Avalon: The Riven Veil Review: The Myst of Riven
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.
I'm Chris Yee.
Today we're taking a look at a small game called Avalon: The Riven Vale. But I got to be honest, um
Riven Vale.
Riven Vale, not Riven Dale.
No, not Riven Dale.
Um this is from Shadow Born Games and this is smaller than their last game.
So, um Oathsworn.
Good point. They're working towards micro games.
Uh Avalon is a somewhat well, it's it's a different take on the King Arthur legacy and you're fighting other people, different factions and it's a fantasy version of this. Not realistic at all, you know, sometimes they're like, "Oh, the like there's King Arthur as you've never seen him before." Well, that's kind of true here, but you want the Holy Grail. You want the Excalibur.
Mhm. Holy Grail's going to pass around like a hot potato. Uh this is also one of the most modular games out there. Before you start your first game, it says, "Do you want to play with A or B, C or D?" I mean, it feels like going to like a an eye doctor almost. I'm going to show in the overview the most straightforward version, A's all the way down.
All right, let's take a look.
Here's a wide shot of what's on the table in a game of Avalon. You have the central board with these areas where players are going to be exploring, turning them over, fighting for majority, getting instant bonuses, and uh building out settlements on here to try to control the game over the course of two or three seasons if you play the long game. There's a board over here that we'll go into detail which tracks battle power and favor, and then every player has their own faction boards here, which we'll go into detail as well. The round structure is set up around the table here. So, each season you're going to first go through the mist phase where you set up the board. Everything will be covered up by mist. Then you go to new prophecies where you're going to reveal goals, these prophecies that players are going to be competing for to try to be the first or any player who completes them in the round. You will get settlement bonuses if you've constructed buildings out on the board, they'll stay here and then you'll get bonuses uncovered on your player board and then players will draw their cards and then begin the action phase. The action phase is called the preparation phase where there'll be three rounds of players taking actions based on what they reveal from their cards before you move on to the war phase. After players have each taken three actions through the preparation phase, you'll move to the war phase following these steps, primarily resolving battles in clockwise fashion moving towards the center of Avalon scoring up for all of those and then at the end of the round you'll discard any excess cards you have. That's one whole season. Each faction is going to have three classes of warriors. You have your lord here who's represented by this side of your player board. Now, one of the important things about this game is you can play with symmetric or asymmetric player powers. Even on the symmetric
side, every player has one special action, whereas the asymmetric side is far more different and will sometimes use special pieces. Otherwise, you don't have to worry about the extra things that make your faction unique. So, you have a lord who can hold two artifacts which will give them special abilities or extra battle points. You have champions here, champions of rank one, two, and three. You can see notches in the base of the miniature and that's simply so that you can keep track if champion one, two, or three is holding an artifact and they have that power. And then you have the basic warriors who are going to be providing one strength out on the board. Can't have any artifacts or anything special. You can construct these settlements which will help you have more permanent foothold on the map and you also have faction power here which is kept You keep track of it as you gain it. You can spend these free actions during your turn, spending faction power to get extra abilities or even extra victory points. There are four decks that drive the entirety of the game here. Players are going to receive two cards from each of the of the four different decks here at the start of each season. The green cards allow you to deploy new troops onto the board. The blue deck is going to allow you to build the strongholds. Yellow is going to allow you to move the units that you've already deployed, and then red is going to be battle plan cards.
These are not action cards. They are simply going to be used when you get to the battle resolution. Each season, players are going to take the Holy Grail card as well as a certain number of beast monster cards and a certain number of artifact cards based on player count, shuffle them together, and distribute them face down to the different areas on the map. Whoever is going to win the Holy Grail will get it for the next round. Whoever wins these artifacts can assign them to lords and champions to increase their battle strength and give them unique abilities. And whoever wins the beasts can either tame them or turn them in for victory points. During each of the three preparation phase actions, players are going to choose one of the cards from their hand that they'd like to play as their action. Remember, battle plans can't be played as actions. So, if I choose to do this one, one of the deploy cards, cuz I want to get units on the board, I will choose this, put it at the front of my deck, and then I have to pay its cost in other cards.
So, I'm going to assign two cards that underneath it that I'm going to pay for it with. Players can do this simultaneously, and they can use this faction card here as simply a divider, which they will keep their hand secret what they're going to be doing. When everyone is ready, they reveal all of the cards in front of their faction divider, and then will we will be triggering off those actions in priority order, starting from the highest initiative number down to the lowest. You'll fire off all abilities on a card. The favor here allows you to move up the favor track, giving you bonuses. This is the symbol for victory points. And then these are deployments, so you can deploy two troops and then two troops to a different region. If it showed four deployments with only a single plus sign, that means all four have to go to the same region. You can deploy to an area on the outside rim of the board, or an area where you have a previously built one of your settlement tokens.
When you choose to deploy or move your lord into a region that is unexplored, you will then explore that region. You'll flip it over, gain a a bonus associated with it. So, in this case, I get to choose either to move up the favor track again, or I can recruit two of my basic warriors to the spot. This area is now available. This is how many points it's going to be worth in the first, second, or third season for the area control. And these are areas where you can build the settlements. The first settlement built always gets a little bonus as well. That card that I mentioned, whether it's a monster artifact or the Holy Grail, which was shuffled face down here randomly, is then revealed. If it's a monster, players will immediately bid for the monster by assigning a certain number of cards, any number of cards they want in front of their divider. When all players are ready, they reveal, and whoever auctioned off the highest amount of cards they're willing to spend and lose will gain that monster, gain its miniature, put their flag in it to show that they have ownership over it. If the lord goes and explores a region that has an artifact in it, players will instead only gain this artifact if they are the winner of this region at the end of the battle, getting the victory points plus the points on the artifact and control of it. If players reveal the Holy Grail, and this is an artifact that will be won by having the strength, the highest strength in that region at the end of the round. There are different types of movements where you can move an entire army. You can move a single piece. You can move an army from one area out to as many other areas, or you pick an area
and you can move all of your troops from adjacent areas into that one area. Once players are done taking their action, they'll discard the cards to the respective decks, the action card and the ones used to pay for it. Then they get to draw up two cards of their choice at the end of their turn. As players accomplish the goals on these prophecies here, they'll gain points immediately, and then they'll also be moving up this favor track. As you move up the favor track, you can get additional card draws, bonus resources, so on and so forth. The point of moving up the favor track is that when the war phase starts, first you see that the Excalibur sword and artifact will be assigned to the player who is furthest ahead on the favor track here. This favor will then reset. And then the next step is that the Green Knight, this noble warrior, will help whichever player has the fewest victory points. And therefore, the purple player gets to place them out into a region. Then we go into battles.
Finally, it's time to resolve all of the battles region by a region around the clockwise of the outside area. You'll resolve those battles, then you'll go to the inner circle, resolve those clockwise, and then finally the central space of Avalon. In each battle, players who are in the area are going to then add up their starting strength. Blue has 1 2 3 units in there with one strength each. However, this champion is holding this artifact, so they get an extra strength. So, they all start at four. Purple has four units here and no artifact, so they'll add four. And now players are going to play a battle plan card. So, this battle plan card allows me to add up to five more strength to my starting strength uh via a little push-your-luck mechanism. You can also boost that limit by playing any number of other cards behind it. So, I'm going to do this. I'm going to go up to eight strength, but I'm spending most of my cards. These are cards that are going to have to last all of the battles for the rest of the round. After I do after I commit and the other player has also committed, we'll reveal our battle plan card and our limit number. So, this player over here has a limit of six. I have a limit of eight. I'm going to be going and drawing cards here. Now, this is another use for the top value. As I draw cards, this is how much power I'm going to add to my battle so long as I do not bust. So, I've drawn a three, I've drawn a two, I'm at five out of the eight. I'm going to draw one more, and I have hit eight exactly. So, I'm going to choose to stop. Even if I busted, I don't reveal
that I've busted. I simply say I am going to stop now. The next player is trying to add as much as they can and they can draw from any decks. They draw one, a three, uh three. Oh, so they're at their six. So, they'll reveal and I'll reveal. And since I added more strength to my combat, I will be the winner of uh of this area. Now, if you bust, you don't get to add that strength and you do not get to uh carry out the effects of your battle plan card. Since I did win, mine says if you win, uh you will gain one favor or three points. So, I choose my reward. Some of these have different effects including being able to move units around to other parts of the map. Tons and tons of different effects. The winner is going to get the full amount of victory points for the current season of the game. The second place player is going to get half points. And the winner, if there's an artifact in that region, will gain that artifact and add it to a champion there, a lord there. Uh and then you're going to go around to each of the different areas resolving combats the exact same way. When you reach the end of the round, players discard everything they have in their hand, set up again starting at the mist phase. And once players are done with that, the player with the most points is the winner of Avalon.
So, I have mixed feelings about the components. Uh uh They're gorgeous. The art is unbelievable. The The miniatures look fantastic. Graphic design, pretty good. Pretty good. Now, this is the the copy that was sent to us. I think this is one of the deluxe versus the only mostly fancy version. Like the the foiling art on the cards and the overview, I should have mentioned at the beginning, that's I don't think that's what the standard looks like. That is distracting, uh but I I don't think that's going to be for every copy.
But mostly for me, I thought the rulebook just wasn't that clear. Especially because it is ABCD thing that you're mentioning. Give me all the rules for the game, then tell me your changes later on. And the asymmetrical stuff wasn't explained very thoroughly, and I think it should have been.
There's a lot of asymmetry. I mean, one faction just has you know, you can get Percival and like that. It's cool, you can get the Knights of the Round Table out there. That's very different from having a Kraken and all that stuff. So, yeah, it's uh it's admirable. It's quite impressive, but I just kind of want the best game and then yeah, like modular rules at the end sort of a thing.
So, go into this also knowing it's going to be it's just a bit of a bear to learn. When we first played it way back years ago on the channel, uh they came in and taught it to us, and it was not too difficult to understand, and I think that would help too. Um but if you're all learning together, it can be a bit of a chore. The game fits in that um area of these area control fighting games where you can also get monsters that Eric Lang is known for. Blood Rage and Rising Sun. It's in that um bucket, I think, but it is more complex in my opinion than those games.
The action driver of this game is yeah, it's it's cards. Every single card in the game is unique and does really cool, fantastic things. You want all of them. You're going to play three a round.
Right.
And so, you really have to sit there and make those choices. You I love paying for cards with other cards when it's all pretty uh understandable. This game straddles that line of I kind of want to understand every card cuz I'm throwing away possible actions to pay for this action, and that can have a lot of repercussions. I think it it stays on the positive side of that for me because at the end of the each round you get to drop two new cards. And I love being able to draw at the end of every turn. I love being able to drop and say like, you know what? I have my next action set. I'm just going to draw some battle plans and prepare for that part or I need to deploy. I'm going to drop two deploy cards and one of the two of them is going to do something interesting.
And on that note, I like the discounts on cards if you do this or if this is in play or whatever. And I find that to be a fun thing to do even if sometimes I might play poorly because I'm like, well, I'm playing this card for a cheaper price somehow some way.
It's more text. It's more, you know, teach up front and all that stuff. But I I do find that very satisfying that I can look at a three cost card and say, well, I know it's got to be good. And I'll save it for the last round cuz it's discounted then. I know it's slightly disadvantageous, but it opens me up to do this now. I think the cards driving this game are incredibly fun.
You know how we talk about some games are multiplayer solitaire? This is not even remotely. Everything is a fight from get from bidding for the monsters when they show up. I want every monster in the game to fighting over the different areas. Um, and you can't win everything. Obviously, you're going to sometimes you look and go like, I can't win it, but you never know. And so because of that the battle phase is almost half the game.
It really is.
but it's a lot of battling.
Yeah, because every area is going to fire off all in one kind of quick succession. I think that serves this game better cuz I kind of waffled back and forth like would it be better if you just triggered battles in the middle of the game? I think it's better just kind of resolve it through because you it leads to that hand management joy and that tension of like I prepped a bunch of battle cards. Ooh, things changed. I'm going to use this battle card instead. But yeah, it is a good chunk of the round. Like, oh, cool. We're done with round one.
[sighs]
Woo.
If you don't like the battles, then I don't think you would like the game because again, it takes so much time. And I find myself when I get to the last battle, I'm like, "Okay." Cuz you really have to keep an eye on what battles are left. Do I need to save this card for a different battle? Will the results of this battle change another battle? And And that's all interesting. The battles are very procedural. There's not a like, "Oh, throwing dice." So, what they added here is that push your luck aspect, which I think is really cool, but also a confusing rule.
This is So, the cards are quite multi-use cuz you can pay them for the you know, for other cards and this and that and the other. You can discount them if you spend a particular type for discounting that one. And then in the battle phase, if it's not your main battle plan, it's just a plus one to your limit. And people keep asking questions like, "Okay, the number in the top left." Disregard it.
Yes, that's tricky.
It's clunky, but really fun. So, I'm kind of torn in two different directions. I love the hand management. And I I don't know Do you like the the drawing extra cards, that push your luck part of it?
I like it mostly. Um it doesn't The The problem is the push your luck often doesn't matter. Like, I've won this battle. You could push your luck a lot, mhm, but I probably won. And so when it But when it matters, it's exciting. I just I have yet to play a game of this where it felt smooth. And that's where Push Your Luck to me it should always be a smooth thing. I want to I'm going to do this. I'm going to do that. And In fact, this company, their last game, Oathsworn, had a wonderfully fun push your luck aspect to it.
And Oathsworn's not a buttery smooth game per se.
not. But you just basically You roll as many dice as you want, but if you get You get too many misses, you're you're you're toast. So, you don't want to roll that many. But I do cuz you never know.
Cuz you want to get a big splash hit. Yeah, I I don't find it that clunky. I think the the drawing cards part to bust or not is the smoothest part of the whole procedurality to get there.
deck is all I wish.
Maybe that, cuz it it leads to people sitting there like, I'm going to draw a hmm yellow card. It doesn't matter.
I agree and I and I had this argument at the table. They're like, well, if you know that several of the fours have come out of yellow, I'm like, NO ONE KNOWS THAT INFORMATION. THERE'S SO MANY CARDS. NO ONE IS KEEPING track of what deck the big cards have come out of. Just it should just be one of the decks. I always drew red. Just straight up. Period.
It's yeah. Uh but
I do really like the push your luck system. I find it tremendously fun. And yes, there are plenty of battles where we played out the battle plan cards. We looked at how much starting strength we had and we said, all right, well, you know, he's got it, right? But at that point, I'm glad that the battle card that I played has a really funky effect on it. I get to move one of my champions from one region to another and that throws off everyone else's calculations because now I got more strength in the center circle and that's going to help me with this battle plan I played later. It's a lot of feeling clever and not a lot of feeling dumb, which I'm surprised about.
Now, I will say that the game has a weird length issue to me for me because you can play two or three rounds. And two rounds is by far what I would prefer to play because it feels that that length of game Once you know you're doing it's probably an hour a round, right? So two two hours.
Feels about right. However,
The problem is I want that third round because you're getting stuff at I got this monster. I've used it once. I want to use it twice. Um I I got the catch-up mechanism of the green knight. Doesn't matter. You know, I I would like to There's things I would like to use more often or or or build upon myself. So, three feels like the right length, but it's also too long. I wish there was a way almost to to prelude this to skip that first round.
I agree. Start with some artifacts. You everyone has an artifact or beast or whatever it may be. I agree time length and the amount of mental load of playing two seasons, two whole rounds of this game feels right, but I want the effects of things and the benefits of things for longer.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's so hard. I'm kind of torn in multiple directions. I think the game is a little overproduced in some ways, a little less clear, but then also I find myself understanding every card very smoothly by the end of you know, by the end of like halfway through the first game. And so yeah, it feels overwhelming in some ways and then it's actually smooth in others and it is procedural and clunky in some ways, but exciting at the same time. So, it's it's a game I'm a bit torn in different directions on.
I agree and that's that's where I I I come down in the final review of this is how do I how do I balance those things? For me it's a seven. I enjoy the game, but I do wonder if I'd rather just play Blood Rage or a game that I can get out quicker. The asymmetrical part of this game is so neat, but it adds so much extra stuff and extra setup and it just isn't smooth. The symmetrical game doesn't isn't even bad because the monsters immediately change it to asymmetrical.
Yes.
on a different mind and the cards you have are different. So, I'm not even sure that asymmetrical stuff is needed, but I want to do it so badly cuz it you have this cool piece I can't use. I want to use the Kraken. You know, I have this miniature for it. So, I'll play this with prep. I would prefer to play it with people who've already played it before, which can't always happen obviously. Um I wish it was a smoother experience, but I do know that some of the people I played it with it will become a 10 for them and other people I played it with will never touch it again. It's very divisive in that regard.
Yeah, I I agree with the same same kind of takeaway. Actually, most of the people I played it with immediate we're looking at you know how much it cost online.
Because it is so fun. It is very different from other area control games. I'm giving this one a 7.5. I I like it. This is one I'd like to turn to, but I don't love teaching, and that onboarding process is a lot. I don't know that I'll have ever get this teach down to a nice quick onboarding.
Sure.
And that's fine. Once you said settle in with a group of people who are going to like this, I think there's so much to dig into even playing on the easiest of all of the settings. I think that the catch-up mechanism, you know, you can play with or without it. I like I like all those little things. I like that there's, you know, little pre-printed things around the victory point track. I didn't talk about it in the overview, right? If someone's really far ahead and you take this benefit here, you catch up a few points. That matters some games a lot. And then getting the Green Knight and being able to deploy him into battle, it does a lot of impressive things. Sometimes clunky, sometimes to its own detriment, but man is it unique. Man, do I love the hand management, and man, are there some really cool surprising moments that happen in the battles. So, I'm recommending it. So, 7.5.
Well, there you go, folks. That is Avalon. Uh definitely going to go in our library because I know people want to play this badly. And uh yeah, it's it's it's epic, and that's what you're kind of looking for in a game like this. I'm Tom.
I'm Chris.
We'll see you next time.
In Riverdale.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dicebreaker YouTube channel.