Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Gateway Games! - Sommelier Suggestions with Alex!

Transcript 24:40

stop me if this sounds like you you started getting into board games during the pandemic you really enjoy going over to your friends for game night but every time you walk into a Target or your local game store to get something for yourself you get super overwhelmed well don't worry this is totally normal and it's the main reason why I wanted to talk about Gateway games today these are games that are easy to get into but that each highlight a key board game mechanic so when you play them and you love them you'll have so many new board games to choose from in that category so anyways if you want to know 10 of my favorite Gateway games that are perfect to start a collection with then might I suggest hi I'm Alex from M suggested game a channel devoted to helping you find your perfect board game today like I mentioned before we'll be talking about my top 10 Gateway Games in my opinion there are two key characteristics for a board game to be considered a Gateway game first it needs to have a relatively low barrier to entry so that new players aren't intimidated before they even start playing the game that means no rulebook novels and no 45-minute setup guides especially if you're trying to hit that sweet spot of 60 minutes or less the second characteristic is that these Gateway Games have to teach you some new board game mechanic that will help you discover your own personal preferences down the road for example When someone tells me they like playing Katan I always ask which part do you like the random resource generation of the hexes do you like the route building of trying to get the longest road or maybe you like the direct player interaction of trading a brick for a sheep being able

to Define what you like about a game will help you find the perfect game for you and keep you from having to waste time and money on Duds and trust me this advice comes from someone who has played many many Duds anyways because of these two criteria I broke my list down into 10 Gateway games for the top 10 board game mechanics on Board Game Geek right now according to this awesome website called BG manual.com it scrapes info off of BGG to compile comprehensive lists about mechanics and it can even help you find games that you might be missing in your collection this video isn't sponsored or anything I just thought it was really cool and I'll make sure to throw the link down there in the description so you can check it out for yourself and while you're down there don't forget to hit subscribe and that little bell button so you can get notified when I post new content anyways let's get into it will one of these 10 Gateway Games be the perfect game for you let's find out shall we all right according to BG manual.com the number one board game mechanic in the BGG top 100 is hand management so we're going to talk about that one first hand management is all about games with cards that reward players for playing these cards in a certain sequence or in a group or something like that it includes games that use multi-use cards and it also includes card shedding games and things like that I think a good example is Scout right that's a game that's been pretty popular lately in that game the cards in your hand present some really interesting decisions do you keep them the way that you were dealt do you flip them over to take the other side how do you sequence these cards to get them out of your hand quickly without rearranging them that's what hand management is all about it's about managing ing your hand in the best way

possible to win Scout is a great example right but I think the Gateway game that I'm going to recommend is maybe actually one that inspired Scout and it's definitely an OG in this category it is one of uve rosenberg's finest games in my opinion it's bananza Bonanza is a goofy looking Bean farming game for 2 to seven players and even though it's been around since 1997 I still think it's a perfect combination of clever hand management mechanics and a simple rule set which make it an ideal Gateway game in Bonanza you have to plant beans from your hand into the two fields in front of you which in theory seems pretty simple could it really be that simple but the main caveat that really brings on the tension is that you can't rearrange your hand which means that the order in which you draw beans is also the order in which you have to play them this one simple rule totally turns the game on its head because now you've got to figure out how to get cards out of your hand that you don't want so that you can take an optimal planting action at the beginning of each of your turns and what's the best way to get these Rogue beans out of your hand well you got a wheel and deal of course you can only really adjust your hand by trading cards away which gives everyone an incentive to sort of pedal their wees around the table and even to make suboptimal deals in order to help them in the long run in Bonanza you really have to make the decision do you want to keep the beans you have and plant them for points or do you want to rely on the open market to trade your beans at the risk of helping out your opponents at the end of the day your hand of beans is everything and the way that you manage it will be the difference between winning and losing so if you're looking for the perfect Gateway game to get you

excited about the most popular board game mechanic on boardgamegeek.com then might I suggest Bonanza number two on the list of top board game mechanics is variable player Powers this is a mechanic that grants different abilities and or paths to Victory to each of the players in the game generally I really enjoy this mechanic but it can be a tricky one to teach because it often requires multiple rule sets for different types of characters take a game like root for example great game great example of asymmetric player powers and lots of variability but if you're playing with four players you have to make sure to clarify the specific rule changes for each individual faction which can take a lot of time especially for new players on the other end of the spectrum you could have a game like pandemic for example where everyone technically has a different role but they often don't feel different enough or balanced enough to really give the game that thematic flavor so with that in mind the game that I chose as a Gateway into variable player powers Falls somewhere in between those two examples it's unmatched unmatched is actually a series of asymmetric skirmish games mostly designed for two players but it can be played in team mode up to four players the game itself is quite simple you'll choose a combination of two actions each turn either maneuvering scheming or attacking and you'll go back and forth until one of you runs out of Health the really cool part about this game though and why I think this is the perfect Gateway into variable player Powers is that they've introduced so many amazing characters into this game's universe and each one's deck of action is both uniquely different and intensely thematic maybe you'll want to play as

the T-Rex from Jurassic Park and recklessly charge around the board chomping at anything that moves or maybe you'd rather try the cerebral William Shakespeare and try to combo your cards together to make lines of I Amic pentameter for big bonuses no matter what your play style there's a character out there for you and even though each deck has some deeply thematic elements in it the core premise and the rules of the game remain the same which I think is fantastic so if you're looking for a great Gateway game that allows you to try new powers and new strategies without requiring you to read a rulebook novel each time then might I suggest

unmatched all right the third most popular mechanic on Board Game Geek is solo games and I think this one's kind of interesting because is it a mechanic is it a solo mode is it a solo only game it's tomato tomato we won't even worry about that I think solo games and solo modes are kind of having a moment right now and there's some really interesting scenario based ones out there like final girl and some great deduction style ones too like suspects which I'm a big fan of but I'm going to be quite honest with you I don't play a ton of solo games personally frankly when I'm playing solo I'm usually playing a solo mode of a heavier game that I'm just trying to understand better but with that being said there has been one particular solo game that I've been really enjoying lately that I think is perfect for this category it's tranquility tranquility is a chill meditative number placement game that technically plays up to five players but that I think really shines in the solo mode in the game you'll be playing a number card from your hand each turn and placing it somewhere on the grid in front of you but the twist is that all of the cards placed on the grid have to be an ascending numerical order oh and one more thing every time you place a card adjacent to another card you have to discard the difference between those two numbers as cards from your hand this means you have to make some really tough decisions especially early on because if you get rid of a number that you desperately need down the line then sorry you're out of luck if you run out of cars to play then you're toast but if you can fill out the entire grid successfully then you win in my my opinion Tranquility is the perfect Gateway into solo games because it's exactly what a solo game should be it presents a challenging puzzle that despite your best efforts you might not solve every time and it keeps the rules

super simple so you can pick it up today and start playing it in 5 to 10 minutes plus it looks great on the table so if you're intrigued by the idea of solo games and you're looking for something quick fun and surprisingly challenging to test the waters with then might I suggest Tranquility all right the next mechanic that we're going to talk about is variable setup this mechanic means that the game starts in a different state every time you play it which usually means changes to the map or to the starting resources or the market or something like that it's a pretty broad one but I really like this mechanic because it generally seems to improve the replayability of a game and I prefer games that present new options every time that I play now there are a number of games that this category covers including storytelling games like Destinies or forgotten Waters both of which I love but for Gateway game I wanted to choose something that uses variable setup to affect strategy and challenge level but that doesn't change the core premise and objectives of the game so that's why I'm going with in my opinion what is a modern classic it's Cascadia Cascadia is an ecosystem building tile placement game for 1 to four players that I think is a perfect Gateway game for many different mechanics in the game you'll be drafting different habitat and animal tiles from the middle and placing them in your own ecosystem to try to group similar terrain types together and position your animals in scoring formations there are are a few more nuances to the game but in general Cascadia has a really low barrier to entry and it uses variable setup in a couple really clever ways first off the starting tiles and animals in the market row are all randomly

chosen at the beginning which means that you can't really predetermine your winning strategy until everything is set out but the main thing that I really wanted to highlight are the different scoring cards each animal has several different scoring conditions that can be attributed to them at the beginning of the game and these scoring cards are really the Crux of each game you can play the family mode and just use the simplest scoring cards you can go all out and choose only the max difficulty cards or you can randomize them and get a unique strategic experience every game each different combination of scoring cards means that your tile placement and animal placement strategy has to adapt and evolve every game even though the rules of the game have essentially remained the same and that little twist I think makes this game super replayable and really really clever I think that also one of the best parts of all of this is that choosing variable setup scoring objectives is actually a fairly common practice in a lot of bigger games so if this ends up being one of your favorite Parts about Cascadia then there's plenty more where that came from so if you're looking for a board game with a ton of replayability with a setup that you can adjust to fit the experience level of the players at the table then might I suggest

Cascadia the next mechanic up is set collection and this one is very very broad I mean it basically just means that the values of the items that you're collecting be a cards or resources or your Tableau or what whatever they're dependent on being part of a set now this mechanic goes all the way back to your childhood I mean it's Go Fish it's rumy Cube there's a ton of games like that but I think there are a lot of games recently that have taken the idea of pure set collection and have Incorporated them into a larger hole that takes it to the next level I immediately think of some Classics like Jaipur where you're collecting sets and selling them for victory points or Splender where you're collecting sets to build an engine to help you collect more sets but the one that I really wanted to highlight is actually a game that came out fairly recently that I think is a perfect mix of simple and strategic it's sea salt and paper sea salt and paper is a really clever card-based set collection game for two to four players that really highlights the set collection mechanic without making things too complicated in seesaw and paper you'll be adding cards to your hand each turn to try and collect sets that will score you points some of these cards may give you special actions that can gain you more cards or mess with your opponents But ultimately you need to focus on building up your sets in order to win now once your sets are worth seven points or more this is where things get really interesting you can call stop and everyone just scores what they have in their hands or you can call last chance and everyone else gets one more turn to try and beat your score you can win big points if you win this bet but you can also lose out on a bunch of points if you lose and I think it's this specific twist that really takes this simple set collection game to the next level I love sea salt and paper because

it's a compact game that feels just as simple as a game of Go Fish but once you start playing it you realize all the different strategies that you can utilize to end up on top I think it's a perfect int uction to set collection because it's so streamlined and easy to get into that it'll hit the table early and often at your game nights and get you rare into go for something even more strategic that is almost certainly going to be in a bigger box so if you're looking for a game that feels both fresh and familiar at the same time that uses set collection in a really clever way then might I suggest SE salt and

paper the next mechanic we're going to talk about is open Drafting and this is basically games where players will pick cards or resources or tiles or something from a common pool to gain some sort of advantage or to assemble a collection that are used to meet objectives at the end of the game now I really like open drafting because it immediately opens the door to more player interaction you could just focus on your own game and not worry what other people are doing but with an open draft you kind of have to keep an eye on everyone else so that you know the likelihood of certain things being available on your turn I think that one of my favorites Sada is a great example of this with the open snake draft of colorful dice that happens every round where you really have to weigh what other people need to make sure the right die will still be around for you on the way back but I think actually the best Gateway game for this mechanic is in my opinion another beautiful game that's also inspired by the art of the Iberian Peninsula it's aul aul is a tile drafting tile placement game for two to four players that is also inspired by Portuguese tiles so if you're into tiles just skip ahead and grab this one but if you're still on the fence let me tell you why I think this is a great Gateway game to learn about open drafting in this game your goal is to collect sets of tiles to fill spaces in your Palace and you'll do that by grabbing them from the public market now the thing is when you grab these tiles you have to take all of the tiles of that same color and add them to your board and any remaining tiles go to a shared pool in the middle potentially sweetening the deal for other players you don't want to grab too few tiles and take too many turns to fill up your board but you also don't want to take too many tiles and risk overflowing your board and taking penalties plus you

don't just want to leave your opponents exactly what they need on their turns either so what you draft and when when you draft it is super super important now I will say if you're not careful open drafting can quickly turn into what we like to call hate drafting I.E taking a suboptimal outcome with the express intent of screwing someone else over and as much as this is a legitimate possibility in this game it usually won't help you win so take that with a grain of salt either way aul is a great example of all of the different options you should be considering in a game with open Drafting and being able to understand your status relative to other players will be an invaluable skill in much heavier games down the road so if you want a game that will EAS you into the world of open drafting that's fun and strategic and will still finish under that ideal 60-minute Mark then might I suggest

aul the next mechanic we're going to talk about is endgame bonuses and these are games where players will earn or maybe lose victory points at the end of the game based on meeting certain Victory conditions now these Victory conditions they can be private they can be public personally I prefer where the bonuses are private because I think it's a great great way to stay under the radar and sneak up on people at the end of the game to steal a win now I immediately think of games like wingspan or I love cats or flamecraft where you can stockpile some personal endgame objectives and drop them all at the end to snack some extra points that no one else was accounting for but I think that the game that I want to recommend as a Gateway game in this category doesn't really have objective base bonuses at the end instead it rewards more forward planning and more risk-taking to help you score big at the end and that game is camel up camel up is a crazy and chaotic game for 3 to players about betting on the most ridiculous camel races you'll ever see in the game you'll be rolling one random die at a time and moving the corresponding camel to see who crosses the Finish Line first throughout the game you'll be placing in-game bets on who you think is going to win each leg of the race and you can make a little cash off of those but the big money really comes from placing endgame bets on the eventual winner and loser of the race you can place an endgame bet at any time even on the first turn of the game and the timing really does matter because you want to be right but you also want to be first do you stake your claim on the camel that's leading on the straightaway or do you risk it on the underdog and pray to the chaos gods that the camels will start moving backwards which to be fair is entirely possible in this game the choice is yours but if you're the first

one correct you'll snag a huge bonus that could very well winning of the game plus you've got two chances at these endgame bonuses as well because you're betting on The Biggest Loser of the race too camel up is a perfect game to get you into this genre because it really forces you to make a decision about the relative value of snagging a small ingame bonus versus a big endgame bonus which is a common decision that you'll have to make a 100 times over and heavier and more strategic games so if you're looking for a game that rewards thinking both in the moment and 10 steps ahead and that really utilizes the endgame bonuses to keep everyone in the game then might I suggest camel

up the next mechanic on the list is kind of a weird one it's just dice rolling which board game geek describes as a mechanism that can be used for many things Randomness being the most obvious okay that doesn't really tell us anything but basically it's just games where you roll dice okay that makes sense right it really includes any of these types of games and even though that seems ubiquitous it's still only the eighth most popular mechanic on the top 100 games on Board Game Geek which I think is really interesting maybe that means that these games rely more on strategy than on luck but I think as long as there's some dice mitigation tactics included like the worker tokens and castles of burgundy for example then dice rolling doesn't always have to feel like well like you're rolling the dice I guess yes dude I think he's doing the dice thing too much anyways there are lots of great games that integrate dice rolling as a key mechanic but I wanted to talk about one that I've been really enjoying lately that I found to be a perfect Gateway game it's spots spots is a dice chucking dog fulfillment game for one to four players that combine strategy with pushy luck elements to make this clever and super cute game in spots you're trying to roll the dice to match the spots on your chosen dogs and you'll be doing so by picking up one of the available actions in the middle that will tell you the number of dice you have to roll as well as how many times you have to roll them you can also gain treats which will give you a chance to roll later in the game which will definitely come in handy when you're looking for a specific number once a dog card has been fully filled out you can secure them by taking a dedicated turn to lock them in but you can also choose to keep rolling your dice and try to fill out all of your available dogs all on the same turn if you manage to defy the odds and do this all of your dogs

are automatically locked in and you don't have to take a turn to do that action but if you overflow your dog house before you get there then you have to discard all of your previously placed Dice and start over this key pushy luck element makes it so anyone can win at any time and when it's combined with the action selection that can affect your odds and the treat rerolls it really makes this a dice rolling game with a surprising amount of strategy despite its easy rule set so if you're looking for a cute dice game that offers a few options for dice mitigation so that you can't always complain that the dice hate you then might I suggest spots all right the next one on the list is income and this one's a really interesting mechanic it's pretty straightforward I mean it's just basically when players can gain resources at defined times right maybe it's at the beginning of your turn maybe it's at the end of the round something like that usually there are ways to increase your income throughout the game and building that engine is often times integral to your success in the game now surprisingly enough there actually are not a ton of lighter games that use this mechanic maybe it's an upkeep thing maybe it gets a little too finicky when you're trying to streamline the rules but my first thought for this one was a game called photosynthesis where you get light Points each round based on where the sun is and how tall your trees are and that's definitely a clever way to approach income but then I settled into an absolute classic Gateway game that I almost forgot had an income mechanic in it it's Patchwork Patchwork is a quilt making polyomino game for two players only and I thought it was a perfect candidate for this category because the tension between managing the tiles on

your board and managing your income is really the Crux of the game in Patrick you'll use the buttons you've collected to pay for different Tetris shaped tiles to fill out the spaces on your quilt but the tricky part is each of these tiles also cost time as you move forward on the time trck you'll cross over lines that allow you to collect your income which is equal to the number of buttons currently on your quilt this means that when you're picking tiles you have to not only pay attention to the shape and how it interacts with the rest of your board but you also have to consider how much income it will make for you in the future so that you'll have enough buttons to pay for the things that you want down the road this tension is really what makes this game great and the income mechanic is really the most important part because it gives you buttons and buttons are your victory points in the game it's always such a hard choice between time and money in this game and that feeling is one that is super common in heavier games that use this mechanic so if you're looking for a strategic game that combines the tension and the decision- making of a much larger game into a nice quick easy tolearn package than might I suggest

Patchwork all right and the last mechanic that we're going to talk about this one is kind of a controversial one I mean it's Cooperative games right is this a type of game is this a mechanic in a game we don't have to worry about that the nen clature we didn't make that so it's not us right anyways Cooperative games are games that you have to work together towards a common goal and personally I really like Cooperative games I mean I come from a very competitive family so it helps when we can all win together instead of getting in each other's faces over things I think that's great and there's actually so many good Gateway Cooperative games like horrified like the Forbidden series The crew etc etc but I found that a lot of these games tend to have some sort of quarterbacking issue where one player who is familiar with the game or the mechanics or something like that can identify all of the Optimal Solutions and basically Force everyone to play their way which feels kind of bad so instead of going with one of those I went with a Gateway game where you can't have a quarterbacking issue because you're not even allowed to talk it's magic mace magic mace is a realtime Mall Heist game for 1 to eight players that is as chaotic as it is cooperative it almost feels like over cooked the board game but instead of cooking you're shoplifting which is actually hilarious in Magic maze you'll play as a broke adventuring crew that needs to steal their weapons back in order to tackle their next big dungeon but here's the twist you're not just controlling one of the characters on the board you're actually controlling all of them each player gets a cardinal direction that they're in charge of which means that if you have the left Arrow anytime any character has to move left any number of spaces you have to be the one who physically moves them on the board no

one else can touch them and the best part is you're not allowed to talk either so you can't yell at the oblivious person across the table who needs to get it together to help you get into the store well that's not entirely true actually this game has one of my favorite board game components of all time and it's called the do something Pawn during the game you can grab the do something pawn and slam it down in front of someone to let them know that they need to do their thing or else frankly I wish that some other games had to do something pwn as well anyways if you somehow grab all of your items and manage to make it out before time runs out then you and your whole team wins I think magic maze is a wonderful Gateway into the world of Cooperative games because once you play it you'll realize that nothing will ever be quite as hectic and if you can handle a level of magic maze you can handle anything between the limited communication and the really simple rule set magic maze is a ton of fun and always gets people laughing regardless of whether you win or lose which in my opinion is a sign of a great Cooperative game so if you're looking for a chaotic intro into the world of cooperative and realtime games that will give you a taste of what it feels like to work together as a team as well as that hit of dopamine when you finally figure it out then might I suggest magic maze all right thanks for sticking around for my top 10 Gateway games for the top 10 most popular board game mechanics I hope this list helps you find a great game or at least helps you articulate what you like about certain games so that you can go out and find that perfect game for you I'm also super curious as to what your favorite Gateway games are so make sure to drop those down below in the comments anyways thanks to everyone who supported this channel so far please don't forget to like comment and subscribe so I can keep

growing this Channel and keep helping you find your perfect board game once again this has been a might I suggested game production and I'm Alex your board game smia signing off

Progress saved