This is a semi-cooperative game which puts the "thief" against the rest of the players, who take the role of detectives. As the thief, you secretly plot your movements around a private art museum. As you go, the detectives take turns trying to find you with their eyes, the video cameras, or motion detectors. You can deactivate the cameras, and you can even cut off the power to the entire museum to mask your movements. Another advantage is that the thief gets a turn after every detective's individual turn.
Another problem for the detectives is the fact that, once the thief has picked up a painting, she can take her next turn before removing the painting from the gameboard. The good guys know the vicinity, but won't know her exact location, as the thief is now up to 3 squares away from that spot. If a detective ever spots you with the naked eye, secret movement is over, and the thief's token is placed on the board for all to see. This can get frantic, since the thief can only move 1-3 spaces, while detectives roll a d6 for movement!
The thief player has to decide when to attempt a getaway. The catch is, some of the windows and doors are locked. There are actual lock pieces, and you must flip over the one you are attempting to open (instant detective frenzy!). If she has stolen 3 paintings (in a one-off game), and manages to get out, she wins. In a tournament style game, each player gets a turn at being the thief, so the number of paintings needed will vary based on the other players' scores.
1991 Mensa Select
Also selected by Family Fun Magazine as one of the best games.
Original name by inventors was Heist. Clue name was added for marketing purposes when the game was licensed with Parker Brothers.
Similar to
Scotland Yard
The Fury of Dracula
Specter Ops
- Way ahead of its time
- Still holds up really well
- Does feel aged
- theft and deduction
- museum
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
- Deduction — Detectives use various tools and observations to try and locate the thief.
- Hidden Movement — One player (the thief) moves secretly on a scratch pad, while others (detectives) try to deduce their location.
- roll and move — Detectives use dice to move and perform actions, trying to catch the thief.
- Thematic actions — Thief can disable security features like cameras and motion sensors; detectives try to get line of sight.
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- And that's because, you know, back when I was a kid, most of the games were roll and move games.
- However, I'm here to say that it's not necessarily the mechanic or mechanism of roll and move that is inherently bad.
- It's just that it's been a mechanism and has never been or often has not been surrounded by a good game.
- So here I'm tell I'm here to say roll and move doesn't suck. In fact, it's the games around it that aren't that great.
- The mechanism itself can be used in interesting ways.
- It's thematically fun. Uh it creates a good story, a good arc.
- It's a really clever way of using pretty much just a roll and move game and it's fantastic.
- It's a wild zany race. You can't take it too seriously.
- Rattle Bones is a severely underrated game.
- It's super tense and really fun. Definitely one of the best role games, Escape the Curse of the Temple.
- Mountain Goats itself, such a clever little game that uses rolling move in a great way.
- It is a such a clever game. It's amazing.
- This game still holds up and it's still great.
- It does feel aged. It certainly does. But at the same time, it felt like it was way ahead of its time and it still today holds up really well.
- The production on that 2003 version was awful, but we had so much fun playing that game.
- It's not inherently a bad mechanism. It's just we have a bad taste in our mouth because most games that had this mechanisms that we remember and played as a kid were just bad games that happen to use roll and move as a lazy way to design a game.
- Roll and move is here to stay.
References (from this video)
- So much better than Clue.
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
- Deduction Game — It's like an easier version of Scotland Yard.
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- The Donald Duck theme it's just a mean random game.
- I love Santorini, but this puzzle game just doesn't work for me.
- It's a simple game.
- I love the cookie theme.
- So, I They all felt the same to me.
- It was an okay game.
- Some interesting ideas there, but just shy of what I'm looking for.
- I think Point Salad is a much better game.
- Fun little card game in which you are trying to hurt other people's flavors that they are collecting while making your flavors better.
- Nice little card game.
- It was kind of meant to be this gateway game.
- As you put out tiles almost Carcassonne style, but it's almost a little cozy in how it plays.
- This is a very simple game in which you're just basically filling cards up with these ink tiles to take them to score.
- Very easy.
- Really nice components.
- Same game, space theme. Who cares? Abstract.
- Member 44 was Star Wars. I love it. How can you not?
- This game where you're just going around the world and exploring and you just see what happens.
- A very fun sandboxy style game.
References (from this video)
- Bigger version of Clue with more suspects, weapons, and locations.
- Meh.
- Mystery
- Locations
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
- Deduction — It looks like they took Clue and added more stuff.
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- So, we're going to jump right into these here. I'm going to take a look at them and tell you what I think about them.
- This game is now 20 years old.
- It's not nearly as good as made by the people who made War of the Ring.
- This is my favorite because all the pieces move like rooks sort of and you're trying to take over other people's pieces and each one has a special power and I like the theming of it.
- Layers expansions bring it up to a nine. Layers is amazing.
- I think the base game is fine, but when you I mean it's it's very it's enjoyable, but when you add the expansion it's fantastic.
- Nothing here I think is amazing.
References (from this video)
- worth trying even if you don't like regular Clue
- museums
- art theft
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- Welcome back to the Dice Tours. We take a look at another shelf in the Dice Tower Library.
- if you like games about delivering the mail, this is it
- Just a solid game of quick, snappy turns
- AIA, what a great game about shipping. This is a fantastic, terrific game.
- You like Dominion, but you want it for dice. This is your game.
- Very very popular games all them. That's why there's two of each.
- Although, frankly, you should always play with the expansion.
- I just really am loving SETI. Fantastic game.
- I do like this game. I have a soft spot for it.
- Vast, not as popular as its successor, root
- My favorite game here is The Great Museum Caper. Nope. I forgot Magical Athletes there. Magical Athlete is amazing.
- I just love Tumbling Dice.