Skip to main content
Loading video...

Golem Board Game Review - Meaty Marble Madness

Transcript 23:28

hi everyone i'm luke hector this is the broken amiibo thanks for tuning in for another review video if you like what you see please remember to leave a like and a comment it means the world to me to know you appreciate the content and i like to engage with my community also don't forget that there's a mini patreon campaign if you want to support this channel a little bit further so we got this big monstrosity today and i'm gonna get the pronunciation mixed up sometimes i say go them sometimes i say gollum you know but it literally just slipped the tug so however you want to pronounce it go right ahead we have to wait for vegeta and trunks to come out of the hypertonic lion tamer that one was on purpose so i had some trepidation going into this one for a few reasons okay not the most striking cover in the world right heavy dry themeless euro as if we don't see 20 million of those every year but also virginia giggly i think that's how you pronounce it simone luciani and cranial creations that team up did another game that i'm aware of get out of there yeah suffice to say lorenzo and i don't have the best of histories uh have been a game i somewhat despise for its punishing nature and very restrictive gameplay so i was a little bit like oh i don't know i'm gonna be another rinse repeat of that but this ended up being the first game that i demoed at essen which is kind of surprising you'd think i would come to this one last or maybe avoid it all together but no it just happened to be the first one i tried granted trying to get into a demo s and kind of meant go to whatever table you could find that was free but still i wanted to give this one a try and well i've played it multiplayer i played it solo and this is a full review so uh

question is did it work the legend of the golem is one of the most fascinating stories in the world and has its roots in the jewish tradition in golem this story inspires a strategic and complex game in which players take on the role of scholars focused on recreating the famous clay autonomous use your knowledge to study traditional books collect gold to melt down into powerful artefacts and use clay to bring tireless golems to life and send them to the city to do important jobs you will need to maintain control of your golems by using your students and spending knowledge you have gained you can also choose to kill off your golems to avoid paying for their maintenance the three-dimensional synagogue creates a dynamic randomization of the available actions with the number of marbles keyed towards how powerful the action is and the colour of the marble dictating how your students move on the game board the golems management is an intriguing innovation in worker placement where your golems will move of their own free will and you have to essentially catch up with them in order to keep the maintenance under control or kill them off before they get out of control and lose you victory points your board can be developed in three different ways whether you want to focus on knowledge in books the creation of golems or the development of powerful artifacts you have a ton of tiles that you can spend to flip over to gain special abilities or more end game scoring opportunities over the course of four rounds you will pick two marbles for two separate actions as well as use your rabbi token to do a third possible action from a selection of tiles that are randomized each round you will be needing to manage your resources carefully as well as

create powerful combos with the actions of your golems and the books that you might acquire during the course of the game once the four rounds are over end game scoring takes place based on your development of your own home player board and of course the one with the most of course now the box for golem stays two hours and that's uh pretty accurate actually at least from a minimum standpoint this is quite a long lengthy game if you play this with two players and solo you could probably get it done in 90 minutes but yeah you're gonna struggle to get it done in less than two hours with three or four players particularly if you have to teach the game and especially particularly if this is your first game it's gonna take you a while and a lot of that comes down to just how many options that you have each turn not to mention the potential that this game has for chronic analysis paralysis if you play this game with anybody who could potentially slow it down they will slow it down full stop end it just it's gonna happen and a lot of that comes down to some of the down time that you do get between turns you are engaged for most of this game but unfortunately a lot of turns and this is gonna be touched on a little bit later and this is not necessarily a bad thing but the turns that you have can create all sorts of lengthy combos you flip this tire which allows you to upgrade this development and by doing so you get to activate this golem which allows it to travel and do this and you can create very fulfilling turns but while you're doing that everybody else is kind of on their mobile phone or twiddling their

thumbs yeah you can think about your next turn but people have got to take marbles or rabbi actions before you do it could mess up your plan and so you do find yourself kind of sitting back and waiting a while not to mention that the game has a lot of setup i mean you've got to set up three different streets you've got all that stuff on your player board to do objective cards the marble synagogue the rabbi actions starting tile setups it's like whoa okay hang on slow down a bit here guys there's a lot to get done and of course packing it away takes a while as well so duration is definitely quite a long one here not painfully long and we're not talking maybe well i suppose not talking the three hour mark here but this is easily probably gonna set you back a good two and a half hours every time to play with the possibility of shortening it down to 90 minutes for solo and two player and two hours is more once you've got three or four of you that are really comfortable with the game but even then four players at two hours that's still a bit of a stretch now there's both a pro and a con with the ease of play overall the rule book is pretty good actually david digby had his hand in this one and the rule book is fairly easy to follow when you go through and you're reading up on how the actions work they make sense with the possible slight exception of the gold artifacts one that one's a little bit more fiddly but a couple of times reading over it and you'll be like oh i see that's what you mean with developing this bit and developing that part but where the ease of play gets a little bit

problematic it's just the smorgasbord of iconography that is in this game there's like a ton of the stuff the appendix pages it's like about six or seven pages at the back of the book for character abilities for development tile abilities for the board abilities the streets and that the objective cards the books themselves there's a lot of icons there's a lot of different actions you can do which certainly makes for a lot of choice but it means that your first game particularly of this one is going to be a learning experience there's no reference sheet which is really bad really this game could seriously do with a decent reference sheet you get a titty little card for the round order but that's kind of it and it's only semi-useful you really kind of need a decent reference sheet for the iconography for players to have rather than have it in the back of the book but it also means that your first games people's brains are going to melt with this the amount of combos that you can create it gets a little fiddly at times it's very fulfilling i mean when you pull off those awesome combos and you get all those resources and flip over two tiles in one go it's like ah it's really good until you realize that when you're trying to in your head gauge exactly what's going on and what sequence to do it in it does overthrow quite a few players right so hang on right i'm gonna do this right so this upgrade lets me do this a five discount let's see that cost me four plus two to do that so that's one technically right so i pay one to do that but then the card book i shove in gets me another one golden clay from this then i'm gonna get

two knowledge from the book as well as create a golem right i've got free clay create a golden bright that's cool and in creating iron i've got the ability that when i create a golem i get to move it one and then trigger an area so i'll move that one trigger that oh that allows me to do an artifact development at minus two discount and it's like what the oh no i've gone cross-eyed so trying to juggle all these little things in your head is certainly very tricky to do particularly in your first game anybody who comes out and tells you that this is a midweight euro is lying through their clay-covered stained teeth because this is certainly a heavy game probably one of the heavier games at cranio creations has even put out i suppose barrage is kind of up there but this is getting close to that kind of level it's definitely a lot heavier than lorenzo and definitely a lot heavier than newton this is definitely going to melt brains in a good way we'll get onto that but yeah just expect a bit of a learning curve to get used to how the game operates but suffice to say that rulebook does a good job of helping you and very quickly to mention the solo mode you get a separate little book to handle the solo mode which is non-tomner and that is very fiddly for your first game gets easier afterwards but you've got to remember a priority order of how the golem works what it moves first what student it moves and then when it's doing actions it collects resources on the track doesn't care about this but it cares about this there's a lot of little intricacies that the old toner uses and you have to use the priority chart on the back of the rulebook like extensively and believe me i lost count

during my first game solo when i was looking through that robot trying to hang on so wait a minute they're doing this one now so how does this work when they do that uh oh i see and it made my first solo game very slow in subsequent solo games though it did get a lot quicker you're still gonna look at a good 90 minutes though for this game because of all the setup and all the thinking you're going to be doing as well as the micromanagement of the actions i mentioned before but yeah just stick with it it gets better and the rulebook is decent not as good as the main rulebook i think it was a bit easier to understand the main game than it was the solo game but not by great deal as i say with the multiplayer and the solo it's a learning curve just stick with it so the previous two segments had a mixture of pros and cons but for the most part decent here though it's a big pro the tactics and strategy element of this game is where it shines at its best it doesn't feel anywhere near as punishing as something like lorenzo or barrage the two games from cranio that i don't like go figure because this one can get restrictive in terms of the resources you're collecting for certain aspects but they're usually the bits you're not focusing on this much if i play a game where i'm focusing a lot on study and the books and the knowledge i'm gonna be able to rake in that stuff and perform some really cool combos but then i expect to suck when it comes to say creating more golems or artifacts because you're focusing die hard on one area but i never felt like it was impossible to get what i needed if i

needed to get the clay to do this or if i needed to get the gold to do this there was ways of doing it there's a lot of options on the board whether it's from activating a golem getting a book card and shoving it in the right column or triggering any sort of other combo that you have there is a way to do it and certainly or melt your brain trying to think right well hang on i need a bit of knowledge for this i need a bit of clay for that that action if i take this marble i get four clay because there's four marbles in there so if i do that and then upgrade the golem's foot i'll get this cool ability and you know it just feels very satisfying i felt like i have the options but i never felt like i was being kicked in the teeth at any point and if i did suffer negative points or any like major downfall i'm kind of the blame for it not just the game is outright trying to screw me over or other players are trying to screw me over it's more oh yeah i really should have thought about that before i took that action that's not great not to say that players can't screw you over by nicking the marble you wanted or taking the rabbi action you wanted or stealing the book card you wanted because believe me i played with one group of friends where i seem to be inadvertently doing that constantly to other people but there is the slight flaw with that as well this game is a little multiplayer solitaire you don't need to care too much about what the other players are doing other than the fact that they might take your card or the marble action you're doing if someone over there is creating a ton of artifacts i can't exactly stop them from doing that they're going to get the gold bars by whatever means they're doing they're

going to get the the development tiles flipped over i can't really influence that at the moment i'm here collecting books and knowledge they can't stop me raising up the study track you might take the book card i really wanted but other than that i'm gonna get books you can't exactly screw over my entire strategy here and that does mean that playing this with more players just basically elongates the time rather than adds anything meaty and meaningful to the game experience i also feel that the game could have been streamlined in a couple of ways like with the passing mechanic for the most part you'll never use this it's a weird little system where if you pass you basically wait for the other actions to finish and then you take a marble out of the synagogue put them all back in reset the rows and then you take your actions that are left the only time you want to do this is if the action you do it has no marbles in it and you desperately want to do that action like no accounts can you do anything else then you might pass but honestly in all the games i have played people have passed twice not joking twice and i've never done it myself this is how rare it happens but you have to teach this new segment of rules in order to say oh well if you pass through this right now we need the second passing round right you're going to reset this and you might not even get what you want anyway it's like all right i'll pass fine put them all in the synagogue and then the marbles come out in a worse state than you tried before it just really seems like a very tactile mechanic that doesn't need to be there maybe you could argue it's a little bit

of luck mitigation but then it's still luck what comes out of the synagogue and that is one little flaw with this game as well if you're not comfortable with the fact that the synagogue marble selection could screw you over a moment's notice then yeah you might want to reconsider but that marble system is really cool i like looking at those and thinking right well if i take that particular action it's really powerful now okay that's cool maybe i should do it but do i need to do that create a golem action right now maybe i could wait but then how long do i wait because the marbles will get taken and the action gets weaker the character card each round take two specific colors and you can trigger a cool effect am i gonna care about that character card in which case i need to be very specific about which color marbles i take but then the color marbles move your students across and it's like well i really need to move the blue student further so i can get it to the end of the track for this objective card so that means i need blue marbles but the character doesn't want blue marbles so do i care about the character or do i sacrifice in the student movement it's so many meaty decisions from a box of marbles it's such a cool little mechanic granted there is no framatic reason why marble should be used as an action selection mechanic in any game whatsoever certainly not this one but that just works so well it's simple it's visually interesting even though the synagogue cardboard box looks a bit naff but it's just a cool little system for action selection and then add on all the rest of the stuff it's a meaty game but a very very fun one

so while on the subject of naf looking synagogues yeah this isn't exactly cranial creation's uh uh expertise here when it comes to aesthetics aesthetics for a lot of their games tend to be fairly muted colors fairly bland i'm not aware of a looker when it comes to their games but this certainly isn't it either the board looks more busy than it actually is it looks at a far off distance the board like oh scares people but when you get up close you realize right it's basically free streets that's the golem movement that's the street movement and that's the tiles right okay that's not too complicated then but it's still pretty muted colors the artwork is not particularly interesting even the components aren't exactly that good the boards are okay and they've got little cutouts for that but marbles are pretty basic the tokens for resources is a pretty tiny actually a little too tiny in my effect and they're just like little plasticky sort of glossy cardboard tokens that for some reason you get those for the free basic resources but then you get wooden gold bars and it's like well why couldn't you make other things wooden yeah i literally play this game replacing the components with things from the stonemaier treasure chest to be honest i mean you can use the the terror chest for knowledge of books and magnifying glasses and you can use the original uh treasure trove one to get bricks for the clay and uh use a coin chest from sinister fish games in order to replace the coins either way you can pimp up this game a bit better than it's in the box it's also a huge table hog like massive table hog you are going to need

a big size table to fit not only the big center board but also the synagogue and the board that goes in front of that as well as your player board and the two little boards that go onto the side as well as the room for the book cards that go above your board this game really sucks up the space on your table you need to be ergonomic with the way you lay this out and certainly you're getting your money's worth in terms of like pieces in general it's just not really going to turn a few heads when they walk by and see that's not particularly interesting it looks as muted and bland as well one of the golems you're creating frankly like big good strong hands now immersion's a bit of a weird one with this one because when it comes again to cranio creations theme is not their strong suit their games tend to be very heavy dry euros well no surprise this one's heavy dry and themeless as well it's literally based on a story like a famous story of like creating golems and that's about all it is for theme i mean you're creating the amount of clay they wander off and do random tasks your students move across the street forwards and backwards they can't catch up to the golem for whatever reason you're like using a marble mechanic to do your actions there's characters who care about which marbles you take it's like yeah come on that theme is gone from here though instantly as soon as you get into this game you forget what it was even about in fact i actually

made the boo-boo at one point where somebody i made a joke whereas like you you killed my twin golem there you've ruined christmas and somebody pointed out to me at the table it's like you do realize this is set in judaism right it's like all right and so i got that completely wrong i forgot where it was even set that's how like null and void the theme is that being said the idea of creating like military golems that are effectively like your children in a sense that go off and do stuff you can make quite a few gags and jokes about the fact that you know you're creating these golems and they're running out of running amok out of control we've had everything from killer golems to rocket boot golems to calling mine jeff and not wanting the killer morphets you can make a few little jokes like that for a laugh but that's the group dependencies talking there the game isn't exactly bringing it out so you're looking for theme it's not here longevity is pretty strong here in elements your development board will not change at all from game to game mainly it's the setup of the main board there's quite a decent amount of book cards and you don't go through that book card deck very fast particularly if players aren't focusing on them so you'll get a good amount of variety from those there's enough rabbi action tiles to fulfill a few games before you start seeing the styling stuff again and the neighborhood tiles are probably the main aspect of replay value where you have seven spaces on three streets and you have ten tiles for each street you pick seven and you lay them out in order of ascending

number that creates a little bit of differentiation between games but not a huge amount so you are going to be playing a fairly similar game from time to time but it's more how you utilize all the different combos to meet your end goal and what that little marble mechanic does for you as well however you do have the solo mode which to be fair once you get over the initial learning curve of dealing with the fiddliness of it it's actually a pretty good way to play the game it simulates a multiplayer opponent quite well even though it doesn't quite you know it has a flexibility with resources and you need to play it on probably hard mode in order to lose to it often although norm was a pretty decent thing do not play it on easy that is like training shoes baby mode like you will obliterate it on easy mode but it adds a bit of extra longevity to the game and so this is not one that i think you're going to want to play all over and over again in quick succession because you might see a bit of rinse repeat turning up from here to there but every now and again you'll want to pull this out and get a really good meaty experience in and so like i say it should stand the test of time for some years to come that sounds like a lot of negatives but some of them are more small or you can get over them where this game really does earn some great marks though is the gameplay itself is just really good fun it's such a good game for anybody who likes combo building anyone who gets a like a big high from being able to pull

off a move where they go that triggers into this which triggers that which triggers that which gives me these resources which triggers that ah that felt so good this is the game for you it's gonna melt your brain like crazy do not go into this thinking that this is gonna be a mid-weight light experience because it just frankly isn't but once you get going and you're used to it it's entertaining to want to come back to it i want to try out different combos i want to try out the artifact strategy this time i want to try out the knowledge strategy this time and it just really did feel like a good enjoyable game it's just held back from the top marks by a few of those negatives i mentioned before so overall gollum has surprised me this is definitely going on my shelf alongside newton and i'm giving it a solid pretty powerful 8 out of ten with a seal of endorsement those negatives take it out of distinction level for me but i still am glad that i got into this game despite having reservations when i first started and found no this is actually a pretty good meeting euro game and i highly recommend it to anybody who's into cranial creations games or just heavy euros in general you don't care about the theme fine whatever there's none here anyway you just want meaty decisions and brain melting mechanics along with like a seriously like really cool fulfilling combo system then by all means gollum is exactly what you want so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple do you like gollum have you played it are you looking forward to it what reservations do you have what are you excited about let me know leave a like on the video and a comment in there because it gives me a lot of pleasure to

read what you have to say because not only does it give me some knowledge but it gives knowledge to other people who are watching this video and if you want to check out more content on the channel then you can check out the next top 100 segment my 30 to 21 that has now been done as well as a review i did recently for geisha's road a new sequel to hannah mccoy from emperor s4 take care and remember as always regardless of what you do with the golems you create it's only a game bye for now everyone see you soon

Progress saved