Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark
Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark is a two to four player dice game from 2015 that reviewers almost always discuss alongside Lewis and Clark, the heavier game by Cedrick Chaboussit that shares its expedition theme. Reviewers generally treat Discoveries as a lighter companion piece rather than a replacement. A convention rundown on Board to Death TV described it as a standalone game that is quite different from Lewis and Clark while keeping the same feel, designer, and art, and it noted that the game looks lighter and more accessible, with no worker placement spaces on the board.
Enthusiasm runs high. Getting Games described a dice game that flips several dice game conventions, and Board Game Sanctuary said it absolutely loves the game for its rich historical theme and player interaction. Our Family Plays Games placed it among its top ten dice games, and Drive Thru Games gave it a strong recommendation, especially for fans of Lewis and Clark. Table reactions are less uniform. The Getting Games host reported that several of the host's groups finished sessions feeling lukewarm, even though the host personally wanted to play it as often as possible.
Core Mechanics That Define Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark
A Shared Dice Pool That Players Reclaim
Each turn centers on a pool of dice that every player contributes to. Players roll dice in their own color, then choose one face symbol and activate every die showing it, whether that means placing dice on player board slots, changing faces, negotiating with tribes, or advancing along an exploration route. Getting Games notes that a basic action lets any die change two other dice to any face, and that players begin the game with it, which gives them unusual control in a dice game. Spent dice go into a central pool, and a player may take either all dice of their own color or all dice in one half of that pool. Drive Thru Games explains that retrieving your color can pull your dice from anywhere, including opponents' boards and dice already used. Because an opponent who loses dice must spend a turn taking them back, reclaiming is a central source of tension. Journal dice add a planning layer, since they are set aside and evaluated on a later turn.
Card Collection and Tribal Engine Building
Exploration cards carry a route of rivers and mountains that must be completed from bottom to top in the printed order, and any excess movement is wasted. The reverse side shows American Indian tribe cards, which are gained through negotiation dice and provide lasting abilities. Getting Games describes the appeal directly: "you are essentially building a customized engine for yourself," since many tribe cards let players manipulate dice or bend the rules. Exploring two cards in one action grants a bonus turn, and animal and feature sets along with teepee majorities supply much of the end game scoring.
The Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark Experience
A Historical Theme With Educational Weight
Reviewers consistently praise the theme. Board Game Sanctuary cites the rich historical theme as a reason for its enthusiasm, and Board to Death TV noted that the rulebook is packed with historical information, so players may learn something while they play. Getting Games said the American Indian cards avoid being exploitative or appropriative, and pointed to the rulebook's explanation of terminology as evidence of care. The journal theme comes through in writing entries beneath the journal card, according to Drive Thru Games. Getting Games also notes that the neutral gray dice gained from tribes feel like genuine help for the expedition rather than help for one player.
Planning Tension Over the Dice
The experience is defined by preparation followed by a payoff. Getting Games describes rolling only every three, four, or five turns, setting up feet, horseshoes, and journal actions in advance, then executing them together when a route is finally traveled. Drive Thru Games frames this as a cycle of building up and then exploding into a large turn. The tug-of-war over shared dice adds a second layer, because a player must decide whether to spend a turn reclaiming dice from an opponent, which can delay that player's own plans.
What Makes Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark Stand Out
Infrequent Rolling That Breaks Dice Game Habits
Getting Games argues that Discoveries flips the usual dice game rhythm. Players are not simply rerolling and hoping for a better result. Choosing which face to activate becomes a planning decision, and tribe abilities plus the change-two-dice action let players reshape the dice they have. Drive Thru Games calls the dice mechanic super interesting and unlike other dice games, and praises how players must time their grabs so they have enough dice to keep moving forward.
Readable Hidden Information Through Teepees
Most exploration cards are covered as they are played, so exact scores stay hidden. Getting Games highlights that the teepee icons on American Indian cards are almost always face up, which lets players gauge their standing with reasonable accuracy. Because the teepee majority is worth a large swing at the end, a player who is one or two teepees behind may negotiate once or twice more to lock the position down. The reviewer calls the reveal at game end a good moment, and notes that it is not all about memorizing what opponents have taken.
Potential Drawbacks
Rich-Get-Richer Momentum in the Mid to Late Game
The most serious criticism comes from Getting Games, which observed a rich-get-richer pattern. A player who completes a double exploration gains a bonus turn, rerolls a large pool, and can immediately spend those dice on tribe abilities already in place. That can produce a run of explorations in which one player pulls ahead while others spin their wheels. The reviewer noted that the winner often wins by a huge margin over clustered second and third place scores, and said Getting Games almost wishes the bonus turn did not exist, since exploring into the central area is nearly attractive enough on its own. Getting Games has not house ruled it but said the change might come if the pattern continues.
Four-Player Downtime and Limited Exploration Variety
Reviewers agree that three players is the sweet spot. Getting Games found that four players can produce downtime in the late game, because each player must plan several turns ahead and check whether needed cards will still be available. Drive Thru Games raised a related concern about the flop of scoring cards: "You have that flop of the different scoring cards that come out, and you can be really trying to set yourself up to get two in a row and travel in a certain direction, and then somebody else can snake that from you, especially when you play with four players." Variety is also a concern. Board Game Sanctuary observed that the exploration cards only show rivers and mountains, so it does not always feel like much exploring. Getting Games added that two-player setups randomly remove many of the more interesting dice manipulation cards, which can leave a dull mix of routes. Cardboard Herald called the game brilliant but objected to the squared corners on its journal cards as a component quality issue.
If You Enjoy Discoveries: The Journals of Lewis & Clark
Reviewers consistently point players who like Discoveries toward the original Lewis and Clark by Cedrick Chaboussit. Board to Death TV described Discoveries as sharing the same feel, designer, and art while still being a different game. Drive Thru Games framed the relationship most directly: the same designer and artists worked on both, but the original has a fixed route with the same mountains and rivers in every game. Its workers return to their tribes where later players can interact with them, a system Discoveries carries forward with the added twist of taking other players' dice. Drive Thru Games' reviewer still leans toward the original, though finding Discoveries more interesting as a dice game. Because reception of the original is split, reviewers suggest that players who did not enjoy it may find Discoveries more appealing. Players who enjoy tribal engine building and the reclaiming tension should consider the original for its fixed route and worker system.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I think that three player is right on the money the best way to play this game. The two player experience is decent, but as I mentioned before you have a much higher likelihood of running into a less interesting set of American Indian cards because so much of the deck is just removed from the game."
— Getting Games
"I like the shared dice pool mechanic where players are constantly trying to use dice to try and activate particular actions on their playboard. There's this beautiful tug-of-war effect as players try to reclaim their dice that have been used by other players."
— Board Game Sanctuary
"You have that flop of the different scoring cards that come out, and you can be really trying to set yourself up to get two in a row and travel in a certain direction, and then somebody else can snake that from you, especially when you play with four players."
— Drive Thru Games