Eldritch Horror in Tight Leather Pants - A Rock Hard 1977 Review
Transcript
in rockard 1977 players take on the role of upand cominging musicians doing their best to increase their skills as a musician whilst working their 95 job during the day but once the sunsets it's time to hit the local music scene to play concerts and increase the fan base and when all the regular folk have gone to bed players will let loose and hit up some clubs to live the way a real Rockstar lives through sex candy and rock and roll all of this has done an effort to become the most legendary Rockstar of all time rockart is definitely a very simple worker placement game at its heart you know you simply place your workers out and it sort of does that vulture thing where it sort of breaks up the board by Day evening and then after hours and so everybody has to place within that specified time but unlike V culture I didn't I didn't find a lot of the mechanics particularly interesting like there there's nothing here I don't think that you haven't seen replicated in every other worker placement game today my very first opinion of this was this is kind of cool I love V culture I love the aspect of um having work placement in different being able to do different things and you see different actions to choose from I really enjoyed that part it's immersive in that way that you do feel like a rockstar or a um a budding hopeful musician by having all these different things and having to work your way up to performing in spe specific areas the novelty of it died down really quick too quickly yeah it kind of did cuz the only thing in terms of mechanics the only thing this game is sort of offering that a lot of games aren't is this very slight Pusher luck element through the use of the game's one of the
games currency candy because what happens is you place your worker down and then if the the slot allows for it you can spend a candy to basically perform twice that perform that action twice it's not exciting it's not as exciting as a pusher luck should be because what happens is you run the risk of crashing flip over a a card the Sugar Rush card and then if it tells you you can perform additional action you do and then usually you increase your your your craving by one and then you roll a die and if you get underneath your craving you're fine if you get over it you've you've crashed and the problem is that when you crash it does remember those old board games we used to play as a kid where the penalty would be to miss a turn that's what this game does you you essentially you have to go to bed early uh you miss a turn uh it wasn't fun when I was 10 and it's not fun now like it just feels like a really dated board game design element like you know that's why a lot of games that are worker placement games have a tendency to like you know you lose some victory points or this and that happen because it's not fun to not do something personally I didn't really mind the miss your turn component cuz I never crashed yeah you just get lucky it's fine I don't think it's going to get lucky I think it's one of the you're right there is Ane element of luck for sure it's a d you roll a die but it's also your choice of using candy yeah of course of course so with the push your luck element you don't push you know but then you have no problem yeah I believe in the the turtle method the turtle method t top Turtle where you slow and steady wi the race you know yeah sure
the ha the story it's true but if somebody's pushing their luck and they're doing a decent amount and they're not crashing they're going to beat you you're going to lose you will lose to somebody who's doing that but yeah it's it's it's an interesting Twist on the worker Place mechanic but but aside from that is the game is relatively shallow it it is sort of a thematic game it is a game where the entire game is its theme and if you strip it of its theme for even a second if the the veneer or the the the curtain of theme drops for even a brief moment or you get a glimpse from behind those curtains you're going to be very disappointed you're going to feel like what is this this doesn't this feels dated not all dated designs are bad there are some very classic type of mechanics that do really well and the execution of it you know makes the game play very enjoyable I for one unlike my I care more about theme than I care about amazing mechanisms and the best way to do you know compound actions and the thing I love most about the games is when it's super immersive and and like medic culture is a great example because like it's wine making which I've never really had any interest to but it's just so interesting and a unique way to look at it all and it becomes so satisfying to play it's satisfying and fun this game I had a lot of high hopes for because I think I really like it's really pretty yeah it's really pretty it's really unique I like the unique component the unique the theme and it's immersive in the way that you you know have a manager and has unique powers and all that kind of stuff but I don't I can't even pinpoint why it got not great
so quickly yeah this game is very Glitz and glamour it's very showy it's it's sort of like going to a concert with a ton of pyrot Technics and the whole band is in like it's like gu or kiss you know they are all in costume or something but then when they start singing they sound like I don't know they sound like DJ khet or something it sounds like it sounds and another one and another one it sounds bad but I did find and and this is where we'll be in complete agreement I think the first play of this game solid Aces it was fun it was good it was fun there it's it's funny cuz like when I started to approach this game the way I would approach this is going to sound like a weird comparison but let me cook here uh like Arkham Horror or or or or ALR hor where you you know you're going around this map you know fighting these monsters and you're fpp over all these cards the same game sir no I understand that but I'm saying like from a narrative perspective it when I started to look at it like oh it's kind of like Elder chore you know I'm going around and I'm just reading cards and you know nobody's impressed by a lot of the mechanics in a fantasy flight game you're there to tell a really interesting story with your friends and to have a laugh and just read this read the cards outline and be like hey guess what guys I had sex with this prostitute and now I have herpes okay maybe that's not that's not as funny but what what when you're a rockar you do you know you do you have fun no you sex with fans not with prostitute oh that's true I am not a rock star clearly but you get what I'm saying you you are essentially like you're having fun you're going around you're reading the stories and everybody's having a laugh
they're you rolling a die and and then nobody's laughing at your Misfortune when you crash but the problem with that is that at some point you you stop reading the cards you stop reading the little story to your friends you just look at what abilities it's increasing or what abilities it's decreasing and then you move on and when that happens and it will happen the game becomes dreadfully boring you know what the cool point the aspect that we love a lot of games that it's simple but somehow secretly more complex it looks this game doesn't have that it's like everything is you you see what you get what you see is what you get and the more you play it the more you recognize it like huh there's no more complex strategy that I can do there's no more creative stuff it's this is just it there's nothing inspiring us to play again you know it's you know like sometimes you'll play a game and you'll Implement a certain strategy and you're like oh I wish I would did this thing instead of that thing yeah went harded this other thing yeah and then this this game coming up I'm going to go really hard into this you don't you don't do that in this game each game does aside from the story does feel relatively the same maybe additional way of twisting this up is maybe different genres people like go down the Jazz Road versus the Clos what if like what if like yeah maybe your goal as a musician is to go and play at these big concerts but maybe a different path to Victory would be just to write brilliant songs you know that transcend Through the Ages and have and provide the player a different opportunity to do something different that still uh
adheres to the theme of being a rockstar but in a different way yeah yeah kind of choosing your objective a little bit cuz right now it just feels like doesn't really matter which player or which character you choose really matter which manager you choose it all feels say me yeah it does it does even the personal objectives I mean they're just it's parting what you're already doing on the board and it's a little it's a little boring like maybe you can you know have to debate between get promotion at work or performing at this you know small Mak a struggle yeah have some kind of different objectives different ways to get victory points so you know some things will give you more victory points immediately some things will give more victory points like down the line so having to some people would gain victory points at different pace basically so different kind of choice and more strategic options versus everything being so you what you see is what you get yeah obious you can tell a really good story within a game that mechanically is really sound and creative and interesting I don't think all thematic games have to be like really Bare Bones mechanically um I but but the theme does it really does shine through on your first play like when we first had the you get a job okay you every starts the job and it's kind of cool cuz like as the game progresses says you really do feel like yeah I'm going to I'm going to quit my job next turn and become a rock star CU I going to get my demo tap you just stop going to work that's true I just got fired I I just just I just let myself get fired every single time I play but it but it is cool it has a nice thematic touch um but but even stuff like that they it
just gets old it gets old like there needs to be something deeper something more strategic like there's so many games that we love that are so so simple way simpler than this have a lot less mechanisms than this but it doesn't get old cuz it's something deeper that you can you know like you don't you can teach somebody the game at a very high level very simply they get it but then there ways to really construct the game deep in your mind to make the game a lot more of a hook and this just feels a little lackluster and the other two big issues I have with this game are balancing and player interaction there's there's no player interaction here it's just you know you might take somebody else's Spa that they were going to take which is standard worker placement fair but one of the primary ways in which you can engage with other people is through the story in which they're telling yeah at some point you just stop carrying what the other story is being told and then at that point there's no interaction like you were sort of racing towards these objectives there's usually three objectives a production bonus a performance bonus and a a publicity bonus with the theme there's so many ways to increase player interaction oh yeah you could do collaborations yeah you could make it like almost like a pseudo Cooperative it's like competitive but there's like an element that's pseudo Cooperative where like you could play together like oh you could do you could be my opening act for and then and then you can um total your total reputation to in order to qualify for certain locations that kind of thing right there's ways to there's opportunity there make it more interesting make more attractive yeah and that way every game that you play as well will have a little bit more of a different field depending who you're playing with and the willingness to cooperate with you the players provide
the variability aside from randomly drawn cards yeah cuz the uh the cards they're random they're they're random and they're not balanced I don't understand why there's five categories of them I don't think it's necessary I think the card should have been a smaller to the whole game but and like nothing a lot of things in this game do not feel balanced like the jobs like there most jobs provide a base pay of $2 but there's just some jobs that have like this extra bonus that other jobs don't have like the trucker truck driver yeah that's my that's my first job you can just not go to work you earn the same as everybody else but you get the Bon benefit of not going to work and there's another guy this everyone you everybody canot go to work but the truck driver doesn't get fired yeah he doesn't get fired sorry and the sound engineer the sound engineer he can record I think the demo tape for less and he wors the $2 works in the music industry I know thematically it makes perfect sense but mechanically the balancing is off it is off and you'll go to some of these locations like I'm going to to slinkies to do whatever and we're not slinkies but like you're going backstage to to party or something like that and somebody else will get all these like Wicked benefits and you'll turn it over and you'll get like nothing you got herpes yeah or even like yeah that's right or even the Sugar Rush card there's like I think there's one or two sugar rush cards in here that don't provide an extra action that's I there that's whack yeah and like some of the it's right it's whack there are just some abilities of the of the the perform performers that you can play because each there's different characters that you have and they have different player Powers some are just better than others
and sometimes their abilities co uh align with the public objectives perfectly and that is not fun it is not fun when you see somebody across from you who has the perfect player ability the perfect manager and and and a public objective they can easily obtain it's annoying it's luck sure but it's annoying yeah the first play really was a win for us and if it can find that way to reignite that spark it can really be um a fantastic game for a lot of people and because of that I would give it a six six I think it's fair yeah it's it's hard cuz like upon first play it'll be higher oh yeah s but then it went down it dropped yeah and I'm afraid to keep playing because I feel like I'll keep going down yeah there's nothing here to keep me invested on multiple plays you know can I recommend that you buy this game I do not I do not recommend you buy this game I recommend you play this game I think it's a great game to play for your first time whether it's a board game cafe or a convention or you're heading over to a friend's house you know have a few drinks have some laughs you will have laughs you will have fun um but if you purchase this game would you you still enjoy it a year from now I highly doubt it I highly doubt it because as I said when you strip the theme and at some point you will see through the theme and you will just see those mechanics you'll see a game that's like a three or four but the theme is really good the theme is really really good and I understand that it is trying
to tell a story and I I I do appreciate that I do appreciate that it's sort of like those old Fantasy Flight games yeah so for all that I I give this I I'm with Kim I give it a I give it a six it's it's a middle of the road game um nothing too amazing but it's definitely worth experiencing at least one time so tabletop Turtle does not recommend rockard 1977 we think it's a great game to experience one time whether that's at a board game cafe or a Convention Center or at a friend's house you'll have fun you will have fun uh but we can't recommend purchasing it because it it doesn't have replayability it doesn't have a lot of replayability even though there's a bunch of variety of cards it just it's it's somewhat lacking so it's like a very novel thing it's funny because of the novelty yeah exactly so that's it for tonight see you in the next one thank you so much for watching bye dad hell Cherry bom