Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Old King's Crown Review | This, or ARCS?

Transcript 28:42

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. Today's video I am going to be reviewing The Old King's Crown. This is a very hot game and I assume most of you have heard about this game already. But in case you haven't, this game is an uh a game where you are an heir to a vacant throne. The old king has abandoned it and you're fighting for its crown. You do so by conflict resolution. More on that later, but everyone has asymmetric factions and abilities that you can acquire throughout the game, and there's an element of betting and bluffing to it. This review is going to not only go over my thoughts about this game after a few plays, but also touching on some of the comments from other people based off of comments made on Board Game Geek, as well as some game comparisons. But next, let's talk about some mechanisms that stood out to me when playing this game.

So in this game, the crux of how you gain influence or points is by lane battling. Essentially, you have three different regions, each with two locations of which you are trying to have the highest power during a certain phase, the summer phase of the game. Everyone plays cards or, you know, a single card or many cards depending on the situation to these locations. And depending on different abilities that you have, whoever has essentially whoever has the highest number wins the region. So it's very similar to war in that uh regard. As I mentioned before, you have asymmetric factions. Everyone has and starts off with a similar deck. It's pretty much identical based off of the numbers that are on them and abilities as well. But there are different asymmetric abilities that you can do either just once during the game.

There are additional cards that are specific to your faction that you can acquire. And of course, you have a deck of additional acquired abilities in the form of the kingdom cards of which there are more than 50. I think there's around 60 or so. And you draft them. you bet for them and attach them to your faction, which gives you abilities throughout the game that are different from game to game. Uh, keep in mind that you can steal these from your opponents as well. All of that in addition to the very robust solo mode where you fight an Ottoa bot essentially with its own deck and tableau and different ways that interacts with the game in a very similar way to a player but with some altered rules to make it uh still functional to play either by yourself or you can add it to a multiplayer experience. And you can even play it cooperative cooperatively against the bot to hopefully score more points than it. So before I get into my own thoughts, let's talk about some game comparisons. And the highlighted game that I wanted to compare this to was to Arcs. This is the comparison that initially made me think about and want to try The Old King's Crown because, as you might have seen in past videos, I've really enjoyed Arcs. Both games are deemed chaotic by some or highly

variable. I think both games offer an element of of chance of luck as well as a lot of things going around. A lot of gear is being turned and a lot of playertoplayer interaction both on the table and above it. meaning, you know, you're in The Old King's Crown, you're betting and bluffing against other people, trying to play the crowd essentially to get ahead. And Arcs has that as well. But like I said, mechanically, Arcs is a game based off of tricktaking mechanisms as well as being a space 4X style theme. And that's different than The Old King's Crown. you have more of a lane battling war type of game with the Old King's Crown. And you know, going further into my experiences, and I guess this kind of bridges the gap into my initial thoughts as well, Arcs, I think, was made to or meant to be more of a narrative-driven game, right? It does utilize a lot of interesting mechanisms in terms of like how the game is played, how and and familiar mechanisms as well. It's not as opaque as perhaps some of other Cold Waries games, right? But it's I feel like especially if you add some of the expansion material, especially the really large blighted Reach, I believe is the expansion title where you can play a campaign arc of arcs. It really

is trying to tell a story mostly through mechanisms but also through you know everything that's being added and the old king's crown is I I will say very uh has a a heavy narrative base if you look closely at the art and I I mean kudos to the designer Pablo Clark for doing the art and [clears throat] making as you know the the theme as rich as possible and as integrated as it is to the game. Um maybe not in terms of the actual mechanisms all the time, but especially with how different factions try to play towards their strengths and and and things like that. And so I I do think highly of the the theme there, but I think it's a little bit more narrative driven in arcs versus more mechanical in the Old King's Crown. Uh, the Old King's Crown does have, I feel, more of an element of you playing the other players with the betting and bluffing and trying to keep track of what cards have been played from other factions since everyone starts with the same number of cards. If you know some of the other factions of other players in the game pretty well, then you can kind of know what their main strategy might be and try to get ahead of that in in a sense.

In arcs, especially if you play it at the base game, doesn't have that initial asymmetry setup. That is usually just acquired through, [clears throat] you know, maintaining cards and and what have you throughout the game. Uh, and so in that in in terms of that, I feel like Arcs is less asymmetric than The Old King's Crown at the get-go. But that once again is just the base game. I think you can really start with asymmetric abilities with expansion material in arcs. And aside from arcs, I would say mechanically you could also potentially compare this to another coldworldly game, which is Routt, which is highly asymmetric in terms of how each faction plays. Everyone has their own separate rules. So it's more asymmetric than the Old King Crown is. I feel like for the most part, 90 95% of the game is very much the same of all the factions in the Old King's Crown.

It's just some slight manipulations and and variances in the cards that you can acquire for your own faction uh versus Route, which everyone plays a essentially a different game on the same map. But then you also have a very light game in Challengers. So, this was brought up to me when I was playing with my friend Jacob. he, you know, who is, I guess, the de facto co-host of this video, but he he thought of this game as being compared to challengers mechanically because it's essentially the same thing where you're playing war against another player. In that game, it's one v one. Uh, in the old king's crown, it could be more than that, but you know, whoever has the highest number wins, right? And it all comes down to the different factors that allow you to bump that that number up or to take numbers away from yourself or from other people during the battle. And that happens too in challengers, but albeit at a very low complexity level. Uh and in addition to that, if you aren't familiar with challengers, it's kind of like a tournament style deck building game where you start off with an initial deck. you play against someone and and as you play against uh many people, so it's kind of like a party game, right?

You you go against other players in kind of like a Red Robin style uh tournament, but all the while in between these battles, you're upgrading your deck out of a variation of options and subdecks to add from. And so you can customize your deck in different ways and kind of go down different avenues of play every time you do so. But each clash is very quick. It takes It's like an auto battle auto battler which doesn't take very much time to go through. But I thought it was an interesting comparison to I mean the core of both games I feel like are the same. You're just comparing whoever has the highest number in each clash. And for the most part that is essentially how you get the most points in both games.

Now let's get into the peer review and what other people think based off of comments. conglomerated from Board Game Geek. So, starting with the more positive critiques of this game. First of all, it's a very rich and atmospheric experience, right? If you're looking at this, and I imagine, and all of my plays have been on on tabletop simulator, but I can imagine if you're looking at this in person on the on the table, the cards in your hand, the artwork is very vibrant and striking, and it really does play a huge role in integrating yourself into the game. So, I I I I will say that I am a huge fan of that and even felt that virtually. Uh it is a very chaotic slash you know very interactive type of game. Uh it's been compared to like a knife fight in a phone booth where things are very tight in terms of who may win you know certain clashes uh and who eventually therefore you know gets ahead in points as the game goes on.

It's a game that could make or break in the first round or two of the game and those who do not have enough influence or points throughout or and don't have a really a way to make up the cards or the uh you know acquire the different side I guess quests of this game. For example, you have these councils that you can send your cards to to gain certain benefits throughout the game. the kingdom cards that I mentioned before, if you snag the right ones, those will very positively help your game, whereas someone else who does not have them can really lose out. And so, it's a positive for a lot of people because that's the kind of tight and cutthroat interaction they like. Uh, but also jumping to the negatives, it might feel a little too chaotic for people who enjoy a more long-term strategic experience. It's very much a tactical game. And so a lot of people who are used to more plan out strategic type of experiences, especially those games and preferences of games that are solely on the table, maybe even multiplayer solitire that don't have a lot of above table mechanisms like betting and bluffing won't perhaps mesh well with this game.

And so those who do enjoy the tactical nature of this game and the timing of events and even the potential opportunities of bluffing someone else would really enjoy this game. You've got uh you know all the mind games with hidden info but also the above the table info as well in terms of what other people factions are. you know, you you do have a lot of ability to play this game at a high skill ceiling based off of your prior knowledge and repetitious play of this game, right? And it's never boring to, you know, a lot of people say that this game is in a constant flux of the ups and downs, not only during the clashes, but before and after with with the kingdom cards and with the the things that you can do with the councils and everything after the main event and clash during the summer phase.

Everything is changing and and people really enjoy that. But, you know, in in terms of more negative critiques, in addition to this game feeling a little too chaotic for more strategic players, a lot of people, it kind of came down to this this dichotomy dichomous uh phrasing where it's like it's too complex for casual play, too shallow for heavy gamers, it's too long for what it delivers, right? So, um, you know, this game, I guess to explain what I, as I was reading these comments, a lot of people felt like you were doing a lot of calculations and predictions and setting up for what essentially was a 5-second flip and resolve in the summer phase as you are resolving these clashes. And so and the aftermath as well tended to lend itself to like you know a a lot of things that were interesting to do but didn't really equate to points that were given later on. That's you know for you know the negative critiques were kind of hedging towards that that sentiment that it was you know just a little too complex for such a small payoff essentially.

um too little control and agency, right? It's too chaotic and uh too much essentially too much randomness in in terms of that. Uh that could be applied to the solo bot as well. I will mention since I solo plays were a part of my experience with this game. You could you randomly flip over the betting chip for example for the kingdom cards and so the randomness of that could really throw you off. it often times it it does flip over to a number that is higher than any of the cards that you would able be able to bet with. And so the randomness in that uh because you do have the opportunity to steal some of those cards, you might never be able to do that because those numbers are higher than the cards, the base cards that you have in your own deck. You'd have to acquire other cards or other abilities to be able to steal them. Uh and so there is that element of of randomness from the bot. You do have the randomness of its own deck in terms of what uh you know cards they're going to be playing to each region, how strong they may be and you know to just to give you an example of a game I I played with with Jacob. It everything was just going against me luckwise, right? I was having a hard time just [clears throat] being able to get the kingdom cards that I needed to put together a good strategy.

I was trying to steal a lot of cards to gain points. I had the Briggins something uh something about Briggins is was the kingdom's card. I thought it was really cool, but I you know the the bot just kept getting high betting chips and so I wasn't able to steal from him or from it. And you know that strategy fell off pretty quickly, right? As well as the cards that were flipping over often the bot winning by one or two points in in region clashes. And so yeah, so there there is an element of luck. And so if you are in this to to experience that kind of luck, some people thought that it was a little too long for that kind of experience, it's fine if it's in a more condensed and shorter time period, but not in a long and complex and uh rulesheavy game such as this.

So ultimately, what did I think? And kind of dovetailing off of those comments from Board Game Geek, I think I share a lot of those both of sentiments, both positive and negative. Overall, I gave this game a 7.8 out of 10. Now, first, you know, I I deeply and tremendously respect this game, the time and effort that went into the art as well as the mechanisms involved. And so, I fully support and and understand why this game is very popular. and very highly rated. But going in terms of what is important to me in a board game review, the rules overhead was middling. You know, I thought it was somewhat of a challenge, you know, to learn. It's albeit perhaps not a game that I typically would play, but it's not the most difficult game to to learn either.

I think it can be pretty straightforward, especially if you play around and kind of go through the different phases and experience it that way. The play length can be long. Uh if you play the full five rounds, it could feel pretty long. Uh I would for example played a four you and you can shorten it to a four round experience and that took about 2 hours or so with a longer explanation as as I was playing it with others. Uh and so take that for as you will. it it could really be a three-hour experience easily in in a multiplayer experience with the standard uh version of the game. You can go longer as well, but but yeah, it could it could be about 3 hours and so, you know, know what you're signing up for essentially. Uh strategy, I feel like you can approach this game strategically. It's harder to do so than in other more static and set euros, but you have your own abilities that you can try to pursue with your faction. And then based off of the kingdom cards that you acquire, especially in the early rounds of the game, hopefully that you acquire, you can base a strategy off of that. And it's just navigating those turnbyturn decisions, which I think are really good in this game. There obviously is an element of luck to a lot of what is happening but if you are playing against other people it's you you know vying against other other folks and trying to predict what they might want to do as

well. You do have the the aspect of the herald that you can kind of uh alert the other players of what you what region you want to try to win but of course you don't have to win that. You can use that as a bluffing technique. And so, uh, yeah, so there are a lot of turnbyturn tactical decisions that you need to make in this game. And if you do like that, it's, you know, pretty pretty intense. Um, the thematic integration is great. As I've mentioned before, the variability with all the kingdom cards, if you play with the expansion, which I I didn't, but I I know what's included, it does offer a lot of different things and modules and different ways to approach and play this game, which are fantastic. uh the mechanisms are pretty straightforward. And so this is kind of where it starts to die down a little bit for me because essentially what you're doing is you're playing war, right? And I I think I'm on the camp of this game being a very high cognitive preloading experience in the the first, you know, parts of each round with the spring phase and planning out where you want to go, thinking about what you want to try to accomplish after the main event as well in the autumn phase and then having all of that kind of come down to just a card flip and, you know, a quick tally to see who wins, right? I I never got that experience of having this game feel feel very dramatic, right? It kind of

all led to a very quick card flip and that was it, right? It it was never as impactful for me. Now, I think that and that really impacted my fun experience with this game. Some of that might be due to luck. Uh you not not having very lucky experiences against other players or the bot. It it it did leave somewhat of a sour taste in my mouth afterwards. Uh not really thinking or and and feeling actually that I did the best that I could, but ultimately things just didn't fall my way and I didn't have as much agency to react or to do anything that I would do differently. Right? And this is where I get back into my my comparison. But but before that, I do that. Um I I fully think that this game is the solo mode is very well thought through. You can really make this game harder as you play against the bot, and I really like how it integrates the multiplayer experience. So five out of five for that. The interaction, of course, is very much player versus player driven, which I really enjoy. and and therefore I think the skill mastery and and skill ceiling of this game is high as well. But the the issue that I see this game fitting for me in my personal circumstances is that I'm more involved in gaming groups and gaming by myself where I don't have the opportunity to really play the same game over and over again unless it's in a digital format like Board Game Arena.

And so this game really benefits those who approach this at a more lifestyle type of experience. I think those who are willing to play, you know, all the different factions multiple times and play even play with the same group, if not, you know, play with other people who have the same skill level and experience with the game. I think that's where this game will really shine. the mechanisms aren't as not I won't say not as interesting but the mechanisms aren't as complex as it might seem. I think I think the rules complexity is a little above how the game actually plays and it's it is pretty straightforward which leaves a lot of room for player interaction and mind games, right?

But I feel like to reach that point, you do need to either have a dedicated group to play this with with the same people or have this in a like online format where you can really play this game over and over again and kind of get that experience just playing the game itself and trying to predict what is happening based off of what's on the table rather than trying to play other players. So it even in the you know handful of plays that I had I wouldn't be able to reach that experience level with just those limited plays. So, now getting back into my comparison with Arcs, if if I were to compare this game or have this game in front of me, the Old King's Crown, as well as ARCs, what would I play? Right?

I I would be happy to play the Old King's Crown, but I think more often than not, I would choose Arcs because I can play Arcs, the base game, with pretty much anyone and teach them the rules, and everyone kind of starts off in the same the same level, right? you have the opportunity to be beat down by luck. You know, if you don't have a good hand, then you might not have a good round and that could potentially negative negatively affect you throughout the whole game. But what I feel like in arcs is that you start the round fresh. You know, you start every, you know, round with a fresh hand of cards. You always have an opportunity, I feel like, to be an agent and to choose which direction you want to go. You could pursue your main strategy by, you know, potentially having the right cards to, you know, seize the uh seize the initiative or to seize the um the trophies that you want to win. But if you don't, you can I feel like you can approach and have a second option that is viable and a lot of people can come back from, you know, if if you have a terrible hand in the beginning round or two, you could have some good hands and I think it does average out and you can have a shot. I I guess what I'm trying to say is that I feel like the feeling of helplessness in terms of what other people are doing as well as what the

game luck factor is handing out to you. I felt more helpless in the old king's crown than I did in arcs. I felt like and and potentially the same result would have always been the same in arcs, right? Depending on the hands that I've gotten in my games past, but I always felt like I had an option. I felt like I could pursue something and still be competitive. Whereas I never felt that way in the king's old king's crown. I felt like unless things were just going my way and the right kingdom cards were coming out for me and the the right plays were being made by other people, they were going after things that I didn't need to go after and it was just working out perfectly well. those, you know, unless that was happening, then I was just kind of at the whims of of this game. And there was no amount of player interaction or bluffing that could uh steer my game otherwise. And I think that is not going to be true with multiple plays and dedicated plays with the same group because I think if you everyone elevates at the same time and really experiences this game at that level, that's when the onion layers start to unravel, right? And you really get to the core of this game, which I think is where this game is rated right now. I think it's justly rated uh at at a very high level. But for me, it's just going to be a little too uh luck driven,

a little bit too much for too little payoff is is kind of the feeling that I get. And and the lack of the circumstances to play this game with a dedicated group, I think, lend itself to me not wanting to approach this game more than some others. If you were to put this game, the old king's crown, in front of challengers, I think I I probably would play the old king's crown. But I sometimes some nights I think I would be very tempted just to play challengers because I would still get that same experience and it probably would be more fun I think playing that game because there's not a lot of rules and not a lot of phases to kind of get walled into. You don't have to wait around for too much analysis on your part or others as well to kind of you know do every single little phase that this game provides. But you can play challengers and just have a fun forward type of experience, right? And uh I think some nights I would rather play that. But some nights where I am mentally prepared to experience this game and just kind of see what happens, then I would do so. But then I could also play arcs and have that same experience too in a way where I feel like I do have more agency in terms of what I try to accomplish.

And so, so yeah, so I I do like arcs more than the old King's Crown, but overall, it's still a very interesting game. It checks off a lot of the same boxes that I would like in and enjoy in a game, but unfortunately, I think it's just a little short of the mark for what I would term a game that I would really want to uh sink my teeth into, unfortunately. But those are my thoughts on The Old King's Crown. Let me know what you think. And uh yeah, a lot of people will probably think I'm wrong, so just let me know if if that's the case. That's totally fine. Thank you for watching, and I hope you schedule an appointment with me real soon. Take care.

Progress saved