En Garde Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About En Garde
The two reviewers who cover En Garde both come away with a warm opinion of it, and both feel it is underappreciated. Justin, who runs the Board Game Animal channel, ranked it in a top 25 list of Reiner Knizia games and said that placing it where they did felt unfair to the game. Justin called it a great little two-player game that deserves more notoriety. Spotlighting Hidden Gems, a video series devoted to overlooked titles, described En Garde as a very entertaining two-player game with a simple yet elegant design. Neither reviewer presents it as a deep strategy monument. Instead, they praise it as a quick, sharp duel that delivers more thinking than its size suggests, and both close by hoping more players will discover it.
Core Mechanics That Define En Garde
Hand Management and Card Choice
Justin describes the game as a very simple to learn and to play hand management game, and the card choice is the center of the experience. Each turn, a player has to weigh which card to commit, because the cards in hand determine how far the fencer can advance and when a hit becomes possible. Justin points to the constant choice of weighing the options of what cards you‘re going to play as the reason the game stays fresh across repeated sessions. That same tension is what gives the game its decisions, since every card played is a card that will not be available later.
The Tug-of-War Fencing Duel
Spotlighting Hidden Gems lists the game as a dueling board game with hand management and tug-of-war mechanics, and that combination defines the core loop. The aim is to land a hit and touch the opponent in order to win the round, and the first player to win five rounds takes the victory. Justin frames the goal in the same direct way, saying that all you‘re trying to do is get your fencer to hit the other. Because the two sides push and pull against each other, every round becomes a contest of position rather than a simple race, and the tug-of-war structure is what turns a small card game into a duel.
The En Garde Experience
Back-and-Forth Tension
The clearest feeling the reviewers share is the constant back and forth between the two players. Spotlighting Hidden Gems says the game play is very dynamic and engaging, and points out that the pace of exchange keeps both players involved. The host also highlights the mind games that arise in the duel, saying the element of psychology is an aspect they really enjoy about the game. Because each player is trying to predict what the other will commit, the tension never settles into a single spike but stays a steady exchange that rewards careful reading of the opponent.
A Quick Game With a Period Feel
Justin highlights the theme as one of the most appealing parts of En Garde. Justin says the game feels older than it is and could almost be seen in a period piece, and that the back and forth fencing strikes a chord that endears the game to them. Justin also stresses that it is a quick to play two-player game, so the period flavor is delivered in a short session rather than a long campaign.
What Makes En Garde Stand Out
Simple Rules, Layered Decisions
Spotlighting Hidden Gems praises the design as simple yet elegant and says it offers a lot of strategic depth. The rules are short enough to teach quickly, yet the decisions are not trivial, and the host describes the game as feeling like a true duel between two people who must think about each choice. Justin makes a similar point, describing the game as having a lot of cool little decisions packed into a quick session.
A Theme That Matches the Play
Justin finds the theme unusually strong for a small card game. Justin calls it a really cool unique little theme, linking it to the sense of fencing that runs through every exchange, rather than a theme pasted on top of an abstract card mechanic. Justin sees that thematic fit as one reason the game deserves wider attention.
Potential Drawbacks
Can Feel Too Simple or Too Chancy
Justin is candid about the game‘s limits. Justin notes that at times it may feel even too simple or too chancy. The brevity that makes the game easy to learn can also leave some players wanting more depth, and the element of luck can occasionally outweigh careful planning. Justin does not treat these as fatal flaws, since they still rate the speed and the choices highly, but acknowledge that the experience will not suit every group. Players who prefer long, deliberate strategy games may find En Garde too light for their tastes.
Hard to Find and Worth Reprinting
Spotlighting Hidden Gems raises availability rather than quality as the main concern, saying the host genuinely believes the game should be consistently in print because it is one of their favorites, and hoping it comes back again so more players can discover this gem. That concern echoes Justin‘s view that the game deserves more notoriety than it has. Both reviewers suggest that the game‘s reputation is held back less by its design than by how rarely it reaches tables, which makes the reprint question an important part of the game‘s story.
If You Enjoy En Garde
Neither reviewer names a direct comparison game for En Garde, but Justin does link it to another Knizia title when discussing tug-of-war designs.
- Royal Visit: Justin groups it with En Garde as one of Knizia‘s tug-of-war games, a push and pull hand management design in which the goal is to get the king over to your side of the board. Justin says these games are done really well by Knizia but do not get talked about as often as they should.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"it‘s a great little two-player game that may at times feel even too simple or too chancy but the speed of the game and the constant choice of like weighing the options of what cards you‘re going to play makes the game really replayable"
— Board Game Animal
"En Garde is a very entertaining two-player game. There‘s a lot of back and forth between the two players, and the game play is very dynamic and engaging. It is a simple yet elegant design that offers a lot of strategic depth."
— Spotlighting Hidden Gems
"it‘s just a quick toplay little two-player game that has a lot of cool little decisions and a really cool unique little theme that I think deserves more notoriety"
— Board Game Animal