Edge of Darkness Extended Board Game Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
hi everyone the new tube thanks for joining me for finally another review I've got in the game I can review from my collection I've had for some time but I've wanted to get it to the table more before I gave it the a proper video review and that wasn't just multiplayer but also solo it's um it ran a big game if you fought like gloom Haman was big this is kind of on par with the same size of crate and that is a e/g game okay listen this thing here we go oh yeah it's a big one isn't it of Darkness this monstrosity of a box do you think maybe he's compensating for something is basically a sequel to a game called mystic veil from John Dee Claire you may recognize it as the game about cart crafting a very innovative game a very innovative mechanic where instead of building up a deck of cards you had a fixed deck but you crafted the cards individually you grab these plastic sleeves as advancements which you slide into the cards and then create these really cool combos with special Paras and abilities and grab the two points and win the game it was no not the most completely simple game you know not light but Midway the Midway game that just threw a really cool twist on a mechanic that I already enjoyed really liked it hopes it's in my collection with expansions and if you want to check it out I highly recommend going on Android Apple or steam and finding the app so really good at the implementation but this is the sequel which they put on
Kickstarter and you tend to only see this either on you might be able to get it from their website I'm not sure but typically when they ug do a Kickstarter for another expansion you're able to get the stuff before it so there will be ways to get this in the future if you don't see on the second hand sale but this is a sequel to mystic veil not the same universe at least I don't believe it's the same universe but this is more a sequel in the sense that it takes the current crafting system and turns another 13 it essentially combines that whole card crafting thing except you now have a communal deck of cards that everybody is I with all the different advancements you've got worker placement in action section with these ten different locations that were possible 36 that you will put in the game that with these agent pawns or workers I guess you will put them on the locations and take them off the locations to perform different actions and abilities on top of this you've also got to defend your kingdom from these frets that come in which which very cool they make away are the reverse of the cards so on the back of these cards that you're sliding but these advancements are these monsters and adversaries that stand on this tower a cute tower and you drop cubes into this cube tower they represent who they're likely to attack maybe everybody maybe just a particular player and you've got with your cards that you've been making in other actions ways to defend against it or to go out on the offensive and kill them off first there's a lot happening in this game I mean this really does a little bit where
there's a lot to deal with in this game I mean it really is a bit of a mammoth in terms of its scope but the question is does it warrant this huge gloom Haven sized box in terms of storage and in terms of cost this is not a cheap game by any means question is what is it worth it and did I he regrets my purchase and yes I will stipulate I did get this on Kickstarter when it first came out however that is not going to influence my verdict so let's go into some detail on this Edge of Darkness game and duration duration depends on the player count greatly here your first game is naturally going to take you a while because you've got to get used to all these different abilities and the concepts you probably haven't seen before and with four players I will say that I think this drags a little bit too long and outstays it's welcome but if you've got four people who know what they're doing and know to plan their turns ahead of time it can go at a decent pace but I still think four is maybe a bit too much unless you are happy to have a long game but free players is not bad free purse is a pretty good sweet spot you have a decent amount of interaction a lot of different cards appearing in the in the street or tableau basically and a lot of different things happening to players is pretty nice and quick still works great there's only a minor change the rules for two players you don't have to learn some funky weird variant for it and so though it's actually pretty sweet as well and doesn't take too long although as much as the game won't take too long there is a fair bit to setup involved you've got to get your ten
locations you've got to get the cards associated with those ten locations you've got to get the player pieces out you've got to get the boards out yo all of that stuff set up the pieces the components then you've got like a prologue round before the game starts where you kind of draft your initial advancement your initial abilities and there's quite a bit happening if we're honest so he's applying the rules are actually pretty good in this I think the rule book and this is adequate enough for you to be able to learn the game you know the concepts in this game are not that complicated especially if you're already familiar with mystic veil mystic veils card crafting is no different here you get the advancements you sleeve them in and then you can trigger all the effects the difference being that it's no longer in your deck it's now a communal pile and tableau but once you get that mechanic in your head the rest of it is not particularly different from what you've seen before in other games the pawns within the action whether they call though the agent spawns that you put on the locations it's pretty straightforward you put them on it might trigger an effect you take them off in might trigger a slightly different effect or a related effect the is a little bit like iconography to get used to in this game you know there's lots of different icons for what type of action is what type of location it is but there's a reference guide on the card that each player can have so you can recognize it and they're not that complicated I mean some of them are kind of self-explanatory or intuitive as to what they are like you know going on the hunt has like to cross swords and putting in training an agent has like a
silhouette of a person with an arrow pointing down you notice there are some notes that be most intuitive thing in the world but I wouldn't say it was overly complex either especially when you have got the reference aid in front of you as for the rules you will probably be rules checking a bit in your first game maybe your second game or say you put it down for a while and you don't pick it up again because there's little nuances here and there you kind to remember but the rule book is well laid out and it's not the world's largest rule book either I mean it's huge backs off and show you so you've got three books in here so you've got pretty touchy and they're big so it's easy to pick it up in reference you're talking big font maybe a little text heavy in places but overall not too bad but this is just so low rules so nice little book for that this monstrosity book is just the playa handbook this basically is a guide that tells you exactly how every location works so you shouldn't have any FAQ issues and some recommended setups that even like not a campaign but kind of like a story based setup so that is just for reference only so this is your rule book not particularly thick as you can see and again this one you do have a reasonable ads of text I'll admit but then you do have some pictorial examples as well to show you some key aspects that's probably my only regret with this rule book is that it can get a little bit text heavy when they're probably should be more pictures but let me know set up that's the set up diagram and
then you've got two four six eight including game end for that and then the back to adjuster iconography of what they mean in detail so you're talking eight pages from a big size rule book to learn I've seen much more complicated rule books than this so I would not recommend this to anybody brand new to the game definitely not and I probably wouldn't recommend this to anybody who is unfamiliar with mystic veil if they are not used to picking up games quick because having it grounding and how the card crafting worked with help not essential but I would say it's advisable so not for this not for the faint-hearted but I don't think you have to be like a veteran gamer to grasses either so moving on to tactics and strategy this game really shines with this aspect because with those locations they generate all sorts of different possibilities for how you can play this game and as you're going through and sleeving the card combos you're creating these in your mind thinking well if I take that one this turn I can trigger that effect because you get the effect from whatever you sleeve for free every turn so you'll always get to do something but then you put on your card you trigger that effect but then you got rabbi but that effect that will get me money that gets me influenced if I put those two agents there and get some battle strength which will be mean when I trigger this effect to go on a hunt I can go kill that monster who's liable to be knocking on my doorstep sometime soon quite a little bit you know you've got to consider here and with the tokens that allow you to number when you do the effects you will
want to get used to using those because if you stare it anywhere from somewhere like three to six cards in your hand depending on what locations are out that might may or may not increase your hand size from free you will get quite a few effects as the game progresses and you will want to use those tokens to plan things out but it's fun to do it and it's meaningful choices you can't it's no point to something going or I'll just doing that order that in that order not in that order no because it can be very important you can pull off some really cool combos to have right well I'm going to use this ability but I don't have any agents down there yet but hang on a minute if I use this ability I can get agents from there onto that location then take them off to do the action then use this card ability and that is always happening every turn particularly as the game progresses where it does sort of go quite like complex in terms of how many abilities you could possibly trigger on your turn particularly if you're picking up each other's cards but the coat the idea that you're always looking at your card and thinking hmm best way to do this this could be fun and that's from a tactical perspective strategically you do have a lot of strategy and again as well because from the get-go when you see those locations when you see those card abilities you're thinking well well I could go for a high attack strength thing and go hunting monsters I could just go on the defensive and just wait for them to come to me I could gain lots of money by doing this this maybe I should just get my and what they call allegiance slips into the cards which basically allow you to take control of
cards so it gives you points and means that other players have to pay you money in order to use your abilities because that's the other thing to note you don't have a fixed deck here you have a communal deck with a tableau of the draft from so you could be using each other's cards so you gotta consider that when you're sleeping but sorry but obviously if you use your own cards you use your own cards great but if you use an opponent's card not only do you have to pay the money for every effect you trigger but the card then goes to their own personal discard pile where they get it on their next turn so you almost are kind of glad that someone's using your card because you know you're going to get it next turn but you may be like well you know I wanted that car because it's got lots of cool stuff on it problem is you make the card too good everybody else wants it so there's a little bit of pushing over there and a good amount of player interaction as a result so it really does like get your brain cells going not to a brain Burney aspect though this will overwhelm possibly a new player or someone unfamiliar with some of the concepts that this game brings into play but I think for anybody who's familiar with mystic veil and gamers who are kind of used to complex games you should be able to pick it up and not have too much trouble but yeah definitely a lot to consider from a tactical and strategic viewpoint and that's one of the reasons that you know one of the many positives that this should be praised for so then moving on to aesthetics aesthetics are pretty solid I mean you hit and miss in
certain areas you have got a lot in this game I mean you have got boards have got massive score pad even bigger board with very good artwork I mean that's one thing I have to say the artist is a was a Elena Danner I'm not sure if I can pronounce that name properly but that is the artist and this is pretty sweet you know that very good very it's hard to describe it it looks like something you would get out of a storybook or those scenes you get like our Lord of the Rings where they look in the distance and see like oh there's a the elven City they're blinking us to Rivendell or something of that in the distance and you see that like really artistic drawing it's a bit like that but you've got it through all of these boards so each of these boards has got you know unique very colorful artwork to the artwork on the advancements themselves you know you won't be able to see these in the camera but they're very detailed they're very you know very colorful very good and component-wise again hitting this here you've got very good thick chunky tiles which is not a bad thing you have got yo cubes which now what ever cubes and you've got some miniatures for you know the various agents so you know and the agents are pretty decent the one minor thing I'm not as big a fan of is that you do have if you don't get the kick starter version or the add-ons you will have these plastic pieces or couple actually
I think it was cardboard pieces yeah you had cardboard tokens for money in influence now which is fine but personally what I did was I grabbed the plastic versions and the metal coins the metal coins actually are very good if you've managed to get the metal coins these are very good and very chunky but I don't get why they put them in such weird denominations like everything's in denominations of 1 for 10 one for 20 it just seems really weird why but what I have to do with mine is that I didn't want the cardboard tokens but when the box was shipped to me it didn't have really enough tokens in it to warrant a full 4 player game so what me and my friend did who also got the game was that because they preferred the cardboard tokens and I preferred the plastic ones we basically traded each other's cardboard and plastic tokens so I got all of these and they got the cardboard ones so that kind of solved itself but that was an era thing so you might be you have to be warned that you may have a slight supply issue or you may have to change up a lot if you're playing this with the max player account on top of that they give you a few like little plastic tubs in order to store the things during a game although I would probably recommend you just get your own alternative thing like I'll use these are rubber muffin tins they work quite well but yeah nice if they give you it in the box but Wow here's the earth the big thing what you think's in this in here you have got the cube tower this monumental thing easily assembled
yeah easily assembled not difficult lacked has to set up on your table along with everything else and that's one thing about the aesthetics you better get used to this is a table hog a big table hog immersion of the theme this one is a little bit more lacking the theme is there in terms of oh yeah the deep watch peacekeepers oh yeah they get you compact strength okay fair enough the harbor for more of your men are there you get more money okay yeah you would earn fares when you're at the harbour and then you've got the okay a few of the other ones I'm trying to think like a university where you go to the University and you can train more agents so the locations make sense for what abilities they do and the setting is nice but it is basically its own made-up fantasy world setting with you where like magic and monsters are a thing it's not quite generic fantasy levels but it's still not exactly Lord of the Rings style levels I mean the book the player handbook will give you ways to essentially like you know a story base on each of the recommended setups and so you could if you want to read the blurb but frankly as you're playing a game you don't overly care it's like you're more playing this game for its mechanics and just the fact that it looks nice rather than giving a monkey's about any story behind it or the lore as we say but with all the card combos at your building with all of those tactics I mentioned earlier and the player interaction you're definitely
immersed in this game from start to finish it definitely will keep you engaged even if not necessarily from a story narrative perspective so then moving on to longevity longevity is really good with this I mean remember why say you have 36 locations in this box now I got this on Kickstarter but I think the majority of those if not all of them were stretch goals so I don't think any of those locations are exclusive but yeah let's say a few of them were and you had like 30 instead of 36 I'm pretty positive they put in our line in this box but let's go with 36:36 will say that 36 locations you use 10 in each game and some will repeat as you go through the recommended setups but you could just curate your own but 36 locations with different abilities and different card advancements so you choose 10 at 36 the amount of times you could play this game with near endless replay value is pretty much insane you know different combinations at different locations will allow you to have different types of games like some will be more coin intensive you'll be able to get some money some will allow you to barely be able to train in the agent so you gotta be frugal with how you use your starting ones some will be very combative so there's threats coming at you all the time constantly threatening you and you know getting in your face they can have drastic implications on how the game is played and allowing for certainly your money's work in terms of
how many times you could play this game and not get bored with the setups and that's before you consider its expandability the expandability with this game it is kind of ridiculous not only do you have the 36 locations that you can use in here all of these mean unique and different different effects and different currents but if you were to get this on Kickstarter or find it with an expansion you have the ability to basically get a big box like this I got this in the first Kickstarter and they recently did a frost version of it I mean come on you know desert one a frost one gloom Haven frost Haven it's kind of the norm when you do these fancy games but this is the box I haven't even opened this one yet this is I got it as an expansion before this was during my day when I was a bit more of a completionist on kick starts now are kind of wizened up a bit but this has another I just read the back another 13 boards another 98 card advancement so basically 13 cards 13 unique car advancements and some tokens for an additional mechanic and another Handbook so this box alone gives me another 13 boards and abilities as well as other setups and you can mix the stuff in here with the stuff in here so you don't have to use any ten boards from here I could use five from here and five from there free from here seven from there two from here eight from yeah I can do whatever I like the replay value goes over there
ooh no we're trying to put one of these boxes in I don't even have the frost one and I haven't even put this in the box yet because I don't need to yet there's already so much content in this box that is not overly necessary and even when you consider that you have solo mode yes even though it's an isolation I can't get two or three players to this game I can play the solo mode and I've been playing several games of that this week this is where Superman works alone and basically it's a bot player so I think I might mention this briefly in my recent solo video that I did but essentially it uses a concept called the voiceless guild it's basically an AI player that works a bit like your Tom the decks are you kind of get in things like wingspan in the stone Mario games essentially you flip a card and based on that card it will dictate what how many cards are going to draft it around what advancement they're going to particularly choose to sleeve into one of their cards and then it has rules for how they trigger off the effects but rather than using the complex effects that are on the locations they will use a simplified set based on these action cards and in terms of difficulty well depending what locations you use that's a difficulty or not but the seven I think there's seven action cards that they use you can flip them on to easy or hard side in any combination you like to up the difficulty and on top of that the choice deck as they call it you know where you flip a card and do something you use 12 cards but there's a good 24
and also 25 solo cards so again you're using different cards every game so there's very variety in the solo mode alone and there's a good solo mode you know you basically do you know they get to go first they do this stuff and you just follow their cards in the methodical way and then you get to do the same thing as you would in a multiplayer game you get to draft your car to decide what effects you want to do use occasions so you get that fun element of the game without losing too much of what you would have got in a multiplayer game except for maybe multiplayer would make maybe slightly different choices at times oh no I think this Edge of Darkness deserves a solid nine out of ten from me really enjoy this one yes it's not the most fanatically immersive game in the world but it just looks nice on the table it's got presents with all the stuff there and what really heightens this to nothing for me is one that replay value and to the solo mode and free the fact that the thoughts and combos and you know the choices you make during the game all feel meaningful you know occasionally you might get a turn where you draft some slightly bad cards and you know you can't do as much but everybody will usually get that situation and there are ways to mitigate it by skipping over cards and it's not usually too difficult to do so so you shouldn't end up with that situation too often and you will get to take a free advancement every turn so you will get to trigger at least something but it
just it really just ticks a lot of boxes for me this mechanic is one that I loved in mystic Vale it's now been basically turned up to 13 and shoved in this game with more meat and it just it's even better I actually prefer this game to mystic veil and I already really liked mystic veil I can't give it a full ten though because I do think that the four player time length the long set arc you know the cost investment of the game you know these aren't huge negatives but I believe it's enough to say look you know I reckon you will get a really good fun experience out of Edge of Darkness with a few little caveats that you just might want to bear in mind so yeah that is Edge of Darkness this is gonna sit and take up most of a calyx square by itself and I do I do that next time AG decide to throw a kick starter out from this game if you are a fan of mystic Vale you definitely want to give this one a look if you're not a fan of mystic veil this probably isn't gonna swing you over to that side but maybe you just wanted a bit more meat and a bit more interestin maybe but it'll swing you over but typically I think this is more do you think the card crafting system is cool if so have a look at this game if not you can pass it by so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken people review and regardless of whether you are run out of space in your collection because of this giant box of the game it's still at the end as I say only again so take care and I'll see you
on the next video