Positano Review - Can You Block Your Opponents View of the Sea?
Transcript
Miniature Market has thousands of board games at discounted prices. Click the direct link below to see all those discounted games. Hello my friends. Today we're going to be in the beautiful Positano, Italy in the cliffs where we're going to be trying to build our places so that we have a great view of the ocean or the sea I guess it is and we're going to be trying to block other people behind us and getting most points. Today we're taking a look at Positano. Uh, this is a beautiful game with tons of of, you know, table presents. Let me show you how it's played. I'll see you on the other side. Now, here's the front two rows of the beach property. You'll notice that there are different colors. Those are the different players, and there's different colored roofs. And these are going to be very important because what you're trying to do is have a view of the ocean. because the main way to gain points in this game is to be able to have your building see out. And you'll notice that there is three different types of roofs. There's a bronze which is basically a cheap building. There is a you know medium price building. And then there are the luxury the gold ones.
Now for every one you can see it's different. This yellow one, both of these can see out because this one is low. You see this one's up too. It blocks the first one on the second the second row here. So this blue tower, only one of them is actually going to score. Not the bottom floor, but this one will. And so these ones all see right out. Some of these are getting blocked. Some of these are getting blocked. And so what happens is you get one point for every bronze built uh floor that can see. So this is two points. You get two points for every silver. So this one's a two points. You get three points for every gold. That's three points. So it's it's it's it's very thematic in that way. Also, by default, you can only build at a level that is the floor. So, this is level one. By default, you can only build up to level one. This one had a special ability allowed to do differently. Level two, level three, level four. So, that's as high as each of those can go. And at the end of the game, you're going to look at which ones can see. Multiply each of those by the types of roof you have. One point for bronze, two for silver, three for gold. That's the main way you're scoring in this game, but you are trying to block others. The other main way to score in this game are gold cards. Three of them are going to be out each game. There's actually a total of 12 cards. There's six cards double-sided. And these going to give you points like the most buildings on the outer columns. Six points for the most, three points for the second most.
Having the most leftover building block. So those are basically buildings that you didn't end up building on top of the the castle there. And then solid tower each individual independent building. So one that's not adjacent to another one. You get two points for each of those. So these two are sort of competitive. This one is not. They're double-sided. So like this one could have been six points for the largest group of contiguous buildings and three points for the second one. So you have these different types of goals. So how do you go about doing this? Each round, everyone is going to simultaneously secretly bid. And what you're bidding for are three different things. A location like second level D or first level D or second level A. It shows you where it is on the map. You're going to be bidding for a certain amount of blocks. Those are the building blocks you're going to be the floors that you're going to be building. This one gets you five. This one gets you two. Some things get you some gelato.
The ones that are less powerful get you gelato. Those are straight points in the game. So, if you took this, you'd get two blocks. You'd get a point at the end. This one gets you three blocks. This one get you three. Or uh in this one, you'd end up having three times at the end how many you actually had uh total at the beginning. So, if I had two blocks, I'd have a total of six if I took this. Um and so there's blocks. The last one is they're all important, but this one's like the biggest point. Tells you, well, am I going to get a level like the bronze, the silver, or the gold? And this allows you to build one. you have to build at least one or and or there's different uh abilities like this. This one allows you to not only build one but also build one on top of something with this is how we break some of those rules plus one of the normal height. So if I'm building on level one and I already have one there, I can put one on top of it because I can go one higher than the normal building. This allows you to go two higher. So like if I'm in the fourth row, the biggest tallest row, you can only do four. You could build up to six on that row with this. So, here you get to build one and you optionally get to place one on top of another building uh too high than regulation height. This one allows you to make a silver building into a silver silver roof into a gold roof. Plus, you get to build a gold roof. So, these are very powerful. And you're bidding on these. Now, everyone has the same set of cards. These are bidding cards. And everyone's going to select one of your cards secretly. I have them showing to you. And then you put it face down. you also get sort of a kicker card that you're going to add a certain amount.
The lower ones and the the the weaker cards tend to have uh you know the gelato for points at the end of the game. So these these have to do with the different rows there like the location, the blocks and the building. So like if I really want a location, I can do this the 70, but I'm going to be probably last for the blocks and or the building and vice versa. And this balances through all of those decisions where one of them is 40 40. But you always put one of these with them. So even if you pick the same card as someone else, you probably will pick a different card here that kind of works as tiebreers. And if it's still tied, there's a number of stars there. So essentially, everyone's picking one of these cards and one of these cards. Once everyone's done, you just flip them over. And then simply you go to the location, you see who has the highest bid, they get first choice, second highest, second choice, and so on and so forth. When that's done, you do the same thing here. So, it's really clever cuz even with just one set of cards like this, I'm at 66, 56, and 10.
And so, I'm usually going to go like first on one of the three things or close to first if I'm playing a four-player game. And so, basically, you do all three of these things in a row, and that's a round. And you do that over a certain amount of rounds. In a four-player game, there's four rounds. You're actually going to build four different buildings. Uh, in a two-player game, you'll be doing six. In a three-player game, you do five rounds. You're going to count up the points as I showed you earlier with all the different buildings depending on the roof and how many can see. You're going to score up all your bonus points and then you're going to score up all the tiles and all the cards that you actually played that had gelato. They're one point a piece. Whoever has the most is the winner. So in the five to six player expansion called the crowded cliff side obviously comes with two more player colors. So we have sort of like a seaf foam orange and the purple. And now there's five levels. It uses the same structure to build it but the first floor now goes on the bottom. It doesn't go on the structure. So now uh you have a fifth floor. And so this one can actually be built up to five high and four high, three high like normal. So there's there's there's higher places now. And of course there's now five slots per row instead of four. Now it comes with six new gold cards. And everything in this expansion has this little uh hex on it to show you that it is the from the expansion. These are double-sided just like before, but now you can see like most buildings in the last two rows. It shows all you know five spots there. And so obviously on these it also shows the five rows for most buildings in the outer column. So this isn't as big a deal as some of the other changes. And so it has this little expansion board for two more players that just kind of sits next to it like that because now you have five and six players. Now for the lot tiles, you'll only use the ones from the expansion.
For the block and the build, you'll use the ones from the base game and you'll shuffle in all the ones from the expansion. So now you see starting tiles for all players up to two through six. Uh there's nine new block tiles and there are nine new build tiles as well. So you're getting them all shuffled in. And again, one of the other bigger changes is there's a variant with four players. If you play four players now, you play everything on this map. And essentially, you're playing for six rounds instead of just the four from the base game. And there's no need to use that expansion board on the right side there. Now, before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I want to let you know that Game Toppers upgrades every game you play, being the one table to rule them all with Game Toppers, leg kits, dining covers, and premium game mats and more. Their 5.0 O Kickstarter is live now and they found a way to deflate prices to prepandemic levels without sacrificing their quality brand.
Now in some cases even by $200 or more, dropping the prices of shipping by as much as 50%, saving another $100 plus. Check out the new Ryan Locket and Amber Sharf mats. Go to gamettoppers LLC.com to learn more. All right, first things first here. Wow, beautiful art and table presence. You want to play a game that people stop as they're walking by and go, "What the heck are you playing?" This is one of those. I mean, you look at this thing set up, you look at all the buildings, you just the scoring just makes sense. It's just so beautiful to look at, and it just it really, really uh brings home what this game's all about. And it really does feel like you're looking at the clips. If you've looked at pictures of Positano or videos like I did at the beginning of this video, it just it looks so cool. And just the mechanisms, they're so simple, but yet they're they could be so crunchy. This is one of those games where you could just play beer and pretzel style, not thinking too much, but just having a good old time for 30 minutes, playing some cards and bidding cards, putting stuff out, and you can play it very casually. But you can also play this game as sort of an advanced gamer, very crunchy, and looking at all the options and looking forward of who's going to pick when and what are they likely to pick and are they going to block me? Do I want that location right now or not? There is so much depth here.
It's great. This is huge on my depth to complexity ratio, uh, which I I talk about often because I love games that have tons of decision space and tons of depth and tons of player interaction, but the rule sets are light and everything is in the decision space and not the this mechanism goes to this mechanism goes to this mechanism just because I wanted to make a big bloated game. This game is beautiful and elegant. And I know that word gets thrown around too often in board gaming, but this definitely is that. I love the bidding mechanism. Very interesting thing here where like you're playing a card secretly and that card is going to be the bid for all three tile types. Your location, how many blocks you're getting, and you know what type of thing building you're going to be able to build and maybe some special abilities to go along with it. And it's so clever that you've got to find the right time with the right card to build the right thing. And it just works so seamlessly.
It's not a slow down auction where everyone's up bidding each other. It's, hey, put your card down, let's go. It moves the game along at a at a a fast clip and but that there it's very thoughtful the way that the cards are balanced and everyone has the same sets of cards. So it's not like anyone has an advantage on any type of thing and it just works so well. It's streamlined but yet it's crunchy and you you're getting one thing and probably giving up another pretty much this entire game. And that's what this game is about is competing goals and what thing is most important to you right now. Uh and I love that they add the little kickers. So, it's like this interesting auction with the little kicker values where you've got the different ones and you know it, do I want to add five points? Do I want to add 12 points to all three things? Uh, it's just really interesting. And also, if you go with the lower values, they get you the little gelatoes, which is just like free points at the end of the game. So, it's like, hey, if you don't really care too much about all three or if you don't feel like, hey, all three of those will be equally good with if I got first or second or third or whatever, then you play one of the lower kickers and that's going to give you some points at the end. Very clever there. Uh, I like that getting first choice. So, you go through each thing, the locations and then the blocks, then the what type of the things you're going to build and then you build. But getting first choice of building means that you place first, which can be in a disadvantage if people are looking ahead. If people are looking at, okay, who's picking first, second, third, fourth in location? Okay, so who's who's getting the blocks? Will you have enough blocks to block me? and then looking ahead and going, "Okay, well, that player is gonna
is is going to build before me." Okay. And now that player might build something depending on what locations are are there, but they have to place first. So, they're at a slightly, you know, a disadvantage even though they get the thing they want because if they're going to go first, they've got to build first, but that's also going to put them at a disadvantage because that means they're probably going to get the lot that they don't want or somebody else is going to get the lot that they really want because the other players are going to get the build first. So, you might be able to get the lot that's in front of somebody or in front of where you think they're going to go and they're going to get to build first not knowing how many things are you going to build. What are you going to take? Are you going to take something that's going to allow you to build up higher? So, it's like, "Oh, great. I get this great thing with a gold building and I'm going to put it on this location that nobody wanted cuz I had to go last in location to be able to build this other thing first with a great gold building. But guess what? Somebody's going to be able to build right in front of me. Oh, and guess what? There's two things this turn that allow people to build higher than regulation height." And so, I get to go first, but it's not always the best thing. And I love that sort of balance of that. I like with the goals. Uh, some of them are very competitive and some of them are not. So, if you want something that's like, hey, whoever does this the best gets extra points or do you want to play the game that's like, hey, two points for X every time you get something. I like that they're double-sided cards and the cards that that the ones on each side don't compete with each other or they don't like they they don't contradict with each other.
Very smart way of doing the goals. And I do like those rules. Those goals can be even more interactive and and and competitive or they can be just more like everyone gets whatever they get. I like being able to push those two things. I typically like the more competitive side of things, but some people might not. So, I got that. I like that those goal cards that they get you score, you know, they score your points. Even if you're getting blocked throughout the game, if you do really good on the goals and you concentrate just like only on the goals and I'm going to get first on all three of these goals and I don't really care how high the rest of my blocks are, you can still win this game. And that's cool. I love the that uh you know, some of those things allow you to use the beyond regulation to block players behind you. So, it's like, "Oh, I get to build two higher than my regulation height, and I'm in uh spot one or level one, and normally I can only build one high, but I'm going to be able to build three high and block whoever's behind me." It's just so clever, and you're constantly trying to fight and build certain spots, and it's just the bidding aspect becomes so interesting because of the little tricks that people can play. Uh, this game has tons of interaction. every single turn that everybody takes affects someone else. And I love it when games do that. Your decision space and what you want to do can completely change depending on what somebody else does.
And I love that. Just this game is just like an internal economy where we're all like just figure out what to do. Uh the game is great even with two players. You would think like this is sort of like an area control game and this and that that it wouldn't be good with two because it's all interaction, but it's it's actually very good with two. It's actually it might even be my my favorite player comp because you actually get the most amount of turns uh with two players. You get to play six uh buildings, you know, six turns. So, two players plays really good. The solo mode actually worked good. I don't typically play a lot of games solo, but I like this game so much, spoiler, that I did play it solo. And it's really interesting because you play for yourself and you play for somebody else and you're trying to make sure that you both have as close a score as possible because the lower of the two scores is your score. And that is really interesting. manipulating the things to make sure that you're building evenly between the two of you. Very interesting. Um, there is an expansion available for five to six players.
That's good for two reasons. Number one, uh, it's it allows more people to play. And even with five to six players, you're still playing at this game less than an hour. You know, if everyone has played before, probably 45 minutes. If you're playing four players or less, it's a 30-minute game. Like, it goes very fast. But it also allows you to play the four player game with a longer variant which I really love because that's going to bring me to my next uh my next things here is my what I didn't like about the game or things that I thought could be improved. I want to I want to stop here and say I love this game. This game is fantastic. In fact, I'm going to spoil this a little bit. I'm going to be coming out with an top five games that I've already played at Origins. This is going to land somewhere pretty darn high on that list because this game is fantastic. Now, that being said, things that I thought could be better with the game. Number one is what I just talked about was four players.
With four players, there's a little bit more less planning you can do because it's like you never know exactly where you're going to go and there's, you know, things like that. But the bigger problem with the four-player game, you only get four rounds. You're basically you're building four towers and that's it. So, it's a little bit less forgiving because if you get blocked on one of your best towers, it really hurts in a four-player game because you only have building four buildings. 25% of your buildings might not score well because your best one got got messed up where like in the two-player game you get six buildings and six to four might not sound like a lot but it is in this game. It really is. So four players I felt like the four player game was a little too short just because you only get to build four things. Um however with the five to six player expansion uh I did get that and I tried that and the four player game goes to six rounds which is the same amount of rounds that you play in a two-player game and it really fixes that for me.
Um, so if you play four player games, try it yourself. Personally, I like the longer game much better. Um, and but the expansion is there if you want to play more players and play the longer four-player game. So, that kind of fixes that issue. Um, the other thing is the cliff side itself needs to be assembled before every single game. Now, I get why they did this. I mean, there's no this this thing's big, right? There's no way. The box would have had to been so much bigger to leave that thing assembled and put all these plastic pieces in this box. It would have been so big it probably would have been not it wouldn't have made any financial sense. So, as I would love to have a box that would fit the cliff side in there assembled, it really only takes a minute to put together. And I could see why they didn't do it because there's so many pieces in this game. It would never fit. The box would have to be huge. Like ridiculously huge. It would be too big.
If it was like that, I would people many people including me would probably be complaining the box is way too big for a game that's this short and this easy to play, right? So, it's a double-edged sword there. I get why they're doing it. Another thing I think would make the game a little bit better for the advanced sort of gamers that are I mentioned that this game has a lot of depth where you can look at who's picking when for for all three and depending on that you might pick a different location. So, if I know that I'm getting the second location, but I also know that I'm getting the first uh you know, or maybe the second building type, gold, silver, maybe I could build two higher than normal. I can look at what order people are drafting in down there and I can look at the state of the board and I can look at the locations are available. I can look how many blocks people have. I can look at the blocks and I can actually math out what I think people are going to do and what I should do. Like, that's what I'm saying. game has it's not humongously like it's not a very complex game but there's a lot of depth if you look for it and with that I kind of wish there were little markers where like hey we flipped over our cards okay lots blocks and building let's just quickly put our markers in order who's first second fourth in each of these to do that way you can just quickly look at the board right next to the board and go okay I'm going to pick first here third here fourth here and then then I can start to strategize because if I'm picking first lots but I'm picking third and fourth the other things I got to see what things what other options are available because that might change what I'm going to do and that's a lot harder when there's no markers or anything like out there I mean if I was really doing I'd just have
everyone write on a little dry erase little tiny little thing there their their their bid put them out there put them in order like like what's in wages and you'd quickly see granted that would add a lot more components but that would actually makes it a lot faster than going wait a minute who's picking their way like and again a lot of people most people probably won't even look at this game that deep and think of all this. But if you want to win, this is how to play the game. Uh, so I would have liked if they just even just four tokens of each color or three tokens of each color to help, you know, when you flip the cards over, let's just put everybody in order so everybody knows who's picking when where would have been a nice little addition. You could just get cubes and do it. It's fine, but it would have been I'm just thinking things that that that would have made this thing better. Um, that's there's uh Whoa, one last thing. Tiebreaker. The tiebreaker system is interesting where you have the cards and there's little dots on there. It would be nice just to know have a play on a player aid what the tiebreaker possibilities would be. Meaning if I hit this and I hit the kicker, I'm using my best card on my best card for building this round. I think that player's going to do it too. Will he still beat me on the tiebreaker? Does he have Does that player have He's pink, I'm blue. Does that player have Will he beat me on the tiebreaker? If so, I'm not going to use this kicker. Again, another little tiny little advanced thing. Uh but that would have helped as well. But overall, those are all sort of nitpicky little things.
This game is fantastic. I would be absolutely floored if this doesn't make my top 10 family games of the year this year. Uh I'll be really surprised even if it doesn't make top five. This game is fantastic. It would not surprise me if this game ends up hanging on to the the best family game of the year for me at the end of the year, but it's a long year. We haven't even gotten a Gen Con or Essen yet. So, it's early in the year, but it is one of the best family games I played in a long time. Positano. And just because of that, it's getting a special induction to my gaming library, which I don't keep many games anymore. It's getting a saxophone serenade. So, here we go.