Skip to main content
Loading video...

Thiefdom Review: Listen Like Thieves

Transcript 9:40

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel and today we're taking a look at Thiefdom. Not Thiefdom. I'll pronounce it right. Thiefdom. This is from Karma Games and it is a game in which you the against the Great Masters Guild collapsed. And so the Thieves Guild no longer have leaders, so you're having a competition to see who can steal the most stuff. This is a game in which you control a gang of three thieves and you're trying to run around town robbing people blind without getting caught by the guards. Sounds like a very thematic game and it is. Here's how it plays. You're going to build a big random board of sorts made up of these tiles next to each other. And this is going to show you there's lanterns here on different spots. There are hideouts. These are different buildings. There's regular buildings and there's locations where you can go and do different activities.

And these lanterns are important because there's going to be a lot of NPCs. I have them laying down, but you have guards and merchants. And they will often move from lantern to lantern. But if someone else is on a lantern they can skip that and go to the next one. And guard, you're going to try to use guards to catch other people's thieves. And you're also going to be trying to rob these merchants. You're also trying to go into catacombs and get things, go into houses and steal paintings and go off and fence them. I'm kind of just giving you an overview, but let's take a look at the basic way the game works. Each player has three different thieves with names here and they're all going to start in your hideout at the board. You'll choose a spot to be your hideout. And each round of the game you're going to have a different card here that shows you which people you control. So here I control merchants A and B and guard A. And I'm going to be picking the order of everything in. I have a 1 2 3 and 4.

And so maybe I'll do it like this. So I'm going to be moving him third, second, the guards first and fourth. So in turn order whoever's first will pick it. So here I would move my guards and do different things, some actions. And then I'd move Valerie and Wilhelm and Margot. But I can do whatever order I want. So everyone does their ones, then their twos, then their threes. And then you will pass this along. And then the next you'll get one you'll get this from the next player. And now I get to move the wagon and move the guard C and merchant C. You have three action points in your turn, which can be movement, you know, 1 2 3. You can go into a building and do something like here for example. I can send gems to get victory points or turn in a painting at the fence to get eight victory points and a special resource. You're running around trying not to get seen by guards. If you get guards you can get caught, lose victory points and get sent back to your house.

But you're going to run around. You will start the game with some equipment. And these equipment you will be able to upgrade your characters with. You also can run into friends who you can get into a fight with or add them. This is important because each thief can hold different resources. You have four spots hold resources. Four spots hold coins back at your hideout. You can carry some of both um coins or resources. When you get different items, let's say for example I get the grappling hook which will maybe let me run through buildings faster. I'll put it here in the bottom shoving up there in the show that I have that. Or maybe a sack, I get that. And so I can have up to two different items. Now I have extra spots to carry things. When you get a friend you'll take the card and tuck it in at the top where you now that you befriended them they'll give you basically another special ability. The game is going to be taking place over six rounds. Certain things will get refilled after rounds two and four. At the end of the game you're going to get points based on the various leftover things that you have. But other than that you'll be taking your turns running around the board going to one place to rob gems, going and dropping off another place, going into houses, stealing paintings trying to avoid the guards moving the wagon around and then trying to rob that wagon changing going around the taverns and buying different things.

There's lots of different actions that you can take, but after six rounds you'll add up your points and whoever has the most is the winner.

There's a lot going on in this game and there's a lot of setup and there's a lot of different pieces out there. I like the artwork a lot. Uh the Miko's artwork is always fantastic and especially when he's you know, drawing a bunch of ne'er-do-wells, your thieves and the friends that they make and the weapons and things and I think that adds to the theme. And I want to talk a little bit about theming here because the theme kind of works sort of. You're running around robbing the stagecoach. You're also robbing these merchants and try sometimes you even rob a guard. You steal their badge. They get really annoyed when that happens. But at the end of the day this robbing and ducking in the buildings and things, I like that. It's pretty difficult to get caught by a guard unless you just want to take the chance that I'm going to move into this spot and I know a guard could get caught could catch me or if a guard is move another guard moves to a spot then the guard can jump over that spot. So there's ways for it to happen but it's usually you putting yourself out there or just not being able to jump into a building in time.

And I kind of wish there was a little bit more of a push your luck aspect to it. Um but and and that's and that that works well like I said, but I just wish that part was stronger. But the rest of it I do like. I like moving the coaches. I like that you control a different set of guards and merchants each time that you pass these tokens around these boards around. I like the picking the order of people going in. You have to keep a a general mind as to this is my thief number two, whatever their name is. They're the ones that have the grappling hook or the boots that make them run faster. You have to keep that in mind. You're not going to keep track of everybody else. The game is a little bit like Istanbul in the sense of I go here to steal the gems, I go here to sell them and they could be close to each other or they could be far away. And if you can find a good loop of get this, do this, sell this you can do pretty well. There's one spot where if stuff if you do get caught by the guards your stuff is confiscated and will go somewhere and you can go there and steal that.

There's a there's a there's a decent amount going on, but like I said you're more kind of looking for the loop of where to go and where guards aren't going to catch you and getting portraits. Or there's a little black order black market orders in the board. They need these certain things to get a good chunk of points. And I think it all comes together in a decent game. What keeps me from loving the game I think is that it just is a little long. There are six rounds and in each round you're making four moves. So that's 24 moves over the course of game per player. And I think maybe with two players it would be shortened, but then you don't have all that interaction. But because your moves are very chess-like, you really don't want to go into a spot where a guard can get you. Because the guards have eyes and I had the pieces laying flat on the board, but they're going to be standing up. And so I'm trying to move a guard so at any point this trip he sees you. And so you when you move and when you do actions you're like, I'm going to go here, do that and go here. I'm out of the sight of the guard. But you're going to find very often I'll go here.

I'm going to move it here, buy these and then come out. But if I come out that's kind of a wasted action. And so there's a lot of down time in this game and I think it just takes a little long. The box says 30 minutes per player which I think once you know what you're doing is accurate. But a two-hour game of this feels a little longer than it should be and most games if you put thought into them they're going to be longer than two hours. It's going to come closer to three. And while the theme is fun and interesting, I don't think it's that strong to carry the game that long. Which is why my final rating for this game is a six. I like the look of the game. I like the concept of the game. I like robbing the stagecoach. I wish there was a little bit more interactions almost forced. I'll sit there and go well I'm every time I control the guard I'm usually just making the guard run away from my people rather than hunt other people's down. And so then the next turn I come and I do the same thing with that guard or if that guard's nowhere near me I'll make him come after you.

It's a clever idea though. I think the game does something different. It is a pick up and deliver even if you're picking up stolen goods and delivering them. Um and and and it and I wish it was a little faster because then I think it could be a really strong classic thief game. As it is I think some people are going to enjoy it and I liked my plays of it. I just wish they weren't quite as long and then I think the game would really sing. So that is Thiefdom. Check it out. I'm Tom Vasel and you're watching The Dice Tower.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things we review, games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved