Fate of the Fellowship - Board Game Review - Will You Sod Off Sauron?
Transcript
I will take the ring to Mordor.
Two hours later. Hi everyone, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken People, a show where I devote my time to ranting, raving about board games, but usually more the ranting part. Let's be truly honest. We'll get on with the review in just a moment, but first I just want to say a quick word about my sponsor. As gamers, we find it hard to deal with empty shelves, some worse than others. You therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time. For me, that supplier is Kiender. They offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future acquisitions down the line. If there's a hot title you're after, chances are Kiendra's got it. Wingsman, mine.
Arnova, mine. Eclipse, actually. I hate that game. It's terrible, but you might like it if you use the referral link in the description below and sign up for a new account. You'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60. So, let's make Gaps in your collection a faint of the past. Get down to Kiender and start saving today. Thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video. Get on with it.
Want to talk about games that are getting a lot of buzz online and social media? Fate of the Fellowship is that one. Zman Games, Matt Lecock, effectively a spin-off of the Pandemic system, which to be fair is a system that has been so done to death it kind of needs to hurry up and die at this point. But that's not to say I dislike Pandemic. It's just, oh, for crying out loud, can we stop now? It is a bit like a dead horse.
Stop. He's already dead. But this one is meant to be kind of more more Lord of the Rings rather than pandemic. There's definitely some like nuances from Pandemic. There's like some inspiration here, but it's meant to be a Lord of the Rings co-op game first rather than a pandemic game first. And certainly, I think that does actually come through, but you'll see more as we go through. The idea is that this is a co-op game, one to five players, that allows people to basically take control of Frodo and various other characters, perform a few objectives, get the ring to Mount Doom, and chuck it in just like you expect from the movies. And I'm a massive fan of the Lord of the Rings movies. You know, it's probably my second favorite trilogy of all time. Favorite definitely got to be Back to the Future. I'm sorry, it's just brilliant. Um, but then so Lord of the Rings, but that does have some stupid moments in it. Um, but yeah, I I really do enjoy the theme. I've got the LCG which I to be fair I've not played in ages and I've played other stuff like Journeys in Middle Earth and you know a few other various card games to do with it but most of the time they tend to be abstract games. They tend to be like ones where the theme is second and the mechanics are first. So I'm hoping that this one is more of a thematic experience that should help to elevate the service as we go through. Oh well without further ado, let's crack on and see what's what.
I'm going on an adventure.
To win Fate of the Fellowship, you must complete a series of objectives. They'll have a few at random and the final one to destroy the one ring in Mount Doom. And everybody will take control of a selection of characters to each that have different special abilities between them and start at different places on the board. The board will have a predetermined setup in terms of enemy red little miniature forces as well as Nazgoul and the eye that's trying to see you. It's all got a predetermined setup except for the deck of cards which you will cater based on the difficulty rating. On your turn, you do four actions with one character and one action with the other character. These actions involve attacking other troops, capturing strongholds, preparing cards and tokens for later use, and traveling across the map, which has its own fair share of perils, particularly if you're Frodo, who constantly has to keep dodging the eye every time to stop being searched. After you've done your turn and done your various actions, you will then draw two cards from the main deck.
And hopefully you won't pull one of these skies darken cards because these skies darken cards increase the fret rate. It means more bad stuff will happen to you. More things appear on the board. It effectively just makes the game harder and harder. But what you're hoping for is to draw more cards that have the various place names and icons on them because this is kind of like your currency to perform various things during the game. Once you have done that side though, the shadow player effectively or the shadow the game gets to have its own little phase where it draws so many cards from this deck based on the threat level. And the idea is is that they have two aspects to them. A movement action where troops will move along the map and try to get to havens to basically conquer them. Or it will have a reinforcement action at the bottom which basically mucks around with a Naz ghoulie eye and puts more troops on the board. But what dictates which one of those two you use is entirely based on whether it's got a red flag or a black banner on the back of the card on top of the deck when you resolve a card. So you've got to do each one individually. This is how the play will continue throughout the game. Players will lose if their hope track ever gets down to zero and they just fall into despair. It's like everything's lost.
We're all depressed. Frodo's gone. Yeah, all hope is lost and they just get conquered. But the idea is is that if you can survive long enough, particularly to the final objective, which involves one last roll to not lose all your hope at that stage, to complete all the objectives and destroy the ring, then all players will win.
Certainty of death, small chance of success. What are we waiting for?
In terms of components, they're decent enough. I mean, the board is a fairly sturdy board from what I've played with. The cards are decent stock. You know, it's probably worth maybe sleving them, but I don't feel that you have to to. I like the little Nazoul miniatures that you've got on these little pedestals that move around the board. You've got little tiny meeples, which are tiny. They are a little bit on the tiny side, but as for when we get into a negative later, you're going to be glad that they are small. Uh, you got pretty decent custom dice, and, you know, generally it's a decent production. Although, money in terms of value is wasted a little bit on the dice tower.
You're a monster. Yes, I'm one of those heathens that hasn't assembled the dice tower. It comes with a Sauron eye dice tower, which is basically these parts all put together. You got to spend a while doing and it's basically just a dice tower to roll dice. It has a big eye on the top and looks cool. Sorry, I can't be bothered to assemble that thing. It looks cool on the table and if you want to use it, go right ahead. But when it comes to looking at different accessories for games and ranking like which ones are great for me like inserts and you know dice and stuff like that, you have to go pretty far down the list before you hit dice towers, which you know, sorry guys, I got to say it. Dice towers are one of the most pointless accessories in board gaming. I don't get the idea that I need to have some construction thing on the board that takes up space, blocks line of sight and everything just to do this.
Wow. I mean, that is so hard to accomplish. You know, I don't need to have some weird tower that I drop things in and let the dice roll. Okay? And I mean, that's a personal thing. I'm not griping at the game for it, but you know, just understand I haven't assembled this and I don't intend to.
Stupid fat hobbit. It ruins it.
But this is where a lot of the money for the game has kind of gone to. You know, you've got decent components and a decent dice tower lookswise, but that does mean that the cost of the game has gone up as a result. And I feel if they just cut out the dice tower, they could have cut the cost of this game down by a decent chunk.
Really spectacular. Spared no expense.
The biggest praise for this game, I think I can say, is just the variety of the setup and game arcs that you can have. Mainly because you've got a decent array of characters here. I mean, more so than any other pandemic game, I think that's ever come before it. All the major characters. I mean, Aomir, Baramir, Galadriel, Gimley, Arwin, Frodo and Sam, Aragon, Gollum, Arowin, Legolas, Gandalf, Marry and Pippen, and Phamir. The artwork is okay. It's a little bit weird in places. And I must admit, Arowin kind of looks more like a guy than it does a woman. Actually, to be perfectly fair, I'm not entirely certain what the character is meant to look like in the books. But when you compare the picture of this airwin with the one from the movies, I feel like I've got a preference as to which airwin I prefer. But I mean, given that she was meant to hide amongst all the soldiers as a man in order to get into battle, I suppose it kind of makes sense. But I don't know, the artwork is a little bit iffy in places. But that aside, the selection of characters is pretty cool.
And they've all got two, if not three different abilities on them, and you're going to get two of them every game. And different combos are going to have different effects. Some are definitely a lot more powerful than others, though. You know, you could combine like Arwin and Aragon and have a pretty good time mustering an Elvish army and just decimating things across the board. If you're playing Frodo with Gollum, I'm pretty certain that Gollum is slightly overpowered. Well, actually, no, not slightly. He is overpowered.
This guy trivializes search roles for a lot of the game. And if you keep Frodo and Golem together, as long as you get over his little minor negative, which is not that hard to deal with, you can basically just march across the board basically whistling about how I'm going to destroy the ring or something, and Sauron can't seem to do anything about it. It's it's kind of, you know, he basically just makes that aspect of the game like somewhat easy. But yeah, there are certain characters that won't synergize as well with each other and you're meant to do them at random. So, you are going to get different combinations. But certainly, if you were to pick the characters that you want, you could end up with some pretty insane combos. But again, a lot of them. And I'm glad that it's not just one ability. It's not just, you know, if Arowind's, you know, well, actually, let's take another example. Um, let's take uh uh let's take Arwin. Okay, let's say if Arwin's only ability was when you muster for new troops in a location, that's Elvish. you don't need to spend certain icons for it. And that was it. That'd be a pretty boring ability. But then on top of that, she's got send aid where when she prepares, if she's in the region, you know, if if the if the criteria matches, you get to ditch, you know, give cards across the entire board. Then you've also got the give council ability where every time you use fellowship, the card doesn't have to match the region.
And there's stuff like so you've got all these other cool pretty powerful abilities, two of them as well. So you've got a lot of stuff to play with on your turn. I also love this objective deck. This needed to be in previous games of Pandemic because this is quite insane. You've got to have the destroy the one re objective and then after that you've got three at random, possibly more if you really want the difficulty higher. Out of all these, there's a lot and they are pretty different, you know, for a few of them. I mean, some of them are rinse repeat. I mean, you know, you've got Sheilob's Lair and Confront the Brog, which is pretty much the exact same thing, just a slightly different story tweak, but and with different characters in different locations. So, there is a little bit of rinse repeat in some of these. But, I mean, you've got, you know, Arwin unfills the banner, lay bear the pitch, challenge Sauron, attain the blessing of the elves, rangers, secure Eridor, uh, freeodin's mind, Sauron, your staff is broken, confront the barro, confront Sheilob, please kill that spider. I hate Sheilob. Unseen Boramir reclaims his on it. There's a lot in here and you're using free at random. So, this creates all sorts of different setups that the game can have which result in a lot of cool game arcs for the game to proceed through. And again, some objectives synergize better with each other. And they do cause some very different styles of games. I've had games where you find a few objectives where you have to do a lot of teamwork to do each objective. But then I had one game recently where I played a four
player and oh no sorry a free player and the objectives basically had each person going for one of the objectives on their own because it didn't require anybody else to team up with them. So you almost had like three lone rangers going off sorting out one of the three objectives to do before we dealt with the whole Frodo and the rain thing. So it does create some unique setups here and there and makes more aspects of the game important from time to time. like an objective might really need you to focus on the dwarfs whereas in another game you barely need to go anywhere near Dale and you don't really care. There's just a lot of good variety here. And I would have expected the game to have just given you maybe, you know, six characters, maybe like, you know, there you go, there's your six characters, including Frodo, and we'll give you eight objectives. You know, that's what I would expect most games these days to do. But the fact that they give you all of these on top without the need for an expansion and if you want to expand the game in the future, you could just give me more characters and more, you know, more of these and I'll be perfectly happy is pretty damn impressive. You know, it adds to the value of the game.
But I just think the fact that they actually went the extra mile to put this much variety in is a good thing. You know, I really like it. Now, the game arcs as they progress certainly it's there's a kind of a positive and a negative for it. I love the early game. I particularly love the mid game, not so much the end game. The mid the middle is kind of like the highlight of these games because when you start off, you you're kind of building up. You're trying to get your cards, trying to get your stuff going. You thought, right, I need to go over to here and get started on these objectives and that and that's all fun and all, but it's more of a setup phase, you know, act one. Act two is when the real like theme and the meat of this game really come through because you're getting into these objectives. There's more troops on the board. you have more stuff to play with. You're getting involved in combat, taking strongholds, you know, and and all of this stuff is going on. And so, the middle of the game is where the past can differ a lot. The end game though is where things get a little bit linear for my liking. You know, dealing with Frodo and the ring is what you have to do at the end. And to do that, you have to get to Mordor. You have to have a bucketload of stealth tokens to even go along these paths because you have to get rid of tokens to go along paths. You have to make a ton of search rolls. You have to go along these paths. You have to have five ring tokens by the time you get there before you can chuck the ring in.
And that makes the end game basically proceed kind of the same all the time. You know, you have this sort of, you know, you have like a branching situation where you've got like five different paths that you can follow at the early game. And then in the mid game, each of those fingers there could have another five paths that you could follow and you could have some pretty good var variation there. But it feels like an all roads lead to Rome sort of scenario where you've got all these different branching paths, but eventually it all congregates into one, which is this bit that you have to do at the end. And that gets very repetitive between games. I kind of wish that I mean obviously it's thematic. I mean, he's got to chuck the ring into Mount Doom. It's what you've got to do.
Destroy it.
No.
I wish that maybe there was multiple ways you could approach the Mount Doom situation because really, you can only get in there from two different routes. You need a bucketload of stealth tokens one way or the other. And there's not a huge amount of difference between the routes anyway. One's just slightly longer but requires the same amount of tokens over time and one's a little bit shorter but requires a lot of them all at once. I mean that's basically your difference between the two and it's just it kind of like a lot of times I play this and I go this is really good up to this point and then at the very end I'm like oh yeah we got to get this bit done. All right let's see if we can get this bit done now. then that's a little bit of a negative that comes into play, but that's after you've gone through two very solid acts before then. Rules to the game are pretty straightforward. You've got a reasonable amount of text to deal with from the objectives and, you know, dealing with a lot of abilities that you're juggling around, but in terms of the main rules, not that difficult. You've got a couple of reference cards for player. You've got reference aids on the back of the book itself. And the book is not the largest book in the world. It's pretty big text with a lot of pictorial examples. And if you are even remotely familiar with Pandemic in the slightest, as much as this is definitely a Lord of the Rings game first and Pandemic second, there's still stuff that comes over. You know, the whole like the the shadow deck of cards, the fret rate, the draw and discard function. Even the fact that you've got a hand limit of seven, which feels a bit more redundant here than in other games. I don't see why they had to keep the hand limit bit here. Maybe it would have been too easy otherwise, although we'll get on to the difficulty bit a bit later. Um, but you know, generally there's a lot of stuff that will be familiar to you and the stuff
that is different isn't going to take that long to grasp or teach.
Right, where are we going?
And when it all boils down to it, this is definitely very much a kind of heads down really think about the puzzle that's going on here. And you've got a good expansive puzzle with a lot of different elements to it. You've got multiple different havens that the enemy is marching towards, some of which are under more threat than others. You've got the different objectives that you got to do. All these different characters with abilities. You've got to deal with the fact that these Nazoul are constantly chasing Frodo around the board with the eye following them and stuff. And you've got to micromanage this hope track. There's a lot of stuff that you're thinking, well, I could do this, could do that, could do that. Was like, h, I don't know. And it's going to require you to cooperate a lot with other players. Now, being a co-op, this does sometimes fall a little victim to the alpha player syndrome.
Throw yourself in next time and rid us of your stupidity. Not as much as other co-ops can. You know, there's a lot going on that's very difficult for the alpha player to entirely gauge what's going to happen. Like you can't predict everything. And certainly there's a lot in here you can't predict at all. We'll get on to that. But in terms of like an alpha player trying to tell people, all right, you know, you need to do this. It can fall victim to that a little bit where somebody will have a situation. It's like, well, you know, this has got to be sorted. So you need to do you need to take your character from A to B to C to D in order to facilitate this for the next turn. And it may be that somebody who knows this game quite well is going to get into that situation with players. Not unique to this game. All the other pandemics kind of fell victim to it as well, but this one certainly will as well. It's not going to escape that factor. But if you can get past that thing and you don't have alpha players in your group, there is a lot of grounds for discussion. There's a lot of times where you are going to have to work together and you're going to have to coordinate these heroes all over the place. You know, maybe not for the whole game. I mean, the game I mentioned where everybody went off as a lone ranger.
Yes, we split off. You know, I went down the middle to with Frodo and Gollum. I took a little route past the elves area. The elves, Arwin and Aragon, basically went into Mirkwood and had to basically rise an Elvish army to kill all the orcs there as part of their objective. We left them to their own devices. And then um Mary and Pippen and Faramir I think did a load of stuff down Gondor Way to try and facilitate the was it the Marry and Pippen objective whatever it's called I forget what it's called. Uh but yeah hobbits pledged their loyalty. So they were doing their own thing there. So all of us were split off to begin with but then eventually we did have to congregate. We did have one objective that required somebody to come down south and we obviously had to coordinate with each other what we were doing there. So whether you play this, you know, um, with two, three, four, five players, there's definitely going to be a lot to discuss.
What do trees have to talk about? Except the consistency of squirrel droppings.
The game also has a very strong thematic element. I mean, I said that this was a Lord of the Rings game first and a pandemic game second. That is definitely true. through the Lord of the Rings theme here is very strong with the characters that you're using and how they work with the different objectives that you can do with the way that the game plays out and how you're leading onto Mount Doom and how things are getting harder and harder. A lot of this is true to what the Lord of the Rings movies and books were like, how the characters should act, how the sort of events play out. I mean, if you're playing the introductory game, you are pretty much copying the movies. You know, you have a starting objective to get yourself to Rivendell and that, but then you've also got an objective where you've got to take down Eisenard, just like the movies, and then you've got the Mount Doom one, obviously, but then you've also got to, you know, challenge Sauron in Ailion by doing what they did in Return of the King. So, the introduction scenario is pretty much bang on what you do in the movies, but then when you flex around with the objectives, you can do all sorts of other stuff that happened from the books or from the movies. I mean I am not an afficionado with the books. I've just listened to the audio books once which felt more like a singalon than did an actual audio book. But you know there's some stuff here which I'm not aware of.
You know some of them are blatantly from the movies or like you recognize them. But then there are a few here where you know it's like lay bear the pits in the merc in Dolan Goldor. Not quite sure what that's referring to. Subdue Umbar. I don't think that ever happened in the Lord of the Rings movie. That didn't happen in the movies. I'm not sure that happened in the books either. And you know, there's a few bits and bobs in here where I'm like, "Okay, I recognize some of this from the law and some of this not, but maybe there's some Lord of the Rings experts that could probably, you know, fill in the blanks there." But even that tiny little blemish aside, now this game feels like Lord of the Rings. It's not just a pasted on theme to try and sell more copies. No, this one actually had some thought go into it. Thank goodness because it's about time that somebody did that with Lord of the Rings.
How hard can it be? And the game comes with a pretty effective solo mode. I'm not doing a separate section for this because there's not a huge amount of rules changes. Mainly, normally you have two characters. You have cards for each player, and in order to give cards to each other, you've got to do a specific action, which is very hard to coordinate. Solo mode's a bit on the simpler side. You essentially have the Frodo character, but then you also have four characters that you pick at random as your characters. And what you do is that you basically do each character in sequence. So you always do one action with Frodo, but then you do four actions with the particular character. So first it will be four actions with Baramir, then one with Frodo, then four actions with Aramir, then one with Frodo, then four actions with Faramir, one with Frodo. And between each character, you're doing the drawing of cards and the shadow deck and all that stuff. So it's effectively like you're playing a fourperson game by yourself. But this is definitely the preferable way to do solo. Don't try to do multi-handed between multiple players. It's quite a lot to juggle at that point. This though makes it fairly simple to jump into a solo game. You know, you have got all the characters to play with. You can focus on the puzzle yourself. And the main two changes are that some of the actions are slightly tweaked. Like you never have to deal with the fellowship action to give cards when you're in another player's location. Thank god.
You know, you have a shared pool of tokens and locations. I cannot begin to tell you how much of a lifesaver that is. However, the negative is that the prepare action, which normally you could just do willy-nilly, now you've got to have the card matching the region you're in. That's a bit more restrictive, but they kind of had to do it because otherwise, I think solo would have probably been too easy as a result. But I enjoy playing this solo. I mean, it's fun to play this with multiplayer, but I think the solo game's pretty damn solid in this. You know, very easy rules tweaks. You could easily learn the game via the solo mode because it wouldn't take you long to convert yourself to multiplayer afterwards because you'll get the majority of the game's mechanics playing it solo. And it leads to the same coolness of having multiple objectives and figuring out this cool puzzle. So overall, solo mode is a win.
This is why Superman works alone.
So quite a lot of good points to talk about there, but this game is not without its fair share of negatives. Firstly, the board itself. Now, this is a very divisive point. There are people who have gone on reviews saying that they're not fans of this board. And then you look in the comments and I see a lot of people coming at them with pitchforks going, "What are you talking about? This board is amazing. It's so easy to visualize. Are you blind?" You know, and stuff like that. I think that there's a middle ground here. The board is not perfect. There are problems here. It is a very busy board. Now, I personally don't have too much trouble visualizing where things are going on the board when it's like this. You know, if you took out all the pieces, the board itself is not too difficult to follow. You know, you've got a lot of colored arrow paths going everywhere. Some of which have got very similar shades of green and blue, which makes them a little bit hard to distinguish. But, you know, for the most part, I can usually follow where they're going. when you flip over a card, it's got the highlighted region as well as the sort of like rough idea of where the path is. So, you can follow that and generally get a good idea of where things are going. Um, the borders between regions, they're just a they're just a dark gray line between them, which is fine when you're comparing, say, Eridor to Inidwa for whatever you pronounce it as. But then when you're trying to distinguish the borderline with the Misty Mountains and you know north of Gondor and sort of a Philly area, it gets a bit hard to distinguish it from the mountain ranges. It does blend in a little bit too much. Now this
is when it has nothing on the board. When you put everything on the board, including all the little miniatures, the Naz and the eye and stuff, holy moly does this board become an absolute cluster.
John Spartan, you are fined one privilege for a violation of the verbal morality statute. Yeah, this um it gets a little bit ridiculous, especially with lots of players. With three or less, it's not too bad. Four or five, when you've got a lot of stuff going on and lots of these shadow cards getting flipped over, it's like, Jesus, man, it's taking a while. But the problem is that a lot of stuff is being squeezed onto this board, which is fine if you didn't have to put components on the board as well, though, because these little guys, yes, they're small, and that's all well and good, but cool blime me, you have to like, you know, squeeze a bunch of them onto one location at times, but you might have a small little circle here that is surrounded by I mean, I kid you not, there's one here, South Ailion, right? Actually, no. Let's go for Osgillaf. All right, people recognize that one. There are one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight arrows coming in and out of that location. Eight. And that is that is just the arrows for roots, you know. And this is in the middle of a region that is very tall and thin. So imagine if I've got a bunch of people here, right?
There you go. Six little miniatures. I already can't see the location. Then you've maybe got two characters. Where the hell do I put these? But then let's say I've also got four Naz well three Nazol flying in the area which is kind of small actually. A lot of the times you'll have six or seven in one region. Okay. So I got to squeeze those in somewhere. Now they're covering all the other locations. Oh, by the way, Sauron's here to visit. You know, I'll stick the eye in somewhere and try and squeeze them in there. Before you know it, I can't see Jack in this region. It's insane. I mean, Ailion is probably the worst offender for this. Misty Mountains ain't particularly good. Some of the bigger regions like Eridor and, you know, Roane, Rovenian, is that how you pronounce it? I don't know. You aren't too bad. But, man, some of these places are so jam-packed full of iconography and arrows and stuff that as soon as you put any amount of components near them, it just becomes impossible to see what is there. Like I cannot just with this setup, which is not uncommon particularly by the end game to have this set up here. I cannot see what locations are in Ailion, where the arrows are going or even who's in what location. It's just too cluttered. And you know, it's not that the game becomes unplayable at that point, but man, does it become more fiddly. You've got to, you know, normally you would take a piece and you would move it one location at a time as you move it from place to place. No, here you have to basically go plump and like pick them all up in one big lump and stick them on the last location after you've pointed with your finger to try and see what's what and wobbit tide you if you knock anything
over because it's just going to have a cascade effect. But it does become a little bit problematic and that's for me to see with like 2020 vision, you know, and you like no color blindness or anything. But if you're remotely color blind or if you're not the best at like vision or the lighting is not great. I mean bearing in mind a lot of people are seeing this directly from the top down which means that it's easier to see stuff than if you're at an angle. You know people forget that aspect. It does become a little hard to visualize what's going on. The setup time and the length of this game also a little bit insane. I mean the box will tell you that this game is playable in 60 to 150 minutes. Um, I mean, technically that's true, but let's expand both of those extremes a little bit. This gives more of a game that can be played in anywhere between 15 minutes to about 3 and 1/2 hours because the game doesn't really know when it wants to end. And a lot of that is going to be based on the difficulty spikes because this game has a thing where basically you could play the game in 15 minutes if it hoses you at the very start, which it could feasibly do.
Oh, listen. You just got to give me more time. Don't make a fool out of me, man.
But then it could also drag out to three and a half hours if you're playing this with four or five players and you've got multiple objectives and you're trying to get it all done and the game's like going to its last marker and you're discussing loads of stuff and it's like the game really is not a short game by any means. I mean, you are not winning this game in a short space of time. You are losing this game in a short space of time, but you are not going to have done all the objectives and everything and got to Mount Doom and done that whole stuff in less than easily 2 hours, I would imagine. I mean, if you're playing solo, it will be less. Of course, you're playing it by yourself. But then my solo games have varied a lot in length because of how much I've been hosed by the game or how long the game's progressed or how complex the situations have got, you know, or even if you're trying to learn the game for the first time. it. Yeah, it's varied a lot. This is a game that just doesn't know when it wants to end. You can't plan for how long you're going to play this in a game night because win or lose, this game length could take you barely any time at all or it could take you the entire night. And you do feel that length when it starts creeping into that 2hour plus mark. I mean 2 hours is kind of fine I think for this like you've done a lot of discussion a lot of thinking's going on and that but then when it starts getting to two and a half free potentially three and a half I have seen three and a half hour games of this it's like holy Christ this needs to end you know this needs to end at some point it's just a little bit erratic on that this isn't helped also by the fact the setup takes an eternity
to do I mean the setup for this game I kid you not this is the rule book right and I told you the rules are not you know they're not complicated It's not a complicated setup, but here we go. So, there are one, two, three, four, five pages devoted entirely to setup. Just the setup, nothing else. And there are a total of there are a total of 10 steps, which doesn't sound like a lot, but there's a lot of stuff you do in these steps. I mean, you've got to create the shadow deck itself. You've got to choose the like the objectives that you're going to do. You've got to add troops to very specific locations on the board. And you've got to look for these very tiny little markers that say where the starting troops are. Very easily missed unless you study the list here in detail and make certain you haven't missed a beat. You've then got to put all the 18 different red troops all over the place in various spots. Again, look at the list. Then you've got to draw nine cards from here and put more stuff on the board. Then you've actually got to deal with the character selection for everybody. get the players and find out where they go on the board. Then you've got to actually create the deck itself of player cards. You've got to write, well, what difficulty are we playing on?
Right, I need to create a bunch of stacks of these cards. I need to put the skies darkened cards in here, shuffle each of these once, then stack them on top.
How long is this going to take?
Can we start now? Jeez, it takes a while. And when you play this solo and you've got to do all of that yourself, it is kind of noticeable that by the time you're done with the setup and you're about to like start the game, you might just have a little cry. You might have a little weep because by the time you get to the end of the setup, you're like, I can finally play. It's so quiet. It's so quiet. Oh man, it does take a while to do. And if you're teaching players this game, it's not like they can really help you a lot with the setup. They can only do so much. So, it's just a bit of a chore to get it all done. And this is also factoring into the extended play length. Now, when you're playing a pandemic game, you accept that there's an aspect of luck involved. You've got the luck of the card draws when you're drawing from your own deck. You've got the luck of the draw from the fret deck. This game likes to take that to another level of the randomness factor. This one has got a very high swing factor despite the fact that it is kind of a heads down figure out the puzzle as um type of game. Boy, does this game like to throw you for a loop at times and make you realize that kind of no matter what you do, sometimes fate just kind of has you screwed. And and you know, the luck aspect comes in various ways. I mean, firstly, you are drawing cards from your player deck at random. Do you get the icons that you want? Do you get the regions that match up? Are the skies darkened cards literally next door to each other in a deck? I mean, you don't do anything particularly special with the stacks of cards. So you could feasibly have a situation where two skies darken cards are right next door to each other. That
can happen, you know, just based on unlucky setup and you could have a skies darken card on the first turn in the game. Like I've literally all I've had a chance to do is prepare a couple of cards, move one or two spaces, and that's it. And all of a sudden now it's like the sky dark and all bad stuff happens. It's like give me a second. But he just moved. It's like seriously. And on top of that, you've also got this uh fret deck here, which has the problem of being very unpredictable. When you have the fret deck in normal pandemic games, you have just city names. That's all it is. City names, London, Moscow, and all that lot. And when the fret deck sort of gets shuffled back on top when the uh what do they call the epidemic cards come out, you have an idea of what cards are going to come out again because you know what you've discarded and they're just city names. That's it. They go on top of the deck. I know that London is coming out. I don't know when it's coming out, but it's coming out. Is London a threat? We need to do something about that. You can predict that this is going to happen. You just don't know the exact timing. Okay, here though, there's an added problem with the cool factor that you have got two different aspects of a card being a bit of a double-edged sword because this makes it very difficult to predict what this deck's going to throw at you because of the fact that the top of the deck being a red flag or the black banner dictates what the card does. I might have these cards that I have shuffled together and shoved back on the deck. I know in here that let's see, we'll look at this one for example. I've got a reasonable amount of purple arrow cards on here.
All leading to the Grey Havens. Okay, Grey Havens has got a fair bit of troops going towards it. That's a bit of a threat. We probably need to defend Grey Havens a bit. The thing is though is you might draw every single one of those cards with a black banner, which means that you never move these troops. Instead, you do something else on the card. So, because you've got all these different cards on top of the deck with two different outcomes based entirely on a random modifier, you can't really predict what these things are going to do. I mean, yeah, it's like, okay, I've shuffled a bunch of these cards and I know it's potentially going to be a problem, but it may not be a problem. It may generate something even worse. I mean, it may be that, well, you know, it's okay. We've shuffled a bunch of these on. We didn't have to worry about the strongholds. Great. You know, not a problem. But all of a sudden, it means now that Frodo has just been searched, like basically strip searched by Sauron's eye, you know, to the point where we've lost all our hope. And this hope track can plummet without any like warning whatsoever because the black aspects of these cards basically move Nazol to, you know, where the eye or Frodo is. And it's not difficult for all the Nazoul to be on Frodo's location at any one time and shifts the eye directly to where his region is. And this eye, Jesus Christ, I have never seen a more skittery, twitchy eye in in history. I mean, in the movies, yeah, Sauron's there and he's got his eye and he's looking for Frodo, but he's kind of like, where is he? Where is that little git? Hey, where is he? Hey, this guy is practically doing a cartoon thing of peeking around a mountain at Frodo every
5 seconds. It's just like he's like, you can't see me. It's it's just basically like a cartoon because it's so easy for this eye to get focused on Frodo's location with a bucketload of Asgoul. Uh so when you try to distract the eye with other players doing combats in various regions and stuff, it does feel like it's all for nothing at times. You know, Gandalf goes to this location, goes, "Right, I'm attacking some orcs here. The eye is over here. Fantastic. Yes, we've distracted it. Now you've got a chance to move Frodo and instantly as soon as you flip over three cards in this deck to now go to Froto's location. I goes to Froto's location. Now is the eye in Froto's location in which case do a search. Everything you did didn't matter at that point. This game likes to punch you in the face without a moment's notice by pure bad luck. And you know, yes, that was a factor in out of pandemic games, but boy do you notice it here when I mentioned the 15minute timer thing. It's feasibly possible to die on the first couple of turns because you could just have a situation where the cards you draw force you not only to have, you know, the eye search for Frodo immediately. Bearing in mind that when you draw a skies darken card from here, if the eye is in Frodo's region, which it is at the start of the game, then you lose two hope. You might not have had a chance to get the eye away from that location before you draw one of these cards, and you've already lost two of your starting six hope. And then you have to roll a search roll. Well, you might have to roll, say, three or four
dice in order to do it. There's, you know, a couple of ways that you can, you know, lose hope on this dieice. One is mitigated with a haven, but, you know, you may just roll the dice in such a way that you end up losing most of your hope within the first like couple of turns and then you just can't build up and then you lose in zero. I mean, it's easily be possible for you to roll that badly.
Wait, my cheating unit malfunctioned.
People are sort of complaining that they tend to lose this game a lot in introductory mode. I haven't found that yet. Introductory mode, I think, is a good level of difficulty. You only have four skies darkened cards in this deck. You have the free objectives and mount and Frodo with the ring. You if you use the normal characters in the first game scenario, they are very good synergizing characters, but even if you flex up the characters a little bit for introductory difficulty, you should be able to beat the game. I mean, I have lost on introductory difficulty, but usually down to a run of bad luck. If you are playing the game reasonably competently, you should win on that difficulty. And outside of those realms of bad luck, I feel like I've won more of the games on introductory mode than I have on standard because usually I've wanted to teach the game to people on introductory mode and I wanted to play it solo on that to begin with. When you up to standard mode, the difficulty does spike quite drastically. Even just the idea of having one of these five, you know, having five skies darken cards in here rather than four is quite a difficulty spike in itself. But, you know, also just like what sort of stuff can go on around the board. But, as I say, it's not so much the difficulty setting that dictates how hard the game is. It's just what goes on with the cards that dictates it. You could play an introductory level scenario and just have it play out like an extreme difficult epic length game because everything's just going bad. But then you could play it on a hard difficulty and just feel like you absolutely walked away with it because the stars are lined for you in every way. And that is what
dictates how hard the game is. Not the difficulty rating, just what this deck kind of froze at you.
Boy, that escalated quickly. The game also does feel like there's some dead actions here and there. There's not that many different actions that you can do and some of them you won't be able to do because you're not in the right location. Like there's nobody there for you to attack. There's nobody for you to give a card to, etc. So sometimes you do find that you are basically trying to figure out, well, what do I do with this character for four actions? I can't really do anything. I mean, it's detrimental to me if I move away from this location because we need to be here for this objective, but then I can't master any more troops there. I haven't got the tokens to get any more troops. I mean, am I just going to be preparing cards when I can only prepare so many and you know, that just feels like a that just feels like a bit of a meh turn. The prepare action is useful because it's good to have these tokens. But the prepare action kind of feels like the you didn't have anything fun to do on your turn, therefore do prepare.
You know, you don't really do prepare actions and go, "Well, that was an epic turn." No, it's just like, well, I ain't got nothing else better to do. I guess I'll prepare this and this and this. you know, fine. But then if you haven't got many cards in your hand, you can't even do that. So, there's going to be limits on when that's useful. And this happens more often than I would like. You know, it's not like crazy all the time. But there were times where in some of the games where I go, "All right, this character can do quite a lot, right? I've I've barely got enough actions to do what I need to do down here." And somebody else up the top is like, "Well, I'm kind of just waiting for you to hurry up and get this bit done, you know? What am I meant to do while I'm here? This is, you know, I can't do much with these characters, you know." Okay, I guess I'll just prepare. Guess I'll grab a couple of Elvis troops, you know. And, you know, sometimes it does like, you know, feel a little bit not so much constrained, but like some players do feel like they're not doing as much as others. I also find that whoever controls the Frodo character doesn't get as much fun as everybody else cuz everybody else is going around like trying to, you know, get troops and, you know, kill off armies and do objectives and stuff like that. Whereas the Frodo player basically is just move. That's basically all Frodo does. I mean, you've got like a a Hail Mary pass for putting on the ring if you're really desperate, but for the most part, your ability is just basically when you prepare, if you're in a right location, you might get another token. That's basically it.
But you've also got this problem that every time you travel, you've got to spend the self tokens or take the search roll, which could basically be a case of, oh, that search roll didn't do anything or it just completely screwed us. You know, you don't know the dice are rich going to dictate this. And that's all you do. you just move across the board and it's not, you know, rocket science to sort of tell which route you ought to take, you know, in terms of, you know, what shall I go through this route that's like, you know, fairly clean and not got many troops or should I go through this region which is completely covered in Nazoul? Well, I don't know. What do you think?
I can't do this.
You know, it's not hard to figure that out, but it's also not that fun. You know, I played a game where I controlled Frodo and Gollum. Gollum pretty much trivializes a lot of the search roles. I think he's overpowered as a character, but when you play both of them together, you're basically just right, here's Golem, here's here's Golem, here's Frodo, and just go get to the end, done. You know, there's not a huge amount of fun that you can have with those two characters as a pairing. But when somebody does have Frodo, which you know has to be a playable character in the game for obvious reasons, that one just doesn't feel like a as fun a character to play as the others. I would have probably preferred it if you had say, you know, two characters each from the lore and Frodo was just this neutral global character that only got one action a turn that everybody controlled, you know, so that you everybody got to do something with Frodo but only one action a turn. That would have been, I think, better because then you could have had more fun with the characters that are more interesting than Frodo. I mean, come on, let's face it. You know, I love the Lord of the Rings trilogy, but does anybody ever watch the trilogy and go, "Oh yeah, Frodo was my favorite character." When does that ever happen?
You know, he's a pretty dull character in the movies. He's a pretty dull character in this game as well. Fate of the Fellowship definitely has a good mix of good and bad points to say about it. I mean, a lot of people are praising this as like the game of the year for 2025. I certainly wouldn't go as far as that. For that, you are forgiving quite a lot in this game. But the negatives aren't necessarily, you know, all really nasty negatives that completely kill the enjoyment of the game. Certainly, I think the graphic design is a bit of a fail in places. The swinniness of the game does mean that you are kind of at the mercy of the game rather than, you know, feeling like your choices meant something. And, you know, there is the high difficulty spikes caused again by that Swinny lack factor.
But, you know, there's a lot to praise. there is a good amount of variety in the characters, the objectives, and both of those two combined together are going to lead to some very different playing games. You know, different game arcs or different focuses, whether it's more to do with combat or more to do with fast travel and everything. I It's a bit sucky that the end game is the exact same objective. So, you sort of play through two really good acts of a game and then you get to the last bit, which is like, yeah, we got to get this Mount Doom bit out of the way. and having to end the game on a die roll can feel a little anticlimatic, you know, like right, we've got to the end, roll and we lost, you know, it's like or and roll and we've won, you know, and sometimes you might get to the end and it's like what do I need to roll? We can't physically lose. I don't roll enough dice to lose that much hope. Okay, we win then. You know, that little feeling is a little bit, you know, problematic along with that. But it is an easy game to learn. The solo mode is pretty good fun and not a big rules teach on top of the normal multiplayer rules. You know, it's got some familiarities to pandemic.
And even though the game I think is a little constrained by some of the requirements to stick to the pandemic system, the game still feels like a Lord of the Rings game first and it's very thematic in how it operates. Yes, I didn't want to I didn't want to build the stupid dice tower, but if you want to build it, it looks cool and it adds to the theme as well. you know that I just can't be bothered to assemble an accessory I'm never going to care about. So, you know, there's some good and bad stuff here. I do think that the negatives hold this game back a bit, but I do enjoy it. I do like to play this. The random length a bit of a problem. I would like it to be a bit more constrained, but as a solo game, I could see myself playing this quite a few times. Once you get past the setup, you know, it is a bit of a problem on that regard. But overall, it's still an enjoyable game and I would give it a seven out of 10. It's a good game. You know, it's held back by some of those negatives. And I did contemplate a six.
I mean, it was tempted to give it a six. And I think it's probably a six out of 10 when you include four or five players. I think when you get to that level where it's like, oh, there is a lot going on. This game's going to take a while. There's definitely stuff happening. But, you know, you played this with people who are fans of the pandemic system, they're going to get something out of this. If they're fans of Lord of the Rings, you're definitely going to get something out of this. Certainly, that helps me in some respect. I don't think that there's a a bias with this. I mean, you could have made this any theme and I would have probably still given it a similar rating, but the fact that they didn't just paste the theme onto the game. They actually took care with it is a plus point and deserves credit for it. But, you know, the fact that the board is very cluttered, the fact that the random swinginess of how the game cards work being very unpredictable and just being very spiky with its difficulty can lead to some bad games now and again. And, you know, that stuff are negatives that have to be considered. I can't, you know, kind of fully understand how somebody can forgive a lot of those negatives and call this like a nine or a 10 out of 10 game because there's just too much holding it back for that. But the game overall is a solid game. It just has some setbacks, some setbacks to make it truly amazing, which it could have been. Like there's a bit of lost potential here, and I could see where the potential was, but it never quite meets that full level to it. But that's by no means saying it's a bad game or one I wouldn't recommend. I'd give this one a seven out of 10, though I did contemplate a six. And I think player scaling wise, the rating would go down when you get to higher length players.
One to three players, I think this is a seven out of 10 easily. four to five, probably a six out of 10, maybe even less with the five player game. I mean, you can play it with five, but oh, blime me, I have seen those games go on for decades in length. I probably would never want to, you know, I've tried it with five. It was a long game. I wouldn't want to do it again, you know. So, five probably not the recommended uh like player count for this. They they always put it on the box to sell more copies. We know this. Okay. But, you know, overall the game has more good than bad. The bad just kind of sets it back enough that I can't say, "Oh, this is amazing." And certainly, I don't quite get game of the year 2025. There's just too much here that you've got to forgive to allow yourself to think that. But it's still good. It's still got a decent amount of variety. It's still, you know, good and puzzly. It's just very sweeny, very spiky in its difficulty rating. has a bit of a graphic design issue with trying to see what is going on, particularly with the cluster, you know, of all these uh things here. And the value of the game is hampered by the fact that you've got this stupid dice tower that you just don't not need. But, you know, whatever.
I mean, that that's not affecting the rating. It's just I just would care. I would rather they sold the dice tower as a separate accessory that you could buy and make the game cheaper because not everybody cares about dice towers. Okay, sorry Dice Tower, but you know, it's your logo. Great. But Dice Towers are just not an interesting accessory. All right, so you know, those little blemishes aside, it's still a good game. I recommend it, but I do feel like it could have been so much more.
All shall love me.
So that's it for me on this episode of The Broken Mele. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my content recently with all the Beyond the Bay game expansion reviews for the South Tigris trilogy games from Garfield Games. Check out my sponsor Kiender. They got good games for sale, good prices, good delivery, good reliable service. What more do you want from a supplier of games in the UK? Uh, also check out the Patreon if you want to help support the channel, you know, in order to get games like this, which this was not a review copy. This was entirely bought out of my own pocket. You know, the Patreon helps to keep the channel running and allows me to get games like this in order to give them full reviews for you. So, by all means, thank you to everybody who does support the show. You make it possible. So, take care and remember, regardless of whether you want to throw me into Mount Doom for not giving Dice Towers respect, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.
Stupid [ __ ] hurry.