Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles
Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles, published by GMT Games in 2021, is one of the better-regarded entries in the Commands & Colors line among the reviewers who have covered it. The Discriminating Gamer places it near the top of several personal rankings, including a list of the greatest GMT Games of all time and a list of favorite games set in Japan. The reviewer's enthusiasm is tied to the reliability of the series as much as to this particular title, and the Discriminating Gamer has said never having played a Commands & Colors game that disappointed.
Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower takes a more restrained view in a look-back review, scoring the game 8.5 out of 10 and calling it a really solid game. Vasel's main observation is that the title has dropped off many players' radar, overshadowed by Memoir '44, which Vasel describes as the most popular game in the family. That point of caution recurs in the broader conversation: reviewers rate the game highly but rarely treat it as the first Commands & Colors title a newcomer should reach for.
The areas of agreement are the quality of the core system and the appeal of the feudal Japan setting. Where views differ is mostly on placement rather than on quality. The Discriminating Gamer ranks the game first among its Japan-set titles and sixth among its favorite Commands & Colors titles, while Vasel's review reads as a steady recommendation for fans of the family.
Core Mechanics That Define Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles
Flank-Based Card Activation
The foundation of Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles is the command system that Richard Borg created for the series and that GMT Games publishes here. The battlefield is divided into three sections: a center, a left flank, and a right flank. Players play cards that allow them to move and attack with units inside a chosen section, so every turn is a decision about where to concentrate force and where to hold ground. The Discriminating Gamer describes this directly, explaining that you have your center, your right flank, and your left flank, and that the cards you play determine which units act. Combat is then resolved with dice, which reviewers describe as a satisfying, familiar layer on top of the card decisions.
Dragon Cards and Tactical Disruption
The second mechanic reviewers single out is the separate deck that the Discriminating Gamer refers to as dragon cards. These cards do not replace the core activation system. Instead, they introduce a second hand of options that can interfere with an opponent's plans, and the reviewer compares them to the trick cards in BattleLore. Because the opponent may hold a response, a carefully planned flank push always carries some doubt, which reviewers credit with keeping games lively from start to finish.
The Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles Experience
Tension Under a Hidden Hand
The tension in Samurai Battles comes less from the dice than from the cards that the other side might be holding. The Discriminating Gamer describes the feeling as a constant question: every time you play something, you are wondering whether your opponent has something ready to undo your work or soften the damage you are about to deal. That uncertainty turns each activation into a small gamble. A flank attack that looks decisive on the board can be answered by a single card, and the reviewer enjoys the way that possibility keeps both players alert.
Discovering Feudal Japan Through Play
Reviewers also describe a sense of discovery. The Discriminating Gamer admits to not knowing feudal Japan as well as other periods studied previously, and says that learning the scenarios and the battles they depict was one of the pleasures of the game. Rather than feeling like a lecture, the historical content arrives through the flank structure and the scenario setups, so each battle feels distinct. For players who know the period well, the game offers the satisfaction of seeing familiar engagements recreated in a system they already trust. For everyone else, it offers an entry point into history that is less commonly covered in tabletop wargames.
What Makes Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles Stand Out
A Proven System Applied to a Fresh Theme
Reviewers consistently point to the value of bringing a dependable system into a setting that is less common in the Commands & Colors family. The Discriminating Gamer praises the game's "great commands and colors gameplay," and says that activating the different sections of the board remains as enjoyable here as in any other entry. Players who already know the series can learn the rules quickly, while the Japanese battles provide a new visual and historical identity that separates the game from its siblings.
Card-Driven Surprise That Keeps Games Fresh
The dragon cards are the feature that reviewers most often describe with enthusiasm. The Discriminating Gamer says they add a lot of spice and sugar to the game and give players all sorts of bells, whistles, and surprises. Because each side can respond with an unexpected move, the reviewer finds that the game rarely plays out exactly as planned. This is the feature that keeps the reviewer coming back to the table, and it is the feature credited with setting the game apart from others in the series.
Potential Drawbacks
Overshadowed by Memoir '44 and the Rest of the Family
The most consistent criticism is not about how the game plays but about how it is seen. Tom Vasel observes that the game has dropped off many players' radar, and notes that the Commands & Colors family is large, with Memoir '44 as its most popular member. For a newcomer choosing among several titles, Samurai Battles may be the less visible option, which can mean fewer local players and less discussion compared with the more established games in the line.
Swingy Moments From the Card Layer
The same card layer that thrills reviewers can frustrate players who prefer tight control over outcomes. Because a single opposing card can undo a well-planned activation, some turns may feel decisive in ways that depend on what is in an opponent's hand rather than on the board position alone. None of the reviewers in this group reported frustration with the feature, but players who dislike uncertainty in a tactical wargame should expect it to be a central part of the experience.
If You Enjoy Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles
- Memoir '44 with the Overlord expansion: Players who enjoy the flank-based activation in Commands & Colors: Samurai Battles will find a similar satisfaction in Memoir '44, which The Discriminating Gamer names as a favorite Commands & Colors game. The Overlord expansion scales the system to epic multiplayer battles.
- Commands & Colors: Ancients: This title uses the same three-section command structure to recreate ancient battles, with dice combat and dirty tricks layered over the card play. Players who enjoyed the flank system will find it a natural companion, and The Discriminating Gamer rates it highly for its theme.
- BattleLore Second Edition: Players who enjoy the dragon cards will appreciate the fantasy version of the system, where trick cards similarly disrupt the opponent's plans. The reviewer describes the minis and creature variety as a major part of its appeal.
- Commands & Colors: Napoleonics: Players drawn to the tactical depth of Samurai Battles will find a more mature rule set here, with squares, artillery behavior, and iconic battles such as Waterloo. The Discriminating Gamer has described it as a longtime favorite in the series.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"There's a whole another deck of cards that can throw monkey wrenches into what your opponent's trying to do. And every time you play something, you're wondering if they've got something that they can pull out of their hat to screw you over or mitigate some of the damage that you're going to do to them."
— The Discriminating Gamer
"This one's kind of dropped off everyone's radar. There's a lot of Commands & Colors games out there. Now Memoir '44 is the most popular, but this one, Samurai, really solid game."
— Tom Vasel, The Dice Tower
"I love the Commands and Colors games. You got your center, you got your right flank, your left flank. You play cards that allow you to move units on those flanks. And they're always a lot of fun."
— The Discriminating Gamer