Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig Review: Where Should My Fungus Room Go? - By Board of It
Transcript
hello everyone tally and farrell here from board of it and today we're going to be discussing between two castles of mad king lubig a wacky competitive co-operative tarlaying game born of a collaboration between stoneway games and bezier games for between two and seven players now when we say competitive cooperative we don't mean that there are two ways to play it is literally competitive and cooperative at the same time this is because as you play you will be building a castle with the person on your left and the person on your right most of the gameplay will consist of drafting tiles putting them into your castles and debating with the other players where best to put them where you can best score points from them but you secretly want to be crowned the best castle maker because the mad king will be coming round at the end of the game and assessing your castles and you'll only receive the points for your worst castle so the player who wins will be the player who has made the best worst castle now this is a hybrid game of the castles of mad king ludwig and between two cities neither of which we've actually played so you can consider this review a clean review uh where we'll be reviewing the game based on its own merits but before we get into it and we'd just like to state for our professional integrity that we were very kindly sent a copy of the game to review by stonemaier games
playing between two castles is exceedingly simple you'll begin with a throne room that you share with the player on your left and another one that you share with the player on your right this is the foundation for your castle you'll also begin with a stack of nine room tiles which you'll look through and you'll pick one of these rooms to play to the castle on your right one to play to the castle on your left then you'll pass the remaining room tiles to your left there are a few different room types each with different rules of scoring points sleeping rooms want you to have one of every other type of room whereas food rooms want you to have a specific type of room to the left or the right of it or it can even be above or below it outdoor spaces score for and the number of a type of room that you have in your castles whereas downstairs tiles score for a specific type of room above it after everyone has put down a tile to go to each one of their castles and pass their stack of tiles to the left then you all simultaneously reveal and you'll discuss with your neighbors about which tiles to put where now this will continue until there is only one tile left in the stack at which point you will eject all the remaining tiles from the game and begin a second round with a new stack of nine rim tiles and the only difference with the second round is that you will pass
the tiles to the right instead of the left at the end of the second round you'll score up you'll go through room type by room type scoring each room individually then comparing each player's highest scoring worst castle and the player with the highest scoring worst castle wins now while the main game is for three to seven players there is a two player variant in which you have a ghost third player in round one one player will randomly choose two tiles for the ghost player but then they get to decide which tile goes to which castle and in the second round the other player takes over that role the first thing that will strike you when you play between two castles is going to be the noise and the buzz in the air as you play and this is because it's an awesome game for interaction and all types of conversations are going to be breaking out across the table because people have to collaborate with their neighbors they're going to be discussing what's how to put where what bonuses they should go for what their strategy in the future should be what tiles to look out for and so on it's an incredible game for interaction where everybody is involved often when you play a game maybe the focus will be on one or maybe two people at a time and it might be that the focus is inwardly if you're playing a non-interactive euro because just strategizing to yourself but here that's not the case and really the reason we play games is to socialize interact with our friends and this is a tremendous vehicle for that what we will say though
is this interaction will decrease the more familiar that you get with the game particularly if you're avid board gamers when you first play the game it's all fresh and new and you really want to discuss everything but when you play more than that you know the ropes so what kind of happens is you turn to one castle and say well i'm placing this tile here because they obviously should go there and then the other player might say well actually i already placed that one there because that has to be connected to that and then you turn to your other castle and repeat the same often there's not too much to discuss and you're really just talking through it just so the other player knows what's going on in the castle in terms of gameplay we're really impressed that almost all of the room types are of equal value and usefulness they combine to create an intriguing puzzle giving players multiple options to take and this branching style of game results in unique castles that are going to be special to you and that game often you're just as likely to want to place one room type as another and the only one that falls a little bit short for us is the orange utility rooms so the way these work are you get points for each connected room type and an unbroken chain of the room type that it demands and these are just the kind of only ones that seem a lot more work than they're worth it might just be us but these seem to only be used as a last resort or to fill the conditions of another tile rather than being picked
for what they do and yeah it just they just fall a bit flat for us but what we will say is that they kind of make up for it because they have one of the best bonuses of the game if you get three of them in your castle as you get to pick three of these end game bonus cards and keep one and these can be worth a lot of points but yeah as kind of summary for us it's just the one that doesn't really pull its way it's the odd one out speaking of the special bonuses these are a great addition to the gameplay they're all different and innovative with their usefulness to your castle depending on your castle they provide a lot of different strategies as you can focus on getting three or five of a kind of a run to score the special bonuses and score big points there or focus on making your castle a well-oiled machine daisy chaining rooms together for mad points or a bit of both you know what worries me about the runs is that i've never seen a toilet room keeping track of these bonuses can be a bit tricky it's very easy in the heat of gameplay to miss that you've put down your third or your fifth tile of a certain room type either because they're spread all over the castle or just because you're really eager to turn to your other castle and see what's going on there and it can also if this happens which it does be a bit unfair because depending what you've placed in the interim by the time you realize you could be scoring more points for that bonus also the scoring is a bit of a beast
it's tough there's a lot going on there's a lot to keep track of it's very easy to miss a room or two and you really have to go over it twice with a fine-tooth cone and the issue is that many of our games have been so close scoring that missing rumor two would change the outcome and this isn't a criticism of the game because it has a very excellent and clear score pad very easy to use it's done as well i think as it could be done i don't know how you'd improve it it's just the way the game is and this great score pad doesn't really change the fact that if you're playing with your family or with people who aren't experienced board gamers you definitely want the experienced board gamers to be scoring this up and double checking it between two castles also occupies a bit of a strange area because it's a strategic game when it comes down to it who wins is almost total luck what tiles are in the game and whether they work with the tiles already in your castle is totally random plus the tiles that you desperately need may never come up because they can be taken from you before they even get near you thus it becomes about working with what you have rather than designing as best you can and that's not to say that the drafting isn't important because it certainly is it's just that sometimes it feels like drafting with your hands tied behind your back and the impact you have on your own castle can feel non-existent in essence what we're trying to say is that between two castles occupies a
weird space because it's so intuitive lying breezy it's practically a party game of some sort but because of its big box and if you have a lot of players it's a table hog i feel like you'd struggle to introduce it to people or get people excited about it if they weren't already board gamers you know and i mean like if you went to a party and you had this under one arm and one night werewolf under the other arm and they would just take a look at that box and the title and then instantly go for the much smaller other game following on from this thought that between two castles occupies a weird space in gaming this isn't a game you'd want to play if you want to play a game and win it because of your own abilities this is game to play if you want to have fun with your friends and family and speaking of family this is the perfect game to play for families because all you have to do is on your turn pick two times you could literally do it at random and the game would still progress and this means that it's pretty great for anyone of any age everyone's going to feel included because of the discussions and i can honestly say this is something i can see being at family gatherings in the future and it just has something for everyone whether they want to be competitive cooperative creative or they just want to be included plus it goes up to seven players and because of the nature of this game it's not going to add on much play time because everyone plays simultaneously
it's always your turn so it keeps everyone feeling engaged it's also extremely intuitive which is a comment we had from our friends when we taught them to play pretty much anyone is going to be able to pick this up and play super easily because you start with a throne room which tells you which type of rooms you should build around it you'll focus on those in the beginning and then those rooms will tell you what they want around them and then you're off so we've obviously been talking a lot about all this interaction with other players and it's great families and seven players but quite clearly none of this happens or occurs in the two player variant because there's only two of you and this two player variant becomes much more like other tie line games and that is a quite relaxing soothing affair as you work quietly on your own puzzle uh you know the aspect of picking tiles for the other player when you play it too is quite interesting but in reality because you randomly pick two if one of them is good for your castle it's going in your castle and then it doesn't matter what the other is whether it's good or bad for the other player so to me it falls a bit flat but i think tally's a bit more up on the two-player variant yeah i actually quite like it um because i quite like the aspect that you have a lot more control over your own castle maybe that's just because i'm a massive control freak but obviously i mean i love playing with other players obviously that's the main
game and it is super fun but i think the two player variant is is pretty good okay so now we're going to quickly talk about the art and the components we are big fans of game trays so always happy when they are included in the game can't go wrong with them it's lightning quick to set up because of game trays and storage is great blah blah blah everything we've said about game trades before super quick super cool love it great presentation i also really love all of the artwork on all of the tiles because i think it's mostly unique right so even though you have four yeah i think they are all unique so even though you have you know seven or eight types of rooms i think it is within those types each room is unique so here i have the three living rooms but one's a sitting room one's a vestibule one's a study each with unique artwork and i think that's really nice and it's really cool and i always love getting the tiles and and studying them and seeing what's on there there's also some in-jokes as well like you have a games room and it has stone marker games in it i love that just just stuff like that it is so the whole presentation and everything there's kind of nothing at fault here really so if you you know any aspect of this is top notch and that's kind of the bottom line final thoughts between two castles of mad king ludwig is a great game to have if you want to play with your family if you want to play with people who are a wide range of ages if you want to play with a lot of people
or if you just want a lighter more relaxing board game night this game is quick to play consistently engaging and has charming art direction you could do worse than have it in your collection however it does occupy a weird space between party game and board game if you're an avid board gamer we can't see this being one that you would choose to get out over other games particularly if you don't want luck to decide who the winner is also it might be a hard sell at parties due to the size of the box and the space it will take up that being said we are super glad to have this in our collection going forward and we really can't wait to play with our families next time we see them yeah if you enjoyed this video we'd really really appreciate it if you could give us a thumbs up and leave us a comment down below feel free to ask us anything about the game and if you enjoy our content it would mean the world to us if you could subscribe to our channel and even more to the dogs absolutely thanks for watching