Automania Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Automania
Reviewers treat Automania as a underrated 2015 design, a car-manufacturing game from designers Kenneth Minda and Christian Otsby whose strongest qualities are easy to miss at first glance. Getting Games described it as a game about making the best cars you can and selling them to shifting markets, and after a four-player session the reviewer said they liked it enough to want to play it again soon. Before You Play described the design as one that still stands the test of time, while The Broken Meeple called it a really solid game that simply was not the best on an aesthetic level.
The consensus is warm. Board Gaming Ramblings expected to cut Automania from its collection during a keep-or-kill session, then ranked it as the best experience of the evening after playing with two players. Reviewers differ mainly on the artwork, which several of them feel undersells the mechanics, and on the asymmetric player powers, which Getting Games found unhelpful. Most reviewers also suggest the game would benefit from more players and a second edition.
Core Mechanics That Define Automania
Worker Placement on an Intersecting Tile Grid
The engine of Automania is a worker placement system centered on a grid of tiles in the middle of the board. Players place a worker on one of the outer spaces along a row or column, and they must take a tile from that line before optionally resolving the action on the space. Before You Play noted that a worker can be placed on a space already occupied by another player only by committing more workers than the existing placement, which the reviewers compared to Energy Empire while noting that Automania's version is stricter.
Getting Games highlighted the bumping that follows from this rule. Workers that are kicked out return to their owners, who can then use them to bump someone else, creating a chain of displaced workers that gives each round a distinctive rhythm. The tiles acquired from the grid are then placed on the player's own board, where they determine what each car is worth and what attributes it carries.
Rotating Market Demand and Star-Rated Sales
Automania's second core system is its market. Each car is built with a star rating, which determines where its token can be placed on the sales ships. Cars are sold to either a European or a North American market, and the first player to sell into a slot receives the better payout. Demand tokens rotate between the two sides of the board, so a feature that is highly sought in one round may fall out of favor the next.
Getting Games observed that the demand track lets players look ahead, with the reviewer noting that you can see three rounds in advance in a four-round game. Before You Play summarized the tension as trying to maximize production star quality while also meeting goals and demands that keep changing. That forward planning is what gives the economy its strategic weight.
The Automania Experience
Tense Jockeying for Position on the Grid
Reviewers describe Automania as a game where every turn feels contested. Because kicked workers flow back into play, a placement can ripple through the table, and players spend the round watching which rows and columns their opponents are targeting. Getting Games described the sensation as a wonderful bumping vibe that ends the round before the board fills up, which it contrasts with worker placement titles where players simply keep placing until everything is occupied.
The Broken Meeple emphasized the same competitive edge, noting that the tiles you take shape what your car can become. Board Gaming Ramblings described a race to sell cars before the opponent does, a feeling that makes even a simple round exciting.
Anticipation and Streamlined Satisfaction
The second feeling reviewers mention is a quick, distilled satisfaction. Automania rounds move briskly, and the game is built around the simple loop of building a car, meeting demand, and selling it at the right moment. The Broken Meeple called it quite in-depth but pretty simple to learn, and Board Gaming Ramblings said it delivers the things they enjoy in car-building games in a very distilled, just fun way. Getting Games estimated a four-player game at about 90 minutes and said it would also work well with three.
What Makes Automania Stand Out
Tiles That Affect Multiple Car Types
Reviewers consistently point to the interlocking factory as the game's defining design choice. Each player's board has three car types whose lines pass through shared tile spots. Getting Games gave the example of a fuel-efficiency leaf tile placed where it intersects both the SUV and compact car lines, which means every car of those types gains that attribute. Because one tile can improve several car types at once, reviewers say players must think carefully about where each tile goes rather than simply filling the nearest slot.
Building a Car Nearly Every Round
The Broken Meeple contrasted Automania with Kanban and Craftwagen, where players must first assemble many components before a finished car appears. In Automania, the reviewer explained, players are making a car in nearly every round from the start. That immediacy is a large part of why reviewers describe the game as easy to get into, even though its tile interactions run deep.
Potential Drawbacks
Artwork That Undersells the Design
The most frequent criticism concerns presentation. Before You Play argued that the graphic design, including the box art and the tile illustrations, does not give the game enough credit, and that its 2015 aesthetic misrepresents how it plays. The Broken Meeple noted that the slightly cartoony artwork put some people off, while suggesting a second edition with stronger art and components could expand the tile variety. Board Gaming Ramblings also noted that a copy was hard to find, so reviewers hoping for a reprint are not alone.
Asymmetric Powers That Do Not Balance the Game
Getting Games played with the optional asymmetric player powers and came away unconvinced. The reviewer felt the powers did not add anything meaningful, that one power seemed weaker than the others, and that asymmetry arises naturally after the first turn because each player's removed tiles change what others can access. Their verdict was that the game is better with an even playing field, even though they still liked Automania overall.
If You Enjoy Automania
Players who enjoy Automania's market timing and car-building theme will find related satisfaction in Craftwagen. Board Gaming Ramblings said Craftwagen does some of the same things, with players building cars and trying to make them interesting to sell, though the reviewers said Automania is more straightforward in that category. Players who want a more involved manufacturing puzzle may look toward Kanban, although Before You Play stressed that Automania is not anything close to Kanban, so readers should expect a meaningfully different experience.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Overall I thought Automania was a really enjoyable time. Again, I really liked trying to be tactical with the overall markets. I really liked the action selection and tile grabbing mechanics from the middle of the table."
— Getting Games
"I mean, you are basically just making cars and selling them, but from the get go you're making cars. It's not like Kanban or Craftwagen or something like that where you've got to start off with all the bits and then eventually make a car. No, in Automania you're making a car in nearly every round, and it's just a simple like game of meet the demands of Europe or America, sell it off, try and make your car like parts, like you know, luggage space and power and all this stuff."
— The Broken Meeple
"The art for this game, it was kind of a detractor for me for a while. The art did not capture me, which is surprising because normally art and theme mean nothing to me, but for some reason this one, the kind of cartoonish look of it, it doesn't really tell you, doesn't really tell you the story."
— Before You Play