Skip to main content
Loading video...

Witcher: Old World - Discussion

Transcript 57:55

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion over in Witcher the old world one of the newest games by Lucas oh man sure that's what I'm gonna go with um his previous games that he's done is Valhalla and uh and Titans which I have uh run throughs and uh and or reviews on the channel so you can go check my thoughts on those um but this is uh this is a game that was clearly highly anticipated uh due to the source material right being The Witcher and I guess uh in collaboration with CD projekt Red yeah so that's really cool because so like again with the city project red all your Miniatures are actually from the games yep um the witches are basically like the armor sets that they are wearing are from the game names of cities are from the game yeah it's pretty nice yeah so this uh the the setting for this if you've played Witcher 3 or two or one uh is not in that setting so you're not gonna come across geralt or lamb Lambert or dandelion or anyone else yeah world yeah so I guess if you're going from a love for those games and you're coming here um expecting to see basically The Witcher 3 as a board game you're not you're not really gonna get that um but what you can do is watch The

Witcher animated movie that was on Netflix that was that was pretty good that's kind of in the setting it's before the sacking of karamorin and the witchers being kind of isolated and hunted and and hated monsters are running rampant and uh and then you're just killing them right so for me I didn't back this game this is your your copy and luckily I was actually able to play it and I didn't back it because while I love The Source material and my wife Kat has read the books right um this designer has been a has is over two for me right uh not like that those games are bad but to me they're painfully average like Valhalla was kind of a it was a deck battling game you kind of wanted people to die to go to Valhalla and they have a million minor expansions um and then Titans was glorified risk kind of in my opinion so I was like you know what I'm I'm just gonna I'm not gonna deal with it but this game is really good yeah um I like it quite a bit it's so this is my fourth play of it it is definitely significantly better than what I thought when I was going back it so this is actually a gift for my wife's birthday um I gave her option of two games um or this she picked this because she

loves Minnies yeah like at the end of the day it was not it was 90 of the minis for her when I got it's like okay is this game just going to be one of those mini games where I'm just gonna make super cool Miniatures for my game yeah but the game can be trash because everybody's gonna buy and film the instructions and the ministers are fantastic and they're famous they're so good they're they're great I was pleasantly surprised this game was actually halfway decent yeah yeah like is it coasting off the IP was it costing off its minis like hey look at our minis there's no how to play videos we have no real coverage over it right but the minis are really good it's like uh-huh uh-huh right oh they don't like your other two games so you're probably gonna fail on this one and hope the IP sells it exactly it was significantly better than I thought was going to be which was super encouraging um I did go on the all-in so we are playing with a one basically the full expansion of one of the sets um and then a couple others that pieces thrown in yeah yeah this one I mean I had the same hesitation it's kind of like like what what can they do because what this game does it's competitive and it's essentially it's a race even adding this expansion which I I really like um it's still a race it is like I I won this game that we just now played and I almost thought I was it was very close we all it was it was whoever won the next fight right uh was going to win my

worry was I didn't meditate so I was like oh did I hinder Myself by uh getting four trophies from winning one Witcher fighting three um uh three monster fights and it's kind of at the very end it's like well we're all tied now so I don't have the time to go and get some tracking tokens and get some other stuff to prep for a final fight I just kind of had to go for it right and luckily my my build worked out and that's the really uh some people might not like that it to me made a it was a little weird of making it competitive um but in the setting right it works it works uh because you think well we're witchers but you're all from different schools and they're not necessarily friends it's like yeah we're all witchers even in the source material like witchers fight by themselves yeah they're pretty isolated people um they might fight together but realistically they find separately yeah exactly uh and like hey because a lot of stuff that I have seen online has been solo stuff and that was another worry it's like is it just gonna be weird being competitive because the video games are Solo right so is this gonna be just mainly don't even bother with other players just play it by yourself I don't know I I have not played this solo and I don't think you have either no I can see this probably being really good solo because you don't the only thing you interact with another player is kind of who's gonna go after what monster when I snipe that from you

if I so choose or do I want to fight you right um so overall I think I think most of it is solid it has a few weird things in the game but for the most part it's it works yep so let's go ahead and talk about uh negatives uh do you have any negatives on the game yeah it's um slows the wrong word it takes a lot of time for the weight of game that is yeah yeah we played for what three and a half hours three-ish hours this one yes so it felt incored well with teaching I mean we played three and a half hours then yeah three and a half that just for me it was not heavy enough a game for and I played this again I don't think I played it in less than two hours yeah two player count to three player count I haven't played in less than two hours that is a lot of time commitment for board game that at the end of the day still has a lot of chance involved with it because yeah it's like because people kept saying oh it's a deck builder and they're not wrong right but it's the slowest deck builder in existence um because you only get one card per turn you get one card per turn it reminds me a little bit of Scarface which I know you haven't played but I did not like Scarface at all because it was touted as a deck builder area control game uh where you could essentially only get one card a turn to

add to your mafia deck as well and it's like don't call it the deck builder if you're not really building a deck right you're it it's almost like a I would almost say it's like an efficiency deck Constructor yep because you every time you get a trophy you cycle out cards and since you only get one card to turn uh you're basically I mean your deck is Razor thin right which is not necessarily a bad thing you don't want to sit here with your deck being 40 cards but at the same time I wouldn't mind it if I'll call next negative is basically at the end of your turn you're pretty much set with how much you've drawn yeah no like and that's where most deck builders are like well you can make an engine that just draws your deck quickly or engine that has just powerful and just walks over yeah here nope and your turn draw three cards you must buy a card you buy your cards by spending the card so you have three cards you just drew yeah which are your actions from the next turn yeah so if you buy an expensive car like oh man that car is super worth it on the way up there with plus one it cost me my entire hand so I get one action next time yeah to move to move yeah because almost none of the cards do anything in Phase One of traveling it's all for combat right so you're yeah you're kind of like you're never really using your deck in creative ways your essential actually building for the fight right

um which some people might like right I I would say if you're calling this a deck builder it's that's the loosest way and it's just because there's no other there's no other term for it right um and tell me because sometimes you might only be buying cards because you're like well I my my three cards happen to be three Waters well I need to go into a forest I guess I'll just grab that one so I can actually because there was one time where it's like well what if you can't move right you know you could theoretically buy one card I mean that'd be your own fault really if you spent three cards to take one and realize oh I can't get to a water spot so I guess I'll just do nothing right on this on a race game right um the other thing again it's time really it's great and it's terrible you ever take basically one of these cards because you're not going to fight enough times that you're basically in phase two you have three options you meditate you can only do that when you're at level five for an attribute um probably only going to do it once you can find it again we're gonna probably do it three to four times yeah and then you take these story cards yeah and they are good they're flavorful but they add a lot of time to your game yeah because you're reading off the story someone has like a choice and then you read off with their choices and that might lead to something else that they have to do yeah which for me uh being a very story driven campaign

kind of kind of player I really like these um but they are completely random these are and uh these decks are not a negative for me uh just because they remind me of like Elder tour stuff more more story more flavor more quests you can go on but yeah if your end game is like well I want to win well you can only do three things to win none of those are you're you're it's just kind of almost a whatever thing that he just had to add to try and kind of justify well to me it does make me feel like it's The Witcher game because that like you don't play Witcher if you don't enjoy having tons and tons of dialogue exactly um and that's what this those two decks allow is that tons and tons of dialogue and so it does give you I call that feel of The Witcher video game but to me that can be a negative if I don't want to sit here with three other people at the table and I'm listening to three other people telling a story that I don't care about that has no progression yeah no bearing on anything that you can do right uh yeah because my my negative with those like I love the fact that they're there but there's two decks like a wild the wild lens and then a city but there's no Rhyme or Reason why they're separate right it's like oh well if you pick one or the other it's like it's not based off where you're at because you can only travel two cities right so it's it's just kind of like well it

would make sense if that you had to stop in Wild Spaces along the way and oh that's where I ended so I have to take a wild event like a road event Gloom Haven or a city event in the city right that makes sense but in this last game we just played you were like halfway through you were like which one do you want I'm like I don't care right like just draw one for me because I can't there's look at these like there's like 200 cards here and it's like I can't be like well I'm really low on money so I'll do the I'll do the city one because that's gonna guarantee me money no you have no idea right you have no idea what they're gonna do um I like that they're Choice based uh you can kind of hope and be like oh you come across a merchant right uh he's selling potions do you a buy potions or B kill him right huh well yeah I'll kill him maybe I'll get gold right uh and and luckily most of them are good right if they do hurt you if it's like oh lower your Shield but gain an attribute of your choice right so my biggest negative of this game has been every single time is your Witcher special ability which makes you which are unique um I play quite a couple witchers now they for me at least some witches I know bear is a little less situational but like so mine I have to spend a potion I never got to the point where like oh I really want to just lose that potion yeah and it didn't give me enough benefit that the potion that I was spending was benefiting me enough Brett

was kind of the same way yeah you have to hit someone enough times and then it's like I get look at four and discard two and he's maxed it out at that point that one's really good I feel like more against Monsters it is against my wishers yeah because witchers is kind of like yeah you do thin their deck but you don't really know what combos they're going for right in their in their deck building so it's kind of but against Monsters it's just like oh great yeah let's see I I play this guy because I wanted to see how it worked I didn't ever use my special once you didn't and I remember looking over and I'm like you have four potions I figured you would have used them but they were all better than what my ability was yeah and so it was like I'm not going to use it everything is kind of built as once right and it is a little bit it's if it was once per fight which some are um like my my spalders that I got was once per fight I can discard any card to take the top card right but my crossbow was at the beginning so it's just like it's weirdly restrictive and that's what this designer does is he just makes weird decisions not bad decisions right but weird where it's like why it's my [ __ ] crossbow why can't I use it at any time in the fight so like my wife was playing the wolf the other day and it is you can use its special ability after you have a combo of at least three cards it adds more attack value to it okay but it's only once per fight yeah and the answer is why wouldn't I be able to do it every single time I get three combos yeah because that's not super rare no I mean because combos um and we'll get to the deck building and all that uh as um because that is a obviously big part of it we just kind of

talked about a little bit of how slow the game is but yeah it's like in in because you can build geralt in the way where he's just whirling right whirlwinding around but it's like okay can't do that again it's like what do you mean right like I mean I mean I I kind of see it's almost he went like kind of he put in theme a lot of theme into one thing and then no theme anywhere else right because it's like my my armor uh I mean I use almost all the time because it's like and I built my deck specifically to be able to pump my shield up have it go down and then it's like oh now I need to draw so right um yeah I wouldn't say that the abilities are now that they're unbalanced they're just not created equal which I guess would people would say is unbalanced but I don't think they're versatile enough to be like oh my ability is vastly superior than everyone's I would agree that actually is where I dislike is like they're not powerful enough to be like oh which wish are you I don't care yeah it doesn't matter yeah really what you're doing is if you're into the source material you're picking the school that you just like the most right which for mine is is the bear school right normally it's a bear school for me um I just this time I want to try Americorps because I never tried them and I was like you know potions are decent so let's see what they can do with them yeah and I mean like me I that my that ability would have been best for my play style because I don't usually usually you go into an Alchemy kind of build but

every time I did get potions I was like I mean I guess it's good if you've you if you have four yeah and bombs and you've used two bombs in one potion and if you're like well I can't use any more I guess I'll now use my ability but they're super handy like potions and bombs especially if you have a tracking token to kind of get the jump on them or against another Witcher it's just like Ryan bomb potion oh you're just chugging and then you're just like and then now I'm gonna 18 damage it runs like oh Jesus Christ yeah I prepped to kill you so I like that they're there but again it almost feels like the they were an afterthought especially because your decks uh you get one special card right I don't think I ever use this I use mine once yeah it came in my hand multiple times and I was more annoyed because it was yellow and blue and I'm like I don't really have those my build was built around green uh green and purples so again this is another thing in like my wife actually made the same comment to me for a game about witchers and fighting there's very little fighting you do that is like you do a massive four fights unless you just lose a lot that's true yeah like if you're winning you're going to do four finals yeah and that's it it's kind of hard to lose it is like the very last fight in this game the the in this three-player game Brett's not here

uh but um I went into the lesson with no tracker and no weaknesses right um the only thing I had in my favor was my maxed out armor right and I was like well I mean it's either go home like go go big or go home and I'll just see if I can win I know what I have in my hand right that might help me but yeah I mean you could theoretically like I there's no way of really knowing but the one where you had all those tokens I was like oh I went down there to increase my combat I was like I probably could have won right but that's a shitty it's just like I know you've sitting there been taking all these weakness tokens and stuff and I'm just like yeah I'll just see what happens right I like I get money if I lose it's no real detriment right so let's just see because then if I win you've wasted your entire game we're running around and if I lose okay well you still go and get it no matter what right uh yeah you do do very little fighting in this uh again weird weird decisions yes um but so let's talk about the the actual schools we were talking about like the special abilities they're there they're very minor um I mean theoretically you can build around it but again these cards that come out they're not like extremely

versatile they're mainly for combos right in the deck building or for movement right so it's not like you can get like a big potion engine oh pull potions back and then so that you can use your ability to like do extra stuff mine kind of allowed me to do that because it's like I'll keep raising my shield and then whenever I can't raise it again oh now it's zero right and then I can bump it up um so what I don't like about this is you have your combat which in which is basically how many cards you can draw right defense your max Shield value Alchemy potions you can you can use and then your special power but then you have a kind of a weird meter which is your level that's kind of based off everything has to be that level before um it raises up before you before you can raise it up that to me completely works against any RPG style in in The Witcher right like I mean again I know theming Wise you're not getting the video games but oh the video games are all you have to go off of right with with when CD projekt Red is involved so it's like if I wanted to go all in on defense and my special ability theoretically I can I can't well no I can't um because I have to get everything else up well no because you can buy it always higher you can't get for the free points

oh gotcha oh I see from over here yeah okay from yeah from those spots so yeah just limit yourself in free which which I mean if you get lucky in those cards and you're sitting with 30 coins it's like okay I'll just buy it up right um so I mean yeah you could do that but then yeah you're not getting it free for level I just kind of find that odd yeah uh and because money is pretty tight money is super um it there are ways for you to get like the biggest jumps that I've seen is four coins five coins maybe you feel rich after that yeah you're like four coins wow right uh and then you go and you spend one level and you're like well I'm poor again right uh hopefully I'll come to this one location that gives me a free coin and you've kind of forced to go gamble right to hopefully it or you go and do Trails but that's slow like I'll put it this way it you can gamble to try and get a lot of money fast or you can do the slow tedious route of just going from location to location location to collect coins yeah or go the location to location you go to uh I I'm trying to I'm reading this upside down consideris yep uh to increase your defense and you go down to our our Mordor uh modron to increase your combat then you come up here and increase your Alchemy then you go Glenmore Glenmore to increase your

special ability and then now you get to level up right and did you just go in this big circle to do that and then it's like all right now I'm ready to fight right um it's just again it's not bad you are technically able to go all in on one thing and then you know get it maxed up that you can never lose it right you meditate that's a free trophy you're gonna do that um but you can do that up until you just can't win that way you just can't win that way yeah so you can get three things up and then just be like I'm gonna meditate each of my turns and then just go fight and if you're doing that then you just go fight one Whatever monster you're probably uh gonna win that fight probably um just because you're guaranteeing it's not like you're giving up anything on cards right you know it's not like oh man I'm not buying any cards nope I'm still guaranteed to get one because how many cards did you have in your deck this time

16. I had 14. um so and I think you got my maybe some extras just from those yeah probably uh yeah so it's just it's it's just it's just odd yes it's odd so kind of talk about cards and combos so one of the things that is weird but kind of cool is you do combos so cards are going to have these little tabs on the side of them they're color coded so there's five different colors in the game um pretty much no card is going to have its color so you have to take a purple card to some other color yeah which one like this card is great because it has all four other tabs to it so I can't do another purple to it intensive igne I have been I'm sweeping org oh yeah but same difference oh I see yours actually has symbols on them mine doesn't yeah and so then you start creating these patterns where I was like okay um that one takes a purple so that's in my hand so and boom boom boom and you just keep building as long as you can make the tabs all work yeah that's cool that's awesome um the downside is your deck your hand is also your life yeah so every card you play is you becoming weaker which other games have done that yes I have seen before we played this I had seen uh one written review with someone saying that that's like complaining about that now

to be fair he also prefaces saying he doesn't like deck builders which it's like well this isn't really a deck builder right um but he's just like he doesn't like the fact he felt that you get punished when you're in combat by playing your car you're doing big massive moves yeah um and I I see that I definitely that makes sense like because if you're because they go into a Discord pile and if you have no card in your deck well then you just have to go with off your hands so if you take damage and you have no cards in your deck you lose what's in your hand right so it's kind of like yeah if I go for one massive swing does five damage but then I draw up and now nothing's and you're kind of like super weak from it but Pathfinder the card game does that um and the Dark Souls card game does that uh both of those are actual deck builders especially the um Dark Souls one where your deck is your life right you take you know 15 damage 15 cards go into your deck you're left with less options it's it's a weird you almost have to kind of tweak your your thinking right um not in the way of I'm being punished but with a thin razor thin deck five damages a lot it is a lot now I'll preface that a lot of times not every car but a lot of cards they on the tabs they give you another ability by continuing that chain so yes you are spending more cards but normally you are getting more out of it than playing one net card at a time yeah

yeah no exactly uh it can feel even a little bit more punishing it because it still is a deck that it's completely random yep that if you're just because again you can't really go into a theme because you're it's like oh I'm gonna go all into magic well I'm gonna take the magic cards well you can't because I don't really combo off each other right so you kind of have to do be a jack of all trades just like you have to be a jackable trades with your skills right so but if you draw and you happened it like if this was I'm just if this was my draw you know I have a I have a blue with a green tab a red and then a gray it's like well I guess I'll do one attack that's two damage I'm drawing one less and then you're drawing and every time you're drawing you're actually kind of losing health and it's like oh five damage well [ __ ] you know right so I didn't mind it no like it it rewards you actually to attack really quickly and super aggressively yes because again the monster's going to hit you for however much they're gonna hit You So the faster you can end that fight you're just better off yeah and it does make thematic sense a little bit in the sense that a lot of the things you're kind of doing when you're traveling is getting weakness tokens right is getting tracker tokens because in The Witcher which is a very Bleak world which are like the witchers die all the time right um like I think one of the sayings is

that a Witcher never grows old like it never dies yeah it never dies in their bed or something because it's like why would you your job is to fight these beings these magical creatures a lesson um the Crone witch so vampires yeah massive vampires and then it's like well if you were to just run in there and be like I got him it's like well you're gonna you're gonna suffer the consequences and I do and I do like that a lot I do too um it's thematic you can try my lesson fight was literally if probably if he had gone again I might have lost only because not because like I could I would have lost to the damage but because I was running out of cards right so then it's like well then you just like think of it as like your stamina right it's the best way I can think about it like if you're doing one massive like a swing you put all in your effort and you do like six damage they don't have defense right so you just get it across it loses six it tries to retaliate maybe it doesn't but you just put in and then you're like [ __ ] because you're I mean you're an enhanced human but you're not Immortal right then you're like okay and then it just lunges at you or does it special three attack which is the player takes damage you get to the number of cards in their hand well you drew six six either you're like that's six damage right uh because the striga just [ __ ] you up right it makes sense but if you're smart like a Witcher who understands these creatures you go out

and you get a weakness token you know you track it so that you're like I'm finding its layer like I know I need to put oil on my blades I need to take these potions or take these bombs into a fight you prep for potions you get some bombs yeah hell even one weakness token in the tracker token is an edge because it's like okay I know where it's layers you do that in the video game right where it's like I think it gets the fiend one of the main quests you find the fiend and you you have to find its Lair and when it's gonna come back and then you wait and then you're pumping potions and then it's like okay well and I do like it's a little fiddly with the tokens um but I think it's nice if one person's kind of doing it um like oh okay you know I killed that monster then they kind of do with or one or it's like I do it so you can go and take your turn and then I'll mess with it but it's a water token that's where the striga happens to be this one's number six so one of the Stricker's greatest strengths is her speed only a well-trained Witcher will be able to keep Pace with her in combat during the monster's first fight turn after the Monster Attack cards revealed choose the attack type right if it's a special attack you get to choose and that's so having these is essential you don't have to but it definitely makes fights easier yes yeah you get so much mitigation right and I can get behind that and so we really didn't do it but it's not hidden knowledge so you find your token you can always look at before you go into a fight yes and understand what your token's going to do because there

were a couple times where I was like oh it would have probably been beneficial if someone had looked because like you have to play a purple card okay I didn't go into this fight I think I need a purple car so I think yeah purple card yeah but it should be open knowledge if you're a Witcher that you know through centuries of of knowledge of knowledge it's just like oh okay we'll stream here because these aren't like one-off beings there are elections all throughout the land so it's like okay well this Witcher died so we know how he died they can teleport but have this ready um the only time I did was it's like what's it's special we know what's a passive you know what's its main ability that's coming in I didn't really look at what the four did because in this particular we use the the big monsters uh there was no way of ever knowing if it was going to do those right so it's like well there's no I don't need to plan for that because it's most likely not happening but the passive is much more likely to happen um yes and I actually like that because it did make the monster stronger than their base version game but balanced out by providing weakness tokens so you kind of had this give and take of it's bigger more epic fights exactly so and that's that kind of goes with what I was about to say you don't find a lot in this game but the fights you um are doing if you're doing it with these don't there they feel bigger yeah yeah I'll put it this way at least for myself like I was at least engaged every time someone was fighting oh yeah I was too it's like oh man what are they gonna do especially right whenever you went and

fought uh bread and it's like that's another kind of weird decision they make it's just the winner of the fight gets a trophy not if you're the attacker right so it's like if you went and fought Brett and because you were one trophy behind it's like well if Brent just happens to win then he wins the game and I'm like well [ __ ] that sucks and I mean my racing was I had to get drove empty trophies behind and I can't get to a creature you couldn't get to a creature or you couldn't get to me right I couldn't get we were both in the same one so you couldn't get to a creature to try and do it right yeah it totally made sense and so it's like you know is win or lose for me at this point yeah I have to get two trophies yeah uh you guys have no incentive not to go fight monsters here in a second so I was like I'm gonna do it yeah and I thought my deck was better than Brett's honestly yeah your deck was Pro your deck was probably better than mine probably um the only thing that might have worked for me was just my defense yeah so I think I think if we were to have fought this game it probably would have been whoever attacked the other person I think if you attacked me first I mean no chance right because you'd have all the potions and stuff but then if I did that like for example if I did to you well I did the bread um with this deck I might have been able to hand it off because I did I did pretty good damage right but I had the defense where it's like okay you're dealing five the Widow's one okay I'm a place cards bring my shield up all the way back up and still hit you for like four um and I'm not saying with the deck building uh

it's not as like creative as I'd like it to be but I I was still able to feel like I was part of the bear school or at least what my initial plan with this deck was I want to kind of have 360 Shields yeah and and it worked and I put in some crazy crazy cards be powerful yeah like I got to do my pirouette like yeah I used a critical hit multiple times yeah my critical hit because I wasn't really relying on card draw right um just a four damage attack it's a four damage attack yeah and then if you do play if you play that with a card that lets me like for example this uh I know I have one in here um like if I do a block oh cool like it might I get two Shield up and then I'm gonna use my pirouette or my critical attack because that's gonna be four damage and it comes right back to my hand right I don't need to draw cards and I can do four damage every turn we really think about it when you have 16 cards and someone does four damage that's 25 of your life is gone exactly instantaneously you're 25 down yeah if we look at creatures level threes or 18 cards and above for the most part we're talking like 12 10 to 14 for level ones 12 to 16 for level twos yeah and then above that for level threes hitting before it's just brutal and you're just going to demolish it is and

that's kind of why so that's why if you can get like in in my case if you can get your Shield up to four right well then you save 25 of your life right um where your opponent can't do that right uh at least in terms of the Monsters uh and I will say even though I didn't lose a single fight but it never felt like it was a wash no you know even fighting against Brett where I initiated the attack and I was able to whittle the shield down before the fight kind of chip them away right it was one good hit right away because when you're dead because you're always drawing so even though I have like five cards in my hand well he just has to do five damage right but the game does reward I'll call it the aggressor um almost everything if you're the aggressor again like the monsters they can't come hunt you down you only fight them even if you go into their territory they're not doing anything to you um so realistically you can prep for a fight as much as you want in the sense of is a race yeah so as much as anybody else is allowing it to happen yeah you're just gonna be able to do it yeah um in a three-player game it almost just naturally went like you went first so you picked up mountain right well you already has a lead on that Brett went he picked up Forest it's like okay I'll go for water right and you kind of just let people do that right uh because there's always Three Monsters out in a three-player game it's like well let's all just get our own you probably wouldn't want to do that right but I don't know it just feels

stupid it feels shitty to just kind of snipe someone's monster when you have not prepped for that monster you're only doing that to be like well it's a Race So I guess I'll just try and stop you I don't like that and that's one of the reasons I do I haven't played it yet I want to try it so there's an expansion in for it for the wild Hunt I believe it's supposed to be cooperative um you're basically finding all of iriden's army all his generals I can't remember all like the one with the huge mace that you go fight with Siri in the game yes the bald guy okay the guy the wizard that you fight later on yeah um like you fight all like there's four generals with iriden being the last and so I believe it's supposed to be cooperative and that sounds fun to me because that does sound fun um now you're all witchers working together to stop it you can play as Mages so yeah that one um that sounds super cool and apparently because I watched a review on the Mages they're significantly different so they are super high outputting damage with no defensive yeah all the Mages like the magic and The Witcher they're super powerful right but they are squishiest yeah well if you think about it there's um I don't remember his name cat would probably know but the guy he literally has Mage Hunters right that's like his whole thing is like they just hunt major so it's like well clearly they're not that powerful if guards can get them and kill them but yes they're super super powerful right and it's really cool

because you can play this it's not like oh we all have to play Mages or we all have somebody it's like you can combine it um in fact the witchers get their magic they know some like Geral for example knows little signs it's like he knows igne to do a fire thing and but it's like that's like probably what Mages teach their kids right she's like oh look at that that's cute and he's like thinking this Quinn Shield is like that's just saved my life and it's like that's adorable we right our four-year-olds can do that I think that's really cool I almost think that the other way to play is the one big monster that feels like a bigger race you know versus because some of that like you know the meditation or the uh the you know The Witcher hunt right it kind of feels like if these event cards go your way if it's like I'll get four gold get four gold like I'm over here like struggling like with one and I'm just like okay I'm gonna go here get one then I'm gonna go gamble I really need to win I didn't win [ __ ] I'm so mad then you're over there like I'm gonna do this oh wow I just get all the money right uh nothing I mean some of those will give you free attributes it's like well if you're if you have more money therefore you have more ways to go pay for training or movement or bombs um money is your solve problems yeah this game and so being poor is kind of rough yeah and that was I was feeling it for a little bit not that it was like game over uh when I didn't have money I

kind of had to finagle it a little bit um but I feel like the expansion where it's like everyone's hunting this one massive monster that's probably really hard to beat right that would be that would feel like okay you got to him first let's hope and then everyone's like invested like hope you lose because then I'm gonna try next turn right uh there are a lot of ways to play and that's something that he does is he adds a lot of expansions to his games Titan had a bunch uh Valhalla has a bunch um this is again clearly his best game yeah um I was gonna bring up something else uh but I cannot remember oh uh whenever you do kill monsters uh it is really cool that you get their trophy yep uh oh the trophies are on the back of their cards okay they're regular cards for the record never play this way and you always use the cool better weakness monsters because which means you need the monster trail expansion like if you if you can get no expansions just get that one because agree this is [ __ ] lame well and that it also includes the bombs it includes more cards oh yeah you said what this was like half like that yeah easily half like there's the Adventure Pack and the monster trail the Tube app added to this and I would definitely just continually have yeah because like it's like oh drowners I mean I know in the video game drowners are kind of inconsequential but it's like I mean there are still times

where if you're playing on higher difficulties they can swarm you and then you're just like literally on yeah it's just I mean but it's like okay this has 10 Health I don't know where the drowner one is um I think it also had ten okay I mentioned the bigger one I was gonna come oh they're the same they're the same yep um but the thing is this only has like some it's special ability but what they add in here is the the the counter or the passive ability the weaknesses on the back which is really neat so it makes you feel like you're actually a monster hunter right um which is just kind of a general one-time ability yeah we had and so when you kill them because they're I mean you're not fighting a lot you're actually getting really nice powerful abilities right uh like the last one I got was the night wraith and you play this game a lot and the night right comes out just like in the video game you know what the trophies give you as a perk it's like the night wraith is probably the only reason I actually beat the legend because I went in with less cards I wanted to but I got to roll a die and help me draw more cards right and what's also kind of cool is you and Brett went really high on combat for extra card draw I was actually the lowest and I was worried in a deck builder type game because in most games if you're drawing you're winning I was like do I is that even is that something you have to do if the lowest the only reason mine was high is because I kept finding monsters that were down here so every time I went there I get to like yeah you spend all your friends yeah so it was more like I'm just going to do this yeah I agree I feel like defense Alchemy are your top best options

unless you know your deck is really good with Combos and you're gonna get every a combo no matter what you draw which my deck was not built that way it was there were times where I draw and I'm like how do I make this work right but I went off of equipment and that's another thing I like is you actually get equipment I was I was wondering if these were only going to be story stuff and it's like gold or potions it's a little light on the equipment that I would want but you do get it again but my problem is kind of like we said before it's so random and there's so many cards that you might get equipment you might not like one of the games I played we had a couple quests we never saw a quest an entire game really yep no little side quests it was just straight up get something get money that's it there's no go to this location because you agreed to help a merchandise yeah yeah hmm yeah I guess it is kind of like okay if you want those a lot then you want them a lot um it does make them feel more special when they do pop up uh kind of like um the crossroads and dead of winter it's like some people like no matter what always just did it and I'm like that kind of that kind of utters it down actually but it's always whenever it does happen it's like oh let's see what's going on and this is kind of like that but again it is a competitive game so whenever and dead of winter is not so

it's like oh man I got this lucky thing that got me this crossbow just for a relatively free two damage oh well okay that's kind of cool I mean but I don't get a crossbow maybe that's why he made it restrictive because it's if I could do this every single time or maybe whenever it'd be too busted right so I don't know it's like he has a few things that I do think are just bad decisions oh let's actually talk about one of the major negatives his rule book doesn't have all the [ __ ] rules in it yeah or at least I'm missing it um because after fights like that's on the blades I'm not seeing in the rule book again could be missing it yeah but you scoured that thing it's definitely not in the spot where it should be okay yeah that's like because you have when you defeat a monster or defeat a Witcher what do you do yes I want to tell me to do everything that I'm supposed to do after that fight yeah because we we had a quest or I had a quest that caused me to have like a special secret card that affected another player right and at the very bottom it was like uh do not raise your Shield value after the fight and I was like well wait a minute uh like there's nothing in the rules that says that you do that so why is it specified here and again translation issues there's some weird wording where it's like it specifies something over here and it's like well then since it's specifying that means the opposite has to be true right um but then it's like well why would it's

why would this be a card if the only effect is that you don't raise your Shield value oh well on the player Aid it tells you to do that as your very first thing after a fight right huh oh you also shuffle all your cards together after a fight so you kind of always refresh but nothing in the rules ever at least it doesn't say it in the after the fight section right so agent could be missing it um I'm going to take a little bit harder look tomorrow on it but um it's just kind of again weird why is it not in the spot if it's if it's on the playwright in the after the fight why is it not in the after the fight section right in the rule book uh because that's a pretty important thing a good to be able to raise your Shield up to its value right because then like after you get to a fight you're like oh man I'm weak I have no Shield I have no potions I have no bombs or at least limited yeah um and be able to raise your Shield up immediately just means one I'm now much more defensible if another Witcher wants to come and try to mess with me yeah um and luckily they did include something of a of a token if witcher's fight you cannot you can no longer fight in that city right so people can't just like gang up on you be like oh I kind of know your your deck's not that good right all right we'll take turds you attack him then I'll go attack him before they can even do anything or they can go get more

potions yeah and go you know level up yeah they they basically it's a safe haven and I like that yep uh the art is fantastic yep it's very very good I'm glad they didn't just take video game right screen caps and uh but it's definitely you can tell it's The Witcher like the world there is one card I was looking at that very much looked like Daryl this one the pirouette yeah very much looks like girl but I don't think it is this guy's missing an eye anyway uh yeah all the cards feel really good um very mature artwork which I appreciate it's a mature theme um would have been really nice if they put in one card where uh it looked like Henry Cavill oh wait no who is it now it's some uh Liam Liam Hemsworth yeah who cares uh yeah I mean I guess we didn't really talk a whole lot about like the traversing and like what the different locations do but there's not really the locations aren't really that exciting no this I mean they're like every other board game it's just go get something from every time you go to a spot yeah um there are chances that if you don't plan your route out well you're not going to get something or if you didn't think through enough turns ahead like I played where oh I wouldn't expect money to raise my Alchemy and then immediately went over to the

um west side of the map it's like oh I could have got my Alchemy for free yeah I should have upgraded X Y and Z instead last term um yeah I I will say like I'm kind of gonna go back to the events they do have one thing that I don't like in Fallout did this um it was a sometimes the quest that you get are your own right like most the time they are but they do have some where a quest token gets placed on a location and anyone can do it go do that uh fallout did that and Destiny's did that I hated them both because it makes no sense right if I go to caremorein and I myself get told that there's some dude in uh novograd no one else should be able to go to novograd and be like hey I heard there's some guy here right it makes no thematic sense it feels more of just like a big old cuck like all right great I'm right here you're over here I guess I'll just go there and take that from you it's like that's dumb right some only I should be able to do that I should be able to travel and a lot of those are like but it's it's weird like why make these these decisions especially when a lot of the quest cards are you hold on to the token and only I can go there why make public ones that's that's just bizarre to me right um but yeah other than that like do you have do you have anything else I'm trying to No I'm trying to to think yeah so

on a scale of one to ten what would you give Witcher the old world seven is probably my highest that's exactly where I'm at as well is is a seven like I feel like for me six is a little too low yeah Eight's too high because it's not like I'm not like wowed by it no it's more of just a well this is his best game but the bar was so low for me anyway you might love Titans and Valhalla and to that I would just say play many many other games but if you're in love with his designs then you shouldn't be uh displeased by this the length is long and that's what kills it yeah it would be higher if the length wasn't as long I mean you could theoretically change it to where it's one less trophy but then that probably makes it to where it's way more random on who gets to do what personally I don't think it's the trophy count it's the problem it's the um how you do everything on your turn just takes time yeah so the very fact like you have to do this event before you buy a card okay but because there are locations that could affect these cards it means to a certain extent the next player online can't just start their turn yeah if these were flip-flopped like and the reason why I know they can't be flip flop is because some of these cards either subtract a card from

you or add a card to your hand um but again it's one of those things where it's like it's a weird cycle of events yeah I want to buy my card then do my own story because again quick and handles happen is the player behind you reads your story event so the player in front of you next player can only start their turn and going because it doesn't affect anyone yeah I mean but then it's like well I have to choose the one card and then it's like well I need to go but I'll wait that location Cycles cards or right or I play the card that lets me go and so I now I have to wait on you right and be like and that's what I mean that like there's little things that could have sped up the game and if that had been the case I would be much more comfortable with a higher rating of it but it doesn't it's just too slow yeah I mean I think they he nailed the theme yep like it it is here you are in The Witcher this these massive decks of story are are really well written right um I like that they're decisions yes uh I like uh that they're always decisions they're always decisions and I like how they're not I mean they're not all they're not bad I mean uh one the only one I saw uh was the one where the drowner girl yeah it was like I was trying this in our basement but it even the the uh flavor text even kind of told you which one not to go with but you could be like oh yeah I'll go with that and I kind of looked at the other option I'm like oh yeah that was only a negative outcome right but they're mostly good

every every good thing I kind of have for this game is either followed up by well yeah and that's in here so there's nothing in this that's just like outstanding right the best thing about this game is the fighting but for me it's like well if you're playing with these big monsters these four things that they can do are almost never happening right and also the fighting is kind of again weird not bad but weird because another player takes up their deck and is like and they call out bite or slam K doesn't really matter like it's just it was just something well how do I let the other players get involved I don't have someone else just kind of it almost feels like this needs to be a Max two-player game right so if I'm finding something the only other player is involved versus some third guy just you know jerking it or something it's like right this is like I would only ever play this two-player or solo right like that way because I'm certain your uh your two player games were they felt a little better okay honestly I was I was wondering I'm kind of seeing Witcher I mean it's definitely the best Witcher yes game out board game uh yeah most people are saying best at two or three it's like 41 people are saying best at 3 36 at two um six people saying invested for uh 29

recommended it for though and 38 people recommended at one I can 100 see that I I would love that I would probably buy this as a one or two player game but unfortunately still this isn't the game I'm now gonna go out and get right um you can just I'll just play the video okay like if I really want to spend because I can spend three hours in the video game just as well and be like oh man I got a lot done this is amazing uh so if the deck building was a little if I if I truly ever felt like my deck was different than everyone else's because I was going for a very different strategy that that would have probably elevated up higher but you had two more cards than I did if we were to actually compare cards the symbols would still all kind of look the same right um you were able to do like an eight damage attack maybe a nine at one point uh which is insane but I think I also had one fight that one shot right someone but just so it's like okay well we're both capable of doing this right now I just got the jump on it before you right and that's really it so so yeah I mean it's good um you have anything else nope I'm good all right well that's our thoughts on Witcher the old world let us know you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone

thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved