Marvel MCU Movie Tier List
Transcript
do
foreign do do hey everybody and welcome to what i feel is going to be the definitive marvel mcu tear list we are going to have a great time tonight because i've got a bunch of my friends on who over the years we've talked about the marvel movies and we're going to see who's right and who's wrong as we talk through the past 22 movies from the marvel mcu but before we get started let me introduce everybody and we'll start from the top going down first is david from man vs meeple david welcome thank you very much for having me i i'm i'm fairly certain i've seen all 22 of these movies i mean i'm maybe more than once probably three times each if i'm if i'm guessing and just so you'll know we are experiencing a little bit of lag i'm not sure i'm sure it's probably an issue on my end so i apologize if
when their mouths move it doesn't match the audio but it's more important about what they say and not what they look like next on the list is a joel from drivethrough grains joel welcome now joel's going to be our level-headed person of this panel i think oh i don't know about that yeah that's that's the plan i was brought in the last minute to keep everybody in line you know keep keep every story straight i have actually been re-watching most of the movies i've actually rewatched i think everything except for the iron mans and the guardians of the galaxies uh for the last couple of months so i'm ready oh then you're gonna be more update than i am and finally from the secret cabal jamie who's gonna be uh probably the most controversial of everybody on this panel from what he tells me i think that there are some on this list that everybody seems to hate and i love them so i'm gonna do my best to foil everything you guys do now let me say uh for those who are watching what you're seeing is every marvel movie but we're not doing them all we're only gonna do from iron man to uh avengers in game it's only those core marvel mcu movies so i know there's a lot more on the list but we ain't got time to go through all those so that's what we're going to be going because somebody just said wow that's a lot of movies but we're not going to be talking about any x-men or anything like that and that's probably for a good reason yeah howard the duck i see on that list down i've watched howard
the duck dozens of times when i was a kid i loved that movie oh boy george lucas at his best well i forgot george lucas made that um okay so uh let me just explain the rules of what we're going to be doing here um so here's for somebody put those who have never seen a tier list this isn't each of our own lists you see here we're going to be ranking movies from great the best of the best all the way down to bad but here's the thing it's going to be a consensus so we're going to bring up a movie and amongst us 4 we have to decide where it's going to fit and that's where some of the discussions are going to come in and um if it's okay okay with you guys let's rate the movies against other marvel mcu movies so not ranking a movie against gone with the wind or something like that these are ranked amongst themselves so hopefully we'll have a good spread across all the categories okay um and uh one thing also is because if you're very passionate about a movie i'm going to throw a little twist in here uh america's got talent uh just started last week and that's one thing our family watches they have this thing called a golden buzzer i'm going to introduce a golden buzzer here if there is a movie that you feel very passionate about one way or the other nobody else does you get one golden buzzer to use on a
movie where it says i'm overriding you all here's what the score of that movie is going to be oh so uh i have got some follow-up questions uh can i golden buzzer someone else's golden buzzer we'll say no you can't so first come first serve first come first serve you get one so use it wisely so yeah the timing of when you play that golden buzzer card is very important yes it is i like how you gamified this marty oh yes yes all right here we go let's just jump right into it let's just start out with the very first movie which is hold i gotta take interaction of this guy here hold on just a second is that how we're gonna do it chronologically yes these are about as close to chronologi it's pretty chronological right now i looked up on wikipedia how they came out so i'm trying to do them from oldest release to latest so i iron man and just let me start this out i hate to start out rating something so high but for me i'm gonna say this was great best of the best yeah i really like this movie i think this movie is an excellent movie and it's an act it's an absolute wonderful start to the entire series uh now if you compare that to the newest movies that are coming out where they're getting real slick with everything it might not compare but i think uh thinking about it from the time i've watched this movie many times and i love it even to this day and i think it's an excellent way to start off particularly
the end of that movie puts it best of the best the very end of that movie puts this movie best of the best okay i gotta knock it down because the villain is lame well you're gonna we're gonna do that with like three quarters of these movies sure i i well i would agree with what joel's saying in terms of knocking it down i agree that the villain is lame but going back to marty's suggestion that these need to be rated amongst their peers in the mcu i feel like this doesn't get a best of the best for that reason alone because of what you said uh jamie with the things getting slicker and not just slicker in terms of a presentation standpoint but the storytelling has actually i think also gotten better over over the years so i would put this at the good personally okay so yeah also i forgot to tell you too what we're going to do is round down so if it's 2-2 then we're going to round down and so we'll round down to good is that what y'all want to rate joel you know what i'd like to change mine to good as well okay here's why because i think that if it had don cheeto in it from the beginning this one would be better because you know it started off with a different i don't remember who the difference is yeah and he got all crazy and wanted more money he wanted as much money as iron man and then they uh so changing it to don cheeto in the next movie who's a superior roadie i think puts this one down all right all right moving on how did iron man 2
fare then amongst you fellas you can leave it right there where it oh it's a little is than that i think it's still fun it is again i think i said we're ranking it against the other mcu movies and i literally don't hate any of them yeah true but i wouldn't say bad to any of them but if we have to rank it amongst the other ones you got to put it at okay solely for hammers like dance that he comes out on stage that's the best part when he comes dancing out he's going to show off all the the things he's like doing that thing and he's like slipping back and forth that's cool right there now remember iron man three's coming so you gotta leave room to go beneath it well here's the thing you mean tony stark three joel go ahead because i think i'm about to agree with you well the thing is is iron man 2 adds nothing to the mcu into iron man as a whole iron man 3 isn't great but it adds to without iron man 3 you don't have infinity war and all that stuff because that's tony stark's struggling it's dealing with his visions it's all that kind of stuff and that really sets the trajectory for the finale in my opinion that's what keeps three i think a little bit higher than two because i honestly they're both kind of fun but three does have three again has probably a worse villain than iron man one so yeah i wouldn't put it bad i'd put it at meh so that's where i'd go okay i'd rather okay but okay i would say okay jamie says okay dave
i'm now i'm not trying to play an odds game here but i have to stick with bad on this one because it is definitely when i think of my list it's among my least favorite of the mcu movies yeah okay if we're trying to spread them out at all uh it's among my least favorite so it has to be at the bottom so joel for me man you got to put at least man all right so that i think among the four will round down to a may all right i'm going to handle that now i'm curious what's going to be bad first i guarantee you dave the one that's not that's going to be bad is going to be great now remember not if i beat you to the golden buzzer that's right i was going to say the golden buzzer can be to pull something down if you want to i'm sure that's how i'm going to use mine all right four first four i say okay you okay wait you like thor better than iron man 2 oh yum yeah but i am a thor like fanboy like i love the comics and stuff from the 70s and all that and but to me it's like this one's it's pretty good it's like it's pretty i just watched it about a month ago and it's a little bit hokey and a little bit disjointed similar to iron man one where the storytelling's not that solid but uh then the villains kind of but i agree with that i think one of the the flaws of iron or excuse me the first thor movie is that they break a rule like it's really it sucks when it when a
when a hero loses their powers yeah and usually that happens in like part three or something or in the second season of a tv show this one in the very first movie he loses his powers and for half the movie he's not thor and i think that's poor storytelling right there it's not really exciting i mean they didn't need they need more of an origin of this is the most powerful being in all of asgard and all this different stuff and then they make him lose his powers immediately and he's just like some chunk wandering around in the desert still good movie though i'd put it at okay because i like the movie but it's a little weird start i think i would vote okay that's two okays that's three okay three okays i don't think you could change it david what would you say oh it's david frozen i think david is frozen oh there he is there he is he's back he's thinking four okays okay there we go there we go yeah we agree nice nice simple yeah first captain america oh best top best best to at the top put it at the top the first captain no no way not doing it i'd say okay no no man no that's way too low at least good i'd say okay oh oh no this one is rough because it's does such a great story of putting an origin story for a character together quickly at the beginning of the movie because i hate origin stories you'll you'll hear
that a couple of times throughout this whole thing origin stories are boring and we're past them at this point and this one it made the origin story happen in the first like 45 minutes of the movie and then the rest of the movie is just him going through all these cool adventures and i want a tv series with the howling commandos that would be like the greatest thing because that group of characters is awesome and man you get to see them do their thing throughout the whole movie and then the end is awesome villain is amazing yup i love it i'm still great i'm still sticking it okay i mean i thought because i know i'm comparing against others and winter soldiers coming down the pike when it comes to a captain america movie so yeah that's what i i feel like with mcu there are some that uh deserve to be at the top of the list and like far more like winter soldier like you said marty i can't see winter soldier in this being compared the same to me so let's let's do a compromise we'll put it in a good but ahead of iron man to the left of iron man yeah grab the rope is that how it works yeah because you can still rank them within the within the rows right to the left of iron man is that better than iron man there you go oh okay oh hold on it didn't work hold on there you go there you go all right i can live with that i don't like it i think it's wrong but why are we agreeing so much joel i'm worried i'm worried now jamie you're welcome to use your golden buzzer that's true that's true
all right uh the very first avengers movie now i i will say when this first came out it was great among all the others going back going back and watching again i would i would say good or great for me me i would agree with that i marty i think i'm right there with you when this came out i think i saw this thing like five times in theaters i loved this movie so much um but in retrospect it doesn't it doesn't really hold a candle you know what it's still not bad though i watched this not long ago and it's still very very entertaining i would put this definitely at good but i'm leaving room just for the few that i think are great joel jamie joe yeah i i just watched it and honestly the first half is a little bit weak sauce um the second half is amazing so from i think for that i'd put it up at good yeah i think good like towards the right side um buddy i'm like with you guys when it first came out it was like i can't believe they pulled it off you know all this stuff um but it's a little bit kind of clunky and slow in the first half and then once once once they kind of get together they get to the uh the shield carrier or whatever and they capture loki everything everything from the moment they capture loki is just amazing yeah yeah i'm good with having
it in the good category for for all the reasons joel said actually i also think that time has not uh played well with this movie right there's a shine that is kind of worn off of it because they've done the hordes of monsters over and over and over again since then and this one now kind of suffers because it has the hordes of monsters at the end so the battle for new york was not as cool as it was when we first saw it that's why i wouldn't put it at great put it at good all right so we're sitting it good then we're sitting in good i feel like it should be to the left side of good but because left's better right yeah i would agree too i like cat better than i like avengers really i like avengers better not like cap we'll round down that's outrageous all right round it down round and down all right iron man three math to the left of iron man two man well i'm saying you guys want to stick it in bad i won't argue it here's the thing when you tease the mandarin and you end up with what you get at the end i can't excuse that i just can't it was terrible they ruined the mandarin completely that didn't bother me really at all but uh i i'm not a hardcore fan so i wasn't like i wasn't all juiced up to you know see the mandarin i would put it in me but i would put it left of iron man 2 because i think it's i think it's better than iron man 2.
yeah i'm exactly the same as david so there's two masks jamie i'm going to put it at bad just because i mean there's some good stuff in it but it's all tony stark and barely any iron man like at the end it's like suits flying around shooting again the mandarin was lame i didn't like the the character that they the real villain who was like i don't know he turns into fire and stuff um yeah i it wasn't a great one and i would put it at bad you guys can put it up at meh as a as the rounding well here's the thing i'm saying bad and we round down so it's bad our first bad movie bad i'm with you marty i feel like this list by the end is going to get more personal than it is really a really real reflection of our feelings on the movies like now i feel like i need to get back at jamie hey well dave do you want to use your golden buzzer on iron man 3.
oh don't waste it that's okay all right i have in mind where i'm probably going to use it is it going to be thor dark world i call dibs it's definitely not i call it the gold buzzer i think you missed one are you using it jamie maybe we'll see what you guys say and then i'll decide if i'm gonna actually reserve it or not because i'm not gonna say this is great but i'm gonna say that everybody in the world hates this movie and i love this movie i think the villain kind of stinks but that i mean a lot of them stink this movie was cool it was a cool movie it had a lot of neat stuff in it it gets a bad rap and i got more to say about it but you guys go ahead and talk i love it i love this movie i put it up at good easy oh my gosh you got to use golden buzzer because i'm going mad at best hey if jamie and i are good and you guys are mad that i'll end up in okay and i'll be happy i can sleep with that i'm i i have to put thor the dark world at bad oh no no no no thor the dark world just like iron man 2 it is easily in my bottom three to five marvel mcu movies why uh it's just really boring and it so here's one of the things for me and all the mcu when they do humor right it's done really really well and in thor the dark world the humor in it was super corny and hokey and like really bad jokes landing
very awkwardly in my opinion um not that i'm judging at all on the jokes but it has some of the worst in that respect um and it was just kind of i mean other than that i would say meh but it's just it's definitely in the bottom of the barrel for me i think you guys got to watch it again i just watched this a couple of weeks ago and it still holds up it's great it's it's a thor story like jamie was saying with the first one thor loses his powers he's you know doesn't really get do anything this is such a thor story it's got the dark elves and this like dark magic dark dimension type of thing and all this stuff and the conflict with uh odin and him and loki's kind of thrown in there just a little bit and just kind of weird extra dimensional magic and infinity stone stuff is in there it's great true it does set up it does set up some of the infinity saga more than most films what's great about this movie is that you know now i love thor ragnarok and and him and everything else past that i love all that stuff but this was the last one before thor became the comic character the comedic character he became almost a buffoon after this uh and he was taken seriously in this movie and in the first movie the first movie has some humor but when he was thor he wasn't a goofball and in this one he wasn't a goofball either and also dark world builds the asgard story uh you know most of these movies like when now that we're getting to the point where everything's all intertwined and stuff we don't have those
story about the places that are very important and asgard and the people you know the giants and the the dark elves and the how those sort of factions interact this movie had that so it's great world building for a part of the mcu that people would have a hard time understanding and since now space and other dimensions is totally normal this was the movie that kind of set all that stuff up i really really enjoy this movie a lot i think it's an excellent an excellent movie uh not as great as the others as some of the others but i i respect this one all right well what it stands right now a good a good a man and a bad ends up being a meh that seems like bad math to me yeah no because a good a good good man man ends up okay but if you drop throw one bat in there it rounds it down to me ah you're gonna use your golden buzzer i kind of want to because i'm looking at all the other movies and i don't think there's any other ones that i'm gonna be crazy okay about i'll tell you what jamie i'll make a deal with you i'm going to use golden buzzer to put it up there good do it yeah do it i know we both want to do it wait where are you putting it good i'm not going to put it up great okay oh you know joel i have to respect that yep yeah actress cause he could put it at best if you wanted to and then we'd ridiculous in the race i know everybody's gonna hate me but put it one to the left of iron man whoa no that's funny it's your golden buzzer if you use your golden brother you get the exact placement it's your golden
buzzer dude yep i agree all right so that we had a lot of uh discussion on that can't i assume we're taking winter soldier to great yes put it right up there that's one of the best one of the best it might be the best yep it might be maybe you know what was so good about that one is the story was to me one of the best of any of the marvel movies with with i mean it was like almost like realistic it's like holy cow this could happen sort of deal you know it was so good yeah it was good that was the russo's first movie that's right yeah they yeah it's great because there's a lot of different kinds of mcu films there's the uh you know like the fantasy ones there's the you know the the crazy space ones science fiction ones there's all kinds of stuff this one is like the spy action movie yeah right and that's so cool that we get that in it too and i love that you know the new uh tv show the falcon winter soldier is kind of following that path right the spy action series and i like that so this one best of the best i agree um all right guardians of the galaxy one i keep grabbing the wrong thing i'm sorry y'all for me absolutely best of the best i would say i would say best of the best wow wow just i i'm sure we all agree with this but the fact that they took this property which i can tell you before this movie came out i knew nothing about the guardians of the
galaxy and i remember as kind of like a you know and i enjoyed the movies but also kind of looking at what marvel was doing and whether they were going to be successful when they first announced this i thought okay here's their first opportunity where they really have to do it well because i don't know how they're going to make a raccoon and a talking tree work and i they they blew it out of the water i i love this movie i mean and this is one of those i saw in the theater multiple times and when it came out on dvd or for streaming i watched it again amazing so wow that was two back to back big big movies um all right avengers another one age of ultron well jamie since you're excited tell us about it i love this movie i like this movie better than the first avengers movie oh uh i think it's it should be under i can't decide between good and great because this is another one that so many people dislike this movie and i do not understand why first off james spader is amazing as ultron he's like the greatest actor and he tears it up with this movie um the whole concept of him and dealing with what he's dealing and this movie is only enhanced in quality since like the infinity stuff because ultron was it was all about that suit of armor for for planet earth right and that's thanos that that the suit of armor was needed for you know if you look at i've watched dave you were talking on uh
i was just listening to one of joel's old podcast you were talking about um how oh crap now i lost my train of thought you were talking about how like uh oh crap i completely thought what i lost my train of thought sorry about that i'm so excited about this movie but anyway the point of what i'm trying to say is that oh all i know what it was you watched a lot of uh youtube videos that kind of pick apart pieces of movies and say like here's all the easter eggs and here's how everything ties together and i've watched a number of them on ultron if you watch like some when ultron's learning about the history of the united states and or i'm sorry the history of the world and going through all of those flashes and those quotes and things it builds this amazing picture of what um of what uh ultron is trying to do and why he's trying to take over the world and put that pseudo armor and rid the planet of the humanity and stuff it's so amazing the amount of thought they put into this film and the way it works and then going forward into the whole thanos concept this movie is pivotal in the series and i love it i think i'm putting it that great at this point oh wow wow i think it's to me it's great but it's like it's like right between great and good like can i marty can i just request the next time we do this can it just be you and me am i gonna have to use a golden buzzer to pull down a movie what is going on here i just rewatched this thing that recently and i was like and i liked it even better this is probably the third or fourth time i've seen it
and i liked it even better let's see here's what the chat's saying meh ultron is bad ultron movie plot is incoherent and disjointed so it's not it is so not it's an excellent plot that develops perfectly and fits into the longer story of the mcu yeah i'm not going to say what my rating is first but i'm going to say i agree with jamie about james spader now it's interesting because at first i didn't like it but the more i thought about it being an ultron that was reflecting tony stark and and and how it's kind of like his child and he very acts very arrogant like that because at first i was a little turned off by how human he seemed um but i came around to really loving james spader as ultron and there's a lot about the movie to like and in fact i'll agree with joel too that upon further watches i've enjoyed it more with that said i enjoyed the phantom menace more watching it the second and third time and that's mostly because i was prepared for the bad parts yeah you can just fast forward past the jar jar and pod racing but the part and i hate that i hate to hammer this home but this is the movie to hammer at home on this movie's humor is awful like they tried so desperately to push in jokes wherever they possibly could in this movie and and they absolutely unfortunately
take me straight out of the the action there's one in particular great action sequence where they're chasing the truck with i think visions in the back of the truck and uh black widow's driving around on a motorcycle and there's literally a point where they after the fact had her dub in beep beep like as she's like telling people to get out of her way which is just ridiculous and that's because kids go to see these movies i know but i don't i don't i don't care about the kid and plus i don't know that that's the case i think they're just here's what i think it happened guardians of the galaxy came out marvel was like uh oh uh we got we got to be funnier and and the people that they have in age of ultron didn't quite cut the mustard when it came to to to fitting in the jokes but i would so with all of that said this would be a bad for me like this is also at the bottom of my list but i'll probably go meh because of the parts of it that have grown on me over watching it a few more times i'll say meh but that's as good as it gets for me yeah and for me i'm just gonna go okay and it's actually gone up since one division because i appreciate it more after one division because it was math for me uh but the movie the thing that made that move for me along with scarlet witch because i just love scarlet witch and she was introduced in that so jamie i'm gonna what's what's your what's your vote joel my mind was
mine was great i would put it to the either the right hand side of grade or the left hand's not a good okay so marty where does it fall start the math so right now wait y'all two are saying great yeah so great great and a great a great uh okay and a man
because okay no you're right it'd be okay yes okay let's say it okay i'm gonna golden ticket this one yep and let's put it on let's put it up at great oh my gosh behind oh my god it'll probably be at the end of great okay together marty you put this together don't blame me i don't agree with the being great but i also again have to respect the fact that he put it at the the end of grade i'll take any respect i can get i never would have guessed age of ultron would be great out of this i'm stuck i've got to watch it again everybody in the chat needs to watch asia ultron in dark world again that's your homework and everything else you can put it wherever you want and i'm all right oh wow those are the two that i was like which one should i have my golden ticket saved for oh sheesh all right ant-man uh i just watched this last night actually i'm just throwing this for me it was it was it was fine it was okay for me it was okay me too i really enjoy it but it in the in the scope of the mcu it's okay yeah yeah and i love paul rudd yep it's a fun movie it's got great actors in it it's got awesome action it's a fun story the villain was kind of boring but you know it's a comedy right and in the mcu it's fun to inject that fun every now and then that comedy type stuff and you know i don't watch it re-watch it that often and i dig it but i dig it though and i would watch it again so i'm going
to put it under okay as well yep i got okay like the humor didn't hold up quite as much i i was laughing a lot like almost as much as guardians of the galaxy that i watched again last night and i was like yeah it's okay all right well that was easy all right so we all agree not much discussion to be had civil war right behind winter soldier yep oh yeah i mean i would i would personally vote to put this in front of winter soldier so all y'all are saying great great great for sure this is maybe maybe my favorite uh i you know this quibbling so you know either either side of winter soldier is totally fine with me i put it behind winter soldier but wherever it falls it's great for me well it's definitely in the great category i really enjoyed it but i would have not thrown in the great i would just said good it will stay in the great whoa i i i mean the the the i mean civil war will always remind me of popcorn because jamie and i got to see it together at uh seman and that's that's where the whole popcorn thing man but uh you know i i really enjoyed it i just i try to limit the number of movies i say that are great that's why so oh that one yeah that one it's utterly rewatchable like that's the movie i would turn on in the background while folding the laundry all day long yeah i'm not going to disagree with you all at all on this one so you say to the right of winter soldier
that's what i would say that works that's what i'd put yeah just keep pushing age of ultron down perfect okay um yeah how many can we get is there a rule where we have so many and great that it automatically will go it rolls down to good because if that's the case all the rest of the movies are great for me all right uh doctor strange i just watched this last night too because i wanted to watch before we got on here and i i was gonna say great before i watched it again now i'm just saying good oh wow okay so you're saying well then we'll just start it up here and we'll go from there so here we go doctor strange is my favorite mcu our favorite marvel character of all time top three favorite characters of all time doctor strange i was waiting for this movie forever i wanted this move out this is the one that i wanted out of all of them and when i saw it it did not disappoint it is a fantastic movie the only reason that i would kind of put it down into good which i'm going to put it in good is because it's the origin story and they spent too much time on the origin story um so it was like like like i i don't rewatch it as much because i don't want to see him become you know the sorcerer supreme again i want to see him get into the action and the villain is a little bit um kind of boring but but as a whole the movie is amazing so i'm putting it in good for those two reasons uh well i was going to
see to me this is for very different reasons it's also in the okay it's a great movie don't get me wrong i love all these movies for the most part except for the ones i really don't like that much and that's just a short short list but this along with ant-man even though they're very different movies feel very similar to me in terms of where i rate them so i would have put okay but i'm no i'm okay with good gosh so here's the thing i would have differed because i probably would have pushed it a little more towards great because i love doctor strange and i i love seeing okay finally we got magic and stuff again i'm a huge scarlet witch fan so i'm more towards the mystic side stuff anyway so that's where we got a lot of this and benedict benedict cumberbatch is just well i think it's just amazing uh in that role i i'm i'm i'm thinking if i want to use golden buzzer or not you could put it up there with the great just to pop it up one oh my goodness but i'm looking at the rest of the moves to see how passionate i am about anything else i think you should use it if for no other reason that it it leaves me with the only golden buzzer left well you can't override anybody else's gold but the only one i would use it on is probably to pull one down and that's just mean is too yeah that's that's me that's mean spirited so that's not in the jest of these it is mean spirited but it's also how we ended up with age of ultron in greece
all right uh okay i'm gonna leave you at the last golden buzzer dave i am going to i'm gonna i'm gonna push up doctor strange and i'm going to throw it ahead of age of ultron i can deal with that it's your prerogative i know i probably wasted it moved just up one spot but i'm happy all right strange deserves it uh here we go guardians of the galaxy two it was not great for me yeah i got this one at okay yep me too i it's it's the humor is great i really like the humor humor was solid not as good as the first one but and the origin story of quill was kind of interesting you know but i don't know it's something that just kind of takes its foot off the gas at the end and i don't know i thought it was a little too complicated i think that yeah yeah they had too much stuff going on there were too many things going around like the different places and stuff uh so i i love the humor like you said i love ego i think kurt russell's awesome and he was a really good villain and that's this is one of my favorite villains of the entire mcu um so i really love that part of it and you get some really great sing thing uh scenes like a mary poppins scene like that is just cool but um yeah so i would put this without good how many do we have left uh one two
three four five okay sorry one two three four five seven yep uh i'm gonna golden buzzer this to the top whoa are you serious i love this movie and i think a lot of people when this movie came out there's a lot of people that immediately said that's not as good as the first and i i very very much disagree i love the first one and i think if you take the sort of phenomenon aspect away from the first one and and then and the nostalgia with it being sort of the movie that did what it did first i think this is a better story than the first one i think ego is by far a better villain than than in the first one um and and i'll admit this here i'm sure i've admitted this elsewhere in public and elisha is probably saying in the comments right now i cry like a baby at the end of this movie every single time with without fail this thing chokes me up and i love it you mean at the uh the part where they do the service at the very end all the ships show up don't don't even talk okay i'm sorry brian all right well well dave you're going to sound the golden buzzer where are you golden buzzer war there buddy so where are you putting it up there and this is out of respect for all of you i will well it's out of respect for some of you i'll put it between doctor strange and that other one okay
there you go all right so before we move on gentlemen we are super top heavy at this point we're supposed to be comparing these against other movies and like so there's no separation among those top five and the others at the end do you like spread them all out so that they're even so that some go into the bad what was that there's some there's some coming up here that i think are going to fall lower for me so some of them get worse at the end yeah okay all right here we go uh the spider-man movie homecoming great we're top heavy and you're just great great i'd put it i'd put it right behind civil war i put this one at good i would put it at good i'd put it at good oh my god all right fine i really like it i think tom holland is amazing as spider-man i think yep it's great um just just left to captain america then what no i i think that uh also kirk what's the other one is awesome like he's such a cool villain and he has and it's one of those villains that i like that he's not like a super villain like this crazy like thanos he's like a smaller character uh he's and you kind of understand why he's doing what he's doing because after the battle in new york like he needs to you know make his money right and the government comes in or shield comes in and stops him it's got it's got a really good heart to it
um but i put it in good solely because it's not as good as those other ones yeah same here now uh joel were you the one that put thor the dark world yeah i got to say you you put this to the left of thor yeah you should get you should get that call at the very least i mean yeah at least there i'd put it above avengers at least come on now above avengers i can't do that easy easy call i can't do that what would you play i i decided with you on that one marty sorry joel yeah we're wrapping it down we're good uh so in the chats couple people have said uh why didn't you include the the hulk with uh you shouldn't click the hawk oh yeah incredible hulk counts let's let's throw in the hulk real quick because that was an older one but we skipped it so i i see it right here so let's just throw it somewhere it came out after iron man it did it did just like you could leave it right there yeah let's leave it right there no oh i just watched it like two months ago it's terrible it's awful yeah i thought it was good you know because original two hulks with eric bana they they are terrible they won't even make the list yeah the eric banner one is horrific yeah it's just awful and when i saw this one i was like okay this is actually a good one and then i watched it again and i was like no it's not normally i would put this one in the okay category but i'm going to put it in the mech category solely because of the actor change because now i don't want to watch it because it's not uh mark ruffalo right yeah it just doesn't feel as good um
but still there's a lot of cool stuff in it so i'm i'll put it in mad just because i haven't watched it in forever and not really interested to go back to it yeah i would put it in okay for me i actually thought this was and i remember seeing it when the same summer that i saw iron man and thinking these are two great marvel movies it probably hasn't aged as well yeah and as i'm remembering some of like the abomination is a little oh it's terrible pretty awful pretty bad okay is this this option this is also the one that kind of like seated that guy with the giant brain head right a little bit oh yeah and they don't they never what they call them not brainiac but you know yeah um that seemed a little cheesy for mcu so i would put it at okay though personally uh so i would put it at meh so i think that's one okay two mezz one bad which i think puts it at may yeah definitely below iron man two as well yeah for sure thanks comments for helping us round out the lower end of our list yeah the leader that's who the brain guy is a leader you know he's a he's a really cool hulk villain but they never followed up on him okay so thor ragnarok and great oh yeah oh i thought somebody's going to argue with me because i was going to say great no i just don't know where it is up up there probably to the left of guardians well there's no point in me saying anything do you not like it no i do love it i love it it's great movie i
would put it in good okay at the bottom of good i think uh because here's here's exactly why okay so it's fantastic it is so fun it is funny the characters are cool it's got jeff goldblum which any movie with jeff goldblum needs to go to great right but here's the thing that i'm really bothered by every time i think about it is how they squander the opportunity of world war hulk world war hulk is the most amazing mcu movie and it would be great great great above captain america if they made the world war hawk movie and this is the start of that and they kind of squandered it they didn't actually do it they didn't have the illuminati uh in the beginning with with tony stark of course they couldn't add xavier and and neymar and those characters but they didn't have that concept and then they got there and he's just there and then he comes home and you don't get the world war hulk that always spoils it for me so it takes it from a great to a good and i like thor not being a goofball and this is where he started becoming a goofball oh i gotta agree with jamie on those points i mean it doesn't take the movie down for me but i mean i agree with you on those points but for me what doesn't really hurt the movie so where would y'all rank it up here in the list well if jamie was putting it in good it almost feels like it has to err on the side of the down okay the end right right put it next to ultron because i said i made that promise move it up one party oh nice oh so
ultron is the end okay nice manner away with my golden ticket that ultron would be at the bottom wow all right all right uh let's decide no no that's fine that's better than something nope nope and we still haven't updated the incredible hulk up there as far as i'm concerned we still have an upside down pyramid so here we go uh black panther uh somewhere between good and great for me i have a hard time with this one i would i would agree i think it's i think it's good uh one of the things that i wasn't a fan of when it first like it's a little effects heavy for a marvel movie one of the things i loved about the mcu is how realistic things were and how effects aren't typically used like in the in the dc universe where effects are used like in slow motion and like you know all that sort of stuff i'm not a big fan of that and this feels like it i don't know some of the fighting felt a little bit more like that to me which took it down a little bit but i love the story and i love the fact that established wakanda as such a yeah epic and important part of the mcu like it's you know the fact that what was it was it yeah infinity war where so much of it took place in wakanda was awesome so the thing for me is is the the villain is probably the best villain in the marvel cinematic universe that's true that puts it in the great but the arc of
um t'challa where he has that whole thing again where like he kind of goes and then he loses his power and he gets back and then there's redemption like it's so telegraphed like a fastball down the middle that's the only thing that kind of bugs me about that but the tie-in with like the stuff that happens in the 90s and everything and i like how they really went into the other i can't remember the name of them but all of the like imperial guard around t'challa and his sister and uh you know michonne from not walking dead i can't remember her name oconee or something like that um like that stuff's really cool but to me it's like on the lower end of great very top end of good in there oh so um let me see so you pick one though great or good joel if you don't mind um all right because the villain pumps it to great okay and jimmy what'd you say i didn't say anything yet i'm putting this in good okay uh i really love it it's a great movie great acting like joel said the best villain one of the best villains there is uh my this is the one that i started to notice the technology in marvel films going so crazy um like just to the point where i can't believe the technology and so the technology of wakanda makes no sense to me and it started to bother me honestly watching the movie there was one point where somebody got shot and they jammed a metal ball and said that'll fix it and then nobody explains the hell that was that technology exists though and it was just like that kind of stuff
was like it's just lazy writing in my mind when you start doing that kind of stuff it's lazy you just this is the dingus that's going to fix it i felt like they did that i felt they leaned into that to just sort of like in an abstract way really underscore the fact that wakanda's tech was so far superior to everyone else's maybe i can see that i could see that as a way to point it out so you know i'm i'm quibbling over great and good here i'm just playing it good it's probably going to be in great anyway uh so i'm going to say good uh i really enjoyed the movie the um the yeah the tech kind of got to me after white and joy hit it on a good point it was very telegraphed what was going to happen uh with t'challa uh you knew what was going to happen with him but i love the james bond feel of this i love it it's kind of kind of like with um winter soldier where it didn't feel necessarily like a uh like a superhero movie there's a little bit of spy and espionage so i dug that yeah the casino scene was awesome yes yeah actually i really enjoyed it but for me i'm gonna throw it at good and i think that's two greats two goods it's just where do we want it in good i think we well i i had the golden ticket of thor you can play the left of the thor dark world for sure yeah i would put it below spider-man yeah i think right there's probably that's where i like it all right all right uh let's see
avengers infinity war ooh the top got to be great it's got great it's great i think we just have to decide where it goes and personally well you got to put the left ultron i mean jamie i don't know yeah yeah yeah definitely it's going to keep moving though i assume yeah left to thor ragnarok i'd put it behind a civil war honestly civil war right there that's where i put it yep that feels good to me that's fair hey we all agree on one wow not much need to talk about i guess it's gonna be interesting to see how it compares to i'll wait i'll wait till we get to the other avengers movie ant-man and wasp i thought it was okay for me it was okay to good i put it right behind ant-man yeah oh yeah i like this one i'm gonna put it in may okay i found the villains boring i found just i just it just didn't work for me but uh so stick it in okay it just didn't stand out it was not as good as the right real ant-man the first i'm sorry the first ant-man right um yeah it was just okay i think it's definitely better than iron man 2 in the hulk though yeah yeah no no but yeah i don't put it down there yeah i got to give it okay i mean okay with that what'd you say that feel that where you have it right now feels right to me all right it drives crazy that the first iron man is sitting there right in the middle of okay that's still bothering me it is a little
weird i'm not sure i'm not sure in the future marty if you should do this golden buzzer thing because now i can't help but like when we're putting something in good like black panther and i look up the age of ultron is above it is great it makes my brain start to melt that's right hey this is why you play test this stuff right so you know we'll know for next time all right now before we get to the next one i want to say i enjoy every single movie on this list even iron man 3. okay just just to re restate that fact okay so what do you want to say about marvel i wonder what's happening now uh i really like this movie when it came out but it really dropped down them for me um i watched it again you know like i said a couple weeks ago and it's somewhere between men okay
there's a lot of things i really like about it but there's like a woodenness to it it feels like a lot of they leaned into like the 90s nostalgia for humor they leaned into like the cat for humor and that just wasn't that great well i love the cat but yeah i mean yeah but you know but it's still it just they leaned into a lot of weird things to get humor out of this movie and there was a lot of like like i don't know like douche chill scenes like the when when they start playing no doubt at that one point near the end i'm like oh no no no this is such a cool scene and now you're doing that uh it just felt wrong i gotta have it to the left of these two though it's definitely better than iron man too so hold on [ __ ] okay so you're saying you're living in it meh joel if well i'm trying to look at an ant-man or wasp and they're like i could it could be a coin flip between the two jamie like you're saying yeah i would put it in the okay category okay david better than wasp i i would put this in the okay category two but it would probably be towards the bottom of the okay category oh boy so you're leaving it to me because i i fell into the meh and here's why to me this felt like a setup movie for the next movie and then did nothing with it because you introduced carol danvers and then she's hardly even in the next movie go ahead well marty i hate to cut you
off but this is the thing with me and i i had the same feeling when i was watching doctor strange again i feel like this one will pay itself off more when like miss marvel or whatever marvel girl whatever they end up calling that movie comes out to kind of go full circle because like you said it sets her up and she's a super powerful like superman character and then she comes in and she kind of saves the day at a certain point end game but not really um and then it kind of sets up that larger cosmological stuff like the eternal stuff that we're going to see the guardians of the galaxy she's really kind of triggering that so she's like the first iron man movie in a way where it's opening up this whole new avenue of the marvel universe and i like that part of it but it doesn't like it hasn't marinated long enough um so yeah and it's really wooden so i would put it to the left of ant-man and wasp which i think david and jamie both said they would do okay yeah yeah okay so right there yeah here so one more to the left oh i'm sorry i'm sorry i drug it yeah cause i do like it a little bit more than ant-man wants okay but definitely not as much as ant-man or yeah he's still never right i still don't see how iron man oh no that's where i that's where i would put it is there i like ant-man better and then a wasp better yeah no that's a good boy i don't know i'd put it to the other side that's right well i was going i was going mass and mine's going to go to the right okay you can live there so i really like the scrolls and stuff
that whole yeah like fine it does some cool stuff the movie just all the pieces there's a lot of good pieces but all the pieces don't necessarily come together and make me feel great about the movie and it ruined uh nick fury's eye patch i couldn't believe the story for that yeah so stupid cat scratch thing yeah i didn't mind it i didn't mind not a cat it's a friggin fleaburg or whatever things called and samuel jackson was so irritated that that's what they where where they went with that i remember him seeing that or saying that in an interview that man he was just like of all think come on that's just stupid i didn't like it yep all right here we go uh the final to wrap up the entire phase four of the marvel mcu eventually we still got far from home though right we could do far from home if you want yeah well i think we got to do far from home okay matter of fact all right so avengers end game i'm going to kind of write it i'm assuming it's going to be up in here somewhere end game end game is great for me i mean yeah it's definitely in the top tier for me yeah it's at the bottom of the top it's definitely not as good as infinity war i would agree with that it's a pacing as a movie as a film the pacing is not super great but yeah it's it's it's so much part of the infinity like the two-part infinity movie that it's hard to to not put up there and there's some
great stuff man i mean if for no other reason that final fight is just like it's hard to deny that so yeah what's great about this movie i really i would put it between endgame and civil war for me because man the end like there wasn't a dry eye in the house at the end of that movie yeah that's right and there was and when they're going back in time when they go to the army base and you know cap is seeing um uh peggy carter there and then and iron man or tony stark's talking to his dad and like that scene has got power behind it right it is the end with captain america as an old man handing his shield over to uh to sam like straight up all of that stuff makes that superior to the first iron man it is i'm sorry it's first avengers end game it's so good it's just you know what jamie just put at the top all the way just killed me yeah all the way to the left yeah all the way left better than winter soldier yeah i'm okay with that jamie just sold me too like it's it's and then maybe we're just paying it the respect because it was the finale of all of this but it deserves it i think yeah well that's the thing is you think about in the history of movies or whatever nobody has pulled off what we're looking at here at all and nobody ever will again i think yeah not even them like it is going to be
right next to impossible for them to actually catch lightning again like this i agree i i will say that it did have there's those moments in the theater that you remember like i know i'm that old as a kid watching the first star wars and the star destroyer fly over and being blown away this movie were you scared when the train came at the screen when you went to see that so anyway i get it i get it uh so this movie has one of those scenes when i was in the theater i saw it opening night and when captain america calls thor's hammer to him the the entire theater almost stood to its feet and cheered it was insane what that one scene did and you've seen you've seen people who uh it's on youtube people will show clips of that well in the latest uh trailer for the upcoming series they show that clip and that's exactly where our theater was so yeah can you imagine any movie like this a superhero movie like make up people cry at the end because of something we've lived with these characters through 20 movies 22 movies or whatever it ended up being and like the way that it all came together and just even the cheesy stuff like in the end battle where they like like they go around all the different different groups like fighting and stuff and they do like some really kind of corny things like where all the female characters jump in and stuff i'm like oh my god that is so cool what they just did even though it's kind of cheesy in a
way too it just all worked together so well to just give you goosebumps every five minutes you're getting goosebumps again about something that was happening it's the perfect culmination to all of these movies yeah yeah and don't forget like when thor sees his mom oh yeah i forgot about i just remember that you know because i was like man that was such like a just ripped you you know what i mean it was crazy because she at that moment she knows she's about to die but you didn't know that back in dark world you didn't realize that she knew she was going to die and then in in endgame she's like oh but i'm a witch of course i know that and they in the all of these like callbacks and stuff like i said i went through and watched all of these and like if i had my own little sandbox i would just have every captain america movie at the top because there's so many like just little moments of like holy crap did they just retroactively make that work or was somebody like thinking you know when they when they did first um first avenger like that far out i don't know but it's just nuts yeah well like a perfect example of what you're saying joel i think in end game where sam shows up and says on your left like yeah yeah exactly like whenever that was determined that what maybe the most brilliant way to make that scene unfold given just a tiny little joke towards the beginning in fact i think that's the opening sequence of uh winter soldier
yeah that it's something else hey so we do are we doing one more movie marty uh yes yeah i i pulled the wrong i got i'm sorry y'all they said i pulled the wrong avengers movie but these things are soft all the way at the front keep keep your mouse away from ultron actually what's ragnarok doing after oh that's all messed up it is all messed up so hold on which one is this which is one on the end where's age of ultron age of ultron is right here right do you even tier list bro
all right so uh finally you said you guys want to do far from home let's just drag that up here what do i think about far from home i like i think it's good i think it's good i just watched that again like i said uh it's good the villain is kind of neat but kind of stupid so i liked it in a way and i liked his whole like crazy you know illusion juice stuff because when you first watch that movie if you know mysterio or like what's happening who is this guy he's from another dimension or whatever and uh and then you go oh okay he's playing a big trick on everybody yeah i did that i did like i actually liked how they used tech uh and sort of stark related tech to to explain the character in this universe um i would put it in good too i think i'd probably i mean it's up to joel as it relates to thor but i'd probably put it towards the end of i put it just to the left of thor honestly actually that's perfect for me because i really think these two are pretty close like there's a funkiness to both of them that i like because i think a lot of times i don't know like i kind of get wrapped up and like well this is kind of hokey but then i think if i read this on the page in a comic book i'd love it well speaking and speaking of that the sequence with mysterio where he's in like really messing with him that's amazing that is straight out of the comic books man it's so so awesome yeah that was good stuff i mean for comic book fans i'm gonna put this one for me in okay at the far
left uh so almost good yeah and that's only because the first half the movie is boring to me it's like you know a teen dating comedy for a really long time and then the action starts because mysterio was a rad bad guy and he was like a goofball in the in the the comics too right he was just like a special effects guy who made everybody think that he was a a magician a wizard and so he that's okay and and i think most people who knew knows the comics kind of knew that was coming right sure so i think that's okay with this bad guy and again spider-man is not supposed to be fighting the thanos level stuff he's always the little guys that are just kind of tricking you or like just beating you up you know and i like that about it but it wasn't as good as the first one i don't think no i'd rather have it in okay than than good right you did kind of fast forward the the uh the relationship with him and mary jane uh and that's because at the end of one there's just a small hint of some feelings between each other and then they really go fast forward into it at the beginning of two and i understand why they had to do that because they couldn't really like develop it over a whole other movie and all that kind of stuff but that that you write that first probably 20 30 minutes of that teen stuff is a little bit sort of sped up it's just not for us uh old people we don't need to yeah well when it stands it lands because i think that you know they did a good job of it like in the acting and stuff and she's like duh you're spider-man you know i was
like that's kind of cool you know um so yeah anyway but i if it's there or maybe to the left of thor i would i definitely like it better than the first store um i don't know it's perfect right there for me uh it's all you all said good right or what did y'all say okay jamie said okay you said okay two goods and then okay oh geez it puts it on me i i like it better than four but i don't know if it's the end of good or first of okay it don't matter it's a it's a coin flip why don't you put it at the left of okay to make it look more better let's just balance this out a little bit yeah it's that's exactly that is the same thing if we go from best to worse either they're up there it's the same thing that's true um so well okay so that we're done with the list looking at this list what movie jumps out you as a surprise of where ended up i know my size of golden tickets i don't know yeah the golden tickets kind of messed things up i agree we'll wreck it it does um to me nothing looks weird to me iron man still looks like other than mine and joel's golden tickets uh taking into account your golden tickets uh you and dave it looks good to me i mean it looks what i would want it to be i mean this whole list looks like what my list would actually be honestly yeah i'm about there yeah i i still
would have put iron man pro on my personal list iron man went a bit higher but again i'm i'm the that's what start that was the catalyst to everything that we've been talking about for the past hour and i've still got to give kudos to that mine i think should be right after the captain america in good i think that's where i would put it but it's okay where it is yeah i'm not gonna change it i'm not gonna change it so wow i'm surprised that that many ended up in great course i think most golden tickets pushed things into great didn't it one of them did yeah or no dave's did too with uh gardens galaxy 2. yeah and i did with doctor strange so oh that's right yeah so there were three it up there
so i said we would go about an hour and we're just a little over an hour to close this thing out just to kind of set up the next phase of the marvel just uh personally what marvel movies that's coming out maybe the next year black widow with turtles uh uh sing sing chi song charts oh my gosh i can't think of the name what's the master of karate whatever his name is that's one but anyway i just remember master of karate or master kung fu that's it master kung fu that's what the comic books got of all those what are you looking forward to what movie is like i cannot wait to see this particular movie in the next year that's coming out in the marvel universe doctor strange in the multiverse of madness number one for me because that's gonna like i said doctor strange is my favorite character the first one is amazing but it's an origin story part two is going to be the one that really like fires me up so i'm i'm dying to see that one yeah i would that that's definitely at the top of my list i think that the number one for me is eternals um like i said i'm a i'm a thor guy i'm an eternals guy there's a great storyline um what happened that well no i'll just tell you the gist of it it basically combines because they've told the ragnarok story in thor a couple of times this one has the eternals in it and i think it's by far the best eternal storyline and the best door storyline and it's just a whole mess of nutty
crazy dark worldy you know guarding the galaxy kind of stuff and i'm really excited to see how they sort of bake in the eternals um you know into the mcu and everything but other than that uh the spider-man and the doctor stranger probably the other two and the new black panther i mean i would say all of them really dave david uh so i was either disconnected from y'all or something because i haven't been i just got back from like two minutes worth of not being on the stream oh good thing you didn't hear what joel said about you now we were just talking about uh of the upcoming marvel movies what's the one you're really looking forward to black widow eternals uh spider-man doctor strange two et cetera oh doctor strange hands down like after after uh wanda vision without question one division took those two characters particularly wanda to a completely new height for me that i would like just never thought i would care about those characters as much as i care about every other main significant character in the mcu yep and doctor strange is going to be up there for me and it's mainly called wonder vision because now i know scarlet witch and dr strange are going to go head to head for a little bit i would assume at this point and i don't want to see those two fight each other i'm also very curious about the new spider-man because that they introduced the multiverse yeah i love multiverse i love multiverse anything and if the rumors are true and the previous spider-man are coming
back james garfield and toby mcguire that'll be very interesting and i also want to throw out a quick i'm excited for the new fantastic four movie which is way out but they teased it a little bit in one of their recent things and that's i'm not a huge fantastic four fan but as i was saying earlier doctor strange is one of my favorite characters one of the other of my three favorite characters is dr doom and they have not gotten dr doom right yet in any one of these movies and i can't wait to see him and i hope he becomes actually a more present villain in the mcu like they use him not as just a throwaway in the first fantastic four but he's going to be like a a present figure throughout a lot of stuff and i would love that i would absolutely love that and uh so yes the next fantastic four movie is another one that i'm fired up about fantastic all right so we are going to uh wrap up here we'll just start at the bottom and uh just kind of tell you know people where they can find you and uh i hear somebody uh is running a big kickstarter right now maybe they want to share a little about that about that jamie oh yeah uh yes actually uh the secret cabal i come from the secret cabal gaming podcast obviously we do you know uh podcast content every week we do some youtube con and all kinds of different stuff and right now on kickstarter we have our uh our yearly fundraiser that we do to um that we run every year so that we can continue making all of this content and uh and uh getting to the conventions and upgrading our equipment and all that
different stuff so our fundraiser is over there now we're doing very well and uh we're on our way to the ultimate goal so check it out if you'd like to support the secret cabal yeah and please do joel yep you can take a look at me at drivethroughgames.com or look up drive through review or drive to games on youtube and i'm always pumping out nonsense it's good nonsense nonsense i like that speaking of nonsense david hey uh yeah come on over to man vs meeple on youtube uh that's where we do our thing uh all sorts of board game reviews previews etcetera and so forth uh come check it out yeah and if you've enjoyed what you've watched please give us a follow or a thumbs up let us know in the comments and some other tier lists this is one of those things i've kind of just discovered and they've got tons of pre-made tier lists out here including y'all the top 100 games on bgg it'd be kind of tough to go through 100 games but be interested to sit down and and rank stuff like that so uh maybe we do something more board game related at some point in time but i want to thank each and every one of you for joining me tonight this was a lot of fun again i got to take a snapshot of this because i'm still kind of surprised where uh uh things uh landed but don't be surprised marty you gave us the golden tickets marty it's your fault it's your fault marty it is i uh it was not play test that well at all so i know also you know what i will say is the golden tickets did prevent
um negatively voting because if somebody would have if if dark world would have ended it like mad or bad i might have had some spite and had a target on on another movie's back so awesome again thanks everybody for watching thank you guys for joining and make sure to follow each and every one of these people on their podcast go follow them on youtube and everything i'll put links in the description to all their stuff and