Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH Podcast - How Do We Value Games?

Transcript 1:23:47

Hello and welcome to the Cardboard Herald podcast. I am Eric, joined as always by my lovely co-host Jack. No adjective this week. No adjective list. Just lovely. Just like sometimes the X-Men. Okay. Exactly. That's a reference I you know you got uncanny, you got extreme, but within the the fandom, the community, when they were like, "No, dog. This is just X-Men." Then the community would call that the adjective list X-Men. See, I learn something new every day. I I Comics are a side of being a nerd that I just never got around to. And it it and well there was a time I as a kid remember my dad had like a encyclopedia of Batman and it was just like all of the different things like that were in Batman, all the different characters and I read through that like frequently.

That was a constant frame of reference that I used. Uh, and never um never read a Batman comic, just the encyclopedia, which feels more nerdy. Being a little bit older than you, I you know, like there wasn't a pervasive mainstream drip of these flamboyant uh and exciting characters that are really attractive to kids who, you know, want to see these superheroes duke it out and everything. Um, so I couldn't just go to the movies or, you know, have that exposed to me just as part of mainstream culture. And I had to get that either through comic books or through cartoons and that kind of stuff. And the other thing is that I grew up in Alaska where we had this very prominent comic shop, Boss, Cards, Comics, and Games. And it wasn't until I was older that I realized that those things tend to be separate in the rest of the United States. Like you had a sports card store and then you might have a comic shop and then you might have a game shop. And there is a little bit of cross-pollination uh in between all of those. But because those individual niches weren't enough of a market to really stand on their own, Boscos in Anchorage and Eagle River, uh, which was one of my first jobs working at Boss in Eagle River, kind of cornered whatever niche nerd market it could when

anime was a big thing. They had tons of anime. They had models. They had fantasy books. You know, like the first time I encountered Game of Thrones as a paperback novel was at Boss, but they also had comics, Magic cards, Legend of the Five Rings, Katan, they had all that stuff. So, like because of where I grew up, gaming as well as sports cards and comics were all kind of part of the same, well, I guess I'm a dork and this is where I go now culture. some crazy things are happening with the lighting on your screen. Yeah, I realized that my camera was wildly underexposed. Uh, and so I was changing it and I was worried you were getting raptured. I mean, we're getting close to Easter, so I didn't know exactly what was happening. And that's fair. And you should be constantly worried about me in particular being raptured. Yeah, it'll be um I So what you've been playing adjectiveless, Eric? No, I have adjectives. You're the one without adjectives. Um, okay. I got adjectives got my hands on recently. Um, two games that were just announced today, um, that we are doing a review on, which is Gingham and Gazebo. Um, both from Bitewing Games. They're just two, um, like super I'm sorry. Did you just say Gazebo? Is it Gazebo? Okay. All right.

I'm going to allow it. Let's go on. I actually What's Bitewing got in store for us? So, is this a hegemony situation? No, no, no. Let's let it ride. Let's let it ride. It's It's certainly pronounced gazebo, but I just find the fact that you in some you No. Gazebo is fun. Gazebo is more fun to say and therefore I'm going to say it in a similar way to zebra. Okay. Um Okay. And I've I think I'm going to have a skit at the beginning of a review, which is generally a good sign for games. Generally, if you or I put a skit in the front of a review, it means that we have liked the game enough to come up with a silly little skit for it. And I that's been true so far. Um there Gazebo and Gingham are two lighterw weight uh games that are uh I think the big thing is they're hyper portable. Um kind of feels like the big um marketing technique with them. Um they have like little uh cases that you have a carabiner that you can strap on and they all fit in a very portable uh container. their maps or cloth maps.

Um, and but both them are just really simple rule complex strategy I think is kind of the best way of putting it where there's um it's both of them have a lot of when you're starting out you don't know what the best move is but after you've played a couple times they feel very uh like oh you can be really smart. Like this game lets you be really smart and if you pull off a really cool move, you can you can win off of that one really cool move if you can get it to a line, right? Um, gingham is a tile layer. It's it's ants that are the tiles, but you place them around trying to connect different suites together in orthogonal uh connections, and you score points based on how long the distance is between the two stacks uh via your ants. And then also a uh like almost area control where you're trying to control the stacks that you create to make them the biggest possible stack that you're in control of. Um and it has a really interesting action selection or sorry not there is also an action selection but turn order selection mechanic where

it they're both visually really striking. Um And there's a with with the ant game that's Gum is gingum. You said there's a turn order selection thing. Is that what's going on with this like brown chocolate bar? Uh so that is a action selection that is you can get bonus actions through that. um where it just lets you do things that you normally wouldn't be able to do, which is either like placing in the same row as yourself or an opponent, placing across the stitch, which on on the map, it's like an an 8 by8 grid for single or two player, uh and a 10 x 10 grid for three or four player. And there's just a line drawn diagonally through the middle. and you can only play on the half of the board that you start playing on. Um, and so for that, it's like there are two sides of the board that and there's a diagonal in the middle. If you choose closer to where there's like fewer spaces, you'll go sooner in the next round. So, if you give yourself fewer options this turn by playing really close to uh one of the edges of the stitch, uh you'll be able to take your turn sooner next time around. Um which leads to like really interesting choices that you have to make. I don't know. I've been loving

that one. That's the one that I've played more of. Um, gazebo is also tile laning laying with like domino style pieces where you're trying to connect larger and larger areas. That one is definitely more area control and less like an orthagonal puzzle type thing. Um, and that one is designed by Rhino Kitia. Um, yeah. Yeah. How the tiles look and the fact that you're describing it as area control, I wonder if it's almost got some resonance of Tigris and Euphrates. Um, certainly as the pedigree and the the tile laying look to it. Uh, it's really cool. Yeah. And, uh, we're going to have Nick Murray as a guest, or rather you're going to have him on as a guest here soon. Nick Murray is the owner of Bitewing. Um, and while you were going to talk to him kind of about the logistics of managing Kickstarters uh amid the the turmoil, um, might be worth just asking him about the continued relationship with Reinaritia because I'm I'm still fascinated that that he's managed this kind of lock in with such a uh well-known uh and respected designer in the biz though I guess Kitio puts out like 17 games a week so you know he's working with all kinds of people but um a lot of his new stuff seems to be coming out in the US through

bitewing um so it's an interesting relationship for sure yeah totally yeah I think that it's um it's going to be a good chat and I think that people should start sending in questions in the comments or via emails Um or we'll probably put a post up here at some point or another. Um that's coming in like a couple weeks. We'll we'll sit down and chat with him. Uh probably just me, but it'll be um I think it'll be interesting, especially with with playing these games more. Um, I I get a lot of questions of, you know, I think with Kickstarter, I in my mind when I think of a Kickstarter game, I'm thinking of like these huge big box games that have hundreds of add-ons. And here it feels like the Kickstarter component of it is you're getting this really cool smaller and smaller and smaller box game. So, it starts out the box that they send it in. And I actually need to double check the email that Nick sent us. But the box they sent us in is just like a standard game box that's like vaguely a harmonies sized box. And then you open that box and within that box is the carrying case that's just smaller. And I think I remember some some part of what I have I believe is a deluxe component. I don't know which part. I'm going to review that when I start putting my review together. Um but uh

they did that for Trails. Yeah. Um Trails had uh one of those like zipper carabiner um outfits uh as well. Uh, but Trails was a much larger box that had that uh smaller carrying component in it, which um, you know, I I think when I reviewed Trails, I mentioned I I don't imagine bringing this to any breezy campsite where cards are just going to go haywire. But hey, more power to you. Maybe you don't live in Southeast Alaska and it's less of a concern on your beautiful picnic. Um, but yeah, those those have mainly been the games I've played. I've had a bit of a hectic week, so I haven't necessarily had a ton of time to sit down too thoroughly and play through some games. Um, though I have a couple game nights coming up. Um, what have you gotten into, Jack? Oh, man.

I've been doing a lot of good gaming. Uh, I think that I've talked about uh doing the Sleeping Gods Distance Skies. I wanted to give just a a quick shout out to that uh Red Raven Games I think uh has come out with their best game in Distant Skies. Uh it's a a better focused system than the original Sleeping Gods. It's very similar, but it just refineses everything. Um though the campaign is very short. It's an openw world game. So, like we just came off this monstrous two-year long over hundred session Frost Haven campaign and then we finished Sleeping Gods like one playthrough in three sessions and we're like wait oh oh I guess I guess that's that. but it left so much content on the table. And it has this brilliant achievement system where you can unlock additional components or things that kind of allow you to give like a new game plus uh run through where it may change some levers. Uh if you're not familiar with the game, a lot of how it works is when you open the story book, it'll ask if you have, you know, say you go to a town, it'll be like, do you have keyword gambler? If you have keyword gambler, then go to this other path, but otherwise here's the standard things that you do in the town. Maybe you get gambler within context of the town or

maybe it's something completely different. And there's hundreds of these keywords. And the levers that the game pulls both within the context of one game and future campaigns is really cool. So instead of shifting gears to play something else, we decided to start a new campaign of that and specifically look for the totems, which are the mcguffins of the game, but also like game play um gameplay affecting items that you can find. Um we now have an achievement list of all the totems that you could get. We're like, well, let's let's just go to places we didn't go. Look for a different ending. Look for different totems. look for different characters uh and see if we can find all this different stuff. And it seems like the game really supports that. There's been a little bit of repeated content, but it's cool that uh we're able to go in a different direction and still have a lot of fun with it. So, um really enjoying that. But, uh new to me, uh that I haven't played, I got Deep Regrets in which is the top hotness.

Yeah, the photo you he Jack sent a photo of like that game and a few others that all came on the same day and that poor mailman or male person had to carry like eight games to Jack in Alaska through the snow. I have no clue. I'm guessing no in Anchorage. So, you know, I guess jokes on them in Anchorage, but uh yeah. So, um, Deeper Crets, I've only played the solo mode so far, but it is really cool. Uh, it's, um, the solo mode isn't really an approximation of the standard game, which is something that I would find off-putting, but it's so interesting and evocative of what I I think the direct comparison a lot of people do is to the video game Dredge.

um where you're doing a survey of the ocean and you have this enormous chart that's dedicated just for solo mode and the the box has a ton of these on a pad. Um but you are trying to catch and successfully bring in one of each fish and I think there's over a hundred fish that you can get and catalog them and you have to write them down and everything. Um, but there's things that could affect whether you go back to port or not. And at the end of each game, um, unlike the standard game where you can go back to port, sell fish, it's part of the game loop to get additional equipment, here you have just a set number of days to catch as many fish as you can with the loadout that you start that game with. And then at the end of the game, you trade in any of your fish and then you can use money to buy equipment that will be available as part of a campaign so you can continue to um invest in your capabilities and hopefully catch um additional fish or you know uh mitigate your luck or um I I guess uh scry through decks or do whatever you need to to be able to eventually complete the campaign.

There's no real loss condition. Um, which is something I would normally find upsetting, but as as disturbing as some of these fish are, and the setting is, it's an extremely cozy game. So, the idea of like, well, this was today's catch. Here's what I was able to successfully bring in. And I don't know, I'll I'll get upgrade my rod and maybe make it so I have another dice that's available to me on all future games. and then we'll see what I can do next time and fill out my chart. Uh it it's cool. It's really enjoyable. Uh and something completely unlike anything that I've done as solo and contrary to what I normally look for in a solo game. Um as a multiplayer game, the rules look great. I'm hoping to play it this week, um including tomorrow at Devil's Club because that seems like a perfect setting to be in a pork town at a bar uh or a brewery, I should say. Um, and playing a game all about going psychopathic, being married to the sea.

Um, and then other than that, playing an oldie but goodie. Uh, I got Aon's End, which I've been looking for cooperative games. Um, also played solo. Uh, my family's been really busy. My game group's been really busy. Uh, so we haven't dived into a bunch of other stuff. Um uh but Aon's End, played that a couple times solo and it's pretty good. Um it's one of those cooperative games that I never got to the table. Uh I when it came out I was kind of on deck building game overload. Uh it does some really smart things that I think are uh novel. Uh even to date I haven't really seen a lot of uh spin on it. um the the fact that your deck doesn't shuffle, it just flops back over. So, you have a degree of manipulation that you can do to your deck with the foresight that you're just going to flop the deck over um has some interesting implications. Uh and the fact that it's kind of this cooperative boss battler, um I guess the original first edition didn't have a true solo mode baked in. the second edition does. Uh, which is cool. Um, I only played with one character. Uh, but I enjoyed the system. Uh, it it has some component stuff that still feels a little long in the tooth or of a time.

Uh, I think the game is from 2016. Uh, so it's definitely uh getting up there in age. Uh, but I I think it holds up if um I honestly I was looking for something that gave me tastes of the the sense that you get in Spirit Island because like Spirit Island, you know, the best thing is you have the different spirits and then you kind of cultivate your powers and work in conjunction with, you know, the current game state, what you're able to get your hands on and how do you grow in such a way that you can tackle this obstacle. Yeah. And you know, Aon's End doesn't necessarily do that to like the extreme degree that uh that um Spirit Island does, but it still has those faint notes. So, I I'm digging it, Brad. I mean, I think that, you know, I have I was interested in Aon's End. Um, uh, I got it on Steam a bit ago and I played the tutorial and then I I think that was like right when I moved, well, I think I got it right when I moved up to Juno or like right before I moved up to Juno and I just didn't unbox like I didn't get my computer plugged in for like four or five months and I just wasn't gaming uh on my computer. So, uh, that was that was a time period. So maybe

this is a sign for me to crack it back open and see see what Aon's End has to hold and make my own opinions uh form them. Yeah. And just see like, you know, was the money I spent on getting Aon's End through the Humble Bundle a good value, right? Was it a good value, Jack? Do you think when you bought it? Well, I had to think about that because this is a game that I didn't get as a review copy and I spent my own money on it just like Deep Regrets. And those are two different examples of where one was a Kickstarter that I originally was like, would this be something that is worth me investing my time and money in? And then the other was a retail purchase because it was my birthday recently and I had some birthday money and wanted to go over to Alaska Robotics to buy a game.

Yeah. And those are important questions you got to ask yourself sometimes. It's almost worth talking about. This week's topic theme. I'm getting so good at these transitions, Jack. I'm getting so good at these transitions. Um, yeah. I I put forth this podcast consideration or this podcast topic consideration of how do we value games? Um, and I think for me, one of one of the reasons I thought about this was with the tariffs, which we talked about in last week's episode, and um just some other things happening with uh me and my situation. I think it's interesting to think about how we value games. And I think that we can kind of approach this in a few different ways, which would be one coming at it kind of in the mind of a publisher, which is how do you determine how much a game should should cost? Because in theory, it it is based on components and that's like a big thought of it. But then, you know, there's obviously a lot of things that go into the publishing of the game that aren't represented in the components. Like, it might have a really long development time. Or maybe this is like from a designer that is like really hot and you think that it would be really good to charge more because you

you think you can cash in on the fact that this publisher has um a big follow or a designer has a big following. Um, so I was thinking about that as one way to approach the topic of how do you value games, two being as a consumer, what makes you think whether or not a game is worth it? Um, and how how do you value it from that perspective? Um, and then finally, and I think this kind of goes back to a topic that we frequently, you know, come back to because I think especially in board games, it's a topic that is easy to loop into most conversations, which is I already own the games. How do I value them? like what how do I how do I go about making like a top 10 ranking or not necessarily a top 10 ranking but how do I choose like this is the game I want to keep for XYZ reason. Um, yeah. So, I think from the first standpoint, obviously as a publisher, components are a huge factor in how a game is priced, right? Like, yeah, the physical cost of it, but then how much do you think is is like with it's a you can tell we did our research for this one. we did our research really great here. Um, I guess the the thought

that I have is it must be really tough as a publisher to know like how much you think people are going to pay for games. And this is probably something I'll talk to Nick from Bitewing about. Um, yeah, but well, I I think there's a lot of considerations that go into this. the the classic example of just the sort of mental gymnastics that go into marketing a game. Um because that's that's really what we're talking about here is uh Splendor for example. Uh because Splendor is a game that has a what you might consider a medium or medium smallsized box. Um, but it's a full game board game box, but it would fit easily within something that's like, I don't know, four decks of cards stacked on top of each other. However, if you want to sell Splendor as a $39.99 game, it cannot be something that is tiny uh the size of gloom hidden buttons and bugs.

Um, like that just does not work to have that sell as a $40 game. I'm so sorry to interrupt. When you were doing like this, uh, your phone read it as a heart and it did a I see it. I I see it. I love it. I am so sorry to interrupt. No. Uh, no, that that totally works. Uh, this is the curse that I put myself into by having an apple. Um so yeah um Splendor is that example of what perceived value is to the consumer versus what the bottom line value uh has to be to the company. And I honestly don't know anything about the manufacturing cost of uh getting Splender made relative to other games.

Um, I've heard certain things about some components are uh cheaper to manufacture than others when it comes to like how much of a markup you can have. So like card-based games tend to have greater profit margins uh than games that have a lot of um more substantive components. But um yeah, I I think that's some of the uh the the the hurdle, the psychological hurdle that publishers have to get over is us as consumers, we want to feel like if I'm paying a bunch for something that that something is a possession that I can actually hold on to. the the perceived value is about the physical product, not about the entertainment product. Yeah. Involved in it, right?

Because as an entertainment medium, board games are huge bang for your buck compared to going to the movie theater, you know, uh maybe going skiing or something, you know, a ski pass to a resort. like low barrier to entry, high yield, especially if you're going to be playing a game and again and again and again and again. I mean, I I've played my copy of Splender like 60 times at least. Why would I b at the idea of Splender costing $40, even if it was really small? So, I I don't know. I'm sure that uh this is something that uh you know people like uh uh or I don't know Stephen Bonacor uh has probably talked about this endlessly or Jamie Stagmire has probably gotten into this you know the marketing decisions that are involved.

Um I know you have aspirations of uh game design and publishing. Um, have you ever when designing a game thought about components uh from the standpoint of what's going to be reasonable uh to pitch to a company to be attractive for them to produce and like what sorts of MSRP they might consider making this game? Like is that ever a consideration in your mind? Yeah, totally. I mean, I've definitely when I have been in the works on a game started trying to figure out what the actual end product is going to look like and then made some decisions of, okay, well, do I want this to be a functional piece? And if so, why does it need to be? Or could I replace it with something else that would be either already a thing that is in the game um or just a thing that would be cheaper to manufacture? Um, and I think that it definitely I keep in my mind because at the same time, in theory, if you're trying to get a game published, you would like it to be very cheap to make because that that just gives you a a wider range of people who would be willing to take on that project. Um, so I think as a game designer, it's in the back of my mind. Um, I of course have

not published a game, so I can't say like I know anything uh past just I have read a ton about game design and I have designed some games that have been um just in in my home and that have gotten a lot of hours of play but aren't uh you know I haven't chatted with a publisher about any of them. But I do I have thought about it where I'm like putting together a game and I think oh I am going to try to let me see if I can make this more about the cards that you're playing with because I also like know that cards are a very cheap thing to manufacture a ton of. And I think the games industry is very unique in how they do some of this value setting because there's a a huge section of this industry that's passiondriven where people who play games and maybe have no aspirations of making money making games will go through a colossal amount of effort to see something that they've created be within the hobby. Um, so you know, like you might have people who are game designers or even game publishers where that's just kind of a side thing to break even, but they're just very proud and happy to invest their time in it. Whereas the value proposition has to be really different. If you are a company paying for employees, making sure that you have competitive wages,

you're paying royalties for games that you've signed, and you have to sell a number of units to be able to keep up overhead, maybe for a brick-and-mortar business, to travel to conventions, to do all kinds of things. So there is already this difference in the market uh especially because of crowdfunding where there's a lot of singlerun games or maybe only run a few times but essentially run as pre-orders with all the money coming in up front and you don't have to do that guesswork about am I going to sell as many units in order to make an appropriate profit off of this and how many do I order so That way I have available stock, but not so many that I, you know, am just stuck with 10,000 copies of, I don't know, Belfast or something. Um, and that that's got to be a really tricky thing. So the the decisions that are getting made um by these small passion-driven uh um creatives like if you were trying to publish a game yourself um would be very different than I think what uh someone like AEG or uh GMT or Stonem or any of these other companies leader games you know who is known for having a large workforce for this industry. Yeah. Uh

and trying to make sure that they're paying all their employees fair wages and keeping them happy as individuals who want to work for that company. It's uh there's a lot of logistics that are involved in it for sure. Um moving on to just like you know we are seeing a game on the shelf and we see a price tag. How do we as consumers come to the decision of whether or not that is a good value? Um, and I think there's Well, before before you get into your thoughts on this, can I drop some cardboard herald lore on Yeah. Yeah. Let's drop the lore. Okay, let's go to the lore corner, dude. Um so here in the lore corner uh it was a very conscious decision and this may come across as uh very hoidy toidy or uh pretentious but when I started the cardboard herald I was very adamant that I did not want to make purchasing decisions for other people. Yes, reviews inherently are going to influence whether people want to get a game or not, but I wanted to be a little detached from that. And part of that was I don't give scores, you know, like I I could have done all right, I give this a four out of five or, you know, like whatever. I didn't want to do that because I I didn't want any sort of

inherent, well, if it's a five out of five, that means I better buy it. Um, and I always wanted to kind of equivocate all my answers to be in a subjective realm. This is me saying why I like a game or think it has value or there's interesting things to say about it even if I don't like a game. Um, and so it has always been from the perspective of of analysis. And part of that is one um a lot of movie reviews that I really love uh or other forms of criticism um had a huge influence on uh this as a hobby for me. Um the Cardboard Herald as a hobby. The other thing was like I don't know, money's tough, man. You know, I I don't know what's worth it to you. Like what what gaming uh does for you? I don't paint minis. So like is me saying you should get a game even though you might get a lot of entertainment value out of the minis and painting them versus uh you know something else where I think that there's a lot of creative replayability. I don't know. So purchasing decisions were something that we consciously steered away from. So this discussion comes with the caveat probably the doesn't need to be said caveat of you do you audience you know

you you think about what you think about but here we can talk about like what matters to us like how we evaluate and how we judge this. So, uh, with that, we'll come back from the corner. And Eric, out of the lore corner. How do you We're out of sepia tone cuz I've made that decision in my head that the lore corner is going to be in sepia tone. We're now back to full color, baby. Um, old man Eddie is done talking about like back in 1873. Um, and you probably should have told me because I frequently in my reviews be like, I would maybe suggest you purchase this if this is your situation. Um, I've said that. I I have already gone against the the old teachings the old way.

Yeah, I could have pushed back against that, but you know, like it it was, you know, it it was it's fine. It's fine. We're out of the lower corner now. We're out of We're out of the lower corner. full color. Um, when I just see a game on the shelf and I I see the price. Yeah. I think for one thing the the one of the first things I look for is the publisher. Like I think for for me personally like knowing who the publisher is or just having that recognition um of have I liked their games before like do they publish the style of game that I typically like is is one of the things that makes me start valuing it more or valuing it less if I know it's a company that I just haven't really had a great time with. Um, so like I mentioned pre in my Molly House review that I I gave Molly House a bit more leeway through its like kind of difficult onboarding uh or it's difficult teach because I know that really get games publish games that I traditionally like so far. So pedigree matters pedigree

matters to me in the sense that if I know zero about a game like I haven't had any hype build up which will affect value or if I haven't had any like oh I know exactly what this game is for the most part or I've read the rule book of this game but I haven't actually bought it. Um, for me, like just first thing, do I know the publisher or do I know the designer? Uh, or like have I at least heard of them? Um, for me, that's one of the things that I look at for. Yeah, I I've wrote uh a bunch of things down. Um, and all of these, you know, like come to a globby, squishy amalgamation that becomes is it worth it? And it's hard to quantify like, you know, because nothing's on like a scored matrix where if it averages this level, then I automatically purchase the game.

Um, but I I had pedigree in there kind of as like prestige, you know, like if I know that this is something uh from someone of note or it's something that's limited in some way or something that uh gives it a certain genesis aqua um outside of the actual this is a game that looks cool, I want to play it. Um, of course gameplay, you know, like gameplay is a thing. Does this look like a game I'm going to have fun is the the first thing that I look at. Um, as far as price range, usually if anything's within general market price, um, $40 to $60 for medium game. That's kind of low these days, but uh um $40 to $60 for a medium game or getting to like $60 to $80 for like a medium plus or something. Uh then I I I find whatever the price that they set it at is probably fine because the number of humans that are involved to get games at a retail location. Um, and but as far as if it's worth it for me to get it, you know, like that that's gameplay, I want to know that there's some cool components in there. Um, we've already had our discussion about good components can't save a bad

game, but uh, they can elevate a game for sure. And if I'm paying some cash, I actually want to feel like there's something attractive and interesting about the game. If I was paying $60 for nothing but cards and unattractive illustrations, then I I don't know that that's going to be worth it to me. On the other hand, I really like Summoner Wars second edition, and that has brilliant art style, and it's mostly cards and a few dice. Um, but I don't have a problem with that being in the same vein as other games that are similar price on the market that have many more plastic or wood components.

Yeah, totally. And I guess for me the the somewhat big elephant in the room is I feel like I don't generally care about how many components. Like I I'm not there with like a calculator saying, "Well, this is 23 dice and therefore it's worth $50." And that's clearly like the tough thing between how publishers value games and how gamers value games. At least I'm pretty sure people aren't out here buying things exclusively based on the number of components or the type of components that have gone into it. At the same time, this is kind of back to what you one of the things games you mentioned earlier. Uh Splendor at $40 for me is like totally worth it because those chips are just so satisfying with for no for no reason.

they did not need to be that like hefty and feel really good. Um, and even if those chips like that box as a whole is really cheap to produce, which I actually don't know if it is. I don't know how expensive like weighted poker chips are cuz that's I mean that's essentially what they are but right that's like totally a thing that it just playing Splender once made me immediately go out and buy it and I would have paid more for it just because of one how much fun it is. Don't say that. Don't say that. We already know as editor cut that out. Editor me uh No. Uh I and I totally get it. I'm not saying that uh Splender is particularly cheap to produce, but I think the psychological impact of a small box is an expectation that it would be small box prices. And just like um I I think the closest comparison is the book industry where you have uh a standard price range for what might be a trade paperback, a mass market paperback, a hard cover, and like a special edition hard cover. Yeah. like those should fall in similar zones at least within certain markets, you know, like uh that's not taking into account educational textbooks or, you know, like

historical atlases in non-fiction versus what the latest Stormlight book is or whatever. But uh you know bringing the comparison to books is something that I find really fascinating about this is that we don't compensate the design time or development time. Um and this is something I talked to John Declair about a little bit on the podcast but also just hanging out with him at um Platypus Con here. we talked a lot about. He was like, "Man, it's funny because like this game that I have spent 10 years working on, far more hours than any other game that I've ever worked on, at least triple the hours that I've spent blood, sweat, and tears and working on is something that isn't, you know, uh is a much more difficult pitch for a lot of people uh and I'm trying to navigate how to get this game made. Whereas a game that I just kind of was like, "All right, this is the game." And it instantly was picked up and the, you know, is the biggest seller and is what's, you know, currently paying for my house or whatever, you know.

Um and uh there isn't a correlation between um the amount of time that someone uh puts in or even the volume of work. It's really the volume of components. And that's where it gets into the book thing because, you know, like aside from really substantial maybe like epic fantasy books, um, uh, a book with a standard amount of words versus a book with more words doesn't like translate to, uh, any, uh, meaningful difference in value. Um, and I don't know if that has an impact on like the psychological value.

Certainly when I was in middle school, you wanted to buy the Wheel of Time books because they were fat books and you got more bang for your buck. You know, I got more naive pulling on her braids. I needed to do that because I needed to kill more time with my books. You need And I think that goes 3,000page books for you. Yes. Yes. Exactly. I needed to hear more tuttering uh going on at uh at uh Terra Valain. Um but anyway, uh that brings us back to splendor and this like perceived value versus actual value. Um, and you know something that's been more attractive to me in games recently, I don't know if you've had this uh feeling, but because of our game space issue, having so many games on the shelf, smaller but beefier games, uh, more beautiful games that have a smaller, uh, shelf print. I don't know, shelf space.

Yeah. Uh, that's been more attractive to me. Uh, I'll actually pay a little bit more attention to games like White Castle and Sultan Sea by Dvere, which take up a tiny amount of space, but feel like big giant meaty games and aren't a big waste of space. Yeah, totally. And I think that that's a that's a factor that definitely is there for you and me probably for a lot of gamers. Like I can't imagine there's people who just I mean there probably are there's so few space few spaces for games and I feel like a lot of common households. Um, so I think having being able to tighten the package up is it feels like paradoxical because when we talk about Splender, people wouldn't pay $50 for Splender or $40 for Splender if it was the smaller box, if it was just like the the deck of cards size box. And at the same time, you and I, I think, both value White Castle really highly because of how much game is in that box.

And it is just like, right, I'm thankful that they didn't make it this bigger box to maybe justify it being a bit more expensive cuz uh how much is Splendor or White Castle like off the shelf? I don't know. The the MSRP. What is the MSRP for White Castle? I'm guessing $49.99. I'm guessing 60. I'm guessing 60. Oh, that. Do you want to guess what my Google of White Castle MSRP brought up? Uh, how much sliders are at uh White Castle? Absolutely.

Love it. It still hasn't gotten me the answer. Here we are. Oh. Oh. Uh, MSRP is $40. Oh, okay. I was actually going to say I bought it at a convention for 40 bucks uh the year that it came out, but I was thinking that that was a uh a deal. A Well, deal. White Castle. You did even better than I thought. Um Yeah. And that that's got some nice components in it. That's a good amount of game for 40 bucks. Like the little fold there. You have the the build your own bridges. Build your own Jeff Bridges. Um, but yeah, I think that is a game I want to play. There's probably a Lego set. You could probably get into the Lego set of Jeff Bridges. Is there a Big Labowski?

Hey, editor, can you play? I was going to say Tron. Yeah, big Labowski. Lego is there. It is there. There is a uh big Labowski something or other rug white Russian rug sunglasses. That's what I'm going for. Uh the one that I'm looking up is Oh, wait. Never mind. Hold on. I'm looking at just like uh people have made Lego sets of their things. This isn't an official one. Okay, we're going to get off of the Lego podcast now. Mhm. I don't know how to navigate Rebreickable. I just know that it exists. So, okay. So, as far as the things that we value, the the things that make us interested in a game, um, where I went over, is it a type of game that seems interesting to me? Um, I'm also going to be looking at is this something that I don't already have access to in my collection, um, or easy access to that my friends have. There was a point when I had to own every game I liked. And then I realized I can't do that. So now if my friend already has a game, even if I really like it, unless I believe I'm going to be playing solo a billion times, I'm just going to go like, well, when my friend, you know, no longer wants it or moves or whatever, then I'll reconsider this.

Um I think manufacturing principles is something that has become more uh important to me. Um and I think deep regrets uh is a great example of this. Uh TEDex uh games has put a big emphasis on uh renewable uh resources uh used in the manufacturing of it. They use corn starch bags instead of plastic bags. all wood components uh or cardboard components. Uh minimizing the um environmental impact. Um those things alone won't uh make me buy a game or sway me in one direction or another. Uh but I do care about these things enough that you know like that can help me make a decision or kind of guide uh what I do because as we've talked about more and more we as human beings are going to have to be conscious about like the outcomes of the world are driven by the dollars that we spend and what are the things that we actually want to support.

M um sometimes uh those like environmental or uh charitable uh things that a company can do uh are hard to sus out the legitimacy uh of them. Yeah. Um but fortunately in the board game space because there's such a close connection between us the the consumer and the people making the games. Um, I find that if you're trying to look for the principles of the people who are making the things, uh, that you want to play, uh, if you want to know more about their business practices, about their, uh, the validity of their charitable, um, uh, work. Yeah. Uh, if they're involved in all of that, it's much easier to find that, become involved, uh, see the payoff of it. And again, I just opened my copy of Deep Regrets and was like, "Yeah, this is great. These are the cornstarch bags." He was talking about starch. Um, yeah. I think that the the manufacturing principles was that those were the terms you used to describe it. It's on my sticky sheet.

Manufacturing principles. Principles. Um, I think that manufacturing principles sound great and it's definitely a thing that you can get a good feel of uh before you purchase something because I feel like most games these days have some sort of unboxing video. Um, so you can get a general idea of how what components you're going to be getting. And also again with all of these uh companies, I I feel like creating reputations of having those um you can definitely make some purchase decisions based on that or like value decisions of, oh, you know, I this game definitely has like I I trust this game to have been made with uh a ounce of at least an ounce of concern over the greater world. Um, and I think that's a very strong argument um to make. Um, one thing to be clear, my my moral superiority here uh is uh very uh low in that I don't go out of my way and research these things in advance. I mean, I understand the death of the author uh principle. Um, and it's, I think, uh, next to impossible to not think about someone being a um, an ass hat. Uh, if I know about

them, uh, being one. Uh, but I don't research every publisher. I don't research every um, uh, designer. And I'm well aware that there are some unsavory things that go on in the manufacturing of any of these products. Um, so, you know, like I I'm not in the clear on all of this. Uh, though what I guess I'm saying is if I know that someone is already engaged in that stuff, that's going to call my attention to their products um, more so. So, for example, if TEDx Games comes out with something new, that's one little thing that I've put in the like, hey, I like some of the things that this company is doing column that will contribute to that glob of value that we were talking about earlier. um that may help push me over the edge is the the principles uh what this company brings to the table, what they prioritize and uh find important align with some of the things that I find important. Yeah, totally.

And I think it can be important as a consumer to educate yourself on what what's going on at least generally. Just make sure you know that you're as much as possible knowing who you're supporting with your dollar when you vote with your when you vote with your wallet. Um, speaking of voting with your wallet, um, one thing that I've definitely done before in terms of like seeing a game on a shelf being like, "Oh, that looks interesting. Let me just take a look." Uh, I will go to like Board Gamegeeek and see how much it would sell for used and just Yeah. with the thought of, you know, if I really don't like it, how how much how much money would I really be losing? Um and one time I made a profit. It was great. Uh, I got Marvel Champions at like a random uh like uh thrift shop and I was like, "Oh, they're selling this for like five bucks. I'm going to try it out cuz I've wanted to try out Marvel Champions and I tried it out and realized that it wasn't really for me." I mean, I know like the Living Card Arkham Horror Living Card Game is another one that I've tried out that just didn't quite hit for me even though I know that it's like supposed to be really good.

soloable um and also multiplayer, but I I was like, well, maybe with a new theme, it's a different living card game system, so maybe I'll give it a go. And it didn't work for me. Um but I was one of the reasons I got it in the first place was I can sell this for like so much more. I think I ended up I think I sold it for like $80. Wow. That's That's actually a Well, cuz it had a bunch of expansions in it. Uh, which I was also surprised that I'm really surprised that it ended up in a thrift shop. Um, that's been like the only game I've ever been able to sell through Board Game Geek. Uh, was this Marvel Champions Living Card Game set that was just a whole bunch of different things, but it worked. I'll take it. But that's a thing that I've looked at where I'm not thinking about it in terms of I'm going to purchase this game to sell it, but just how much inherent value does this h game have like with with the once you once you drive a car off the lot, it's worth it's lost half its value type situation.

So, uh, if we took out resale as an option, if you say there there was a game where you're like, "That looks like a pretty fun game, but I don't really need it in my collection. Cost $80." Uh, but then you saw at like a convention someone had a used copy that they were selling at like a bizaar or something for $40 and you had no intention of selling it. and you passed on it as an $80 game that was like, "Yeah, doesn't really do much for me." Is there an instinct of like, "Oh, this is an $80 game that I can get for half off. I need to buy this now." Um, I'll definitely take another look. Like, I don't know. I think that's a thing that happens where if I see something's on sale, I'll be like, "Let me just let me just take a look. Let me let me reconfirm whether what value I I would be willing to pay for this." Um, I would say typically if I'm if I'm not buying it for the reason that I don't think I need it in my collection, Mhm. I don't think that there's really a ton of like monetary reasons to sway me to then purchase it later. I'll definitely reconsider. Like I've definitely gone back and been like, Arkham Living card games on sale. I could I could give it another go. Maybe I like it. May maybe I just didn't give it enough of a chance. Um I got to get

some of those expansions in there. Get some of those expansions in there. You just didn't sink enough money in, man. Maybe maybe um they have a big sale on it. I'll take a look. And I usually take a look and I I come to the same conclusion that I I unless I didn't purchase the game for financial reasons, it being on sale typically won't make me buy it. Um, right. I've definitely looked at games and and I've there are absolutely games that I've taken a look at been like, "Oh, that game looks like a lot of fun, but it's it's just a bit too expensive for me to be able to say like definitely yes, even if I think that it is at a good price." Like I I'll just give an example. I haven't purchased Oath because I just haven't really ever felt like I think this game looks really great. I don't know if I should spend $120 on this game, right? And that's I think a thing that I still want to do. I do frequently come just loop back to that because I o wait wait wait for the expansion because it's supposed to have better solo focused material you know like that there you go you know um but that's that's a thing where if I saw Oath on a

pretty good discount I would absolutely purchase Oath that's 100% a thing that that would sway me to purchase Oath versus anything else because for Oath with it is it go does go back to I think that game is a good value at $120. I just fiscally am probably not in a position where I should spend $120 on a game despite the fact that I would get tons of hours of play out of it. And like the the dollar to hour ratio would be good compared to other forms of entertainment. But yeah, you know, that's just a consideration with with being a gamer. Like that's a very strong financial commitment to a game. I think a big part of it is the impulse buy. You know, like if there's a game that I'm like, I don't know, it looks like it might be good, it might not be good, and I don't have access to it, then dumping a hundred bucks for something that I may end up going like, this was disappointing. um is a big difference from, you know, like finding on sale for 50 bucks or something like that and being like, "Oh, okay. Well, you know, this wasn't for me, but at least I didn't spend a hundred bucks on it." Um, so that's where it's definitely going to sway me. Um, a game that I'm not

entirely sure that I like. Uh, we of course have different motivations. We get to talk about it on podcast. We get to do review videos. Uh even in in addition to like um you know us uh getting um uh review copies of games, even something like Aon's End or I just got The Last Bastion. Part of this was me going like I've done my research. I kind of think that they're going to be for me, but I'm not really sure. And I I don't actually have a lot of people who I'm directly connected with who I really know their interests in games and is this something that I really should just throw a bunch of money into? But at the same time, it's the games were affordable. You know, End wasn't super expensive. The Last Bastion wasn't uh super expensive. and I wanted to fill gaps in my video or video game my my tabletop gaming knowledge so that way I could talk about them possibly do some reviews on them have some content to create so I have other motivations that offset the cost even if those aren't things that I'm I'm directly uh looking into. Yeah, totally.

And one thing that we should maybe talk about is you and I do get because of primarily your hard work, we both get review copies of games on occasion. Uh, I would say that is something that I I kind of have to factor in, which is a little bit of I for one still want to put money into the board gaming industry. As a person who's like an active participant in the board gaming industry, I would like to put money towards it. I've also had times where I have not purchased a game because I already know that I have games that I should be playing to review. So I I right I've fallen away from impulse buying games. Um I'm at this point mainly buying games that I just really am like, "Oh yeah, that game looks great. I don't know if we're going to get a review copy or not. I'm just going to purchase it because I would like this game." Um, yeah, it's actually uh kind of gone the reverse for me recently since you've been doing uh stuff on the channel. That's freed me up to um do more exploration out of uh outside of mere obligation. For a while, I was very much that way. Not that I was refusing to buy anything and not that I was, you

know, like refusing to spend money, but just my time was largely focused on games that were being sent to me. So, I didn't have a lot of incentive of uh getting other games unless it was something that was so specifically up my alley that I knew that I wanted to get it. And in that case, it probably was going to be content for the channel. Yeah. Now I have more occasions to be like, you know what, we were talking about Forbidden Jungle. I'm going to get Forbidden Jungle. Um, I'm going to get Aon's End, The Last Bastion, you know, like I I'm going to get these things because we have more time and flexibility to split up projects. Um, I don't feel like every game that I touch has to get a review because we're doing a podcast and can talk about uh games more often. like we have other avenues and flexibility, but I do know kind of where you're at. And for a while, that is definitely um where I was.

Uh I I am appreciative for being in the blessed position of getting a lot of rad as hell games for free to check out. Um so that way we could talk about them. Yeah. And I mean I think that and we could talk about the economics of being reviewers uh for a bit which is just like how much in theory how much value does company get by giving us games versus us having to not or like just not purchasing a game and not doing a review on it. Um, but realistically, uh, we both still are going to have games that we want to play that there's just not really a way to get a review copy of.

Um, and I think that Aon's been out for 10 years. Indie Board and Cards is not like soliciting for reviews right now, you know? Like I I guess I could I I guess I could hit them up and be like, "Hey, you know, like you got some expansions." I may even end up doing that. But the initial like uh you know, like, "Hey, I one, I had birthday money. It was my birthday recently. I'm in my last year of my 30s. Living the dream. Uh woo." Um, and two, uh, you know, like all this tariff stuff has made me go very into, uh, supporting local. Um, so I went over to Alaska Robotics here and picked that up. I went to record store day yesterday, picked up some records at, uh, downtown disc, you know, trying to help these uh, local businesses. Um but yeah, you know, as far as uh the the values that uh we bring to the table as influencers, content creators, as much as I the I feel gross saying those things, um I it just saying it aloud makes me want to say smash that bell. Um and that's just awful. Um so uh what I do know is that there's huge

value uh in even small channels like ours which is a small channel were a big fish in the in the very small channel market. Uh we are a very small fish in the big channel market uh even within the board game sphere. But having a review video get 500 views or something but from an audience that specifically cares about what you have to say is meaningful and is so much less expensive than putting like a banner ad up somewhere or you know having a uh well I guess you don't put advertisements in magazines anymore but um point being you might there's Senate magazine. There's there's board game advertisements in Senate. Like the the amount it takes to do the graphic design for one of those advertisements and pay for it to be posted for hopefully like a hyper specialized audience is more probably than just the cost of the the raw materials for a board game. Like in theory like Yeah, it's Yeah, absolutely. I mean, if if a board game costs uh say $80 MSRP, then that publisher probably has that copy at like 18, maybe $20 or something. Um, and so

they're just out 20 bucks and some shipping for some dedicated people to talk to people who let's say half of that audience expects a level of reputation. Um yeah from from them you know like there are people who watch every single cardboard Herald video or occasionally watch these videos with a knowledge of who you and I are thinking well you know like they are one more group that if they say they like a game that goes into the this is a a positive in that big glob of value. Um, and that is such a low investment for a lot of publishers. And but speaking of value, other people's reviews, I think that it's very helpful to just like I think a game goes way up my oh, I will pay I will definitely pay that much for that for that game. If I know a friend of mine who I like really either I know their sense of game mentality like if completely separate from the Cardboard Herald. If you Jack my friend tell me that you like this weird space Euro game, I will I will look for that game. Like that's definitely something that like reviews from friends, reviews from like if there is a content creator that I've followed and like generally know their vibes, I will trust

like going back to that adds to a I might I'm not going to purchase a game exclusively because a content creator or a friend likes a game, but if I'm on the fence, that will tip me more towards towards buying a game than not, right? And that's that's such an intangible one where all of this is intangible. All of this is subjective. What are we even doing here? I don't know, Jack. Oh, my chair just broke a little bit. We both started leaning back and it just caused problems. Cause problems and caused chaos. Um, but yeah, I mean, I think that There's just so many different ways to value games and I I hope that with this podcast we've kind of given some thoughts of what are the bigger things for the two of us like especially for like watching a review from me versus watching a review from you kind of knowing whether or not we what what you and I might value in a game and might give it credit for take or like ding it for. Um, and also just like, you know, we I mean I I think that that could be a whole separate discussion of just like what taste is, you know, like what what

are our absolute preferences? And maybe that really comes down to things like, you know, top hundred games or, you know, top 10 in a category or something. That's where you can elaborate more on why I've arranged these specific games to be this way. Um, and if you watch our reviews, I think we articulate for good reason what we like about a game or what we don't. But, um, you know, that that could be a whole other thing uh for use case scenarios for, you know, things that are going to get our attention and everything. But I I think at least this podcast, this goes into what things at least initially attract us to a game and like what what are some of the broader categories of things that might get us to um investigate a game a little bit further? Yeah, totally.

Um what's the most valuable game you own? Um, so if I'm saying emotionally valuable, I asked this question and did don't have an answer. So get if you can stall for a bit while I figure that out. I can vamp, baby. I can vamp. Uh, most emotionally valuable is I have an original copy of Hero Quest, which back into the cardboard herald lore. Beep. Uh, this is a game that I played with my brother a ton. It was really my exposure into deeper board games and heroic fantasy uh and was a really important uh part of uh a key time in my life uh where I was kind of developing into who I was and what my interests were. Uh and so HeroQuest is well I guess it's available now in a newer version. Um, so that's cool. But I have a original copy, so that's probably the most emotionally valuable. Um, monetarily valuable.

Um, I would say that uh, well, Frost Haven is the heaviest MSRP box that I have. And then collectible value. Um, I have the Viticulture wine crate with all the Viticulture content in it. And the wine crate is numbered 00001 out of 5,000. So, I guess that's pretty cool. Oh, wow. That is really cool. Neat. Um, for me of the your answers were really good and like really nice emotionally. Um, my what I would consider my most valuable game would be this random copy of Ascension I picked up at a at a at I think it was at Platypus Con.

Um, because I think I got this for like five bucks and I have my wife loves this game so much. We have gotten I think easily 40 hours total of Ascension. And this is just the base set. We haven't even gotten into the expansion. And that doesn't even count the the so many hours my wife has put into the app and that I've put into the app playing with the expansions. That is just this and also it came with card sleeves that are Ascension card sleeves, which I think are cool. Nice little um but the uh Oh no, I have to sort that later. I took a card out of one of the starter decks and I don't know which starter deck it is.

I'm going have to go in and count cards later. Um that one just in terms of dollar amount to fun is the most valuable. Um emotionally valuable is probably I don't know can you see it here? Yeah, that copy of Terraforming Mars is like one of the few games I brought with me from when I moved up to Juno from Los Angeles. Um, because Terraforming Mars is like one of the games that I consider like my first heavy into the board game hobby games like past past Katon, past everything. And that's the that's like the copy that I've carried with me. I think I brought it from Boston to Los Angeles and then Los Angeles to Jun. Like this has been one of the oldest games that I own in terms of like how long it's been with me. Um and we still play it frequently. This is still like one of the games we teach people after we've played like Wingspan a few times or something else a few times to like go like, "Okay, Do you like big games? Cuz we can we can try one. Terraforming Mars isn't even like that crazy all things considered.

Once you get like right once a person's gotten four or five rounds in and they start getting it, it's easy. So, it's not like it's a very heavy game. I'm not bringing out Dune Imperium or sorry, well, Dune Imperium or Imperium Horizons on on these people that are still new to games. Um, okay. That we gotta end this because that's a bananas claim that I realize you said Imperium Horizons instead. But just it breaks my brain to imagine Dune Imperium being somehow more complex uh than Tyra Mars. Uh, as I was looking I was looking at Dune Imperium and thinking Imperium Horizons, you know. Um, Dune Imperium is probably not a heavier teacher than Terraforming Mars. It's It's probably same zone. I I tend to think of terraforming Mars as a little bit uh crunchier crunchier and little bit less esoteric, but I feel like that's that faux paw is as good as any to end the podcast on. Uh, everybody is going to leave this week's podcast with thinking I'm I have a weird time learning the rules to deck builders.

Yeah, exactly. That's the major takeaway of this episode. Thank you so much for tuning in. Uh if you have any questions for us about our opinions on how to value games or uh questions for future podcast topics, if you have one in mind that you really want to get our thoughts on, uh please comment them on YouTube or Spotify. Um or you can email them them into us at uh cardboard herald@gmail.com. U we'd love to get your thoughts on that. Um, thank you so much for tuning in and being a great community as always. I'm hoping this was a little bit of a more light-hearted episode uh compared to last week's. Um, that's the hope. The hope is that we didn't like really traumatize somebody with talking about value.

Um, thank you for tuning in. Yeah, we're we're over here talking about value of games and people are like, man, I my value has has devastated. Forget that. They're tracking how much it costs to get a box of mac and cheese right now, you know. Um, well, thanks for tuning in. Uh, I've been Eric with the cardboard Harold along here with Jack. Bye. Can you do the heart emoji one last time for the fans? For the fans. There it is. Damn. So dumb.

Progress saved