Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:54

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for alfred hitchcock's rear window uh which is the weirdest theme i think to put on a game i would have never thought to put anything like this especially in a game that's what they say game of deduction and suspense by prospero hall um basically it's a re-themed mysterium um with a big twist with a better twist i think this game is a lot of fun okay i really enjoyed this um because you're right it is it is similar to mysterium but there's there's so much more yes like it's more concrete and there's more teamwork involved in it yeah in mysterio no no no everyone not a and

traitor there's no traitor everyone but there's because the cards are just so ambiguous that and your random hand of seven i think and you're just kind of like okay there's a silver dot and this one hopefully they see it and then they run with something else and you keep but they keep their cards it's the same kind of logic where you where you keep trying to feed them the clue for them to guess the mur the person the place and the weapon yeah right the difference is at the end it comes down to how many clues you can basically find so not everybody might make it to the very end section but more people give it and there's some weird end game to mystery yeah it's just it's kind of janky yeah but yeah this one was great um i don't think the theme really comes out but actually i haven't seen the movie i think it absolutely does you haven't seen the movie shut up the war style of it it does come out in the arc stylistically

the same i mean this is a little older than pnm but the way that the text is displayed on these is of the 50s yes pan am does that too that's one thing i like about both of them yeah yeah um 100 agree but you're right i need to watch that movie i'm gonna go home and watch it yeah i i have not seen this but i mean it's still i it had so much like clue giving but keep it in the back of your mind that it's like well is he trying to mislead us this entire time but he can only mislead us so much so much because if you do that successfully it's gonna be the most satisfying thing in the world if you can get somebody put all the work and get them to six points and then do that and that's that's where i was hoping like you guys kept thinking there was a murder and i thought okay if i got you to six points like i really was clear like on the drunk yeah like i weren't like that's why i picked up the card and placed it though and then put it all down so there was no question what i was pointing at but you could have just botched i could have seen completely and just rode that out till the end you have to almost be vague in a couple areas or something right right i feel like also a process of elimination at work yes i would i would i would imagine it would actually be difficult to win with a murder just because the players have so much avenue to get concrete answers you'd have to like now that you've played with me as the director if i got murder it would be harder for me to you know slap off the fact like you guys got three four and then six like you continuously got more points right if

the next time we played and you had two one two yeah four yeah i always start questions like really but i also know you're good at being a traitor and i try not to met it because i've been in that situation so many times where it's like no he's he has [ __ ] cards there's that's why he's turning them face down but the math in my head was like hail mary or bust is kind of the way i was looking at it because we had nothing to go off of what was it again it was a trey sheik that's right but in defense of the traitor mechanic um if you are intentionally misleading and people aren't getting things right right we could say yes there's a murder but which one oh yeah of the four spots agreed we've got three things right it could be idiots i still to win i still have to get you guys to five or six right with a murderer yeah so you can't just completely just randomize the cards and just and just you know trash the game so right i think that is a very interesting twist i agree uh for a game like this because they're always 100 well no i mean deception murder in hong kong has a trader um but i i don't really compare deception and mysterium oh everyone does and i'm like they're different i'm like the closest one is obscurio that is more like that does have a traitor um because the person who's narrating like hong kong they don't have that much choice right here is all about what my choices are to direct you guys to it is exclusively

choice almost yeah i really like the pairing i think that's a very interesting mechanism there's a lot of options oh when you guys were like go and point the arrow to that i was just like don't do that don't do that you guys are on the right track because you have it just plain in a corner i was honestly just going to point to her a dress and i was so happy we went to here instead because then it was like okay guarantee you're not going to get her if you actually i was kind of hoping then you would point to the arrow and point to her address because that was the best chance to get you guys to shake at that point well it's also really cool because everyone a lot of these games there's usually like one person that kind of carries but everyone that brought in really good like information that's like oh yeah like zach was like oh it's the gardener and it's like you're right that is what it is um but that was also based to solve around information of like just the math that you can do it's like we got three right over there and we're 100 certain it's the writer so if we're thinking that this is romance and therefore it can't be the writer but that doesn't make any sense for any of the other clues we got so therefore we can't be going all the way back right um you guys have any negatives on the game um that wouldn't be it's light enough that any of the things that wouldn't be perfect about it i wouldn't critique it for right it could be the same complaints for all those other games right yeah

then the hand of cards is purely random and you're just dealt [ __ ] it's like right yeah but you're given three director tokens so you can you can mitigate mitigate it enough yeah like and we're also given uh i i really like these special abilities yep i think um there's definitely one that's better was it the window card uh heard the face down window i think that can be used correctly in a specific one it seems like they could have right but i fix it a little bit but i don't know it's weaker but then you got like two powerful ones yes no you just instantly know and then a point to exactly what i'm trying to get on that car because most of the time it's probably one item on a card so i can at least show you exactly what i want yeah obscurio has something very similar to that where they can play an ability and you point to either something because even if it wasn't the drunk and he points to like the gray or something it's like okay well clearly it's someone within that color which there isn't so he wouldn't do that right but he could have done it up here where it's like okay well he's pointing at the red but again i was so happy that you know like the one that you take a face down card you discard it and i give you another one yeah i had another card with alcohol in it and you guys saw that they're alcohol and kyle was was it dinner or was it drunk and i was trying to get across that there's lots of alcohol and when they demoed that game the the guy who worked for the app is just like yeah you draw a card and put it down i'm like what is that gonna do right and they're like oh no that makes sense and i'm like it doesn't but okay and yes lo and behold they got two two two two whenever i played my game i'm gonna keep [ __ ] stupid right

okay i'm giving you great clues this entire time it's frustrating but you know what you asked for negative i am actually going to call out the the theme as an not necessarily a negative but just an odd choice now it is suspenseful and it does build in that kind of hitchcock way but i think he missed it by a generation i think he's appealing to a generation that isn't going to play it's so strange because i i mean i'm kind of with books movies and games i judge them by their cover i saw this and i'm like that looks like trash like there's no way a cover like this where it's either for pedophiles or peepers i well one i mean i didn't i also didn't know it was alfred hitchcock's i just saw a rear window and i'm like i don't know anything about that and this looks like it would be cheap it's a well-known movie of his but it's not one of his most well-known yeah right and i'll say when like you guys were bringing out real winners like what earth is game like rear window um i didn't look it up at all i was like that's probably not going to be a game for me yeah so anytime a game has a theme like this i'm instantly drawn to it and it's because i'm so [ __ ] sick of seeing marvel anime boxes yeah other generic fantasy i'm like this would be hp this would be hb lovecraft before i played the the the dark tower returns game like i'm just like oh we're going to do this again and i do like it i like it a lot but like return to dark tower i'm just like it's not a generic fantasy theme but i

did think that going into it because i'm just like i've seen it but but something like this and even with pan am pan am i rolled my eyes until i played it and i like the art in it outside of the actual game yeah right and even with those those massive ips yeah like i love marvel but it comes down to a point where it's like okay i like that marvel game like marvel champions like that's one i'll just keep giving it to me lovecraft i mean right you keep giving me more so it is refreshing to see something like this however i do think brett's right that most people are avoiding this because it this tells you nothing it's not going to pull children into nor would you really want to but like certain younger generation that's not going to connect with this right right but this is honestly i would probably get rid of my mysterium and replace it with this game just because i think it's better yeah i would love this i am not inclined at all to play mysterium i've tried several times every time it just seems like it's random guessing and then the clue giver pissed off because because you're not getting what i'm thinking well yeah it's it's definitely one of those the art is just kind of too abstract and mysterium park is just the art is it works for every single person so i can't give you accurate clues um but this has repeating and and it matches with the clues i will say that what has mystery is mysterium comes with the variety that each one of those cards can be taken in such a different way right i feel like if you play this enough especially with the same director it's

like okay well you know he picked that one for the police officer um right they're not as so like so i feel like it oh maybe if you play this game every single day it would become kind of like oh this is when you want to play with different groups yeah right because you want to see how different people sync up with it and we'll say this game definitely felt like we sunk up quite a bit better i mean it's why you guys figured out immediately why i put two greens in the opposite spot right that wasn't really fine i was zack on that being like well he he put two so therefore it's not them at all right oh yeah that makes sense right because thank god you were the director because you guys would have been one one one all right there has to be there has to be a murder i'm like no just no one thinks like me right i'm just bad uh but in terms of games like this this is up there this is really good i i still would probably play deception or obscurio over there um and because deception and obscurity have that traitor this one doesn't have to have one those are guaranteed to have one right so i like that's the suspense part for me and deceptions done in 20 minutes straight up because it's always five minute turns three five minute turns plus the yeah and i usually blow my guess on the first round right so so you're you're guaranteed to be done no longer than 20 minutes so it's kind of one of those games where like if you have a bad time you're just done yeah this one was still a little bit of time like mysterium is you know what this one actually i i would agree mysterium has a soft space uh spot in my

heart because it's always worked well for my pre like my early game group so i still have and i still like it but i very much understand its flaws this is actually i think a perfect blend of mysterium and obscurio you have that potential trader where it's like man is he really leading us away but also the clear decisiveness um so people don't feel dumb the whole time right uh and there's elimination so you know anybody that has a little bit of analytics in them because like well we only got three right here and we got four right there what we're the same you know well we got we have three of the same things there so and that problem means that those three are correct yeah might be wrong yeah but the math starts figuring out and you start reading the director a little bit because like i think at one point uh it was either in day two and i know for a fact in day three like whenever you whenever the day started how quickly you put stuff down it's like okay so we're 100 right on that right because he reinforced it strongly yeah because i dropped that and that immediately to try to again exactly to reinforce this is the police and this is a typewriter okay it's really cool you get to look back and be like okay we got three right so what's wrong about that yeah and then day two you pop those down so it's like okay we know ryder's correct it has to be her yeah right and it's yeah i like that it's really solid yep i would never yeah never have touched this ever especially because it's by the op it's like uh you guys kind of do shitty games

you do math they do not shitty games they do mass market games which mass market tend to not do well yeah uh yep but this is the first one yeah you get the goof game movie game game is it is it the movie game the goof the troop you didn't goof troop the movies they were pushing that hard at gen con they had the guy who who voices goofy in the movie and like voices max and you could sit down and watch a screening of the movie and it sold out like super quick and then they had like it would make sense that would sell out it's the right generation apparently i watched that movie matthew willard was that gen con [ __ ] i wish i met him he seemed so cool there was comments underneath it and people were like oh he was so nice he was so nice and then somebody was like he was an [ __ ] to me you know what maybe you were the [ __ ] he just didn't want to put up there's a lot of [ __ ] there i know i demoed one with him uh but yeah i'm this is definitely a shocker for and this came out this year too like this feels like it should have came out in like 2013 2015 but it's a 2022 game yeah um we'll be watching it soon i will not it didn't work that well for me to be like well i mean this was so good it's like i played battlestar galactica and wanted to watch the show no i'm not itching to go watch a rear window uh i mean why when the master when the the masterpiece with shia labeouf is out right that's true uh you get to watch him makes every movie

oh 100 yeah if i need to be cheered up one day that is what i go to he was in constantine he like out acted keanu reeves and then holes now holes is actually legitimately good but yo the transformers movies when he quit doing them they just tanked had nothing to do with michael bay or his shitty direction i mean they did tank after he did well arguably they tagged while he was but all right so it was when they lost megan fox that's really it bring her back with machine gun kelly and just start reboot the transformers movies and they're taking all this robots that's just crap all right so on the scale of one to ten what would you guys give rear window we'll start with uh oh you know what i'll start um i'm at an eight i'm surprised i'm very very surprised i would i would very much like to play this again i kind of agree eight eight yeah where are you guys at i'm i'm thinking actually nine nine yeah nice zack i'm gonna eight point five yeah yeah it's the second time i played it but i play i'm gonna play it more and yeah i want to see how badly i do as a director so that's kind of where it's like ooh real quick actually before before we we go what do you guys think of the length you thought four days was good or yeah um for the amount of guessing that has to happen yeah i would say yeah for the last day to be suspenseful and and

get that pressure on you have to have four because at three it just wouldn't work three two five is too long five would be way too long i could see it being shortened by maybe just having three three overalls per day sure and shorten it to three days yeah yeah i think you could do that if you want to or if you want to keep the keep the the four pairs you do ten cards in your hand sure instead of eight because eight was just like for sure you had to play every single one of them right right um but i mean and all right i still think it worked really well right because you didn't have to put two face down right because i think day three only put one face down yeah mm-hmm uh day two i only put no no you put two we just flipped the face up because we were trying to figure out what the hell and then we flipped it up it's like yeah that's the murderer he [ __ ] he did it nope all right well that's our thoughts on rear window everyone i hope you enjoyed let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this view hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved