CO2: Second Chance - Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey one welcome to the discussion for co2 second chance so we've played this game a couple times now both with four players essentially we've done it with just you and me and so here's here's what I want to keep this review off with because we the first time we played it we thought we were doing something wrong because we like lost actually played three times the first time we lost like almost immediate yeah and we're like okay we must have been doing something wrong so then we played it again we're ascetics we weren't that far in and then we uh and then we started over and we actually won after kind of fixing some of the rules of being able to go over 500 because the board doesn't wrap around like that so that's kind of annoying just from a design all games cuz you have to put something into five runs and give you anything to do so um but I was sitting here and I'm like well how how the [ __ ] can you like stop the fossil fuel pant plans from from showing up or stop yourself from losing apparently it was a very common question someone posted on
BoardGameGeek I'm starting with the assumption that I misunderstand the rules here but according to my understanding of the rules there was a very good chance in a I'm in competitive briefing cooperative four player game but the players will lose the start of 2014 with perfect play and they puts up all those reasonings of you know the dirty power plants the fossil fuel plans will be coming out there's you start with uh where was it there it is there's basically a tough like a certain number of 40 so even if you even if you focus on get two power plants built in the earlier one so there's six areas you could still get 440 lose and and if you don't have the points to net it out right one you won't be very hard if you got four you so with that being said this this guy's comment was her beetle beetle is are that this is by design but the rules as written even with perfect play you will lose a good percentage of the time whereas I find dang it but I had oh we lost the first round someone said dang dang I thought I found it I'm above that essentially what it is is I viola star that made this game with
the intent that no matter how well you do like even if we played it perfectly we could still lose because the the real world scenario is that we already [ __ ] ourselves enough with climate change that no matter how much effort we put into it we're still [ __ ] yeah essentially is what is what his reasoning behind it is and with that being said uh I get it I get the message he's trying to send I totally support the message that he's trying to send however I have always made the argument that theme does not always equal good game mechanics because wow this is a somatic game and Oakland is it a very very thematic game the reason why people play games is not to be reminded of the [ __ ] real world as the real world sucks so it's like it's not fun to sit because you want you want the hope and you want to have a fun time playing it so like the game should be hard and it is very hard it's like you should be able to with the the scenario that you're given the toy the tiles and all that you're giving there sure be a chance of victory not a well tamanna CLE we already [ __ ] ourselves so imma [ __ ] you in the game too um I I highly I really disagree with them basically saying you could play the game perfectly and you could still lose because to me that takes away desire to play the game right because it's like
well because we're never you gonna set it up like there's always the chance of what we might win this time because I play games that are hard almost every cooperative game is hard or at least it should be but to make that an intentional decision kind of rubs me the wrong way even though once again the message is clear like I get it but you can get that message across by also letting players have fun he gets the message across just by how challenging the game is right and we'll probably get more into that into the discussion right and how it plays out but I wanted to thought yeah I wanted to talk about that because first of all this theme is very political especially currently at the time most of this recording climate change is a huge topic all over the news and I'm not gonna make I'm not trying to spark [ __ ] anything but but I think it's an important game and I actually very much love the theme because it's not done anywhere all of his games that I've seen are themes that are very integrated together and and barely touched on except for one he has one called videos but there's another game similar to that those other one about the gallerist running an art gallery the one we'd also that you are on the channel for escape plan was you don't do the heist or trying to get out of the city for the ice um so it's weird because I love everything about this game but I don't like the fact that it's
like because because the environmental goals are [ __ ] it's insane like I'm I whenever comes to strategy games I it bugs me when I can't figure out where we were went wrong yep like if I was like if I was too busy strategy game and I'm like oh it was at this point like that that move is probably what cost me or cost us or what I'm trying to think back like maybe not doing forest so early on because then we were kind of scrambling because the last time we played we did we did for us at the end of the game and it only continued to net us out from there but if it really wasn't that it was literally just the way the tiles came out basically like that that [ __ ] does I mean yeah we probably could have gotten more points last round but that we were trying to think ahead in the name of the game and having to worry about getting all your points now me and not think ahead to me goes against the theme of the game right and when I love aspects of the game that I like so much yeah the fact that you have to think decades ahead you have to think of the next decade the next generation right and how right and so currently where it's like okay well what do we do now it's like but the entire game you're not doing stuff now you're doing stuff for the future because there should we go up until 2040 the only way I could have
thought that we could have done something about that is instead of building in [ __ ] Asian stuff we could have built in North America and in South America I did get rid of the thirties no they I can think of us this we just shouldn't have built that recycling plant and try to get more knowledge and that's the only way your turn once the knowledge got written it got rid of the church that really got a seven yeah because then we get rid of those I mean in all reality the only thing the only thing I conversed with the game I think we did really well up until until we lost but it's just the the fossil fuel tiles are they're just random and that's really the only random aspect of the game and I don't like that I don't that's probably my biggest negative there's actually two negatives I have about the game so we can talk about those the biggest one I have is and this is only for the cooperative we haven't played competitive and I have no interest this game competitively because it's semi cooperative and I [ __ ] hate semi co-op because it's like so I just don't like something cooperative but I don't like going because they take the competitive nature of this game and then make it cooperative but they still have some elements of competitive like like private goals right I don't think that needs to be in a cooperative game panel I I probably house rule because it does nothing except does make because you can't talk about your hand you can talk so it's still kind of its it feels committed but it's not in any way right there's no logic or reasoning to explain
why you can't talk to one another yeah a cooperative game we should all have to keep our cards a secret exactly especially especially the end of Caitlyn's right because those are ones that we should be collectively trying to work we'll have to collect let me try to work towards yeah cuz it's like and you can't you can't even like allude to them like some games when it's cooperative you you can't like tell them exactly what would that be you can kind of be paid you can't even do that you have to just okay you know let me know I have to in forget Archer it's like there it it puts a bear in prison unnecessary barrier because we need a fully a cooperative game and even the [ __ ] rules it says right right right not there right here well I thought it was in issue so now I doing it oh there it is this game offers two modes to play a fully cooperative mode of play um not really yeah you all work together and there's no back seven there's no nothing but why add goals first of all why I'd like there should be objectives that everyone has to beat which are these right like so everyone has to go for those and it's like okay well you can do that but then I have my own so I don't like the private goals and I conquered them I think the goals would be better if you laid out eight cards up there and said as a team you have to complete four yeah well that's what the UN cards are basically um I think the UN cars could just be done away with yeah they're just kind of something they're just like
they're like to be they own how much steam or anything yeah they don't have much to the game right um there's technically a variant you can add which is that un like where's that whether they called it I thought you its operations where is it the UN inspectors variant and basically they they move along the environmental goals and then if you don't complete that one that round then you lose double points for it which is just I mean that's us too because that's the hardest thing about the game I like the the goals because they they are they fit with the theme so like oh we need you to build at least two like we want you to build at least two plants yeah in these countries or right we want you to build two of the same you know plant as a player so it does make sense I think they could be tailored to a group right so you're actually group objective but it does make sense for the game the other thing is since it's fully cooperative I don't like the idea of like because once again it feels competitive but it's not like we can't share money yep like so and I understand you could share money the game would be too easy yeah like having and like bangable share knowledge and all that it'd be too easy so it now one I'm not too upset about because it lets people feel like well okay this only this company has the remote so they're gonna put money into it but it just it's just something worth
mentioning that if you want to play this fully cooperatively fully is in in quotations because you can't you can't share anything against your knowledge you can't share cards you can't share money so there's that the other thing that I think it's just weird it's not really a complaint because it doesn't really matter a whole lot and a fully phase I don't the control aspect it makes sense in the competitive game that they just put kept it in the co-operative for no reason like it's like oh hey I control Asia okay don't tell it the burden on that player at the end of the game to basically pay up one of the yeah yeah or if they can't then they have to be penalized and then we lose points for that all right hello you have any negatives those oh and then I gather the fossil fuels are like I like that there in the game because that adds a little bit more element and theme to it I just don't like how random they are yeah that even though they're random I think they could be better balanced somehow yeah like we touched on the world her light it does put a bad taste on my mouth it you can play the game perfectly and you'll still lose yeah I know that's the way with games that are kind of luck and I think the luck based the luck portion of the game is the tiles in the cards yeah but where it would like the luck aspect cuz I don't I don't mind luck in games but in a game like this where everything is just so
clean right um and everything is at your fingertips like you know everything you know you need to do the only thing that's random is you have the tiles the environmental goals that come out they're random at the beginning of the game but you don't it's not like they're coming out randomly and you're like oh we have to deal with right now like so you look at all those you're like okay we need to do Asia and North America or Asia and Oceania and we need to focus on these because this is what's gonna hurt this it almost be easier if you've laid out all your fossil tokens at the start of the game yeah and then you could say okay this round we know that by the end of 2010 we're gonna have this this much hurt on our emissions yeah which in real world you kind of know yeah I mean okay we kind of know where we're at we kind of know how we're gonna yeah probably by the end of this decade or you know probably know about we're right right and then you can play the head better that's a good idea and that's wait these are just make a housewarming present game that way you could I just don't know how it would break it because when you look at it so from a game perspective I see where they were coming from it's like okay we're trying to do this decade so let's build some renewable energy plants okay well we did it in a few but these countries still need energy so they went with this one right randomly I guess they're like oh [ __ ] it let's throw a dart I total this time so that comes out but it was make sense that not a lot of countries do renewable energy so it would make sense that okay at the beginning of the decade you put them out and if you don't
do away with them then it hit your mission right or if you do them all to begin to the game and say you know we had that or 2010 we're like oh we built a plant well now that you know you put that on top of it and yeah we have no offset our emissions right you kind of plan ahead cuz you know in the real world you can look at Contra Hina is like edges are worse than others so and this I mean it doesn't always fall in a place like South America they want trees well you know that doesn't make sense to the deforestation but you know they might have forty four-year-old okay they're probably the worst country we need to focus on them yeah what make the game a little bit it would fit the theme right an automatic sense of it right I just don't know how you would do I mean I guess you've been house rule that because and we could we could definitely play you know a game with a couple of the house rules that we like sharing the cards and put them all out I think that might make it more enjoyable I'd be curious I'd be curious to see how that work to like because if it's like okay 2010 part of the setup for that or part of the cleanup is we put all those out and then we don't but then because then there's the aspect of the points the victory points that help me lower it afterwards well at the end of the game you still total it up so you put them out the start but you don't it doesn't hit you till the end of the decade hmm you're right so what I was thinking yeah I come back I'm kind of an agreement with you we can lay out just the dekhi that we're going into at the start of
the decade yeah and then it's like as we all know we're gonna be a twenty forty exactly I don't lay them out yeah the way about the start so yeah it's 2010 that we have you know thirty twenty twenty twenty thirty and thirty and then it's like okay this is what this is what will hit us and I don't think it would make the game a whole lot easier because you know we could have these green tokens and like we had Asia inertia Oceania but they might have all twenties and then we have 40s in Africa it's like it's like well we watch I close these off they're doing why get rid of the four right because you know hey that's round three that's gonna cost us twice points yeah I mean essentially yeah it's we're doing the same exact thing just in a different order is really what it is and I would be interested to see if that would how that would change the game up because both sides I can see you're being somatic so uh do you have any other negatives that are popping out not really that we've covered I think the money's well balanced I think the I think this the knowledge skills are well balanced in terms of your progression yeah I I really really like this game I do too I do too and I like talking about it a little bit more like I'm not as upset that because there's there's games like pandemic where it's like no matter how well you play just the way that the cards come out you can still this [ __ ] you right but the biggest difference to pandemic and this one is pandemic is an hour right this is essentially three or four hours long with the Box actually say oh
this is 120 minutes that's your claim in speed before you lose yeah I said that's a minimum yeah I took about an hour probably a two-player game yeah um I like the player count I actually like this as a two-player game I said why because and here's the other thing negative or not it doesn't really bother me but some people could this plays up to four it's it's since you can't share money you can't do anything for people is a little much hybrid like rigo's of who you're playing with too many minds to try be thinking Australia the game doesn't provide you enough like strategic options that for people can contribute like two is enough to be like what if we did this or this or in bounce back and forth maybe three before people like you there's almost always kind of one or two or three right answers that someone you're not all gonna have something to contribute most of the time half the people can be like no that works yeah and then they only have to worry about their own objectives I think actually as a two-player game because the the actions equal out like that's another thing I do still really like is that the number of players there's not more you know more tiles coming out there nothing's rent nothing's more random and you still the same number of actions it actually would probably be easier well no because the only thing more difficult would be you'd have to specialize more in knowledge with your scientists which isn't too terribly hard but I'm you have
four actions to do it instead of you know I think that's interesting number of players you get learn actions I mean my favorite thing about this game is everything like just like a skate plan and I'm assuming the gallerist I'm assuming is terraforming Mars one which is probably going to be [ __ ] insanely hard as well is every single action piece is grounded in theme yep except for kind of the the coal tiles I mean the fossil fuel tiles are still the mattock this is how they come out as weird but yeah like where you move your scientist makes sense like the knowledge you gained makes sense go into Summit makes sense yeah I think for me like my biggest positive is just how well the theme of this game clicks mean with the current world that's also true home because you start the game and you're like holy [ __ ] where do we start yeah and that's almost the boat I mean the world's in it's like we've created this [ __ ] right how do we go tell how do we fix it and the first round is very overwhelming because it feels like you're not getting anywhere that's true it's like let's how about this well how about this yeah I want to do this yeah and what's your be sorry for it that's the hardest ones alright how can we do it the cheapest and the easy it's like that's a short term that's not helping us just recycle you know and so like the
costs of everything is the met it fits the theme and that's it goes back to the balance yeah and because like recycling cheap and easy but doesn't get you a whole lot yeah and doesn't help in just like hey emissions or the the [ __ ] O's oh and this [ __ ] up okay what's the best way to balance that ok forestation great when we're away where we're gonna move it well that costs a lot of money and then or okay well how do we do it oh yeah no one knows how to do it so it because that's the hardest one to get up on the track you're right it is very very thankful yeah with the current world and I will say though if you can make it for the most part past the first decade yeah it's a little bit easier and the last time we played we did win yeah through the whole game and we said it already but the theme of the game in the sense that when you strategize as you're playing you have to be thinking a decade ahead yeah and that's and that's I think that money must have been where we got caught up because we were thinking so much we're like oh we're fine on points and then saying oh great right was still divided I didn't think of that the the fossil fuel we were thinking we're good yeah and we're thinking we're thinking so hard in the next century we're neglecting the current one right I mean I like I said I really really do like this game there's I mean I could do a whole lot of pauses and really get down the weeds rang but you know only a couple negatives that we've talked about yeah I like it
alright because some things that might seem weird to others works like well can I move my scientist straight to his summit and it's like no why he doesn't know anything about it he has to build a project first and then move right into games he got he got knowledge at the Ryan so they need now we can go talk about it there's a lot of like and still once again even with escape plan this game has a wicked learning curve actually not even just like ass-kissing escape plan was way lighter than this one toilet and everything in that game made sense thematic sense and touched on a bit like that but it's so difficult to teach this game because it's like I can't just tell you what you do on your turn where I have to tell you literally everything about the game and which is some people won't like that because they like to be able to well don't worry about what these do likes and especially talked about when it comes up yeah don't worry about it just do your turn and then we can we can talk about cooperative games I can help you his games though I mean it's it's short of me just being like alright cave doesn't read it read it yeah because I mean that's essentially what I had to do I read the same three times before I before I taught taught everyone and and then like with with crystal and cat it still didn't really click I mean with with you and I it did and even then it's like well he's still we still have to go back to the rules and that's kind of another negative is that because of the the car if you kind of have to be like it doesn't lobbyists lobbies cards makes sense and actually they have some symbolism that I really like I like that the three main actions are three symbols
so you can look at your card to me like okay that's an infrastructure I have to infrastructure uh so a wind plant and I get that right I like the red and green icons where it's like red is what you pay green is what you get is just quick to look at I like symbolism icons and games like that as long as it's minimal angle it's it's used almost everywhere like that gain knowledge symbol is is everywhere right so it makes sense once you see it I think with these cards they could have easily done a description they could have because that's the only this is just really big they could have easily just told you right in the description then there are not long yeah so it'd be like one or two lines and that's the only reason I've had to pick up the rulebook yeah is to because no matter how many times you play you might get a new card and be like four to seven yeah it's like uh um I think they could have done that and some things like like which is also weird but also I mean that it's not Nathan I'm just talking about aspects of the game is like cards that are like the summit ones for example where it's like oh okay you infrastructure that so he went to a solar summits like you I can't play this cuz it's not my turn so I have to willingly move my my scientists there to be able to play that doing more knowledge I like the lobbyists cards um I do too they have a little bit more i I mean once again this game is just so clean like even just playing it once because of just how integrated it is with everything it it just makes sense Alice to me it does the market is just very easy I like how it's not a convoluted market it's just hey once
this is empty you know price goes up because people are buying them if you're selling it to a lot of price goes down because they're like oh well we're not going to keep paying a lot for things that people don't want that control I could live without it doesn't really do a whole lot but I think that I think that I really like is I like have a look the the different the different plants all look different like I just like how it sits you know solar panels and then it sits rivers and then recycling I just think that look I do like how they fit together to like with with the infrastructure I don't know what the hell these are like it cuz I can see okay that looks like a forest I looks like solar panels and those are oh I think that might be it I think that's probably the closest thing because it is infrastructure okay well but yes that is probably what that is that makes that makes some sense um but yeah like this game has some weird things do you like which you do like this one or escape plan better now that we were supposed to like this one but I like this I like the theme of this one better it's easy easier for me to immerse myself in the theme of the game that's true and there's a cool thing about cuz this isn't a terrible rule book they do things a little bit backwards they explain the executive actions before the main actions I didn't do that and my other play I did the main actions first and then because once you understand the main actions the executive actions will just make it I mean either way I just thought executive actions were a little bit we're a little bit weird but each example they gave
they they gave some real-world knowledge behind it like scientists the scientific community has shown that climate change has been accelerating in recent decades and that certainly human activities have had significant impact among the major human factors is a release of carbon dioxide from fossil fuel power plants and they do it on every page under every single example like carbon trading UN goals for 2030 operations infrastructure so and it all relates to the current build power plant power pan power plant forestation in the game and it just kind of just explains more and more based off of the actions that he put into it so he definitely did this research I don't know which one I like better between because escape plan and co2 and those are the only two of his I've played but from escape land I was like I have to play his other game so I have the gallerist I backed on Mars off Kickstarter and then I don't think I'll get I might get mean use just to have it because I really love his games um remember what I gave escape plan 9 yeah um yeah I think freaked out I think I like this one better because this is cooperative yeah I'm big fan of competitive games I'm not competitive person yeah I am so right but I love competitive games but I also love cooperative games but the theme for this
one is yeah it is it's more graspable almost because I've never robbed a [ __ ] bank and I escaped a city yeah and visually I think this looks really really cool too it's a different design what do you think actually this was an important aspect what do you think of the victory point mechanic the fact that your victory points are not like they're tangible so it's like you've gained them but you're most likely gonna spend and like the victory it's so weird because you victory points within the competitive game yeah you you know you only wanted to go up it's not something that you would ever spend to lose yeah those games that have it to where it's like money at the end of the game is every every dollar is a point so you have to think about what do I want to spend this and lose points or keep it this one it's like your victory points are kind of like your way of buffering how bad you're doing the only thing that I with the point system I'm not sure about calling it for 3 points yeah I think that's the only thing I don't like about it I like that it's it's blue it kind of represents clean air you know they say offsetting they could pick it up maybe like a leaf symbol to represent you know yeah green points or something yeah I think it could named it differently I like like I mean I like it because I had near thing is with the knowledge I like that how knowledgeable you are then you can either get money or you can get victory points yeah you got
more of it on that decade you know so you're up to six you're like well I get six points again offset quite a bit of a mission yeah I just given that yeah okay um well I can't really think of anything else that we haven't touched on that besides literally just talk about you know every single aspect we think about the cover of that know so scale one to ten not a half nine and a half that's a I think the I mean I'm not gonna just recapping I think FEMA's phenomenal I think it plays very well really the the negatives are small in my opinion yeah even though they said hey you could play perfectly and lose that just I kind of take that as a bit of a challenge yeah because it makes me appreciate or victory last time to even more because it's really get through it yeah I think next time I want play just to player mmm what some of the households we talk about to see if that yeah it Hayes's the experience a little bit but I don't have I really really like this game cool cool yeah I think uh I think for me I think I'm a little under I thinking about a nine an escape plan escape learn would still be a nine for the exact same reasons ice but because for me like it is a bit of a challenge but I I since I placed so many games all the time and I value my time quite a bit I still I want the challenge and I do very much like it but I don't like the idea of spending
three and a half hours like because imagine week like it the the defeat isn't as sour because we only made it to a decade to twenty but imagine if it was to 2040 can we just lost because I'll flip ya like no I'd like that's essentially like having a deck of cards and then one of them in there since you lose yeah that's essentially what it is because unfortunately like at the beginning of the game if you play the tiles down and you can know okay well we just ignored them so that's a row fault but you can't do anything about those tiles getting flipped so I think it would be a nine for me because of because of those fossil fuel tiles I like that there in the game I just don't like the fact that they come out at the end of the decade where you can't do anything about it in a game where you can do everything about everything you do you know Sally flipping them over at the start of the decade what almost eliminate that right so I'm really curious to play it again unless like watch I just been [ __ ] myself the entire time it's not I mean for each region yes start if the current decade space has a power plane you skip it otherwise fill the empty space by randomly drawing a fossil fuel power plants from the fossil fuel deck and you decrease it by that much and then if you can't pay it then you pay a fine which cost you points see that's fine too if you can't pay that you can pay the fine like if it's like oh we didn't do that so we lose CP unless you control the area then it's like oh well then I have to lose it or I have to pay it um but yeah and then reducing it just
because I understand that also the increase of costs from the deeper we get the harder it is to oh we really [ __ ] ourselves even more anyway I was just thinking about that we lost two points per tile that's open right reduce yeah it's not so we lost 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 yeah so we will go down like three points yeah so because we weren't able to and those could have been our own fuck-ups we focused more on trying to get forestation out which when it wasn't asked for No so I mean but I get it like I would even that that's something even a negative for me that's just even that's part of the game where it's like we need to focus on what the [ __ ] environment is asking for us which we if we don't do that surprise surprise I think we we strategize the current game too much off the previous one we're like hey let's get the first one right out there that's our with we Pike I've had like two to three more plants built and not worried about forest right well yeah no one was asking for it like I mean some of them were asking for knowledge and forest towards at least most but not really yeah we did think about oh well forest is really good well it is but only really good when the [ __ ] current environmental situation rains it and this one didn't it for summary at one recycling and then wanted it in Asia and ocean yet so that probably is so looking back it's probably yeah that
probably is a run fault like that's a good time at ik right so worried about what the current of our yeah so um so maybe maybe the with that being said I'm hoping to keep it at nine I still don't like how the end the end of the decade most likely determines if you win or lose but I guess with more experience if you play it more and more you would just look at you know that those are in there so you can think okay any point [ __ ] euros Europe can just open up a coal factory in glocca so we need to plan for that and then if it doesn't happen and you're just not much better off or so still gonna give it a nine I think that's still very very solid score that it doesn't I'm it's not gonna be like a little play this game it's a nine and a half and nine the other thing else cool cool so that's our thoughts on co2 second chance less than what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you