Asking for Trobils Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Asking for Trobils
Reviewers agree on the basic identity of Asking for Trobils: a light, fast worker placement game with a loud, cartoonish theme. Most of the discussion treats it as an accessible entry point rather than a deep strategy experience. Hungry Gamer is the most enthusiastic voice, arguing that the game is at its best with six or seven players, where turns move quickly enough that nobody sits idle. The same reviewer admits it is a simple game that will not satisfy anyone looking for something meatier, but frames that simplicity as the intent of the design.
Opinions diverge mostly on presentation and expansions. Several reviewers comment on the heavy orange palette, and one reviewer found the second edition visually unappealing. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower calls it a very good introductory worker placement game, and the same channel's shelf tour notes that the box is almost entirely orange. TheGameBoyGeek places it at number 75 on a personal top 100 list, praising its tongue-in-cheek humor and describing it as surprisingly innovative for an entry-level title. One more irreverent reviewer noted that it won The Dice Tower Family Game of the Year award in 2015, while still calling it largely unoriginal. That reviewer found it fun anyway, mainly because the turns pass so quickly that boredom never sets in.
Core Mechanics That Define Asking for Trobils
Worker Placement
Each turn, a player places a ship on one of the locations around the board, and the heart of the design is the bump. If a rival's ship already sits on a space, placing your own ship there sends the original back to its owner. Every placement is therefore also a guess about whether an opponent will land on top of you. Reviewers describe a rhythm in which you can either pull all of your ships back to your player board for a full turn of collection or leave them out and keep working. Hungry Gamer singles out this pull-back-or-bump loop as the element that keeps the game interesting despite its very simple rules. Bumping your own ship is a special case in the rules, and reviewers mention it as a small but notable twist on the basic action.
Resource Management
Resources flow through a simple chain. Players collect space carrots, space crystals, and ore, then trade them for traps, space slugs, mega traps, and credits. Capturing a Trobil requires turning in a specific combination of goods at a planet, so every trip commits a player to a particular path. Reviewers highlight the upgrade board as the key accelerator. Paying credits to attach an upgrade to your board gives you a bonus each time you visit a linked location, and the more upgrades you own, the more you can convert in a single visit. One reviewer says this upgrade system actually speeds the game up toward the end. Finally, dumping captured Trobils into the sun pays out credits, and the flipped cards still count toward final scoring, so the conversion has a lasting payoff.
The Asking for Trobils Experience
Quick and Breezy
Almost every reviewer returns to pace. Turns consist of placing a ship or pulling ships back, so downtime stays low even at high player counts, and reviewers report very little analysis paralysis. Hungry Gamer describes the game as quick and satisfying, with rounds that zip along, and considers that speed more valuable at the table than extra depth would be. Tom Vasel's description of it as an easy game to teach and start playing fits the same picture. The result is a game that a group can get into within minutes, with just enough tension in the bumping to keep attention on the board.
Playful and Tongue-in-Cheek
The theme does a lot of the work. Hungry Gamer adores the presentation, pointing to the big round board, the wacky art, the puns, the Easter eggs, and the sheer fun of saying the name out loud. The idea of catching horrible space pests and flinging them into a star is presented as ridiculous in a way that makes the game easy to enjoy. TheGameBoyGeek points to locations named after famous scientists and to silly science jokes printed on the box. Reviewers seem to agree that the humor is consistent throughout, so the cartoonish tone reads as the point rather than as window dressing.
What Makes Asking for Trobils Stand Out
It Plays Best With a Full Table
Hungry Gamer makes the strongest case here, arguing that the game plays better with more people than with two or three, and that six or seven players produce a special experience. Because the core rules involve so few mechanics, larger groups zip through their turns instead of waiting. The same reviewer contrasts this with many games they love, which take forever at high player counts. Even a partner who rarely asks to replay a game asked to play this one again after a four-player session, which the reviewer described as a rare result.
Easy to Teach and Quick to Start
Multiple reviewers emphasize the low barrier to entry. Hungry Gamer says the core game is quick and easy to teach, and that getting a large group to the table and playing fast is especially valuable for a game built for crowds. One more irreverent reviewer reports that no one they played with asked a question about the rules after a short explanation, and describes the game as a worker placement experience that can be picked up by almost anyone. TheGameBoyGeek describes it as very entry-level and says it can be played with nearly anybody.
Potential Drawbacks
Thin for Players Who Want Depth
The most common criticism is that the core game is light. Hungry Gamer calls it a light Euro, says it is very simple, and warns that anyone looking for something crunchy and brain-burning will find little to chew on. Another reviewer says the game can drag toward the end because of the number of City cards in the deck, and suggests that a smaller deck might have helped. Reviewers generally agree that the game shines as a quick, social experience rather than as a challenge that rewards long study.
Expansions and Visual Clutter
The two expansions earn praise but also create friction. Hungry Gamer likes both the companion and troublemaker modules, yet the designer and the rulebook say not to play them together, which the reviewer finds frustrating because the board seems to have room for everything. The reviewer also expects to use the expansions only occasionally. On the visual side, one reviewer finds the orange palette and the look of the second edition unappealing. That same reviewer warns that the standees can hide information on the board, and that with many players they add confusion to what is otherwise a simple game.
If You Enjoy Asking for Trobils
Glow is the title that the community pairs with Asking for Trobils in comparison discussions, so fans of this game should look there first for a similarly light, fast, and colorful design. Beyond that direct comparison, reviewers point to the game's appeal for large groups and casual players as the trait to chase. Readers who enjoy a worker placement game that plays fast with a full table of six or seven, leans on a goofy theme, and teaches in minutes should look for other entry-level worker placement titles built around the same priorities, since those are the qualities this community keeps coming back to when they describe why Asking for Trobils works.
What Reviewers Are Saying
it has this lovely mechanic of you pull back or you don't of you're just pulling yourself back or you're putting something out and you're getting your resources. but as you're doing that you're trying to figure out what the other players are going to do.
— Hungry Gamer
Their side's white and orange, but it is a fun worker placement game where you're placing workers down or pulling them off the board. It's very good introductory style game collecting resources and getting rid of these annoying troubles.
— The Dice Tower
Ultimately it's a very simple sort of entrylevel streamlined worker placement game. um simple to understand but has um unlike some some other worker placement games the the element of collecting certain goods and then turning them into other goods before you can deliver and the timing and the efficiency puzzle of it.
— TheGameBoyGeek