Hanami Review: Deep Knizia Lore
Transcript
Hey there everybody, I'm Mike Delisio.
And I'm Chris Yee.
And today we are coming to you with a review of Hanami. This is coming from Key Master Games and designer Reiner Knizia and it has a little subtitle here, Samurai reimagined because this is a re-implementation, a re-theme of a pretty well thought of game called Samurai that came out many years ago. It was part of what was called the tile-laying trilogy. It later became known as that. I don't think it was billed as that at the time.
No, and if it was I would say those marketers got to step up their game.
to step up their game. Yeah,
It's the card trilogy.
Yeah, it consists of Tigris and Euphrates,
Mhm.
and Samurai, which is now Hanami, and Through the Desert. All of those games have been re-implemented within the last 10 years.
Yeah, well wait, one of them very soon upcoming too, right? The Tigris and Euphrates.
Yes, yeah, they they that that one had been re-implemented as Huang and then before that it was kind of yellow and yellow. Anyway, we're getting deep into Knizia lore you don't need to know about. Let me show you how this one plays and we'll come back here and let you know what we think. The first thing I want to point out here is that there are two sides to this game board. This side, the Nihon side, is what you're going to be playing for essentially the base game that is most reminiscent of the original Samurai game, but there is an alternate side to this board which is unique to this game, which is the Tokyo side of the board and I'm not going to really be talking about this one as much, but I did want to show it so that you can see kind of what the other side is. It has a different makeup, but essentially the setup is going to be uh pretty much the same uh depending upon player count as it shows you here, which I'll show you on the main side after it's all set up like this. Okay, here we see the board all set up for a four-player game. It's mostly a random setup with the exception of this spot here that shows the three trees. It means you're placing one of the three different types of celebration tokens in that area. The rest of them are going to be randomly seated. There are a couple of places that have two trees, meaning two tokens go there. And the only thing there is you can't have two of the same celebration token on any of those spots.
You adjust for player count here, meaning that if you are only playing with two players, you'd just be playing on this main island of Honshu, and you'd have a smaller distribution of the number of the celebration tokens. Here you see the blue player's components. Everyone has a player screen that they'll be keeping their hand of tiles behind. And it also acts as a very nice player aid, where it's going to tell you both the distribution of all the the tiles that you have. It's going to have the main action tile that you would use in all of the games. These special action tiles are a variant, and we can talk about those briefly at the end. And then just the basic turn structure, where you're going to be placing one or more of your player tiles. If a celebration token will be awarded, then that would happen. And then you draw back up to five player tiles. It also mentions that once per game, you can flip your ability card to activate it.
And I'll talk about that in just a moment moment, excuse me. Then you see all of those tiles played out and the ability card. So, essentially what you'll be doing is once you've gotten your um components, your tiles, and everything, you're going to shuffle all those up. Shuffle, shuffle, shuffle. And then you're going to draw randomly five of them that you'll place behind your player shield as your starting hand. Like so. So, normally I'd have this as a screen to hide from the other players, but for the purpose of the overview, I'll just have them open-faced here. So, um what these tiles are going to do is they are going to give you some amount of strength or influence on a particular space for these particular uh celebration tokens. There are three different celebration tokens that you're trying to gain a majority in at the end of the game. Essentially, if at the end of the game you've claimed majority on two of these three, you immediately win. If that doesn't happen, then there's an alternate scoring that we'll talk about.
But, basically, on your turn, it says play one of your player tiles and then also play any number of fast tiles that you would like on your turn. And that's the symbol to denote which tiles are fast tiles. If you choose to play fast tiles, they can be played before or after your main player tile. So, let's say perhaps I'm looking at this. I've got the Sakura tile, which I can place anywhere, but I essentially would want to be placing it near Sakura tokens. And so, a good idea for me might be to place this one right here because I now have four Sakura influence over this space and this space because they are obviously adjacent to it. Now, it says in addition, I could play one or more fast tiles. I happen to have these two boat tiles that both show that fast symbol. So, I may choose to place these now if I want to. And maybe what I would do is place one here and maybe place one Actually, might I might do is do this. Place that one there and that one there. These boat tiles can only be placed in the water, the lighter colored blue tiles on the outside, whereas your regular tiles can only be placed on the land tile. So, I keep shifting that around for some reason, but anyway. What this is saying is that now, over this space, I have five influence over that tile because this is a wild. The boats
are wild. And in this space, I've got six influence on the sakura token uh token, and two influence on the um onigiri, the rice ball. All right? Because these are wild. Also, you notice these cats. These are wild for any of the tokens. And so, if I had played this instead, if I'd chosen to do this, now what I have is four influence over that sakura tile, and five influence over both of those tiles. So, maybe that would have been a better play. Let's say that I'd done that. And then, at the end of my turn, I draw back up to five behind my ti- behind my screen, and I've got ready for my next turn. Other players are going to be doing the same thing, placing out their influence tokens. At any point, if uh a token is completely surrounded um on the land tiles, then you would award that token. So, let's say the green player had come and done this. All right? Well, at this point, what happens is you're going to evaluate this token because it's completely surrounded by land. You You do not need to be surrounded by water.
As a matter of fact, doing this would have still caused that one to trigger because it's surrounded by land. But let's say we did this. Now, by doing this, we check. There is four influence from the green player, and four influence from the blue player. Whenever there's a tie, this doesn't get awarded to either player. Instead, it gets placed right here. This is where the tide uh tokens go. If at any point four tokens are placed here, that would trigger the end of the game immediately. But, let's say instead that green had chosen to play this. Now, they're not going to win this token at that point because the blue player has four, and they would take this. But, they are placing influence on these two.
So, maybe they're setting up for a later play. And that's the general idea of the game is that you're going to be placing one or more of your tiles, trying to surround these tokens to gain them uh into your supply so that at the end of the game, you have majority of as many of these different celebration tokens as you can get. You also have a one-time ability to flip over your ability card. And this says to swap the position of any two celebration tokens on the board, which would mean that you're doing something along these lines. Maybe you're wanting to do this. The problem is you couldn't do that because you can't ever have two of the same uh tokens on a spot. So, instead, what they would likely do would be to do this.
And now they're fine, okay? So, every player has the opportunity to opportunity to do that once per game. All right? So, we've talked about all the different regular tiles. You do have a special tile, this action tile, which allows you This is it right here. This tile will allow you to move one of your player tiles to an available land space and then place this in the original space. So, um let's say that on a later turn that the blue player had had maybe gone here, and they had maybe this uh here, okay? And now what they want to do is they want to swap so that they can place a tile that maybe wasn't in a good spot.
Maybe they did this, and now they place that there. The end of the game is going to be triggered in one of two ways. I already mentioned the first, which is that if you get four ties and those tokens have been placed here, that would trigger the end of the game. The other way that the end of game could be triggered is if any one of the three main celebration tokens have been completely removed from the board, that would also end it. So, let's say for example that all of the sakura tiles, all of these have been cleared from the board and claimed by players or placed over here, that would also trigger the end of the game. And at that point, you determine the final scoring. What you're going to do is everyone is going to reveal the tokens they have, and whoever has the majority of each of them is going to get one of these large tokens to show them that. If there's a tie, no one gets rewarded that token, but let's say for example that one of the players had collected that, and another player collected that, and the first player had also gotten the majority there. If any player ever collects two majorities, they are immediately the winner of the game. But let's say instead that three different players had claimed these tokens. What you're then going to do is you're going to count the other two token or the the amount of tokens in the other two categories that you didn't have the majority in, and whoever had the most of those combined would then be the winner. If that still doesn't break the tie, then you're going to count the total number of celebration tokens amongst all three, and whoever has the most would win there. Otherwise, you would share the victory. There is a rare
occasion where no player can wins one of these three majorities, and in that case, you go with whoever has the most celebration tokens total. I mentioned there is another side of the board that has a different setup, and that is recommended after you've played the base game a few times. There are also some special action tokens that you can add into the game as well. Uh so, this is a uh uh fast token that is wild of one strength. This is one that would allow you to draw another tile when you play it and add it to your hand. This is uh then that's a fast token. This is another fast token. This is a wild three. This is one you would place Excuse me, let me get that more so it is in focus for you. There you go. This is one you would place on top of another token. It basically replaces whatever you put it on top of with a three wild.
And this is one that allows you to copy another tile. It can be one of your tiles or another tile. And you just would point that arrow towards the tile that you want to copy. So, those are some advanced action tiles you can add into the mix as well. You can also add in advanced ability cards. So, instead of everyone having the same ability, you can shuffle these up and pass two out to every player and they can pick which one of the two they want to have. They all have different abilities that can trigger. They're all still one-time use per game, but it gives everyone a slightly asymmetric ability card that they can use once per game. And that's again something you can do to add into the game. There are also some variants as far as how the game is set up, things along those lines. But generally speaking, that is how to play Hanabi.
Let's head back up and let you know what we think. All right. Well, um when I first heard about this, I was of course excited because I am a fan of Reiner Knizia's games. I I like Samurai quite a bit.
Mhm.
And I like Keymaster as a publisher. They've done a lot of games I've liked, and so all of those were good. And then I saw the re-theme, and I was a little bit worried.
Oh, I'll I'll go worse than you. I I outright disliked it. I thought it was a weird idea to take this known entity of a game that's been around for decades now, about a fierce kind of samurai warfare, uh but but a game that really is highly interactive and and fairly cutthroat, and then to say, "You're vacationing in Japan."
Yeah. So, I was skeptical, to to say the least, but uh you know, hope springs eternal, and I'm glad that I uh kept an open mind, because while I will say there is a thematic disconnect, especially having the context of the original, right? Because I can't remove that context. This is, as you said, confrontational, very um interactive, but it's in this space of beauty, because it's a gorgeous-looking game, and you're on vacation, and you're having picnics, and you're admiring flowers and paper lanterns, and enjoying rice uh treats.
It does work. It does work.
Mhm.
But there is a little bit of a disconnect. I think what you're losing with the thematic integration with the mechanisms, you're gaining with approachability.
I agree. It's going to have a much wider audience than just kind of a generic, you know, a serious-looking samurai thing.
Yeah.
Honestly, my my ideal would be this graphic design and art and all that, but still with that samurai theme. That's not what we got, so reviewing for what it is, I was actually very surprised that the re-theming towards this like pleasant vacation theme, it works. And it it teaches just fine. People don't constantly scratch their head and go, "Why is this game so mean?" Like, now you just let them know ahead of time, "Hey, this is a kind of a majority's tile laying game. It's we're going to get in each other's way and that's kind of the point of the game. And so I had that major concern. It kind of just eased away. I forgot about it completely by the time we were taking the the smooth turns of the game. By the time the intriguing decisions had to come around and all that. It it works fine and it's a beauty to boot.
It is. And so let's just talk a little bit briefly about the differences between Hanami other than the theme which is clear and the original game Samurai. There are not a lot on the base side of the board and I showed you both sides of the map in in the overview. So on the on the side they suggest you begin with the only real difference mechanically is they changed an action tile to an ability card.
Yeah.
So that you can choose when to to trigger that rather than get it as a draw a tile draw.
And that that feels good. It feels a little bit more like kind of a modern design thought modern development thought where yeah like that that threat is always there instead of hopefully I draw it before the end of the game.
Right.
Nice little improvement but almost almost negligible honestly.
Right. So continuing down that path of just this base side. We'll talk about the extra stuff towards the end. Um what it kept is that beautifully simple turn structure of play one or more tiles on your turn. If you have claimed a token, you claim the token. It can sometimes be more than one if you got a particularly clever play in there and then redraw back up to your five tiles. Within that there are so many fantastic decisions. Um a lot of turn angst which again slightly belies the theme but still works. And so all of what made Samurai great is still here.
Yeah, and if you've never played it, I think this is a a surprisingly approachable game.
Yes.
Have the majority of strength around stuff. Some of the tiles are wild, some of the tiles are boats. That's most of the game and some of the tiles are fast where you can play more than one. It has a very good smooth turn structure where people are constantly engaged because there's a lot of tension between turns, especially the more player count.
Yeah.
More players, more tense.
Yeah.
Uh I think that it works well two, three, and four. My preference is at three player because of the just a little easing off of the tension. Your turn comes around a little more frequently, so you can lay these clever plans and these traps. Uh two player is a little bit much of the um zero-sum
Yeah.
nature. If I don't get something, you do, that directly is it. With three players, you kind of have that interesting spread. Um I hope I'm not jumping too far to a point.
No.
I think the three player tension works really great with the scoring, too. Honestly, the scoring part works well for any of the player counts, actually.
Yeah, it just kind of feels a little different at the player counts, but it works well for all of them, the scoring. The idea, which I talked about again in the overview of of, you know, you if you're able to get two of the three majorities, you've won the game. That's it, right?
Beautiful.
Um and I've seen it happen. It's happened frequently enough that it's not like this, you know, shoot the moon necessarily. I've seen it happen. But much more likely to happen is that you'll have more than one player that has the majorities. And then you have to go to the the secondary winning conditions. And so that is one of the things that made this game so compelling. Um he's played around with this idea of of the scoring like that and things like Ingenious. He he he he almost always will have a scoring twist, you know what I mean? And and and this one is particularly uh compelling, I think. It's particularly interesting. And um yeah, and that's still there, for sure. Um and at the different player counts it works. It just feels a little different.
I agree with that. It
[clears throat]
It still maintains the same amount of tension when you get to that final reveal. You know, it discourages you from getting like seven flowers, right? You're really better served getting four, and that's probably the majority based on what everyone else has, and then trying to get a second, you know, another set of four of the lanterns or something. So, it it's nice. It kind of It forces you to specialize to a degree and to diversify to a degree, and it's not easy because players are all vying for it.
Yeah, and you and you can kind of see what other people are doing. It also is remarkably fast for the amount of game you get. Like, this game flies by.
Mhm.
And you know, because there's the two different ways that you can end the game. You can either end it if you have four tiles that have been kind of thrown away as a result of a tie, or if one of the three uh tokens are gone from the board. And so, that happens quickly. Um and it's sometimes, when you first start playing it, it will sneak up on you. And so, the the pacing of the game is also very interesting. Uh but, it's a very satisfying uh feeling to get this much game in that amount of time as well. Another positive, I think, yeah.
Yeah, I I agreed on all fronts there. So, that's kind of covering That's whether you're looking at this as a review of the new version or even just Samurai or this game in system in general. You wanted to jump at some of the differences, the back side of the board and special powers and stuff.
So, that back side of the board is brand new. There was no such thing in Samurai. It was always the same board of the basically of the, you know, uh archipelago um of Japan. And
Pronounced archipelago on this title.
Oh. Got it. Um so, that is nice because really what it does is it just it it I think that it makes the boats a little bit more uh possibly impactful. It's tighter, you know, cuz you have these smaller kind of spaces. And so that just really what it does is it just kind of gives you a little bit different of of a kind of terrain to play on. It doesn't fundamentally change the game, but it does make it feel a little different. And so I think that's good if you've played the the base game or the first side of the map a lot. And then the other thing it adds are three new special action tokens and the individualized ability cards that you can add in there.
I think So, here's the thing. There's three [clears throat] new tokens in the game I think are all pretty explainable. They're all pretty understandable. And I really like having those in there. You can play with or without them. I would just throw them in even if you're not familiar with the game, but if you want to experience kind of the the most basic game, play front side of the map, don't throw in those special ones. Everyone's special power card is the same.
Yeah.
So, it's nice that there's some kind of built-in variability on top of the already core game variability of how those those um the tokens that you're vying for coming out on the map. Right. I think that my one big complaint though is that on one of the specialty tiles is a very important feature where it gets played on top of a previously played tile. And that icon is very difficult to to always catch.
Yeah.
Uh it's I I guess the easiest way to say it's easy to miss it.
Yes.
And it happened even after I pointed out to someone, "Okay, see this little little icon here? This is exactly what it means." And then two turns later someone goes, "Chris, is that your stacking tile not stacked?"
You're right.
Yeah, absolutely what just happened.
Yeah, and and I agree with that. I think that the iconography on those is too too easy to miss. It's it's very slight on there. And um they're they're interesting abilities, right? The stacking, the draw an extra tile, um the copy another tile. They're very interesting. Um and they feel close enough. It doesn't feel even though I I I don't believe that the Knizia designed those, he approved them. They don't feel completely out of place. They feel like, you know, they fit. Um I see them as nice, but not necessary. That's kind of the way I look at them. If you have played, again, this game a lot, uh maybe if you've come back to it and you used to play Samurai all the time, add that stuff in cuz it's neat.
It gives you a couple of little things to kind of change some of those little uh inflection points throughout the game. Um but they're not needed. I don't think that they're drastic reimagining's of the game.
And that's kind of the same way I feel about the specialized individual power card effects where you can all have the same one, swapping those tokens around, which is majorly impactful. But it's also fun that you can have different powers, and it just it's like a feel-good kind of variability where someone says like, "Oh, once per game any one of my pieces is a boat and I can place it in those exclusive water spaces."
Yeah.
It's not vastly going to change things. But if you if you know the game loop, it does kind of keep you on your toes a little bit extra. So it's a nice little bit of extra in there.
Yeah. Um so ready to go to a final thought? Do you want to lead it off?
Sure.
Okay.
Yeah, I I like this one. When I first played Samurai al- almost 15 years ago, I think at this point, uh I I thought it was pleasant. I thought it was slick and it was good. Um and I at that time I was Oh, that's probably like a seven for me. Over the years it's just grown, actually. I I I rate this one an eight. I think this is a nice edition of it. I thought the re-theming was going to bother me, and it instantly disappeared once I was playing it because I think this is a good production except for that one, you know, the those little two icons that are hard to miss or easy to miss. I think that it's a a really smooth game that doesn't really feel dated at all. In part, I think because some game it it fits in line with a lot of games that have come out recently, actually. Iliad by the same designer, For the Gods from different designers, Blitzkrieg. If you like those games and you missed on out on Samurai, this is a great way to jump into it. So, highly recommending it with an eight.
Yeah, and I'm coming in just a little bit higher than 8.5. I do think that this is an excellent game. I always thought it was a great game and and I think that this is a very thoughtful reimagining of it. Um you know, sometimes I can be a little bit reactive against re-themes. I'm like, "Oh, is this cynical? Is this" I don't think that was the case here. I do think that you are missing a little bit of that thematic integration, like I mentioned, but I'm excited that potentially more people are going to have a chance to play this game, to discover it, because it does feel fresh. This does not feel dated to me at all. You've mentioned several games. There are some other ones that I think also give similar feels. And I'm happy to see it back. I think it is a lovely lovely production. So, if they're going to change it up, they did a heck of a job with that. And and so, I'll give up my my little you know, knife knife fight in a phone booth, but let's just hit each other with flowers instead. So, that's that's what it is.
8.5. I'm very very happy with this and glad to see it back. Getting a getting a proper spotlight.
There you go.
All right. Well, that's going to do it for us. I'm Mike Delisio.
And I'm Chris Yee.
And have fun on picnics.
Hitting your friends with flowers.
Eating rice.
Pocket flowers.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh, we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.