Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wingspan Board Game Review - By Board Of It

Transcript 12:34

hi we're Italian Farrell from bored of it and today we're gonna review wigs burn and we've also brought in expert bird chasers to help us collect some birds now you've probably already heard about wingspan as it was arguably the hottest board game of 2019 and it's also just pretty much won a clean sweep of all game needs and you're golden geek Awards and if you haven't heard a bit already it is a beautifully illustrated game about collecting birds on your planet and doing actions associated with birds and board games speak what this means is that it's an engine building game driven by cards this game is to collect a variety of different birds onto your different habitats and you've got forests grasslands and wetlands and the points in this game are called feathers and the person with the most feathers at the end of the game wins and the way that you collect the points is by playing the birds themselves throughout the game with objective cards by laying eggs with end-of-round bonuses and many more other ways this is a super simple game that can be recommended for board game beginners and the whole family but there's also enough strategy

that advanced gamers won't get bored which is perhaps one of the reasons why this game has become so popular it also comes with a handy starter guide and a special deck for new players which takes them through their first few turns which is great if you're trying to entice family members or friends who aren't into board games to give it a go on your turn you'll take one of only four actions see super simple play a bird game food lay eggs or draw a bird card we personally find the engine burning of this game quite genius in the way that we'll actions link into each other allowing you to create a well balanced system so this is what it will look like at the styles of the game you will get one of each food and five bird cards and then you have two out of these ten Whittle it down to five things so we're going to keep the grub and we're great at capture so we can fly them immediately and in similar vein we're going to take wheat and we can keep any for the second food cost of the bluej and then everything else has to go and now you can see we've

got five things one two three four five so first one we're just going to play one of these birds and we'll play the blue-gray in that capture which costs one crop and you can see the cost and where they're supposed to be played in top left and put them here done then we're gonna gain some food so that this says we can gain one from the bird feeder or if we spend it bird card game two we're just gonna spend one so we take from the bird feeder and put it in our supply then the third action we're going to lay eggs so pretty simple just put that and then put the eggs on the bird don't final action also exceedingly simple draw a card so you just take the card from the deck and put it in your hand and those are all the actions you can take as we just showed when you take your turn put your action cube down but where the game gets really interesting is with these brown piles on the birds because what will happen is you'll take your turns normal gaining food but then if you have Birds of brown powers they will activate in order or birds of white powers wiped away when you play them now for instance in this case we're going to get to get a cherry from the supply this

one that says take dice from the birdfeeder and this final one will let us draw two cards now these bonus powers are what elevate the game for maybe a much more simple game into the euro strategy game that is because you want to optimize your rows and get the most out of your Birds to do while doing actions you'd otherwise already do now when all this is over your key will move here and then when you run out of cubes the round is over then you'll lose one of those cubes and put it on the objective marker so the game takes place over four rounds and for each round you're going to get randomized bonus tile shown here and these give players something to focus on during the round and an opportunity for extra feathers and I also like them because they give new players something to focus on a goal to aim for but I do have to say that these bonus tiles are somewhat redundant and because of the narrowness of the game a lot of players will end up tying for first place second place and then what happens is you divide the point by the number of players and round down this becomes just painful to count out every game because every single objective is going to have players tying and then you start going right well okay so the three players here to yell at that and then you divide it by that number and then you round down ok so then this one all he tied again so then you do the calculation in the other way what do you get for lost

it goes on and on it's painful and what I mean by narrowness is that it's not it's not an asymmetrical game right everyone has an equal opportunity say if the objective is to get Birds and your wetlands aryans an equal opportunity in this game to have the most birds in the wetlands it's very difficult for a player to storm ahead and get that through good engine building and then this means that everyone's going to time and it just makes the whole bonus points bit superfluous and we've found that players who go for first place all the time but they mainly tie those players that don't bother at all those players are going for will only get a very modest points advantage so for players who like pure strategy you should be aware of some amount of randomness in wingspan mainly coming from food and bird card availability and the way you mostly gain food is from the 3d bird feeder and you take the five-day put them in the back and it will now show you what food is available but if we're all being honest with ourselves the game didn't really need a 3d bird feeder but it's quite fun to put together and it's cute I quite liked it to be honest back to the randomness your birth have a specific food cost that you need in order to play them and if that food is in the bird feeder on your turn then you're in luck but if it's not available

on your turn then the game becomes a little bit more difficult for you let's say for instance that on my turn all of the food in the bird feeder matches my bears great but on Farrell's turn the food in the bird feeder doesn't match his Birds then our ability to play a bird card then is is down to the roll of the dice and the luck of the dice and not just good and bad strategy on either of our parts also what can be quite annoying in this game is that the dice in the bird feeder won't be rear old until all the remaining one shows the same face and this makes it difficult sometimes to get the food you need as well however what we do like about this game is that it allows you to use two spare foods you have in place of any one specific food you need so you always do have the ability to play the birds in your hand even if it takes you a little bit longer continuing the same vein you're going to be dealt two objective cards at the start of the game these are worth and gain furthers if you can meet the requirements but here the randomness comes in because you're supposed to be going for specific birds but there's no guarantee that they'll ever come up in gameplay or you over be able to get them and because you're asked to do this at the start it makes it a gamble and it can very often not pay off the game does the gay this however because they give you the percentages of the chance of the birds coming up and this lets you kind of decide and start do I want to go for

high feathers but you know rare birds or do I want to go for the easy one that's only going to give me a few points we would like to say there that we have no big issues with the that we just talked about and we do really really like this game yeah I think that we just wanted to point out people who for pure strategy games where you have to rely on yourself and your own mental acumen that there is an element of randomness in this game and from time to time it could win or lose you the games and maybe that could be a problem for you it's something to think about this is where we do our quickfire review comments so the game has very aesthetically pleasing and calming artwork the simpleness of the actions allows you to explain this to someone very quickly and get them involved the quality of the components is very high it's really a pleasure to kind of play and handle with the dice and the birdfeeder in the eggs returns a quick and play time is short the game has a very intelligent way of linking the actions into each other culminating in a terrific engine builder there's no direct player interaction so you can't purposely brief the other players the only interaction really comes from the bird feeder and the bird cars making it a nice friendly game where you only focus on your own system people who prefer heavier euro strategy games might not necessarily like this

too much due to the things that we just mentioned so the randomness and the lack of player two player interaction yeah I also think that the price point might be an issue because I think it's too expensive and it will turn off the people who would enjoy the game and most eg more casual gamers and people who want to share games with their family comparatively like you can pay $15 10 pounds extra and get scythe which has custom molded plastics and you know all the faction mounts from the big game board and everything and here it's just not comparative for the price they're charging but the quality is very high in this so I guess that's where the price goes but it's just something to think about and I don't care about that because you paid for it the dogs love the birds although not for the same reasons as us we'll just start by saying we 100% recommend this game particularly if you like more casual games or you're looking to share your hobby with family and friends even if you prefer heavier more strategic games definitely still get it there's a quick intelligently designed little game that's great for breaking out as a palate cleanser in between heavier sessions gaming however we will say that whilst we're super glad we have this game and will continue to play it for years to come it's not something that we constantly have the itch to to get out all of the time and we prefer to

play it when it's getting late or we're waiting for the rest of our group to join us and we wouldn't make this game the main event of the session

you

Progress saved