Skip to main content
Loading video...

Defenders of the Realm: Discussion

Transcript 29:48

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for defenders of the realm and subsequently uh the dragon expansion um because i think all the other expansions are literally just hero expansions yeah uh so this game uh came out uh as you know uh was a century no what's what's ten years ago it feels like a century a decade thank you it feels like it came out a century ago uh in the board gaming world because ten years is a long time in in this hobby uh to where you really see how bad games were back then no this is obviously a revolutionary game when it came out i'm just going to go ahead and say for me this is not a game i would want to play today because at this point so many games have come out that just do what this game does and it's it's just better um and we say it's for a lot of games it's like why play this game whenever you can play you know five others um uh funny enough for you and i would just kind of talk about sorcerer city totally different game but i'm like oh was it [ __ ] you're like nah there's just games that do what it does better um so it's always hard to do reviews for for these kinds of games that are aged because it's like do you do you review them as if it was 10 years ago or do you review them now or try and do a mix of both i say

both i think the first step would be acknowledge that this is a building block of uh the hobby of a lot of people and so it does that well because the reason i say because when when how long ago did you play this for the first time do you remember like five years right ago and even then i kind of feel like it was aged at that point i played this when it first came out yeah and then went from there you know perfect stuff so so we'll get a little bit of a touch on uh both aspects but i will say that uh this game is aggravating for me personally in many ways because it's just one of those it's i mean the design was there was no mitigation in games like this it was all about just randomness and that gave you variety because you never saw the same thing but the way the game it's either really difficult or really easy um just depending on how the cards come out and i for me i just don't think that's fun it's like you can't strategize and win cooperatively when you have absolutely zero control over every aspect of the game um die rolls uh hero cards and uh darkness cards are all completely random and there's very few ways to mitigate it like with the special cards that like that you happen to have where it's like oh hey you can reroll failed results yeah that was that was like your one special card that he happens to start with or that you happen to start with and it's like great yeah that came in handy but that's

our one card for the entire game um you have no control over where people are going you have no control over uh the quest cards you get quest cards are also random and those can be [ __ ] or really good uh but you don't have to work for them on top of doing everything else so it's it's just it's just frustrating um whenever you're trying to be like hey let's try and win cooperatively but you really just kind of throw caution to the wind whenever it's like well it doesn't really matter what we do because even even the good card that we drew throughout the run through after planning okay if he doesn't move we can kill this guy and we draw a card it's like this is a good card no it's not because it would have pulled all of us into and it's like so we just wasted this entire turn um or actually multiple turns to try and plan for this so it's just annoying but uh what do you guys think i mean i i like it just because it's just it like it's very simple it's very straightforward um the randomness of it is is a lot to be it gives you the chance to be really frustrated at it but um i mean just for being a basic game um it doesn't really stand the test of time but i have fun like i i didn't not have fun so there was a there was like a tipping point for me i was like yes this is really fun and then it was almost it was almost with that the the darkness card where i was just

like okay my fun just just plummeted yeah uh and i should preface all this with saying [ __ ] the dragon expansion yeah it is dog [ __ ] richard lonius you suck at expansions i think i think it was just the fact of trying to make it uber challenging because back then it was like with a lot of those games is like cooperative most people are playing this cooperatively you know so cooperative games are supposed to be really really hard yeah people trying you know and stuff and i think yeah it because you see those with like robinson caruso and ghost stories where it's like uh super punishing games but it's like not many people are masochists and they would still want to have a chance of winning while also being challenged so it's a fine balance yeah and the dragon expansion does not have that balance it's just hope you get lucky and win that way otherwise you're just gonna lose and for many games it's just like i want to feel like i didn't waste my time you know where it's like hey let's strategize and it's like oh man ooh like aeons and for example perfect balance of a cooperative game that's challenging and you still have a chance of winning um even though there's still randomness in that game it's like oh okay we might have a chance but we also have a chance of equal chance of losing here it's like yeah it's about seventy percent and seventy five eighty eight ninety percent chance they're going to lose um with the dragon expansion completely uh brad what do you think this game where it doesn't stand the test of time

you know i mean i i prefer base game obviously like we said i play the base game pretty much exclusively just because it has a higher winner win percentage where it's still challenging it's it's just it doesn't feel as crushing yeah i put games like this into the same category as let's say um talisman for you okay and stuff like that you know like it feels like i still like the game not the dragon space necessarily but i love the game because of what it does and because of when i you know it was one of my early games that i got into and stuff like that yeah um but it definitely feels older yeah um not even just the way it looks actually i i really don't mind i actually kind of like the board um the board art because it it has that very old-school d and d magic the gap yes i was i was just thinking how much i love the aesthetic of the game yeah i don't even i mean mine like it looks like obviously if you saw you'd be like wow this looks dated but i think it works i kind of like the hey in this area there's the fourth it just zooms in onto that i i kind of like it yeah well and then it's confusing the first time you play it trying to remember where everything is yeah it takes a little bit it doesn't help that most of the cards are misprinted where you're looking at it and it's like oh okay i need to find wyvern forest that's blue where is blue it's not blue it's green okay so that sucks um so it's one of those things you know like this is

this was a um this game spawned a lot of stuff with the richard lonnie's you know like we both went whole hog into uh freedom five yeah which is going to be kind of the everything that's happened with this and the defenders of the last stand and stuff like that oh he's learned from you know and then it's over ten years hopefully it's culminates into a great uh right with freedom fights with the sadler bros right yeah that's the other guy that's that's all sudden i'm like who made that game with him it was a named person so this using this deal and and again this is like pandemic i mean it has some of the pandemic stuff to it you know which pandemic came out 2012 i want to say i'll look that up while you keep going but um this one's just i like the custom customization of this game as well because 2008 okay um yeah so pandemic came for i think they kind of used a little bit okay yeah this came out two years later um but uh the customization of this game to make it harder or easier they give you ways in the rulebook saying you know like with this there's a way to make this you could start with royal blessings you can start with more stuff to make this easier you know i mean i kind of made it easier for this playthrough because you're not supposed to have any all those quiet cards in there at all right um so yeah i mean it's it's brutal the minions are a lot tougher in this than the base game the i think i think what makes it what

makes it difficult or at least the dragon expansion specifically is that the war status cards is that these are these are the only or like the darkness spreads cards the generals already kind of rapidly move well actually brimstone is the only one who doesn't just beeline it to monarch city uh he's actually setting fire which i like i like the variety with him because it's kind of like man do we go after him do we leave it alone uh but onyx sapphire and hemlock all of them just are four spaces away you can very much draw four cards in a four player game each person just happens to draw right green and then you just lose and with no ways of cancelling it except the wizard can potentially mitigate it on his turn um but the war status is just kind of like it i think it's too even because this is in the base game even that's the same one yeah and it it's like i wish that for the dragon expansion a new war status came out because when you kill one dragon it's like well there's just no way one gen multiple generals are going to be moving and when they're four spaces away that just increases your odds and you're you you can't finish quest quick enough you can't gather cards because they're random anyway like we potentially might have been able to kill him if uh if the monk happened to draw black cards then it's like oh okay like uh

then let's let's at least attempt to kill him because then we'll only have to worry about sapphire moving but drawn two darkness spreads that just increases your odds especially with how quickly they move yeah literally the next two cards were two black right this is not i mean yeah it's great if we killed him because that means it's only minion spreads but i wish the one complaint with the placement like they picked a new placement for brimstone yeah a different starting spot than where the base game guy starts i wish there was a way and i haven't really mastered out the look but sapphire almost needs to start like in the furthest away ghost marsh or something yeah wait because of how difficult because when she comes out as in this scenario when she comes out as the general she has what eight life yes and you only can hit her on five pluses yeah you know um and your ability wouldn't have worked your six would only still count as one hit you know specifically against that so she is so difficult and if you're pulling cars it doesn't even matter because i was just mapping it out real quick no matter where she starts it's four spaces away still like even the first ghost marshes one two three four which is nice for hero movement that really besides the ends are nothing attached to the end except one location is it's not impossible for characters to just quickly get around which is nice um especially with the way oh i'm gonna spin this to you do eagle and move four spaces um so so that is nice but

but yeah i would have almost liked with the dragon expansion because they made brimstone do something different with him moving around it'd be cool if all the other dragons besides sapphire did something unique right uh with their movement instead of oh no they just they do have you know the unique minions but their movement to how you lose is the same it would make more thematic sense i guess that saf you lose if sapphire gets to monarch city right uh that that dithers down the darkness spreads a little bit more because it's only sapphire who's gonna be lined it but the other ones still [ __ ] you know with everything else like the fire tokens it would have been really cool if i think that would wear poison and like darkness yeah like fear or whatever yeah that would have been like just have all those tokens yeah it'd be a little samey but may have them dude like fire you have to spend extra actions to put it out and you take a damage if you're in there um maybe fear makes you get rid of cards poise or poison makes you get rid of cards fear makes you lose actions like that would have been really cool because then the board starts these are like because these aren't the gen i mean they're generals but these are like the henchmen really to sapphire so it'd be cool if they all were doing her bidding and [ __ ] over the land and then sapphire is if she makes it to monarch city then you lose and the interesting thing is is because we played scenario one and this is like introducing this is the dragon's rampaging what incentive is the other one but i think scenario two is realm in flames you know

it's there's the fire dragon brimstone uh is unleashed and unleashed him with an independent agent to turn the realm into an inferno so he comes out with lord valazarg which is a guy oh he's the he's a green guy isn't he uh red oh red okay so he said that makes sense so he'd be d you know demons sapphire comes out gorget which is the green he's the gay guy and then onyx so there's two dragons and two to reveal which changes up the wheels and there's different setup rules for that and then there's there's a uh scenario three's called onslaught so there's different stuff and then there's the land is dying and the burning lands and how many scenarios are there it looks like five five five yeah and maybe it's just that once the dragon's rampaging is just it's too difficult it's it's one of the reasons why i don't like ghost stories because i was like the game's impossible well yeah because it's literal randomness like it's a to me it's a faux difficulty it's like well we don't really want to put any rules or actually come up with mechanics to make it hard so how about we just add in dice and random card draw and it's like yeah i guess yeah that that does make it hard but i don't i personally don't like that i like my idea now because of just sapphire because you might once see once again no matter where she's at right it's three or four spaces to get there so you can still lose with four sapphire draws but having these guys do other stuff um would just to me just makes thematic sense because you still have to kill them and

you still that's how you win that makes her easier to kill so yeah taking out the other ones right and it it lessens the the fire coming out or the poison or the fear instead of just oh they're all trying to get to monarch city creative so the dragon expansion i really don't like uh and we've played the base game years ago like years ago uh and yeah the base the base game is fine it's it's like it's base pandemic um a little bit uh and if i'm not mistaken the base game generals it's been a while with the the orc uh what was it a necromancer there's like that yeah it's like an it's like a necromancer type yeah they're undead yeah and it's a different dragon it's not it has totally different abilities yeah than that she's yeah and they they all did something a little bit different yes which yeah is is a little bit nice yeah one thing that i love about this game besides i actually we we talked about on the top 10 one time where i think you were advocating for the art if they were because at the time they were going to remake it and you were and i was saying they should up they should change it relooking at it i actually really like the old old art it fits the game because the game feels like an older style game exactly um even i kind of really like it just feels especially because i play dnd a lot it just feels like going back to old school

d and d uh but one of the things that i love are the characters so uh and if you get the expansions there's a bunch of them my cat play the paladin because their character in d is a paladin i picked eagle rider because that's never a class that is in any any game um and then the monk because i like monks but all kinds of interesting ones in there yeah cause you got ranger barbarian dwarf i mean your basic rogue cleric uh this one's just weird adventure around wait till you get to the cat one right elf lord uh thief which i don't know how that's any different from a rogue but it's a more nefarious road yeah the rogue that's not silly captain of the guard assassin seeker sorceress chaos wizard oh that's cool that's where there's chris yeah he looks uh wanda from one division uh no it's it's uh i couldn't think of a i was trying to twist wanda into a male name uh wendell when yeah wendell wendell uh maximoff yeah so chaos wizard the shaman druid healer and feline feeling you're just a kid yeah so i mean i i just think that's when feline rolls a natural one in combat you may re-roll each natural one

one time if the second roll's at one she may not re-roll again so yeah like they all feel unique uh which is a huge testament because back i mean for a game i mean grant the expansions for the heroes didn't come out at the same year that the game came out but it's really cool that unique abilities like that uh because i mean the eagle rider feels completely different than from the monk and the paladin and the wizard and stuff like that there's no like overlapping abilities so i like the variety of all all the heroes yeah i mean that's i'm trying to think that's that's pretty much it like i can't really think of like anything really to anything else to really say about the game uh dragon expansion sucks i don't really like it uh but yeah i mean it is it's a fine based game but it does show its age yeah you guys get anything else no cool so i think that's about it all right well on a scale of one to ten uh what would you guys give defenders of the realm um just because it does show signs of aging but because i just i have respect for it and i'm here for the aesthetic i'm gonna give it just a solid five wow i was expecting you started that like on a positive note just because yeah it's just i had so much fun and i mean it is show it's in age but five exactly is that with the expansion yes okay yeah

but like i i just didn't voice negatives because you guys were covering it but yeah it has its problems it obviously has its problems and that's where it shows its age but yeah i just think a five is completely fair um i really wish that the dragon expansion took my idea uh that would i don't know i'm obviously super biased because it was my own idea and i'm like over here just jacking myself off with how cool that would be i'm so smart i'm i'm a genius why aren't i designing games uh taking the dragon expansion out i'd still i'd give it a six i think it's a slightly above average game especially considering it came out 10 years ago i did not play it 10 years ago but it has been a while since i have played it and we played it like multiple times base game and then with the dragon expansion but i hadn't remembered what the how brutal brutally random the expansion is um with the dragon expansion it would go down to a five uh i just it's it's hard for the sake of being hard there's no cleverness around it um but yeah i think i think overall like the defenders of the realm uh taking all you know all of it into consideration i think it'd be about a six slightly above average so i'll be just a step up above you i would say base game nowadays seven yeah back when it first came out with all the craziness and how awesome it was yeah this would have been i mean this was like a 910 game

um it gets done a lot better you know so i would probably still keep it at seven i don't care for the dragon expansion i've only ever this is only yeah with other people this is only the second time i've ever played the dragon expansion so i'd probably do six maybe because they're still playing defenders so seven six uh can you could you with the dragon expansion could you play base game and just swap in the dragon is there any rule protecting you you can you can do like mix and match however you want yeah so that's kind of like a base game and not do sapphire but do like brimstone well you have to sing you always have to do oh okay so like you'd have oh that's right that's right right so like oh you could you could play the dragon expansion and not use onyx and put board for goth or whatever his name is there are you could put the red general in instead of the red brimstone i mean you can you can mix and match you just have to have the same color that's that's actually that's pretty nice um that gives you some flexibility so you don't have to do all four dragons you um well and also there's there's cat there uh captain the guard or general whatever the term was that they used for the dragons because there's another version of each dragon um oh so uh what was a camera what was called now sorry it's um uh oh god sorry wow the judges don't have this memorized oh i know um it's right actually right here it says there's no uh oh agent of the dark lord there's there's versions of each of the

dragons called agent of the dark lord as well so like there's a brimstone agent in the dark lord version and there's some phoenix version and stuff so that just changes it gives you another version of the dragons as well which are used in the scenarios and just different versions as well so they have a little bit different ability gives you some variety there that's nice i mean also i didn't really care that the minions had different abilities that was just one more thing to keep track of uh well they were harder than you know like yeah they're it's just like that is actually another thing that i that i don't like is yeah like i this should be i mean you could easily house rule it actually i'm going to talk a little bit more about it because when you kill a dragon you get a special but only that person does which is like their semi-cooperative nature like in pandemic when you are not eradicated when you cure disease everyone has that ability that's how it just should be like what we could have easily done this has been like all right green slayer everyone has or green dragons there everyone has that i don't like the fact that it's just like nope only the eagle rider can now kill green minions so i'll add my little note to your new rules for the dragon yeah whenever i go the richard lonnie's right exactly so like or instead of me and everybody because i was clear away yeah the people involved in the battle all had that ability because you three all took them down and all their little right oh my god these are the three that killed the jews yeah these are the three heroes who killed our lord yeah since grouping up is so important and taking down the deal that way like that'd be cool those three characters have all had that

that yeah a token or something yeah some of this like like a little hemlock dragon token that everyone puts on their card to be like hey right there smoking on my pipe right you're just like oh you youngsters like you're supposed to be helping us fight why i'm just teleporting around i'm the kid i'll be dead real soon i'm trying to organize the militia you never did that uh yeah i mean that would just that would just make it thematic and a little bit easier or do it to where um i mean this this would make it a little bit too easy i think or if you kill the dragon then no no imps show up i know that only happens in eradication and pandemic where you fully wipe it that they never come back uh that's a little worth a minute if we got all of the imps off the board they're just like awesome yeah you we wiped out the cult uh that would be nice uh once again you could probably house you could easily just house rule it where it's like i mean you can probably make your own tokens for each of these and just be like oh okay now yes us three killed it so now we each now when we run through a green location the the they die um but yeah i i think you do have the flexibility to do stuff like that but as is only the person killing against the ability that's just stupid especially when the minions are already hard enough to kind of deal with uh with with the dragon expansion the other thing real quick just to toss

in right before you close is i don't feel like in most adventure games you know you feel like you have the time to do stuff and this one with everybody being four spots away from the deal it's like you know i i i mean i guess i could have because of teleportation went to the end but like i didn't feel like i had time to get to the end because everything was already there right so you just i just don't feel like you have time to explore yeah you know you really don't have time to do quests the quests are i mean kind of like kind of like you said more of a bloated deck i remember last time i played not really liking these because it's like half the time you get a quest that's just useless um like that hey i'm gonna run to sapphire's location and get a blue card okay that's not there's 70 minions i need to go deal with does it specify on that do you get to search through the deck for a blueprint take the first blue card oh so you don't get to choose no if it lets you choose you could go pick one that had two blue dots yeah that'd be you know or something that'd be a little bit more worth it but nope it's up search search you know until i find the blue one and then which thank god thank god i oh look at that there's the one that was worth it and then the rest of us get shuffled man well i was gonna say something but i you were talking about exploring um what would have also been nice with the dragon expansion is if you have heroes like it'd be cool if that if you had heroes in the location of the generals as specifically the dragons they don't move

because it's like yeah they're trying to get to monarch city but we're stopping them hey we're both there maybe at some cost you lose a card or you lose an action or they're just so interested in that yeah it's like like it's not that it's like i get it they're trying to destroy monarch city but it's like we're we're heroes so we should be able to prevent them like my eagle riders swooping in to stop him and then my monk is just like when you get down here i'll kick your ass uh that would be that would be another way because they are you can just get completely screwed where it's like okay [ __ ] uh maybe suffer the consequence of their ability if you're preventing them from moving uh that would that would just make it not i don't think it would be super uh like easy if you just because because if you suffered their ability then especially like hemlock for example you would just get one turn before you're basically wiped um to prevent them from just going all right i win uh so yeah it just it's see i'm gonna keep my score the same i was gonna think about bumping it up to a six overall because of the variety of swapping in and out but we've sat here and basically thought of like nine different ways to make a new game how do we how do we make this game better and i don't like doing that those are just ideas that i would have that maybe hopefully freedom five implements uh but we'll we have to wait six years before that game comes out uh so yeah i think i think i'm gonna

keep it as a five um you know uh with with everything and then a six base game so all right that's our thoughts on defenders of the realm let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved