Tapestry Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
hey folks welcome to another broke amiibo review and today it's tapestry their art of tapestries when this game got announced my god you could not believe the hype that was growing around for this people barely knew anything about it and suddenly it was screaming its name from the rooftops I miss tapestry have you got tapestry I have tapestry in my pocket you wanna play is it was so over height like crazy we're talking more than things like syphon that in the past and to be fair stomer games does have a pretty good track record with their games no not all perfect I must admit you know there are some that I'm not as big of a fan of yeah but there are some that are in my collection and one or two that have been in my top ten for a long time so there are very much a mixed bag with me but when this gone out it's like oh it's a a to our civilization game by stone Marv and everyone just went nuts so naturally I had to jump on this bandwagon now review copies it's not something I tend to see very much from stone Myra so this one was one I went out and bought myself because it's like I got it try this I need to find out exactly whether the hype train is justified here like I do all the time and see if it was worth the money and also worth the time it's got some interesting feedback from people I must admit but like I say we're gonna see what my faults are so tapestry itself to our civilization game although to be more accurate it's more of a tableau builder in a sense it's kind of got a mix of everything lots of little mechanics the idea is is that you play through effectively four rounds of the game where you're leveling up these four different tracks each one representing a type of development for civilizations
and military science technology and exploration now I say rounds but that's kind of been if quotes because the the whole concept of a round is kind of fluid here you don't all do something and then end round and then clean up the idea is is that you keep taking actions that cost resources but once you're done you decide I'm gonna have an income turn and then you go through this step-by-step process of collecting some more resources playing another type of streetcar which is kind of like a special effect that you get for the next round and doing stuff that your Civilization card like you know your player power effectively gives you but you might do your income turn a complete from time to when the opponent does sooner rather than later so your game will end when you've done I believe the or fifth income turn in the game but you might be sitting there for a few turns before the next person actually finishes the game and does their fifth income turn it's very just kind of not necessarily entirely multiplayer solitaire but you are effectively building up your civilization at your own pace compared to everybody else's but of course you have to pay attention to those development tracks to see where everybody is the idea is is that with these resources you are living up on these tracks and each one gives you a special like a power or an action that you can do and the actions are different on every single space so you lever up a middle if you track and this will allow you to put outposts on this global map where you control locations exploration allows you to place these hexagons almost Carcassonne style on the map
itself and build up the land and get some extra bonuses that way the the technology one allows you to get technology cards which level up slowly as the game goes on but you can speed up in other ways and basically it gives you a bonus as it levels up and the science Trek allows you to potentially level up on other tracks with the role of a die but gets you a few other little odds and sods you know as time goes on and sometimes without the bonus so it's kind of like a way of speed leveling other tracks but you don't necessarily know which track again the level now the tracks behave very differently but they work in a similar chrome set they cost different resources to any now high the tiers are and the actions get progressively better and better and you've got to decide whether you're going to do a little bit on each track or more often than not really focus on one particular track and try and maximize it to its finish now once you've done enough actions that you've run out of resources to be able to do more actions that's when you take your income turn and then you rinse and repeat and go through the process again until you've done your fifth income term once everybody has done their fifth income turn then funny enough the one with the most victory points scattered throughout the game and the dengan scoring is the winner of course now as I said this is hard to call a civilization game as much as it says on the box yes you are building up a civilization but this is very different from something like fruity ages or Nations or any other or even just civilization in general where you physically have this like this very distinct civilization that you're building up from the ground this one
feels more like a tableau builder but like I said it's got a little bit of everything the exploration of the map is very much area control the tracks themselves are kind of a typical gyro mechanic level up a track and get better at it you've got resource manager which is typical of a sieve game but then you've got a slight bit of tableau building with the tapestry cards again a special effect that you can get for the round there's just and there's even like a little city building element on this little square map that you have which has blocked off elements but you you place little buildings that you can unlock that give you more income and you if you pass by certain levels of those tracks you unlock these landmark buildings these gorgeous landmark buildings will be under them later and these can cover spaces on your map and it's almost like a barren park style not quite polyomino but you know you're filling up the spaces and trying to complete the squares or complete entire rows and columns it's got a little bit of everything almost like a big like stoma you're a mini game series it's just lots of little things put together to make this one game in terms of the rules themselves they're actually not that complicated there's a little bit of rules referencing here and there and you've got a fair bit of iconography to sift through but once you get to grips with it it doesn't actually take a lot to play the solo mode I'll get onto in more detail later is a little bit more fiddly to get around but for the most part you basically just choose a track to level up pay the cost and do the action and the iconography is rinse repeat on a lot of things there's a very good reference guide to tell you what everything does your first game might go
on a little bit longer as a result but for the most part I found that in during my first game I'd kind of picked it up pretty quickly in terms of oh yeah so I do this and this and now I do that in there and now my income turned right in and do this you know obviously I wasn't necessarily playing it's in the most optimal strategy but I'll certainly got to grips with the game pretty fast now this obviously starts with the easiest thing that no one can deny is a positive in this you know well aside from the fact it's probably overproduced in a sense but my god this is pretty nice this game the map is probably the weekend the board itself can look a little bit bland in a sense the map tiles are not overly detailed in their terrain so it almost looks like a very kind of like old PC game style looking map you know it doesn't look overly good on the table but the bit that is not under produced is all the cards the boards and those buildings pretty much every card and civilization card in that tell us about is linen finished and oh it feels nice in the hand feels nice to hold it you know you don't really need to sleeve these cards even though you can if you want the box will fit them in but frankly I think the cards will keep in good quality for a fair while but the building's oh my god I mean firstly you've got a lot in this box this is just one players worth of pieces and you've got these like so I like almost like plasticy rubber style buildings have been molded into different shapes with lots of other wooden pieces as well you have got the tiles that you have got
these giant light civilization cards with the special effects and there's a lot of them in the box but building go get those buildings out you get a tray of these and these buildings I want in more games could you imagine suburbia if it had filled me like this I mean the new editions really nice perfect could you imagine if it did look at these things things are ridiculous they are amazing and I love them they are so good probably like I said over a produce for what they do because frankly all you do with these buildings is you basically when you get past a certain level on a track you unlock the building if you got there first and you place it on your little square map and that's it it doesn't do anything else for the rest of the game is purely a placeholder you know something that a polyomino tile could have done just as well but instead they give you these and they're so good you're not sleeping with it are you right oh my god I mean the game is not cheap this is going like a 60 to 70 pound game on the retail price not cheap and for what you get in it most of that money is going into the production quality of the buildings I have to say the rest of it is kind of like I would expect this from a cheaper game and you know certainly I don't think it's necessarily going into
development I'm a little bit more on that later but god yeah production quality this thing is sound the insert will hold everything for you cards resource and everything you just put the board on top and then bag up some player pieces and that's it it fits in there nicely in a decent square size box now the game says one to five players it plays fine as a solo mode actually in fact I dare say it's probably better as a solo mode the way it works is that you not only have the old Tom know which this though marketing is kind of famous for the Tom the factory and you also have a shadow Empire the shadow Empire pretty much does nothing apart from level up tracks randomly and you know Mickey buildings if you're not quick enough you're Tom though however scores points for various symbols but is also leveling up the track and you use these two cards paired together kind of like what Gaea project does actually in its solo mode and as you pair them together and you look at various icons and it tells you via reference aid whether like they level up on this particular track or that particular track whether they take an income turn and you go through this deck of cards that's randomly sort of allocated at the start a game and add more cards each round so that their income terms come less frequently the it actually works pretty well and once you've gotten used to the game it's a good way to really try these other civilizations because there's quite a lot I mean there was a fair few in this bag I forget how many of there is but there's double digits where I mean like 12 to 15 I believe all these civilizations each one behaves very differently and solar modes a good way to just churn through them and try them
out of course that's a hit-and-miss affair as well the game says 90 to 120 minutes that is accurate if you are playing I'd say a two-player solo possibly a free player if you know what you're doing a 4 player this is going longer than 2 hours unless you really really what you're doing and play quickly you're easily looking more at two and a half hours with a four player game and it is quite a long affair you know in general I mean most civilization games struggle when they get to lower time links because the quicker the civilization game the more abstracted it has to be and in this case that's definitely no change here and a bit of a negative in my opinion because the most civilization games I want to have a strong theme you know what you're doing this for magic and I feel like I'm part of the civilization this one though the theme is not there you know these tracks I've just got whatever actions on it you know you go one often the technology track and you get a technology and then the next one you get to get a little income building and then the next one you get a tapestry card and then the next one you get like you can scrap the technology cards and draw one it's it's these they're not necessarily in any particular order in terms of how the actions work and the whole city building thing I mean you're basically just placing these building the tiny buildings look weird compared to this monstrosity and you're just putting them up to fill up rows and columns why because reasons you know the maps themselves want to go grass and one's called mountain one's called desert and
there's slightly different areas which are blocked off that you can't put buildings on do they feel like a desert or grass on a mountain nope it's just a little picture at the top that reminds you that's the terrain type otherwise you would not be other tell the civilizations yes yo summit called craftsmen entertainers futurists in that and for some of them they've got player powers that kind of makes sense but then others are like okay whatever and even then as a civilization some of these names are weird I mean the futurists okay that kind of makes sense the craftsman is odd that's not really a civilization that's just more a trade and then there's one called the entertainer's civilization of entertainers how does that work they've got some really bizarre names and just generally as you're playing these tapestry cards that can chop and change from anything you know if you mean tyrannical one year and then suddenly democratic the next and just all these things happening on with leveling up a track and just exploring out this map and going nothing just to get a bonus and having to orientate your tile so it lines up the terrain you know and you for each one it does but you don't have to it's just a lot of these things I'm saying go a long way to saying that this is not a thematic game in the slightest you know you can make jokes about each other civilization and what you're doing but that's you injecting it into the game it's certainly not being drawn from the gameplay itself now the biggest issue I have to tackle is the question of balance and swings this is getting a lot of flack from some people because of what is known as are the swings that this game creates for a two to two and
half hour game this has a lot of luck in it a lot of swings now some of that comes from the dice you roll you conquer a particular territory and you literally roll two dice one of which is good and one of which is victory points and they scale up you ideas is that you pick one of those to have his reward so you can basically have a good which frankly most of the time you don't really care which good tis you know sometimes you've got a little bit of a preference but then you're usually already getting that by some other means or you can get anywhere between like 1 to 7 points well hang on so a die roll gives me potentially five to six more points more than you just because I rolled it on the die and then the science died you know you you level up on the sidetrack and then it lets you roll a green d12 well something to say which track you level up on out of all the four it's random I don't get that you know if I'm leveling up on a science track and I think right guys so I just put all your effort into making me the most a militaristic man ever I demand that you know make me a spear or make me a gun machine gun or say make me powerful and like why would they make you a telescope or a toothbrush yeah that wouldn't make any sense
yeah we were working on this machine gun for you sir but look at this look at this push chair we've made look you can carry a baby in it and everything there's like dude I told you to make me a gun how did you make that for matically it doesn't make sense but also random again you know you could level up on that science crap thing you know I'm gonna boost up on this particular track you roll the die and you don't get and you get like a track that you've barely paid attention to where if somebody else does the exact same thing and gets exactly what they want huge swings the point scoring at the end is all over the shop I mean somebody could be on 90 points somebody could be on 180 somebody might get 300 points it is ridiculous how far apart these scores are close finishes 99% of the time do not happen in this game you usually be able to cool the winner a good halfway through maybe three quarters yeah because you yes you'll level up at different times you know somebody does their income turn before you in sight oh my god they're miles ahead of me on points oh yeah wait I've got to do an income turn yeah then I'll go past it but when somebody gets to the end and they reach a certain point you just know that the next person does their income turn is easily gonna get more points than them but the die rolls are a smaller aspect you know you can mitigate some of them or they're not as painful as they could build oh I think that science dies a bit the cards though and the civilizations there is a reason stone Meyer has recently put out an errata for the civilizations as
balance tweaks they're not balanced I'm sorry I don't care if you have played this game 20 times already and claimed you have got the strategies down these civilizations and tap energy scars are not balanced end of discussion though you can don't even try yeah there are some civilizations in there that get you all these cool bonuses and points every turn for literally just doing what you should be doing anyway and you know I mean oh the craftsman I was looking at this one here you know they're the you get to put a building on here instead of that map well putting them on your map is really good for points anyway unless you absolutely focus on it and even there you to be a particular civilization to get the most out of it so you could put them on here instead and every time you do you get some cool bonus and potentially lots of points well alright that's pretty cool what city entertainers do well each round they get to move on some weird track and get a one time bonus and the bonuses don't really link to each other because if you decide to do something that's technology related you can't do it twice in a row so hang on a minute I get a tiny little bonus every round whereas you the futurists get to start on the first so on the second tier of every track to begin the game with I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul what oh my god and that's one example but yeah the civilizations are just all over the shop hence they have had to release a writer to balance some of them out and I don't think they've managed to do it they released it and they tweaked some of the more powerful ones but then the weaker
ones didn't get changed the entertainer's are still as rubbish as they are if you one is the entertainer's then I would like to know what drug you gave your opponents so that they just did not play optimally enough to beat you because they're that bad a civilization I am sorry they're just four renders they have not won a single game that I have tried with them whether I've played them someone else has played them or I soloed them they just do not win games and tapestry cards this was what I was kind of looking forward to most with the game you know the tapestry goes oh yeah you can have this hand of cards with special abilities and and you'll be able to play these and develop your civilization in a unique way unfortunately it's not what I thought it was going to be I thought you would have this tableau of tapestry cards and you could get like a few of them out or lots of them out and try and think of a euro game is a good example suppose Maracaibo actually I did recently you know you could have a tableau of all these project cards in front of you to try and shape what you're doing I thought you could do a similar thing with this sadly all you do is you can collect as many as you like but you only play one around and the first round you don't actually play one it's just called teaming fire or whatever it is and the fifth one is the end of the game so you play free tapestry cards that's it free you have a deck of cards about you big and you play free cards 3-3-3 ellendale's friend cards ah wasted
opportunity here the cards themselves are okay but the swings on them are ridiculous as well one card might get you for resources live in blinken and I another one might get you a couple of points if an opponent decides he wants to level up on the military in your next turn another one might you know tell you to roll the green die and get no benefit again random you might just roll something really rubbish another one actually makes everybody roll the die and level up on the track so you play a tapestry card and you get something rubbish in your opponent get something they really want you've just benefited the opponent from a tapestry card has been a favorite I the effects are just all over the shop some of those are just clearly better than others and it boggles my mind as to where the development time went with this now I don't mind a little bit of luck in a game you know a luck in the euros fine as long as it's not too much I think this one has too much frankly but the balance on these cars is just crazy I can't understand where this is coming from and I know what some people are gonna say they're gonna think more hang on a bit Luke what about viticulture you love that game so much and safe why do you like those two with the luck they have and not this one well firstly cipes luck is only in the encounter cards and there's usually a good choice you can make cuz you get to choose our free options and for the front and frankly I've seen people go crazy for the encounter card and still lose the game you know grabbing every single encounter
card on the board does not guarantee you a win you know and a lot of the other stuff isn't luck based it's deterministic so I'm fine with the whole like neo stuff in safe viticulture I know what you mean in the first versions and that you know those visitor cards were a bit all over the shop but the advanced ones in the tuscany expansion now give you two choices per card and there's always one of those two choices that's good for you rarely do I ever pick up a card in viticulture and find it's completely useless but you add in those extra packs the was at the River Rhine pack whatever is the URI Rosenberg one I think there was another one that they did you throw in those little site packs the cards and them are very well done very good balance and you know give you easily decent options on every cart so I'd grant you viniculture has a bit of it as well but it has been improved and also a viniculture because I don't tend to play with five or six players is a max to our game in fact usually it's a 90 minute game you know that one is just on that cusp boy the luck factor doesn't bother me as much but fair play I can see that if some of you want to use the viticulture argument I can see exactly where you're coming from but I guess I tell you this has got a lot more than the viticulture and scythe error does from a luck element more than euphoria does and that's rolling dice on the regular basis if you are not a fan of luck in your euros or you fought the likes of viticulture had too much luck in them for your for your enjoyment then you need to stay away from this game because it will drive you up the wall now it sounds like I'm really sliding
off this game and on those aspects I am but there is still some enjoyment to get out of this beyond just the production quality it is smooth as butter once you get going and you know the it is quite cool to try out these different paths you know am I going to do science I can do military am I gonna do your exploration am I gonna do technology the technology cards again not particularly formatic there's a lot of them but they are just very basic get a VP get a resource maybe get a building and the fact you can build them it kind of different times is sort weird I mean somebody can invent the toothbrush and and all of a sudden invent time travel hey that was a bit of a step and then after time travel you invent nails well I literally couldn't invent a nail before I invented time travel how's that work you know you can tell some pretty interesting stories with your civilization here and if you're into that kind of role play aspect of games and I'm into that to an extent then you'll get a bit of a kick out of doing that with what everyone does again production is sound and if you play I ideally want to play this for free players or less not for five the game doesn't take too long and the solo mode is pretty smooth as well once you get the hang of how the that works your first game with your tongue there might be a little bit fiddly as your rules checking exactly what the symbols mean for an automata or a shadow Empire but once you've got one game down you can turn through a solo demo T fast without too much trouble the setup does not take very long either I mean you basically have a couple decks of cards some are laid out the tiles
just go in a bag everybody chooses a sieve takes all their player pieces sets up a little board themselves and you're pretty much ready to go it's not a particularly long set-up time it's not even that drastically on the take down time either so thankfully most of the time you're playing this game is actively in the game but there's still some more negatives with that I mentioned that it's better with less players a lot of that is because this is a fairly multiplayer solitaire game now you can't directly screw each other over at least very rarely I mean you might be able to topple over one Tower every now and again or you might beat someone to the tier of a track so it's not a hundred percent multiplayer solitaire you do have a little bit of tension with other players and you do have to keep an eye like okay I'm going to go get this landmark on technology hang on you're definitely not a bit quick they're up there to beat you to it you know there are aspects like that but for the most part what people are doing with their Tapestry cards or their own little map that they've got to them is kind of their own thing the fact that somebody opposite me is going mad on expiration is not really having much of an impact on me if I'm just going full technology for a say so having more players I don't think adds enough to the game to warrant the extra time length that it does and there certainly can be a bit of downtime in this because your turn might literally just be level up pay to resources and I'll point this little building down done your turn and then the next player takes an income term I bought a five step process okay yes get your civilization bonus now get
your income now score you yellow buildings and I'll score your map how many rows and columns have you done okay now play a tapestry card was it do you know and going through that whole process and then the player after them also takes an income term and you start wanting to flip the table it gets to that point and with income tones going off at different times you could be sat there waiting it there while in a four-player game and in a five player game it is almost unbearable to sit for the amount of downtime it has I mean I will outright refuse to play this five player ever again free player max is what I say for this game four is not worth it five is definitely not worth it two or three though you'll get a pretty decent affair out of it I don't think the game is bad this is not like one of the worst games I've played all year or anything there's still stuff I like in it but for the amount it was getting hyped for what I was hoping the game could achieve for the fact that I like Civilization games you know when they're not super dry and not five hours long more saying I like a decent civilization game I like fruity ages are like Nations there's other ones I like to but this one just didn't meet the mark for me and it hurts more the fact that I'm more disappointed by it than I am hateful of it yeah there are some games where I think there's a good chance I'm not gonna like this and funny enough I don't like it that doesn't really irked me as much as a game that I thought I was gonna really like that just didn't meet the mark it those pros cons but just too bad doesn't it's not
good enough for me so you know I still think that some people are gonna kick a kick out of this though and some people have you know some people are playing this constantly over and over again in there and join it it really comes down to what is your personal opinion on those luck I'm sorry the luck and the swings and the imbalance on some of these cards and that will that bother you or will you just chalk that down to the game not being predictable you know for you to have a different experience every time because it does feel a bit different each time with the civilizations and the cards that you come out there's some similarities with all the tracks and that but you know you could have a very different game exploring one particular civilization compared would say be militaristic with the same civilization and different tapestry cards might affect what you're doing but they're not drastic enough a change you know and the ingham buildings I mean you might get a few of each you might just go mad on one particular type and see what happens there there's a lot of options and all app apps and if somebody said do you want to play a game of tapestry and it was like free players all that I'd probably say yes I'd be happy to but I know that this is not one I'm gonna seek out it's not one that I'm desperate to get played you know it's it's there's a lot I like but those things just perk me a lot and this is the hardest one I can think of to write I don't really know what rating to give it I can't like give it like a really negative value because I would still play this game but I don't want to seek this game out and I have to admit I really don't like the problems that are in this compared to the pros that I do
like it's such a hard one I'm towing to in front between two numbers I think overall I think I'm gonna give this one a six out of ten in total I was thinking about five I really was thinking about five but I do get some entertainment playing this game the solo mode is decent you know I don't mind a bit of luck and swing in the solo mode if I was to keep this game I would probably just play the solo mode but if somebody wants to play it to a free player I'll probably play it but those cons are really bad cons not just for me I'm sure for other people as well and there's just some destroy PSA's that just don't work for me and they are big point like they're big loss of points on the rating for that but I don't think this is boring I don't think this is a like a bad game per se hence I don't really want to pull it into five and don't want to make any lower than five definitely but yeah six is probably the best I can do it even then that was teetering between five and six it's fine it's okay but it's a huge drop from the hype that it was setting itself up to the bar was just set far too high and it doesn't get anywhere near that bar unfortunately so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken people review and regardless of whether you have swung all the way around a 360 in come full circle with
the swings and imbalance at this game as it's still at the end of the day only a game take care then I'll see you on the next video
you