Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 32:53

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm doing a discussion over The Old King's Crown. Now, this is over the base game. Uh the company for this, Eerie Idol Games, uh did a really cool thing with their latest crowdfunding of the expansion where you could pledge and get the base game early while we wait for the expansion. And I think that's pretty cool. I think more games uh more companies should start doing that. But Old King's Crown was a game I do remember going on crowdfunding, but I ultimately did not back it at the time. I can't remember why. I just didn't really didn't really vibe with me. And then it came out, got a lot of buzz, and I was like, "Sure, now I'll back it."

And boy am I glad I did. I think this game is tremendously designed. It does a lot of really, really cool things while also still being somewhat familiar. This is a game that I have my door shut. my dog has figured out to still get in. Um, only one of my dogs. Anyway, uh, this is a game that does a lot of awesome quality of life things within the game. So, first and foremost, the art on this game is outstanding. [snorts] It is so good. Uh just even look at the cards and how unique they are to each faction while also still, you know, with the with the Kings Road cards and then the four four the six locations you can go to. It just really stands out. So [clears throat] if you're a gamer who appreciates art in their games, this is one to probably even if you don't like this style game, just play it so you can look at the art. Uh, and then the intricacies of this that shines at a larger player count. I think my only negative of The Old King's Crown is that I think it's it's just one of those games you play at four. Uh, to be fair, I haven't tried it at three, but I have tried it at two and it just it works.

It's fine. It just doesn't shine as as much. And the main reason is because a lot of the interactions between players are based off of the cont uh contestion contestion contesting contesting. Anyway, you're fighting for three different regions uh every round. And whenever it's just two people participating in that, there's not much going on because whenever it gets to the summer phase, uh, by that point, everyone has had a hand of cards and they are placing them down face down to compete for three regions. And everyone has to compete for each of these regions. It's not just the place where you place your herald. Although where you place your herald matters because you might want to you're going to get some extra victory points and you might even steal some victory points from other players.

So that in a two-player game just doesn't do much because it's just you and the other player. And I also feel that the factions while are very balanced might not be as balanced in a two-player game. Um, so there's there's that aspect in a four-player game. The intricacies between all the different factions and how they are designed and built to kind of counter uh to, you know, to have something that's unique about them and that's very powerful about them. Uh, have a counter from the other players. A good example is the purple faction is all about kind of power creep at the end or utilizing the lost pile, which is a an area of the game that's technically out of the game, but you can interact with versus burning a card that's actually permanently out of the game.

The purple faction has lots of ways to manipulate their current cards with lost pile cards, but the blue faction is all about kind of turtling in and locking down regions. Uh, one of their abilities is that they can declare martial law, which means for this round there, uh, no no uh, cards can be placed, moved, or removed or anything like that. So, it could just be a huge hindrance. and every faction has something like this. [snorts] Um, so I think that that's really cool. Speaking of the factions, the fact that they do play so asymmetrically, even though the the the cards that they have, every uh everyone's starting deck has the same type of cards. As far as I'm aware, I don't think I wasn't able to notice any differences. everyone has like the same icons and same scoring and so it has that system, but the fact that your faction's abilities manipulate those cards differently is pretty genius because you don't have to sit here and pick up a new faction and kind of learn what every single card does. Oh, I've never played the purple faction before. Let me learn what every single card does. Uh now their side deck of cards that you can spend um [snorts] labor label label uh loyalty. Is it loyalty?

Labor. Man, now that's going to bug me cuz I can't remember what that resource is called off the top of my head. It is called lore. Wow. Wasn't even wasn't even close. Uh you can spend lore tokens on to actually unlock these. These are different except everyone has the same 11 card. The other four cards are actually different and tailored. And I actually really like that. Oh my god. I really like that. I don't like that my dogs are just barging in here. Um, isn't that right? Isn't that right, Rosco? Uh, [snorts] I'm losing my train of thought. Yes. So, while the factions are still asymmetric, they're not so asymmetric that you can't help someone if they're trying to learn the game. Uh, unlike games like Routt, where if you've never played a faction and someone is asking questions, oh well, I here's the rule book. Research it yourself. Uh, I know you're never going to play this game again with me because it's too much. It's too much overhead. This game does not have that.

So, I really like every single contestion of a region always was high anxiety because I'd have Well, what's really cool about the the three regions is the person in last decides in what order they trigger. And that could be huge for a lot of people. You're actually kind of hindered from going first because you have to do all your actions in a given phase before everyone else. So people have tons of chances to react. In a lot of games, I tend to want to go first. This game I uh or the last four player game of this I played, I think I sat in second or third. I kind of went back and forth. And I kind of like that. It was very nice to sit there and see what was going to happen because I had I had plans on in what order I needed things to trigger and every time a region would go off, it could have worked out tremendously for me or it could have been the worst thing possible. Um, [snorts] the one thing I'm not entirely sure on, so the game lasts five rounds and you could play a short game or you could play an extended game. I don't know what the sweet spot is for it. Uh I don't know whether I think a short game it it feels a little I don't know. I I think a short game allows for more kind of excitement because more people you know the game isn't going to go on forever. So you're

incentivized to use your abilities more your tactics. But a standard or extended game probably has more strategy. You're more likely to hold on to your tactics and try and seed uh you know seed the board in in a way that's going to help you know position you for later on in the game. It gives you more access to gain lore tokens so that you can actually buy your unique cards instead of having certain factions or certain King's Road cards come out that are in your favor.

[clears throat]

So, in all reality, there's not really much to this game that I actually dislike this game. By getting the base game early, uh, I was able to confirm or deny whether or not I was even going to keep it in my collection when the expansion did come my way. [snorts] And now after having played this multiple times, I'm very excit I was actually researching what the expansion did because I was excited for what they were going to bring to to the game. So, and they also do something a little bit unique in cuz in the games I've played, obviously the ones that you're going to be going for are it feels like the top four. Uh the battlefield just gives you two victory points. The harvest field gives you the king's favor token, which allows you, which is also a cool system is everyone has a unique printed on power that you can only activate when you have the king's favor.

That's really unique. I haven't seen anything like that where you get something that's kind of temporary uh by having a specific token and other people can just take that from you. Uh the castle allows you to activate what was it? Um yeah, yeah, it was activate a council, which is kind of another area control of you get a benefit for having some guild uh markers over there. And then the wilderness allows you to journey, which is another way you can gain lore tokens. But then you have the shrine and the necropolis, and both of those mess with your deck and your discard pile. And in a game that's like this, I feel like in the first few games of this I played, I never saw the value of those because I mean, I'll shuffle my deck eventually.

But upon multiple playthroughs and at a higher player count game, these are actually incredibly important because when you have to draw from your deck and you can't, you actually lower your hand size. And as you play this game more and more, having a hand of cards is incredibly powerful. Mo mostly because there are keywords that trigger off of cards in your hand. So having, you know, there's a uh where is it? Uh, yeah, there's a zeroost card that's a ruse and you can play that in and it has uh ambush or retreat. So you could position yourself in a way where you might win uh but you're not entirely sure. So you could put the ruse down and the ambush ability allows you to play a card from your hand back into or into that uh region. [snorts] Or you could plan on ambushing but then see the situation is just not in your favor and you don't want to lose this card. So you might just pop it back for a later round. [snorts] It is incredibly powerful. And by manipulating your deck uh or your discard pile where you're constantly putting cards underneath your deck so you don't have to reshuffle. I mean, first of all, one, it just gives you access to your better cards again versus uh you know, sooner than you would if you just shuffled.

And two, it doesn't allow you to lower your hand size. So, that's really cool. And also if you're playing a longer game, uh because I've never had it go below five, um in a longer game I imagine the reshuffleling and stuff happens a lot more. [snorts] So that's really cool. The only thing I mean there's there's two potential negatives uh that I had exper experienced in a larger account game and that is a the keyword deadly. And deadly is a keyword that happens in the night phase which in the summer you have, you know, you reveal the cards for the region every in turn order uh everyone does their summer actions and then you do night actions and deadly is a night action for the most part. And basically if your uh card does not have a shield, it is going to be removed from the game. Uh well, it's a shield or a helmet. A helmet goes to your discard pile when it's eliminated. And shield means it's immune to deadly, so it's going to stay.

It's going to stay there. Um, in a larger player count game, deadly seems to pop off a lot more, and that can be kind of annoying if you are constantly being affected by that, and you don't really have any way to to find out if someone is going to be popping deadly. And in a four-player game, there's three other players who could. And all it takes is just one person to put a deadly out. It could be this region and one card has deadly and the other three don't. And that one card is probably going to win because they can kill out all the other all the other um cards. So, and there's other ways to give your cards deadly. So, it it is kind of annoying when you're just trying to do this this pretty standard uh you know, contested rule where it's just higher number wins and Oh, deadly.

Okay, next slash. Oh, deadly. Oh, hey, by the way, have you uh Oh, deadly. It It feels like you're playing as a blue control deck in Magic where can I play? It would be It'd be cool if I could just play because every Oh, hey. Okay, I'm in this region. Oh, one person that's deadly there, second person that's deadly here, third person that's deadly here. I guess I'm just [ __ ] So, it is slightly annoying. Not to say that there aren't ways around it and you can. Not many cards have deadly. In fact, I think in the opening uh in the opening deck, only one card has deadly and it has a chance to be removed itself. Uh cuz it says if there are any active opponent people cards in the clash, eliminate this card.

So, it could be a one-time use. And maybe that's just I'm not as experienced as some people who might be playing this game a lot more. Uh maybe deadly becomes a non-issue or it's a card that you hold on because other players know you haven't played it yet. So, that could just be a more inexperienced thing. But, I do know in my experience with the game, Deadly, it just kind of gets annoying, at least early game. And then the second, and this is probably where most people are going to have issues with the game, I absolutely love it because it is um it's how you kind of get a build going. And that is the Kings Road cards.

So, these are special cards that you bid on that give you either a one-time effect or a passive effect that can really benefit certain factions more than others. Uh a good example is so in the spring phase you are bidding for these kings road and there are four options available when you're bidding and everyone can take their card a card from their hand to bid on it and it's very simple. Highest bid goes first and you you have some you have three options. You can either take a card, you can steal a card or you can just pop your card back. So, there's no real risk to using a card. If you if you really have one out there, but you don't really want to blow your load and put a 10 out there. You're like, "That one's really cool. I want that one. I'll put in a seven." That that seems like a relatively high number. And someone puts in their nine and they take the card you wanted. Okay. Well, that's the only one I wanted. I didn't want it that bad to put a higher card. So, on my turn, I'll just take my card back. And now it's in my hand. But then the person who when you take a card, let's say it's this uh white watchtowwers, you put it in front of you and the card you use to bid actually stays with that card. So this is a really cool dynamic in this game where you are permanently removing a card from your deck to hold on to an ability that you might have the rest of

the game, but it's not entirely impossible for someone to steal it from you. Um, there are ways to buff your numbers, but let's say I really wanted an ability for the rest of the game. And you can theoretically put put your 10, which is the second highest number, the only other one is an 11. And you, but you're without a 10 the entire game. Uh, well, not the entire game. You can take another kingdom card and remove the ability and then you get the card back. That's another cool thing is if you ever if someone steals a card from you or you replace it, the card you use to uh hold on to it goes back into your hand, which might be another strategy. Uh so I really like that. I like the fact that you are able to steal from other players because and I think they throw that in here because these adventure cards can be so powerful towards one particular faction that you might just think, okay, there's no way in hell I can let them keep holding on to that. So, you do have ways to steal from it. And if you can't, well, then they're out for a high number uh high number card the rest of the game. However, I can see these adventure cards being, you know, kind of being a deterrent for some players because there is a lot of player reading, card reading, and, you know, reading what your opponent might do in a given region that the adventure cards do add an element of swinginess.

I mean, there are a lot in here and the purple faction actually has a way to kind of re-trigger cards or get them back. Um, so a good example is for the purple faction, they have an ability that allows them, it's a one-time use tactic, but [snorts] they have a lot of map cards. And when you go to journey to get the lore tokens, uh, if you use a card with a map, then it goes to your discard pile and it's not lost. Well, for example, the glittering caves is whenever you journey with a card that has a map, gain one point and one additional lore. This is huge. And a great combo to that is actually one I was using as an example is White Watchtowers. Plus five strength to your bidding and occupying cards. When you're first to resolve your bid, gain a point.

So by just having those two cards as a purple faction, they could put, you know, a five in the glittering caves and, you know, I mean, a seven in the other one. And so that means that it's a 10 and a 12 that's occupying. The bidding round comes around their low their fives now become tens to uh to compete. And now whenever they go to journey, it's uh oh, hey, I'm going to go journey with uh with this card that has that has two two maps on it. All right, neat. So that's going to be three lore markers and a point. Oh, and I got a point for pitting. And pretty much no one's gonna be taking this from me. And yes, you might be thinking, okay, the game's not that long. It's four rounds, five rounds.

First of all, you're not going to get both of these anyway, uh, in the same round anyway. But, ow, I bit my tongue. Um, but [snorts] the fact that this is a possibility and the uh and the purple faction has ways to ramp their lore a lot could get them a lot of endame victory points, which is how they're built. I personally like the fact that this can happen and the game does not last all that long and it's not necessarily all that impossible to take this from someone. You just have to really think if it's worth stealing or if you get your own combination of adventure cards. I know the red faction has ways to actually have three adventure cards and it's probably not sustainable to win uh based off lore alone because you don't get that many victory points at the end of the game, but it's also not a high scoring game.

So, the adventure cards, while I think are absolutely stunning to look at, I think they do add an element of uh randomness to the game. [snorts] Uh so, the and the only other negative that I potentially have is it it's the winner comes down to obviously whoever has the most points. And the tiebreaker goes to someone who has the king's favor. And if no one does, it goes into whoever's first in turn order. Now, normally I don't complain about tiebreers because who how often do those happen? It's it's almost a non-issue. Oh, hey, we tied for the same points and oh darn, you got the tiebreaker. Cool. And you move on, you know? It doesn't come. It's not a matter of, wow, they had more points than me, I lost. That sucks. It's like it's almost like, well, I got second place.

I got what? I got first be second place. However, the tiebreaker goes to whoever is first in turn order and the entire game the person who has the most points is the is in first. So, I thought it was weird that the tiebreaker was going to someone, hey, you had the most points the whole game. Uh, I guess you just also get the tiebreaker. [snorts] And maybe that's just more fresh in my mind because that's how the last game ended was a tiebreaker and it just felt a little cheap where the rich just kind of get richer. Uh I'm nitpicking honestly on that point. The other thing that's a huge positive for this game is its [ __ ] rule book, man. Its rulebook is so so good. Whoever wrote that just must have been that must have been their old job or their current like they must have hired a person. It it [clears throat] comes off as a very thick rule book. But this I promise you cuz how many pages is it? It's like it's 50 pages but there are so many examples in this rule book. It is probably 15 pages of actual rules and then uh 25 pages of examples. So they it's hey here's how the rule works.

Here's how bidding works. Here's three examples how bidding can go. Okay, time for the clash. Here's five examples of a clash. They just really knew how to hammer in this this kind of game. to coincide with that. Uh, I think they did do while this is the excellent player raid, I hate the fact that they only gave gave one. So, I really hate that. I hate when any company does it. Give enough player raids to all the players. Just that cost you nothing. Just do it. I don't want to have I know it's out there. I know I could easily scan that and print my own. I shouldn't have to. I paid 200 bucks for this. Print three extra [ __ ] sheets. Now, the rule book is still very good. The other thing to talk about this game and its positives are it's just the round structure is done so well. You have a token that you move around. Oh, start of the year.

Everyone draw cards. Oh, okay. Now, let's move over. Determine turn order. All right. We're in spring. We're in this section. Time to time to place bids. Okay. Let's move that over. Place your heralds. and and and all of these steps say in turn order or simultaneous. So, okay, place heralds. We know turn order now. So, purple go first, then red, then blue, then uh then green. Yeah, I think it's green. All right, you did that. Now, let's move over in turn order. Everyone does their spring steps. And you can easily see that same icon. I have this icon that lets me do this action. I don't want to do that. I don't want to place any supporters. I'm done with my spring actions. Okay, next person. [snorts] It's done so well that this game, for this kind of game, you could teach a new people and it's organized where they're not going to get lost. Then you move to summer. Okay, let's do this. And it's all step by step telling you exactly what needs to be done, how a clash is done. You do the three clashes. Then autumn in turn order do autumn actions. And then in winter it says simultaneously everyone does winter actions. Boom. Rinse and repeat till the game is over. I I absolutely am stunned by this game. Not only by its art. This these kinds of games tend to feel that the art carries it. Uh man, I'm blinded by how good the art is. And I'm I'm forgetting how mediocre of a game it is.

You know, that happens uh quite a bit. That's not the case here. The art is outstanding and the game is extremely good and they chose to support it. I think this game has a lot of depth even though it's relatively simple to learn. Uh there's a lot of nuance and things you wouldn't pick up on first playthroughs and I could see this being a game that a lot of people play and it gets deeper the more you play it with the same group. Uh, and and I was I was complaining about the the King's Road cards having that element of randomness to put a positive spin on that. Well, that can make it to where the game doesn't get stale. If they didn't have the King's Road cards, I think just living off the clashes would make this game kind of boring. You play it a few times, be okay. Yeah, cuz there's only these four tactics per faction. There's not eight, and you shuffle them, and these are your four. It's these four.

So, I feel like the factions would get kind of boring, but because of the king's road, there's a good chunk of them that allows you to use your tactics in very interesting ways with the kingdom uh kingdom cards you have. So, I do I love that they're here. I just think some people might not like the randomness of it. And then, yeah, and then the expansion will be will be coming out probably soonish, and I'm very excited to see what that brings. So, on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm giving the old King's Crown a nine. I really enjoy this. And this is coming from someone who has kind of softened on these style games. Or maybe not these style games. Euros tend to I have softened quite a bit on, but these area control kind of high conflict games. I was worried that it was going to be cutthroat and annoying, you know, with the Herald. Oh, my Herald's here. Your Herald's here. Uh, so you steal points from me.

or you can steal my kingdom card. It It's not actually that mean because the way the game is structured, if you're like me and you're thinking, "Oh, you can steal points from me and you can steal my shit." [ __ ] that. Uh I promise you it really isn't that bad because everything that happens is done in a way that it would have been your own mistake. If someone stole a kingdom card from me, that is because I put a lowv value card there. If it was pertinent to my strategy and I chose to put a lowv value card there, then I'm pretty much asking for it to be taken from me, especially if it becomes too powerful. And if it's not, if it can't be stolen from me, then I willingly chose to put a high value card there, which means it was my own decision. I wanted to hold on to that. I'm I'm good with being without my 11.

And then the second with the uh the stealing points. [snorts] Um if you're in first place, then that's kind of as a you're kind of expecting that cuz you are in first place. Other games do this. Power grid is a great example of being in first is rough because everyone gets to buy resources before you. So by the time it comes to you, hey, I'm winning. Uh now [ __ ] is way more expensive. It's it's this design of some some form of catch-up mechanism. So, if I'm in first place and I'm going to the battlefield to try and get two more points, well, everyone else, they might not even want to go there. Uh, but I'm kind of expecting that. So, A, I'm in first place, so I'm winning. B, they they might want to put their Heralds there.

It might behoove them to do so, to potentially steal points from them, but they run the risk of getting points stolen from them. If they lose that section and my Herald's there, great. Not only am I getting two points for my herald or a point from my herald, two points from the location, you all put your heralds there and I won. So I'm getting three more points, which is what is that? Two, three. So five, what is that? Eight point swing cuz I gained five and everyone lost one. So it's not just a matter of, hey, I'm in first. I don't get to steal from you. Uh or it might be uh just the fact that I yeah I'm in first place and the second place person ended up winning that location. So they they're going to steal a point from everyone else. It's not everyone steals points from the person in the lead. You don't get to pick. It's just if a herald's there. So, the two main aspects of this game that as I heard about them before I played that could have been a huge turnoff for me ended up pretty much a not not really happening. Uh, I think it happened in the last four player game of this I played. Stealing a kingdom card happened once and losing stealing points happened twice and it was between the same two players. I got points stolen from me and then I stole points back for my friend.

Except in my situation, I ended up stealing points from more people. So it it really does work. Uh so yeah, this but this kind of game whenever it requires a large player count, that is usually where I kind of get I don't know. I I really have to hedge my bets because a I don't get a lot of four player games or games best at four played. I have a handful of them in my collection, but it's narrowed down to games that are really good at two. So, that was one reason why I didn't really want to touch this one because it felt like a game that would be best at four. But, the game is so damn good that I think I would just rather have this in my collection on the on the rare occasions I actually can play it at four. So, this game gets a nine out of 10 for me. I really really like it. I think they did an excellent job. I wouldn't say this is uh their first design. They don't have their names on it uh for the designers, but I think the publishing company I think that is their first design of a game and they have nailed it. And that's it everyone.

That's my thoughts on The Old King's Crown. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved