Everstone: Discovering Ignis - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Everstone: Discovering Igni. Now, this was a game that was obviously delivered to me and whenever I opened it up and I took a look at it, I was like, "What is this game?" I have no recollection of ever paying for this game or talking anyone about this game. And as I was going through like my Game Found orders, it was there. So, some some version of me purchased this. And I was like looking it up and I was setting it up and I'm like, "Man, I do not remember anything about why I backed this." Um and usually whenever that happens, it makes me very skeptical because it's like I'm I'm more worried that the game's just not going to be that good or cuz there was nothing in my mind that made me think like that reminded me of getting it.
So, after after playing it and diving into the nitty-gritty, unfortunately, like I don't think this game is bad by any means. Um to me, it it hits that spot of kind of it's it's another game. It's another resource game. Like I was trying to get into the theme and that wasn't really doing much for me. It's like this hybrid worker placement engine building game with some resource management. You have three resources, really. You have different colored gems. Um and you kind of build up an engine by discovering these relics. Every There's a bunch of relics in the game and they're all multi-use and this is like a pretty cool element of the game. Like they have a caravan cost or they have a they have a cost to repair the relics and you can essentially whenever you repair them, you slot them under these four actions. So it kind of has this hybrid Scythe um action selection system where you kind of can do one of four actions and then you go top to bottom and you can really ramp up these actions.
You can get a bunch of really cool combos. You can get caravan upgrades that give you benefits before you even do the action and then you kind of go down and any relics that you have repaired, they have a bottom ability. So then those slot into uh the specific action you know uh uh columns and then you just kind of ramp as you go along. Uh they also have a sell cost that if you choose not to actually keep them to place them in, you can get like a really powerful one-time ability but then it gets discarded as well as anytime you have to discard a relic has a discard cost. So you're always getting something. The interesting element of this game is that you're not trying to get victory points, you're trying to get reputation.
So this has another track that basically first person to 10 reputation ends the game and whoever has the most by equal number of turns wins. And there's a number of ways to get reputation. There's global achievements so you've seen that in Dead Reckoning or you've seen it in Scythe where it's like, "Hey, here are these main objectives that if you complete them, then you'll take an influence token, place it on there and that will get you a reputation." There's also relic cards that whenever you have them slotted underneath a certain column and you do that like this one requires five blue gems to then take one of your influence tokens, place it on there, and it's like boom, now I got a reputation point. Um, there are influence tracks that you can go up that if you go up to the max, you take that track and you you lock it in a spot that gets you a reputation.
Here's kind of where I'm overall at is all of this stuff I have seen before in other games. So, and it all works in those other games. That's why Ever- I'm not like really on Everstone, but to me, having played all those other games, it's like, well, it's kind of another Euro. And I I'm in this position where it's like, well, nothing here is glaringly bad. Everything works, but because it's a bunch of different mechanics from other games, it's like, well, I've seen this before, so nothing is truly exciting for me. And this is not necessarily Everstone's fault or the designer's um or designer, Sam Macdonald. It's not his fault. Uh it's just that I'm in this Euro position where it's like, it has to really wow me. It has to basically be like, this is all 100% unique or just popping off in a way that I vibe with.
And it and it doesn't do that. Um like, whenever you are doing your action, like there's there's thought in everything that you do. Like, whenever even from the very beginning of setup, you have these setup uh relics, these starting relics that you choose to either slot in, and that's going to immediately make one of your four actions better. Uh one you're going to keep, which means you're going to try and repair it. And one you discard as your starting resource. That already has a lot of decision-making in there. Um there's a ton of relics, and some of the actions are really cool. Others are I mean, everything is like relatively useful. And uh And so, whenever you're actually planning, like whenever you're planning on going up on a track or which area you want to go visit to do its special location action, there's thought behind it all. Like, this is a very, very solid Euro game.
Um I'm just kind of like eh. Like, there's something in the game called Leroy's Looking Glass. And here's actually, so here's before I actually talk about these cards, cuz I have them specifically pulled uh to talk about them. You also have personal quests. You have a starting quest. Now, the starting quest is the same for everyone, and I actually kind of was like, that's that's kind of stupid. I I like when everyone's starting quest is a little bit different. But, I guess you have that starting quest to really kick off the the reputation. And you also start with a personal quest, and those are different. Um Like, so you have those, you have caravan upgrades that are really powerful that you can get through a variety of ways.
Uh there's nothing here that's really absolute luck. Um like in like, "Oh man, if I had that ability, like I'd really pop off." It doesn't really have that. I mean, there are there are relics that definitely can swing in someone's favor. Um but, the only luck is honestly uh whenever you do the harvest action. But, even then, the harvest action you might want to do not necessarily to find a relic, but to get the benefits of not finding a relic. Cuz you have these three dice on every single relic card, there are these three numbers. And you roll these dice, and you're trying to get the die value equal to what's on here. So, this is a six, five, and a one. Well, I rolled a five, three, and a and a two. It's like, "Okay. Well, if you have the workshop action, you can actually spend a variety of gems to mitigate and modify those dice as well as the back of the relic deck has a free tool you can use that also might give you a benefit either give you plus one, minus one, or completely flip a die face.
But, when you harvest a relic and you draw the top card, you actually immediately get to either sell it for its sellability or slot it into any one of your workshops. That's really powerful. Or if you don't get it or you choose not to mitigate it, you actually get to look, choose any two dice, add them together, and move up on one of those influence tracks equal to those two dice values. Two to five let you move up blue, six to eight is yellow, nine to 12 is red. And then the remaining die, whichever track you moved up, that's how many gems you get. So, you could choose to do the two and the five just to move up on the blue track and then get five blue uh resources. And then, if you happen to have the uh Thelanish the Thelanish, it's like, oh well great because that was underneath my explorer action or my my harvest action, I can use those five blue now to spend to place an influence and gain a reputation. So, you actually do get uh tons of combos in this game. Um the beginning of the game is kind of slow. I feel like that I actually kind of like the idea of first to 10 reputation will end the game, so it's kind of a race instead of first to have the most victory points or first to get all their influence out on the board or first to get six global achievements or whatever it is. It's first to 10 reputation that will trigger
the end of the game. I like that. Um but the beginning of the game does kind of feel slow. Like you eventually by the end of the game it does start ramping. You you can have a max of six relic actions in one column. And if you are repairing relics in those specific columns, they have to go down into the relic spots of those columns. But if you're harvesting them, you get to pick. So you can really get a a cool synergistic um like relic column cuz you go top to bottom. And you have ways to relocate and stuff like that. I like the fact that the relic or the the caravan uh board has a workshop ability. So that whenever you do it, if there's not a relic there, you actually get the workshop action, which can be super beneficial. Like the one for explore lets you spend a yellow to place an influence token out on the spots.
Um and I like how you can spend or how it influence tokens in those spots give you a location bonus anytime someone goes there. So if someone goes to this spot, it's like, "Oh, well, in this game two people had uh two influence and that mean that they're both going to get blue um resources." Um and what's also interesting is that whenever you go to a location, you do all your stuff, but then the locations actually swap out. There's these outer limit areas that will cycle between these actions. Um so any location action is really good. Like for example, this location um you have to spend six gems of the same color to get a reputation point, but that can't be spammed. Like you can't get this engine where it's like, "Oh, before I even do the exploration action, I get six of the same color. I'm always going to go to that spot."
Uh you can't do that because once you use it, it gets cycled out and there needs to be two more exploration actions before that one comes back. Um now you could build a plan around that, but that is something that you uh you could do, but you can't spam it to ramp the game to an ending. Uh, so I like that. I think that's an interesting element. That's something that's kind of unique. Um, but the game also like it just has there's I I I don't know what the theme is. You're a caravan trying to find relics. That's that's really it. The The relics do have names. They do have unique art. But that's that's pretty pretty much it, but it's a solid euro.
Now, these relics I would almost cuz there's ones that have S's that are your starting resources. Also, there's these ones with a P on the back. I would probably remove the ones with a P because there are cards in here that are called Leroy's Looking Glass. And this depends on if you like like alternate win conditions. So this one is you win the game if you repair all of three of Leroy's relics in the same turn. And they're not that hard to do. Like you need to have six yellow, one red, one blue, and six of any other color, and be able to place two influence. If you do that, so if you happen to harvest them and because if you if you discover them it says keep this relic.
So yeah, it's going to clog up three of your four workshop spots, but there's so many ways to expand your storage for relics that six, 12, 14 14 uh gems is not that difficult to get. So it almost I don't know. I feel like this is I mean yeah, other players would have to let you get this if it's out. If someone sees you grab one of these and there's another one available in the market, someone should automatically just grab that just to either sell it, discard it, or slot it underneath in one of the relic columns because because it is so easy to do.
But there is a chance that someone could be harvesting or drawing relic cards. There's ways to draw relics and could draw into them. And it's like, "Okay, now it's an even bigger race." But there's no player interaction really. Yeah, you can kind of bump spot people from exploration spots, but there's no stealing, there's no none of that. So it's kind of like, "Okay, can you get the 10 reputation before I can get 14 uh resources?" And I almost feel like these were included in the game kind of as a way because 10 reputation still takes some time to actually get. Uh especially these global achievements are kind of uh at least in my experience, they're they're not super easy to do. I mean, yeah, getting three caravan upgrades. Some were more easy than others. One is to have 20 resources. One is to get 10 resources in one turn. And then three of them are having six relics underneath the barter, explore, and uh repair action.
But I feel like trying to get 10 reputation before someone has these three. Uh if they get these three, it almost feels like it's a sure fire way to win. Now, this kind of reminds me of something from Space Base. There's that ship where it's like, I don't remember the specifics on how you trigger that. But it's a it's a do these specific things and win the game. Um it just depends on if your group is that kind if if they like that kind of stuff or if they'd rather win through the normal means of racing for 10 reputation. Uh this will probably be my only negative. Now, in certain games that I've played of this, I've actually enjoyed having this because the game was taking way too long and the actions and combos aren't interesting enough to warrant this game being uh like 2 plus hours.
So, it's kind of like, all right, can someone please get to 10 reputation? And this is a nice kind of way where it's like, all right, hopefully hopefully someone didn't take it so someone could finish that, otherwise it again, it's not bad. Turns are quick. Um but it is kind of multiplayer solitaire. Like, it's like when I go to my barter action, the caravan upgrades can give me a thing, it's going to let me take a resource, draw a relic card, and discard a card. I get the discard bonus. Now, I get to do my barter action. Okay, I'm going to move all the way back to Igni, and then I'm going to buy a relic and slot that somewhere, and then I'm going to get the Igni reward, and then if I have relics underneath, I do all of those. And now that's my turn.
And then in all honesty, there's almost nothing I mean, unless someone's buying a relic that you're also wanting to buy, there's not a whole lot of reason why you can't just kind of already take your turn. Um one shoutout I want to do cuz I don't know if this is a first-time designer. I actually kind of I'm going to look that up real quick. Oh, look, I already have uh BoardGameGeek pulled up. So, Everstone by Sam Macdonald. I think this is his first design. Um so, one shoutout is the insert is actually really good, and on the side of the box, it shows how everything is stored. So, that's uh that's a really good job. And I think this game does have uh like room for expansions. I think like uh the fact that there's already a decent amount of of um explore locations. There's a decent amount of starting relics. There's uh there's some variants in the game that give you different like Agni uh actions.
And I think there's there's I mean there's ways to give your caravan special abilities. They they compacted a decent amount of stuff into this little box. I think that might be one of the reasons why I ended up getting it was it was kind of this stand-alone game. Like it wasn't this expansion or wasn't this grandiose massive campaign game or this bloated Kickstarter game. It was this self-contained Euro. And if this is the first time design, which is what I'm seeing on BoardGameGeek, uh it's a very solid start. Like I really don't have many complaints other than well, I have specific Euros that I like and all the ones that I've seen in this game I've seen in other games and I already have those other games and I like those more.
But I do like the idea of Caravan. Like there's another game about caravans called uh oh man, Almanac. Is that what it was? Almanac's Peak or something like that? Dragon's Road. Is that what it's called? Something like that. It was about caravans. And I like this concept. I just wish this game was maybe a little bit more thematic or but I mean it's a Euro so it doesn't necessarily have to be. Uh yeah, I mean that's that's pretty much it. I'm trying to think of other things that like that it that it does. One thing that I do find a little odd is you have these slots for your influence and there are five spots and each of them hold three. And so anytime you have to place influence uh you take it from a very specific spot and once that spot is empty, like it's basically once you place three three influence, you now have an extra spot to store resources.
That's that's perfectly fine. I actually I I don't mind that specifically, but it's like why why design it this way? Like why have it to where you have to go in a very specific order? Besides the fact that oh, once you've done that enough times, you get a reputation for it. But it says like oh hey, these 15 that you have are limited except not really. Once you have to place resources or place influence to get a reputation like for the relic cards or for completing personal quests, you just take them from somewhere else. Like mainly you take them from explore locations, which is not again not horrible because if you have a lot in one spot, you're the one that's going to get the benefit the most. But then as you start needing them to complete personal quests or global achievements, then you start getting less reward from those spots.
But I don't know, I almost would have rather just had a pool of your 15 influence. The the weird oh, I have to do these three first then do these three then these three then these three and hey, I get a reputation. It is it it doesn't feel all that necessary. Um but it's very easy to place influence. Uh each spot has a limited number of influence that it can hold. So it kind of has a race element, but also those specific location bonuses aren't that amazing. They're really just for more more resources. So it's like if one person goes here, it's like oh, the blue player is going to get three yellow. The burgundy player is going to get one yellow. Um and and that's that. So I would like to see a little bit more interaction like cuz again, there's really not much except I took a relic you might want.
Like there's no nothing. I mean there's bumping kind of. You can't really block anyone, so it is everyone kind of playing their own game. Um but that's that's pretty much that's pretty much it. Like on a scale of 1 to 10, like I know I haven't been like really raving about this game, but I also haven't really been on it. Like I'm going to give Everstone a seven. I think it's a good game. Um I don't think it does anything that's like a wow factor for me to be like run out and get this game, but at the same time I'm also kind of jaded uh on Euros. So, if you this I think this is a really really solid like for a first-time designer, it kind of is a really solid starter to a to a Euro. The rulebook uh is formatted a little bit weird. Um like whenever I was learning this game, I had read that rulebook twice. And whenever I was first playing it, I still had to reference it cuz for some reason it it could have just been me, for some reason just was not clicking. Cuz it kind of gives you a little bit of rules and then it gives you set up or gives you set up gives you a little bit of rules and it goes into the concept of the game and then it goes into more rules.
Um and when you're trying to reference something, like a great example is whenever you have an icon that says place an influence, it's like, "Okay, does that mean place an influence anywhere? Like if I have an ability that lets me place an influence, does that mean where my character is at? Because that's what the workshop action does. Is that the same icon for everywhere else? And what if I can't place an influence there? Do I just lose out on that ability?" It's trying to find very nuanced situations like that are not easy to do, but the information is there. I've definitely seen way worse rulebooks. Um but I also got to give them props for the to the fact that the insert fits everything. And for those of you who are looking for kind of a starting point, not necessarily a gateway game. This is definitely not a gateway game, but kind of a little bit more meat to it than but then not so heavy. Like I kind of put this before like the T series games, like before Board & Dice games. I think this is a very solid um kickoff point. Cuz then once you play this and you play other ones, you might see the inspiration for this one. Um and I think that's a really good thing.
Like I'm not saying, "Oh, wow, this game just has no originality." It has some unique stuff to it. And the fact that you can combo and do different strategies of Caravan to try and get your 10 reputation. There's There is some meat here. I I never felt like I was going through the motions of like, "Wow, this is clearly someone's first time designing." Um like it's it's a good game. So, that is my thought on Everstone: Discovering Igni. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.