Scythe - Board Game Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies where we discuss games and how they work for two players this time we are talking about scythe designed by jamie stegmire it plays with one to five and tends to run about 90-ish minutes scythe puts you in the shoes of one of five factions competing for resource and dominance in a very cool alternate history europe think what if world war ii had mechs the whole thing was inspired by the artwork of jacob rozalski and the theme is a big part of it it's a medium complexity game that combines action selection and resource management and a bit of area control all in a race to be the first to get six stars and control the land let's take a look at how it works in scythe you need to pay attention to two boards the first is your player board where each turn you will be choosing one pair of actions you always get to do the top one and then if you have the right resources you get to do the bottom one as well top actions include production trading coins for goods bolstering your military or popularity and moving the bottom actions let you build mechs create buildings and list and upgrade everything else the second board is the shared map which is where you're going to be putting everything as you slowly spread your empire of workers and mechs and explore the world if two factions ever end up on the same space they fight which is decided by blind bidding with your military strength plus adding any combat cards you may have but it should be noted that combat tends to
be few and far between for the most part scythe is about engine building and it's this engine that will lead you to your victory stars which you score for things like maximizing military or popularity gaining all of any one of those bottom resources completing randomly selected objectives or winning up to two combats game ends as soon as one player places their sixth star and then you score points for stars controlled lands extra resources and a bonus for building placement and then a winner is declared one of the key factors of size replayability is its asymmetry each of the five factions has different strengths and weaknesses with different character and mech powers and starting areas on top of this players are randomly assigned boards at the start of the game each with a different combination of top and bottom actions and different action costs this combination will also change your starting resources and turn order which together can greatly affect your best path to victory to add to this variability there are also random objectives and building bonuses each game as well as a deck of events that happen when your character reaches one of those little tokens each offering a mini choice of possible actions if you want there are also several expansions including one that adds two more factions one that adds to rigibles with extra battle and worker movement capabilities and one that adds a full campaign mode with a ton of little mini modules
that you can incorporate into your game once it's all finished we highly recommend that for both all of the new stuff and for the surprisingly cool story you probably already noticed but this game is gorgeous all of that starts with the art that's displayed on every possible area and adds a lot to the personality and then there are the mechs and the characters which are different for each faction and all have a surprising amount of detail cards are all super high quality with most of them being oversized the player boards are double layered to keep all of the cubes from moving about the wooden bits are all great the shared board is highly detailed and even has a second oversized version that combines with an optional add-on if you want to supersize all of it it all just feels so classy like you want people to see you playing it and it's surprisingly inexpensive for how much comes in this box scythe officially plays one to five and that's mostly true scythe definitely feels different at different player accounts mostly that is in the area control aspect combat is rarely ever a huge part of the game with most games seeing maybe two to five battles in total but with four there will be a bit more combat as well as more of the subtle jostling for spaces or racing for event tokens whereas with two you'll likely be left to do your own
thing with maybe one scuffle a game near the central factory for players that want to immerse themselves in the action selection engine building aspects of the game this will be a huge positive but if you like more interaction and area controlled tightness that will be lost at lower counts there is an ai that can be used however to bolster player numbers but it is a bit fiddly and hyper aggressive so it isn't so much a player replacement as a different kind of challenge we do like it with two however especially playing through the expansion campaign which adds a few modular challenges that help tighten up the board scythe is going to appeal to a lot of gamers largely because of the look and the style of everything but also because of its unique blend of engine building and area control however like we said it's not going to be for everyone it certainly looks like more of a combat game than it is which can turn off players who come into it wanting to smash those mechs together and the factions are not perfectly balanced but if you want a resource an action management game that fills your table and immerses you in a really cool dystopian world they don't come much better than this it's also deceptively easy to learn apart from the ai which makes it a surprisingly good fit as a second step for players who are new wish to the hobby and that is it please
let us know in the comments what you think of scythe especially as a two-player game and which are your favorite factions and please do like and subscribe and hopefully we will see you all next time for another game