Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ark Nova | Is It The Game of the Year? | Overview and Review (Episode #62)

Transcript 32:57

i think there's a very serious issue in this game i i have one serious issue with this game hello everybody my name is ilya and my name is tyler together we make up clavre i said that really weird but we're a couple that loves to play board games board games now today we're going to be talking about a potential game of the year yeah it's been up and everywhere everybody's talking about it it's hard to get a hold of a very up up up pop up i don't think i've ever seen a game climb the board game geek rankings as high as as fast as our time gloomhaven draws the line went really fast but it's because there was uh uh preston kind of set by gloomhaven but this is uh yeah i don't think we've seen game no i i haven't paid enough attention until recently well the game we're talking about is arc nova so this was designed by matthias wig and it was published by capstone games and what it is is basically you're building a zoo yeah and you're making sure that you're having uh conservation efforts as well so you're not just putting animals in cages you are a good humanitarian an adamantarian an uh humanitarian humanitarian i think that would be this is it encompassing yes this game is too big so we're gonna now we're gonna move the box and we'll keep talking about it uh yeah so like ilia said is it's a game

about zoo azu building zoos you're basically competing against each other to see who can make the best zoo by achieving the most appeal and the most conservation so you want to try and like balance the two to also we'll talk about the scoring later on but this game is just uh it's heavy it's fun it's long there's a lot going on but first it's fun heavy and long oh what is that supposed to mean i don't know that's what you said yeah because it's a long game and it's fun to play well let's just heavy weight well let's give you a quick overview of how to play as always you'll begin by setting up you'll receive a zoom app action cards and components in your color as well as you'll draw two final scoring cards and eight zoo cards of which you'll choose four to keep and discard the other four you'll then set up the main board so it looks like this now your goal in arc nova is to obtain appeal conservation and reputation in order to have the most successful zoo when one player's appeal and conservation tracks meet the game end is triggered all the other players will get one final turn and final scoring will begin now let's learn how to play the game is played in turns with occasional breaks that will occur throughout the game on your turn you'll play one of your five action cards now depending on where that action card is an associated

strength is matched right here now you can adjust your strength using these x tokens which can be gained throughout the game you can also upgrade your action card throughout the game which makes the action stronger now let's go over all the actions cards allows you to obtain cards throughout the game these can be either done from the deck or sometimes even from the grit through the snap action upgrading your cards will allow you to draw cards from the reputation or the deck where the first cost is only from the deck you'll also have to move the break counter twice when you use the card's action now the sponsor's action card will allow you to play sponsor cards from your hand depending on the strength of the sponsor's action it'll also allow you to gain money tokens by taking a break corresponding to the action spot now upgrading your sponsor's card will allow you to play one or more sponsor cards as long as the total level of strength is x plus one you can also play sponsor cards from reputation range as well or you can break for double the money now building will allow you to build standard enclosures kiosks and pavilions into your zoo you'll build one building with a maximum size of what the strength is and pay 2 money per space now when placing buildings you'll have to place them adjacent to existing buildings kiosk will generate you more money throughout the breaks and pavilions will increase your appeal now upgrading the building card will allow you to build one or more different buildings as long as the total maximum is the strength of the card as well as

special enclosures will be available to you including the large bird aviary and the reptile house now the animals action will allow you to play animal carts from your hand but before you do that you have to make sure you meet the three criteria you'll check to see if the conditions on the left side of the card are met you'll have to make sure you have enough money to pay for the animal which is the cost indicated in the upper left corner and you'll have to make sure that there is an empty enclosure that is corresponding to the size of that animal now if you meet all those conditions you can pay the cost and get the animal to put into the enclosure placing it face up by your board now at that point you'll execute any of the effects that the animal may have upgrading the animal card will allow you to play more animals at lower strengths as well as get a reputation when playing a five strength animal action you'll also be able to play animals from your hands or from your reputation range but there'll be additional cost depending on where on the reputation track you're playing these cards from last but not least is the association action card playing this card will allow you to perform exactly one association task now these include increasing your reputation gaining a partner zoo which discounts the animals you play based on the region they're from gaining a partner zoo university which increased reputation grant research icons are the only way to increase your hand limit to five cards instead of three and do some conservation project work now this is one of the primary ways to

get conservation in this game you can support a conservation project already in play or play a conservation card from your hand to support it immediately now you'll place one player token of your choice from the left side of the player zoom on the condition you fulfill and as a reward you'll advance your conservation counter and reputation counter if applicable as per the depicted award on the card now when you take that player token from your zoom app you'll also activate the corresponding bonus some are one-time bonuses while others are one-time and ongoing every break now when taking the association action you'll need at least one association worker on the notepad of your zoom app you'll place that worker in the corresponding action space now if one of your association workers already on this task you can instead place two to perform this task if three of your association workers are here you may not perform the task at this time however the association workers do come back every break now upgrading the association action allows you to perform one or more different association tasks as well as make a donation your strength still has to match up to what they are but the donation is a strength free action so you can donate some of your money to obtain a conservation each time you do the association action and you'll do these in order on the left side of the board now at the end of your turn when you've taken the action you'll shift the card back to strength space number one and shift all the cards to fill in the gaps this is how the strength will cycle throughout your game now if you choose not to take any of the actions you can also obtain one x token

you'll still have to choose one of the five cards and move it to the first space now as you move on various tracks on the board you'll get various upgrades this includes some decision on the conservation track as well as some bonuses on the reputation track now when the coffee reaches the break space it's time for a break the player who triggered the break will obtain an x and the following steps will be taken in order first you'll discard cards down to your hand limit three or five if you have the special university marker you'll then remove all the tokens on the action cards if there were any these can include multiplier venom or constriction tokens you'll refill the association board with any corresponding tokens you'll then replenish the display discarding the two bottom cards and then shifting all of them down finally you'll take income you'll obtain income from your spot on the appeal track kiosks which will earn you one money for each unique building special enclosure occupied standard enclosure and pavilion adjacent to it or any cards that have the income symbol you'll then return the break track back to the player account and keep going now the game ends when a player's conservation counter and appeal counter meet or surpass each other at that point all other players will take an additional churn and then scoring can begin first you'll score the cards in your zoo area as well as the final scoring cards then you'll determine victory points the way the victory points are determined is by looking at the area where your

conservation counter is located you'll find the lowest appeal value in that scoring area this is now your target number you'll compare your target number to the value of your appeal counter subtract the target number from your appeal value and the result is your victory points the player with the highest positive victory point is the winner will your zoo draw people from all over the world and have the most magnificent conservation and efforts something like that yes mine will or do you call it a zed a zoo just because we're from canada and say z's like zed does not mean we say zoo differently does that mean americans say is ado okay so what do you think about our nova i think it meant the hype yeah i agree so i think i i tried personally i don't know if you did i tried not really looking into the mechanics understanding game-winning whatsoever all i knew is it's a game about building a zoo and initially i i'm not a huge zoo supporter i don't love zoos i think the whole putting animals in cages is often very not good and a lot of zoos do a really poor job of it this game actually kind of spins it on its head because i think the conservation of animals is such an important factor here and you can't win without doing a good job in the conservation efforts which then really celebrates the love of

animals i think she kind of puts that whole theme on its head so i really that was a good surprise because i didn't expect that i'm like you know it'll still be a cool game let's check it out yeah there's got like a there's a lot of things you can do in the game that like really motivate like partnerships with other countries so that you can work together to do certain things uh mr worldwide yeah worldwide so you can focus more on research and breeding programs kind of thing so it's just like it's very i think aware of what's going on um with particular species and it like brings she has a bit of light on it well while maintaining like the fun aspect of it as well yeah absolutely yeah well i guess let's dive and see if there's any comparables that we can compare it to before we kind of get into the the gritty the gritty why is it gonna be the game of the year what are some of the factors okay but what are some of the comparables for you who what would you compare this to well i think i think i've been hearing just like a lot of people compare it to this game and i do see i do see the alignment so i will say terraforming mars okay and the reason i say that is because the deck in arc nova like the game itself is heavily reliant on the cards that you have you have to be able to properly hand manage use the cards appropriately to collect yourself the most points and almost like build like a engine resource type thing and arc nova you do a very similar thing

you have to use your resources and your income to pay to play these cards to build on your uh little um board that is yours yeah your big zoo um and then like similar to terraforming mars where you can pay to like increase heat place down ocean tiles place down um cities and such like there are these things that are happening except now you have your own zoo instead of having to play on that main board yeah i can see that i think it terraformed mars aries especially because of the actual action sequence i think that like even that kind of speaks to me as well uh i think my comparable and this one's a bit out there so bear with me with you i think it reminds me a little bit of scythe and the reason i say that maybe i'm wrong maybe you can say like that doesn't make sense but the reason i say that is in scythe you have kind of one of the four areas you can go to and here and based on the area and what you have unlocked you can kind of take an action and take more potentially if you invested more into it here your actions are in one of the five cards but kind of the le the if you haven't taken the action for a while it's worth more and you can take more out of it and it kind of and then you can also upgrade those actions as well and have them be better in the game so that's kind of my loose comparison that's yeah like it's loosely there but it's i like i think that's what really drew me to scythe is that you have those actions you can upgrade those action and that's the drive of the game where i think here it's very similar because a lot of the

times i felt oh like i really want to use this action but it's not time yet and how like doing all these feels like it's a waste of a turn because i want to do this and i can't so like how do i progress that is either using cards or what can i do to upgrade or like do that better yeah sometimes x's or other things so that's my comparable yeah i think that's fair would you validate i think i i think it's okay i think the action sequence in this game is particularly um like well it's one of the main things that you have to do yeah and being able to optimize that upgrade the right cards because in no instance are you able to upgrade all five that's true uh so you have to choose choose appropriately based on what you're given and there's a lot of different things that go into that decision and sometimes you end up making the wrong choices because early on you have no idea what you might be up to so now let's get to the heart of it is this the game of the year and what makes it the game of the year right okay so um does it does it me it obviously meets the hype in my opinion but why is it such a great game and is it the game of the year yeah i like i can't think of many other games that have skyrocketed like arc nova um just like in the public eye and personally uh this year alone arc nova has probably ha has to probably be my favorite game so far like it's bold um it's between that and wayfarers but wayfarers is technically not like it's not fulfilled yet so it's

like it's not out so i don't know if it's a competitor it hasn't flown the height yeah exactly well but it hasn't so um i think for me uh it the theme of it because i think initially i love animals animal games win me over immediately zoo games uh so then i started getting kind of kind of what i said earlier is i'm like okay like i'm gonna like because it's animals but it's zeus but the fact that there's such a hard like efforts in conservation and actually kind of remedying that whole zoo rhetoric that's it sold me instantly there's a ton of animals in this game there's so many different cars so many different species each of them can can interact a little bit differently like it the theme of it just absolutely sold me um yeah it is pictures of animals which is interesting because if you don't we often love our art and games but i think it works here like i think it works it makes it also there's so many cards that i think it's different for them all to be able to impress you that'd be the extra deluxe edition yeah you have to make it a thing there are so many cards yeah yeah the theme here is i think it was questionable when i first heard about it but now it's not so questionable i think i understand where they're coming from i think they did a good job with the tile placement which i guess kind of brings me to my neck or the next point that i would bring up in this so the theme is really great but i think like the mechanics in this game just feel like they flow really really well it feels very smooth you know that you have to take your action sequences and it all kind of just like makes sense so

from that perspective the first thing i will say is even though it's a long and heavy game once you understand the flow mechanically it's an easy game to teach in an easy game game to play again i agree so i think that's one of the things that has going for it the other thing is that it combines a lot of different mechanics so you've got resource manage well resource hand management i guess you have tile placement that you have to be aware of and then you've got like um set collection essentially and i think like those three are extremely popular games and maybe because it's been being compared to terraforming mars so much that like those are maybe maybe those are just like the really popular um mechanics amongst the amongst gamers and i think um when you put them all together and you do it well then people start to notice people start to talk and sometimes it is just word of mouth but it really is um a really well smoothie this is a smooth game i think what i'll say for that because i 100 agree with that uh but what i think i'll say is that it look it seems to me what the designer has done is looked a lot of these mechanics a lot of other games that use them and just fine tweak little things to really elevate the experience squeeze fine-tune yeah so the example i'll give here is the hand size for example the hand limit is three or five if you upgrade yeah which seems really small but because you're able to use the cards on the board like i think it just gives you more strategic depth because i remember there's a lot of games similar to this where i'm holding on to 11 cars and i'm paralyzed at what i'm gonna play yeah that's true so i really

like that's a really smart element and i feel like there's a lot of smart decisions like that in the game even though the way that the tile placement works is you can easily correlate which animals which and do a quick countdown to see like if they still match filling up your zoo there's a lot of small things that just really stick with me and i really like that yeah yeah and like even to that point is like they're because there's a lot of going on a lot going on like you think it would be overwhelming it would be like something that uh is hard to like actually pick up and keep going with but no like just be the way they've done it and the way they fine-tuned it um they've just done a really good job at i think uh highlighting those mechanics and then it starts just it starts simply just from the action sequencing actually sequencing is just the best yeah those five actions are so straightforward you just need to choose when to use them and then like the what ends up happening is in my opinion in great games is that like you have to be able to when you replay it you can tell that you're getting better and better at these games and it just feels uh really really nice when you go through this action sequence because it's just it's another piece that just makes the game so simple yeah it's so complex and i love the planning aspect of it too because the games where you can plan something and all of a sudden you make a move and you move on this track you get the bonus here the bonus gives you this extra thing which means you can do this and this like those chain combinations are the creme de la creme of the board game wow so and this game has it and it's happened multiple times you just love it

yeah and we even talked about the variability of this game yep lots of maps yeah lots of maps lots of cards lots of cards but yeah let's stick with the maps for a minute because i think like so they set you up pretty nicely there's a starter map which basically your first game and then you will not play that map really again because then there's the game that's after the starter map once you play for the first time this is a map you should use yeah but then there's one like all the eight maps that you have they're different and they have little various abilities that really influence your gameplay in quite a big way yeah they definitely like uh the other day we were playing i got one map that i um i didn't really i didn't really pay attention to much of the ability that was going on and then i realized halfway through the game that like i should really be driving home this ability because it's a strategy within the strategy of already collecting the cards planning your zoo and everything like that and i think i missed the mark on it because of that so it's very it it doesn't force you down a lane yeah but it it really like motivates you particularly when there's going to be close games where like you know you probably should have at least utilized it better it's gonna drive your strategy for sure and there's and it's interesting because it's themed as well which is really cool but enough of us absolutely loving this game true what are some of the reasons that this game may not be the best game the game of the year the best game doesn't deserve the hype what are some of the critical aspects of it i do have one yeah go for it i think there's a very serious issue in this game i i have one serious issue with

this game too and i think it's your serious issue that i'm actually signifying it probably is let's hear it there's no otters in this game no otters there's a sea lion i actually think there's a martin or a minx which is a family of an otter but there's no otter now i've heard there may be an aquarium expansion in the morning but an otter is an essential animal and it should have been in this game otter's not being in the game it sucks i get it sometimes they just don't make the cut get tyler and water promo card exactly and there are a lot of otters out there you could have included any one of them how many species of water 15 anyways anyways okay that's besides the point okay what are some what some of the uh my first critique is the fact that there are so many cards so particularly if like you're looking for certain cards because you've already got a board that is like ideal or maybe there's like base conservations or conservation cards in your hand or conservation car or project cards on the table like there's a lot a lot of things that are going on um but if you never draw that card that you need or draw cards that you do that benefit you then it feels really really bad and i think particularly maybe it helps when you play four players but in a two-player game we've never gone through the day no we'll go through like maybe a third of it so we don't see those cards and the worst part about it is like after you play it a bunch of different

times you know the cards that are there you know which ones you're really looking for and how do you get to them there's no way so i think to me that that that's like that's a flag because it because it draws it drives a bit of randomness and i i would have a pre i would have appreciated the more like uh focus in on being able to like actually successfully do your strategy now maybe maybe some of the strategies stronger than the others so like it has to happen like there are a lot of reasons that it could that it makes sense but i don't think i agree and i think the reason i don't agree is because i think that's the whole like kind of adaptability because there's a lot of cards that do the same they're very similar thing but i would argue but it bears yeah there's there's a lot of there's not a lot of bears but i think it's like you're absolutely right that you may not like even though you're not you may not draw any north american countries and have the conservation yeah for north america like that's super valid but i think i love that there's lots of cards because it means that every game like because at one point like i i know like myself you know what you're looking for well no and like i remember like consciously making a decision to be like i have not seen any australia continents right like there's that goal i initially went for it i have one i'm going to give up on it because it's just not worth it for me to kind of continue so i'm going to pivot because i've drawn this new card so like i like that and that's what i like like with a lot of like i think that's why i also really like terraforming mars is because no game really feels the same because of that because there's so many different

layers of strategy you can create but i hear you of like the frustration behind not drawing yeah like cars i think maybe like with the base conservation sure whatever but like if you've built your board up to like i don't know one of the ones is like you have to have a certain number of like primates in your zoo and if you're one off yeah because you've been going for it the whole game and then you can't find your last one like maybe it's in the extreme situations i'm thinking of but you've paid for that card because and now it's an end game goal that's true so you've you've essentially what you've done is you've wasted a turn and then arguably every other primate you played after that was a waste of a turn because you couldn't have got there anyways that's fine but i mean like that's part of it right like i get it part of the game i think it's just the critique that i would give it um what would your ideal deck size be like because i think right now there's 250-ish carts maybe like 150 150 yeah so i'm not saying that it shouldn't be any smaller i'm just saying that this is a critique of mine okay so the critique that i have is this is a long game yeah and i think it is um to be honest i don't think i would want to really play it more than two players the two players the two player experience like you get everything you need to get from it like i think with and we haven't actually had the chance to play it like a full player account yet yeah so i'm curious how that will compare and what the length of that will be because there is a lot of the times that you have to

make a critical decision it takes a little bit longer to think through all the choices that you can make forced into a break or be forced into a break yeah and the breaks but like and i think it does scale up the game scales up appropriately for the player count uh but the length of it might be a return for some folks yeah it a hundred percent will i think because like the first time when we played it i think it took us what two and a half hours but that was like two years yeah and well with learning so we were sitting there learning it i think we've got it down to like an hour hour and a half ish maybe but like i don't think it's exciting two hours to play the game that's crazy but who knows i don't know it is regardless it's a long game yep and um i think that brings me to my next critique actually okay after playing a long game like that you think you would be excited to see what you score right i don't like this critique and um sometimes you end up with negative points now okay don't get me wrong i get it it's how the scoring model is set up you have to like pass on the um conservation and then pass on your appeal and then you basically take the difference yes i get it i like it and i've never scored negative you got zero i got zero i got zero and that's not negative that's not negative i have scored negan anyways anyways so like what you can end up doing is if somebody ends the game um and then you haven't passed then you end up getting negative points and that can feel really bad if you if you've played a game like for so long and i think i think so i like i i hear

you but i think what i'll say is when i first i think i feel like i like this game i'm not meaning to like disagree with all the creatures i'm nitpicking at this point i think what i'm trying to say is i think that one of the few things i heard about this game because i've tried to like not really read reviews not really know anything about it because i i have heard that exact critique is like oh it can be such a long game against a point so i'm like oh no how can this be but really it's not a big deal at all because of the like it's not like you're working like negatively backwards and you're losing no no it's the way that they connect and yeah sometimes you're gonna get negative five or negative six which is not a bad score no it's not if the winning score is maybe two yes like so sometimes that differential is not so like don't let that be a deterrent until you've played the game if you've played the game and you felt really bad for getting negative points very valid yeah but i think like from an app like i had another misconception based on that review from other phones so i really want to kind of flag that yeah yeah that's fair you're not lose it doesn't because i know games where you lose points sometimes feel bad that's not the case you don't lose because of the scoring well okay you you you do lose you do lose points in this game but it's not it's like it's like mostly when you're really because you

yeah and you lose points in one area but you actually end up gaining points in others so like um yeah it works out to be uh it works out um but i'm just saying that if i played a two-hour game and i got negative points it is it is actually a funny concept if you were like to tell like say we talked to your mother and she's like oh like what do you play and she's like oh what was the final score and you're like zero three yeah she's like what are you doing with your life this whole time playing hockey yeah i just i i'm not saying it's a bad thing because you arguably you can look at it um as two different scoring things yep and then at the end of it you just take the difference and then if you do well you do well yeah but um i love the scoring in this game i think it's reminding

do it and i really enjoy when they do because i think you can have a higher appeal lower uh conservation kind of do both and do the mix because i think there's times i've been on opposite sides yeah we've been opposite side of the scoreboard and like it is it is essentially just like at least your strategy yeah and then whoever yeah exactly the boards the cards on your board like it just leads to exactly that your strategy okay well finally before we leave off to our question of the day does arc nova meet the game of the year title right now it's only may but i think it does i i don't i don't see why i wouldn't i i it's hard to find people love it people are raving about it it's moving up in the charts i've really enjoyed this game so um and we've played it a lot we have played um like that points there i think for me because like my argument would be you have to have a game that's true and that's what i'm trying to think so i think for me definitely it could be i think i'll definitely hit that top 10 of 2022 for me i really don't see any like i don't ah actually i i challenge it for there to be ten other games that kind of surpass this experience for me um but in general i think there's just so many things this game does well and when it had high expectations going in and met them for me so i'm excited to see how i feel about it over time when we play it even more and start to show to people i think that will be that will be a breaking point is it a two-player that we'll come back to that that'll be

like our pinned comments in a few months once you've played it at full player count and tried it a few times we'll come back and kind of leave a comment and say do we think this is more catered towards like a two-player experience or do we even enjoy it even more that'll be your update yeah exactly but for a question of the day i just want to know if you've played arc nova like do you think it meets the hype uh or if it doesn't like what did you wish that done better um yeah just like give us your thoughts do you want to play it like is it even up your alley um yeah well thank you so much for watching if you enjoyed our content you know what to do hit that like button hit that subscribe button we make videos a weekly and we're always excited to share our board gaming experiences with you folks and listen to the stories that you have to tell us and then keep uh your minds open that's not what i'm trying to say keep an eye on yourself prepare yourself because we will be announcing what our theme for the long month and there's been some rumors oh yeah we may have even mentioned it here and there but our announcement today is it's gonna be july it will be in july but what will the theme be uh yeah so for those of you who don't know we did a roll in right month last month last year and we're gonna do another month of games specific types of games this year is it mechanic is it a theme is it who knows designer we do know it's in july we do so keep an eye open and we'll see you around soon exactly until next time though this is us checking out

bye you

Progress saved