Skip to main content
Loading video...

Where Did Game Night Picks Get The 170 thousand subscribers in 4 months. Rodney VS Chaz Stats Dive

Transcript 24:33

Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again for another episode of Bower Rides the News where I take a look at a different tabletop gaming news story put into my eyeholes and your eyeholes. And this time we're taking a real deep dive because I already did a video covering Rody Smith of Watch It Plays video and I did a video covering Chaz Marlor of Game Night Picks video. But at the end of the day, there's one thing that still felt off to me and it also apparently lingered in my comment section as well as I saw a couple of comments uh in various different videos. one of mine included like, "Yeah, but where did all the subscribers come from?" And so what I did is I like to do is I like to look at numbers and statistics and analytics. And so what we're going to do is we're going to take a real deep dive and figure out exactly where all the subscribers came from that Game Night Pics gained in a very short period of time. And the best way to show you this is on SocialBlade, a website that I really, really love. Check it out probably once or twice a month. And it just kind of shows you a whole bunch of analytics. Now, right now, we're looking at my YouTube channel, Bowers Game Corner versus Game Night Pics, just for a comparison so you can see. So, we're going to go way way way back to uh yeah, let's just go right here. This is July 23rd of 2025. Uh and this is chart down here is the number of subscribers each of our channel had from March to uh September of 2024 to 2025. And you know, and to put this into context, Chaz's channel was quote unquote dead for a while as he worked, I believe, on uh

Board Game Geek and I think he did some stuff with with Rodney Smith as he mentioned. So, it was pretty much non-existent for 5 years and it was slowly eroding and and losing subscribers because that's what happens to channels as they die. So, we go slowly down, but then he comes back and, you know, it looks like he's gaining a moderate amount of subscribers. My channel, same thing. Roughly on the same path. However, where things start to get interesting is where we zoom this out a little bit. And then you say, "Okay, well, he had an amazing October. Just a banger of October." You say, "Wow, that was a that was a huge jump right there. Awesome. you've gained uh 7,000 subscribers in just roughly a month. That's fantastic for a channel of that size for like I would be over the moon, right? And then it's like, "Oh, okay.

Well, let's keep going." November, can you keep up the momentum? You say, "Oh, wow. We kept up the momentum. We certainly did. Let's keep going. Let's zoom it all the way out to 2026 now." And it's it's it's okay. That number that just keeps going up. That just keeps going up. And it's it's just and then it teeters off. February 1st, 2026. I wonder when Rodney posted his video. That that's one thing to look into there. I didn't look into that. I've looked into a lot of different aspects of this. Uh so, and then yeah, I'm going to guess it's somewhere around there because then it actually starts to go down a little bit. But as you can see, the real question we're trying to answer is where did the 170,000 subscribers come from? Right. And the best way to do that is I thought maybe go check out some other stuff. So, first thing, this is all just kind of some filled in information for you.

August 13, 2025 talks about doing a new segment uh that's going to be coming out right here. Reach out to several publishers of games. We had in mind to sponsor some of the episodes and others are just our own picks. So, they're reaching out to publishers, which I like I never do that. I like they reach out to me. And this is also their Patreon, by the way, if you want to support it. Uh it's it's currently got 34 members and seven posts, which 193,000 subscribers. I don't know if that's a good ratio, but I imagine it's not. But that's not what we're looking for here. What we're looking for here is where did all the subscribers come from? Because it's not super hard to figure it out. Like let's let's go look up the big time period was around November 4th, 2025, which was roughly five months ago.

Now, before we get into that, there's some things that I I want to explain why I really decided to cover this and why I was like, "Oh, this might be something that I think people would be interested to know to have this extra kind of chunk of the pie of information." And it comes down to this video up here for a game called Phantom Epoch where he did some uh I at least I'm assuming sponsored content for them because it says that it's a it's a sponsored video. and why I want to focus on and most of his videos actually around this time period are sponsored which you know it is what it is. It gets to 35,000 views right and to put this into perspective before that the things leading up to it let's just go back say 3 months behind that from 9 months ago 1.2 1.2 1.7 2.9,000 uh cracking near 5,000 6.200 3.70 3.7 2.1 1.4 6.5 1.7 2.7 1.2 to 17K.

That's a nice one. And I'm going to guess that's probably where they're like, "Hey, check out this stuff we're doing." And they they set it out. But I don't want to speculate too much. We're just here for the facts. But you can see there's no numbers that are really coming close to that since they relaunch. So the 35K I was like, "Oh, wow. That feels that feels really off, right?" But because it's not like it's, you know, Forbidden Island, like a Kmart, Walmart, Target kind of game. It's a much beloved game. No, it's it's believe it's like a Kickstart, I believe. Right. All right. So, I was like, "All right, so let's go look at some other Phantom Epoch videos and see what we're like." Okay, 5.6, 9.8, 5.5, you know, 4.3, 3.8, 1K for their Kickstarter video, and it's it's And then you get to theirs of 35,000. Like, hey, we played it for 40 hours. Here's 975. Now, you're like, "Oh, it's a much smaller channel, but it's still Man Versus Mele." You know, these are uh and and just put that in perspective. Man versus mele. I told you that game night picks has 60,000 more subscribers than Man Versus Mele. No, it's actually way more than that, isn't it? It's like 120,000 more subscribers. You say, "Wow, that seems odd, right?" Like with how long they've been in the grindstone and like just it's just and that's when I was like, "Okay, I really want to start looking more into this." And when I did look at this, it's luckily for me, I'm a stat nerd. And so I have Vid IQ here. And you start to see

some very interesting trends. So this was six, five days after published, we get 35,570 views, and then we round off with like 35,800. So it just it hits a certain point and then it's it's just dead. Also, the engagement not good. Now, I'm going to show you two numbers an awful lot here and and I want to Oh, yeah. This one likes it looks Yeah, this is VPH. So, this is views per hour. So, it spiked uh 4 days after it published where it was getting a,61 views per hour and charts like that you're you're going to see an awful lot of here, but we're going to go through them quick. So, views per hour stands for views per hour. A key metric for tracking how quickly a YouTube video is gaining views and its potential to go viral. Because that would be the big explaining point.

If it's like, "Hey, this is how he gained such a huge chunk of subscribers." You go viral. You're like, "Wow, for I look at some of your views and they're super low for board game content." And it's like, "Yeah, well, go look at my plumbing content." And you see, I had one go viral with like 5 million views or whatever you want to call quasi viral, which gave me a huge chunk. They don't have one that I saw, which we're going to get into. Now, the other thing we're going to look at is engagement rate. Typically, the average engagement rate on YouTube typically falls between three and 7%. This is how many people are I mean, I guess you might say quote unquote real viewers. Some people would say I'm not saying it. Bleacher Report says it. Uh, but I also wanted to go back real quick and I want to show you some of their videos, their non-sponsored stuff from a variety of different times back to show you that we're at 10.8% 8% engagement on this video right here from 11 months ago, which which has 1.7,000 views. Uh we're at uh 9.3 here, which is from 5 months ago, 2.3,000 views.

2,000 views here, we're at 11.4% engagement rate, which is really nice engagement rate, by the way. And you also look at these charts and say, "All right, we got the big spike when it first happens, then it kind of trends upward." And that's what you kind of look for with the most these like when one of my videos trends upward, that's great. That means it's going to be like a little mini evergreen just always in the back getting a couple views every now and then and you see boom trending up. We're not going to see a lot of these once we get into the big numbers that game night picks is getting which doesn't look great. So let's just get into it and let's start with is that your arrow in my back? Oh, that's the phantom epoch one. That's the one I was talking about. Um which we already talked about that one. But as you can see, after the first 14 days, the popularity was just dead on the How do I get out? Here we go. Total views. Yeah.

No, this one was at Sorry, not 14 days. This one was a fiveday one. Huge fiveday spike and then just boom, death. Moving onward, we're just going to go through these because we're going to bang bang bang them out. Uh because Yeah. So, we got how much the world's most expensive board games. So, this one's 7.1. This is 11 months ago. This is one of those outliers, one of the ones that was doing better before. Um, it looks like he was really paying for ads. And you see, nice trend upward. Nothing nothing too bad yet. We got seven months ago, 17K. This is where we see like, oh, nice trend. And then like this double bump here. Good for them. And I'm wondering if maybe this is one that they they sent out to publishers like, hey, we're doing a lot of content. We're getting some good views. Um, I would like I'm not saying that like in any other way. And then here's Phantom Epoch. And you'll see notice includes paid promotion in the back and they were doing a lot of paid promotion for different people too. Uh which I thought was interesting and they posted in there. But yeah, so this one is the top 10 games we were starting and then we lost. This one's sitting at 58,000 views and and this is so it's like nine days, 10 days, 11 days and we're getting some good numbers here. But then for whatever reason, you know, 81 days out, boom, huge spike taking place, you know, over a couple time period and then back to this. That one's still good, though.

Like, I know you're like, "Wow, these are looking good. These are looking good for us." They're about to not look good. Yeah. This is a lot more of what we're going to see going forwards is just this shoot up straight line to roughly 35 to 40,000 views and then just not not a lot more after that. Which, you know, I understand if that were a typical trend, but it doesn't it doesn't seem to make sense why some videos would just do that and then stop doing that. And then we also start to see the engagement rate of 1.1. And that's a good number as we're going to progress forward. Um, oh, it reloaded all the videos. That's going to be annoying. So, this one, next one here, ultimate duel. So, this one, 1.1% engagement, 42,000. Oh, did it really load everything? Are you kidding me? But when we look at the views per hour, bam. And it makes me want to know like the structure of their ads like how long were these companies getting cuz like yeah rias a dance of love you know but anywh who what I'm getting at here is I'm still not seeing anything major that would bring in a 100,000 plus subscribers because at the end of the day it this is perfectly fine. You're allowed to purchase these and and run them and do all sorts of good numbers and get those numbers up there. But what I believe Rodney is trying to say and why Rodney's trying to say, "Oh, yeah.

So, here we go. 0.5, you know, boom, we got the nice steward upward." Well, this one was a 28 dayer and then bam. So, you know, did how long did ah yeah, it's just it doesn't look great, right? And once again, where are the subscribers coming from here, right? Like I don't see anything where it's like you would gain over a 100,000 subscribers. There's no big big breakout viral hit amongst them. It's just a lot of routinely around 35 to 40,000 views like this one right here where it spikes up and goes that way. Right? And that's also why I kind of showed you the Patreon earlier as well because it's just kind of it's not it's not any evidence. It's just like, hey, well, that's kind of that's kind of surprising, right? Like it's like you're gaining this much of a fan base in such a short period of time. These people are so excited for you and yet we're not we're not seeing that converting over to Yeah. Then so as soon as the the timer runs out, it's like boom, it's out, right? And what Rodney I believe was trying to say and I watched the video and I responded to it and I don't was that you know the major issue here is that that he had and once again I don't want to put words in his mouth so if I get this completely wrong I will run it back for a second is that he's charging a good deal of money

to publishers to sponsor their game in his videos and how the payout structure worked was it was based on the number of views that the video got. Right? So would the companies have entered into these agreements knowing these sort of things? Now, in case you're curious, cuz I was also curious how much it cost to purchase these views and subscribers if you if he's doing that is, you know, these ones specifically are promoting your videos. Now, I'm he's saying that he's using the YouTube stuff that's built in. By the way, I want to clarify that Chaz mentioned he's using the YouTube stuff built in that is just purchasing ads. But it just feels odd to me and and you're going to see it time and time and time and time again that there's so many of them that are just at that 35 to $40,000 range that it becomes like the 43K. So it's like 34 39 38 34 35 36 36 40 47 That's a big Christmas one right there. 38 39 40K 38K 39K 40K 42K 38K and when I say them all out loud back to back to back to back to back you say oh okay yeah I get I get I get your suspicion now because it's like this is what pick like picko this old ass game like is like cool it's

like but that level of consistency like how to play Tamagotchi collection s works as someone who makes a lot of how to play videos like there's a wide range to these things and yes this is a how to play video pretty much how Tomagotchi collection plays which now you're like oh okay so Rodney Rodney might potentially have a reason to be extra annoyed with this as Jazz was essentially reaching out to publishers who might maybe I don't know have considered working with a different content creator to make content. and he's like, "Yeah, look, look at the views you're getting, right? Like, look at the So, yeah, you know, in case you're like in case you want to know more of like, hey, maybe why is Rodney coming out and saying this?" Like, we can draw some lines here. But back to what I was saying. So, uh, thousand YouTube views, 2500 YouTube views, 5,000 YouTube views, 40 boost, 40 bucks, 50 200 shares. These are like real websites you can go to right now. And I just want you to get an idea of how much money these cost.

25,000 views plus 800 subs plus uh 1,000 likes. How much? $879, right? And most of these were in the 30 to 40,000 range. So if we were paying for them, by the way, which we're totally I'm not saying that he is. I'm just giving you these prices. It's a very expensive cost of investment put into the YouTube channel, right? 100 views, buck 49. You want the fast views, 10,000, 50,000, 179 bucks. Like, like none of these websites I saw were were cheap. Like I'm a frugal person. Yeah. You want to buy subscribers? 300 for 21 bucks. So, back to what we were talking about some more of the videos, the EOM. Um, yeah.

So, we got 40.5 and then it just trickles off. And now that it loaded all these videos, this is super annoying. But the engagement rates also suffering, which is why I showed you those engagement rates from before we started to get into the huge quote unquote huge views. For me, they're huge, right? Like this one from 1.7 and we're we're crushing it at 10.8% engagement. That's great. So, we'll fast forward through a couple of these. So, 40.8, you know,.7 engagement rate. And this is just more like you make your own informed decision. I'm not here to tell you one way or the other. I'm here to show you numbers and tell you that those numbers made me definitely look at the situation differently.

right? When it's like, yeah, we were getting 143 on day one, 127 when we were running the ads, and then just boom. So, I guess the question is, do you think that I I guess I don't even know the question, right? Who do you side with? Did this change your opinion somewhat? I guess. Yeah, let me know that in the comments below. And once again, I'm I'm hoping to cover more news in the future. I don't think we've had anything this juicy in a very very long time, but let me know about the formatting, what you think about it. For this one, I just tried to compile as much information as I could because I'm going to sound like I have bias. And yeah. Yeah.

After seeing all this information, it's hard to not not not to side with Rodney for me, right? Because I definitely feel like had the publishers known that this is what was going to happen, right? Like this is what happens after it goes off ads, by the way, it's probably just going to just completely do nothing. And then the other thing is with that level of cons, so here's the thing. with that level of consistency, hitting between 35 to 40,000 views, super duper duper consistent and NOT CRUSHING IT ON THE likes necessarily, right? 129, you know, 170. Like, where do,000 subscribers come from?

And how much extra is a publisher willing to pay for a YouTube channel with 30,000 subscribers versus Was it 190? 190, right? I don't know. You let me know in the comments below. We'll speedrun through more of these, but it's it's all pretty much just

just like we're

stub 1% engagement.

Huge jump 14 days hits 37,000 done. I would be willing. Oh, let's go through more here. Like, yeah, this one's Shadows of Brimstone, in case you're wondering, the publishers, right? Let's go through some of those, right? Let's see. I think I saw uh Arcane Wonders on there. Big up from Mage Wars. I love me some Mage Wars. Give me that collector's. Give me that full. Yeah. So, we got 14 days. We hit up to 34,000. And where's Shadows? Oh, Shadows of Brimstone again, right? I think I saw Sagrada on there. Like, it's it's great for them. Like, this this one's 20K. Oh, yeah. It does go down because this is where things So, this is from two months ago. This I believe is this before everything hit the fan because yeah there was one episode where I noticed that the engagement rate went way higher and it was the top comment was like hey here from Rodney's video. Yeah.3%

today

like for brick like this this episode's brought to you brick like this like do you think that they would like and this one's Yeah. Some of these look Yeah. They look even better. Like this one looks like okay, this looks like natural engagement. And then for whatever reason, boom, up here we get there. Let's use the per hour. So it looks like Yeah. Yeah. Like that's it's not a good look right there when days, you know, when those chunk of days because that's a that's a number of days right there. 25. Yeah. And at the end of the day, for me personally, I just I don't feel like these publishers would make the same deals they made had they seen this information.

And then this one, I believe, yeah, this is the one from one month ago. What's so much drama in the video? Lost in the shuffle made me laugh. Um, yeah. And then so this is where the contra and so that's and it looks like there's still potentially like yeah same thing. This one is from one month ago as well. Grant's amazing by the way 1.8. And then this one. And I I just I I don't see where 170,000 subscribers came through if you're getting that consistent views, right? Like let's just say every single one of those people 35,000 a pop, you know, subscribe. Like, yeah, I love this ch this is amazing. Those 35,000 people subscribe. In theory, like there's going to be a huge chunk of people who I've already subscribed on those next 35,000. So, like, where are you gaining the view? Where are you gaining it? And it just it looks real bad. It looks real bad. And now I go back to Chaz's video and how much time we spent focusing on.

Yeah, I'm using the Yeah, I have no doubt that he was probably using, like he said, the ads that were, you know, the the ad stuff that you could purchase on YouTube, but based on the numbers in the back end, it looks like that was not potentially the only thing being utilized. And uh yeah, definitely not not a great look. So, at the end of the day, I I I really have a hard time seeing in that time period with all those videos you saw where 194,000 came from, right? So, let me know what you think about in the comments below. And as always, if you're enjoying the content, please be sure to click on subscribe button down below or consider supporting my Patreon for down dollar down below. Really does help a lot. And I'm launching Kickstarter later this year to give out gift out critiques, maybe cover news. I don't even know. I don't know. You tell me what what I can do, what digital services I can provide. As always, thanks for your time, YouTube. Bye-bye.

That's the wrong thing. That's a live stream I'm doing in 16 minutes.

Progress saved