Tapestry: Plans and Ploys - Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and this time i'm going to be doing a no run-through review for the newest tapestry expansion plans and ploys now a full caveat here this is actually a review copy that was sent to me by stone meyer games so take that uh what you will um but the other caveat is if you've seen both of my run-throughs for tapestry or my discussion of tapestry you're gonna know i don't like this game so uh the fact that they sent me a review copy it just shows how telling the company is that just because i give things negative reviews of their games they're not gonna not give me a review copy just because of that and with that being said this expansion does nothing it does nothing it it is okay that's not entirely true if you like tapestry get this expansion if you don't like tapestry and you're thinking oh well maybe the expansion will fix it well it doesn't it doesn't at all like you know some games are like wow that game is real garbage oh no play with the first expansion because it fixes a lot of the problems and they're like oh and it does if you're of the same philosophy of me which is an expansion shouldn't fix the base game the game
should already be good enough on its own and expansion should only enhance that then that is it is what it is however this is just extra content it is new civilizations uh civilizations if you can call them that um and a few new tapestry cards a few new science tokens and by a few i mean like four uh they do come with a now the base the new printing of tapestry actually comes with this anyway but also does come with a like um like uh civilization adjustments on the back of the rulebook so for the original sieves where they might have been a little bit more busted because they weren't really tested uh then it comes with that pretty much the only aesthetically pleasing thing that this expansion comes with it comes with a bag like a burlap bag for some reason but it does come with these little tokens here and these tokens are aesthetic aesthetics only they go on the four tracks to indicate what the um you know the buildings that you get to place on your on your board uh like that that they've been taking and they're also colored so you can actually kind of find it's like how does this one it they're colored to represent those those types of buildings this i actually thought was a pretty nice touch to the game uh just because it showed had that like okay it's there i was the first one there i take the token and i can easily find
the building that was nice but there's no new text there's no new rules there's just new civilizations and the civilizations i mean for what the game is they're not horrible like they're pretty interesting and the tapestry cards are different as well and i'll get to that in a sec but essentially like for example one of the factions that you can play is the treasure hunters they start with four of their cubes on there and at the beginning of their income turn they can place that on the type of terrain and gain a benefit like if they place on a mountain they get to place they get a worker and they get to roll you know both the conquer dice and take both benefits or if they place it on the grasslands they get food and they get to roll the red dye twice and and add and keep both um which is actually pretty cool because if you roll like if you get lucky and roll a seven and a seven you get you just get 14 points so that was kind of interesting pretty straightforward uh there's also there's some new intro i always like the names of the factions like the the obviously this is where tapestry shines is kind of on its civilizations um but there's another one in this where it's aliens so radically different uh from the rest of them but you have aliens in there they actually start with four space tiles and at the beginning of their income phase they get to place a space tile on their board and get the benefit of that so that's kind of cool you don't have to run through the exploration track
um some other ones here that they have they have spies you may place a player token on one of the unselected options here to gain the corresponding benefits so for example one of them is you gain the benefits of a when played tapestry card gain a bit of benefit of a neighbor's tech card so you can just kind of steal what other people have done uh and a lot of these are actually like place your income tokens like these tokens here on to your your player mat um and there were stuff like that in the original game as well um like the tinkerers you can place a player token on one of the unselected options advance to the next bonus on any track and gain that bonus for free do not gain the benefit of any landmarks you pass that's pretty cool to jump higher up on the track like from bonus to bonus choose one of your advancement tokens gain resources equal to the cost of advancing into its current position so like if you're in the tier three you can gain of exploration you can get enough food and two of anything um so they're they're pretty they're they're pretty cool you know i mean the names of them are neat so infiltrators spies advisors recyclers okay not all of them are cool tinkerers islanders river folk and utilitarians um so that's that's pretty much that so those are those are pretty interesting uh if you i mean if you find that kind of stuff interesting uh as far as i can tell they're they're pretty balanced like the final score of the
game that we just got done playing was aliens versus treasure hunters uh the final score was 196 to 163 that's not horrible um and uh and then the new tapestry cards which like i said there's not a lot it's a small box as you can as you can see that they do a lot of counters like they have a lot more counters they're not just traps that you lay down or that you have in your hand and you just stop someone from you know taking over one of your territories like some of them are actually like oh if someone tries to play a trap against you cancel it and take one of their tapestry cards surrender if an opponent conquers the territory um then you can discard that and you actually just get to roll the conquer dice and gain both results this one is double cross you may discard this from your hand if an opponent plays a trap against you if you do cancel a trap and gain five points so there's a lot of the new tapestry cards where they cancel something that your opponent might do to to harm you um and you gain something out of it uh those those same cards actually if you don't use them for their ability you can play them again a bunch of points and like a resource or an exploration tile but honestly this did not improve my opinion of tapestry i still find it to be extremely themeless and extremely boring uh and not a civilization game in any way whatsoever i still hold true to the fact that the fact that they put this civilization game subheading underneath actually
ruined the game because you're gonna naturally compare it to civ games that's just what's gonna happen and with better sift games out on the market this is just not one of them um but like i said before if you like this game and it's perfectly fine if you do like my opinion is just my opinion um then i i highly recommend you go and get this expansion because it's only this is going to give you more of what you love it's going to give you more unique tapestry cards give you more unique uh civilizations with corrections to the other civilizations that were in the base game um it's going to give you more things to do with the solar variant if you play with the solar variant which i actually this one was interesting with taps because i also did a solar variant run through uh where they actually mimic two two players which i thought was pretty cool but they do something pretty neat in this uh which is the for the solo variant um with the ottoman the shadow empire there's actually a campaign so you do get a campaign but only with the solo variant uh and there's five five total games with that have unique setups and unique uh rules so like the first one is called focus scenario two is world war scenario three utopia scenario four the fall of atlantis and then scenario five foreshadow so you get five solo variant solar variant campaign uh which is probably the biggest
change to the game with this expansion let's see yeah you get a bag you get i don't know what the bags for oh yeah there's actually more more stuff there's new landmarks that is that is a key thing i was so focused on the civilization and the other stuff so they have these new landmark cards that the person going last in turn order will draw uh from these from this deck equal to the number of players and pick one and these are basically bonus landmarks that you get to put into your civilization and their unique buildings so for example this is a digital studio that at the end of your turn if you have at least two complete districts in your capital city you just gain this landmark um and it's like okay and you just gain a new landmark so it gives you something to strive for besides trying to just race up the track higher than other people now some of the tapestry cards actually just gave you a landmark instead of anything else so they they do kind of want to focus on actually getting some of these buildings because it was always in my opinion extremely difficult to want to do houses because you had you got points for each completed row and column but it wasn't always so easy to do that now it looks like with these bonus landmarks you get to at least get and they're pretty decent size i think they're the other two by three uh so we'll cover six squares and then with the new tapestries giving free landmarks that i was able to actually get six points
uh worth of of the the houses um so that's that's not nothing um so yeah so there's there's new that there's new civilizations um there's the aesthetic tokens which these are actually my favorite part of the game uh no new techs and a solo variant campaign and new tapestry cards so i mean like i said really what this review boils down to is if you like the game get it if you don't like the game or you're a on the game i wouldn't recommend it i don't think these are going to be i don't think anything that this expansion is going to bring is going to elevate it to something that you're wanting if you already don't like it if you're like me who didn't like it this does nothing this did nothing for me i just i played the game uh with it and i was like yeah it's still tapestry like there's nothing that was like oh what no that totally changes everything no there there was no eureka moment so with that being said i mean my room my my score for tapestry is still a five out of ten it was a four when i initially reviewed it but i mean i think it is just a five an average game uh and the expansion i mean this is actually a hard one because normally i can just review an expansion be like okay it's either crap one or a really good one and this might be the first time i've actually reviewed an expansion for a game i don't care much for so that's that might be why it's a little weird so here's the thing if if i'd like tapestry this would be like an eight an eight out
of ten because it gives me more of what i would already like um with a few unique twists and turns some some fun civilizations and maybe more ways to actually get some uh of these landmarks onto your onto your uh whatever that landscape um but for me personally the expansion's a 5 out of 10 as well it's it's not it's not a bad expansion but it's not a good one either because it's for a game that i don't really like but i think my most accurate one is going to be the 8 if you like tapestry so that's it everyone those are my thoughts on the expansion for tapestry plans employees let me know what you think of the game tapestry or the expansion in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you