Legacy of Yu: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over the legacy of you one of the newest games by Shem Phillips I believe he designed this yep Shem Phillips and this is the solo only game uh where it's so lonely campaign Legacy quote unquote uh completely resettable campaign um I have finished the campaign so uh like basically it just depends on uh how well you do it's going to be a minimum of seven games because if you completely lose out or you completely win out uh that will be at least seven games but then you might win some you might lose some and go back and forth who who man okay all right this is a very weird review because I binged this campaign like I played it uh I did like one practice game um just to you know figure out how things work I like did the very first one then kind of reset it real quick and then start it over uh and then basically played seven games in a row uh it is I can tell that this is a good game but this is a game I will I would never want
to play again uh and I think probably binging it is what did it in for me because after a few games it became extremely tedious and frustrating although the bones of a game like the bones and and the the you know the way it works and the mechanics and all that are very solid it's probably meant to be played every now and then just because it would be less frustrating that way so I'm not going to say that there's like a meta to this game I think there are a few things and a few different strategies you can do but for me what almost guaranteed a Victor every single Victory I had I was kind of in uh based off the same strategy and what I did was uh there are buildings you can build the purple buildings that basically turn all workers as equal they become interchangeable and this is almost key uh to do so the cards that I would get and that I would slot underneath because whenever you build like The Villages or the huts that allows you to slot more I would almost always go for the ones that gave me uh the white workers the laborers and then I would go for the uh the purple buildings because those turned whites into whatever I needed at the time whites could be used as yellows yellows
could be used as whites and then I would just slowly start getting those to where by the end of a game I would have all four of those purple buildings out so that turned every meeple that I had into whatever I wanted it to be so it just kind of became oh all right and then at that point you're also generating a bunch of the uh conch I think that's what the wild knock on calorie the cowry shells which are kind of a resource you can use to trade so you trade those to get Provisions you need Provisions to go out and fight barbarians uh because barbarians ramp up extremely quickly but if they're not a problem if you can use every worker um like as whatever you need it to be so be and you also get a bunch of those calorie shells because whenever you do the Harvest step you gain uh you gain at least one calorie and then an extra one for each of those purple buildings you have so during each Harvest by I don't know like the latter half of the game you're gaining five of those as well as just whatever else you might be getting from your cards uh so it became kind of like okay yeah that's what I'm doing in every single Victory I had was basically determined by that uh and and that would be fine that would feel really good if I did that like one game
and then you know played another game a week later and maybe did it again and and pulled it through but all that is to say is this game is not easy in any way this game is so difficult but at the same time I don't really feel like it's difficult through it it feels random everything just kind of feels a little bit random because uh you have a deck you start the game with a deck of 10 cards uh and then during the Harvest step you draw four of those and your your cards have um they're multi-use which I think is really good I like it uh they have like a a brown like section and uh and then the red section and then like some uh white section that only comes in uh there might be some slight spoilers I'll try not to spoil anything uh but the white section comes in later and then we have a bottom section for uh for you to get like a permanent Harvest ability I the the brown section is if you choose to discard your card that's what you get out of the brown if you choose to completely get rid of it you get the brown and the red uh but you're choosing to get rid of it and uh so you're and then it's not even like you have the same deck from game to game what you do is you shuffle all the town's fault cards you Shuffle those and then you draw a 10. or you don't really
you draw a ten you you do draw a 10 but you make them that 10 your starting deck and I find that completely RNG like it how well your game is gonna be I feel like is a highly deterministic based off of the 10 cards you start with like there was a time in one of the games and again I'm not gonna spoil anything where a certain section was was supposed to be more difficult but due to my starting hand I was able to actually get rid of it completely and I was like well I don't feel like I really earned that it just happened to be that my opening hand was just really good and okay I guess I'll just I'll deal with that situation but then games that were extremely difficult were oh I really need meeples oh look at that not getting any meeple cards all they're all provisions cool because the way that I hate I hate how The Barbarians work so you have a deck of Barbarians and uh whenever you like you start the game with one barbarian out and at over the course of the game you have a icon that tells you how many barbarians are getting added to the row not how many need to be in the row how many are getting added so if you don't deal with like one barbarian you're adding in another one instead of being like Oh I didn't deal with that one he's
still there so then it becomes two barbarians and and if you can't deal with that one through sheer randomness then it just it's gonna sand or a snowball into a disastrous effect because some of these are just like I'm gonna try and look at the starting ones like some of these are just you need two red and a blue and if you can't deal with them you can bribe them so it's either you have to destroy a card from the top of your deck and that's one way you can lose is if you cannot destroy a card that's what that that's one way you lose or you turn into calorie shells now sometimes some of the strategies you look at the barbarians and you're like well I don't have three Provisions or I don't have two Provisions so but I can get resources that let me bribe and so that's kind of what you do uh sometimes is if you just can't get the meeples to do that but that becomes extremely annoying when it turned when one barbarian turns into two and then two turns into four and then you're just like then you have less townsfolk to uh to you know higher to pull into your deck and you're almost as guaranteed to lose there's a lot of this game that feels like like it's almost wanting you to lose I'm not saying that you can't win out uh I'm just saying that if everything I've seen especially has uh your first game
your first game is going to be extreme like I remember looking up literally a post say asking people asking how are you winning your first game um in some almost everyone was saying they either lost it or they barely won uh and I mean yeah that's gonna kind of figure out how this game works but I feel like almost every game worked the same way but man those barbarians just get extremely extremely rough eventually you kind of learn because the the uh what's it called the ditch it's not a ditch you're you're going You're trying to build a um uh uh canal you're trying to build out the canal uh eventually you learn that okay the second fourth and sixth spot are going to make you draw an additional Barbarian so you kind of get your engine set up to be able to deal with that and I mean again that's kind of why you kind of figure out the puzzle of the game uh so by your you know third fourth fifth game you're like yeah okay I know exactly what those what those benefits are uh that's what I'm gonna go for I know what benefits the Hutts give me the underneath so that's what I'm gonna go for and you kind of just do the same thing over and over and over um and and then you're then you're done
uh so like I said this game this game is good like it has some elements of like Hadrian's Wall if you haven't played that I highly recommend it but Hadrian's Wall was kind of like you are utilizing so many you're turning this meeple into this meeple which it gets you those and you're using those together get these resources and you do that here uh and it could just be again that I binged this game to play out the campaign uh it just it just got pretty tiresome pretty quickly and some of those barbarians like because if you when you win um you get obviously a story and I haven't talked about the story yet but I will get to that uh basically when you win you get nothing for it you get it it just adds it just makes the game harder so it kind of is like hey you know I want you I want you to lose like you you should lose like we're basically gonna add in you know mechanics that guarantee you to lose and I just I find that kind of cheap it's like well that wasn't really creative I didn't feel that it was creative I felt like you just made a soul Barbarian cards that are just kind of like super annoying to deal with and a slight spoiler here um it's early on but some like one of the first things that gets added if if you win are like barbarians that are decked out in
armor and they do give some story elements and theme of why things are happening so that does help uh but a lot of The Barbarians if not almost all of them require three meeples to deal with uh various colors uh these meeples require four and four meeples is a lot and because everything's just shuffled into the Barbarian deck there's no way of controlling what comes out so I had a game where the very first card that came out was a four meeple Barbarian and the one I'm looking at specifically requires two red and two blue well you can't really do a whole lot like that uh with that and in the very beginning so he requires you to either discard the top card of not discard exhaust the top card of your ready deck you know your draw pile or get rid of a yellow meeple and if you have no way of generating yellow Maples then your deck is getting thinned out and again that's one way you can lose uh and if you're not drawing any cards that give you two red and two blue uh while you also need three Provisions to go out and fight them you it that's basically you kind of see that and you're like nope it's a wash and then you kind of just redo it and I don't find that I don't find that fun uh I've had some games like that Shadowrun Crossfire did
like that where you could set up the entire game and look and be like we lost and you kind of have to hear it helps of course that it's solo so you are playing by yourself and you can be like um that wasn't the card that was drawn first but um do you really want to do that like do you really want to set it up and just be like I mean you could if that was the only thing that kind of messed it up you could just be like ah oh whatever and then just put it away and Shuffle it into the deck and then draw one that is I mean yeah that's another one that's like well gonna lose there because some of these barbarians get get insane and I The Barbarians are part of the theme and I'm not upset at there's a variety of Barbarians it's just that it's completely random on what's coming out the one I happen to just look at would be basically um it'd be almost Game ending if if that came out super early before you even have a chance to draw any cards that could be good because theoretically you could put a barbarian out or even have a few barbarians come out it could be two fours and you're only drawing your opening hand was Provisions because this game doesn't reward you a lot like it does reward you and it was nice when it happened but most the time it was just beating you down over and over and over a lot of the story cards like story cards come from the huts and then the canal cards uh it just felt demoralizing to
get them like it would be like I guess some slight story spoilers but there'd be one where it's like oh yeah finally who trudged through that got that Canal section built awesome I feel really good and now let me read my story oh it added a barbarian to the row cool did I get any cool Powers did I get and nope nope that was my reward was being punished with potentially losing uh because there's no like half wins like you either win or you lose so when you're trying to progress the game and finally eke out a win and you have to read a story section you're almost not excited to read the story you're like you're like oh God what's it gonna be oh reading that reading that and great all right well I lost and then you have to start it all over now the lose cards uh like there's there's two like I said there's there's three ways you can lose if you ever every time you have to reshuffle your ready pile uh you have to move the flood token over if it ever lands on the spot that your barge is at you lose the flood has like caught up to you that's one way you can lose like I said if you cannot destroy a card uh that's their nf7 barbarians ever uh are out at the top that's how you lose uh but whenever you draw you draw the um the defeat card and then whichever
way you lost it's either by flood or it's by uh barbarians or your deck you read a story section and then it gives like that's how you get benefits I don't know I just kind of find that uh a little flame like it is nice that it's like hey uh you lost here's rewards it doesn't you know kick you while you're down but it almost feels like it wants you to win lose win lose like alternate between the two um or if you are gonna win multiple games in a row it has to be by pure Randomness versus anything that you did uh strategically uh yeah the barbarian's coming out I I absolutely hated it it became very very annoying and another thing that I because I was kind of looking up some strategies whenever I was uh whenever I got my ass handed to me my first couple games uh basically you want to make your deck as fat as possible like you started out with 10 cards the luckily the the far left card is always free and it it is easy to get Provisions but you need Provisions to go get more cards uh you also need Provisions to deal with barbarians you do have a kind of a lot to manage it's not a difficult game in terms of understanding it is relatively straightforward which is good uh but there's like any time that you're able to draw more cards or put more cards into your deck
you should just because it what I was doing which I mean I wouldn't say is necessarily fun but is if your deck gets really fat and you're able to deal with barbarians like I like a lot of my games were just like oh yeah I have all these I have all these meeples uh they're all interchangeable so essentially there's just a pool of whatever I want them to be uh if you're able to do that and I was generating a bunch of calorie then uh your hand of four cards like if you have a deck like a deck of 15 cards uh you can just like they become nothing like I could turn in this card for a black and be like you know what I'll exhaust that that's more you know it's more token or that's more meeples that's that's you know two black and then oh this one's a white and yellow yep white and yellow just add that oh this one's three uh Provisions yeah I'll grab the three provisions and this one's a a white and another provision so now I have this pool of stuff and I have all the provisions that's allowed to me as well as all the calorie and yep I'm gonna build out that uh the last section of the canal now you don't automatically win when you do that you have to survive the round but because there's only four it only over adds four um there needs to be seven barbarians up at the top that's how you lose so a lot of my games that I won were based off of
I'm like okay there's four barbarians out I can deal with two of them so that means two will stay four will get added that's six and I win like now you've got to be careful about doing that you don't want to thin yourself out too much because some of the penalties if you don't have their bribe cost or uh you know the inability to bribe then you you might be like oh I still I can't draw or whatever um even though you actually wouldn't have to draw because the Harvest is at the beginning of the next round so you just basically have to survive uh their attack and then and then you win uh so I get I mean again there are different kind of strategies but if you play this game multiple times in a row you kind of go through the motions and find out what works for you and there were times where I did have to alternate like some strategy or or what I had to do but not not much like it's still I think it was one game I did my all white and then make them make all the maples Universal and then like I tried doing something different the next game and that was not working so then I just reverted back to what was working and that continued to work so that's kind of and like I said the mechanics here are good I feel like they're good for like one game a week or something so now let's go to the story
and it's really interesting that this game came out because another game came out that was I guess it wasn't a uh it wasn't a standalone game but an expansion came out called uh Wrath of the lighthouse uh for empires of the north that's also a solo only story driven game um I'm gonna go ahead and say this is how you do it this is how this is how you do a solo only story driven campaign because uh Wrath of the lighthouse I think is not done that well this is very clean um so you don't even read through this at the beginning there's no like story setup although I kind of wish there was like that'd be nice if there was a little story setup but you're jumping into the storybook very quickly almost every card that you start with has a story section to it and then you you just need to read the um introduction to kind of understand why you're doing what you're doing uh the story sections there I mean there's there's a lot here they even say at the back of the rulebook by the end of a campaign you're gonna see 40 to 60 percent of it so you're you're gonna you're gonna see almost everything uh in one playthrough but so I think there's about two campaigns worth in here and I think that's also why they made it the way they did because when you win lose win lose back and forth you aren't seeing as much um you see you definitely see a lot more if you win a lot of games in a row where you do almost everything like there's
some extra stuff that comes in obviously through a campaign game that you some of it you don't have to do others you do but the writing uh now here's what I did also because I wasn't recording this I it just went on like Spotify and just looked up traditional Chinese music and I listened to that and that helped a lot uh the writing here it's not bad and I wouldn't even really say it's amateurish I'd say the writing's pretty good like uh you follow forgive me if I um you follow well it's a legacy of you um I do not know his last name though uh you that's his name why you uh you follow it's from his perspective and the trials and tribulations that he goes through while doing this massive what they call the great work for the emperor while also defending themselves from barbarians and as you're doing certain actions and you know winning and losing you do um I mean you you go through his perspective of that uh it's not like gory or anything uh there are some serious moments and I'd say the writing was probably Amplified from the music that I was listening to but it's definitely it's not bad and I
think it handled adding extra stuff very well like uh and then the way certain things will happen now there's only a certain number of Victory cards uh and the Only Rule about that is there's a gold victory card and that's always on the bottom so the rest of the victory cards have just shuffled and put on top so certain things might happen at different points in time which could give you a little bit of a different style of campaign but if you uh if you go through it you will see it also it'll be kind of a when is this gonna happen versus if it happens uh uh but yeah the story I I I mean like I said I didn't always want to I want to go into it for the Reading part and like the story portion but I hated what was usually coming after that because it was very rarely good and but like I said whenever you're reading the story stuff and it is good you're like oh yay yeah that's nice but I I'd say as an overall like story driven you know campaign thing it's it's pretty good I was surprised because obviously Garfield games and Shen Phillips don't do stories in their game so this was surprisingly well done uh the storybook was written by Benedict hewittson um so he did a pretty good job and I will also say I love this artwork I
really really like it as if you've watched my channel for a long time you know I'm not a huge fan of the Mikko that's obviously art subjective I do not like the mikko's artwork I don't like his people sorry I love his scenery like I love the way he does Landscapes and stuff like that I think that's really good but his people just are the most grotesque things I've ever seen drawn uh but I guess Sam Phillips which I would have to guess is his brother I really enjoy the style that they did for this game uh yeah and it's completely resellable so like whenever you're done you can it's very very easy to reset uh because there's just a deck of story cards and they're numbered one through 69 so you just look for those put those up and then everything else is just really organized in this box so it's compact it plays like I said very clean it's just I had main issues with it playing it multiple times in a row I to where I kind of felt like I figured it out and then I just went with that and then anything else that kind of happened it was just more annoying like it wasn't and whenever I was getting new stuff added or new cards were coming out I wasn't like hmm how am I going to deal with this puzzle it was more just Oh yay because here's the thing there are sometimes whenever you get really good
cards in your deck and you clean up a canal uh and a lot of the canal cards like some of the beginning ones will just be like oh yeah you use you know you have to spend these workers and these calorie shells and then you get a wood and you have to destroy two of your cards it's like what I thought I thought that was supposed to be a good thing I thought that's what my entire job here was to do yeah yeah it is it is you're punished for it though like you you've cleaned it out and because of the damage comes from the top of your deck you're kind of like well all right here are the next two cards and those are my best two best cards okay like you can get stuff that a lot that gives you multiple resources and you need brick or wood to build buildings so if like the top of your deck is you know something that or you really need Provisions or or you need wood and you you the top two cards that are discarded are your only wood generators well sorry they're gone I mean theoretically they're not gone like if you run out of cards starting to shuffle a discard pile and put them back but it's you're you're probably not gonna make it that far and that's the thing that's what really irks me about this game is it it's random in that sense and so you're random from your deck your random from the cards that are available your
random from The Barbarians coming out uh you're random from the cards that are being you know damaged and so you lose a lot of the games do the randomness or you win some of the games through the randomness I I don't know I I don't know it's uh am I glad I finished it probably more in the sense that I'm glad I'm done versus like that I'm like yeah you know I saw it through I I don't know maybe maybe just don't binge don't binge games because yeah I don't know but but isn't that also a detriment if you're like incentivized to not keep playing because you're it might just like not be that good if you played multiple games on the road normally you want to play multiple games like games like a game in a row and like it's not bad like like I said it's very streamlined uh you just kind of you're there for the story yeah um I'm trying to think of other like positives because I can't really like it was mainly the story the first couple games were really were really
solid whenever you start figuring it out but then it almost seems like once you figure it out it either just becomes tedious or frustrating at least for me that's that's how that's how I was feeling that by the time I was I was gearing up to be done I was like all right hopefully just one more one more but I will say the conclusion is satisfying like the the writing portion of the conclude like maybe their intention was to make it brutally hard so if you come out on the other side uh as a Victor then you feel like you feels in in the story and so and and I'd say that they succeeded in that like I I enjoyed following his journey I think
think this is a game definitely worth getting but checking out if you're a solo gamer um and you like his games this is definitely one to check out but I would highly highly recommend that you do not binge it like that that would be my advice is like oh should I get it uh it's like yeah absolutely it's clean it's a solid story um and it it adds enough each game that it doesn't like that stuff it doesn't get like stale but just don't don't play it over and over and over to try and finish the campaign um so on a scale of one to ten
I am gonna give it based off my experience I'm gonna give Legacy of you a I'm torn between a six and a seven I do think it is a slightly above average game I am going to give this the benefit of the doubt and say seven I think that if I did not play this as quickly as I did I wouldn't have been as frustrated by what was going on in the RNG because it wouldn't have been as apparent to me uh so I'm gonna give it the benefit of a doubt and give it a seven I think this is a really I think it's a good game now it has elements this could have been an eight or a nine but it just it's too random but it is also very streamlined whenever you're playing solo like I've played frostpunk solo and I'm like oh my God but here you just you just have this stuff right next to you and you're just in and out just getting it done uh resetting a game is very quick uh and the it's also the games aren't long it says 60 minutes that's Max I think like if you're playing a game obviously because you might just lose right out the gate but if you're actually getting into an actual game 60 Minutes is is Max um if I was going based off my experience of the multiple games that I did uh it would be a six um but also at the same time like I'm the the frustration that didn't like
stay like I'm not still feeling it it was just more of kind of like okay that was that and then you just reset it and keep going um so yeah I'm gonna give Legacy of you a seven but again that's a weird ranking because I I will never play this again like I I I was able to get get the victory so I read that uh and I'm like I'm done I'm done like I don't need to play it again and potentially read this you know kind of the same story over and over I don't need to read the the defeat cards um like so it's it is kind of like once you get the victory you're done they do have promos you can get it says provides three ways to increase the difficulty for legacy of you um that's Bonkers to me uh I guess give it some variety it would be neat if like you could just play this without having to do the campaign like I guess the right you can just play the first game but it would have been cool is like if they had an after campaign thing to where you can just add certain stuff to like a module kind of thing like oh hey I'm done with the game but I don't want to do the campaign again so I'll just uh I just want to play it but they don't have any of that to my knowledge so the the promo cards just kind of are added throughout the campaign uh
so that'd be that'd be something that that'd be nice like there are some Legacy games that do that where it's like oh you're done okay well now here's how the game can be played after you're done with the campaign but this doesn't have that and I think this would be a solid one to just have as a one-off of things you can just be like okay what do you want to add you want to add this this like kind of a module thing of the what the campaign does add so you can just kind of do your efficiency puzzle and that really is what this kind of game is if the deck is if your deck is working you know well and the Barbarian deck isn't isn't being too rough it is an efficiency puzzle which as if you watch a lot of my Euro discussions the efficiency games aren't something that I particularly enjoy because I feel like once you've figured it out then you're done it doesn't allow a lot of variety so the Euro games I enjoy are the ones with a bunch of variety to them uh and this game doesn't have that like I said it's good it's a good game but understand that you might just spray the blues through no fault of your own especially in your first game uh yeah so I think that's it uh from me uh so seven out of ten Legacy view let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be
notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you