Vantage Board Game Review
Transcript
Hello, welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews. Don't do unboxings, but we might do a few playthroughs in the near future. Today, we're going to be talking about a supposed openw world exploration game. We're going to be talking about Vantage. And in this game, you will have crashed into a planet. You'll be using cards to explore a world, rolling a few dice, taking a few tests in the hope that you can fulfill an objective and win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, be telling you what we do like, what we don't like, then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Vantage is worth your time and bother today and in the future. So, remember, if you're new here, please consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, and all that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you after this bollocks advantage. How'd you play this game?
So, Vantage is a supposed openw world exploration game. There will be some minor spoilers in here, but it won't be anything that you're not going to experience yourself when you crack the game open. So, it's going to be the first few locations that you're going to visit, but not all of them, right? If that's a problem for you, then you can [ __ ] off now. So, Vantage is a game that reminds us a little bit of Tales of the Arabian Knights and the old ' 80s game books you used to get, you know, like Fighting Fantasy, Lone Wolf, and all that sort of [ __ ] It's like tried to take the concepts of these older games and try and embellish them with some I guess new mechanics and all that sort of thing. Right. So, Advantage, you are part of the crew of a spaceship. You will have crashed landed into a planet and you and your other players will be spread across different locations on this world, right? You'll be given a shared objective that you may have to complete. You don't really have to do it, but you will have won the game if you complete it. And everyone will get a character. Each character is good at a different skill. So, you might have somebody that's good at negotiating or somebody that's good at taking stuff or fighting or whatever. Each character will have a special ability that is usually triggered through these boost cubes. So, you'll spend boost cubes to activate the special ability. At the beginning of the game, you will have a location card on your little tray thing, and it will usually have like a picture of where you are, some text on the bottom that will describe where you are, and usually on the right hand side, there will be a list of actions and a number that when you choose the action, it will direct you to one of the story
books of that color. Yeah, each color refers to a different type of action. And in the top lefthand corner, you will have a number that refers to the numbered location in one of the books of the location where you are. Right? So on your turn, you'll be able to take one of three actions. You can take a location action. You can only ever take one location action at each location unless the game tells you otherwise. This is usually done in the books when it tells you to continue or giving you the may continue option, right? But other than that, you can only do this once. What you'll do, you'll choose one of the options along the right hand side, and you'll get one of the other players to go to the location in the same colored book, read you the cost, and also what the action entails. So, you'll have maybe like a three and a hex that will tell you to roll three dice, and it will give you a little sentence about what you're actually trying to achieve. So, when you take the location action, you have to do a challenge, you'll take that number of dice, and you'll have to roll them. But you will also be able to mitigate the chances of taking a penalty cuz in Vantage you cannot bail an action. You will always succeed. The penalties come in the form of health, time, and morale. So before you roll the dice, everybody collectively can spend skill tokens that they would have got at the beginning of the game or through other actions in the game, right? You'll be able to spend them and then you'll roll the dice and you can then choose to further mitigate the penalties of the dice by allocating them to yours or other players cards. These slots will appear on your character card. They'll appear on item cards. And maybe you'll have like a companion that can absorb the cost. There may be restrictions. You
might have to be taking a certain type of action or they may have to be limited to the icon on the die. But once you're done with that, then you'll take the penalty. Yeah, it may be that you'll have to reduce your health or the time or whatever. Or maybe you'll just have to put them back in the die pool because once the dice have been used up, you'll be able to take all your dice off of all the cards and stick them back in the supply. The circular arrow one means that this is going to slow that down. Yeah, the hyphen means that you just dump it straight into the penalty box and it doesn't do anything. Other than that, you'll have to move your attributes down. If ever any players attributes go down to zero, then you will lose the game immediately. Right. The next action you can do is a card action. I think we've already sort of touched on this. Yeah, but you'll take some boost cubes or whatever and you'll be able to spend them or you'll be able to do something else that says on one of the cards that you have got, right?
You'll always have a 3x3 grid with your character in the middle. And once you have got all of them filled up, then you'll have to move cards from your reserve cuz you can keep cards in reserve from your reserve stack into your play area. But you'll have to take a card out, right? So the final action that you can take is a depart action when you've exhausted all the options at a location or the game tells you to. Then you will look at the little compass that's in the top leftand corner and you'll have to choose one of the locations to go to. So you'll go either north, south, east, or west. If there is an entry, you'll go to the relevant book and another player will read out to you what happens. If there's like a little dot, then you'll have to go to another book and the same thing will happen, right? If you change location, you'll dig into the location cards, you'll swap it out, and you'll stick your placeholder into where the new location card was, right? So, yeah, I mean, that's basically it. Yeah, it's not really many rules to this. Most of the rules come in the form of actually exploring the game. Yeah, like we said, if you manage to complete your objective, then you win the game. And the rule book does say strangely that you can just decide for yourselves what winning a game actually is. So if you think that just you know sitting down and get bored out your [ __ ] brains wins the game, then that's fine. Yeah.
Because there's not really any kind of way that the game guides you through this other than the objective that you randomly draw at the beginning. Yeah. And a lot of these don't really make any sense. You know what I mean? So it is a case of aimlessly wandering around until you've decided that you've had enough of it. Right. So what do we like about Vantage? So the first thing that we quite like about this is that there is multiple ways for the game to give you clues as to what the location actually entails. Yeah. Like you can look at the actual picture that you're looking at, right? Your vantage point. And this might give you clues about what some of the actions might lead to. Yeah. So if there's a character on the card or something and they look kind of aggressive, that gives you a clue as to how you might approach a situation. and you might want to sort of hang back and see how things play out. But then sometimes the game actually works the other way and if you hang back you actually miss out on something because you misjudge the situation. So like with all these types of openw world like narrative driven games like Fighting Fantasy books and all that sort of thing. Not really 100% sure how it's going to pay out, but there are clues in the text and on the cards and maybe even the actions themselves might give you a clue as to how the actual location is going to go.
Right. So the second thing that we like about this and this is probably the best thing about this game is that the table talk that you get from discussing what you are going to do is fantastic. Yeah. Like we played this the other day and one of my mates was trying to decide how to approach a situation and we were all getting stuck in trying to imagine what the other person was seeing because you're not allowed to show the other players the actual card. You can describe what you see. You can read the text. You can even tell them what actions you've got on the card. Yeah. But you can't show it to them. So really you got like this sort of personal thing going on. How you are imagining what the world might be like and everyone else has got their own vision as to what is being described. Yeah. It's like read a book in it. You know what I mean? Everyone's going to put their own personal print onto what they are seeing. Yeah. And discussing that trying to give people advice as to what might happen your thoughts on stuff. It's really really nice. Yeah. It's just a shame that there's not really that much game underneath it. So the final thing that we quite like well it's not what we like about it. It's what we admire about it. Yeah. and that is that this game has taken a huge risk. Yeah, it's taken apparently 8 years to create this game and it kind of shows. Yeah, because it is vast. Yeah, it's not really an open world game. I don't think I've seen a true open world game up to this point where you can basically do whatever you like because this game does funnel you down certain routes. Yeah, it's like a flow diagram. So, you start here and it branches out. So, you can't really go wherever the hell you like because there's some locations that aren't accessible from other ones if you take a certain path here. But yeah, that's this word has been banded around loads about this game, but it is an ambitious game.
Yeah, in taking risks and being ambitious, that's got his own foles and some of the inevitable pitfalls that are presented when you're trying to create a game like this. They've been sort of papered over rather than concreted over. You know what I mean? So, what don't you like about Vantage? So, the first thing that we don't really like about this is the fact that the game has a paper thin dice rolling mechanic that just feels like it's been inserted because it had to have some kind of board game mechanism chucked in. Yeah, this is essentially a game book that is based around card play, right? So, whereas the old game books had a couple of dice, you added up the numbers and you added an attack strength and all that, with this one, they've tried to be more elaborate. They've tried to tack on a proper game onto that style of storytelling. Yeah. And for me personally, it doesn't work particularly well. It gets in the way of the story if there actually is a story. Yeah. It becomes a bit of a chore trying to get all your skill tokens together to try and mitigate the die roll. And having to roll a bunch of dice multiple times just disrupts the flow of the narrative being told here. Right. I like the fact that you can't fail, but then I don't like it as well because there's not really any kind of risk because, you know, other than losing a few hit points or what have you got, you're not really at risk of anything because even if you die, then you can just say, "Fuck it. I'll just carry on." Yeah. There's nothing really to stop you. I mean, the game basically gives you the option of tossing all of the threats aside and just carrying on. You know what I mean?
So, the final thing that we don't like about Vantage is I got some questions about the longevity of this. I know the world is huge, but I'm not talking about how long you could play it for. Yeah. It's that if you do end up stopping the game and you do go back to the beginning, you're going to see all of the [ __ ] at the beginning of the game multiple times, you're going to have to wade through that [ __ ] quagmire [ __ ] before you can get to the stuff that you haven't seen because there's no real way to save the game in here. Yeah, we ended up putting all the cards in baggies, but there's no official way to save the game. It seems to me that the rules try and discourage you from just carrying on. You know what I mean? They don't really want you to do that. They want you to go back to the beginning and start again. And in a game that is effectively just a big flowchart of encounters, really small encounters, yeah, they're not really that well described. Understand why? Because you haven't really got that much room to play with. Yeah. Having to troll through a load of crap that you've already seen before. That is a problem. You remember time stories? Yeah, it's the same sort of thing. You get to a certain point, you [ __ ] it up, then you have to go back, redo all the stuff you've seen before. It becomes a real [ __ ] chore.
And before long, you are thinking, "Fuck this. I can't be [ __ ] asked." So to summarize, is Vantage worth your time and bother today and in the future? So I'm a bit torn about this. Yeah. Because when we first cracked this open, I was like, "Fuck me. This is like really, really good." Yeah. I'm got stuck into the story and I thought, "Yeah, this is like a fantastic experience." Yeah. This is like Tales of the Arabian Nights on steroids. But after a few hours of playing this, Yeah. the game started to reveal itself as a weak implementation of the game books that we were playing like 40 years ago. You know what I mean? It's not really any different to that. Yeah. It's a more complex version of a game book based on cards. Yeah. And the dice rolling mechanic is paper thin. Yeah. It disrupts the flow of the narrative if there is one. I mean, the storytelling in this is just as weak. Yeah. There are some surprises in the game where you are tested and you thinking, should I keep going or shall I stop now? Yes. So, there is that sort of thing. But ultimately, the story isn't really there yet. It's just a series of random encounters that don't seem to be linked together. And the aimless nature of the supposed open world is this game's downfall. Yeah. Because to be honest, I start to get a little bit bored. Yeah.
Start to get a little bit frustrated. Like I said, this is nothing but an elaborate game book. And I suppose it's a poor one at that. Yeah. I'd rather be reading Death Trap Dungeon or Forest Doom where a promise is set out. You've got a quest to complete. You know that every location is linked to the quest that you are on. In this, you're just going to be thrown some random encounters. You're going to be going from one location to the next. And where there isn't that predetermined promise, yeah, where you are given the illusion of free roaming. Essentially, what this game boils down to is a series of very, very small encounters that don't seem to have any kind of linkage whatsoever. So, ultimately, that plus the feverishly boring dice rolling mechanic lets this game down. Yeah. So, there you go. That is Vantage. Remember, if you are new here, please consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, and all that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you next time.