Unfathomable: From the Abyss - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Works of Luck. And Kevin and I are doing a discussion over Unfathomable from the Abyss, the expansion to Unfathomable. And we'll probably talk about more Unfathomable um because while you have played Battle Star Galactic, I don't think you had played Unfathomable at that time, which is basically the same game with a rethe. Um but with the expansion, I was finally able to get that played. And man, this game is so good. I really like Unfathomable a lot. Um, also Battlestar Galactica, but this scene does a little bit more for me just because I've never seen the Battlestar Galactica show. Um, and I'm a huge Lovecraft fan. His works. I love the person like his morals and what he stood for. Uh, no. So, this game whenever they announced it, it was like, okay, is it basically going to be the same game? and it pretty much is uh rethemed, but whenever we have had played it uh again, I was just reminded of what a solid solid hidden trader um cooperative game.
Um but because I have done a discussion over Unfathomable, Devon, what do you think of Unfathomable? Oh man, hey, I enjoyed the Battlestar Galactic variant, not knowing anything about Battlestar Galactica. I just know there's people that or there's creatures that can look identical to people and take their places. Yep. And hey, what a perfect scenario for a traitor game. I know, right? So, I mean, I enjoyed that one. It was great. It to me, it's kind of like the quintessential betrayal game. Um cuz I don't remember Betrayal House on Hillary well. That was like the other one that I don't remember it very well. Yeah. Well, that one is everyone it's cooperative until a certain point where the the haunt starts and someone Yeah. like, "Oh, activate." Yeah, you're you were in that room with that item, so it's you. Gotcha. Okay, that's right.
But yeah, it's great. I mean, very straightforward. I mean, for most part, it's simple gameplay. Sort of the the subtleties uh therein that are I mean, the really the meat and potatoes of it all. Mhm. Um you know, there's the the test after every turn where everyone has to play certain cards or taint it with incorrect cards. Right. So, you're either trying to build yourself up to be prepared for these challenges or build yourself up to be prepared for those challenges to [ __ ] it up. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz the the core gameplay is is again very straightforward cuz there's certain locations on the on the ship that you can activate that kind of like you said, always end up preparing you for the mythos phase. uh where this is where a lot of the game and a lot of the the seeding of betrayal or um maybe like ways to try and give yourself some good graces cuz the entire the entire game you're giving out loyalty cards, but the way that they've done that in this game is one of my favorite mechanisms in a hidden trader game where it's like, okay, everyone has their loyalty card.
there's five of us, so there's, you know, a majority of human cards, but there's a certain number of hybrid cards. But we don't know from the get-go if those hybrid cards were dealt out because there's still loyalty cards left. And until they're halfway through the game, it's like you're then you don't know if there's ever a trader. Like you could be like sewing discourse, which is what I tend to do. whether or not I'm the traitor. It's like I always like to start throwing out accusations, which doesn't help me in any way because everyone's like, "Well, you're the one talking the most, so it has to be you." And it's like, "Yeah, but this game's boring if everyone's just like, it's obviously sad. It says every time, by the way." Uh, it does tend to be that way. Uh, but I love that fact. I love the fact that it's like, okay, if there wasn't a trader then, there is for sure now. So, who is it? And cuz if there's no trader at the beginning of the game, you're going to end up moving a lot quicker on your because everyone's working together. And then boom, now all of a sudden those new loyalty cards are out and now the traders have to really start ramping up their like the the failures of these Mythos cards, but they can't do it in an obvious way because then they just get thrown in the brrig and it's like, "All right, put them in there. Get in the brrig." Um, but the game has so much going against you anyway because some of these cards are uh are very difficult. Like they have a high threshold value. Monsters. Let's see here. The different, you
know, resource losses from mthos. Yeah. Or just from regularly advancing the uh the ship. I mean, yeah. I just I mean you think that the curse or whatever the the spell the cleansing ritual um is just a [ __ ] threat. Yeah. As it is a benefit. Yeah. If you're swarmed with monsters, it's like, "Okay, let's just get rid of all of them." And then you can It's like, "But I need to go outside to save some people, right?" Yeah. You get out there and you're damaged or there's passengers on the ship that get killed from it. That's how we [ __ ] lost. That just it just happened to be seen. Oh, look. There's Oh, look all these passengers in the water. All of a sudden, everyone's in the water and it's like, "Oh." And the the ritual's like one step away from the nuke and it's like, "Oh, guess guess what the traitors are going to do?" Yeah. Cuz I happen to have the character that whenever they reveal themselves, it's like, "Oh, immediately defeat a passenger in the in the pile." And then it's like, "Oh, now it's my turn. I'm going to go to the chapel. I have a lore card." Boom. Then it just boom. Just just they're just obliterated. And I think it was literally the perfect amount of souls. It was. Um and cuz at first I thought I was like whenever the first passenger was flipped it was an X.
I was like, "Oh no." But cuz you can never be too sure cuz I obviously I knew it was me, but I had no idea who else was the traitor. And I'm like, "Okay, I'm pretty sure it's not Devon." Um and I'm like, "Could it be Allan?" just because but he's maybe he's just like playing the game and he's like I don't really know how to be a trader but I'm I'm just playing the game and I don't know I think that that makes a lot of fun. I also love the fact if you reveal yourself as a trader, you hand out your other loyalty card. And if you have the the luck or the unlucky part of having the second hybrid, you could be like, "And welcome to the team." Yeah. Or you hand out um a uh a human card and then now people could just not trust that person. So discourse it it is honestly I mean it's a long game like it it eats away like uh like two to three hours not even that probably three hours it was a long one like I think on the box it says it says two to four um I'd say this game usually runs pretty pretty long but I don't know it's engaging the entire time and and I think that that is a telltale sign of a good game is if you're not Like, jeez, how long? Like, I wonder if we've been playing. Like, when is this over? Like, you're engaged until the game is over. Yeah. Yeah. No, the mythos and everyone having to participate or not participate. I mean, sure, you have no cards, but it's like, okay, you're still so invested, then you have to, you
know, know what's going on and kind of count the number of cards. Okay, how many negatives do we get? And did it succeed? Did it fail? Yeah. And I mean with the with the fact of the chaos deck of having two of every card and it's like okay two cuz like there were multiple times where I threw in the incorrect card but there were still always two like there were two negatives against the mythos check and it's likeoo without like okay cuz once there was more than two it's like okay someone sabotaged it right so we know there's a traitor right but whenever it's exactly two you still you're like man was that was that did someone put that in or was it the chaos deck? Um or you could be on the trader side and like not contribute and hope that it just naturally fails, but then the chaos deck puts in the right amount and it's like damn it. That happened multiple times, too, where it was just enough to hit the threshold whenever the fail attempt would have been really bad. And it's like, okay, I need this to fail, but I don't really want to show my hand too much. Maybe the chaos deck will help me out. And it doesn't. It's like, oh, okay, cool. It was just the right cards that got it up to that threshold.
Um it's it's just such an awesome game. So whenever they announce an expansion, which Fantasy Flight is known to not really do anymore, they if it's not Marvel Champions or Arkham Horror the Card Game, they don't really support their games. Yeah. Uh so from the Abyss expansion and we can go over kind of the modules that it throws in and see what you what you think. Uh we'll go over the simple one, the bless cards. which are Oh, so they weren't even in the game before, huh? No, the bless Yeah, the blue the blue blessing cards are basically just a new resource, a new type of card that you can get that is purely a positive. Where are they? And you have to have ways to actually draw them. Yeah, they're Oh, sorry. Boons, not blessings. So, they have values, you know, one to six just like the rest of them. Um, ingenuity.
You can discard this card for an ability as if it were any skill type. Um, Providence. The next time you would lose one or more resources this turn, lose one fewer resource. Uh, but the values on them are always positive towards whatever skill check, regardless of the check. So, what do you think of the booms? Oh, I mean, I realized they weren't part of the core game. Yeah. Yep. They are not. None of the all the only uh cards cards of the core game are the five the five skill checks. Your your typical I mean but you also have the traitor cards or the treachery. Yeah. The corruption cards which are just strictly negatives. Yes. So you know they're kind of their antithesis. The boon cards. Yes. Um I like them. I like them as an addition because again if you have the corruption cards it only makes sense. you have goon cards that um luckily the only people that can draw corruption cards are revealed traders unless you have other ways through events that make them which is another way that caused a lot of problems is because some of the new methos cards were like hey throw in four treachery cards into the deck and then you look at the chaos deck and it's like ah this is all treachery um it's all treachery always was but right yeah you mean it's treachery it always was the the uh the boon cards are kind of a nice way where it's like, okay, players are going to, you know, be prompted to draw them and that's going to be very beneficial um regardless of honestly who gets it. Uh because they
might still be helpful to the hybrids if they're if they can play them correctly. Uh so the boom cards I think were a nice a very nice addition. The other one that was actually relatively a big one are the allies. What do you think of the allies? The allies. So those were like the soldier and the cook. We didn't use them too much. Someone used the soldier like first thing which was kind of cool. Yeah. But it's like their action efficiency wasn't awesome. Yeah. They're kind of I mean they're neat. I know. So essentially what were they? They were a benefit if you if you like rescued a passenger maybe. Um the they was just prompted like you started with some out on the game like on the board but like it was just hey if if an event caused more to come out. Uh I think the reason why the allies can be good is because they're not an action so you can go into their spot use them before it doesn't count as one or two actions. Oh I didn't realize they were an action. Um yeah so they I think I actually still have them.
Are they in here? No. Where are you? Where are you? And I'm so sorry. There they are. Yeah. So, because none of them say action on top. I I mean, maybe some of them do, but like uh conspiracy theorist draw one boon card and one treachery card and then they wander. Like they roll and they start moving around. Um security officer has another way for you to throw someone into the brig. Soldier, defeat one deep one in any space. Ruffian attacks one monster or revealed traitor in any ship's face, add one to the die result. So, but none of them say action on it. So, there's just something if you if they're in your space, you can just use them. Okay. For their ability, it's not too bad, man. No, again, it's just one extra thing out uh that might help or hurt uh whoever is activating them. Okay. Uh but you're not flooded with them. They're not just like all out on the map. Uh which I did enjoy.
there's only a few out any given time and sometimes there's none at all. So the the allies, they're there. I didn't really think that they were, you know, amazing extra content. Yeah, pretty much. But the other big thing were the um the horrors, which are these three, the shog, the uh tentacles, the grasping tentacles, and then the drown spirit. What do you think of the horrors? Um, I mean they added a little more variety from the I mean Mother Hydra and Father Deon. Yeah. Daddy Don. Yeah. And their spawning abilities. Just an extra extra bit of monsters that can spawn with a few different effects. I mean, the tentacle will usually grab somebody or spawn a passenger and immediately grab them in the water. Y spirit seem to kind of cut through a little faster.
Explodes. Uh, yeah. The spirit kind of uh started damaging people. Um, what was their big thing? They they damage as soon as they come in and then they Oh, they remove spells from the game. So, that was kind of their big thing. And then the Shog Goth uh did the same thing for items. But the main thing about the horrors was the fact that they couldn't outright be defeated. Like, you couldn't just go and and kill them. You if you succeeded, you could only push them back. So, if they're in an interior space, you have to keep pushing them back and then spend uh skill cards to push them back even further. And the only way to remove them from the board is by either casting the spell. I want you to put yourself on a boat right now. Visualize you're on a boat. You're in a tight corridor that's coming at you. Are you pushing that back? Yeah. Yeah. You know, I think I think it's just a matter of using using my my uh influence. Yeah. Did you whip out your godkilling shotgun? Yeah, exactly. Um, no. I am so obviously dead.
Uh, because I killed myself as soon as one deep one crawled on the ship. Uh, I would Yeah, there's I don't know what you do about Yeah. this thing. So, the horrors are are neat because again, they're they don't constantly activate. That's what makes this game, you know, not overwhelming is that Mother Hydra and Father Deeon and the deep ones on top of the horrors, they're not const. It's not like, oh, and determine they're all activating. It's based off the Mythos card that's like, oh, this time it's the deep ones. And then you can quickly, this game does a fantastic job of having player aids that you can just look at and be like, okay, step by step, here's what the deep ones are doing. Mhm. Um, but then they, if you leave them unchecked, then they become a problem, right? And then if they destroy what, six locations, then it's game over. Yep. Ship sinks. Uh, so I thought the horrors were were a very nice touch because Mother Hydra, if they're not doing anything, then it's kind of like, okay. So they had a little extra pressure. Um, and they also stop you from activating spots, you know, while you're there. And they can damage you and being damaged because I think at one time when you and Chris, you know, sped up the boiler room both it you damaged the boiler room which sent both of you to sick bay. And it's not, you know, gamebreaking, but being sent to sick bay cuz whenever your entire economy is based off the cards in your hand and you only get to draw one at the start of your turn, you can't help out anyone.
Um, and you can't really do anything. uh because a lot of cards have you or a lot of locations have you get rid of cards. So the horrors were a uh a very nice touch. Um and that kind of goes hand in hand with the horror icon of that extra deck that kind of had another track that were generally bad um whenever they went off. And that's pretty much it. Yeah, that's pretty much what the expansion added. I mean, new cards, new characters. Level nine yards there. Yeah. More items, more characters, more methos cards. Actually, 72 Bethos cards. More. Pretty more.
Yeah. And And then it I mean it added, we didn't do this um but they added Prelude cards, which we can take a look at um now. So, they are an option. There are optional cards that uh does variable setup uh which they've introduced in Elder Horror which was a way to kind of be like oh here's how this game is going to be unique playbased game but our prelude card was different. Um so I'm trying to remember how those uh prelude cards were introduced. Oh, maybe it is in the back because again we didn't do them. But during setup, uh, shuffle the day, twilight, and night cards separately.
Then you draw a day card, which could be variable conditions. Advance the travel t the travel track two spaces. This does not cause components in water spaces to move. Hey, that's a that's a solid, you know, day one. And then we have a twilight preparation. Each player draws three SC skill cards from their skill set. And then you have nighttime, which could be boarding party. Spawn one deep one in deck spaces three and one deep one in deck space 4. Move each passenger in those spaces to the closest water space. So add a little bit more variety to the to the start of the game. Could be a nice touch. So So yeah, I mean I think it's a solid expansion. Yeah. I mean, what more could you ask? I mean, a few new gameplay components, right? Mostly every uh what's it?
Every function within the game is expanded on. Yeah. So, more of everything. Yeah. Great. So, if you already like Unfathable, then it's going to be more. And what's also nice is whenever we were playing with the expansion, that was the first time we had played with it, and I was like, I'm not really going to like look too much into it when things pop up. And by the time like the first things that happened like the the horror track or the way the horrors work, it was super easy to be like, "Oh, okay. Now I understand how these work." Oh, yeah. Fate track. I guess that was another one. That's the fate track. It was a small track up here based off the skull symbols. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um Yeah. That goes with the horrors cuz that's usually what spawned them in. Gotcha. Which was a new symbol that added to the Mythos deck and it's like there's only like four of them, you know. Yeah. There's not that many. It basically just uh brings in like either brings in horrors or has them activate on top of uh so cuz that was yeah the new icon which added to the methos deck. So yeah like I really do I think the from the abyss expansion is a must expansion to get only if you play unfathomable every day you know. Uh but I don't know.
I really I probably wouldn't play Unfathomable without it. Yeah. Like I know. If you want a board game, you have to have all of it. It's the law. You can't do without. I mean, know it exists. You have to purchase it cuz I mean, what are you going to do? Save your money? Yeah, we don't do that here. That's stupid. So, yeah. I mean, cuz there's nothing that it added that I was like, I don't really like that. I mean, I really like everything that it did. Uh, so from here on out, I would play with the from the Abyss expansion. Um, so yeah, that's it. You got any negatives? anything about Unfathable that or the expansion that you didn't like? Uh let's see specific thing that I didn't like. Nothing particular. I mean nothing was too swingy, right? I mean essentially any like fail. I mean I mean our failure was kind of pre-ordained unfortunately the last game we played.
There was nothing we could have done the way that that that came out. It just happened to spawn close to four. I mean on top of your ability. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, but it just a bunch of people spawn. We went from like five to zero. Yeah. On on ser on passengers and it's just like there was jack [ __ ] we could have done about that. So that's I mean that is a good point. Like there's there's not a lot of agency. It it's like perfect storm of they all came out and I don't even really remember how they all came out. They just did. I mean I mean I think it was a mthos effect. It was the song of the deep or whatever and it caused a whole bunch of them to spawn like cuz they're jumping into the water. That's right. And then we were like one point away from the cast. Yeah. And it it's like I will say that it's not like uh oh we lost. It was probably a lot of decisions over the course of the 3 to four hours. Yeah. I mean I I'm not saying that and that's probably how any of these games is going to end. Yeah. In a in a in a betrayal uh victory. Yeah. U is that there's going to be a resource that's middling to weak and a series of lucky events or unlucky events, however you want to take it, whichever side you're on. Yeah. Will occur. Yeah, cuz it it Yeah, it was literally okay. They all spawn and then the character I had was the doctor that had the the reveal ability to kill a passenger, which could have been nothing. But then it was also my turn and I could nothing stops me from going to the chapel and boom casting the spell and we we flip them.
Um so that can occur. I mean it wasn't two feel bads for me cuz I mean I don't know it's these kind of games is just fun. Yeah. Um cuz yeah it was like mostly food was what was worked on. That is true. Food was like whittleled down. It's like tactical. You guys were like seem like like food was the place to target. Yes. Yes, cuz it dependably would go down just with time and just anything you could do to weaken it further. Yes. Yeah. I mean, but at that same point, you guys were at 12. It was You were exactly at Yeah, we were getting close. So, it was one more pass. Um, so if it wasn't my turn, Well, actually, it was also bad luck because it was me as a hybrid and then the very next player was also a hybrid. Yeah. Um, so but the other thing throughout the entire game is no one besides me was being super accusatory.
Um, and of course as the hybrid it's like I want to show Chaos as much as possible, but if no one else is really trying to figure out who it is like the brrig went untouched. Mhm. like which was the first game I played where not were m you know right or wrong like no one went to the brick and it's like throw someone in there which the brick can be a shitty place if you're not the traitor because if you're trying to break out it's a skill check that everyone gets to contribute to so if they don't want you out you're kind of just there not getting to play um but it's like if you really think it's it's a player, you throw them in the brrig and it's like, let's see how this goes. If we start succeeding all of our methos checks, sorry buddy, you're staying in there. Um, but then you can reveal yourself as a trader and then it's your own skill check to break out and and so on so forth. But that whenever this and this kind of game wants people to like the the player um interaction and if everyone's playing it kind of like okay it's my turn your turn. Well then I feel like that actually lead makes it easier for the hybrids to win because it's like okay yeah I mean no one's suspecting me so I guess I'll just keep screwing things up.
uh and the game over because this game is not necessarily a war of attrition for the humans. If the game goes on way too long, your resources are going to run out. There's very few and far between opportunities to gain resources and if you do gain them, it's usually at a cost. Mhm. So, it's like you're you're wanting to ramp up the u the travel track as much as possible because also puts pressure on the hybrids, right? the faster you're moving, the less time they have to fail it. Uh, so they either have to reveal themselves early, which obviously shows their hand. Uh, so I mean that's I mean this is to me all that is a positive to the game. No, but yeah. No, I can I can definitely see if you're 3 hours in. It's just like and everyone lost. Yeah. going from five to zero on souls uh where it feels like you have no control is that could be extremely frustrating.
Um but yeah, so on a scale of 1 to 10, Devin, what are you giving Unfathomable? I'm giving Unfathomable Solid Trader Game. Uh like I mean it's I mean it's the same game with like a different coding from the Battlestar Galactica. That's true. It is. It is the same game. Well, to be fair, you can buy this. Yes. Oh, you can't buy the Battle Star Galactic anyway. If you can buy the base game for like $300. Oh god. So, that's fair. And if you're looking for expansions and good for them for ramping up the IP that or the the brainchild. Um, yeah. Solid. Easily a nine. I'm like, do I want to go higher? H I'm trying to think. With an experience group, it'd be pretty solid. like where you move a little faster. Do you know what's interesting about that? I'm glad you brought that up because I was the only person that had played Unfathomable. You of course played Battlestar Galactica, but we had So, not counting that, even though you knew the bones of the game.
Um, we had we had a fiveplayer game and it was three new people and I felt like it went it went super smooth. Yeah. Like I don't think there was ever really an instance where it's kind of like, man, they're really not getting it. Now, that could have also been just because I happen to be the trader. It's like, wow, the most experienced person got it. But no, it there was just something about the way this game works just seems to just be intuitive. It makes sense. In a five player game where four people, three are brand new to the game and it feels like everyone had played it before. That was impressive to me. I'm still going to say a nine. Nine. That's like a solid game. Wouldn't recommend with with the expansion as well. Yeah. Yeah. Um I a few more moving parts. I didn't feel like they it leaned it any way. U maybe actually helped balance it possibly. Maybe. Yeah. I think and what's kind of neat what the expansion does is it gives players more to do because the the boat locations really aren't all that exciting. It's oh look at the top two waypoint decks or move the casting track up. Yeah. Gain an item, get a few more resources. Yeah.
Draw items. But cuz the game again is based off player agency or player interaction and these mythos cards uh cuz that's where a lot of the the cards are coming into play. But the expansion gave more to do. It gave more uh horrors to deal with. It gave more um uh allies to deal with. Uh so while also adding more cards. And what's also kind of neat, they added uh these these um personal crisis cards. So in the base game, it was everyone who was playing had their own personal uh trauma methos uh card in their in the deck. Okay. Uh but what's and so maybe you drew yours cuz if you if we drew a character that wasn't in the game, you just discard and drew another one. Oh, but now everyone has their personal crisis in front of them. And if you draw the personal or their own mythos card in front of them, if you draw a personal crisis, now it comes up. And I like that. I think that adds a little bit more flavor to your character. Um where if you happen to be the one to draw that, you're going to have your own meltdown. Yeah. Based off who you are.
Uh but yeah, like I thought the the expansion was I was a little worried that it was going to really bog the game down, but having everyone at the table again, three for sure people who had never played the system and and the expansion on top of that and it felt like this just seamlessly merged into that. Uh that's that's amazing. Um, I I know I'm definitely at a nine on the base game. I think I'm going to go 10 with the expansion. I really There was nothing in the expansion that I was like, hm, that kind of sucks. Like the only one that we were kind of like, oh, we didn't really use them was the allies. And maybe maybe it was just, you know, bad allies at at the given time.
Some of them could come out. Maybe the soldier would should have been used more. Or if the soldier pops out whenever there's a bunch of deep ones, you're just like you run to him, kill that guy. Um, and like you said, it just adds more more characters. There's a ton more characters. Streamlines it. Makes the uh player aids a little bit better. Uh, the player aids are fantastic where it's like you rarely have to look like every time a monster activates, it's all here. You're very rarely looking through the rule book. Mhm. Um, yeah, it's it's amazing. So, I I really liked and I was going to say, yeah, it's long. That was the only thing that kind of was like, h, should it be a 10? Cuz it's 3 4 hours. Mhm. But if you look if you look back and it's like, okay, that was 4 hours. And not one of us was like, is it over? you know, cuz I' we definitely played games where it's like this is way out saying it's Yeah, we had one of those. And that wasn't this game.
It was It was awesome. So, yeah, I think I think the expansion is is great. Uh but not a must. You don't need it, Mhm. but you're going to want it. So, yeah. Um do you have anything else? No. Solid recommend. Well, that is our thoughts on Unfathomable and from the Abyss expansion. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is to stream. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on.
Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.