Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hostage Negotiator: Discussion

Transcript 26:22

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30 day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to the discussion for hostage negotiator crime wave and career uh i just finished doing a two-parter to a whole career of uh of of you know the career game where you know going from year zero to year ten and i gotta say this game is so much fun uh like everything about it the career thing the the variety um the gameplay the theming oh man it is it is a blast uh but that isn't to say that it's perfect uh because it's not so uh i i'll go over a few of the um negatives that i have with uh with the game before talking about all the positives so initially when i when i got this game um i remember seeing it like years ago when the base game came out and at the time i was like no that's not for me um and so that just goes to show how how much i've changed as a gamer um but there's one major complaint that i that i kind of i it's not that big of a deal but at times it can be very frustrating so whenever you are doing

a um like a negotiation like whenever you're just doing a regular whatever pick your guy and then go through go through the cards um there could be times where and they mentioned in the rulebook that the dice feel like they decide how how well you do and that is um and like even in the rules it's like now that's not true it depends on how how you play your cards and things like that that is for the most part the case where it's like it sometimes is you know what like what cards you play and like okay well this one is uh can be super critical but if i fail it's not gonna be the worst thing or if i only get one success it's not going to be the worst thing uh but there are i mean the game does rely on dice unfortunately so no matter really i mean you obviously want two successes that's going to be the best so but you have a two you have a you have a one in three chance of getting a success um and for the most part you are going to be rolling two dice because the how many dice you roll depends on the temperament of the uh the actual abductor which i think is really cool i i like that thematic a lot like if it's if they're very much on saving people or on one stress level then uh you're rolling the more dice because that just means that your your cards are working for them like what you're saying and what you're trying to go for is uh it is resonating within them

but you know if they're still wavering you know they abducted people then you're gonna roll two which means that they're either or but then they get uh the highest possible which i really like that a six and a k isn't one die it's really they just have to be on k um and you roll one which means they're not even listening to you anymore i really really like that but that doesn't go that doesn't mean that like the dice are all fun and games the the difficulty of each abductor is going to still be dependent on the way the dice go um so that that i mean it is it is thematic and i and i get that like i i do but like it's still from a game perspective when you're like okay man i really need this card to go off like and then you roll no successes you're just like great another blank um and then that can just kind of be frustrating uh or if it's because it's not even like i mean the five and six are successes a four you can get rid of two cards to turn it into a success so you have kind of a 50 50 chance of getting but like you you also have to decide okay well to make it the 50 50 chance am i willing to go with the two cards to to help that and you might you never know uh i will say i still like the fact that you that you do have some hand management to be able to get rid of two cards to be able to um uh to at least have a better odd

in that so like i said the dice can be extremely frustrating and if and if you're succeeding or doing well then uh then that's because the dice are going in your favor if you're doing poorly and the hostages are being killed left and right um then you're like it's it could mainly be because of the dice are you rolling blanks and there's nothing really you can do about that so that's the major complaint um the other complaint is gonna be and it's gonna kind of tie into the career uh expansion more than anything and i gotta say the career finale was really lame like and it's really frustrating because everything else about the career i loved i thought that the the years because there's a lot there's a lot in here uh for in terms of like cards so you have your year zero so you pick one of those in year one there's there's so there's like five total one two three four yeah so there's five of each year um so 50 cards you have or 55 because of the year zero uh and so so you're going to get a different combination of how your career goes each time you play not only going over how many you know all the personal cards that are going to come in so i really like the theming of the career it's so much fun very uh what's the word

like invocative where you are very much like trying to role play and be into this kind of job as a cop um and then also the fact that stressors can come in depending on decisions that you make i love the fact that you have decisions with each one of these every single one of these you're making a decision and you don't know they did that whatever i can't remember what that's called where you have the the red thing to see through it i love that because it prevents you from trying to like peripheral read two options or even read two options and be like okay well which one sounds better you just have to make a decision and go from there um so i love that the stressors can come in i love how even every career a hostage um thing might not happen and this is a perfect example of how you do a a campaign where you play the same game over and over now this game has a bunch of variety with it and grant i have everything but with the abductor packs with the crime wave and with the the base game you have a bunch of variety with your abductors i mean there's i went through one two three four five six seven eight nine 10 11 12 13.

i think that's yeah there's 13 total i believe we'll go with that for now uh or 14 whatever there's all at least at least 14 um and in in a game because there's multiple campaign games excuse me where really the campaign is you just play the same game over and over and over and you just collect ever you just add up victory points at the end whoever has the highest wins um or there's like a faux legacy where it's like okay well in ch at the end of uh you know episode one then do this or this and then it slightly negates the the different games um so this one i was always excited for each year because i didn't know what was going to happen in the career i didn't know if i was gonna have to fight someone uh fight someone i didn't know if i was gonna have to negotiate with someone who i was negotiating with how that was gonna go if you succeed or fail because you have to mark on you know what you do for uh for you know how well you do for each of these and then uh and then you also have the personal thing at the very end so it brings in something you know into your role-playing life uh that's that's the perfect example so so i did it's about it was like a total of eight hours of part one and part two not eight what four four hours um for part one and part two

and that was a blast that was four hours where i was like wow that time flew by because i had no problem just being like okay going on to the next year i thought it was this was going to be like a a 10 part series where i had to do one whole year because each year is going to be this card then this hostage and then nope it just zooms by super quick uh but with all that being said the finale spoilers i guess is you just read a deck of 10 cards and that's that's extremely disappointing not that the 10 cards weren't interesting because they very much were but in a game where all your other cards all your career cards there's five of those and you pick one from each you essentially remove the variety of the uh of the ten cards that are here you go you will go through all well i guess you technically might not depending on how well your merit or your stress does you can remove dice if you don't go up in merit then you start with less dice and then if those get removed then it goes just to one of three different endings um but i don't know i'm just really disappointed i wish it was a final final showdown with with sicko instead of it being like okay well he shows up in your house and he and he does this mind game with you because he likes to tour with you i mean he's really a rip off of the joker all that's fine i like that part i like the theme of this i just didn't like how i'm sitting here just reading 10 cards because one it

works out because i'm doing i did it for a series i recorded it but imagine just sitting at it like sitting by yourself because it's only a solo game and reading it and then you're like okay i'll choose this okay okay okay and you do that until 10 cards and eventually it's just like okay well there's no more finale cards go to ending b and then once you do that then you already know what ending b is so i know what one option of ending b is um it was just very very anticlimactic it could have been better if they actually did it as a like what they did for the halfway point where it's like okay well now this whole new game of year five where he kidnapped your wife and then you have to do some weird uh negotiation thing with that they could have easily done it for a final showdown um so that's that's basically my biggest complaint was that was that finale that was just kind of uh kind of lame so let's talk about the actual nego a hostess negotiator so one i love the theme i think this is a very very cool theme i love van rider games they uh they they got me hooked with uh the big score and then um then they did detective city of angels which is a phenomenal unique detective game uh then i've done

their crusoe crew that one's a fun cute kids uh escape game and then there's i this one i knew about for a while but i just never went around to get it and it's so fun the uh i i i like the card play i like the variety of how each hostage uh like not not each hostage each abductor is completely different from one another they have their own demands they have their own reason for why they're doing things uh they some of them have their own pivotal events some of them have their own their own tarot cards uh and so you're gonna interact with them and they come in in a relatively different way i mean it all will kind of boil down to um you're trying to save hostages that's that's it uh so it's kind of how you're gonna go about doing that um and what makes what makes the career so fun is there's actual stakes involved in a solo in in just a one-off like okay well i'm gonna go and i'm gonna do edward quinn you know you obviously only have your okay well your your win or lose condition um but in a career you actually have like i said you have weight to it how many people how many people die how many people succeed how well you do in that negotiation will affect your career stress personal stress and and marriage and all that you can get potential stress depending on it it will just affect certain things which i love like it would in real life

um you saved ten you saved nine people but one person dies well you then save nine people you got one person killed that's kind of the mentality um this game can be extremely dark uh and there was one one where it almost was super super dark where the the the cult had put in their kids as a as an abductor and then the card that happened to come out uh was a hostage they tried to escape and if you roll die and it's like okay i failed then it kills them and in that particular situation the the the hostages were the abductors and if if you killed one it was the top one so that basically meant the kids they they killed the kids and that's like what the so you have a bunch of situations like that um but they they do obviously do a disclaimer where it's like hey every all likenesses and situations it's all fictional if there's anything that's similar to something that happened it's purely coincidental and i believe that i think all the the ripoffs of you know career with with oh okay well he's on the cover with joker or something or sicko not joker with sicko it's um uh i mean that's playful because i mean joker's not a real person and i don't even know for a hundred percent if they even took that uh and ran with it but that gives you some some some weight and like i saved um let's see 18 20 31

32 38 uh 50. i saved 50 total people but i lost 10. and even this year 10 wasn't even anything so and that could also be the way that the the the fi the finale happened that could have also also just been because uh of the years 10 because it just says like he's back and then but there's more year 10s in there so that could have just been the scenario so um so i hope that that's the case that the finale of career isn't always hey read through these 10 cards because that would be really lame um so so yeah like this has weight to it i saved 50 people in my in my career run through i became captain i got divorced i think at some point um the card was messed up and i almost virtually had no stress so this was a lot of fun but i lost 10 people so it could be it could be very hard if if for people who don't who can't like disconnect from reality uh or if they're there if if this relates to you in any way then don't play this game because the theme does come out so going back to not in the career if you're just playing you know um crime wave or just the regular base game what you're going to get out of it is what you put into it what i tried to do was try to role play and and do some discussion because reading from the cards they tried they tried to give you at least an idea

of just like with the top saying but and then give you some flavor text uh that can aid you but it's not always gonna like don't play this game kind of like other storytelling games don't just be like okay minor extraction okay one success okay i'm gonna just stay calm okay play that don't do that because you're gonna you're gonna take a lot out of out of what the game is trying to give you what i would suggest is kind of do what i did and i'm not the best storyteller and i'm not i've never dm'd any type of tabletop but try to explain what you're doing try to explain okay well they played this like this tarot card came up um and it's gonna cause this so why are they freaking out like that what and i'm gonna play you know um you know you just need to trust me like because because you're doing this and try and try and make the the theming around it even more give it more flair and more glamour because you don't have the the aid of the career stuff the the personal stuff the stressors the the career cards you don't have all that aiding that add even more theme you just have the game um but i still think the game is is a lot of fun the dice can make it extremely stressful uh we're like okay i need this i need this one to succeed i need so many career conversation points right now to be able to purchase this specific card because i have no way of getting out i have no way of capturing him or killing him but i want to so it's like okay so who okay i'm rolling two dice and

yes okay i got a success and then i have two cards left i'll discard to make that a success that gives me the four that i need or which then in the spend phase i can buy um but the tarot cards are a lot of fun too because then you're like oh okay awesome then they flip one and it's just like it can turn the whole thing on its head where you're like oh no like hey discard a uh discard you know a card that has an extraction on it or things like that and you're like no that's the one card i had that sucks i spent so much time and because there's only ever for the most part 10 tarot cards so you have 10 rounds at least to try and get them before the pivotal event which makes things really chaotic and a lot of fun i love the pace of this game i love how it's just like okay boom you just play as many cards as you feel like playing trying to resolve them in the best way possible then you go to your spend phase you cannot buy the cards that you got that you just played back but you can buy whatever is available um all the tools and and things that you've learned in your career to use to try and help you in uh in this situation and then then it's his turn you just flip a tarot card and it's like boom this is what happens um i love the fact that there are demands that can come in that if you give them the demands they're potentially going to be really good but there's also going to potentially be really bad and i like that i like looking at and be like man should i just give him his

lieutenant back that's going to be a really good ability but uh if i get rid of him then his lieutenant stays and i have to deal with him can i do that uh and each one of them is is different with their own specific demands as well as just there's different terror decks there's different escape demands on how they want to get out different just uh the game just has a bunch of variety and the abductor packs just add more to that so i'm trying to think uh oh the length of the game is uh is really good it says 15 to 30 minutes that's actually about right i feel like each abductor that i went even whenever because whenever there were new ones coming in that i've never played against like they had their own rules but they were super quick to learn it's like okay so this is how these work all right yeah simple enough the game relatively stays the same with a few minor rule changes uh and boom let's go i have my starting six cards and let's just kind of get this get this ball rolling okay well with this guy this is what's happening so i'm gonna try and change up what i'm uh like what cards i'm gonna use this time one thing that it's kind of it's more just annoying uh in in just aesthetics is they have two hostage negotiator like negotiator cards conversation cards two sets they have one with the guy on it and one with the girl on it

uh the problem that i have is not the fact that it's a male or female it's the fact that during the career whenever you would open cards then uh the cards that you were opening had the female on it but i was playing with the male like the male conversation cards it didn't affect the game at all it's just aesthetically i just had a mix and it's like okay that's just kind of weird um i i guess i i would have almost enjoyed if they didn't even have a picture of a male or female on it just had like a different type of thing uh to delineate between the two but that's neither here nor there um yeah like and here's the thing is like i have uh like more things to potentially open there's uh i think there was yep there's career three or c3 envelope so there's that there's uh yep that was the career finale but then there's also these alternate finale cards so there's these two that would probably change things a bit i don't even know how those come in um and then what's also pretty cool is they have these hostas negotiator abductor profiles so you can actually kind of like okay well with um gonzalo herrera for example it tells you the setup changes and everything about them uh in a card so it has rules in here and even a little map that shows you where he's trying to get to uh in the the three different locations

loved the variety of the abductors not not a single one of them felt remotely the same even they didn't even have to do anything to change it just the fact of why they were doing what they were doing made you role play differently me talking to the the instagram influencer or the only fans chick is different than how i'm going to talk to the siever family how i talk to the silver family is going to be different than how i talk to you know whatever the the cult it's just this game is is a lot of fun uh and i think the theming and card play and things like that overshadow the kind of in this particular case the career finale lackluster uh and then also the randomness of the dice because it just the game's so quick anyway that if you if you lose um it's just well you know sometimes and and the career lets you even give a reason to why dice are bad instead of playing just because i did play a uh just a regular game you know just against whatever the terrorist guy arcane uh and i mean it wasn't as fun like the career was still very enveloping and engrossing but it's just like if if you roll blanks you fail on every single thing he kills all the hostages that just gives you more theme to go off of for decisions that you're making and you can be like okay well now i i tried my best and he just wasn't listening he wasn't having it this time and he just

he slaughtered all those people now the decisions i'm gonna make might be different i really really really like that so so yeah there's this game's a lot of fun i can't really think of a whole lot um to uh to say but uh so on a scale of one to ten i think i'm honestly gonna give this a nine because whenever i can play a game because really the career was just phenomenal okay so actually i will say hostage negotiator by itself uh is probably around a seven um like even with the variety that's gonna i mean that that is gonna that's that is gonna uh uh you know be a be a positive because you you're not fighting the same hostage that or the same abductor every time you have different ways different tarot cards that you can throw in different uh demands and escape demands and things like that that's all fine um but ultimately with career it it bumps it up to a nine because it has so much around it that just adds so much theme to it that make the regular game of hostage negotiator have weight to it and so so overall uh a nine because i can't really see i mean i could probably just play a regular game of hostage negotiator and just put in that theme myself um but the career is so so fun and the fact that it took four hours to do ten games um is just is a blast so so yeah that's that's my

thoughts on hostage negotiator career slash base game and i guess crimewave really just added more cards and this storage solution which is really really good um but let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved