Beyond Solitaire Podcast 219: Ted Caya on Take
Transcript
It's ad break time. I'm proud to announce the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. Right now, they have a fun new project on the way. The Cracked Mirror, a downloadable expansion for 500-year-old vampire, turns the game into an episttolary experience for one to two players. The expansion will be available for free in 2026, but you can get it now for a small donation. And trust me, every donation helps CLGs as they continue their mission of producing peer-reviewed games in the academic space. It is pioneering work that no one else is doing yet. Also, if you want to help me keep the lights on over here on the podcast, you can support me at patreon.com/byonds solitire. For now, though, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire, and this week in the pod, I have a very special guest. This is Ted Ka. He is the executive director of operations at Leader. Uh but today instead of talking about how he keeps the lights on for us, uh we're going to talk about his new game because he's the designer of our upcoming game, Take. Uh how you doing today, Ted?
Good. How are you, Liz?
I'm I'm doing all right. I like working and not actually being at work. Uh so for people who are curious or have been following a little bit, what exactly is Take? Yeah. So, Take is a riskmanagement and negotiation game where players will be planning and executing a series of heists to try and have the most money by the end of the game without getting caught by the police.
Sounds good. Um, what is your personal experience? No, I'm kidding. Uh, so actually though, how did you get into this topic? I mean, this is your first game. You worked on it for a long time. So, when did you start working on it and like what drove you? Yeah. So, for me, heists were kind of the biggest gap in what I could find a game for. I kind of purchase and play games theme first. Uh, and kind of, you know, take things that I'm already interested in, try and find a game that is going to emulate that. Uh, and heists were this kind of big gap, at least in the way that I thought about them or wanted them to be portrayed. You know, I had tried the Burrow Brothers series of games, which are a kind of fun co-op game, but the kind of sneaking around the building and peeking around corners wasn't the part that really excited me about the genre. It was uh kind of the planning.
It was the chalkboard scenes. It was the uh the bulletin board in GTA 5 kind of putting together the plan, thinking about the different routes and stuff. And I felt like uh board games were well suited to replicate that kind of thing. Uh, but I didn't feel like it I had any kind of thing. If I could have just bought this game, I wouldn't have made it.
You know what I mean? Like it was just out of this need of like I I want to be able to uh I want this thing to exist and I want to be able to kind of play in this world a little bit.
Yes. Excellent. So, you mentioned that Take is a negotiation game, but I think this is the perfect podcast. Talk about the fact that that's not how it started. Take began as a solo game, which is why I like it. So, um, tell me about that, you know, tell me what it looked like at the beginning and then how it expanded to multiplayer and then like how those modes have informed each other during development.
For sure. Yeah. So, it began as uh I think the original thesis of the game was that with unlimited amount of planning time, you could erase all of the risk from a job. And that was so you can imagine that the it originally set out like imagine if Splatter made a heist game. There's no luck. It was you just had to accomplish all of the exact things that needed to happen. And that was something that did kind of work for a solo game. Uh, I mean it was it was grindy in a way that wouldn't be fun and I wouldn't you know suggest that that version be published but uh it was something that uh was kind of working but also had a a flawed premise in the fact that the feeling that a heist is supposed to generate the kind of will you get away with it or not uh was already decided.
you know, you had that feeling a little bit at the very outset, but it was decided by the time that you arrived there. And that became a lot clearer when kind of moved into a multiplayer setting. So, originally, I was just doing it for myself. Uh, therefore, I didn't need to worry about, okay, what does it mean to have uh another player sitting at the table uh doing these things? So, it was kind of from the ground up just well, if this works for me, another person could theoretically do it at the same time. you will be points of interaction and and that will all play out. Um but the uh as I kind of started playing it with more people trying to show what the game was doing uh the crunchiness of those kind of uh hardcoded you need these number of things to be able to do it became immediately untable like there was there was not going to be any world in which three or four people at the same time could be doing those calculations.
Um, so then started going towards more of a, you know, introducing some of that luck, some of that risk mitigation, [clears throat] which then as it flowed back to the single player in it created so much more replay-ability and gave kind of the emotional core of a uh of a heist in a way that felt a lot better. Um, so I was I was inspired a lot by the Leaving Earth, uh, which is a, if you don't know that being naffy, uh, solo game. Uh, but it is also a multiplayer negotiation game because essentially you are all just playing the game next to each other and you have basically unlimited ability to make trades and uh, force risk off onto each other and mitigate it through, you know, one person could do research and then share that for free with with a second player.
Um, so yeah, that that's I hope that answers the question.
Yeah, for sure. So I guess the other thing I want to talk about is how long was this process of making small changes? Because when I got there, you know, somebody pulled out you pulled out take and somebody was I played like a cut an earlier ver cut of it than we've been looking at the office as like our serious we're going to do it game. But you know, people would say, "Oh yeah, Ted's been working on it for years. Oh yeah, Ted's been working on this on and off for years." Like when we talk about that, how long exactly are are we talking? Yeah. So, I've been at Leader for coming up on six years now in about a week. Um, and I've been working on this for probably about seven then. So, this so take predates my work at Leader Games.
Awesome. Uh, and then did the earliest versions of Solo. So, for people who don't know, you're going to see a version of this soon when we do um the the Kickstarter. However, we're going to talk about things that exist that may or may not continue to exist in dev. So, everybody chill.
[gasps]
But um so for solo I think it's really special because you know the negotiation multiplayer version of the game is you know there's a lot of smaller jobs but there isn't like the one big job whereas the solo mode is based on the one big job and we can swap it out among different scenarios. We've got like the bank, got the armored cars, we got the museum which is my favorite so far even though I do not support robbing museums. Where were you last week by the way Ted? Um
[gasps]
Um, so there's lots of really cool stuff going on. What was was there always a scenario like that and you wanted to do the big job or is that something that you realized you could do?
So originally and I have in my office you can see this and maybe we'll eventually share it. Um, originally all of the jobs had I would say the level of detail that you see in the bigger jobs now in the solo mode, which is uh the original like big mechanical hook of the game was there was this big clock with 12 time units around it. And the police routes on the outside of the building were coded to colors that would come up in different thirds of that clock. uh and you had to make the determination at what point on the clock you were going to start the heist. Then every activity inside the building would take time. Uh and then once you were out, you then started to get away at that time unit kind of through. So, which meant that even down to, you know, jewelry stores had, you know, alarms that would ch change the time and, uh, you know, the amount of time it took to door uh to to open a door was going to be, uh, different depending on which crew you brought, which tools you had, you know, all that stuff. Um, so the eventually a lot of that got abstracted away, but I definitely still wanted to have those kind of nitty-gritty details for some mode of the game in there. So, I think the it kind of ended up being shaved away from the rest of the game due to playability reasons. Um, and you know, in the multiplayer game, you get all of that. You don't get that detail, but you get the different detail and the nuances of the negotiation.
So, the amount of rules in terms of like what actually needs to happen on the job are kind of superfluous. Uh whereas in the solo game we have a uh you're getting a lot more uh cinnamon, [snorts] you know, it's a lot more cinematic. Um as you are going through the specific steps of life.
Yes. And obviously I really love that. Uh so wow, this is a very early cut that I could not even imagine. That's awesome. Um so this game has heavily evolved in many ways. The other one I kind of want to highlight just so people have something to get excited about is the driving system is super fun.
Um, how did that one develop? Was it was there always like a big driving sequence or is that something
too? Not at all. So, uh, one of the things that kind of came up in my, you know, I say it's research a little bit. It ended up being research, but it was just interest before that. Um, was that and people were hear me say this around the office. Nobody gets caught at the bank. It is incredibly rare for someone who's robbing an institution to have the police pull up and then them surrender inside the building. It is always either on the getaway or it is in the aftermath of the job. Um so for a long time I knew that I wanted people getting caught on the getaway. That was when that was going to happen when you were going to realize that it was done. The problem was uh kind of I'll guess I'll give you the the original getaway system was with that time wheel. You basically just had to follow a route that didn't touch a color on that color's time thing. So that was the no luck version. Once I started pulling away from that, it became you rolled essentially one dice per distance that you had to get. And then you had to arrange them so that they were counting up one through the number you were going to. And then anything that was off, like if you rolled two twos and a three and you needed a one, you would need to pay basically one heat to turn that two into a one and get that. And that was the system I was like h I was proud of. I was I thought it was clever. um ran with that for a while and then Josh uh Yearsley, the rules editor, uh came to town and we played it and in the most tactful way possible, he was just like,
"Not this." He was like, "This [clears throat] isn't working. It is like you're rolling the dice and you have to figure out all the different things there. You're losing all of the tension from the getaway." Um, and basically people kept pushing against this idea of like why am I doing all of this consideration about the heist itself and then I'm doing this like flat roll to find out whether I did it or not. Um, and that was when kind of switched the wheel because I realized that if that is where people were going to get caught, it needed more uh it needed more of a set piece to kind of uh help imagine what exactly happened on that. So that was where this kind of big wheel came in where always it has been you're rolling dice, you are trying to not point at the dice uh with your wheel and the way you turn the wheel is influencing kind of where the car is moving in the city. So uh that's kind of how that ended up there. And then it's been probably a year year and a half since then of tweaking exactly what it means to point at a dice, how you can turn the wheel. you know, for a long time it mattered how hard you were turning the wheel and how many spaces you had available and that's been cut and replaced with some other stuff. So, um, it's been a long journey and it will continue to be a long journey. I'm sure that that is the part we're working on right now and will uh probably go through a number of iterations. We're not quite at I know a number of times in studio working on other games, we've had the moment of uh scrap it, uh, everybody go make your own design for it. We'll
come back in a week and we'll see where we're at with like four new things. Um, and we haven't had to do that yet. We're still working within the like iterative loop. We haven't like scrapped and gone to a new system yet.
Interesting. So, you mentioned heat. Um, let's talk a little bit about that because it does feel very Grand Theft Auto, but I think that's in a good way. Um, what what were your inspirations to decide like how you wanted to talk about police interest and getting caught? What elements of investigation made it in? It was straight. Uh when I I tried a cut of the game, it didn't have kind of that star system, like a one through five star system for a long time. Um and when I added it, um and I for I don't remember exactly what caused me to add it. Um but there was some need for a like kind of a number there. I needed to know like exactly what the the heat was. Um and putting the stars there immediately the reaction from people who played it was so obviously correct. Um, it is such like similar to a lot of things in movies and stuff, Grand Theft Auto has just such a cultural hold on what crime and heist mean. Um, and being able to put the star system there was essentially cut out any explanation from that part of the game. People understand how much the cops want to get you is measured between one to five and if you go over five, uh, you're toast.
Um, so we, you know, we talked about research a couple times. We've kind of touched on it, but this is actually the thing that really got me worked up about the game other than the fact that it already has a robust cell mode, which is a key to my heart immediately. Um, so you know, you you know, a lot of things like, okay, well, nobody ever gets caught at the bank [clears throat]
or um, you know, like you you picked a very specific time period
for this game. um what so it's like 80sish. What inspired you to pick this period and like what kind of research have you done about it?
Yeah, so I I'd say the kind of I've like I said I've always been interested. There's a great podcast that I listen to. I think all of the episodes by now like 200 episodes each focusing on one heist a piece plus heist news which is individual. It's called heist podcast. um you can look it up and then read a number of books about all this stuff and as you kind of see more of these things you know I think movies are often so much about this kind of bespoke nature of the heist of like oh what makes this plan interesting when in reality there's a lot of just tried and trueue methods and there's a lot of just patterns emerge the same way that the police like have a certain way that they investigate these things so there's certain pieces of evidence that are going to be worse or not as bad um they're like I said just these patterns emerge. So, uh, speaking of the time period for a second, because this was a thing where when we brought it into the studio, there was certainly a number of people who felt like they wanted to do like the kind of the ' 60s7s vibe. And I kind of I explained why take is always going to say kind of late 80s, early 90s. Um, for a number of reasons.
Uh, one, it was kind of the the cash economy was still alive, but it was starting to sunset. So, uh, you look at prior to like 1985, nearly every major heist was a bank job. It was it was all cash because there was so much just paper money floating around. It was easy to easy to get away with because it's not as trackable as stealing certain other items. Um, so that didn't have the kind of diversity that I wanted to see in the different jobs in the game if we go back too early. Um and then a number of things kind of happened in that era that kind of work to diversify the things that people are stealing. So in the game there are six different goods that can uh be stolen in addition to cash and things like you know the rise of consumer electronics was happening in that era. So all of a sudden these things were getting smaller and more portable and more expensive. Uh you had uh Vince Bango's uh Sunflowers art went at a hu it was a massive auction. I forget exactly how many millions, but that was the first time that kind of a bunch of people's ears perked up to, oh, art can be this valuable. I mean, know always, you know, sales for hundreds of thousands before, but all of a sudden, millions of dollars for a single painting. That was notable. Um, and it also made people want to collect them, which raised the demand, which did all of those uh different things. Um, and then there's some stuff about like diamond and gold pricing that kind of went on in this era, and that's all well and good, but the the main thing were kind of those uh electronics, the art, and then the cash kind of sunsetting and forcing people to diversify their
targets. Um, so that was important. It also exists at a very interesting time technology-wise. Um, nowadays there's so much a lot of like heists are hacking jobs there, uh, which are just not as exciting. They're not as cinematic. um I don't understand them as well. Uh they uh but the old school I think you saw like two waves of like I'll say the golden era of heist which was that late 80s early 90s time period and then around 2008 there was a lot of them uh which you can especially in the US which you can imagine why suddenly some people were trying to figure out ways to uh supplement their income around that era. Uh but yeah, and I think the uh that early 90s just it felt obvious when you hear a lot of these big ones, it was and it did extend into the early 2000s. I'll say too, you look at some of the biggest heists, a lot of those I say it peaked in the early 2000s. Um and then it kind of windowed down as people started carrying less cash and security started to catch up.
I had no idea about any of that. That is fascinating. Um, so one of my favorite things that we've kind of done as prep for Take is that you sent us this like really great list of films and books and like things that we could read to like get into the mood
for [clears throat] Take. So for um people who are listening and might want some Rex, uh, let's start with movies. What are your favorite heist movies? Especially ones that'll get you in like a take state of mind.
Yeah, let me, if you don't mind, let me pull up the list so that I we're looking at the same thing. Uh, and I don't have to
remember exactly what landed on there. Right up and we see I mean I know the first one on the list is Rafifi. Um, and Rafifi is something that like it is not the kind of movie that you'd expect to be made today because of how long it takes during the heist. Um, Rafifi has a infamous I think it's either 20 or 30 minutes uh completely silent, not completely silent, but the only sounds are the sounds of them uh cutting through the ceiling and then drilling into the back of the safe. Um, and between that and then earlier on kind of casing the job, it is just so methodical and it shows again how genuinely like impressively focused these jobs can be, especially when you're looking at things that aren't uh, you know, stick them up jobs or robberies. Um, when someone needs to like get in through a building, this thing takes time. I mean a lot a lot of famous sites. I mean these people are spending uh you know hours if not days inside the vaults drilling out the safety deposit boxes or stuff like that.
And Rafi is one of the only movies that actually I think captures that amount of like focus and intensity uh for and it's also it's very old. It's impossible to find online. Uh it's from 1955. I only have seen it because I found uh the Criterion copy of Barnes & Noble. Uh so it's it's like it's difficult to find. It's not really in streaming as far as I'm aware. Um, and have you se Have I I don't think I've borrowed the DVD yet.
No, it's that's actually on our list of like things that we need to do as a work activity. So,
yes. Yeah. Yeah. And the nice thing about So, also I'll mention uh Rafifi and the next one I put on the list which was the killing the uh the Kubric one. Um, those are they were both falling under the haze code which stipulated that the criminals could not get away with the money at the end of the at the end of the thing
which is so you look at uh even like the original Oceans 11 like sorry spoilers for the 1960s Oceans 11 uh they also don't get away with the money um and that was required because it was like a morality statement is well we can't show crime pain uh and uh killing famously has a very frustrating end sequence where it all it all blows away on them and they don't get away even though like you are as you are rooting for them like I don't think that is that is just like a element of the genre you're rooting for the success of the crime that's where the tension comes from so it's those two early ones where it doesn't really work out is always kind of like deflating a little bit even though I think the the first parts of the movie are great um the one that gets around this uh which I was kind of a weird ad to the list was for a few dollars more which is the second of the Sergio Leone Man with No Name trilogy. Uh, and that one is it has a lot of the elements of like the heist genre, even though it is technically what they're steal. There is there is a heist in it and there is um like some cash that they are fighting over, but the real heist is like other men's lives. It's like a bounty that they get.
Uh, and because it wasn't like a crime in the same way because they were all criminals, uh, they do get away with it in the end. Like, it does work out well. So, that one has like weirdly, no one talks about as a heist movie, but it has a lot of these kind of elements that, uh, actually tie in with the genre, even if it's not in the same setting. Um, so those are kind of like the the main older ones. I know I also have Dog Day Afternoon and Bottle Rocket on there and Bottle Rocket is the one that I want to uh call specifically which is it is Wes Anderson's first movie and it is the probably the most accurate heist movie for uh what you hear just like kind of the low-level bumbling job. the way that they are trying to uh like they're trying to rob the cash register from like a bookstore and then they're trying to get uh the safe of a like refrigeration plant. And these are like things that I hear all the time in like story like people like especially in the the heist news like when you hear about just like a local interest piece of like oh a place got broken into and the things went wrong or you'll watch videos of like someone trying to you know rob a cell phone store and the doors shut down and uh they don't get out. these little kind of mistakes that are just kind of endearing in a way. Uh and that is what Bottle Rocket kind of uh represents to me. Um on there. Uh and then I have a whole suite of like kind of later movies that I think are really good. I the only one that I will like enumerate on I
think is uh Logan Lucky which is another comedy one but it is so process focused in the way that a lot of heist movies end up becoming like character pieces later on. uh which is fine and that's good like I like movies like that but uh in terms of like what is getting me in the take state of mind it is the the the process of we got to do this then we got to do this we got to do this this went wrong this went wrong how do we circumn that um so yeah that that is that's the one that I like if I'm really feeling if I need to like kickstart the creative juices that's the one that I'll go back and watch because it's so entertaining and it's so uh yeah just so much All right. So, not all these great recommendations, but hearing you talk about them
leads me to more questions, which is of course the true game of the game game for me always. So, um the first thing I want to just talk about because we did talk about it kind of in like early hints about this game. There are no guns in Tate and there are no like directly represented police. They're investigations,
but there aren't actually like cops on the map really other than like the ones that just kind of
show heat coming on you as you drive.
What drove those particular decisions um going into this game?
So, the no guns thing was uh really a directly result of the research which basically was uh if you actually pull the trigger on a job, you will get caught. It just raises the stakes to such a level that I don't think you can find a major heist where somebody was killed that didn't end up getting caught. All of the ones that like got away with it fully uh were nonviolent heists. So the idea of like representing it just be it became a historical uh to rep the idea that if someone had a gun and was able to use it and then still get away with it just didn't ring true uh in a way. So that was like an easy cut in addition to it being palatable for like and I don't like I don't the Louve you know as you referenced earlier the Louve job that just happened last week or a few days ago whatever it was um was so compelling I think to so many people because it was nonviolent nobody got hurt [clears throat] and that's what like is exciting uh and that's what like gains that's what allows you to not lose respect even if even if you're mad about like the crown jewels being stolen and all of that stuff at least nobody got hurt. And I think that there's actually a lot to be said about that. Um, so I I luckily have the historical part to like fall back on, but I also have the benefit of it like, okay, I don't know how many people actually want to be kind of utilizing weaponry in their in their idealized. Um, and then the cops thing was was a point of view choice. It was we're telling the story from uh the
point of view of the criminals. You just simply don't know what the police are doing at any given time. You don't know how they're investigating. We see that in movies when it cuts away, but you don't in real life, all you have is the paranoia of sitting at your apartment waiting to see if the cops show up outside of it. Um, so I I didn't want to I didn't want to represent too deeply what was kind of going on on the police's side of things. And certainly I never wanted to have somebody playing uh on the police side of things. Um I the goal of the game, you know, eventually became sitting down with your friends to plan an ice together. Um having one of your friends trying to stop you from getting away with it wasn't just wasn't as fun. And if I could represent it with the game system itself, why uh cast a player in that role.
Makes sense. The other things come up as we were talking about these these movies and I find this very charming. We talk about excitement
about like respect for the people doing the heist. You describe some of the small mistakes as like charming and like we're talking about like the fun of heists, you know? I mean, they are crimes. What is it do you think about heist that makes us find them so compelling in a sense where it's like we kind of hope somebody gets away with it?
Yeah, I think it is because the uh the object of desire is so obvious and relatable. Um, you know, you don't relate to a murder because you don't want to kill someone. You know what I mean? Like, and but you do want money. So like I think everyone like understands why somebody would want to steal money from a bank. So you get someone who's like understandable motivation and then I think there is something about just the amount of effort that goes into these jobs. Again like nobody nobody respects the person who just walks into a bank and starts waving a gun around and scares a bunch of people and stuff. It's when the bank staff arrives on Tuesday morning after a long holiday weekend and finds the balsam broken into. And that's that's all that's left. That's the part that's like ah cool. Uh at least to me and I think to other people because I I see the way other people talk about it. Um and yeah, so I think it's just a combination of motivation and kind of the effort that goes into it. Um, and I think like heist and crime besides having like a a media presence, they also have a uh I mean there's cultural backbone too.
A lot of these things uh we talked about John Dillinger before uh famously will tear up mortgage records when he would rob banks so that the bank couldn't tell who owed what money and that like kind of turned him into this kind of like folk hero. And it was especially it was at the time too when people weren't that fond of banks. I don't think people are that fond of banks or a lot of places that are, you know, holding on to a lot of wealth right now too. Um, so there's a little bit of like Robin Hood uh aspect to it. I think that uh people get again a lot of that goes out the window if anyone gets hurt. Um, which is why I mean but you look at like I said the really big jobs often nobody does get hurt because they know that's not a path to success. Um, yeah. I mean, if you if you feel uh if your gut turns at the idea of a heist, please let me know and we'll we'll try and throw it out.
Yeah. I mean,
it's more of like a it makes you feel naughty in a fun way
and like it's it's evocative from other crimes.
Yeah. Sec Diamond. It's a big shiny rock. Of course, people want to steal it. Of course, you have to put security around it. Nobody is like mad about that. I don't no museum's like, "Oh, I wish we didn't have to secure these." Like, no, they get it. Um, so I think it just it's just so like innate to our understanding and it's like exciting like people uh people like getting away with things in their day-to-day life too. So they I think it's just a accentuated version of that a little bit.
Um, and so just to just to fill it out because we got a lot of readers listen this podcast too. Um, if you're going to go read about heist, uh, what are what are the best reads?
Yeah. So, uh, on the fiction side, the one that I would recommend is, uh, Prince of Thieves by Chuck Hogan, which later got republished as The Town because that was the movie that was made off of it. And that one, I think, was I mean, it's like a really well-written thriller book. Uh, it is got entire chapters devoted to kind of the casing of the jobs. Uh, it's got, you know, different parts. It's got multiple different heists, which is always like important to me for uh like I said, the take is about doing multiple heists. It's not about just a single story. It's that repetition that kind of gives you the feeling of being a career criminal. And The Town or Prince of Thieves is kind of doing exactly that. Uh and then on the non-fiction side, I want to highlight the big con uh which was a uh anthropologist's study of the language that conmen in the 1910s and 1920s kind of used and the methodology they used to kind of uh get uh people to uh trust them and eventually give up the equivalent today of I mean hundreds of thousands of dollars people were losing to these cons. Um, and it it almost reads it reads like a fantasy. Like I can't believe this ever happened, but like in this time like post, they can like uh you can like wire money that existed at the time, but like you couldn't call on a cell phone to like uh verify things. So the uh it's just it's it's really intense the kind of planning
that went into their jobs. It also I say does two things that were relevant. One, it shows that these were like repeatable methods. It wasn't again these bespoke ideas of like, oh, what if we did this this time? It was like, nope, this is the job. This is how we do it. It works uh so often. Um and then, uh it als it also got turned into a movie um with Robert Redford. What was the name? Do you know uh the one?
The Sting. Uh The Sting. What? The Sting was based off of The Bacon. Um, but yeah, no, it it's a it's it's a fascinating fascinating read and it like it although it is not like stealing from an institution, it does have the same amount of planning and like the amount of lying. I mean, you'll see a lot of times in real big heists. It is the human element that is what is being circumnavigated, not the uh not the physical security often. And the big con is like all about the human element.
That's super interesting. We could talk about this forever actually, but I want to pivot because we work together and we have these conversations together. You know, when we talk about leader games, especially as we kind of are moving into like an era where we have a new in-house designer. Congratulations. Um, you know, we spend a lot of time talking about like what makes a game a leader game.
Yeah.
So, how what is it about take that makes it special for us? I'm asking you to talk yourself up because you're too humble, Ted.
Yeah. No, I mean, I think the so take uh from what I would consider originally like not necessarily a Leader Games game, um was molded that way, not because I was so intent on like I can only publish it through Leader. Uh but because the kind of methods we use to determine whether a game is working or not is kind of the only way that I now know how to judge games. uh like the vast majority of my plays are prototypes under review at various stages. Um so the uh I I think the things that take specifically hits on are um the level of player interaction um which you know obviously we're talking about the multiplayer game here for a second because that's certainly that's the part that was pitched and kind of went through the green light system and then the solo mode on the side was kind of you know my personal desire, your desire. Uh that's that's all good and we're like super excited to have the fans uh see that part. But in terms of like right now what makes the leader game, it was that level of player interaction. I think it was the uh there is a certain um kind of I think mechanical not subversion but there's unique there are some things in the game that kind of work odd. You know it is not using necessarily you know it's not like a deck building game. It's not a tile laying game. There's there's a lot of the game is kind of floating in this like weird like above the table space um
in a way that like if you couldn't talk during take it wouldn't work. Um which again pays off in the player interacted site but also plays off in like actually how do these like actions work uh are a little uh different.
Um and then I you know the emergent narrative is something we are constantly talking about. it needed to uh be able to tell a story. And a lot of times as we talk about games that are here um is about how do you talk about the game when you're not at the table? And this is like one of the things I've talked about with Matt, our uh community manager and who hosts the ROM podcast. Um is that you can kind of send games through the podcast test, which is like how many episodes could be devoted to talking about this game? Um, and that's not a perfect test. Like Oath famously like is not exactly like a good podcast material. Um, it is like this big sprawling interesting game, but like it's kind of hard to talk about in a elongated way without just talking about your own plays of it.
Um, you can't really talk about these kind of strategic comparatives. Um, but like the way that you're able to like tell the stories and I think the um when Josh and Kyle were on the stream last week and they were talking about uh kind of their play of take that we had done that morning um seeing the the number of details they remembered from the job uh hours later uh was so like um I think it just proved the point that like what the the game is providing is these ability to create not just moments but these kind of strings of moments that become a narrative of exactly what the intent was, how it went wrong, what the ending was. Um, yeah, I think there was one more thing that I think is relevant. Um, I'm trying to remember what it was.
I don't know if I lost the thread. Um,
it's all good now. I just edit it like that never happened. Uh, you know, the other thing I think is really interesting is, you know, I I I absolutely will play and enjoy multiplayer Take. Um, but you know, I'm a soloist in part because I don't necessarily love
having to put myself out there and like horn in on a [clears throat] deal.
Um, so
Take is a very free form game, at least right now, where you have to like decide to insert yourself into a situation.
So,
I guess what comments do you have about that in general as a design philosophy? And then what things are built into the game for people to look for to like help them latch in if they are looking for something to say or contribute.
For sure. So I think the um yeah two sides of that one that was the fact that people have to kind of force themselves and advocate for themselves as well. I always say is I think arguably a weakness of the design. It is like it is a requirement that uh buys a lot of good stuff for it. But um unlike there's a lot of negotiation games, Chinatown is the one that I will like point to where if I have a I have a need for, you know, a laundromat tile and I can look over at somebody and say like you you have a laundromat tile, let's talk. Um and take doesn't have that as much. There are some places where like certain crew uh are needed and you can see that's there.
But because the jobs are so complicated and there is so many different ways you can structure both the loot allocation but also the way you go about kind of mitigating the risk, it is it becomes incumbent upon the players to explain why they would be good because the information overload for the person like in the leader planning position is so high that they just won't be able to loop in everybody. So uh that is something that you know mechanically I think is probably best addressed by the player powers. And this is like one of the next things we're going to do is do a sweep of those because what you want for a player to sit down and be able to identify a type of job uh or obstacle that they are uniquely suited to overcoming. And that will at least signal to them, hey, maybe you should speak up if you know if something is getting stolen and there are diamonds involved, hey, you should maybe speak up and try and find your way uh to get in on this. Um, but yeah, I think it's like I said, it's it's a cost that is getting paid and certainly some people who are uh really uncomfortable advocating for themselves uh might have a hard time unless they have someone kind of looking out for them. Um, but like I said, what you earn for it, I think, is is immensely interesting. Uh, with the amount of information that players will be able to collectively hold in their heads, even if not, you know, one person wouldn't be able to.
Yeah, it also does make every game deeply different. I will say that having played the solo a lot does help me understand the board state a lot better.
For sure. Yeah. No, the the the solo is like the crash course in the mid because in solo you don't have the jobs don't get easier
in solo. There's not like there's not a set of solo jobs that are like, oh, here's the little baby, but you only need to take care of one lock. know it's it's all the same thing that you would collectively do, but you're just given so many more actions uh to like protect yourself from it that you can kind of and you kind of start to learn these actions are more important. These are where I have leverage in the multiplayer game that I can say like no, I will do this and now you need me because this is the thing that's actually going to make the difference between us getting away with it or not getting away with it.
Yeah. Um, so, uh, just kind of like a loose chat at the end. Uh, for actually first I do want to ask, um, this is so interesting to me. So, our I love where we work because yes, like half the building is like the creative side and the other half is ops, but we also are like people really play all the games. We all kind of get a say. Uh, so how does it feel for you as somebody who's mostly ops, although you play a lot and have a lot of input into our games moving over to our side of the of the building?
Oh, so I I've said this before. I would never want to do your job. I would never want to be a full-time developer. Uh the I think part of that is uh I wouldn't necessarily want to work on uh a game that anyone put in front of me, you know, and that's like that's like a selfish desire of like, you know, not wanting to turn your hobby into work. Right now it can still exist as in kind of a weird hobby space even though now I have like a responsibility to do certain stuff with this one. Um, but development is hard work and it gives me a headache uh at the end of the day and uh it's I I just I wouldn't want to do that day in and day out. Um I love the business side of things. I'm interested in it. It animates me uh to kind of do operation size projects in a way that like games are fun but they'll never truly fully animate me uh in that same way. Uh so I don't think that uh yeah like I'm I'm happy to involve myself as much as possible but like Nick is the lead developer on take uh so he is like organizing the play test. He's been doing the things in the evening. He kind of gets final call and making changes for stuff and I'm I am more than happy to see that power. Uh like I said I sat in like a year and a half ago. Um Josh came to visit and they were doing a card review of Oath uh of all the new Oath cards and I just sat in on that. I didn't even talk. I just listened and I was wiped by the end of the day. I mean because it was two to three hours of
just
talking about different card powers and what's balanced and is that featic enough and stuff and it is ex it is exhausting work. Um and yeah, I would I would not want to sign up to do that. Oh, that's
How has it felt to see I guess we we started to have some outside play tests. So, how has it felt to see responses to your game from people outside of our office?
Uh, it's good. You know, I haven't seen any in person. Uh, since I mean I've I've played games outside the office back older versions like kind of before it get brought in. Um, but I haven't seen any like in person reactions to the new stuff. Nick has reported to me and generally said good things. Um but yeah, it will probably be a few more weeks before I see kind of what that looks like. Uh so I don't know how it will feel. Um it's certainly been great to hear that things are going well that people seem to be. You know, there was I guess my biggest concern was that people would feel I mean there's a lot of luck in the game. Like there's I think there's no way of uh navigating around that. There's just like maybe luck is there's a lot of die rolling. Um and that can hit certain people a certain way. Um, so I guess the the fear of going into that was always uh would people feel like they were getting the narrative momentum out of all of the die rolling or would they just feel like it was a crapshoot and um you know whatever was happening. And thus far uh I think those fears were unfounded. People seem to be understanding what the game is doing. um how it seems to me navigating people caring about victory but not so much that they get salty about it uh at the end that usually by the time the end rolls around they're like they want to see the ending but they're not like mad at the game for taking it away from them um because that was just part of their story. Um and I think that's a that's an important needle to thread and it seems like thus far it's been doing that.
Excellent. And then you know it might be too early to say although once I started designing games it's like I haven't been able to stop. Do you feel like you've got another game in you?
I think I think there will be other things I'll work on. I don't The ideas that I kind of mle over once in a while aren't necessarily like leader games fits. Um, but I don't see any reason why I would stop kind of poking around and stuff. I think anyone who plays games seriously probably has at least one or two ideas kind of like kicking around in their head. Um, and board gaming, you know, at least the gold mage is very young. there's a lot of themes that aren't been explored. There's certainly mechanics that can still be uncovered. Um, so yeah, I think uh I'll continue to poke at things, but like I said with the development answer, you know, certainly I'm not looking at becoming a one title a year game designer. Um, which if you know anyone new, all the respect to you, that's it seems like fun. I couldn't do it. Uh so I think the you know if in a couple years I have another project that I'm like uh feeling like needs to exist then maybe something that I will pursue.
Um but you know uh until then I'll just kind of like follow the interest as it as it arrives.
Fantastic. Okay. So I usually ask softy questions like towards the end of these interviews. U but I'm going to target yours a little bit because like you're the only other person in the office who likes solo gaming. True. It's a lonely time, man. I guess it's my destiny. Um, but uh what are some solo games that you have been enjoying?
Uh, been enjoying. So, I think recently uh I was just playing a handful of games of Magic Realm, which I don't know if you've been in the room and we've talked about the 1979 Avalon Hill uh adventure game.
No.
Uh, it is it is incredible. It is nearly unplayful uh because of the the production and the rules. So like I learning to play the game I had to basically rewrite the rules in my own word doc that I now use as the reference uh for playing the game. But it is uh it was a fantasy adventure game that was made prior to Dn D being published. So, it has like all of these different it is trying to emulate fantasy literature, not trying to do D and D like every other fantasy adventure game has done since then. Um, so that's been a blast and it's it's another one of those that plays almost identical to uh there's obviously like you can fight other players and you can go on adventures with them if they're there, but it is fully works one player. Okay.
Um, and then let's see here. I've been wanting to get Spirit Island back to the table. Uh, and I have yet to pull the trigger on, uh, actually getting it out and setting it up. Um, I don't know what's been holding me back there. You Spear Island used to be my favorite game, uh, of all time. Uh, and I think I got buried in content, I think, at some point. I think Jagged Earth like uh, which I played a bunch when it came out. Uh, I think it kind of like narrowed my uh narrowed my like ability to get it out and like explore all the stuff um because of just the mountain that was in there. Um, and then of course seasonally Final Girl uh I I am a big fan of Final Girl and I'm just should be on Monday getting the newest set in uh the kind of like Halloween uh pumpkin head inspired set. So really looking forward to that.
That's a game where like again it is so narrative first. feel like if you die quickly or you die unfairly at the end, it is all just kind of part of the um part of the the story that gets generated out of it. And I I'll play that with my wife a lot. Kind of like we'll take turns making decisions or we'll just kind of, you know, I'll roll the dice and she'll make the decisions and then it's no it's one person's fault when something goes bad. Um but yeah, no, I I've been over the last like four weeks about about what I've been doing.
Nice. I actually have to agree about Final Girl being great like alone together. I think Tate has a lot of potential in that direction as well. Like you can't put that on the box,
but although Final Girl has Van Rider did put one plus on Final Girl boxes going forward.
Okay, so on take we'll put one plus three to five.
Yeah, I know. I Yeah, the two player gam I I just want to mention on that real quick because it it is it has come up already and it will continue to come up the oddity of of one, three to five. Um, two-player. I tried I tried a cooperative two-player variant and it sucks all the tension out of the game. It is unbelievable how the tension is gone from the game because you ask, "Hey, can you, you know, handle these locks for me?" And the person goes, "Yeah." They never push back. Uh, so like two-player cooperative like nearly doesn't work unless you were to specifically divide the responsibilities at which point, you know, I've seen the Nemo War reviews. people are like, "This is just one player divided in things."
Um, and then I tried a two-player like Mantis Falls style. You don't know if you're working together or not. Um, but again, as soon as you as soon as you were, the tension was even though you didn't know, the tension was still sucked out of the game because uh you're doing that. There's And then two-player competitive is just like has the zero sum problem. It's just it's just odd. Um, so yeah, if we did one plus, comma 3 to five is probably too weird to put on the box. Uh, so that will just have to like live uh live on the BTG threads. Um, but yeah, I think uh two player just has so many weird aspects about it. Um, but it as alone together, I think it is absolutely a good candidate for that.
Yeah, I think that's that's very fair. Uh, and then my final question that I always ask, although for I really don't know the answer to this. Um, I often ask people, oh, if somebody wants to follow your work, where do you like to be found? Are you on social media at all?
No, I don't like to be found. Don't look for me. No, I like uh people can uh I'll like I'll eventually start poking my head in the Discord for the tech channels uh talking there. I have a BG account, so I can respond there once those get started up. Uh my email tadlegames.com is like open. I'm happy to uh receive questions directly there or through support. they can just pass it on to me. But no, I don't do the social media thing because um I don't want to
honestly that's probably better for your soul.
That's what I'm hoping.
I I however everyone out there am terminally online if you haven't figured that out and that can be found anywhere. It's beyond solitire. Um Ted, thank you so much for coming on. This is a blast. I've really enjoyed getting to like talk to you this way.
Yeah, thank you for having me.
All right, everybody. Um, this is uh Take is coming to Kickstarter and I think we're hoping for January.
Yep.
I We don't have an exact date, but expect January.
Um, and y'all should be watching some movies and and reading some books to get yourselves excited for it because I'm really happy with the robust solo mode. And if you like to argue with your friends about who's going to drive, uh, this is the game for you. All right. Thanks, Ted. And then everybody out there, please uh like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.