Innovation Review
Transcript
welcome to john gets games episode three today we're going to talk about innovation this is a civilization themed card game that uses simple rules to mask a surprising amount of complexity i'm going to go over the rules and then i'll do my review all right so how do we play innovation this game is split up into 10 different ages we start with pre-history we go around to the information age we've got nine standard achievements over there and five special achievements over here we have a player reference sheet with a bunch of quick rules on it a location for our scored cards and a location for our achieved cards so every card has this layout in the game where we have the value of the age on the back of the card as well as in the top right we have a name for the card and then four different icon locations one of these icons is always a hexagon and its location can vary as you can see from this card right here this hexagonal icon has no in-game effect it's more thematic so every card has three legitimate icons on them there are six different types of icons in this game right now i'm showing castles crowns leaves some light bulbs some of them show up early game some of them show up late game kind of shows the progression through time castles for instance die off by about this part of the game lastly we have text on the cards this is called dogma effects and i'll explain those in just a minute so on our turn we're going to take two actions and they are from four options the first of these options is drawing this is simple we look at the highest age value of our top cards in our player
area we draw a card to that value so in this instance we would just draw a seven and we put it over here into our hand as a universal rule in this game if you ever try to execute a card that does not exist so draw or score a card like a seven then you go to the next value so in this case if you want to draw seven you would draw an eight if there were no more sevens all right the second action that you can do is you can meld a card from your hand in this case you take a card from your hand and you place it out in front of you this is how you get cards down i put this here as a new pile because i currently have no purple cards if for instance i had wanted to place this yellow card instead it would have had to cover up refrigeration which i don't really want to do at the moment so we place railroad down there no further costs and that's how we get cards down the third action in this game is where the meat of this game comes into play all the complexity every card in this game is unique and every card in this game has dogma effects on them so to execute a dogma effect for an action you look at one of your top cards and you do all the text on that card for your action i'm going to explain some of the important dogma effects now the first one is i demand so this has a little leaf icon then it says i demand you return half of the cards in your hand this means everyone who has less leaves in their display as i do is gonna lose half their hand i have two so anyone with zero or one leaves is going to lose half of that hand the second important part of dogma is this is the way you can score cards
so down here this one happens to say you may score a card from your hand so i look over here and i see a two three and seven seven is a higher number so i'm going to slide the seven over here i now have seven points in my score pile this is the only way to get cards into your score pile the third important part of dogma is sharing of non-demand actions so this does not say i demand down here they are two separate for one action you execute both of them but you do them in order and now everyone who has the same amount of leaves as i do or more gets to do that scoring card action so i haven't actually done this yet it's still in my hand and we go to the person to our left and we go all the way around and people can also do that so if someone has three leaves then they can also score a card from their hand they get to do it first everyone who does this however gives me a bonus free draw action so i would get to draw another seven because they took part in that action so they get to weigh the cost of scoring that card versus giving me extra stuff in my hand so let's just go ahead and score that pretend like no one else could do that the last important dogma action is splaying cards so if we look over here this green card says you may splay your green or blue cards left the important bits here are the color and the direction so for instance i could execute this dogma action and i splay my cards in the left direction i've now revealed more icons so this on future turns or perhaps i did
this before i do the demand i now have more leaves so my demand is more powerful or less people can jump in and score with me so this is a really important way to get more icons into your tableau early game you splay left mid game you start splaying right which has the possibility depending on where these hexagonal icons are to show even more icons and late game you could display up which shows just a ton of icons all right so the that's everything to do with dogma that i think is important enough for this right now the fourth different action you can do is achievements so we talked about these ones up here firstly these special achievements over here have specific conditions on them the moment you meet that condition you take the achievement it's a free action you know it doesn't cost you an action you slide it down here and then you have that achievement in order to take these standard achievements you need to spend an action so if you look over here we have circles with numbers in the middle of them this number correlates to five times the value of that age so for instance if i wanted to achieve pre-history it has a five down here this is the score that you have to have in order to take it so you have to have the score value of that and you have to have a top card that is of equal to or higher value of the age i'm trying to achieve so i could take pre-history and put it into my achievement area in this instance i would now have two achievements you don't lose you don't spend your score you just have to prove that you have it and now no one else can score
pre-history okay so let's talk about how we win this game the first way to win is in a two-player game to be the first person to six achievements in a three and four player game it's less achievements to get to that and you just win immediately if you have that many the second way to win is if somebody the game ends if somebody tries to draw or execute a value 10 obviously there are no 11's the game ends immediately now the person with the highest score value in their score pile is going to win the third way that you can win is a couple of the cards in this 10 stack have a special winning condition for instance we have artificial intelligence over here and this specifically says that if someone activates this dogma and robotics and software are top cards then the person with the lowest score wins so there are just special win conditions in here that can have the game end in goofy odd ways but usually people win from getting the most achievements all right i'm going to jump over and talk about my position on this game all right so my review of innovation is going to start with the things i like and shift into issues i have with the game and the first thing that i like about this game is that despite feeling quite abstract at times it really pulls a thematic vibe out of these cards you know we have this experimentation card which says draw and mail to five these are basic mechanics of the game but it feels like you're experimenting you don't know what you're gonna get it's a bit of a risk it could cover up something you really want or something that you didn't want so you're experimenting and it feels like an experiment we have other cards
like fission which essentially nuke everyone back to the stone age in a big apocalypse all score piles hands and boards just get wiped away and just whatever cards were left and you just start from scratch essentially and the game's gonna end relatively soon because most of the cards are out of the game but it feels like you've just been nukem to oblivion and really the only person who's going to do this is the one who has the most achievements uh and then we got this one i mentioned earlier you know if you have robotics software and artificial intelligence out you start this robot apocalypse essentially that wipes out all the best civilizations and the person with the lowest score wins because they were the ones who were just under the radar of the robots it just feels very thematic and very cool uh despite just working within the constructs of this uh of this relatively abstract feeling game the next thing i really like about this game is just i love games with multiple use cards where the whole game is encompassed in cards and you can use these cards in different ways you can play them some cards let you put cards underneath other cards so that you can then splay out the icons you need just i really like having all of a game encapsulated inside a card with lots of different stuff going on and this game has that uh like crazy uh one definite thing that comes across in this game is balanced through overpowered combos there are so many cards in this game that feel just crazy overpowered i mean you might
look at this and say this game's going to suck there's a card that kills everything but that isn't the case there's a card it seems like every one of these ages has a couple cards that the first time you play you're like that can't be balanced this game is that's crazy but you just you make different combos of your cards and over time you find within a game and within multiple plays you'll find it really does all balance out with just this overpowered thing working against that overpowered thing i mean there's just huge swings where someone could just steal someone's entire score pile and put it into their hand or put their entire hand into their score pile and just huge swings that can happen in this game and that's definitely part of the fun as long as you know about that going in uh next up there's a little bit of engine building in this game like some cards will play off other cards in your tableau like for instance earlier in the rules i said you know you might have wanted to splay these out so that you show more leaves to make this card more powerful you definitely get some cars are just better solo they don't really work with others but many card kind of combinations work very well together to give you a really cool lead and you'll find you might spend two turns being like you know execute this and then that and then your opponent does something and you do the exact same thing again and they get exasperated because you're getting so much score and then their whole goal is going to be to break your engine somehow by stealing your card or just scoring your card or destroying or something just trying to get in the spokes of different people's engines it's really cool i really enjoy that that mild engine building that happens in your tableau uh the last thing i want to talk about as far as the stuff i really like about
this game is the play time you know for a game that can feel very chaotic with crazy cards that swap things around and push things stuff around there's it usually takes between i'd say 10 to 30 minutes for a two-player game uh the fastest game i ever played was about eight minutes where we got two out here and then somebody drew a card that let him draw a four and then let them drew uh seven and then the other person copied it boom we were just like we were already in age ten after like six turns it was crazy but i've also had some games go as long as 40 minutes in a two player game some of them can drag on a little bit especially early when you don't know the card text quite as well but i like the playing time it doesn't overstay its welcome considering you can have some crazy combinations happen that you have you have a plan you have a plan and then suddenly your plan is gone because something kooky came out but then next turn you could come out with something kooky as well it's really cool i really enjoy the fact that it doesn't last too long uh one potential issue that people well people have definitely had with this game when i'm playing it in the past is how text heavy these cards can be you know if you look at this card right here i mean that's just a lot of text and going through the rules overview you probably noticed that most cards have a lot of text like it's rare when they just have a couple things on there and so the first few times you're playing this game turns can take a while just because you have this hand of cards and you're like hold on i need to read this card now i need to read this card now i need to read this card wait i need to go back and read this card because i think these cards might work well together no they don't okay i'm going to read this card so the first few games you play the
turns might feel overly long and that has definitely turned some of my friends off for me i have now played this game 23 times i give a general feel of what cards are where and when they come out i see a card i know what it does for the most part and and i i really like the way it all interacts but it's gonna be very very text heavy and some people just that just puts them off they play one game and they're like i don't want to play this again because i just don't want to spend the whole time feeling like i'm reading a book uh the next issue that i've had people run into with this game is the icon counting so late game you have all these cards splayed in various different ways and you have to keep counting up like okay i have uh i have eight crowns and you have uh seven crowns okay we're good and next turn you're like well i i've i have eight crowns still okay yes i do and then oh crap you have nine crowns wait let me count that again okay uh let me count one more time you know it can be it can definitely take a little bit of time just counting up all these icons there's six different types of icons although at any given point usually only about five of them are in play because castles get taken over by something else but i've seen on board game geek people can get like things you print out and they have little you can put little meeples on it to show you exactly where each person is that might help things out a little bit but it can be definitely a little overwhelming having six different icon types trying to keep track of who has what when because it can be very important with these demands to defend yourself it could just it's been a complaint that i've had with some of the people i played with that they just it's a little bit too much to take into account especially considering all the
texts they're also reading this first time that they're playing the game now as far as my concerns with this game those two things i've gotten over i love this game that it's amazing i've played it 23 times obviously i hope to keep playing it for a long time in the future the only issue i have with this game is that it is a two player game in my opinion the box says two to four players i've played it with three twice and it was just bad and the reason it was bad is because multiply that text complication with the icon counting with more than just one person when you have that one person you can kind of remember okay i'm dominating on crowns i'm doing good and you just and also what they have their texts on their cards that are in front of them over there you need to know what those say because that could be a demand or it can be a crazy combo and you're going to play against that if you imagine having this person over here and this person over here they both have five big splayed stacks of stuff it just it's a brain burner and it it becomes unfun it's just not it's just too much going on to analyze and one-to-one is brilliant it's amazing you go back and forth it shifts and and also the game only takes like i said ten minutes to half an hour versus you start getting three people in this game could easily shift to an hour and suddenly people start playing uh not having fun don't even get me started with like a four player game i mean you're just your brain falls out of your head you have so many icons you're trying to keep track of there is a two on two player variant but still it's just too many icons
too much specific text that's all unique it just does not work two player is the way to play this game two player is brilliant two players one of my favorite games ever three and four players make this just crap so that's a really important thing to keep in mind and as long as you're okay with it going in that you are looking at a brilliant tight potentially crazy cool comboy kind of uh card game that's fine just ignore the three and four players thanks for watching my review please let me know if you have any questions comments or suggestions on how i could do this better and i'll see you guys on the next one