Custom Heroes Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Custom Heroes
Custom Heroes is a 2017 card-crafting climbing game that has so far been covered by reviewers in very different ways. The most thorough look comes from Watch It Played, where John Zinser, Watch It Played sat down with Pat McDonald for a full demo covering setup, advancements, and a complete hand of play. Board Games UnLocked picked the game up at Gen Con for ten dollars, mostly on a whim, and openly admitted it had no idea whether it was any good. Tom Vassel, The Dice Tower mentioned it only briefly while touring their shelves, but they singled it out for anyone who enjoys games where you customize cards and shed them.
The shared thread across these takes is that the game's appeal sits in the tension between a familiar climbing game and a tinkering layer that keeps changing the cards in play. Reviewers who did play it came away impressed by how quickly the changes accumulate, while the one channel that had not played it stayed curious rather than convinced. Because the cards are plain, the satisfaction clearly comes from what happens to them during play, not from how they look.
Core Mechanics That Define Custom Heroes
Climbing Trick Play Over Follow-the-Leader
Watch It Played describes the foundation as a follow-the-leader climbing game for two to six players. Each player starts with a hand of ten basic cards. The player who leads may play any number of matching cards, and everyone after must answer with an equal or higher set. When everyone passes, the table is swept clear and the last player to have played leads the next round. Trump cards beat any play, and a card marked as wild can stand in for a value when it is played as part of a set, which gives the familiar Daihinmin-style climb a little more room to bluff and surprise.
Sleeved Advancements and Card Crafting
The second system is what makes the game unusual. Each card has four advancement slots marked with yellow, blue, red, and green dots, and players can slide advancements behind their cards on any turn. John Zinser explained that the advancements for the left and right hand mainly raise or lower a card's number, while other advancements add special abilities such as wild or trump. During the demo, a one was turned into an eleven with a single green-slot upgrade, and a card that had been pushed down by a negative advancement was later restored to a ten. Using an advancement costs a power-up token, which is the main brake on how aggressively a player can rebuild the deck.
The Custom Heroes Experience
Tinkering Under Pressure
Reviewers describe a satisfying moment-to-moment rhythm in which a hand that looks hopeless can be rescued by a well-timed sleeve. Watch It Played kept sitting back to upgrade cards in the middle of other people's plays, adjusting numbers until a play could reach fifteen or beat the table. That makes each turn feel like solving a small puzzle, where the question is not only what to play but what to rebuild first so the play actually works.
A Shared Table of Changing Cards
Because every round reshuffles and redeals the cards, an upgrade made on your turn may end up in someone else's hand. Watch It Played explained that the cards are reshuffled after upgrades so the whole table keeps using the modified cards, which turns personal investment into a common resource. The advancement bag adds to the uncertainty, since players draw a random advancement from it without seeing what they are getting, so the table is constantly reacting to the unexpected.
What Makes Custom Heroes Stand Out
Upgrades That Work Around the Table
The most consistently praised idea is that advancements are not locked to your own turn. Because you can upgrade behind your screen at any time, you can answer another player's lead by changing your own cards before you respond. This keeps every seat engaged even when it is not your turn, and it is the feature that makes the card crafting feel like part of the trick-taking rather than a separate setup phase.
Scoring That Rewards Going Out Early
The end-of-round scoring gives points based on finishing position, and the rules reward going out early. Watch It Played noted that the first player out in a six-player game takes five points and draws an advancement from the bag, while in a two-player game going out earns four points. The reviewer summed up the result by saying that the fewer players there are, the better it is to go out early. The first player to reach ten points must then win a hand to win the game, which gives the endgame a clear finish line.
Potential Drawbacks
Plain Cards and Dense Explanations
The visual side is not what draws people in. John Zinser was candid that the base cards have nothing exciting going on in them, so the game depends on the sleeved advancements to supply the visual interest. The scoring and advancement structure also took real explanation, and the quick video skipped a betting advancement entirely, so new players should expect a short learning curve before the layers click.
Upgrades That Can Help the Whole Table
Because upgrades go back into the shared deck, a costly rebuild can benefit opponents as much as the player who paid for it. Watch It Played framed the power-up token cost on powerful cards as the counterweight that keeps a shared deck from getting out of hand, which means strong upgrades are never free. Players who dislike handing opponents a boost may find this part of the design frustrating, even if it is central to the game's identity.
If You Enjoy Custom Heroes
Players who enjoy Custom Heroes's sleeved advancements will find similar satisfaction in Mystic Veil. Board Games UnLocked explicitly compared the two, pointing to Mystic Veil's card crafting as the reference point, and noted that the card crafting is layered on top of deck building there. For players drawn to the way Custom Heroes lets a shared resource change hands, Edge of Darkness offers a similar pull, since Board Games UnLocked described it as a blend of shared deck building and card crafting that rewards building on what others have set up. Players who like the trick-taking side more than the crafting side may also appreciate the follow-the-leader rhythm, which Watch It Played describes as the core of the game.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The cards get reshuffled each turn after they've been upgraded so we all get to keep using the upgraded cards."
— John Zinser, Watch It Played
"It's a trick-taking game about with their card crafting system, you know, like what they do for Mystic Veil and Edge of Darkness and all that."
— Board Games UnLocked
"Custom Heroes, if you like any game where you customize cards and card shedding, that's great."
— Tom Vassel, The Dice Tower