Skip to main content
Loading video...

Origin Story - Board Game Review - The "Catwoman" of Superhero Trick Takers

Transcript 18:59

Hi everyone, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken Evil, the show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games, but usually more the ranting part. We have got the newest entry from Stonemire Games. And this one just sort of came out of the blue cuz normally Stonemire is like very open about all right, we're doing this game and here's the development line and everything, but for some reason this one just appeared. It just appeared out of nowhere. This is origin story and this is essentially meant to be a 45minute tricktaking game. So, I was like, "Okay, granted, I may not have the best history with Stonemar games in recent years, but certainly trick takers. I'm keen to see what they can do with this cuz I like trick taking as a mechanic. You know, I've got a few. I've got several that work for two players and multiplayer. I like the co-op ones. I like the competitive ones. Trick taken is a genre that I kind of like. And lately, we seem to be noticing a bit of a trend in the industry of a lot of trick- taking games coming out. I think trick taken is now kind of it's not as bad as say like the rolling right genre when that became popular but certainly a lot more people are starting to make trick taking a part of their game and you know what I'm cool but the problem with that is that you can only do so much with the trick taking mechanic to make it unique interesting and to make it like you know stand out from the pile so curious thing with this one is it's had a few mixed reviews online you know some people absolutely rave about it and some people hate its guts and it's like okay so what's it about that's so divisive.

Other than the artwork, which obviously the artwork's fine. I mean, it's nice artwork. You know, this artist has done a lot of nice stuff in the past, but you know, and certainly I do find it weird that the um back of the box has got a piece of paper on it to basically count as the back of the box cuz for whatever reason, they didn't print it on the actual back of the box.

Really spectacular. Spared no expense.

Slightly odd, I admit. But yeah, I'm curious to see what it is about this game that's getting people talking about it in both ways.

Get on with it.

So, pretty straightforward. Origin Story has you take control of a superhero board with a basic hero and basic special ability that's unique with all five of them. You have this massive deck full of various bonuses that you can give your superhero. And this takes place over the course of five rounds. Each round, players will draw three of these, pick one to upgrade on their board, and then these powers will build up as the game goes on. Some need to be charged with stamina, which is kind of like your little currency, but others are just like ongoing abilities or things that apply to the first trick, the last trick, the scoring, whatever. There's all sorts of different stuff in this deck. Over the course of the game, you will have built up four of these special powers. So there's different ones that will be triggering each round. But at the start of the game, you will have been given a couple of these like big superhero cards to uh consider and then you will have picked one and it will use it as a round reference card.

But in round five, you will place it on your board as like this is my identity. This is who I am and it's another power that you'll get for round five. Also during a game in round three, you'll draw an event card. It has some special things that apply to round three only. So it's just basically part of the narrative. And the trick taking part is as you would expect from every other trick-taking game. There are essentially uh three main suits as well as one trump suit. And you play in standard tricktaky fashion. So some somebody plays a card, everybody else has to lead. The trump suit will beat out all except with all these powers going around. It's going to depend on what you have as to whether you want to win or lose tricks or not. On top of that, you've also got an alignment dial which can be set to hero or villain mode. And the idea is is that if you want to be a hero at the start of the round, then you need to win more tricks because you'll get more points.

But if you think you're going to shoot the moon and go for the whole I win no tricks aspect, then you can flip it to the villain side and you don't want to win tricks, in which case you'll get a flat amount of points. The game will scale from one to five players. There is a solo mode included and a two-player variant as well. Primarily, it is meant to be played with three to five players. And that's pretty much all there is to say.

That's easy. a fairly straightforward affair, fairly straightforward rules, at least when it comes to the rules for the main game. You know, the rule book itself is not particularly big and there's not a huge amount of rules to explain and if you've played any trick taker game in the past, you'll know exactly how this works. So, the main flow of the game is nice and straightforward with a nice easy rule book. The main complication comes from all these powers. Now, each individual power is not necessarily, you know, confusing in itself, although a few of them may require a little bit of a second read through. But the problem is that the rule book does not cater for all the potential interactions that this deck of cards can have. You know, you might have free powers here, somebody else's free powers over there, somebody else has free powers over there. And when they interact with each other or mess around with the timing of phases and stuff, it can get very confusing.

And if you don't take my word for it, go on board gamege geek and look at how many forum threads there are for this game in terms of asking FAQ questions. A lot rise up here. In fact, this is probably the trick the the trick taking game I've played where I've had the most questions asked during the game. You know, most trick takers may like, how's that work or that little card or that little ability? And you know, one or two abilities are, you know, questioned. This one though, you get plenty of FAQ moments pretty much every single game. And sometimes you just have to make a decision and run with it because the rules do not make it clear how they should interact. And unless you want to spend all your time trapesing through BGG forums to find the answer, you're just going to have to make a decision and roll with it. Now, the trick taking part is nothing particularly special. I mean, it's only three suits and a trump suit and that's basically it. And you only get dealt eight cards at the beginning of the round, which is kind of a bit on the low side really because it doesn't mitigate enough like getting a hand of just one suit. Most trick taking games will have you draw about 11, 12, maybe more cards than that. And I think that's a better number because it allows for like times when you might draw a lot of a suit, but you'll still have usually some of the other suits as well. With eight cards though, you could end up in a situation where you just legit don't have an entire suit in your hand. And if you have got something like, you know, five or six cards of the same suit in your hand, you've only got eight to begin with, then it makes that just a little bit more impactful. The special abilities that you grab are kind of like the focus of the game. You know, building up a very unique player board

to everybody else, and they definitely will make you pretty unique. The starting ability is a bit lame for players. You know, most of the time you won't even use it. And that along with some of these other powers does have its own problem. We'll get that get into that in a second. But there's all sorts of weird wacky powers here. I mean, the beast mode, you know, gain a stamina if you win at least two more tricks than the hero who won the most tricks. uh you know the belt add two to the value of your science card suit. Uh if you win the first trick gain two VP if not draw a card discard a card or this one gain two VP if you won zero tricks you there's all sorts of different little powers and that's just four out of a whole deck. I mean you do have quite a lot. You know the variety in this game is pretty high. Got to give it props. Little things are a little bit odd. I mean why they bothered with a event deck just to have a random event in round three. It just seems kind of odd. I mean, if you're going to do events, why not have them in every round? Or just don't bother with the mechanic. It just feels like that was like a throwaway one in there. But the abilities that come forth, you know, including your end of round ability, all cool. It does, you know, make you quite unique. The problems that they do create though are twofold. Firstly, there's a lot to keep track of by the time you get to round four and five. Because when people have got, you know, three or four abilities each, particularly in the later rounds, and if you've got a lot of players, you find that this is like, oh Christ, I know, what what can you do again? What can you trigger? So hang on. So at start around, you can trigger this, but at some point you want to win zero tricks,

but not this round because you're not charging your ability. Are you actually charging it? No, you're not charging it. Okay, fine. We'll do that. Um, okay. What am I doing with this one? Uh, trying to Right. So that's fine. And you've got an ability which mucks up one of mine. It's like there's quite a little bit you got to keep track of between players, particularly in the later rounds, which is why this game feels kind of more at its home when you play it with less players. You know, a free three free four max, I think five is a bit too much at that regard. The two-player variant is not bad. Actually, the two-player variant has you basically playing each with a sidekick who has a bunch of cards face down next to you as well as a couple face up. and you you have a choice of like, you know, playing one of their psychic cards and they might be able to win the trick for you if you're like you didn't want to win it yourself or if you're about to lose one and you don't score points for them, but you'll always have two visible cards out of the ones they've got and each player has one. It kind of makes for maybe like a tiny bit of extra strategy that you can get from a two-player trick taker.

Although, that being said, it's still a variant on a game and it's still not the best way to play this. And let's face it, we already have Fox in the Forest. Fox in the Forest is the definitive two-player trick taking game. There is none better. So, you know, rather than having these trick takers try to have a two-player variant with dummy hands, which dummy hands are not popular with people, you might as well just stick with something like Fox in the Forest. Uh, but the main issue I have with these powers though is the main problem that befits every single Stone Mar game in existence because I'm pretty sure it's the Stonem games um, you know, office. There is some defense mechanism that basically kills you stone dead if you much like Alice in Borderlands defense mechanism if you utter the word balance because it feels like with the design of this game that somebody just basically went right let's just copy how trick taking works in every other game ever right we don't need to design that and now let's just come up with as many different ideas for powers as we can brainstorm in one big session with a couple of drinks that's what the design of this game feels like because these powers range from, you know, pretty much mostly useless to situationally good depending on the player count to outright broken. You know, there are definitely aspects here where, you know, when you create this many powers, you're going to end up with balance issues.

But, you know, Stone Mars track record does not have balance as their main forte. I mean, hell, even the ones on my shelf like Wingspan and Vidiculture, I would not stand up in front of you and say, "These are balanced games." No, even they've got balance issues and same with Scythe. But, you know, recently we've had games like Tapestry and a few others which are just outright broken. You know, even expeditions, you know, broken player powers and stuff. They just don't seem to know how to make player balance a thing. And here it's even more compounded because some of these cards, you know, you draw three of them and you get to keep one. So, there's a little mitigation. It's not all bad. It's not complete randomness, but some of these cards just don't work in a two-player game or a three-player game, but they are fantastic in five, and vice versa. A card that's fantastic in two and three players absolutely sucks for five. And this is even the case with some of the basic abilities that you have. You know, stuff that requires you to win certain things. I mean, if you won two or fewer tricks, gain one VP per stamina on this character. That in itself is infinitely better to do in a high player count than it is a low player count. But nothing in this game scales with the player count.

It just gives you a bunch of powers and just says play it with as many players as you like and see what happens. That that's not good design to just basically say, well, you know, some of these cards are going to be frequently unbalanced. Roll with it. And you know, you might be building up a particular synergy, but it is still luck of the draw as to which powers you get. Somebody may just end up drawing the most broken combination possible with these powers in which point they're going to steamroll the game. By the end of round three, you'll have like, you know, some powers on your board. You'll have had the event in that and you will realize there is just no way I'm going to win this game because they've got such a broken combo already. My powers don't synergize at all. I just never drew anything that kind of worked and there's no way that I'm going to be able to recover from this pointswise.

And that's not a good feeling when you feel like you've basically been pseudo knocked out of the game in an early stage because somebody just got lucky with their powers. And you know, luck is a big aspect of this. Now, I get that's probably what it was trying to go for. It was just meant to be a chaotic trick taker, but I like my trick takers to be more, you know, more serious nature. I mean, yeah, you can have trick takers with wacky special powers and, you know, weird bidding phases. I mean, I've got Niet. The dwarf king is fine, but it's not one of my favorite trick takers. But I mean, I play stuff like The Crew, uh, Fox in the Forest. Um, you know, the what was it called? The King Boru one that, um, I think it was Osprey games brought that one, which had trick Taken as a little mechanic. Uh, you've got the Lord of the Rings Trick Taker that's come out at the moment. Um, I've got a Badger Badger downstairs that was another, I think it's called Badger Badger or the Badger Trick Taking Game or something. It came out a couple of essence ago. And I've got Nikosu Dice.

Fantastic trick taker game. Uh, try to think of other ones that I've got. I' got diamonds, you know, another great one. I think I already mentioned a crew. So, there's a lot of these great trick takers that can have some cool funky abilities, but they're still generally a serious trick taker. Banner festival, another good trick taker. Yeah, they're sort of coming to mind, the ones that are on my shelf. But this one just feels like a bit of a chaotic mess. It's just here you go, basic trick taking, but we've thrown in a deck full of special powers. That alone does not jump out as something that reviewers out there should be giving nine out of tens, 10 out of tens for you know Darren and you know a bunch of other creators I mean they are going ape for this like saying this is like one of the best things they play one of the best trickt takers they played. Sorry, it just freaking isn't.

All right. You know, there are trick takers like the Crew and the Kosu dice and stuff like that that I would be giving nines and tens to. You know, those are fantastic trick takers for a two-player. Fox in the Forest can't be beaten as a two-player trick taking game. Solo mode, you know, you basically have your hand and you have two hands for the AI opponents. And it's not the it's I mean it's it's okay, but trick takers for the most part don't work solo. And in this case, you've got two hands, so you've got some idea of what the opponent has, but the the way that it gets cards and you have to learn this like little flowchart basically of right, so hang on. So if it's got the if if it's got the trump suit in there or it's got the highest card, it will play this card. But if it's got this aspect and it'll play this card and it's got this aspect, it will play this card.

just like you got to remember that all the time which is pretty difficult to do but also it's a very swingy solo mode. You know the powers and the abilities that the opponent has and also just the timing of when it will play certain cards and the fact that it gets more cards as you go through just make it very random and swingy. So again the solo mode just feels like a bit of a chaotic luck fest. I mean go watch a couple of uh playthroughs that there are on the internet. You know, some creators have done solo playthroughs and as you watch them, it's just it just doesn't feel like there's a huge amount of control in there. You know, trick Taking is not a genre that really works for solo with the exception of four Northwood. For Northwood is in my collection now, and I got to admit that's a bloody good solo trick taker. So, you know, there are exceptions to this rule, but this is not how to really do a solo trick taker in my opinion. It doesn't even feel that much like a trick taker at that point. All in all, this one just kind of feels flat. You know, it it just feels like a chaotic mess.

You know, I'm playing a very basic trick taker game with a bunch of special powers, and I may just happen to have a bunch of powers that work fantastically and a bunch of powers that don't work at all. And that's basically the game. You know, there's not really a huge amount of strategy in the game between rounds. I mean, yeah, you might influence your choices and that, but even the whole alignment dial thing, you know, you're playing a two-player game, being the villain is pretty straightforward. you know, it gives you a flat 4vp, but then heroes give you one VP per trick one. In low player counts, you might as well just be the hero all the time, but in high player counts, it's a lot easier to hide behind the villain mask um and, you know, go for that aspect. So, it's, you know, player count has an effect on this as well. It's just, come on, you they needed to reel in a little bit of that chaos. You know, the chaos factor is too high here. the player scaling is non-existent.

It It just doesn't, you know, it just leads to games where somebody can be knocked out early, feel useless, or it can lead to games where somebody is so powerful that you might as well just call the game there and then because there's no way you can beat them. It's just not what I want to see from a trick taker game. This one for me gets a four out of 10. It's a below average game for me. It's, you know, I like the fact that it's a simple game to play. It's not it's not, you know, a difficult game. It's got very few rules until you get into the solo mode and then it gets a little bit more fiddly, but it's very basic trick taking and the powers themselves aren't tricky. But the interaction with them is going to lead to a lot of FAQ moments. And if you don't like trapesing through rules forums or if you don't like having FAQ moments, this is going to put you off like that. But, you know, having player scaling issues with one of your main mechanics of the game and having a bunch of powers of which like a third of the deck could become useless depending on what player count you're at. I mean, that doesn't sit well with me. You know, that's not how it should be done. There are better trickt takers out there and perhaps for me, I'm more of a serious trick taker player rather than a chaotic trick taker player. um you know that maybe that's affecting me somewhat cuz definitely I think as I look at a lot of the trickt takers on my shelf they are generally more serious trick taker games with maybe some funky abilities but not chaotic stuff like this you know this is for a different audience perhaps I don't know

he's already dead so that's it for me on this episode of the broken melee if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumbs up on board game when it goes live on the page don't forget to check out the rest of my Essen content there is plenty of games reviewed and plenty more to come besides I've even done some trick takers in the past. I mean, look at my Noosu Dice review that I did. That is a fantastic trick taking game and one that does need to be brought into a more common market, but uh you know, that is the kind of trick taker that's like, oh yeah, creme to the creme, not something like this. But, you know, it'd be interesting to know your opinions. Do you love this game? Do you hate it? And is it purely just because you, you know, is it down to this? Is this the reason you think it's amazing? If so, I totally get that. it just isn't for me. So, take care and remember, regardless of whether your origin story is going to be just you constantly brooding on the rooftop or not, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.

Progress saved