Skip to main content
Loading video...

Eila and Something Shiny: Discussion

Transcript 25:28

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Isa and something shiny. I have just at this moment finished the entire series. So, and I got to say this game was a journey. Um, it takes a lot for me to get an emotional reaction um out of out of board games, especially narrative campaign games, because the writing never seems to be kind of like the forefront. Um, and not that the writing in this, I mean, it wasn't really there like it's you didn't read a bunch, but most of the time whenever something chaotic happens or something that's supposed to be scary or sad, I'm always able to disconnect from the fact that it's a game. Um, cuz the board game like medium doesn't really, I don't know, elicit that response from me anyway in the same way that reading a book does or watching a show or playing a video game does. It just doesn't hit the same way this game did. It was it. It's insane. I don't And And what's amazing is it was able to achieve that in only five chapters, six technically with a with like a prologue.

Um but the I had so this was kind of an experiment because I had years ago I actually still had the videos on my channel surprisingly but I deleted them um to you know replace them with this new series. Um but I had actually been sent this as a pro like you know whenever they were originally going on Kickstarter. So, it's been a long time and I think they only had enough for the first chapter or something. And I was like, "Yeah, you know, the the game's fine, but uh it's clearly designed for kids. Um, and not that there's anything wrong with that, but I'm not a kid. I was in my 20s at that time. Now I'm in my early 30s." Um, but as this game was released, you know, a few years ago, I had heard that the story actually gets dark. And I was like, right. Cuz I had heard it from people who had kids. And I'm like, okay, it's dark for for kids, you know, like, oh no, there's a fight and oh, it's, you know, like I thought it was going to be geared towards it says 12 and up. Um, like honestly I think the age should be higher cuz there are instances in this story where even I'm like as a 32-year-old man I'm like Jesus Christ like who is playing this with their kids? They they do kind of pull the wool over your eyes on this. Um but

the first and foremost they are able to achieve something that many larger campaign games fail to do with more like less is more with this game. If you are like me and you like you see the box cover with the rabbit the stuffed rabbit on it and you're like okay this is this is a child's game. I implore you to give it a shot because you're going to be shocked. I don't want to spoil anything in this in this um discussion. Um but I cannot emphasize enough about how engrossed I was. And it's only five chapters. Like what's amazing is I I want more. Um, there were there were like whenever you're reading like the prologue in the comics and you're kind of getting context clues from the pictures and you're like, "Wait a minute, like how much time has it been?" Or you have to infer something based off the decisions or things that are being told to you and you're like, "Well, why is it this way?" I was enveloped in what was happening about a stuffed rabbit going on a journey to the top of the mountain.

Um, I kept thinking certain things were going to happen and either if they did it wasn't quite the way I expected or if it didn't then I'm even I was shocked. Um, like I didn't do it during the series. But I promise you there were instances that had I not been recording or had this been an actual show, if this had been a show, like a short uh series or a book, I would probably have teared up. um just because they they did things in this narrative, in this campaign that hit for me, like story beats, whether they're cliches or not, uh that just hit me in the fields. And I like I I finished all five chapters in like two days because every time I I sat down to do a chapter, I was genuinely excited to to keep playing or whenever I was done to jump into the next chapter. Um, and there's only five and the chapters last like an hour. So, you get I don't remember how how much this game was, but you get uh like 5 hours worth of content on one playthrough. Now, technically, this game does have replayability cuz I was doing it for the for the channel. Um there wasn't like there wasn't a reality that I was actually ever going to sit down and and play through it again. Um, but you absolutely could because the ending that you get, um, at the very

end, you'll kind of be like, if you get the ending I got, it's like eyeopening and you're like, "Oh my god, well, now I have to re, you know, play through it again because what I thought I was doing was gearing up for this thing, but turns out I should not have been doing that." And then they they pull they do another thing for you and it's like wow I was not even expecting that at the very end. Um so it it's just absolutely mind-blowing for a game that looks like this to have one of the best narrative experiences that I've ever had in a board game. Um, like the closest thing that I could I could give to like shocking things, um, like shocking narrative elements would be from a game like maybe this war of mine, which is meant to hit home the horrors of war. Um, and when you're going through the narrative stuff through that game, it's real life situations you can apply and see. And it's like, yes, okay, I can see this. But like in a fantasy game, like when you look through my top 100 or my top 10 or my top 10, you know, top 10 games of all time or top 10 uh campaign games, not a single one of those hits me in the same way that this game did. And I I'm just so

mind blown by it. I I can't I honestly can't [ __ ] believe it. So then we move into the game. And the game's actually good, too. That's the thing. Um you are you have like your your little notepad of of items um that you carry over of supports you get, which are abilities, and habits you get. So, it also does a great job of the choices mattering. Like, yes, I got most of the items at some point or another. And what I thought I was doing was actually building. And you you can like you get to make decisions throughout this game that will determine your kind of build.

And you can go like a physical build, a magic build, a resource build. Um, this game also happens to do character builds better than a lot of campaign games out there where for some reason those games are just really restrictive and here it's just like no, you have 15 items. Yeah. But but where what you think you're doing with them where you think you're just going to breeze through the game which you do is not really what it ended up being about. And so that was amazing. On top of the fact that you get really cool support cards that are abilities, you get habits that kind of go into the the narrative deck of things that your character has learned and picked up to do that all contribute to the overall story of like I remember when I got this. I remember when I got this. Uh I know what this does now. um like your choices actually end up having such a significant impact on the game.

And then not only that, like yes, combat is literally a d6 die roll, but it's like you actually have mitigation, which some games don't even [ __ ] do that. Uh it has very simple resource management. Um but that resource management you're invested in the whole time because you're constantly having to spend it. You need it. You need energy at the end of every night, otherwise you start taking wounds. You have a certain health limit for each chapter. Um, the game is not fail forward in any way. Like, if you don't meet the objective by the end of the seventh day or you take all the wounds, it is just redo it. But the game is honestly not geared towards that. I never felt that I was ever in any chance of losing. Um, which I per I didn't have a a problem with at all. I love the fact that they it wasn't hard for the sake of being hard. They didn't keep you strapped for food. Uh so you had to like really struggle, but it's like if you were out of food, you were kind of like, hm, I need to figure out ways to get it.

Um but the resource management just worked to serve the purpose of of the rest of the game. Because if it was literally like like how certain campaign games are where you're just sitting there flipping a card, reading it, and moving on, that's not engaging. Like, yeah, I mean, it was engaging here, but it was also because there was a game tied to it. Um, like I mentioned, the game is only five chapters and you can see the progression, the time progression apparently of uh of Isa's journey through throughout, you know, her purpose of making it to the summit. Um, and each chapter is unique. Now, the prologue is is literally just like 5 seconds. It's to teach, it's a tutorial, but chapter 1 through five all have different systems. Like chapter three is the mine where you kind of have a tile exploration. Chapter 4 um has like these these uh um contracts and privilege cards and things like that. So they didn't hammer you down with repetitiveness. Not even if it was repetitive, it's only five chapters, so it wouldn't have been that big of a deal, but um at least every single chapter was fresh.

And what was also great is when when you you only had to learn the game through chapter 1, but then when you got to chapter 2, it was like a page of new rules and you're right back in it. Um I I I mean the the game play of it just absolutely like worked. it was so complimentary to um to the narrative and and you know I think I mean it's probably just because I happen to play this game in a time where there was a lot of turmoil in real life. It's it it gets increasingly difficult to upload videos about playing board games while there's, you know, pe people being ripped out of their homes. Um, constantly being oppressed by the dog [ __ ] [ __ ] horrific administration that that we're dealing with. I'm not going to turn this into a political video, but my the point is is while horrific things were happening in this game and the narrative, there was always the slight um like the the message behind it that kindness and love prevails. Um and I think that that happens to contribute to why I'm just so enamored by this game because it's like you don't get those messages a lot. like it's difficult like I said to just keep uploading board game videos and try and you almost feels like you're pretending like nothing's happening in the world or you feel powerless. Um but like whenever

I am talking about you know you know personal uh morality or political situations with my friends I always you knowark hearken back to like you we got to maintain hope like I have literally a tattoo on my back that says in the darkest times hope is something we give ourselves and if you want to make a difference then help your fellow man help your neighbor. um because that is what's going to make you feel like you're actually making a change in the world. Um and that stuff definitely goes a long way. So that's kind of what this game was ultimately trying to say was that the the route that I took of getting super strong that that's that's game RPG stuff like oh I know we're going to be fighting a lot so I want to be really strong and it was like yeah you can do that but that's what this as you get stronger the more you turn into a monster and it's actually by choosing kindness you're still able to achieve a better outcome.

Um, so that this this game was just absolutely fascinating. I don't even know this designer, Jeffrey CCH. Um, I don't know if this is something that he if he's working on another game, you know, it's been a while actually. Let's see. Let's see. Um, Isa and something. This came out five years ago now. Um, Jeffrey CCH. Oh, holy [ __ ] Um, Island Something Shiny. Uh, Terrorcape. Oh, cuz it's Northstar. Holy [ __ ] He did Terrorcape. Wow. This dude has Couldn't have a bigger uh like that's night and day. But wow. Oh, cuz it's okay. Ice Makes and Northstar.

Yeah. Okay. That's Wow. Um well, I absolutely love Terescape and Terescape 2. So, yeah. I would love if if he went and made another game like like maybe if it's it's not even with Isla or if it was like a sequel to to this one. Uh cuz I thought again with the the the kitty nature that I had, I thought it was going to be trope after trope after cliche after cliche and no it never was. Um sometimes some of the art was way way more intense than I ever thought it would be. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. I mean, I if you if you're watching this, and I highly recommend you go watch my series because I haven't had those types of reactions ever that I can think of in recent memory. Um, like it it just kept taking me by surprise. I am flabbergasted, honestly, by this. So, so yeah. Again, if you're like me and you see this and you're like, "Okay, well, that might be something my 5-year-old would enjoy, but not me." You're going to be surprised.

You're going to I literally It's like after chapter two, you're like, "Okay, why am I caring? Like, why is the events that's happening actually make me care about these characters or um the decisions I made?" And you could be like me. I mean, you could just play through it and see the ending you get and then replay it if you like it that much. I will say if I had to think of some negatives about the game. Um, it is choice-based. Like, you do get to make decisions and that will lead to a different ending, but I will say that the narrative choice making is very light. Like don't get me wrong, it does serve the overarching narrative and it feels awesome, but like for example, some of the earlier chapters between ending A and ending B, those are pretty much the exact same. Now, how you get to those, of course, feels different. So, this game does end up being kind of like it's about the journey, not the destination. Although, it does end up being about the destination, too, which is awesome, cuz that's I'm a destination guy. It's like the journey could be great, but if the if you don't stick the landing turns to [ __ ] Game of Thrones is a great example. Um, but your different endings don't necessarily matter at later chapters. Like if I got ending B in chapter 2, that doesn't really matter in chapter 4. I mean,

maybe it does in the slight tweaks because I have certain items. I guess it kind of does, but not in a noticeable way. Anyway, not that that's really a that's like a very minor nitpick. Um, it's more of kind of on the when you're reading ending A and ending B in like a chapter, it's like, oh, okay, because that will have to lead to the next. It's not like, oh, if I choose this then this uh ending, then I'm going to go to a completely different section. It's like, no, you're still going from, you know, the factory to the mines that's going to happen. And so it's just a matter of what comic you read to get to the mines. Um, but that's like a minor nitpick. Uh, I mean, other than that, like I I I really got nothing. I think I think they just they they killed it here. Um, so yeah, like like what I was saying, you could just be like me and play the game and then be like, "Okay, how do we get this different ending?"

And then do and then just see what that is. so you can truly get the full narrative experience um in one playthrough cuz it doesn't really justify a replay. Um because you do end up going through most of the cards. Uh like yes, there's going to be a few blue cards and a few red cards that you don't see, but not like you don't have like a massive stack of [ __ ] that you're like, I didn't even go over there. It it's not like that kind of narrative thing. you will see most of the cards, but um and it and the how to get to the endings does kind of um seem obvious. Uh like it's like especially whenever you like it's like okay, ending A is always going to be meeting the objective. Ending B is they're going to provide you with another route to get to ending B. And then if there's like in chapters four and five, there's an ending C and that's a little bit more obscure on how you get, but still it's still relatively easy to find.

Which again is not really a negative. I'm actually glad because for a game like this, I wouldn't want to [clears throat] sit here and trudge through hours upon hours to be like, what? Why is this obscure? Oh, I would have never thought to do that. you know, some games like to be a puzzle and make it really just abstract on how you get a certain ending. It's like I don't want to deal with that. So, yes, I like how everything felt obtainable and it was kind of like I always wanted to because it feels like the the lower like ending ending B is like the is better than ending A, ending uh C is better than ending B. Um, and you can go that route if you want to. So yeah, I mean again, this game was absolutely amazing. Uh I was just engrossed the entire time and loved it till the very end. And I'm a 32-year-old man and I was expecting this to be like, "Oh, haha. Yeah, it's dark."

Uh nope. Nope. Those people were right. And I'm very, very glad that I experienced this. It is easily one of the best board game experiences I had. And I never play solo games. And I play a lot of campaign narrative driven campaign games. Like if you've watched my channel for any significant amount of time, you know I'm the campaign boy. I I back and buy and play campaigns all the time. And some are fantastic and some are dog [ __ ] And this one was fantastic. So, I really hope Jeffrey does and I think that this is like this style of game is worthy of keeping an eye out. Like I I it's like this is the lesson to not judge a book by its cover.

So, cuz I'm looking at the side, I'm looking at the side. I'm looking at the art and I remember those moments and it's like, wow, it's it's just it's so good. Um, on a scale of 1 to 10, Island Something Shiny is getting a 10 from me. This game was like, yes, if I'm trying to be kind of somewhat objective about it. I mean, for what this game was, like the resource management management with the money and the, you know, you had like the food and the and the energy and the knowledge, it you were constantly rotating it. You had to manage it. It wasn't super hard to manage. So, it wasn't frustrating, but you got to feel cool. You got to see your Yeah, the character build was was there. You get a bunch of items based off the decisions of what you did. Um, [snorts] hell, even the the cards getting through the chapters were quick. So, it's not like it ever it never felt like a slog.

It always felt like you were making progression in the in the chapter. After 45 minutes to an hour, you were done with a chapter, and that felt good. Um, and then you just quickly pack it up and you can either play a different day or like me, I was like, I gotta go to the next chapter. I gotta I want to play it again. I want to see what happens. Um, the fact that the narrative has you care about the characters without without beating you over the head with non with with verbal diarrhea where you don't have a massive book that something just reads to you and you're like, "This is just nonsense." Um, yeah. Like I I just I honestly can't believe it. Like it I'm still reeling about it. Like it's like there's there's a small part of me just because again this feels so appropriate to the current times where now more than ever we need to choose kindness and love for for one another and have each other's backs and protect those who can't protect themselves. If you have the capability to help someone, you should help someone. It's just like it's it's it's really really hitting home. Um, so yeah, this game is special.

So give it a shot. You will not be disappointed. Yeah. Anyway, do good, be empathetic, care for others, help others if you can because while like I said in the darkest times, hope is something we give ourselves. Not all is lost if you I should say it here. Um my channel is meant to be all are all well I wouldn't say all are welcome. There are definitely some people who [ __ ] aren't welcome and you [clears throat] know who you are. Check the color of your goddamn hat. Um, but it's uh but yes, like I I want my channel to be a source of entertainment and a source of distraction um if you need it. But yes, like this game got me. It It got me for sure.

Um, anyway, before I keep rambling, that's my thoughts on Isa and Something Shiny. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved