Hadrian's Wall Board Game Review | A Decent TableTop City Builder
Transcript
do you remember the old Caesar games on the PC they were around in the mid90s and you were essentially a Roman Governor tasked with building up a town or city and there were also a few missions where you had to repel Invaders me I personally loved them in fact I'd say Caesar 3 still holds up today as a great city building experience and Hadrian's Wall for me anyway reminds me so much of that game so much I'd say Hadrian's Wall basically is a city Builder on the tabletop allbe a bit of an abstract one as essentially it is just a flip and right box ticking experience over two sheets of paper the game itself looking at it very much feels like an exam in fact me wife asked me what the hell I was doing when she first looked at it as she thought it was some exam I was taking for work at all uh glancing at it she was very confused as it is just two sheets of paper filled with great artwork lots of empty boxes a few cards and the odd resource token here and there the game from a glance looks extremely basic but in playing it the exam comparison is pretty valid as you need to maximize all your resources and people to build a wall SE ition
repel the Scots to keep the populace happy and utilize all the major civilian factions to get the bonuses that you need to win the game and this small little game can not only be extremely addictive because of that little juggling act with your wealth of options on the board but it can also be very bloody difficult as learning this game is relatively easy use resource to tick a box get reward or push towards a further reward down the line but mastering this game takes a lot of trial and error and ability to work out how best to become basically roboute Gillman and min max your weight of Glory as this game can be unforgivingly punishing if you make just one mistake on one of your runs say on turn three a mistake that you think might be very minor but it will end up being so costly that you will end up failing to win the game or campaign level in the end and yes this small box game has a 15 level solo campaign available on BGG and I believe it might be included in some of the new reigs of this uh ball game but don't hold me to that and that campaign is
sing blowing difficult so difficult I've yet to pass the fourth chapter of it yet after about five tries but this game is also so amazing that I'm not ready to give up and I'm determined to pull up me boots and beat it one night and that's a testament to The Addictive puzzle this game offers with its challenge as I always get caught asking myself different questions whilst playing what faction do I focus on the market for goods the arena for gladiators priests for the basically overpowered Gardens always a must baths to Aid with descent if you're neglecting defense or military for scarting and good soldier defense so do you ignore the right columns entirely and focus on the city building and walls where you build landmarks and have great production hotels Workshop shops and Roads to get more production meatles and civilians there's a huge wealth of options Available to You realistically from the second round as the first round tends to always just be a standard oh let's build out a certain way to lay down the foundation for the next five with you not really stray much from the same old standard path as you don't have that many starting resources or open area on the Two Bits of Paper but from
round two onwards though those wealth of options will suddenly open up to you once the foundations have been placed and yo will be massively overwhelmed on your first couple of players as y will inevitably try to go for a jack of all trades approach where you try to do a little bit of everything but end up mastering out and realize you've got a midlin score of about 40 or 50 points because you fail to prepare before each round properly and they have a grand strategy that often needs to be changed each round depending on your given resources from the flip of a card I admit I often felt like I was being screwed over by the randomness of the card drawer as I had planned to go down a certain route but suddenly call and I began to realize that's not the game's fault it's mine as I wore giving the puzzle aspect of this game the respect it rightfully deserved as great players down mown about what they've been given they utilize what they've got correctly and go and bang at of the juli taking time at the start of every round to plan out all your intricate moves is great people often say that's what makes Gloom a and Mage Knight special well it's right here on these two sheets of paper you have to strategize or else you're doomed to fail
or be mediocre and all this happens in a box scking game that realistically takes about half hour to an hour to play along with like 5 minutes setup and te down does it have issues of course this is a solo on game in all but name yo Rock up to your game night busting at this box hand over a few sheets of paper to your mats and say have that it and and you'll think you're in secondary school again taking your GCS as there is no interaction on offer whatsoever whilst the game is going on this is a solo exam where you try to maximize your points so you're literally sitting down and doing a tick boxing multiple choice exam alongside other folk you could pee about and talk strategy or you like whilst playing but for me would be a little bit boring playing a solo game with other around you just sudden play it at home and enjoy your little puzzle game all on your own I also believe there's certain options on the board which are a little bit overpowered and force you to always Tech them if you want to win like the gardens which basically UPS everyone's track the hotels and workshops which give you more meatles and I wouldn't show away from landmarks or the road like Ralph ceretto they can be pretty good burners over the course of a game if you get them early enough the
campaign though for me is also pretty much Essential as this is what's pulling me back inconsistently if this game they have a solo campaign it would just be a tick boxing beat your own score Style game and from my perspective it would have been played basically once or twice and sold at that point CU I often find that style of game has no longevity with me but I will say this after I've completed the campaign I will probably be done with this one and I doubt I would ever come back to it after that point the campaign's puzzle with its varied missions and structure is what's keeping me around and this for me don't bring out that one and done style feel like other Garfield games do I'm talking of course about Raiders of the North Sea or architects of the West Kingdom which have a great one and style done structure and gameplay which means I can put it on me shelf for 6 months and play it again at a later date still having a great experience whenever I do so Hadrian's Wall don't elect that response from me this game is like a puzzle book you'd buy a h once you get back off it the novelty wears off and he gets dumped in the corner never to be seen again only this is a bloody expensive puzzle book as it can often be seen priced at
50 bloody quid online and that price for me is way too high I got this for 20 quid or it was 25 I can't remember but I got it second hand that feels right for this game that is essentially two pieces of paper you laminate up and then draw Ray Mark play with to get more longevity out your sheets of paper I will in complete in this campaign probably get 30 to 40 plays out of it you can play every night cuz it's so easy to set up I could play on a coffee table in the living room with the kids around me but without that campaign element I would honestly be deeply disappointed and feel like this one is a bit of a dud the campaign is essential for enjoyment for me but I know that feeling will wear off once I am done with it and there is no reason to ever play again at that point point from my perspective so I'll try and get me money back which at 25 quid should easily happen so I recommend you shopand for this one second hand D brand new and for that reason it kind of gets a three out of five for me that's all I got to say so now so Tatty boy