Is GREAT WESTERN TRAIL New Zealand WORTH IT?
Transcript
do you want to see sheep sheep sheep sheep and more sheep wait what's the plural of sheep is it Great Western Trail New Zealand I think that's the plural for the game the Great Western Trail it's the same thing isn't it Great Western Trail is probably one of my top five favorite Euro games of all time when they announced a Trilogy based on the original game I was super excited to see what twists and turns they could inject into the original formula of the game and in this video we're going to be looking at 10 things you need to know about Great Western Trail New Zealand there are some good things some things on the borderline and some things that definitely could still be improved on and don't forget to stay to the end of the video as I rank all three Great Western Trail games in the trilogy hi my name's Danny I'm an avid modern board gamer from Australia who love sharing my passion for this hobby with you my friends and my family come and join me on this journey let's go so can I trade you two wheat for three wool um I think that's a different game how about two Settlers of Katan games for three Great Western Trail games sounds like a deal right now before we get into the first thing you should know there's something you should know before the thing that you should know Great Western Trail New Zealand as you can see behind me is a really long long long long board game that takes up a lot of table space this that you see here is really literally a
two-player game and it takes up my whole dining table area including this extension bit that I added out hey Danny I'm looking for a place to rent do you have any space at your place uh sure are you okay well I've got an unfinished game of Great Western Trail New Zealand at my place setup and there's literally nowhere to sleep the first thing that you should know about this game is that now you can she the sheep from your hands each sheep breed has got a wool value that's listed on the card some sheep have a lower strength value but a higher wool value some of them have a low wool value but a higher strength value now shearing your sheep is really important because you need to use the building location that allows you to do so and you can Shear one species of sheep per Shear that you have in your worker row so if you got two different if you got two shearers then you can Shear two different breeds of sheep this provides for a gamechanging opportunity where halfway down the track you can actually dump some of the cards from your hand to gain coin and also move your disc over to one of the wall stations that are at the end of the track or on the Seaboard and that provides for a dual way of thinking no longer are you waiting to get to Wellington to cash everything in you can cash your sheep in twice getting double value out of your single trk across the trail I love this idea that you can gain extra income halfway along the trail it also means that when you're looking through your hand of cards you're thinking which ones am I going to save forward Wellington and which ones am I
going to actually drop off here now and so you're really torn between uh saving the value for the end of the trail and keeping that card in your hand or using that value now and getting rid of it so you can access further cards in your deck New Zealand's located in the southern hemisphere shouldn't be called the Great Southern Trail the second thing that you need to know is that gold is a very valuable resource in this game you can access Gold by landing on certain building spaces accessing parts of the finer track and getting bonus tiles gold is really quite useful because it allows you to access four of the modular cards that are picked at the beginning of the game out of the 10 cards that are available that you can then acquire into your deck each of the four cards are graded based on their power the first two cards are worth three gold the third card is worth four gold and the compass card is worth 5 gold and by paying your goal to add these cards into your deck allows you to explore new synergies new Pathways to Victory and new abilities that changes from game to game and some of the cards even kind of play off each other I know in the games that I've played we've used the ship card which allows you to place a storehouse either three spaces ahead of your ship or three spaces behind that added flexibility of being a to place those storehouses out means that when you get to Wellington you have those particular spaces on the board already set up for you to be able to sell your cattle and then place your discs there I really like the fact that you can add new species sheep which have extra
different values of wool and strength values as well as different Victory Point values and there's even ones where you could build buildings for free that are one higher than existing buildings that you've got on your playboard so for the third thing that you need to know kind of squeeze three different things into one point is the fact that the train track has been removed that existed in the first two games uh the train track really served as a way for making things cheaper for you as well as um forcing you to kind of spend a a little bit of your extra money in the form of Transport costs but now those transport costs have been translated into the cost of putting your storehouses in certain locations the second change is the fact that this whole Market grid has been split in two you've got a section where you've got workers which become cheaper the more of them there are and then you got this section which has the bonus tiles which kind of influences the ticket timer effect for the game the Third change is that predominantly a lot of the base objective cards have a base Victory point value of three now so it doesn't matter which kind of combination of cards that you get you're going to be able to score three points if you can satisfy every objective card that you own the fourth thing that you should know is that this shipboard provides players with a multitude of new opportunities that invites for some long-term planning so whilst players are kind of juggling the immediate actions of the main board players need to be thinking ahead about how they actually going to push their ship along so that they have access to all the places that they want to get to because there's no
point getting to Wellington dumping your sheep and then not being able to place a disc out kind of puts you in a really tough situation I like the fact that there's actual three different Pathways you can take this one at the top kind of gives you access to these wool um Harbors then you've got this one in the middle that kind of gives you access to both and then this bottom track kind of gives you access to more of the normal Harbors each of these kind of locations where you place a storehouse um your going to have to pay a fee to place it on there but it means that later you'll be able to also access bonuses that these little Harbors uh give you so this small Harbor gives you a bell card for free and four victory points at the end of the game this particular um Big Harbor is going to give you a value three Romney sheet and 10 victory points at the end of the game if you can actually deliver there and you know spend that wool value I like how there's a lot of forward thinking but the bonuses that you get along the way are far more interesting this part of the game really took inspiration from the rails to North expansion that was something you could get for the original base game but I love this reimplemented version here the fifth thing that you should know is that there is a new Pathfinder track represented by this king fisher bird the idea of this Pathfinder track is that at the beginning of the game you get to offload one of your discs from a white space on your board unlocking one of the extra abilities that you have and the fact that you get to choose which disc right from the very gate go means that you're already know what kind of Avenue you might lean in towards now when you
extend the Pathfinder track there are a couple of things that are locked away in this juicy track first of all there's gold there's lots of victory points especially if you get to the very top of the track but most importantly this is where you unlock the extra movement this is the only or one of the only ways you can actually get plus one or plus two movement to increase the speed of your cowboy As you move along the trail the other thing that you can do on this track is you can choose to cancel all of those fees that you pay when you cross the hazard tiles having that ability to decide you know what I don't have to pay fees for the rest of the game means that if you have buildings that are on that Hazard section of the track all of a sudden you don't have to worry about that anymore which is a really good incentive for investing in that pathway the Sixth Element that you need to know is in regards to the buildings themselves four of the general buildings in the game are going to flip over about halfway through so at the beginning of the game four of the buildings are going to be on the number one side which gives you the ability to take um objective cards or move up the Pathfinder track or move your boat you've even got cards at aat cash your wool in for money or acquire bonuses or remove hazards or gain extra gold the actions on the number one side of those four buildings are actually quite positive and beneficial and quite plentiful which will really get your game kind of moving along but as soon as you clock over into the second half of the game where those
four buildings turn over all of a sudden now you can access more bonus tiles you can use a double auxiliary action and then your ability to move your ship comes down to the number of sailors that you've got if you really want to power through with that strategy I love the fact that these dual s of buildings are becoming a lot more functional the idea that you're not going to have these static uh buildings for each and every game but these buildings are going to flip over and you're going to actually have to adjust some of the actions that you're using cuz I found that through a lot of the Great Western Trail games you're often using a same a similar sort of combo Synergy where you you can kind of get into a pattern of using those same synergies a lot but this changes the dynamic of the pathways a little bit more and the sort of things that you can extract out of the action tiles from a Cool Change in this game is the fact that this worker board is slightly reduced in its length but also you have access to a wild worker which essentially functions as any of the four worker types normally you've got the shepherd which kind of allows you to purchase a sheep for a cheaper cost you've got Builders who kind of help you build buildings um more uh easily and then you've got the sailor who allows you to move further and move more quickly across the Seaboard and you've got shearers who help you to Shear a greater number of breed of sheep by having this wild worker you can kind of use them in areas where maybe a particular worker might be non-existent
on this Market board and having that extra flexibility means that all of a sudden this whole section of your player board becomes a whole lot more interesting a whole lot more easier to fill up and access especially when it comes to the bonuses and activating them and then when you can kind of pull these off when you place them to get certificate tiles which are kind of these like endgame scoring and immediate bonus tiles you can then reuse them later on when you acquire another one to fill up those spaces again and get the bonus again there's a whole lot of flipping and moving those workers around that makes the game feel really Dynamic number eight is a very small tweak to the game but it adds some extra openness to what you can do with your deck originally a lot of these uh times two tokens allowed you to just get a card from the deck and then discard a card and do it twice now the fact that you can join two of these tokens together to be able to get a gold as well as remove a level one shopshire sheep from your deck entirely from the game makes this a whole lot more valuable and a whole lot more powerful you can either use it to churn through your deck or you can use it to um help you get gold which you can then spend to acquire new cards into your deck I just love this small change because it just gives you that added element of yeah if I really want to access those high power uh breeds in my deck this is the way I could try and do it number nine is all about how the new modular cards work I
really love these new action cards this uh Pathfinder Card means that when you draw this card in your hand and you play it on your turn you get to move up one space on the Pathfinder track but then you get to immediately discard this card and draw a card to replace it that is such a powerful thing to be able to do often when you're playing a lot of deck building games the cards that you have fill up your hand by having a lot of these cards in your deck means that every time you draw two or three of them and get them into your hand you can kind of chain them together and create like a chain reaction where you you know increase your value up the Pathfinder track that maybe gain $2 or even increase your certificate value number 10 is all about the design of the main trail board there are a couple of different changes here first of all there's some spaces that have ability next to them and these spaces that have abilities that Nets you extra gold or extra uh actions that you can do are often placed either before a hazard or after a hazard so by building there whilst it seems a little bit more risky if you can access that ability that's going to give you a little bit more opportunity to uh manipulate your deck a little bit easier in the game but it does come with some level of risk the other thing is that there's a lot of spaces on the board that have this Pathfinder symbol on it which means that you cannot build in that space unless your marker is at least at that numerical level on the Pathfinder track so that means some spaces tend to be
locked uh at the beginning of the game but then open up towards the end of the game as you enhance your level here the third thing I'll mention is that I really like the sequencing that occurs with the building tiles connecting the tiles in a particular order means that you can get a lot of value out of them for example this movement tole which allows you to use a double auxiliary action get the double auxiliary reaction when I land on it the fact that I move to the next tile means that I'll also get the benefit of that and then getting the cash from that tile can be spent at the following to which allows me to buy all the Sheep at the Sheep Market before we go on in this video I really want to talk about something for a minute and the fact is that I am so proud to be an Australian and we always often think of our New Zealand friends as being literally part of the same country and as our closest neighbors it's so good to see some New Zealand representation in the board gaming world when this game got announced I think my heart truly fluted because I was like oh my goodness usually New Zealand is forgotten of big maps and if you've ever played pandemic you'll know what I mean when you look at the world map that New Zealand doesn't even exist on that pandemic map now when it comes to some of the things I think that need to be improved I think they've really strengthened a lot of the cool key mechanics from the original game but I feel like there could have been more opportunity to to be able to Cull and thin your deck I did feel like in the game that I kept at certain points drawing a lot of those uh breed value one shopshire sheep at the wrong time
and so it was often short by one or two cards uh in terms of being able to uh transport my sheep to certain ports but I feel like that's a very minor thing in terms of the big overall Improvement to the game play itself other thing I'll highlight is that if you haven't played Great Western Trail a lot uh it is a very point salady game and point salad does not mean shallow it just means there's a lot of different ways to get points and so you kind of have to lean into like two or three different ways to be able to do well and I think for some people who like to kind of go deep into one particular Avenue uh they often don't feel like point sality games are kind of their thing and so I think that's something that you should know is that if you didn't really like the original Great Western Trail and you didn't like the point Point sality nature of it this game increases that points sality Nature by like an extra like 25% what do I think of the three Great Western Trail games and what order would I say is my preference based on how good and how enjoyable all three games are well I definitely have a couple of my favorites um I'll try and just quick give a quick summary of each game couple of highlight points and then kind of give my uh assessment on it so with the original game I just love the Simplicity of placing out those building tiles uh really trying to get your deck to be as distilled as possible and getting that really great income at Kansas City I also like the fact that you can move your train forward to try
and um pay less transport tax but also access some of those higher end cities and then connecting those cities together giving uh you points created really interesting Synergy in the game with Great Western Trail Argentina I really like the fact that they introduced the idea that the cards have multile functionality you can even um use wheat as a resource and then also use the multi-uses to the actual worker tiles themselves which is really really powerful RIT really interesting because the strength of the worker help you to do extra things and gave you more options a big change to the board itself was the fact that as you moved uh your train down the track it would provide you with early exit points with which kind of allowed you to skip this you know the back end of the tra meaning that you could control the tempo and the speed at which you exit the trail uh whether you wanted to keep progressing along and use actions uh further down the track or whether you want to just quickly cash all of your cattle in I really like the fact that you had a little bit more control over how fast the game progressed then you had these uh ships where you wanted to really load your cattle onto these ships in time because it was like a timing element where they all kind of like left at different points in the game and then you'd want to offload Lo them at the three City boards which I did find to be a little bit lackluster when I did play it felt very mathematical felt like a count keeping didn't really kind of feel very thematic that whole sense of putting a disc on a ship and then
sending that ship to a city and that City offloading that disc and putting on another place getting all these random points so in saying that with Great Western Trail New Zealand I feel like the focus was a lot more on the deck building the idea that the Seaboard had a lot of Pathways to choose from which I really really enjoyed and uh The Duality function of the cards was still retained I think in terms of overall enjoyment of the game and Design Elements I think Great Western Trail Argentina really sits at third place for me I think on my initial couple of plays of Great Western Argentina I really love the freshness and the dynamic changes I really like the use of the workers and the strength of your cards uh that really gave me an interesting um area to think about when it came to deciding how is going to work uh my game and my cattle uh but ultimately I feel like the shipping mechanism in that game uh is a little bit not very interesting enough for me uh and whilst I do like the train element uh I think that really provided for some interesting twist to the game that we already knew coming in second place is the original Great Western Trail uh this is the game that really made me fall in love with it I have the first and second edition and I just really love the Simplicity of what it does putting buildings in order making the trail longer as you cycled around the focus of just building your deck and cing your deck as you go there was just
so many great options uh tied into such a neat package and I just really loved and whenever I actually teach this game I always go to the original first before trying to teach either Argentina or New Zealand and it's just one of those games where I just know know feels grounded and I know that you still have so many great thinky laid options to the game play and then with Great Western Trail New Zealand that is definitely my number one I definitely describe it as the next level Great Western Trail game Great Western Trail 2.0 it does a lot of the things that the base game does but it strengthens and broadens the different choices in each of the areas down to the deck building the way you use wild and Joker workers and the bonus tiles the way that you um pick the CS that you choose to travel along the Seaboard and place your storehouses the way that you can really refine and have a lot of control over your deck and then also uh integrating the fact that you can sell your sheep for their wool value means that you can kind of cash those uh sheep in a lot earlier making the game far more uh controllable in terms of what you want to do with your deck but also the tempo of how fast you go through things and where you actually get your money from so what did you think of great Western Trail New Zealand is this a game that piques your interest are you a fan of the original game or is this the first time you've ever heard about Great Western Trail share your stories your thoughts your opinions your beliefs and your experiences in the comment section below now if you found this video super helpful please consider
liking this video subscribing to my channel and if you want more Sayan influence over the sorts of videos I make please head over to my patreon page and support me there I really appreciate all the people currently supporting me and uh continually watch my videos it brings me so much Joy now if you really want to find out more about board gaming head over to my main page there's a board game video for everyone otherwise this is Daddy signing out I hope your next board game is a fun one see you
soon