Shallow Sea: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in the game Shallow Sea, which I played for the first time in Geek Way to the West 2026. So, Shallow Sea looks like this. This is a player mat. This is actually the solo mode setup, but we're going to focus on the player mat and this tile selection area up here. Um There are two things that I really like about this game. One, and I would say the main thing, the main favorite mechanism is the tile token selection process. So, on your turn it has paired benefits um that you're going to choose from. You're You're In general, you are going to choose one of these fish tokens, which are really nicely made. They're great fish meeples. You're going to choose one fish meeple and then one tile that's adjacent to it.
And this is, I think, really clever in a way that is uh not immediately apparent. Especially particularly that you're not gaining all three of these things. You're gaining two of these things and one of them has to be the fish. So, the fish is important, tied to my second favorite mechanism, because you are placing it somewhere on your board in the hopes of completing one of these tiles. So, actually this player has completed all their things, so it's not not a great example, but most of the tiles have uh requirements on each of their corners where they're looking for specific colors of fish. And you can pair those benefits together. So, for example, this yellow fish may have been next to two tiles that wanted to be next to a yellow fish right there. They're both happy that there's a yellow fish right next to them. Um One thing they're not really showing here is whenever you complete a tile, you actually have to have to take one of those fish meeples and put it on top of that tile, as you can see like here or here, here or here.
Uh so, that is one thing that you're getting this fish meeple that is used to complete, potentially, up to four different tiles that surround it. The other thing though is that, again, you are not choosing both of the tiles, you're choosing one of them and they come from two different categories. One, actually here's what the tiles look like in terms of completion. This tile wants a purple fish, a purple fish, a green fish, and a green fish in those specific places and it's worth nine points. Um So, these are the kind of the basic more basic spatial tiles that you're trying to complete. There's also a line of more complex spatial goals that you're trying to complete that are related to uh specifically in reference to where this tile is, you were trying to have two tiles next to it that are equal to um equal to the uh equal to one another.
They have the same type of coral on them for this specific goal. Each of these are different and they are, I would say, a little bit more complicated than this tile row up here. The reason I'm highlighting this is that one, for experienced players, this is still a great choice. You're choosing uh a a more simple spatial puzzle versus a more complex spatial puzzle. And doing a mix of the two, as I learned during the game, is better. It it is ultimately better in the game cuz you're going to be able to fill more spaces to put more things down. Um and get more points, too. But, I also think it's great for onboarding because uh for me, it was my first time playing Shallow Sea. It was a lot easier for me to focus on these basic this basic spatial puzzle than understanding what all these icons meant and and kind of grokking the the next level spatial puzzle. So, I focused almost primarily almost solely on these. I lost the game as a result, but I still had fun doing so. So, I really like that choice in both for experienced players and for onboarding new players. They have the choice between the simpler tile and the more complex tile and when exactly and where exactly they want to place those tiles.
That is my favorite mechanism in Shallow Sea. I really like this new level of paired benefits and I'd love to hear what you think in the comments below about Shallow Sea or about other games that have a paired benefit, but maybe give you an extra level choice there as you're taking it. Um this is akin to Cascadia, but with another level to it and really in adding that extra level it gives you a little bit of flexibility and really as I said helps for more experienced players and helps for onboarding new players. Yeah, let me know your thoughts about Shallow Sea in the comments below. Thanks.