Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 28:00

let's be real Apple Jack is not the most popular game of all time even among Rosenberg games its rating on board gameing geek is a 6.8 out of 10 many prominent reviewers were lukewarm at most when they spoke about it when it was released back in 2022 I'm coming in at a five as well on this one um I I just don't think this is a good game there's five fives across the board got to be kidding me this is so dumb to me this is a three out of five all right so I'm giving it a five five five they were all wrong just kidding I love these reviewers and I agree with some of their opinions but Apple Jack by U Rosenberg is one of those Diamonds in the Rough among lightweight board games that is somewhat easy to teach but hard to master if you want proof of this look no further than board game arena the game has a very competitive following with many players Vine to beat the to player in each Arena season and with alltime rankings in the 600s yes with only around 130,000 games played on board game arena since its release it's still not the most popular game on the platform however I think many people realize this game has a lot more going on than what meets the eye without going into too much of a review one thing about this game online is that the bookkeeping is taken care of automatically there is a lot lot of intermittent income and scoring in this

game and mathematically it can be jarring when playing it physically with that out of the way more brain space can be used to play this game at its most efficient now what is this strategy Iceberg I've really enjoyed learning about various non-board game topics via the format of the iceberg which starts at the tip with knowledge that is known by most folks diving down to the lower tiers of the iceberg with knowledge that is known to some I've decided to adapt this format to teach about the strategy to this game and further classifying the tiers of the iceberg I start at the top with the most basic knowledge you need to know how to play this game well followed by insights I've gathered from multiple plays over a 100 now and by study of the game at it and its best players as the strategy gets deeper and more complex note that I myself am not an expert technically on board game arena but I have played this game more than 100 times I stated before and have taken the time to look at the stats and the games of expert players and of course there are my observations and subjective opinions on the game and though I try to be as objective as possible I may still not understand everything so comments and insights are appreciated with that explanation done let's start at the very tip of the strategy Iceberg for Applejack

this tier is not wholly intended to teach you the game rules so if you're not familiar I would reach for the rule book or watch a video on how to play this tier is a small step above that rules that may maybe you have missed or that are crucial as a foundation for understanding the deeper strategy of the game let's turn to the rule book with a nice overview of how turns work in this game first you choose a tile from either side of the dice pay honey the currency of this game as displayed on the tile and place it wherever you want on your Tableau if you place the Beehive symbol or the hive next to another one you receive the lowest amount of Honey back then move the dice to the next spot on the central tracker and if there is one or no tiles choose from refill each spot on the central board not just the adjacent ones next to the dice with one tile note that you can always flip a tile over to place it on the sheep side and you gain 200y for that move sometimes if you cannot afford a tile to place on your Tableau you must do this I will say now that this move is never optimal sheep will not help you score at the end of the game or at least to score optim so it is best to avoid flipping tiles whenever possible an important concept to remember is that for every beehive connection you receive honey back so

multiple connections can get you even more honey back at this level it's important to know that you score points in two major ways blossoms and groups of apples you score points three times twice during the game and once at the end blossoms score at all scoring opportun unities and you simply add up all of the blossoms shown on your Tableau and receive that much honey however the exception is during the second scoring opportunity when the dice Pips turn from 2 to three you will count how many blossoms you have and score twice that much honey so collecting blossoms in the first two rounds particularly of the game can get you a lot of points a lot of Honey which allows freedom to buy tiles and builds up your final score try to to group as many of the same type of apple together as you can in one group you will not score for multiple groups of apples the reasons why will be explained in the next

tier now that we know how to squore in this game how do we score the most amount of points possible in the rule book the explanation for how apples are scored during and at the end of the game may sound mathematically daunting at least it did for me it's not as straightforward as just counting up all of the points shown on your tiles so I'll try to break it down so it's as understandable as possible by the end of the game you want each Apple color or type of which there are seven Apple types to be in a single group of at least four apples the reasons for this is that are that at the end of the game or first you will gain honey from each type of apple by subtracting the number of apples in the group minus the PIP on the dice at most it will be three so four apples per group gets you at least one point positively at the end of the game the second reason is that there is a bonus scoring opportunity if you have large groups of apples called the variety bonus based on this chart as you can see if you have four types of apples with at least four apples in each group you'll gain an extra four points at the end of the game if you have all seven apples of groups of four you will gain an extra 35 points the difference between each of these bonuses can matter a lot if my opponent only has six of the seven types of apples in groups of four or more and I have seven I'm scoring a

whole free 14 points more than my opponent so your goal for every game is to group all all seven types of apples in groups of four or more if you don't happen to reach all seven Apple types with groups of four don't count yourself out of the game just yet I've lost games where I've had all seven groups met at 4 each for each apple while my opponent lost out on one group my opponent though won because they had stacked two of their apple types enough so that that it overcame the deficit of points I had made over them for the variety bonus and let me explain at the end of the game you will gain a score based on the total amount of groups of apples in groups of four and above sum that value and then multiply it by two for points meaning if I have a group of 11 pink apples for example as is depicted in the rule book I subtract three from that final pip count on the dice and multiply that by two to get 16 points from that single color the way that I think of it is each apple you add to a specific group starting with the fourth Apple you add to it is worth two points each at the end of the game you can calculate how many apples you would need in your group to overcome any deficit that you might have if you can't reach your goal of seven groups of four so overall my plan at this stage of experience with the game is to try to get to Seven groups of

four as soon as you can by usually the middle of the game to sometime just after after the second Blossom scoring and then continue to build out from those groups with more apples to increase your base score at the end of the game in addition accumulating blossoms is more important in the first two rounds of the game as you can count each Blossom that you place in the first round for example as equaling Four Points once for the first Blossom intermediate scoring twice for the second Blossom scoring and one more time with the final scoring blossoms will lose their value as the game goes on when you add them to the board so try to plan out your tile so that you can maximize how many blossoms you accumulate in optimally the first two rounds of

play at this point of my journey in learning Apple Jack I started playing more games against top players I started to realiz some things about the first third of the game the first seven turns before the dice Pips turn to two tile placement is key to success in the next two phases of the game and that's what I want to focus on now before I continue you might notice that you can play the game in a few different ways the way that I and many of the top players play on board game arena are with the as side of the board just hives instead of apples on your personal Tableau random Apple tiles on the main board board and having a side tile next to your to your board to choose from on your turn which is refilled if you use it so back to tile placement I noticed a few different ways that top players used to start the game depending on what tiles are available of course you can start on an edge matching hives saving you honey to spend early in the game the first phase I would say is pretty tight when it comes to honey so this is a very viable strategy you can also though place a tile straight in the middle of the board and build out from there if need be I would recommend starting this way in the middle if one a tile has three or four apples on it of different colors two the tile has many hives on it and three the tile itself costs around 8 honey at most

hey this is Phil from the future just want to let you know that there aren't a lot of tiles that have eight as their High number so there's more on that later so if you do have to choose a tile to start in the middle you can go with a tile that has nine cost on it or seven or even lower if you wanted to uh it's either going to be seven or nine eight is a pretty good start if you have that available but just letting you know that might not be the case all the time in a two-player game for example the first player starts with 16 honey and the second player with 20 if you play a tile in the middle middle without gaining a discount back by playing on the edge you would risk losing so much honey that you can't buy any of their tiles for quite a while if you play a tile in the middle that fits the criteria above it gives you a lot of flexibility to build out from the middle as well as having the edge hives being able to be played from if need be one thing to know is that the most expensive tiles in the game costs up to 11 honey it's nice to have enough honey to buy one of these tiles if they do pop up in any case I would pay attention to all the tiles that are currently available on the board see what the most expensive ones are and make sure you don't spend honey in a way that you wouldn't have enough honey to purchase those tiles typically those more expensive tiles that have multiple and varial types of apple on them are a

great way to start your game in the first place in addition to starting out the game with a tile in the middle I've seen this pattern of beginning to play out successfully too you start with the triy hiive tile on the edge of the board this gives you an opportunity to play out from that tile and after playing you can play another one that matches two hives one from the tile and one from the board as seen here yes it does require some honey investment but if you Tye this just right and use the right tiles and apple groups you can make up that difference later and still have the flexibility you need to build off of this and continue your groupings one great way to gain a lot of Honey early in the game is to make multiple Hive matches so this start helps facilitate that opportunity to do so now there is Randomness in this game of course whenever tiles are refilled and of course how the game is set up in the first place and this happens this refilling process rather happens a few times during the game so sometimes you may be blessed with the tiles and apples you need in a pinch sometimes you and your opponent will not see a certain Apple type for the longest time during the game making any of those tiles more competitive one thing that has helped me face the reality of this Randomness is having a big picture in mind of how you want to organize your Tau I found the most efficient way to

build your Tableau is to have single apples and tiles with two of the same type of app on it usually around the outside of the board with the tiles that have multiple Apple types and multiple hives in the middle of the board this is one reason why starting with a multiple tile with apples on it in the middle and at the beginning of the game which creates flexibility to respond to the randomness of the game to be efficient in this game you optimally want every tile to count towards the largest group of each apple type as much as possible block blocking off an apple type can not only lead to having to make up lost ground elsewhere by building up a group but sometimes you don't even realize that you're missing one or two apples from getting that magical fourth Apple for each group so starting the game out in a way mentioned before in this section gives you the best chance to play anywhere you can and with as much efficiency as possible mitigating for the randomness of tile flips

after rising to the 200s in ranking on board game arena referring to my journey again I started playing more consistently against tougher opponents and I waffled back and forth between the rankings of 100 to 200 for quite a while I tried to learn from mistakes and take the strategies I saw from other opponents as much as possible and it was at this level of play that I started to really understand understand the foresight that you need in this game to be successful I think once you start to feel comfortable with how your own Tableau should be built out each game understanding the main Tableau and the main board and what your opponent is trying to do is key to being successful in the long run against tougher opponents first I try to look a few turns ahead of the game at at the very least two or three turns ahead but optimally more this is somewhat easy to do too because your opportunity unities to draft tiles will always match the spaces as depicted by your player shape whether that's a circle triangle Etc before I talk about the main board first let's talk about your Tableau many of the expert players plan tiles ahead so that as you place down a tile that matches multiple sides for a lot of honey you gain multiple Avenues of income I think of this as a good time to tell you what a good score is at the end of the game good players can consistently get scores of 140 and above in my opinion with scores going as high

as the 190s someone has probably cracked 200 out there but I have not seen that personally yet or remember doing so one key to getting this type of score is to match up tiles with multiple hives to other tiles surrounding it at the same time if you can do this multiple times during a game this will seemingly exponentially increase the honey you are receiving and that is amazing this is where I also address the tiles that only have blossoms on them and no apples they often have a lot of sides with hives on them I like these tiles in the mid to Lake game if you have already achieved your groupings for apples for example uh these tiles are great if you can place your Apple tiles in a way to really benefit from these Blossom ones as you lay them down sometimes these tiles are great to to play somewhat early to allow for more hives uh to match Apple tiles into later on and discounting the cost that it would take to do so but I tend to pick these Apple tiles over these just Apple tiles in general uh depending on the situation these Blossom tiles can really help you get a lot of honey and I think these situations usually happen a little bit later in the game one thing to know is that when you look ahead the tiles that are in the space ahead of where the dice is placed rather than the space that is behind will always be available to you when

your turn comes meaning the turn before your opponent will have the opportunity to draft a tile from that space behind where the dice will go for your turn if you plan out the tiles that you want to draft two or three turns ahead I recommend you try to find tiles that work together in these quote unquote ahead spaces to avoid your opponent drafting a tile that you potentially would want or have a backup in mind if you really want a tile that would be available to your opponent before it comes to your turn one thing is that is interesting is about how the main board works and on the space that you are currently taking your turn in you have your tiles that are ahead of you and behind the dice as we've mentioned before if there are multiple choices that are appealing to you know that you can always save the tiles that are behind the dice currently as the dice goes around the board these tiles that are behind will be ahead of you when the dice returns to that same spot your opponent won't have an opportunity to draft that tile until after you're free to turn when you could have drafted it note that this observation works best at two players and it really only applies to two players in this particular circumstance stance it doesn't work this way with three or four players because of how quickly the dice goes around the board and the amount of spaces does not uh

really match the way that it does with the two- player I have the most experience with two players and so if you are doing this at this player count this will work for you so if you can try to apply this at higher player counts but it might be a little bit different as you look ahead on the main board especially with the variable Apple tiles on the board one thing that can influence your decisions is what apples are coming up for intermittent income roughly the first third of the board has no apples for income the second third has the variable apples that are randomly assigned at the beginning of the game and the last third has printed a printed static order of apples each apple type scores twice in a round if you have the chance to grab a few tiles and group them before that particular Apple type is scored intermittently especially before the first time an apple scores then you can squeeze out a few extra points of honey for scoring and for spending another way that you can keep tabs on your opponent is to look at the Apple groupings and their apple groupings and try to block them from obtaining that essential fourth Apple for that particular group they are going for this is especially important in the last phase of the game you could be taken away at least 14 points from your opponent's final score if you are able to successfully take tiles away from them it is a bonus if you can use them for yourself and for your own benefit

whether to fulfill that fourth Apple in your group or just to improve the group that you have started further your sideboard is a great way to hold on to tiles your opponent needs that does not necessarily have to go onto your Tableau if there aren't any great spots for them at the moment overall looking a you turns ahead is key to understanding what your opponent needs and can draft from as well as what you need I haven't made it to the expert player level myself so I can't speak from direct experience I will update this video if I do end up reaching this level however I have played and studied the games of enough times of experts to ascertain that in in order to play at this high level you apply the steps that we have covered in this video the last thing I wanted to really address are the spread of tiles in the game how each apple and Hive are distributed so you can have an idea of what to expect and your chances of finding the apples and tiles that you need in a pinch there are roughly equal number of each apple spread throughout the 100 tiles of the game either alone on a tile or found in duplicate or with other Apple Types on the same tile there is an average of 31 apples of each color except for one extra pink Apple and one less brown and dark green apple in the game while it shouldn't matter too much

when collecting your groups it might be statistically a little bit harder to find the brown and dark green apples but speaking from experience I've had games where I've had either an abundance of or am in dire need of each of these Apple types when looking at the tiles and how much they cost in other words the cost of the hives it seems there are more tiles between the costs of 4 through 7even forming a bell curve of sorts the further you go from the sort of average cost there are very little tiles that cost 2 or 11 the extremes of costs in this game and for some reason tiles that cost eight as well once again if you have the chance to start a game with an 8 cost tile I would recommend looking at that tile and try to prioritize it and see if it fits with your board it could save you some extra costs as you gather the more abundant seven and lower cost tiles I also looked at which tile costs include blossoms and total the amount of blossoms found on each tile cost by the way the total amount of Blossom in the game spread over all the tiles is 61 it is skewed towards the least expensive tiles further supporting the strategy of opening the game with lesser cost tiles to gather blossoms that could boost your endgame score after you get to the cost of seven for tiles blossoms tend to go away for a maximum score grabbing high cost tiles isn't the recommended strategy including those

lower cost tiles can not only fill in the gaps on the edges of the board real well but also Supply you with blossoms for scoring once again know that there are only five tiles with only blossoms on them and with an increased amount of hives for matching these tiles are great for setting up multi- matches and could be placed earlier in the game for potential scoring opportunities there or you can place them later in the game after you have secured your groups of apples my last piece of advice is to keep playing this is pretty easy to do on board game arena and there are always opponents to play there you always have the option to look at the statistics and match yours against other winners as well as the top players to see where some deficits might be I'm not very familiar with the solo game but it would be a great way to understand the basic rules if you have the game physically and perhaps Tinker around with different openings and things like that what I have found to be the most useful is to just replay games of extra players this is free and easy to do on board game arena by clicking on a top player you can go to their game history and Replay Games of theirs now this feature is somewhat controversial in the forums on board game arena so I won't disparage your opinion on of this if you are counter um or against this opinion but I feel like it this is a feature that is out there uh it doesn't breach any real life information and so

since it is available I think it's a great way to analyze the game and its best players to improve your own game and this is true for any game rather on the platform in sum I will break down my points of strategy as follows one always try to get at least a grouping of four of each of the seven types of apples make these groupings as quickly as possible so you can maximize the income you get from them during the game as well as the bonus points at the end of the game two always try to have enough honey to buy any tile that is face up and ready to draft at the very most it will be 11 prioritize tiles with blossoms on them third prioritize tiles with blossoms on them early in the game tiles with only blossoms on them will help you score multiple Hive matchings later on in the game four if you can try starting the game in the middle of your board and try to place multiple Apple type tiles in the middle of the board with single type tiles on the outside edges to maximize the flexibility and to mitigate for the randomness of this game five always plan two or more turns ahead and pay attention to what your opponent needs to fulfill their goals please comment and let me know if any corrections need to be made or if there's anything you would do differently that has brought you success in this game let me know if I should make more

strategy videos like this by liking the video my name is Phil and I've been your board game doctor today thank you for Consulting with me and I hope you set an appointment with your board game doctor real soon take care

Progress saved