Foxes and Lions Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Foxes and Lions
Foxes and Lions: Renaissance City-States in the Age of Machiavelli draws passionate engagement from players who have seen it in development. Those who have experienced the game at conventions and in preview testing leave the table with genuine enthusiasm. The game succeeds at something remarkably difficult: it makes Machiavelli's political philosophy playable. Reviewers note that the game captures not just the military conquest one might expect from a Renaissance setting, but the Byzantine political maneuvering, economic pressure, and constant threat of betrayal that defined the Italian Wars.
The game's central appeal rests on what designers Liz Davidson and Paul Wright call "evocation" rather than simulation. Reviewers appreciate that Foxes and Lions does not attempt to recreate every historical detail. Instead, it focuses on making players feel the specific pressures and choices that Renaissance rulers faced, creating an emotional authenticity that precise historical accuracy alone could not achieve.
Core Mechanics That Define Foxes and Lions
Blind Bidding for Mercenary Captains
At the heart of Foxes and Lions lies a distinctive system: players bid with florins, the game's hard currency, to recruit mercenary captains. These captains emerge as mandatory events, and all players place simultaneous blind bids to secure them. No one knows exactly how much anyone else has to spend. The bidding is competitive and tense; the highest bidder wins, but every florin spent is gone regardless of outcome. Players describe trying to psyche each other out, gauging how desperate their rivals are for a particular captain. The captain pool is limited: once the 20 mercenary captains are used, players must wait for historical deaths to free them back into play. This scarcity makes each captain valuable and the bidding moments memorable.
Florins serve multiple purposes beyond hiring captains. Players spend them to adjust the impulse order at the start of each turn through another blind bid. They use florins for papal conclaves, allowing players to influence who becomes the next Pope. Espionage actions cost florins too. This parallel economy sits alongside the CP (card play) economy of the "Here I Stand" system.
Espionage and Political Maneuvering
Espionage in Foxes and Lions operates differently from previous "Here I Stand" games. Most notably, it is available from turn one. Reviewers praise the resulting atmosphere of paranoia and constant low-level betrayal. Players can ferment rebellion, suborn mercenary captains to flip allegiance, and sabotage fortifications. These actions create real consequences: if a defender rolls well against an espionage attempt, they can declare war on the attacker without formal alliance-breaking procedures. Reviewers highlight moments where espionage opened a path to betrayal even among allies.
The multiple paths to declare war reflect the game's commitment to uncertainty. Event cards can trigger sudden war declarations, as can espionage success. The mechanics reinforce that Renaissance Italy was perpetually unstable. Players form alliances out of necessity, not trust, and betray when advantage aligns with opportunity.
The Foxes and Lions Experience
Political Paranoia in a Tight Map
Reviewers emphasize the atmosphere of uncertainty and distrust. The conceit is simple: you are surrounded. Venice controls cities within Naples' domain. Milan's territories sit scattered across the map. The great powers of Europe function as external threats that can invade and potentially deliver collective defeat. The game deliberately denies players the comfort of knowing exactly where they stand with one another. Alliances hold only as long as mutual interest sustains them. Because espionage can wound even allies, no one feels truly secure.
Emergent Narrative and Dramatic Consequences
Reviewers describe moments of genuine drama and humor arising from player interaction and mechanical consequence. One reviewer recounted a game where political maneuvering led to a cascade of unexpected events: Venice stole a crucial mercenary captain through espionage, a papal conclave replaced a favorable pope with a weak one, and external pressure from the Holy Roman Empire forced new alliances. The game creates situations where player decisions carry real weight. Choosing to ally with the Pope makes you a target for other powers who resent papal influence. These meaningful choices, layered with uncertainty, produce games that feel like grand historical drama.
What Makes Foxes and Lions Stand Out
A Machiavelli Thesis Done Right
Paul Wright, one of the co-designers, is a Renaissance scholar, and Wright's influence shapes the game's ambition. Rather than treating Machiavelli as a simple cipher for betrayal, the designers drew on the Discourses on Livy, the Florentine Histories, and even comedic works to capture a fuller vision. The game tests Machiavelli's hypothesis about mercenaries, for instance. Machiavelli hated mercenaries and thought them unreliable, yet they were central to Renaissance warfare. The game lets players discover whether that skepticism was justified. Government systems in the game reflect Machiavelli's belief that republics are fragile, constantly threatened by time and circumstance. Players must perform "lawgiving" actions to reshape their territories' political systems. Reviewers appreciate that Foxes and Lions grapples with Machiavelli's actual ideas about politics, republics, and the nature of power.
The Ever-Present Threat of Collective Defeat
Foxes and Lions includes the possibility of collective defeat, something reviewers find both novel and thematically powerful. Histor ically, the Italian Wars ended with the dominance of the great powers and the eclipse of Italian independence. The game models this through an "Italian Virtue" track that declines whenever the great powers achieve their objectives or when player actions betray Italy to foreign powers. If this track reaches zero before any player achieves individual victory, Italy falls and everyone loses together. More than just a mechanical threat, the system forces an interesting choice space: do you pursue your own victory, or do you try to resist the great powers for everyone's sake? Reviewers highlight that this can lead to moments where a player is blamed for Italy's downfall, creating narrative responsibility that elevates the political tension. One reviewer noted this resembles Republic of Rome in creating menace from historical fate, but applied to a different era and with different win conditions.
Potential Drawbacks
Substantial Complexity and Learning Curve
At complexity 4.5 out of 5 and with a 300-minute playtime, Foxes and Lions is a heavy game. Reviewers noted that while the core rules proved straightforward, the decision space is vast. Players must balance CP spending, track hidden florins, manage political systems, and navigate alliance diplomacy. The sheer number of considerations can intimidate newcomers. The game demands mental engagement and rewards those who grasp its systems.
Development Status and Solitaire Limitations
Foxes and Lions is still in active development as a P500 title at GMT Games. While reviewers express confidence in the design direction and praise the playtesting process, the game has not yet reached final production. For solo players, the current design is not recommended. The game's multiplayer political dynamics and the necessity of player-to-player negotiation and espionage make it particularly ill-suited to solo play. Reviewers noted a low solitaire rating, and designers have not prioritized solo variants. This game is designed for the table, for human players, for the electric tension of face-to-face negotiation and the memorable moments of betrayal and alliance.
If You Enjoy Foxes and Lions
Foxes and Lions claims its place as the fourth game in the "Here I Stand" series, a lineage of card-driven wargames focused on political simulation over pure military tactics. If Foxes and Lions grips you, the natural next step is to explore the series that inspired it. Virgin Queen, which covers the Anglo-Spanish rivalry during the 16th century, shares the same core systems and offers similar depth in political maneuvering. Tanto Monta, covering the Italian Wars themselves but with a different design philosophy, provides a thematic sibling. "Here I Stand", which covers the Protestant Reformation and is the oldest game in the series, established many of the systems that Foxes and Lions adapts. Each game in this lineage trades abstraction for historical flavor, and each rewards careful political play and opportunistic negotiation.
Beyond the "Here I Stand" family, players drawn to Foxes and Lions might find resonance in Republic of Rome, which also uses collective defeat as a design element and challenges players to balance personal ambition against group catastrophe. For those who appreciate the RPG-like element where you play as an advisor to a potentially incompetent ruler, Crusader Kings 3 offers that same sense of working within historical constraints while trying to reshape them. The comparison games mentioned by designers all share Foxes and Lions' core appeal: they put you in the shoes of historical actors facing genuine dilemmas, and they let you discover what you would do.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"No, I was trying to take down Venice, but she stole my mercenary captain and then she set the Holy Roman Empire on me."
— Beyond Solitaire
"Everyone has left the table with a big smile on their face."
— Zilla Blitz
"And I like that little prickle of fear that that something could go wrong even within the turn."
— Beyond Solitaire