Fellowship of the Ring the Trick Taking Game Review. A Crew Killer
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Board Stupid. My name's Wayne and I'm Matt and this is our review of Lord of the Ring the Fellowship of the Ring trickt taking game. That's a lovely title. That's a long title. You did that in one take as well. Amazing. Take as well. So I'mused I'm by myself. I love it. So uh this is a fabulous little game in a fabulous little box with a fabulous production. If you want to hear what we think, hit the subscribe button. Don't have to take the ring to Mount Doom. You don't need to create your own fellowship. Click. Just you click it and that's it. There's no school behind the corners. No to sum looking for you. It's nice and easy. Um, let's go. Let's go. It's a vibe. It's all we need.
What's the pink game? We'll use for you and me. What's the sh So, Matt, how does Lord of the Rings Fellowship of the Ring trick taken game play? We're gonna I think we'll just shorten this at the end of the day. Uh this game I'm not gonna say the title again because I've done it fellowship fellowship. Um you uh it's a trick taking game. So you you and your uh companion and your fellowship uh going to try to beat the game uh with a with a trick taking cooperative trick taking cooperative trick taking. Um, now what these games does, it adds narrative to the to the to the to a normal trick taking game. Uh, that means that you're going to play uh a series of um chapters uh that follows the chapters of the uh Fellowship of the Ring the book, not the movie, the book. So, if you are a fan, that is uh that's really good. Um, and basically you're going to follow Frodo and uh and everybody else uh from the shrine till the end of the first book.
Each and each chapter is going to be quite different to each other because um you going to be playing with different characters. So at the start of each game um each one of the players will pick one of the available characters that every chapter are going to be different and each um and each character will have its own victory condition. For example, Frodo must win the most rings. Uh or um uh Mary or Pipe, they trick the least trick or Gandalf need to win just need to win at least one. Um and and so on. Each one very different to each other. Uh so you need to try you and and your group need to find out how to make all those victory condition around the around the board. Uh in a such a smooth and fun way is yeah definitely this is analogous to games like the crew uh in fact I say games like it's analogous to the crew. Yeah. So the crew and the the crew under the sea under sea deep.
So analogous to those games in that it's a cooperative trick taker that is done in scenarios. Um the difference I feel with this versus the crew is the crew has this specific limited communication piece where you can identify what kind of cards you've got using this. This doesn't have that. It still has limited communication. You can't talk about your hand, but instead of that, it has this exchanging mechanism, which I think is amazing because you can tell a lot by exchanging a certain card with one of your colleagues. Each character will have the power, some not all of them, but most of the character will have the power to exchange at the start of the game cards with another player. Uh, for example, Mary can exchange with Frodo.
And if I know that Froto needs to wing the most ring, I might give him this or that card and then he's going to give me a card back to try. So, you're trying to manage the unlock of the of the card of the card draw. Exactly. You're trying to manage that. And what I love about this game, Matt, is the tremendous amount of variety in all of the scenarios. It feels like they've done every single variation of trick of the cooperative trick taking thing. It's so staggering. Um in in the box that is absolutely uh wonderful wonderful production. Beautiful production. you will have this um this very very nice insert and basically um each time that you go to the to the next chapter uh you will have to take the deck from the from the box read the um the story card is going to tell you a little bit of the law a little bit about the uh what narative it's going to tell you the setup what you need to do it going to give you some special rules for that specific um chapters and it's going to tell you which character are available and how you going to need to to win the game basically. Uh but not only that, cuz you will have to add some of the cards. It's going to be cards that are specific to certain chapters. Again, no spoiler because a lot of fun is actually finding out through the process of discovering a but um each chapter will tell you, okay, now take the next three cards and add it
to the to the deck or take that extra card. you need to shuffle it and uh if this numbers comes out you need to do something else. So um it's really really fun and um it keeps you as you say it's always different and not not just slightly different it's every single chapter something quite different mechanics or adds a different mechanics or take away one of the mechanics. So uh we enjoyed it so so much. It has, I think, 18 chapters in this game and you'll get a lot of value. Even if you just played through those 18 chapters, you'll get like a good few solid nights worth of trick taking with your friends if you wanted to do that. Um, uh, and even if you've done all of the chapters, Matt, yeah, that's the people will ask, "Oh, well, I finished. Should I b it?"
No, you don't. Don't you don't do that. There is a whole set of rules around the cards that you take to create the final the final deck, the final challenge uh that you can play which is a beefy, enjoyable uh exciting trick-taking experience using set cards uh that you would have discovered over the over the course of your play utilizing sort of the various challenges that you would have already encountered and sort of blending them together into this final uh long victory challenge which the game uh the game calls long victory as having to complete all of the characters, which is real bloody difficult. Yeah. Yeah. Real fun. Let's talk about difficulties because normally the trick taking games, especially the cooperative ones, uh they depends very much on the people you got around the table or depends very much on the scenario or they are very like luck driven. Um I think we found this been quite challenging in some of the chapters. Some of them like we've been stuck on one of them for over an hour.
The other savage. Yeah. Some I mean some of them are easy breezy relatively speaking especially the starting one cuz it's kind of like um it takes you like by the hand and explain you how to play a trick taking comparative game basically. But the more you go in, the more um rules you have to add or or specific challenges you have to overcome, the more difficult it becomes. And you need to start strategizing with the people around the table. Actually, how you going to achieve that? Cuz if some of them sounds like, oh, that's easy. It's not. No, like it's not having to win the last trick, but making sure you don't win a specific card at the same time. Real hard. Yeah. Or the other way around, having to win a specific card.
Uh, but that's the only card you're allowed to win. That is all of these like, okay, that sounds okay, but in combination with the other challenges around the table, that is the puzzle. Yeah, absolutely. I think where the magic is. And we did find it like challenging in a um uh in a very nice way. It's never been stressful. It's always been like we failed. All right, what we going to do next? How we going? How are we going to There's never been the point where it's like, "Oh, we can't do it. It's impossible." No, no, no. We can always work it out. We've always like stroke the beard. Think about how we can It happened a couple of times that the last round we we couldn't we didn't manage to do it or and when you actually do it, it gives you that feelings that the crew gives you when you achieve like a different like a difficult scenario. You go like, "Yes, we do." Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, we don't want to spoil too much about all of the different mechanisms that you'll find because I think it's important to have that um sensation of discovery. But Matt, should we talk about the production a little bit and how this game feels a bit? We must. Let's go.
Matt, I just want to start with the art direction of this game, which I think is absolutely fantastic. I love the artwork. It is incredible. I'll say it right now. Uh, this is the best artwork in a Lord of the Rings game ever produced. It's just the most beautiful on this kind of like stained glass. Yeah. Kind of like cartoony stained glass that is it's actually perfect for the for for the game. It's perfect for the theme. It just like absolutely stunningly whimsical. The box itself is a is a is a beauty cuz you got even like like a book. You got the how do you call this? This little ribbon there to to lift up your cards to lift up the cards. Um you got your your ring one here. Uh cuz we haven't said but one of the um one of the the the suit of the cards is going to be the rings. But you can't play your rings from the start. You need someone to break and uh and play one of the rings.
you'll find out in the um in the rules. No spoilers against want to give you give away any of the of the cool stuff. Beautiful production. Absolutely fabulous. I mean, it's such a great product for such a great price point as well. I mean, if you are a Lord of the Rings fan, even if you're not a fan of like go tricking games, this is such a lovely to have. I think I think it's a it's a must have for a for a Lord of the Rings fan because it's uh even just like they the production the physicality of the production is absolutely stunning. I I don't know how they pulled this this off. It's just like it's is amazing. They nailed it with this one. Absolutely. Um but that's why it's been one of the most sold games of the of the start of this year and well well rightful. Um, but if you're not a fan of of Lord of the Rings, but you are into trick taking or you are in cooperative games, this definitely gives you something. This could be a nice starter because you can play just a chapter and then put it away. It it goes on and off the table in 30 seconds. It could be like, "All right, let's play a couple of scenarios and then and then off you go play another game." uh but gives you a lot of like uh ice breaker around the room in terms of like let's play together. Uh it's kind of like a good appetizer. It's a very good appetizer but at the same time it could be your main meal cuz we spend like the other night we spent three hours playing this game and really enjoying it as well.
This game has a really great feeling. I mean I I personally this my this is my own take. I feel like if I have this, I probably won't play much of The Crew. I mean, I I know I know you've mentioned that you think the crew maybe has more legs in just dipping in and out of scenarios. So, my my only takes with that in terms of like length of how much you're going to play this game in the future. So, um again, as you said, at the end once you finish all the chapter, you going to select the the rules will tell you take this these cards. They're all numbered and and create the final deck and you can replay as many time as you want. Uh however, the final deck is going to be quite beefy. It's going to be kind of like a 30 minutes to 40minute experience. Yeah. While the crew some you can do some of the scenario in 15 minutes. Uh you can always go back and replay one of the chapters. It's going to be slightly more complicated. you need to find out with the right card for that for that scenario because at the end of the day the more you go forward the more you kind of like mix and put some of the card away. Um but I mean to me I would you have it in in a in alongside the crew I guess? Yes. I'll definitely No, no, I will definitely own both. You would own both. Fair. Um I they can definitely leave both in the um on the shelves and they can come out. Uh if I know that someone in the room is a fan of uh Lord of the Rings, I will be we
must play this game. We must absolutely. I just want to quickly briefly talk about the rule book before we get into our final thoughts, Matt, because this rule book is a amazing uh and b has about the best FAQ I think I've ever seen in games. It has literally every question you could possibly ask for each chapter written out here. Brilliant. Cuz of course adding different rules for each chapter with a complication of people be like, "Oh, well that say that, but the car say this FAQ is going to be there." It's literally like every question is going to be there and you really that's it. Fair enough. Let's play. Really, really good, man. It's Yeah, absolutely great. But uh let's go on our final thoughts. All right, Matt.
So, where would you put the complexity rating of uh the fellowship trick taker? Uh and give us your final thoughts on it. Um I would say um trick taking um for the people that played them before, this could be very much like end of the beginner. It's it's just like it adds the rules every time, but they're very well explained. Uh, if you never played a trick taking game before in your life, it could be just to get your heads around on how a trick taking mechanisms work. It could be slightly more advanced, but so that's why I would say it's bang on between beginner and advanced somewhere in intermediate. Yeah. Well, and intermediate. Sorry. Did you agree with that? Yeah. I think I'd stick this in the intermediate category because of those reasons. If you've never played a trick taker, that might baffle you. If you've played loads of them, you grew up playing Hearts with your nan. Yeah, exactly.
I think that's very British state. There you go. There you go. You'll be fine with this. Or if you played The Crew before, this will be absolutely easy for you. Easy peasy. Yes. But what about your general thoughts on this game overall? Um, I think that again this is awards materials for the end of the year already. Um, this is uh a fantastic production, amazing game play. um absolutely fun to play it and on top of that the cherry on top. If if you are a fan of Lord of the Rings and uh you love the books most than everything uh this this is the game for you. This is a game that you need to have in your collection. If if you stumble on this channel and you don't know anything about board games, but you are a Lord of the Rings fan, you can simply take this and look at the cards and you'll be amazed. Yeah, you'll absolutely love it.
Uh, I am fully in alignment with you, Matt. I think this is definitely award material for sure. Both in a couple of reasons, either car best car game or best cooperative game already. Uh, and it is just a marvelous product more than anything else. For a decent price point, I don't think you can go too far wrong. So, I think for me, this has got to be a seal of excellence. Well, it is a seal of excellence. Absolutely. Like 100%. There is no there is no doubt about it. It's so good. Especially Yeah, especially it costs you like what £15 or something like that. It's a great It's a great game, great product, super fun, amazing IP, beautifully and lovingly produced. Uh you're going to get a ton of fun out of it. Uh and it's not going to break the bank. I mean, no fantastic. You tick all the boxes. So, uh all the boxes.
Go and check it out. Like literally like go to the shop and to your local store and check it out. So, that was our review of The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, the Trick Taken game. Is there another subtitle or another? I think that's all of them. That's it. Okay, fair enough. What do you think? Have you managed to play this game yet? Please let us know in the comments below. And specifically, how do you feel it matches up to the crew? Do you like it more? Do you like it less? Do you think they need to sit side by side, or do you replace one with the other? Uh, I'd love to know what you think uh in the comments below. And if you've made it this far, my fellowship, well, check the Patreon because uh you can find Frodo there and the ring and you can you can help Frodo helping us helping the channel subscribing to the Patreon defeating S and finding a lot of treasure because you're going to have a lot of exclusive content. Uh there might be Golem here and there. Um, a lot of things you can you can find a lot of things on the Patreon. Uh, a lot of exclusive content, behind the scene, all the UKG stuff that is going to come out, all the exclusive interviews, a lot a lot loads of stuff.
Uh, no fellowship required, no dealing with Gollum. And as we said, uh, you can always hit the subscribe button. Absolutely. join our fellowship uh on our journey uh to to become board game YouTube people. Yeah, whatever. I don't know where where are we going with this? I don't know. But we made it to the end of the video. Uh check out the rest of our videos. Mhm. And we'll see you in the next one. Ciao. Think is what you should play and see.