Skip to main content
Loading video...

Undaunted: Stalingrad - Is this the best deck-builder ever?

Transcript 19:13

this episode of brains on games will talk about undaunted Stalingrad a deck building game set in World War II I'm gonna brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we are going to talk about a World War II deck building game this one has campaign elements and honestly it was the winner of a poll that I put up a week and a half or so ago because I've received a whole pile of games in the mail and undaunted Stalingrad was the one that got the most votes in terms of the game that people wanted to hear about the most here is the box for undaunted Stalingrad by Osprey games this is a huge giant box because it's a campaign game so there's a whole pile of pieces that came in this thing it's a game that takes between 45 minutes and an hour to play a scenario it's for kids age 14 and up and it's a two player game so you can't play three or four players with this one it's two players only let's take a deeper look at undaunted styling grad undaunted Stalingrad is a deck building game but you've also got a board that's made up of these tiles and they're they're representing different areas of the city of Stalingrad this was I think the bloodiest battle of the second world war and you're playing the Germans versus the Soviet so one player will play the Soviets through an entire campaign and the other player is playing Germany it's medium in terms of its

complexity and like I said you can play a game in about an hour and in terms of winning the the goals are scenario specific and some scenarios will have different Mission goals depending on whether you're the Germans or the Soviet players this is set up for the very first mission so I'm not spoiling anything by showing you anything that's on this board and I won't show you any of the the more advanced units or cards that you unlock as you go through the campaign one of the neat things about this campaign game is although your deck changes and you're going to have casualties and cards that you're not allowed to use later on you don't destroy anything you don't put stickers on anything so everything can be reset without needing to buy extra cards or or an extra board or anything like that there are plenty of tiles you saw how big that box was there are plenty of tiles and there are a whole bunch of different scenarios in the box but tiles as you go through the game you may be able to destroy some areas of the board and change their layout so things can change over the course of the campaign depending on what you do it's a branching campaign because you've got these well this is a the map book that shows you how to layout the tiles for any given scenario but each player the Soviet player and the German player also have this scenario book that tells them what units they're going to have available to them what their starting hand is what their mission goals are and there's a little story a briefing that goes along as you go through the game so

you read one section of text and then it'll tell you well this is what you need to set things up for this particular scenario of undaunted each player is going to have a supply of cards that they can pull into their deck you've got a four card hand and what you're doing is playing the cards from your hand in order to either give orders to your pieces that are here on the board or to draw Cards into your hand or to draw cards from your supply and put them into your deck each of the cards has a few orders that you can give or actions that you can take when you play those cards and The Riflemen tend to be among the most important ones because you're going to want to play those Rifleman cards to eventually get The Rifleman over to your objective because The Rifleman those are the guys at least at the beginning of the game those are the guys the only ones that can control an area of the board by flipping over that little scouted token and showing that you're in control you're drawing cards from your supply into your deck you're using those currents to give these these pieces orders in the game sometimes you're going to be shooting at the other players it is a war game so for example you know one of the best combat options at the beginning is your machine Gunners and what's neat about them is that they they get to roll two dice and they're 10-sided dice in this game they get to roll two dice if if they're just trying to attack and inflict casualties but they can also do

suppressing fire which just flips over the piece that they're shooting at so then it's got this these stripes on it and that means that the piece can't take any actions the next time you play a card with with this logo on it Rifleman a you just get to flip it back over they can't do anything else so they're sort of Frozen in place until you do something with it that is a super powerful action in the game we found and really great that the the machine Gunners can do that because they roll four dice for suppressing fire because they're not trying to kill anyone they're just trying to freeze them in place so that they can't do anything when you roll those dice your your opponent is going to have a defense value depending on the tile they're on and how far away they are how much cover they have and you roll a 10-sided die equal to or higher than that defense value is going to be a success doesn't matter how many successes you get if you roll a 10 on the 10-sided die you automatically succeed but otherwise you're just trying to get at least one success in in order for that action to be successful because it is a campaign game there are things that carry over like I said earlier you might destroy some of the tiles on the map that's not something you can do in the first scenario but there might be casualties your machine Gunners or your Riflemen might be firing at their opponents and inflict some casualties and that might mean that they're going to permanently lose a card from their their deck now there are Replacements you can get

reinforcements into your deck because you need a certain number of Riflemen or else you're not going to be able to do the control action that's going to allow you to move towards victory in the next scenario but the reinforcements tend to be weaker than the cards they're replacing so they might have one action less or they might only be able to fire for at a certain range on the board for example you also get to upgrade some of your current so so your currents might become veterans after a particular scenario is finished you'll draw a couple of cards that are going to be replaced by cards that are more powerful that maybe have a more powerful action or have something extra that they can do when you play that card so things gradually evolve over time you start out there are some tiles here that say you can't drive tanks or Vehicles into them you don't have any vehicles in your supply at the start of the game so those are things that get unlocked later on what skills are you working on though when you're playing a game like undaunted Stalingrad well one of the things when you're talking about a board like this and they have certain tiles that are that are your objectives and it's there's an area control element to it you are working on those spatial skills you you need to figure out in this game your your soldiers your units can only move through squares that your Scouts have already scouted out for you so they have to have that little symbol the binocular symbol on them or else you can move that way so you have to have a scout the Scout has to move through uh that space and then your Rifleman or

your machine Gunners can move there so you're you're doing this spatial problem solving here with the board but you're also thinking about probability How likely am I to draw one of these cards into my hand or there's so many in the deck that that's going to slow me down I'm only going to get two actions instead of three next turn uh how close do I need to be before unlikely to succeed in suppressing or attacking an enemy soldier because you know you're rolling those 10-sided dice if you've got four chances you might be able to roll seven or higher if you've got four chances but if you only have one die to roll The Rifleman only gets to roll one die so uh there's it it can be very risky so you are thinking about probability both for your card draws what cards do you want to put into that deck to make sure you're drawing the ones that you want on any given turn we did find sometimes there was this card you know I I had The Rifleman and he's just in the right place but the space wasn't scouted yet and I couldn't draw a scout card to save my life so I couldn't move the Scout through so that slowed me down for a couple of turns while my opponent was whittling away at my forces each scenario too though is a puzzle for you to solve you've got an initial setup you can't see the whole board here there are Soviet soldiers that are way way down at the bottom on the way I set this up I played the Germans when we started this game so each each scenario is set up as a puzzle for you to solve and each

player is going to kind of change your options through the actions that they take on top of that as you go forward in the game you'll have certain cards or units that are more valuable than the others that you really have to be careful about you might be reluctant to risk them so because you're you're solving a new puzzle each time you're looking at the pattern of how things are laid out on the board to determine what are you going to do next you might have to adjust your strategy on the Fly because each scenario is a new thing with different goals and if you're being flexible in your problem solving if you're using pattern recognition skills even your understanding of probability and using that to solve problems those are all examples of fluid reasoning that flexible problem solving working with incomplete information applying what you learned in one way to a novel scenario right all of the scenarios are novel here the first time you play through the game so fluid reasoning is another skill that you're working on here and finally you are of course playing through uh these campaign scenarios in a city that's in really in the world set in a time and a battle that really happened so there is an opportunity here for discussion and maybe to do some research about that Battle of Stalingrad that lasted five months I really didn't know too much about what happened on the on the Far Eastern front when the Germans went into Russia other than the fact

that their soldiers were so cool they didn't get very far so I I didn't know a lot about that I knew more about what was happening in Italy what was happening in Africa I didn't know too much about what was going on in Russia so I did do some reading because you know the story here is is an interesting one and it is like I said the bloodiest battle of World War II so you've got that idea that maybe you're going to spark some curiosity or some discussions or or encourage a teenager to do some research in terms of you might even do some research to figure out well what might happen in the next scenario so that you can plan ahead a little bit uh to play against your opponent final thoughts about undaunted Stalingrad this is a very thematic war game uh with a campaign where it's it's tense to begin with I will tell you when you're rolling those Dice and if your opponent's rolling the dice and they're trying to shoot or suppress your soldiers you are on the edge of your seat waiting to see what's going to happen so especially since we are playing a campaign game and there are long-term implications if you lose some of these pieces you do get more attached to those soldiers as they get upgraded you're more attached to the veterans I think and you're more careful about those and we found ourselves as we were playing a bit reluctant to to put some of those cards into our deck because we didn't want to risk losing them when we weren't really sure whether we had a good chance to win the scenario or not so we were trying to be really

careful and cautious with those veterans we didn't want to waste them because we were we were attached to them uh and and so it's extra tense the further along you go you get units that are unique that don't um you don't have a large number of them so you don't want to lose them especially since you you risk losing them permanently so it's thematic and it's tense every die roll all of your opponents moves are interesting there's never enough cards and orders and actions to do all the things you would like to do and it combines area control the the Strategic part of a board game with the the deck building mechanism you know and I'm not a fan of deck builders I wouldn't list them you know we've talked about trick takers we've talked about dexterity games I love both of those Euro games uh another game that sort of combines a strategic board game with some deck building elements would be Concordia and that's one of my favorite games of all time but the deck building is is not as uh prevalent I guess you would say it's not as traditional of a deck building game the way that undaunted is because you do have cards that you're trying to get rid of uh here in this game but also the cards are units that get lost and so like I said it's thematic I like that this is a campaign game but it's one where you don't destroy or deface or mutilate your cards in any way it hurts

my heart to buy a game and then have to tear up cards or or to face them in some other way so the fact that this is one where you can just reset everything when you're done and maybe in a few months come back to it or play with a different player or or uh you know loan it to a friend who's who's into these kinds of games so you've got this this real I I think it's very clever it's a streamlined mechanism of combat where you're counting your distance in the cover and you're rolling those dice for Success uh I think it's easy to grasp what you're doing here once you get an idea of what the orders do uh it's not too hard to figure out the rules but there's there's still strategy and and it's a tense fun game to play uh there's some Randomness because you you do have those dice rolls but you can mitigate it to an expense to an extent uh by placing your counters in in a place where it's less risky for them to take those shots are there downsides though to undaunted Stalingrad well I mean there are maybe a few I would say that the artwork on the cards is great the characters on the cards are great they have little names that are written in cursive like their signature but the tiles themselves are kind of samey they don't look a lot different from one another in a way well I mean you're sort of looking at almost like a satellite image of of a bombed out City so thematically that does make sense but

it is kind of hard to distinguish one from another it's a good thing that the tiles are numbered would be very hard to figure out which one was which if they weren't they do fit together like a puzzle so you've got like a railroad that runs through you may not be able to see that on the camera but it's not the the graphics on the tiles are not super appealing I would say and they don't distinguish one from the next you're not going to be talking about necessarily Pavlov's house here because you know it's just a non-descript brown roof that you can see there's nothing else about the tile that makes that stand out other than there's a name printed on it in some homes or some families the the limit of playing at a two player count might be something that interferes with the enjoyment of the game if both of my kids were home I couldn't play this with both of them because it's a two player not a three player game and a concern that I have I haven't played through every single scenario in the campaign but one concern that I have and this might be more risky depending on who you're playing with and how those games go is that later games in the campaign might be less balanced because of things that happen in earlier games maybe you've lost some of your veterans from earlier missions and so you don't have the more powerful cards where the other player does have them maybe some area that that you needed for cover has been destroyed and and you don't have the same degree of cover that you would have had on that space otherwise so it's possible that the later missions might be a bit less balanced you might really

have to puzzle out how are you going to win it one player might be at an advantage over the other but I have to say this is you know other than Concordia which is one of my favorite games of all time this is definitely the best deck builder I have ever played it is just it's so smooth and tense and everything about it other than the satellite pictures on the tiles uh it it just uh calls out to be played again I'm surprised I'm not playing it right now but my my partner in crime is working today so I'm I'm here to tell you about it uh this is a fantastic game that really is evocative it's so thematic um that every single card play uh you know you're watching the other player what is he gonna do I just really really enjoyed this game it's my first time playing an undaunted game they've been on my radar for a while but because the the deck building mechanic isn't my favorite um I I waited until now where everybody was talking about the campaign elements and when I heard about that I thought well listen Maybe This is the one that I'll try this is the evolution of the undaunted franchise maybe so we really really like this game if you like World War II style games you're limited to choosing between you know the Soviets and the Germans you don't get to play the Allies maybe but uh if you like World War II style games uh if deck

building is something that you're into if you like the area control mechanic like there is here if you like Campaign games where you don't wreck your stuff um this is perfect in all of those areas so Osprey games has really knocked this one out of the park if you have any questions or suggestions you can leave them in the comment section below the video or you can email me at Brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.ca is the website that's where future episodes ago the previous ones are up there already brain Zone games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time

Progress saved