Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 16:47

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Online. Today I'm doing a discussion over Black Orchestra, which is a cooperative game that is entirely about killing Hitler. Um, which is an interesting premise of a board game. And I feel like this cuz this came out in 2016 and which isn't really that long ago, but almost 10 years ago. And it's kind of crazy to think about that in that short amount of time, you almost I feel like you almost wouldn't ever get a game like this. uh because it is clearly uh you know centered around like I said killing Hitler and centered around the the the time of World War II which not saying that there aren't World War II games but the hyperspecivity of the the Nazi party and the theming of the event cards and who the characters that you're playing um just has this air of importance to it where all you're attempting to do is gather a plot to and certain items to attempt to kill Hitler. And even in the back of the rule book, it tells you that how quickly you do it is how many millions of lives you save. So, this game definitely doesn't shy around its source material.

But 9 years ago really isn't that long, but I would be completely shocked if a game was was made that had this theme. Um because now it almost feels like it would be almost, you know, tiptoeing around it like or or just like hey or alluding to a lot of that. But this is kind of a gem uh of a game in my opinion. Is it the best mechanically? Absolutely not. But I think what it actually brings to the table is something that definitely needs to not be forgotten um or lost. And I I know there are games that players or people could see and be like, "How could you have fun playing a game like this?" It's like, "Well, it's not like we're playing as Nazis. We're not, you know, trying to make them succeed. Everything you're doing is to thwart uh Hitler and his deputies." And and ultimately, again, how you win, the only way you win is by successfully fulfilling a plot, which ends up killing him, which is yay. And it and and because of that, I think this game gets a pass for a lot of its systems. But if you're curious, like the entire game, what you're doing, which is very, very simple, is really rinse repeat. This game, if it keeps going on longer and longer, uh, really starts to kind of

show its age because on your turn, you have a certain number of actions that allow you to kind of just move, see what an item is at a certain location, collect it, and then you might just have that. Uh, you might just find a plot that that needs it. You have these conspirator cards that you're drawing from as an action you can draw. There are 12 plots in this deck and you're trying to find them and each plot has things that like have required elements like, "Oh, we're trying to get him by poisoning his food." Well, he needs to be in any Berlin space, so you have to you have to just kind of wait for him to go there. Uh, but then you can get more dice if you have poison, if you have intel, if you have if you're a civilian, because each character can either be an obair, um, a uh, Vermacht or a civilian.

So, you're trying to gather all those requirements to give you the best chance to actually succeed on the plot. But, and this, if a lot of people, if you watch this channel a lot, you know that I despise almost um, dice dictating whether you succeed or fail. But that is literally exactly how this game goes. Let's say in the poison food uh plot, you he is in a Berlin space, which he has to be anyway, but then you are a civilian. You have poison, you have intel, you you have, you know, the four dice that it gives you. You have a card that gives you two more dice. So, and you only need three successes to be able to win. and you roll and it's an absolute I mean in this case it would actually be a success depending on your suspicion but let's say that you don't you don't roll any of the birds which I forget what they're called it but you also don't roll any of the targets so you absolutely fail that that's literally just how the game goes and for a lot of people I think that could be very frustrating because if that does fail then you had to get rid of the poison you had to get rid of the intel to do that. So now you have to either find that again, try it again, or ditch the plot and try a different one that you can attempt. But what makes this game so special, at least to me, is that in and of itself is incredibly

thematic. There were so many assassination attempts against Hitler that failed that I mean that almost succeeded. And because of that alone, it just it really adds that extra element of theme. Um, yeah, you're not actually moving around a board and and you know, putting the food in. It's not like the actions you're taking are thematic, but the results of of the actions that you're doing are at least in terms of the plot that you're that you're attempting. So, whenever the mechanics itself, I think, are very straightforward. This game is super easy to pick up. In fact, half the board, this whole black section here is basically the rule book. It's so there's no player aids. It's like, what do I do on my turn? Oh, it just says everything that you need to know over there. What happens if you're arrested? It says everything you need to know if you're over there. How do you enact a plot?

What happens if it fails? What happens if it's detected? It's all right here. Is it an eyesore? Kind of, but you're not really doing all that much whenever you're playing. You have these little pawns. uh that are straight from generic board games of who you are. This game, if it came out, it'd be crowdfunded and it would be miniatures and it would honestly be over over I think it would be overshadowing the actual material. Um, and then like there were just so many things that go into it that I think the theme pretty much carries this whole game because if you're like needing like the one where we just played, we needed the the one plot that we finally got was bombing his plane and we actually had everything going for it, but we needed him to move and he had to move by an event. And so because we were banking on that, we just kind of b, you know, bited our time, waited around until he finally moved.

And luckily it succeeded. We were doing a lot of conspiring, a lot of things to keep his military support down so that if he finally moves, we had a higher chance of succeeding. But there were so many events and things that could go wrong that it could have just not. Uh, our suspicion could have been raised. There could have been a Gustapo raid that causes us to get arrested or the person who was going to enact the plot gets arrested. And all of that just really adds to this intensity while you are playing that is missed in a lot of games or a lot of games I feel have components kind of like protect the game. They're just like, hey, like when you chip away at it, it's like, well, this game really isn't like mechanically sound or it's not that good. Yeah, but look how pretty it is. Look at all the components. look at the miniatures, look at the whatever it might be. And this game doesn't have any of that. You're playing and if it's like, "Okay, finally, finally, Hitler got on a plane." Like you you've just been waiting and then you have that anticipation. You're like, "He's finally on the plane. Now we can try this plot."

And it fails. And you can immediately just from that alone thematically explain why it failed. It's like, "Fuck, like, god." Okay. All right. Well, we don't have any more explosives. Okay. And he like who knows when he's going to move next. We can try and find get more explosives somewhere else. But the map opens up as more and more stuff happens. Once you finally go into the different decks, like once you finally go into deck 4, then you can now go to Stockholm, Ria, uh, Trebinka, um, Avitz, and there are cards that require those to be open. So you might have some cards that are useless, but they're really good, but it's later on in the game. Um, so it's like, okay, do we do we just try and search for a different plot, come up with a different plot, and hope that that works? It it really just continues to to amaze me. Even though, like I just said, on your turn, three actions, move, grab an item, draw a card.

That's that's pretty much it. like uh and and what's actually kind of interesting is that when you succeed or if you succeed, like I mentioned earlier, it tells you how many um lives you saved, but that amount is lessened. It's kind of like a score almost, which now I think about it is kind of like a shitty, hey, check your score on based off how many people didn't die, but you're also trying to get it to where you kill a bunch of him and his deputies at the same time because you can't really kill them on their own. It's not like you can I mean, there are ways to remove them from the from the game, but like you're kind of wanting them to be grouped together when your plot goes off. So, it's like, yes, we got them all because there's goals and and and uh Bowman and Going and all those people that move around the board constantly as well, and if you start your turn, they have a negative effect. What's also kind of interesting that I really enjoy is you have two tracks on your on your player sheet that is your motivation and your suspicion. and your motivation.

Like you start off timid because obviously trying to assassinate someone can't be like the most woo this is super easy. Uh but it goes up to skeptical, positive, committed and zealous. And the the higher that is, the better off you are. Now you can actually commit plots or or attempt plots based off your level. It also unlocks a special ability based off who you are. And I like how there's a little text on who these people were, which unless I'm completely mistaken were real people. I don't think they just made this up, made these characters up. Uh, so that's uh that's just amazing for historical context. But then you also have your suspicion track that goes up and down. You're trying to keep it as low as possible because when you do a plot, let's say you roll five dice, but you're at extreme suspicion. One bird causes it to be detected. So it's like, well, that wouldn't even be a success anyway. But let's say I rolled enough to be successful, but I also rolled enough birds for it to fail. It doesn't matter.

You were caught and then you're, you know, it's detected. And there's a difference for detected and failed. Failed means you get to keep the plot, but uh that's kind of it. Detected means that you lose the plot card in general. Like I said, there's only 12. And then you're arrested. And if everyone's arrested, then you just lose the game. So there there's that element of of theme as well just off of a cube going up and down on a track. So you really are doing so much to try and give yourself the best odds and even if it fails then it's like all right, we just got to keep trying. So I really enjoy that. I think the event cards are great. I like how just from the beginning of the game you remove two. So, there might be certain cards that you're looking for that just might not be in the game, and they get increasingly more and more difficult as the game goes on. There's this neat element that I haven't really seen in other games where there's like key events that get put in uh based off, you know, the stage you're you're at, but then there's other cards that don't go off if a key event is played. So, there's like you can't just have multiple key events. So, that's also going to kind of change based off of which one happens to come out first. And I think that's really cool. So, I mean, overall, I think that this game definitely deserves its place. I'm I'm not saying it's the best cooperative game out there, you know, mechanically,

just because it's it's literally not, especially if it keeps going on longer. If you keep failing or things are just not going your way, it can definitely wear out its welcome. But by having that overbearing um just understanding, if you really get into the theme of how god awful this, you know, this regime was, then you know, if you you just kind of, at least for me, take that into account when things fail. It's almost like you have this this goal to strive for. you want to beat the game super quick because then you can feel, I don't know, a little bit better in the hypothetical situation that millions of people weren't massacred. Um, so yeah, I I think these games are are kind of lost as, you know, as time goes on. People might just seem to be afraid to really dive into this this time period and explore these hard-hitting um topics.

And I think that's almost a dangerous mentality to to go into. These things need to be represented in any form of medium whether you enjoy the game or not because it it could just be too heavy for you. That's I mean a personal thing, but it's it's really I think kind of fascinating especially cuz it's like when people when people were like about like oh Doom is, you know, it's there's a bunch of demons in it. It's like yeah, but you're killing them. It's like oh this game has Nazis in it. Yeah, but you're trying to kill the the worst one. So, like I'd say that's an admirable goal of a cooperative game. But yeah, I I don't know. I think I think this one I I don't see many people talk about it. I don't really see many people have it in their collection.

So, I mean, I've had it, you know, for years, and it's always just been been one I've kept around just because of what it actually attempts to convey whenever you're playing it. So, yeah, if if you don't know anything about it, it's a really really unique one. Again, mechanically, it's not the best. Uh, it's serviceable. I mean, it's it's good, but I think the theme and everything about it really kind of elevates the overall experience. So, um, on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give Black Orchestra an eight. Uh, that's that's everything, including theme and mechanics. I think if I was to give the mechanics a little bit more of a pass, which I already do, I would give it a nine because I really understand the importance of the source material. Um, but I think as an overall game and what you would be expecting out of it, I think an eight would would really kind of just encompass all of that. So that's it everyone. That's my thoughts on Black Orchestra. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon,

and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved