe. Uh, the Holy Roman Empire, the French, the Spanish, and the Ottomans play that role in our game, and you can lose collectively to all of them. So, what Liz is getting at, and I'm kind of expanding beyond it a little, but the conceit of the game is that you are paranoid. You are surrounded on all sides. Um, some of the powers have

holdings of other powers right in the middle of their dominions right at the start of the game. Uh, so Bari, for example, is with Milan, right in the middle of the Kingdom of Naples, which is annoying to Naples. Uh, and that's just one example. Uh you have tons of independent city states of course just like independence in the series that you may want to prey on uh but will of course argue about with other powers. You have six minor powers to contend with in addition. So the the state of play in this game from the beginning is a state of uncertainty, a state of doubt, a state of chaos, all the things that Maveli described about Italy at that time and other historians can talk about too. Uh, so we wanted systems and mechanics that would get at that and give you more opportunities for for real backstabbing uh than you get in some of the other series games where Liz is right. You know, somebody may have that rare card to mix things up. But for the most part, if you have an ally, you have an ally for the turn. If you're at war, you know you're at war. If you're at peace and not allied, you know that, too. But we wanted a lot more um uncertainty than that.

Yes, we want you to be stressed out and worried that somebody's gonna stab you in the back like um and you know, I don't even know if we talked about this last episode, but um you know, the way that we're doing mercenary captains now, I think is very fun.

Yes.

Um so, get ready to have your Florence. So, not only are you having to pay your mercenaries, but when captains emerge, you have to bid for their favor in order to employ them. Um, and so you know, periodically during a round as a mandatory event, somebody will play a mercenary captain and you're just trying to get them out there. Um, so how many do we have again? It's like 20.

20.

Yeah.

Yeah. It was hard to call down to 20, believe me.

Well, there's so many. They're fun.

So many. And you know, maybe there'll be promos or add-ons someday. Who knows? We can get more captains in the mix. But basically the way they work and this is one of the key ways to spend your florins is you have a number of mandatory events captain cards. Most of them are in the deck from the beginning. Some come in later. Uh and they can end up in people's hands or not. So in a given game you could have very few of them early on. You could have a ton of them early on. Every game's going to play a little differently. And what will happen is you'll play that mandatory event. You'll get your CP on top of it like you would in any series game. Uh but when that event happens, everybody has a blind bid on that captain. So that's where your florins come in. Your florins are hidden behind a screen. So nobody knows exactly how much you have.

And it's difficult to track for reasons we can get into later. Uh so everybody will put, you know, anywhere from zero to however many Florence in their hand and say, "This is what I'm bidding on that captain." And it's a great day for the captain because the captain will collect the money regardless. So no matter what you bid, the captain is quite happy. Uh that money is spent, but only the high bid will win. Uh so there's a lot of guessing. That's one of the most fun part of the game in testing right now is watching people try to psych each other out on those bids. Uh it does uh bear saying that uh the captains we have in the game reflect a wide range of leaders. Um most of whom would be what you would call condiary. So they would fit that definition pretty well. Contractors, right? Uh but some of them wouldn't fit that definition, but we found them way too interesting not to include. So for example, Katalina Forza is somebody we wanted in the game. She's fascinating. She's fun. The history behind her is great. Uh so she is in that pool of captains, but she wouldn't qualify perhaps as a condo the way the others would. You have two cardinals in the mix uh who end up helping you uh get troops or other advantages. They were in fact involved in the wars in one way or another, but you wouldn't call them condotiieri. Uh, but those are exceptions. Most of the captains we have do fit the bill of that classic definition. And all of them come with vulnerabilities as well as abilities that are specific to them. So, they

don't just have a battle rating anymore. They have that. They don't just have a command rating. Yeah, they have that. And command rating is used for other things now, not just what it traditionally was. You can get into that eventually. Um, but in addition to your BR and CR, you will also have advantages, vulnerabilities, and other quirks. You know, you might have affiliation, for example, with a great power, which means that captain will never fight that great power. It'll stand down, he'll stand down, she'll stand down from that battle u because of the historic relationship there or or a tight allegiance. Um, others have no allegiance whatsoever, so they'll fight for anybody. Um, so this is one of the ways you can bid blind with your Florence in the game. There are a couple of others. Uh, you bid blind on impulse order at the beginning of every turn. We haven't mentioned this yet, but we have variable impulse orders. So, one of the things for me in the series games like Piss and VQ that sometimes I understood why it was there, but sometimes it frustrated me is you always know who's going to go when and who's going to be next. Maybe there's the occasional event that throws that off, but mostly you can predict Ottomans will be first, you know, in BQ. Um, we wanted to mess with that. So, there is a default impulse order. Venice is at the top at the beginning, but in the beginning of each turn in spring deployment, you can bid your Florence blind. Again, you pay no matter what to change the impulse order a bit. So, the order could change from turn to turn. And that has a lot of

advantages since impulse order is a common tiebreaker in the game. So we wanted that flexibility in the system that we felt wasn't quite there before. We do leave the option if you want to play it the oldfashioned way and just have one set impulse order like you do in the other games, you can do that. Uh but we really like the variable order. It really throws things off. It's another way to spend those precious florins. And the last thing you can bid on, it's probably not the only thing of that I'm thinking of right now, but uh is a papal conclave. So if a pope dies, we can get into in a minute.

So if a pope dies, because you have a a range of them, you start with Alexander V 6. There may be others coming later. They do get old. They do die of natural or unnatural causes. Well, when a pope dies, unlike the other powers which have more of a linear lineup of rulers, uh you'll have to have a papal conclave to vote on who the next pope is. And it may turn out to be someone the papacy player doesn't really want that much. Uh so we wanted to introduce that element into it. The papacy has an advantage there, but all the powers will be able to influence that conclave including by spending their money. They can buy votes behind the scenes to affect who ends up being next pope.

Oh yeah. I uh I won't lie, that continues to please me as an aspect of the game.

Yeah. Because you know the Julius I the warrior pope for example, he's in the mix. You could try to get him in there and that would be great for the papacy, but not everybody wants to see that. And there are some, let's say, weaker popes, including one who refuses to do espionage because he's too good. uh who might get voted in against the papacy's will.

Yeah. Bummer.

A man.

That's Adrian. Adrien won't do espionage.

Oh man. Um so one thing we've been hinting at and not talking about a lot, but we should. Um is that there is the possibility of collective defeat. And there are also, you know, in addition to you trying to deal with your own crap as an Italian citystate, um, you're going to be dealing with incursions from outside because, uh, your business is not only your business, but it's also France, Spain, the HRE, and the Ottomans business. Um, so that's one of the most fun additions and also one that's like under construction right now. So, let's talk about like where we're at.

Yeah, I think I think we actually had a huge breakthrough recently. I thought so too. Certainly conceptually we're we're implementing the change now.

It's run the gamut. I mean, honestly, so first, why are the great powers and the collective defeat there? Okay. Well, for one thing, the eventual outcome of the Italian wars, you can pretty clearly say was a victory of the great powers, not a victory of Italian citystates, which is what Mchaveli feared. Uh he died uh shortly after the sack of Rome. Uh so you can imagine that he was pretty down on Italy's prospects in the last days of his life. Uh so we wanted that sense of doom and menace coming from the greats again France, Spain, Holy Roman Empire and the Ottomans. Uh and we also wanted collective defeat for a couple of reasons. one, I enjoy games that have that as a possibility. Going back to Republic of Rome, which we also ran at Circle DC alongside Foxes and Lions, that was a blast. And that that menace of the game and the historical circumstances overwhelming all of you while you're trying to, you know, backstab each other and win the game. We wanted that to be a possibility, at least occasionally. We feel like that should happen. Maybe it should happen a lot. were trying to calibrate that in some of the early iterations going back to the coinish version. Uh the great powers had no teeth and nobody were really nobody was really afraid of them which felt totally wrong. Okay, they're bouncing around. They have some formations but you know we're not that afraid. And of course as we've moved to the here I stand vein and of course as we've iterated multiple times now on the greats uh we have seen a swing sometimes

in the other direction. Oh my god they're they're running rampant. They're dominating the game. There's no space for player agency. So, we have finally, I think, hit the sweet spot where the great powers are a menace. They are a problem. They can pound away at you. Uh, but you still have a fighting chance to win the game. Part of the temptation, of course, which is the temptation most Italian states fell into during the period, is to enlist those great powers occasionally to your own ends, to convince them to go after your enemies and stay away from you. Yeah. So if the French armies are marching down towards Naples and marching through uh Milan's dominion, which is what happened in 1494 with Charles VII. Uh obviously Milan would like to encourage King Charles to keep moving south to Naples. That's what he came for, right? Uh and to leave them alone. So you will have a lot of decisions to make as the great power formations move around the map. Uh somebody online described them almost like bumper cars. Uh they're they're definitely there and they can slam you hard if you're not careful. And what we track in addition to you collecting individual power VP which thankfully translate nicely to Mchaveli's Ver 2.

Ver 2 points is what we call them. That was a happy accident. Uh you're trying to win by collecting those just as you would in any other series game. But we also have a track called Italian Ver 2 which Mchavelli also cared about and that is a doomsday track. So every time the great powers take keys, every time they achieve their objectives, every time you bend the knee to them rather than fighting them when you had the opportunity, which Mchaveli might have encouraged, uh that VP track goes down. So when that track bottoms out at zero, you all lose the game together. And we have mechanisms in the rules, which I like a lot, that ascribe blame for the collective defeat. So, someone's going to be the scourge, as we call it, the person who messed too much with the great powers in the first place and caused the downfall of Italy. And we also have the lap dog. So, which player ends up being the special little puppet of the great powers at the end. It could be the same person, by the way. You, this is like the worst outcome possible.

If you are both the scourge and the lap dog, you really have failed. Uh, and you will get the blame at the table from every other player. because I wanted originally when I was originally thinking about the design uh and Liz thankfully grocked this immediately uh I wanted there to be a process of um ascribing blame. Um now you might not agree with it at the end of the day but the game will give you an outcome one way or the other. A player's going to win or a great power collective defeat will happen and we will blame one or two people at the table for why that happened.

Oh yeah. Because it has to be someone's fault. It has to be. We have to scapegoat somebody.

It's more fun if it's someone's fault.

Um, yeah. And, you know, I'm I've been uh very very happy with like the player behaviors that are appearing because of these things. So, you know, I was definitely courting trouble um in our most recent play test on TTS uh because I decided to sweet talk the HRE into messing with Milan so that Milan wouldn't be able to have the energy to go to war with me. And

And you don't want the HRE messing with you?

No. So, I gave them a a convenient distraction while I was Venice.

And you were Venice, right? You're Venice in Yeah. So, you're doing really well. You're rich and people are resenting you.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And I one thing I actually really like about this is that uh the behaviors that we are coaxing out of players are very historical. Um like you you naturally understand the motivation for why you would do certain things. So like Venice starts out in a really strong position. They have a ton of money. That's what they want. They're doing great. Um and everybody hates them. And if you go back and like read about the Italian wars, there's literally like a everybody hates Venice war. Uh followed by Venice getting picked up into a different alliance with all the people that were fighting them previously to go deal with one of the great powers.

Yep.

Um and

dead fellows.

Yeah. And so, you know, you can't hold a grudge too long in the game or at least not outwardly. You can wait for a chance to stab somebody later. But, um you know, you you you need what you need in order to gain an advantage. Um, and so you can't hold those grudges even if somebody kind of stabs you in the back for too long because you might need that person later.

Yeah, that's totally right. And I think as we've seen in testing both live on my end in Philadelphia, you know, with the prototype that we have and also the testing that Liz is doing on TTS with Joe and that I'm eavesdropping on and we're going to extend that TTS module hopefully by summer at some point to more and more people because we want lots and lots more testers. We've had a lot of testers. We've had a lot of people demoing it at various cons and venues, but we need more people obviously.

Oh yeah. Uh, and what Liz is saying, I think, is exactly right, that we're coaxing out of players behaviors that align pretty well historically to those powers, but we're also leaving them enough freedom, agency, and wiggle room to do things differently or to do things that make sense in the moment, or at least you thought they made sense and you realize they don't. Uh, but we wanted that sandbox kind of feel I think is important because I'll just put my cards on the table and I won't speak for Liz, but uh, games that pretend to be perfect simulations of history, I just don't really believe that's possible. And I don't pretend for a minute that this game or any other will ever capture exactly what all this was like. Um, but we're doing the best we possibly can and we're trying to model the psychology and the limited agency, let's put it that way, uh, of the players in this situation historically. And we don't want a game that's on rails to the point where everything's just going to happen exactly the way it did. It it might, but it doesn't have to. And we wanted that sandbox feel to the game. you know, you're playing in the world of uh a vicious Renaissance Italy. And I think that's one of the best strengths of, you know, like Here I Stand for example. Uh it it has certain things that may feel uh, you know, pre-ordained to happen, but it also has a lot of wiggle room within that, a lot of agency. Uh and I think that's important. You have to feel

that you're free to play in that environment. And I think within the series, we hope this will be the game where you have the most of that kind of sandbox agency keeping in mind that there are any number of things that can ruin your day and any number of other people including the great powers who may ruin your day.

Yes, many days ruined. Yeah, I'm I'm actually with you. So for me, what's important about a historical game isn't that things play out the way that they did in history. It's that you are dealing with the same types of choices and we're evoking the right kinds of feelings to capture what we think was going on at that time. So it's not, you know, you made this alliance and you did this. It's ooh, you felt this particular kind of pressure and you responded in a way that maybe isn't what historically happened, but you understood the feeling and then you made a choice about how to deal with that feeling. Um, and that's where you're kind of like capturing, right, the the Italian Wars essence of everything. So, um, you know, I was really enjoying our demo where I was playing the papacy because I got lucky and Alexander V 6 didn't die the way I expected he would, and I was going to get another turn with Chesery just tearing up the map. But people were about to notice and be mad about that, too, which means that I was probably going to deal with some papal assassination attempts. Um, you know, and then a conclave that might put Julius in. And even though he's a great pope, like he and Chesy don't mix. side of lose my best captain and my one and only captain because Venice kept buying everything. Jesus. I'm like um but you know that's um you know things don't always play out exactly the way that they do like in the history books. But there are like moments and people who appear and you can try to

like position yourself to make the most of them, but you just don't know if it's going to work out because um maybe illness will get someone, maybe you'll get a lucky break or maybe somebody will put an informant on you and like stab you in the back for real with an assassination attempt. Um, and so I'm looking forward to just more plays with more different people who will act differently because I also think that like every demo is fun because people's motivations as players combining with their motivation like you know built into the game uh always leads to something a little bit different.

Yeah. Talk about a game that will encourage your local metas to evolve. Uh I think you know the the chemistry of the people around that table I have seen create radically different plays of the game. So for example uh occasionally one of my groups I have a big group of testers but I don't have all of them all the time. So a certain subset of my testers are more on the conservative side. So they don't do much in the way of aggression early on. They're all trying to consolidate what they have. They're trying to pick off independence and align miners the usual. and then you put a different group around that table and people are doing horrible things to each other from the first impulse

and that that is really a reflection of the personalities. So um one of the role playinging conceits because I do think one of the beauties of this series is uh the role playinging side of it. I I love that part of it. You really do feel you know you're playing uh you know Sultan or you're playing uh Charles V you know and here I stand. There's something amazing about that feeling, but we actually uh imagine it slightly differently. You're not really playing your current ruler. You're playing the power behind that current ruler. You're playing the Mchaveli. You're playing the adviser. Uh in some cases, you may feel you're playing the polity. You're playing the people that have these rulers inflicted on them. Because there are 26 rulers in the game across five powers. And they do change. We already hinted at how they change with the papacy and the conclave. All the other rulers for the powers come and go pretty much on a kind of it's not a schedule per se, but it's conditional. So, if certain things are happening on the map, then it may lead to a change in your ruler. And some of the rulers are awesome, some are horrible, some are a little of both. Uh, most are a little of both. And they come much like the captains with abilities and vulnerabilities, problems and advantages. and we wanted you to experience what it's like to deal with not only your dominion but with a person who's not only in charge of it. Uh and that person may be as much of a headache for you uh as anyone else. So for example, Pierro Demetic is the first

leader in Florence when the game starts in 1394 and he's about to get kicked out. He was known as the fatuous uh or the unfortunate depending on your your preferred term. uh fatuous basically meaning he was horrible and incompetent. He did not have the gifts of his father Lorenzo the Magnificent and we show that in the game not only with some of his uh special vulnerabilities but also his admin rating. So his admin ratings is zero uh which means he can't hold any cards from turn to turn. That's how incompetent he is. He's the only person in the series that I know of uh that doesn't have some ability to conserve cards. And so you're gonna have to play everything in your hand every turn until he's gone. That is a headache for you on top of managing your dominion and worrying about your enemies and worrying about the great powers. That ruler is someone you have to deal with. So almost imagine yourself in a kind of cabinet position, you know, working for a ruler who is more or less uh you know in charge and on the ball.

Yes. Um, I also just want to express gratitude towards all of our testers because this is a big game. It takes a long time to play it. It requires some real commitment and um I'm just so grateful that we have so many people and like so many more online like who are interested um in testing this.

It's a big group of people online who've already said please let me play test and we will try our best to accommodate everybody. We want all those different voices and perspectives. Uh again, yes, it's like the rest of the series, you know, a commitment game. So, uh it's an all day game at a convention or an all day game at your house if you can manage to align everybody's schedules. This series also works well, of course, as we know, if you're playing it, you know, uh using Vassel or TTS, uh and you can take time and have weekly meetings or monthly meetings or whatever it is, right? So, it's a game that is, you know, hefty in terms of commitment. I will say it is only seven turns and I think there's seven manageable turns. I don't think uh mechanically we are um more complex than Virgin Queen. We're pretty much in Virgin Queen territory.

Um probably not as complex as Tantomont by any stretch. Uh but definitely in VQ land. And so we feel like it does flow well even now in its current form. Uh if you have players who are familiar with it, if you have newbies, you know, that's going to change your equation. There's going to be some mentoring and teaching that goes on there. But I will say if you're familiar with this system, you will find a lot that is very easy to grasp and is ready at hand to you. You won't have a problem with the new things. We're trying to allude to what those are. Um maybe one other we can mention just while it's on my mind. Uh patronage. So those of you who know Virgin Queen and its patronage system which featured artists and scientists, we have made some changes to that that are important. I think uh one is we now have three tracks. You also have humanists. Humanists very loosely defined. Some of the figures will be humanists as an historian might define them. Others are humanist adjacent shall we say or writers of various types.

Mchavelli is among them. We even have a poet Cortisan Tulia Darona who is really cool because if you manage to get her ability, she becomes an informant that you place on someone else that can never be stripped away. She is latched on to you and you're never getting rid of her. Uh and she has some other interesting abilities, too. So, we wanted uh 10 of each type. We have 10 artists, 10 scientists, 10 humanists, and we wanted each of them to give you an ability. So, if you know VQ, artists tend to give you VPs, whereas scientists can give you abilities, but we wanted an ability for every figure in the game. So, all 30 of those figures have something cool that they can do, provided you roll well enough on the patronage uh at the end of turn. We also made it so that you can pick your uh subjects now, so you don't pick randomly like you do in VQ. You choose who it is you're going to sponsor, and hopefully it works out for you. Um, and if you get to somebody, if you get to Da Vinci before somebody else, so be it. Uh, you may or may not succeed with him, but you were there first and you sponsored him.

We do roll out the patronage figures gradually over the game, so you won't have all 30 um overwhelming you. You know, it's cognitive overload to have all 30 available from turn one. They roll out basically two a turn of each type. So on turn one, you'll have six of those 30 figures available to you. Over time, more will show up, which also will create some variability in the game because you won't always have the same roll out of artists, scientists, and humanists. It could be very different from game to game.

Absolutely. Um, so, uh, before we kind of go into other things we've been playing lately, is there anything else we want to talk about for Fox's Lions? I feel like we've covered a lot with

a lot of the new things. Yeah. Um

yeah,

we didn't mention this much uh sentiment and yes your trade value those things

that have really evolved over time right so uh sentiment reflects the feeling in a space of the populace towards its current government.

Yes.

Now you might say you know in a late medieval renaissance context uh who cares what my people think? Well, uh, Mchaveli talks a lot about you better care about what your people think. And famously, the thing that everybody remembers, right, is he said it's better to be feared than loved. But what they forget is he actually said if you could be both, and maybe that's a tall order. If you could be both feared and loved, then you will have the ideal uh sentiment in your population. So each space on the map that you control in your dominion, you are interested not only in its government, but you're also interested in its sentiment. And so feared and loved would be your ideal state. Hard to get to, hard to maintain. Feared is your kind of middle state, your default state in most places. And hated is what Mchaveli said you should never ever be. If you're hated, then you're in trouble because they're coming after you. Your people will undermine you and you will lose power. So, we have these three states of sentiment in the game in every space. They're pretty easy to track, especially in the newest incarnation of the game in the map. Uh, the other thing we have is trade value, which is basically how you figure out what florins you're going to collect when you trade, which is usually only once a turn.

Um, once upon a time, we had the so-called trade value or prosperity of each space be a fungeible, manipulable thing, and you could spend CP to raise or lower it. And yeah, that was cool. Uh, a little bit too Europa Universalis almost. Uh, and we did away with that because it was just too much micromanagement. It was cluttering the board. Uh, it also was a way to spend CPS that meant you weren't spending them on other cool things. So, pretty much our our design principle has been and and with Joe as developer, if something isn't cool and fun, why am I spending my CP on it, right? if it isn't really aiding the bigger picture of my strategy, why would I have to worry about that? Yeah.

So, we did away with that and instead we've tied the trade value as we call it now, prosperity, whatever, to the government type you have. So, merchant republics are going to be more prosperous generally. Uh lowly vassals and tribute states are going to be on the low end of trade value and that is directly tied to your government. So, now you pretty much have an easy time of calculating what you're going to collect on any given trade. And that was a design choice, one of many we have made and I'm sure we'll still make uh to heir on the side of playability and air on the side of fun and air on the side of doing meaningful things with your CP.

Oh yeah. Uh I just want to add a little flavor in here because we weren't talking about this last time and it just brings me so much joy. Um so the main scenario that we've been testing is entitled God Will Not Do Everything which I just find hilarious. Um, but it also kind of underpins like the philosophy with which you're supposed to play this. So, probably the this is just the most bangerch quote in my opinion that I've come across. So, like talking about when Sodorini died, he says Sonarini's soul went to hell and then Pluto was like, "Stupid soul. Why hell? Go to limbo with the children because he didn't actually have the nerve to be evil enough to deserve hell." Um, and so, you know, are you going to play foxes and lions? Are you going to go to limbo with the children is my

Yep.

my thought.

What are you willing to do? Are you willing to stake everything on your next big move? Um obviously in a game you're probably less worried about the moral consequences of things you do. Uh but we wanted to encourage that kind of darker innovation uh that comes with a game that has Mchaveli somewhere in the title and on the cover. Uh so I think we've done a pretty good job of encouraging that. We we see it in play tests all the time. People are leaning into uh making the unpopular yet necessary and perhaps immoral decision. Um and and that's just a part of the flavor of the game. Liz mentioned God will not do everything. That comes from near the end of the prince when Mchaveli's imagining, you know, will there be some ideal prince who can unite Italy and stop us from being humiliated at the hands of the great powers and others and each other?

uh and he says you know even if such a prince were to arise and try to unite Italy which of course didn't happen for centuries later till centuries later uh even if you had that person that person can't count just on luck can't count just on God making things work you have to take matters into your own hands so for as much as you can lose this game by collective defeat and for as much as things will happen that will ruin your day or your plans uh you're there's a lot you can do a a lot is in your hands. And so you may make the right call or the wrong call or somewhere in the middle, but you're going to be making calls all the time. You're going to be making tough decisions. And I have found in testing people agonizing over what's in their hands and what's in their floor and treasury and what captains they have or don't have, uh, an awful lot, even more than any other game in the series.

Uh, I have seen people wrestle with, okay, what do I do here? Uh, and there's no magic simple answer, right? You have to figure out what's best for the moment. As Mchaveli said, you have to suit yourself, adapt yourself to the times. Uh I will say on the captain front, nobody starts with any at the beginning of the game. So if you are not getting a captain, it means you don't have a leader and it means your formation size for offensive purposes cannot be greater than four, which is the series standard. So the desperation you feel when you don't have a captain and everybody else has one and maybe Venice or Milan or somebody's walking around with three uh will put you into the mindset of the people of this time and you will have to go all out to remedy that situation whether it's getting the next captain on auction or suborning someone else's captain taking them away which is a win-win for you uh not for them obviously. Uh, so there there always going to be these crunchy decision spaces in the game and we wanted you to have real agency but to have real headaches.

So, um, if headaches sound like your thing. No, I'm kidding. Um, so I just want to remind everybody before we talk about um other games for a second, uh, this is on P500 now at long last. Uh, there's a lot in that box. This is definitely the cheapest price you're ever going to get it. So, I recommend that you go over and pre-order it now if you think this is for you. Uh because um I don't want you to It's like a $50 discount right now, which I mean, no matter how you're counting your Florence, that's a win. Uh so um Paul um obviously we've been playing some fun games recently uh because we played an epic like five hours of Republic of Rome at um at Circle DC. But what else have you been playing recently that is making you happy? Well, I've been playing uh, believe it or not, one of these granddaddy war games, old school World in Flames with a group of people. We have now been playing it basically once a month or every other month for about two years.

Uh, we may be coming to a resolution. It looks like it's over for the Axis, but we'll find out. Uh, so that's another heavy crunchy game. Foxes and Lions is nowhere near that complexity. Uh, I've also been working on a new design that that I'll try to sneak preview at some point, but it's about tax evasion in the Renaissance. I won't say anything more than that, but that's been giving me joy because I've been starting to figure out how it would actually work. And it is a much simpler game than anything in Foxes and Lions series or Here I Stand or anything like that. Uh, so that's that's been a pleasure for me. How about you? Um, I have been just trying to make time in my life to play Mage Knight: Apocalypse Dragon because that's basically all I want to do right now. Um, um, but um, you know, I've been working too hard, but I'm happy to say so like by the time this is out, we'll have announced new games at Leader, which like brings me a lot of joy. Um, and I'm starting to have more time for my own games. So, I'm still playing Obsession Online, and I've actually been really obsessed with uh playing Forest Shuffle on BGA, mostly with Ricky Royal, who continues to just

beat the brakes off me at this game. He's really good at it. Um, but you know what? Um, I I've just been taking pleasure in like my little turns on things. Uh, and of course I'm looking forward to getting to our game night uh of Republic of Rome because that

yes, we have an ongoing Republic of Rome game and I feel like it's never we're never not going to be playing that. It seems like we have so many people who want to join in and and we've kept playing and of course recently that group that Liz is part of, it's not anyone's fault, not Liz's either. Um, but they had such horrible luck. They lost Rome in two turns. But now they're doing better in the new in the new game that we started right after that because that was that was a a disappointment, but it was part of the game.

We cannot lose on Tuesday because Tuesday is Rome's birthday and that would just be

that would be wrong. So,

I don't think you will.

Um, and then Paul, you made a Blue Sky account. So, where where can people find you online if they want to see what you're doing?

Yes. Uh, I'm a Blue Sky account. What is the name of it? Well, I'm Paul Wright. You can find me that way. Uh, is Borg in my name there, Liz?

Come on. You have to Palace Borg. You're always Yeah. So, no surprise. I I actually had that BGG handle uh with Palos Boura because my wife nicknamed for me as Palus. And then I put Boura in because I couldn't think what else to put. And that was way before this game ever came to be or even be an idea. So, it really turned out to be appropriate now.

Yes. I mean, it was just it was just foreshadowing. Uh, but uh Paul, as always, delightful to talk to you. Sometimes in public, usually not. Um, but um, yeah, I'm super excited about Fox's Lions where it'll go. Uh, this is going to be a great rest of the ride. So, I hope that y'all out there are going to be joining us.

Yeah, absolutely. We want we want your feedback.

We do. All right. out there. Please like, subscribe, comment, and most of all, happy gaming.

Progress saved